Power Module Reliability Insights
Power Module Reliability Insights
CONTENTS
1. Foreword ................................................................................................................................................... 2
2. A brief outline of semiconductor device reliability ................................................................................ 2
2.1. Change in failure rates of semiconductor devices........................................................................................... 2
2.2. Failure factors of semiconductor power modules ............................................................................................ 4
2.3. Heat-fatigue phenomenon in semiconductor modules for electric power ....................................................... 5
2.3.1. Heat stress model during module actuation ................................................................................... 5
2.3.2. Fault mechanism with power cycle and thermal cycle ................................................................... 6
[Link]. Power-cycle life fault mechanism ............................................................................................ 6
[Link]. Thermal-cycle fault mechanism .............................................................................................. 7
3. Quality-guaranteeing activities................................................................................................................ 9
3.1. Mass production procedures ........................................................................................................................... 9
3.2. Environmental control ...................................................................................................................................... 9
3.3. Periodic inspection of manufacturing equipment, instrumentation and maintenance control ......................... 9
3.4. Material purchasing control .............................................................................................................................. 9
3.5. Manufacturing process control......................................................................................................................... 9
3.6. Intermediate and final inspections ................................................................................................................. 10
3.7. Quality information ........................................................................................................................................ 10
4. Reliability Tests ...................................................................................................................................... 12
4.1 Reliability Test Method ....................................................................................................................................... 12
1. Foreword
Power modules, semiconductor devices for electrical use, were launched on the market in the late 1970s as BIP
type modules (transistors, thyristors, etc.) embedded in bipolar-type semiconductor chips and again in the early
1980s as MOS-type modules (IGBT etc.) embedded in MOS-type semiconductor chips. Currently they are widely
used in many home electric appliances such as air-conditioners, refrigerators, washing machines, etc., and in
applications for various industrial inverter devices, servo, UPS, electric and electronic peripherals.
At the same time, the reliability of the device has increased rapidly along with improvements in semiconductor
technology. Typically, for equipment that demands high reliability, a semiconductor device failure rate of 10 to 100
FIT (1 FIT = 1×10-9/hour) is required. In order to realize that level of reliability, naturally the reliability of the
semiconductor must be improved. It is very important to consider the harmony of the equipment design and working
conditions under the various new stresses added to the semiconductor’s characteristics and reliability.
It is often observed that the failure rate in the market place is markedly different for semiconductor devices
manufactured in the same way because of a weakness in machine design or a difference in usage.
Here we introduce our company’s reliability test results and activities to guarantee quality with regard to semiconductor
device reliability, by examining problems of typical machine design and usage that must be take into consideration
and cases of faults that actually reached the market.
2
Power Module Reliability
market, the failure rate decreases dramatically because the stress level declines, and it is usually between several
FIT and several 100 FIT. Because of this, design with some leeway on the device-use side is required, and
generally it is desirable to have a maximum voltage rating of below 50~60%, and a maximum junction temperature
rating of below 70~80%. One other important element that must be remembered is the semiconductor device in use,
the circuitry used and the environmental conditions (various cases of stress, etc.), which can affect improvements in
reliability too.
As stated above, when it comes to equipment reliability design, it is necessary to consider the trade-off between
performance/ reliability and economy when selecting a device. It is not easy to attain both high performance/high
reliability and economy, so a balance of both must be selected. It can be said that selecting a semiconductor device
by considering the performance, reliability and harmony of the equipment is an important learning activity for the
user.
3
Power Module Reliability
Among the factors above, one of the factors deciding the usable life period is heat fatigue failure inside the module
between the chip and wire junction or between the insulation substrate and the base plate (solder junction). The
next section introduces a description of heat-fatigue phenomenon and cases of failure.
4
Power Module Reliability
Two actuation patterns of the heat stress model during module actuation are shown in sections in Fig. 3 When
selecting a module, consideration must be given to its usable life and the machine design.
