Gender Perspectives on Family and Marriage
Gender Perspectives on Family and Marriage
5.1 INTRODUCTION
Family and Marriage are the basic units of the society. Family is also an institution
that is considered as the seat of nurturing, care and socialization of an individual.
It is also supposed to be an institution that protects a person from the threats of
outside world. But, on a closer look with patriarchal background and gender
lens, the institution of family is found not to be an egalitarian but hierarchal
structure. In this Unit, you will read about how family can be a seat of power and
subordination and oppression of some members namely, women, girl child and
also of the members of non-normative sexuality. Along with understanding family,
marriage as an institution, we will discuss the different kinds of discrimination
inherent to marriage. It should be stressed that marriage by itself and as is
understood today wasn’t/isn’t a universal system in terms of time, space and
communities and how the patriarchal and sacramental nature of marriage keeps
women subordinated and perpetrates violence against them.
5.2 OBJECTIVES
After reading this Unit, you will be able to:
Explain the nature and function of family;
Describe various forms of marriage in India; and
Critique subordination and hierarchy within the structure of the family and
marriage in India
55
Gender and Family
5.3 NATURE AND FUNCTIONS OF THE FAMILY
Various studies from across the world have elaborated upon the nature and
functions of the family. Majority of these studies emphasize on the universality
of family as a social institution, that in provides socialization, support, love and
protection to its members. These studies portray family as an egalitarian space
whereby all members enjoy equal patronage and love, and consider it as a heaven
otherwise insecure and violent world. However, there are studies which challenge
such unilateral understanding of family. These studies come mainly from feminists
and queer scholar. They bring forth the ways in which family operates within
family determining differential access to resources both material and non-material.
Violence and discrimination are used as tools to maintain family “integrity”,
status, power, and honour. Let us read about functionalism which is important to
study family as a form social institution.
Functionalism
Functionalism states that family forms the basic institution of every society and
is universal in nature. Through its various functions, family meets the functional
pre-requisites of the society and helps maintain its equilibrium.
The most basic relationship within the family is that of mother and child based
on the physiological facts of pregnancy and lactation. Therefore the mother is
primarily responsible for rearing and nurturance of the child whereas the father
plays an indirect role.
Functionalists propose that the wife is required to give direct help to the husband’s
work. She is expected to adjust and assist the husband in meeting the various
demands the occupational sphere places on him.
Feminist studies critique functionalism bringing forth the various ways in which
power operates within family leading to hierarchy, discrimination, and violence
against various members. They show family as not just a space for love, peace
and cooperation but also of conflict, violence and negotiation.
Socialist Feminism
According to Marxists feminists, women’s subordination is related to the
ownership of property. They argue that family along with exploitation of women
will be wiped out with the usurping of capitalism. Socialist feminists contest
such ideas and point out ways in which even the working class male benefits
from the family. They point at the ways in which the structure of the family in
capitalism affects and appropriates women’s labour and renders them unequal
both within the family and in the labour market.
Radical Feminism
Radical feminists emphasize on sexual rather than economic exploitation. They
link women’s oppression to their sexual and reproductive role performed basically
within the family. They call upon women to reject their biological reproductive
role and take the help of technology to subvert male domination. Some of the
important radical feminist analysis of family comes from Kate Millet, Shulamith
Firestone,and others.
Kate Millet (1971) unites that the patriarchal family insists upon legitimacy of
offspring. It pronounces that the status of both child and mother is chiefly
dependent upon the social and economic status of the male.
Shulamith Firestone in her book The Dialectic of Sex (1972) opines that the
material basis for the inequality between men and women is produced within the
biological family.
Family honour and purity of caste is believed to be dependent upon control over
and purity of female sexuality. Family, according to feminists, plays an important
role in maintaining this purity through socializing its members especially women
to control their sexuality. Girls are expected to be feminine and not attract male
gaze to remain pure. Family itself controls and punishes arbitrary behaviour in
this regard. Restrictions on mobility, maintaining purdah, stress on virginity,
chastity and fidelity, stigma of illegitimacy, importance on early marriage of
girls are all mechanisms through which family actively contributes in maintaining
caste boundaries and protects its purity and honour.
