Temporal Design in Architecture
Temporal Design in Architecture
Akio Takatsu
and
Yoichi Ando
Professor em. Graduate School of Kobe University
Home: 1-4-132-105 Hiyodoridai, Kita, Kobe 651-1123 JAPAN
e-mail: andoy@[Link]
With regard to the two cerebral hemispheres, it has been indicated that the left hemisphere
controls language, logic, calculation, and time-series processing, while the right hemisphere
governs nonverbal cognition and pattern processing. According to recent findings (Ando,
McGraw-Hill Yearbook of Science and Technology, New York 2009, p. 384-389), the
general characterization of the left hemisphere as “the brain for temporal perception” and
the right hemisphere as “the brain for spatial perception” contributes to better
understanding people’s relationships with the environment in terms of psychological
reactions. However, a spatial perspective only still tends to dominate in the planning and
designing of architectures and the urban environment. In fact, a planning or designing
methodology that successfully employs a temporal perspective has not been established,
yet. Temporal design approach is basically regarded as associated with three concepts: the
development of the body as the first stage in human life, the development of the mind as
the second stage, and the development of individuality as the third stage. This paper
presents a temporal design methodology that addresses the third stage of development in
human life (creation based on personality). There are prevailing scales of time used in
temporal planning design, which is attempted to summarize in this paper.
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 34
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
while the right cerebral hemisphere governs And the other, temporal design is generally
nonverbal cognition and pattern processing. regarded as being associated with the three
Moreover, according to recent findings, the stages of human development: the first
categorization of the left cerebral development (body), the second
hemisphere as “the brain for temporal development (mind), and the third
perception” and the right hemisphere as “the development (creation due to unique
brain for spatial perception,” contributes to a personality which is oriented by DNA). The
clearer understanding of a person’s realization of one’s individuality requires an
relationships with the environment in terms awareness of one’s differences from others
of psychological reactions. (Fig. 1; Ando in terms of DNA. This is achievable by
vitalizing one’s brain to a degree that
and Hosaka,1983) .
renders even subtle differences perceivable.
For a person to perceive “preference,” it is Since the brain achieves maximum
necessary that both cerebral hemispheres are vitalization when both cerebral hemispheres
simultaneously provided with effective are effectively stimulated, equal weight shall
stimuli (Ando, 1983, Chen an Ando, 1996a, be given to the temporal and spatial design
1996b, Ando and Singh, 1997). In addition (Ando, 1998, 2009a, 2009b, Ando and Ando,
to the dominant spatial design approach, 2010). As well as the designing spatial
associated with the perceptions of the right factor, the designing temporal factor is
hemisphere, a temporal design approach, certainly needed. This paper presents a
related to the left cerebral hemisphere, is hypothesis related to a temporal design
vital in the planning and designing of methodology that addresses this third stage
architectures and urban environments in of development.
order to achieve not only “functionality” but
also “preference.” 2. PREDOMINANT PERIODS IN
HUMAN LIFE
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 35
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
Table 1. Sense of space (Right hemisphere of the brain) and spatial designing
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 36
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 37
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 38
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
skillful positioning of staircases and bridges. cloud. Each day, during sundown, a ray
of sunlight penetrates the hall from an
ii) Circadian-rhythm: a day opening in the west, illuminating it in red.
The greatest natural change that occurs This is an example of a temporal design that
within a day is the alternation between day conforms to the circadian rhythm, and it
and night caused by the rotation of the Earth. produces a scene representing the arrival of
The rise and fall of the tide can also be the Amitabha Buddha from the Pure Land.
perceived within a day. Predominant This architectural masterpiece is designed
rhythms in life that are shared by most for the third stage of human development to
people include events and activities such as provide people a sense of being alive by
waking up, eating a few meals, excretory, experiencing an extraordinary space.
working (or study), and sleeping. The
duration of a circadian cycle is generally 2.3 Predominant periods determined by
considered to be 25 hours. infradian-rhythms
Apart from the natural flow of time
experienced through such rhythms, people, i) Weekly cycle
in their daily life, deliberately engage in a A week is an entirely artificial time
variety of activities throughout the day domain created by mankind. While changes
based on “schedules” and “programs.” occur between each “day” of the week, a
However, even if activities change by the variety of “weekly” programs are repeated
“hour,” a daily program tends to be repeated. and routinized, such as school curriculums
Therefore, people have created facilities, and television programs. Seeking freedom
such as theaters, concert halls, theme parks, from weekly repetitions and routines, people
and global merchandise centers (GMCs), to take vacations seeking extraordinary
engage in experiences that nourish “life” in experiences, including traveling to the sea or
terms of experiencing the sense of being the mountains to explore nature, and
alive. traveling to historic cities. Through such
In the Jodo-do of the Jodo-ji temple, the activities, people experience the sense of
statues of the Amitabha Triad stand facing being alive in the third stage of human
east on the pedestal of the lotus above the development.