■ Actuation mode 1
・Actuation pattern shows few changes in case temperature (base plate temperature) but frequent
changes in junction temperature (known as PC life or power cycle life)
■ Actuation mode 2
・Actuation pattern shows relatively calm temperature changes at system actuation and shut down
(known as thermal cycle life)
Tj
Temperature
TC
Tj
Temperature
TC ΔTj-C ΔTj
ΔTC
ON OFF
Tj :Junction Temperature
TC:Case Temperature
5
Power Module Reliability
Fig.4 shows the structure of a typical power module as module actuation causes a change in the junction
temperature and stress appears by the difference in linear expansion coefficients of the aluminum wire and the
silicon chip, causing a crack to appear on the junction side. The crack develops and eventually separates
completely.
With the comparatively gentle changes in module-case temperature by inverter actuation, etc., when conditions
cause frequent junction temperature changes, power cycle disruption must be taken into consideration during
machine design. Fig.5 shows a photograph of a case of junction shear due to power cycle.
Fig.6 shows the results of our company’s test carried out on a module product’s power-cycle life (power cycle life
curve).
Chip Wire
Solder layer
Base plate
Aluminum wire
Silicon chip
Insulating substrate
substrate Aluminum wire
Crack
Silicon chip
6
Power Module Reliability
1,000,000,000
100,000,000
10,000,000
cycle
1,000,000
100,000
10,000
1,000
1 10 100 1000
ΔTj [℃]
Fig.6. Mitsubishi IGBT module NF series power cycle life curve
Aluminum wire
Silicon chip Insulating substrate
Insulating substrate
Crack
7
Power Module Reliability
1,000,000
100,000
cycle
10,000
1,000
10 100
⊿Tc [℃]
Fig.8. Mitsubishi IGBT module NF series thermal cycle life curve
8
Power Module Reliability
3. Quality-guaranteeing activities
The quality, price, delivery and service of a product are all important elements but the most important thing as long
as the product exists is the quality of the product and the continuing service to the user of the product.
In the semiconductor industry, the quality levels required by products are very high. On the other hand, high quality
control is required in the mass-production systems with very advanced technology such as the process control
capability seen in the “wafer process” or the minute work seen in the “assembly process”.
A brief description of the quality-guaranteeing activities is given below.
9
Power Module Reliability
10
Power Module Reliability
11
Power Module Reliability
4. Reliability Tests
4.1 Reliability Test Method
Mitsubishi semiconductor devices can be used with full satisfaction because they are built to high levels of reliability:
precise quality control through the design and manufacturing processes along with quality-guaranteeing inspections
of every production lot assures high reliability. Various reliability tests are performed to check the level of reliability.
The contents of the test are shown in Table 1, the example of test results and failure criteria for the representative
type of power modules are shown in Table 2-Table [Link] semiconductor devices are tested for reliability
based on the standard of Japan Electronics and Information Technology Industries Association (JEITA). (Related
standard: International Electrotechnical Commission Standard( IEC standard)).
Table 1. Mitsubishi power module reliability tests
Item Method (JEITA) Conditions Related Standard
Thermal Shock ED 4701 307B Condition A : 100℃ : 5min., 0℃ : 5min., 10 cycle IEC60068-2-14
Temperature Cycle 〃 105A -40℃ (60min.)~125℃ (60min.), 10 cycle IEC60068-2-14
Vibration - - 10~500Hz/15min., 10G, 6 hours IEC60068-2-6
Terminal strength ED 4701 401 9.8~40N, 10 ± 1sec. IEC60068-2-21
‘or 401A 2.2N ,30sec
Soldering 〃 302A Condition A: 260℃,10 +2/-0sec. IEC60068-20
Environmental Testing
M5 : 1.96~3.5N • m, 10 ± 1sec.
M4 : 1.47~1.7N • m, 10 ± 1sec.
M3 : 0.98N • m, 10 ± 1sec.