The responsibility for protection of family and caste honour that family confers
its male members gives men the right to exercise power over the females.
Feminists argue that the process of gender socialization in India primarily takes
place through rituals and ceremonies, the use of language, and practices within
the family. Gender division of labour is ingrained in children very early in
childhood. Little girls are expected to help in domestic work such as cooking
and looking after infants. Boys on the other hand are reprimanded if they show
58 any interest in the above works. They are expected to accompany their male
Family and Marriage
elders to the work site outside the home. Girls, feminist studies show are expected
to learn to bear the pain and deprivation, eat anything that is given to them, and
acquire the quality of self-sacrifice. (Dube, 2001)
Feminists also point out that given the fact that son preference is ingrained in
Indian families which are largely patriarchal, patrilineal and patrilocal in nature,
girls grow up with the notion of temporary and secondary membership within
the natal home.
Rajni Palriwala (1990) addresses household within the context of womne’s work.
She argues that such division of labour kept women away from the market oriented
income generating productive work thus making women economically dependent
on men.
Other critique of the family comes from the dalit feminist thought and queer
theory.
Check Your Progress Exercise 1
Note: i) Use the space given below to answer the questions.
ii) Compare your answer with the Course material of this unit.
1) Explain ‘Liberal Feminist’ understanding of family
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
In the coming section, you will read about dalit feminist’s critique of family
queer critique of family studies and domestic violence within family.
According to her, ‘members of the family are burdened with the duty of replicating
the structure. Families are also not open for any and every one as the gates for
entry are birth and marriage. The use of force and violence for submission and
compliance is not unknown.
Child Abuse
‘Children are victims of substantial abuse of a physical, psychological and
60 emotional nature. This includes sexual aggression, beatings, as well as extracting
hours of labour from children who should be in school or at play (Karlekar: Family and Marriage
1998: 1744). Given her burden of the household duties, it is the girl who is
abused more, she experiences only daughterhood and is deprived of a carefree
childhood which is generally reserved for boys (Kosambi: 1998). Child sexual
abuse is one of the most rampant forms of child abuse which is rarely talked
about.
Families rarely talk about such sexual abuse. When the rapist is a father, brother,
uncle or cousin the chances of reporting are even lower. Though the girl child is
more vulnerable to sexual abuse especially in Indian context one cannot deny
the prevalence of male child sexual abuse. If there is a silence around the sexual
violation of the girl child in the family, this is equally true of cases of sodomy
and abuse of the male child (Karlekar: 1998: 1745).
Sexual Harassment
Sexual harassment also occurs in the domestic sphere. Unwelcome sexual
advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal or physical conduct of a
sexual nature constitutes sexual harassment. Sexual harassment forms one of the
basic tools of men to keep women in their patriarchal defined space. It can be in
the form of comments on the physical appearance of the female and abuse with
sexual overtones, fingering, jostling against women, manhandling, ogling etc. It
creates an atmosphere of fear and hurts the dignity of the woman concerned.
The above forms of violence reflects a part of the various ways in which different
members of the family live a life of hierarchy and unequal power and status
within family. These violence show that family is not always a space of safe
haven and eternal love but actively hierarchies, discriminates and violates its
own members in different capacities.
Heteronormativity is about only opposite gender i.e a man and women being
allowed to marry.
Source: [Link]
11100014-Cartoon-the-bride-and-groom-during-the-wedding-ceremony-contours-Vector-Stock-
[Link]
Same sex marriage is tabooed and not allowed socially and legally
except a few countries which grant legal sanction to such
marriages.
Couples from the same sex i.e. as shown in this picture a woman
and a woman in love are not allowed to marry.
Source: [Link]
atthameeni140700020/29650244-hand-drawing-cartoon-concept-happy- same-
62 [Link]
Family and Marriage
Same sex couples like in this picture a man and a man marrying is tabooed,
stigmatized and made illegal by both society and law. [Link]
politicalhumor/1/S/2/Y/4/[Link]
In India too same sex love and marriage is tabooed and banned both by society
and the law.