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 39
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 40
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
autumn festival (harvest festival), and the described as an outdoor classroom space. In
new year’s eve celebration, serve as the case of higher-grade classrooms, a group
opportunities to vitalize life by deviating of classrooms share a large indoor
from the mundane pattern of life. Those workspace. For intermediate grade
events facilitate an awareness of seasonal classrooms, each one is assigned an
changes and the passage of time as well as individual indoor work space. Thus, the
enable one to delight in the changes in school provides the children with a spatial
nature. These are temporal design practices environment that considers their stages of
created by the Japanese because of their development and facilitates their transition
close relationship with nature, dedicated to from the initial three years to the later three
“life” in the third stage of human years of elementary school education.
development.
ii) 10-year cycle
2.4 Predominant Periods of Human Life- Especially mentioned term in human-life,
Stages which concerns with physical and mental
development, is 10-year cycle. This is a
Several predominant periods under longer cycle that governs physical and
mentioned are empirically derived and have mental development. This includes the
not been confirmed by firm evidence. Even duration from childhood to graduation from
though they are hypothetical, the following elementary school, during which children
predominant periods as largely concerned require the care and protection of their
with temporal design is proposed. parents; adolescence, during which children
prepare themselves to become independent
i) Three-year cycle from their parents; and the period of time in
Furthermore, we are empirically aware which a person becomes financially and
that the mental and physical development of mentally independent from their parents.
a person is governed by an approximate And then, stages of life continue to change
three-year cycle. This includes the first as a separator for about 10 years.
phase of childhood (infancy), during which It is necessary to modify spaces taking
a newborn child gradually becomes capable into account the ten-year cycles governing a
of basic communication and conscious person’s mental development. Infants and
behaviors; the second phase of childhood lower-grade students in elementary schools
(post-infancy), during which a child could share a large room with other children
gradually becomes capable of and substitute a study desk with a large
communication with persons other than his dining table. However, in the second
or her parents; the first half of elementary ten-year period, children should preferably
school education, during which children be afforded a private room or at least a space
establish the foundation for social living; in which their privacy may be respected.
and so on. During the third ten-year period, individual
An elementary school constructed with daily schedules differ greatly, making it
consideration of these three-year cycles is necessary to devise designs that provide for
the Utase Elementary School in Chiba City. such independent lifestyles, such as those
It is renowned for its “open school” policy. that consider the paths between the bedroom,
Each lower-grade classroom is accompanied bathroom, and toilet, etc. In the fourth
by a space in the courtyard, which could be ten-year period, children may leave home,
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 41
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
allowing parents to enjoy the second half The formalized rebuilding of the Ise
life with greater freedom from financial Grand Shrine occurs every 20 years. One of
burdens and various obligations. Therefore, supposed reasons for the 20-year interval is
it is necessary to thoroughly consider what that it corresponds to the duration required
one would like to do and in what type of to transfer construction techniques to a new
dwelling one wishes to live during this generation. Considering that human
period of life. Once people become old, they life-spans were shorter in ancient times, this
require handrails along hallways and parallels the 30-year cycles of the modern
staircases and may also need to consider era. This is a remarkable example of
eliminating differences in floor levels. One temporal design that ensured the eternal
may eventually require a wheelchair or perpetuation of the sacred shrine.
become bedridden. It is possible to count the Another example is the Disaster
number of years, but impossible to foresee Reduction and Human Renovation
the future. Life is replete with uncertainties. Institution in Hyogo Prefecture. Dedicated
Therefore, a long-term perspective that to commemorating the Great
considers the ten-year cycles should not be Hanshin–Awaji Earthquake, this building
ignored in planning a home, which is part of was established as a center for hosting
the basic infrastructure that supports life. informative exhibitions about the earthquake,
Separating the skeleton (building frame displaying materials related to the
and energy/water/drainage infrastructures) Earthquake, conducting research about
and the infill (interior structures) is a design urban disasters, and disseminating
approach that can be applied to such corresponding information. For these
structures, which effectively fulfills the
needs of the ten-year cycle. Such
construction enables the modification of
only the infill, without touching the skeleton,
in accordance to the changes in the different
periods of life. Since houses can be
renovated without deconstructing the
skeleton, the method is eco-friendly and
contributes to resource conservation.
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 42
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
i) 100-year cycle
In Japan and other advanced countries,
people now reach the age of approximately
100 years old. Human development has been Photo. 2-8 Site of Hyogo Prefectural Museum
accelerating since the dawn of history. Even of Archeology in Onaka Archeological Park
though we may lose track due o rapid
changes in the business world, it is
important to remain aware of such 100-year
cycles in relation to the enrichment of
culture and landscape which are the
basement for the third stage of human life
glowing, when considering urban
environments, architecture, and houses.