High Temperature 〃 201A Ta=125℃, 1000 hours IEC60068-2-2
Storage
Low Temperature 〃 202A Ta=-40℃, 1000 hours IEC60068-2-1
Storage
Endurance Testing
12
Power Module Reliability
Storage
Moisture Resistance 〃 103A Condition B: Ta=60℃, RH=90%, 1000 hours 5 0
High Temperature 〃 101A Ta=125℃, VCE=1020V,VGE=0V, 1000 hours 5 0
Reverse Bias
High Temperature 〃 101A Ta=125℃,VCE=20V,VGE=0V,1000hours 5 0
Gate Bias
Intermittent 〃 106A,602 Tc=50~100℃,5000 cycle 5 0
operating life ~603
13
Power Module Reliability
Storage
Moisture 〃 103A Condition B: Ta=60℃, RH=90%, 1000 hours 5 0
Resistance
High Temperature 〃 101A Ta=125℃, VCE=510V,VGE=0V, 1000 hours 5 0
Reverse Bias
Intermittent 〃 106A,602 Tc=50~100℃,5000 cycle 5 0
operating life ~603
14
Power Module Reliability
Storage
Moisture Resistance 〃 103A Condition B: Ta=60℃, RH=90%, 1000 hours 5 0
dissipation fins.
15
Power Module Reliability
Storage
Moisture Resistance 〃 103A Ta=60°C, RH=90%, 1000 hours 5 0
High Temperature 〃 101A Ta=125℃, VCE=max. rating voltage ×0.85V, 5 0
Reverse Bias 1000 hours
Intermittent 〃 106A,602 ΔTc= 70°C, 30000 cycle 5 0
operating life ~603
16
Power Module Reliability PRELIMINARY or TENTATIVE
Mitsubishi Electric Corporation assumes no responsibility for any damage with customer safety design deficiency and/or
usage of outrange of specification.
•Mitsubishi Electric Corporation assumes no responsibility for any damage, or infringement of any third-party’s rights,
originating in the use of any product data, diagrams, charts, programs, algorithms, or circuit application examples
contained in these materials.
•All information contained in these materials, including product data, diagrams, charts, programs and algorithms
represents information on products at the time of publication of these materials, and are subject to change by Mitsubishi
Electric Corporation without notice due to product improvements or other reasons. It is therefore recommended that
customers contact Mitsubishi Electric Corporation or an authorized Mitsubishi Semiconductor product distributor for the
latest product information before purchasing a product listed herein.
The information described here may contain technical inaccuracies or typographical errors. Mitsubishi Electric
Corporation assumes no responsibility for any damage, liability, or other loss rising from these inaccuracies or errors.
Please also pay attention to information published by Mitsubishi Electric Corporation by various means, including the
Mitsubishi Semiconductor home page ([Link]/).
•When using any or all of the information contained in these materials, including product data, diagrams, charts,
programs, and algorithms, please be sure to evaluate all information as a total system before making a final decision
on the applicability of the information and products. Mitsubishi Electric Corporation assumes no responsibility for any
damage, liability or other loss resulting from the information contained herein.
•Mitsubishi Electric Corporation semiconductors are not designed or manufactured for use in a device or system that is
used under circumstances in which human life is potentially at stake. Please contact Mitsubishi Electric Corporation or
an authorized Mitsubishi Semiconductor product distributor when considering the use of a product contained herein for
any specific purposes, such as apparatus or systems for transportation, vehicular, medical, aerospace, nuclear, or
undersea repeater use.
•The prior written approval of Mitsubishi Electric Corporation is necessary to reprint or reproduce in whole or in part these
materials.
•If these products or technologies are subject to the Japanese export control restrictions, they must be exported under a
license from the Japanese government and cannot be imported into a country other than the approved destination.
Any diversion or re-export contrary to the export control laws and regulations of Japan and/or the country of destination
is prohibited.
•Please contact Mitsubishi Electric Corporation or an authorized Mitsubishi Semiconductor product distributor for further
details on these materials or the products contained therein.
17