Source: [Link]
+marriage&biw=1280&bih=589&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0CAcQ_
AUoAmoVChMIytrl1t_6xwIVxSSOCh1 OdgyH#tbm=isch&q=posters+on+
section+377+ &imgrc=rZxti0ZjZ9bgoM%3A
Traditionally marriage involves a man, a woman and their children. One of the
important purposes of marriage is believed to be for biological reproduction.
63
Gender and Family
+marriage&biw=1280&bih=589&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ved=0CAcQ_
AUoAmoVChMIytrl1t_6xwIVxSSOCh1OdgyH#tbm=isch&q=indian+cartoons+of+family+
in+india+&imgrc=XxFfOhBybON9uM%3A
Source: [Link]
Polygamy is the term for plural marriage. It can in turn be subdivided into
polyandry or the union of one woman with several men; polygyny, or the union
of one man with several women. Group marriage, involves several emn living
with several women. Within polygamy polygyny is more common than polyandry.
Based on rules of marriage, marriage takes palce in two broad forms- endogamy
and exogamy. Endogamy ensures that partnes in the marriage belong to the same
social group. i.e the same caste, tribe, religion, class and others.
Marriage between Brahmin Woman and Brahmin Man- Endogamy i.e Caste
[Link] between Dalit man and Dalit Woman – Endogamy i.e
Caste
EndogamyMarriage between Christian Woman and Christian Man –
Endogamy i.e Religious Endogamy
Marriage between Bodo Man and Bodo Woman- Endogamy i.e Ethnic
Endogamy.
In India Hindu social order through its caste system strictly followed and continues
to follow caste endogamy. Any violation of it entailed punish,ment including
what is known as honour killing. Endogamy and Violent enforcement of it
continues rather rigidly even in contemporary times.
65
Gender and Family
Exogamy on the other hand entails that individuals marry outside their own
group. Gotra exogamy whereby individuals are expected to marry outside their
gotra (lineage group), and village exogamy (which was the norm of marriage in
some north Indian villages) entailes that members married outside one’s village,
are some among the various forms of exogamy. Exogamy of gotra is also strictly
followed in India. Breaking of gotra exogamy rules can also lead to honour
killings.
66
Family and Marriage
Source: [Link]
[Link]?cb=1348985994
Based on sex of partners, marriage can be of two kinds’ i.e heterosexual marriage
and home sexual marriage. In heterosexual marriage, partners belong to opposite
sex, where as in homosexual marriage the partners belong to same sex.
Before reading further attempt the following.
Check Your Progress Exercise 2:
Note: i) Use the space given below to answer the questions.
ii) Compare your answer with the Course material of this unit.
1) Explain different forms of marriage
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
2) Write short notes on:
a) Endogamy
b) Exogamy
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
......................................................................................................................
In the following sections you will read about feminist theories on marriage,
violence in marriage and queer perspectives on marriage.
Gender Socialization whereby girls are told that their task is to cook, clean,
and perform repetitive uncreative work and be subordinate. Whereas boys
are told to occupy position of power, do masculine creative task and enjoy
the fruits of women’s work.
At the same time when they go for work outside home they are paid much less
than men. There is continuity between women’s subordination within the “private”
sphere of marriage and family and the “public” sphere of wage work. Further,
research also show that even when women go out to work in similar positions as
men, they are still burdened with house work performing “second shift” – one
shift at office and another taking care of home and family by doing housework.
68
Based on the Studies feminists argue that they advocating of gender division of Family and Marriage
labour in marriage harms the position of women as a whole, merely by
constraining their options and ambitions. Confining them to domestic sphere
and placing on them the exclusive burden of housework, gender division of labour
limits women’s choices and life chances.