The Hyogo Prefectural Museum of
Archeology inside the Onaka Archeological
Park, holds pit-type dwellings from the
Jomon Period that have been discovered and
reconstructed. One of the functions of this
building is the preservation of the original
atmosphere and landscape of the
archeological park. Therefore, the building
was constructed within a new artificial hill
inside the park. When visitors enter the Photo. 2-9
museum, which represents an ancient world, Interior of Hyogo Prefectural Museum of Archeology
they walk along a walkway surrounded by The wall which is consisted of the waste soil
huge walls designed based on the motif of produced by the construction work
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 43
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 44
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
In this sense, this architecture is a good ii) Imaginary present: 10–15 min
example of temporal design attuned to the Many people would agree to experiencing
emotional present. boredom when the cityscape remains
constant for more than 10 or 15 min,
especially a busy cityscape. Hypothetically,
it is assumed that an image is formed
through the integration of the previously
mentioned moments of the emotional
present, and that this process occurs in the
10–15 min time domain, identified as the
imaginary present. This is exemplified by
the way in which a 600–1000 m area, the
distance covered in 10–15 minutes of
walking, is easily graspable by our minds as
same area of city and one colony. In
addition, in the case of documentary films,
etc., the maximum duration for
uninterrupted concentration on a single
theme is generally believed to be 15
Photo. 2-10 Mizu-mido at Honpuku-ji minutes.
(Tadao Ando 0 Process and Idea;TOTO Press) An architectural design that considers this
predominant period is the Kaiyu-type garden
(stroll gardens with a central pond), such as
that found at the Katsura Imperial Villa and
Rokuon-ji Temple. A Kaiyu-type garden
typically has a large pond at the center, a
path around the pond, an artificial hill, a
small island in the pond, bridges, rocks of
various shapes, an arbor, and a tea house.
Such elements provide the visitors with
changing scenery as they walk around the
garden, while also imparting a strong unified
image of the garden. Thus, such gardens are
pioneering examples of temporal design
related to this time domain.
3. SUMMARY
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 45
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
Table 2. Sense of time (Left hemisphere of the brain) and temporal designing
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 46
[Link] ISSN 1346-7824
REFERENCE
Ando, Y. and Hosaka, I., 1983; Journal of Chen, C. and Ando, Y., 1996b; Journal of
Acoustical Society of America, 74(S1), Architectural Planning and
S64-65(A). Environmental Engineering,
Ando, Y., 1983; Journal of the Acoustical Architectural Institute of Japan(AIJ),
society of America, 74, 873-887. 489, 73-80.
Ando, Y. and Singh, P.K., 1997; Ed. Ando, Takatsu,A. , Mori.Y. and Ando, Y, 1997;
Y. and Noson, D., Academic Press, Music and Concert Hall Acoustics,
London, Chap.4. Academic Press, London Chap.30
Ando, Y. and Chen, C., 1996a; J Journal of Takatsu, A., Sakai, H. and Ando, Y, 2000;
Architectural Planning and Acoustical design and measurement of a
Environmental circular hall, improving a spatial factor
Engineering, Architectural Institute of at each seat. Journal of Sound and
Japan(AIJ), 488, 67-73. Vibration 232(1)、263-273.
Ando, Y., 1998; Architectural Acoustics, Takatsu, A., Sakai, H. and Ando, Y, 2000;
Blending Sound Sources, Sound Fields, Acoustical design and measurement of a
and Listeners, AIP Press /Springer - circular hall, improving a spatial factor
at each seat. Journal of Sound and
Verlag, New York
Vibration 232(1)、263-273.
Ando, Y., 2009a; Auditory and visual
Takatsu, A., Sakai, H. and Ando, Y, July
sensations. Springer-Verlag, New York
2000; Acoustical design and
Ando, Y., 2009b; Theory of temporal and measurement of a circular hall,
spatial design of environment, Mcgraw improving a spatial factor at each seat.
Hill 2009 Yearbook of Science and Building Acoustics, 113-125.
Technology, Ed. Blumel, D. Mcgraw Takatsu, A., Sakai, H. and Ando, Y, 2002;
Hill, New York, P.384-389 Blending architectural and acoustical
Ando, Y. Ando, T., 2010; Journal of factors in designing a round event hall.
Temporal design in Architecture and Journal of Sound and Vibration 258(3),
Environment, 10, 1-6. 499-515
J. Temporal Des. Arch. Environ. VOL.12 (1), 2013 Takatsu, A., Ando, Y., 47