Source: [Link]
69
Gender and Family To summarize, feminists see marriage not as an egalitarian harmonious institution
but that which is fraught with contradictions. According to feminists, marriage is
a hierarchical institution whereby women are given secondary status. Gender
division of labour, capitalist economy, unpaid housework, unequal wage system
in paid work, heterosexual norms, control over women’s sexuality, eulogizing of
masculinity and femininity, violence, unequal property and other rights, along
with discriminatory laws make marriage an unequal exploitative institution.
Let us now read how violence is perpetuated in marriage.
Ill effects of marriage
Marital violence can be perpetrated both in active and passive manner, it can be
in an overt and covert manner, and can be physical, sexual and psychological in
nature or all at a time. Violence in marriage involves kicking, beating with hand
or stick, dragging the woman by hair, cutting her body, abusing her with foul
language, keeping her hungry, having forced sex, shouting, scolding, threatening,
desertion, restriction in her movements, restricting her from employment, and
many other means of torture. Some of the forms that it takes in India are discussed
below:
Early Marriage: Early marriage is encouraged to control the sexuality of the girl.
She should be passed safely from her natal home to the marital home without
bringing in danger to the family name. A girl’s sexuality has to be controlled as
if she misuses her freedom it may bring disgrace upon the family honour. Early
marriage results in early pregnancy, which is harmful, and life taking for the
mother.
Dowry: is an age-old practice related to marriage in India. It is the exchange of
wealth especially from the bride’s home to the grooms. It can be in the form of
cash, ornaments, lands, modern gadgets or other movable and immovable
property. Dowry forms one of major causes of wife battering. Wives are beaten,
70 deserted, tortured, murdered, burnt for extracting more dowries.
Wife battering: the most widely practiced and widely denied form of domestic Family and Marriage
violence is upon the wife that sometimes leads to the death of the woman. It is a
wife battering. Wife battering involves physical, psychological and sexual abuse
inflicted complex social phenomenon of power relationships within the family.
For a long time most of these violence were not even legislated against by the
law. It is mostly through the efforts of the women’s movement that today most of
these forms of violence are declared illegal through legislations. However,
violence such as marital rape is now recognized as a crime by the law.
5.10 DIVORCE
In many societies divorce has become an accepted part of marriage. All legal
systems today grant the right to divorce to both women and men in marriage.
Divorce laws have become simpler with granting of mutual consent divorces.
Though divorced status is considered as normal in many societies, in India it is
still difficult to opt for divorce especially, for women.
India has different marriage and divorce laws for different religions. Almost all
religions have their own marriage and divorce laws.
Divorce still is seen as an act of breaking of marriage and family even when
sought under conditions of cruelty.
5.11 SUMMING UP
The unit discusses the nature and functions of family especially taking the help
of functionalist studies of family. It describes how largely family is accepted as
the basic unit of all societies and is functional to the maintenance and progress
of society.
Feminist rejected such understanding on family and their efforts in bringing out
the discrimination present within family. Indian feminist and queer studies on
family and their attempt to unfold the important role family and familial ideology
have played role and the subordination of women in family and marriage were
discussed. In India, discourse on women’s rights within marriage and family is
a complex and contentious matter as it is closely intertwined with religious and
social identity politics/issues.
71
Gender and Family
5.12 KEY WORDS
Hemorrhage : A flow/oozing of blood from a ruptured blood vessel.
Access &Control of Resources: Resources are important to ensure livelihoods
of individuals.. Women have been denied access to education, health services,
credit, land and technologies historically due to gendered divisions of labour,
patriarchy, economic inequalities and socialization.
5.13 REFERENCES
Bell, Norman W. and Ezra F. Vogel (1968) (eds.). A Modern Introduction to The
Family. New York: The Free Press.
Rao, Anupama (2005). ‘Sexuality and the Family Form’, Economic and Political
Weekly, 40(8): 715-718.
Rinchin (2005). ‘Querying Marriage and Family’. Economic and Political Weekly,
40(8):718-721.
Banks, Olive. 1986. Faces of Feminism. New York: Basil Blackwell Bhroin,
Feargha Ní. 2009. ‘Feminism and the Same-sex Marriage Debate’,
[Link]
accessed on September 3rd 2015, 10.30am.
72