High-Performance Concrete with Admixtures
High-Performance Concrete with Admixtures
ABSTRACT
1
Abstract
In today’s world concrete is probably the most extensively used
construction material in the world. But the conventional concrete is losing
its uses with time and High-performance concrete is taking that place.
There is a growing awareness all over the world about the waste
material like fly ash from thermal power plants, silica fume, and blast
furnace slag etc. high-performance concrete taking this waste material to
be produced. The Thesis presents experimental studies conducted on 2
samples of HPC mix of M60 grade using Silica Fume as a mineral
admixture to replace the cement by 2.5%, 5%, 7.5% and M80 grade
using Fly ash (FA) is replaced with cement by various percentages i.e.,
5%, 10%, 15%, 20%, 25% and silica fume (SF) as addition of 10% by
weight of cement. Effect of adding mineral admixture to concrete were
studied. In first sample, On comparing the result high performance
concrete having 7.5% Silica Fume gives a maximum compressive
strength value. Maximum splitting tensile strength value is achieved
when cement is replaced with 7.5% of Silica Fume. Hence it is
concluded 7.5% of Silica Fume gives the maximum compressive and
tensile strength to the concrete we can say that concrete mix is high
strength concrete.
Performance properties of the concrete need to be studied. On the other
hand in second sample, the compressive strength is increased by 11%
for replacement of cement by 15% fly ash and silica fume 10% was
addition of cement. The flexural strength test value for 28 days was
found to be 8.5 N/mm2 .The split tensile strength test value for 28 days
was fund to be 4.2N/mm2 .It can be concluded that the percentage
weight loss due to HCL and H2SO4 solutions for combination of SF %10
as addition of cement and 15% FA replacement of cement is minimum
compare to all trails.
2
Chapter 2
INTRODUCTION
3
[Link]
4
high modulus of elasticity, low permeability and resistance to
chemical attack as compared to normal strength concrete. To
produce such a high performance concrete mineral admixtures like
silica fume, fly ash metakaolin, GGBS on the one hand and super
plasticizer on the other hand used along with normal ingredients.
High performance concrete is not a special concrete. It is same as
conventional concrete but because of lower water cement ratio,
the use of some admixtures and super plasticizer etc…
they can be summarized as the following five aspects:
High durability.
It is of long service life and small maintenance cost under normal
service condition. Under special service conditions, it can meet the
special requirements of anti-erosion, anti-freeze and thaw
resistance in harsh environment.
High construction performance.
It can smoothly complete the transportation and pouring of
concrete under specific construction conditions, so that the
concrete structure with superior compactness and uniformity can
be obtained;
Higher strength.
It is able to satisfy the strength requirement of design bearing
capacity, and has enough capacity to increase strength in the later
period to ensure that the strength of structural concrete does not
shrink under normal conditions;
High volume stability.
Concrete is not stratified and segregated before condensation, and
its volume changes little after hardening, with good crack
resistance;
It can meet the requirements of environmental protection and
sustainable development.
In many field applications concrete is required to meet certain
specific performance requirements besides high strength. For
prestressed concrete bridges, offshore structures, highway and
airport pavements and in machine foundations, concrete should
possess high fatigue strength. For nuclear containers exposed to
very high temperatures, the concrete must have high resistance to
thermal cracking. All these needs have made the researchers to
think seriously to find out an appropriate technology through
research and HPC was the outcome.
5
It was observed and noted that since decade of years that the cost
of building materials is currently so high that only corporate
organizations, individual, and government can afford to do
meaningful construction. Waste can be used as filler material in
concrete, admixtures in cement and raw material in cement clinker,
or aggregates in concrete.
HPC technologies have used for the construction of numerous off-
shore structures and long span bridges; repairs & rehabilitation
works. The philosophy of HPC concrete design should be
STRENGTH through DURABITLITY. The development of High
Performance concrete (HPC) to improve its performance has
brought the essential need for additives both chemical and mineral
of concrete. Most of the Developments across the work have been
supported by continuous improvement of these admixtures.
Hence, varieties of admixtures such as, Fly ash, Rice husk ash,
Stone dust, Silica fume.
. High performance concrete is used for concrete mixture which
has high strength, high workability, high durability, high density,
and high modulus of elasticity, low permeability and resistance to
chemical attack as compared to normal strength concrete. To
produce such a high performance concrete mineral admixtures like
silica fume, fly ash metakaolin, GGBS on the one hand and super
plasticizer on the other hand used along with normal ingredients.
High performance concrete is not a special concrete. It is same as
conventional concrete but because of lower water cement ratio,
the use of some admixtures and super plasticizer etc…
6
Higher strength.
It is able to satisfy the strength requirement of design bearing
capacity, and has enough capacity to increase strength in the later
period to ensure that the strength of structural concrete does not
shrink under normal conditions;
High volume stability.
Concrete is not stratified and segregated before condensation, and
its volume changes little after hardening, with good crack
resistance;
It can meet the requirements of environmental protection and
sustainable development.
In many field applications concrete is required to meet certain
specific performance requirements besides high strength. For
prestressed concrete bridges, offshore structures, highway and
airport pavements and in machine foundations, concrete should
possess high fatigue strength. For nuclear containers exposed to
very high temperatures, the concrete must have high resistance to
thermal cracking. All these needs have made the researchers to
think seriously to find out an appropriate technology through
research and HPC was the outcome.
Water-reducing Admixture, the name itself defines that they are used to
minimize the demand for water in a concrete mix.
Workability is the important property of concrete, which is improved by
adding water, but if the water is added more than necessary, the
strength and durability properties of concrete will be affected.
Retarding Admixture
8
These accelerators also improve the strength of the concrete in the initial
stage, increasing the rate of hydration.
Air Entraining Admixtures
10
Chapter 3
LITERATURE SURVEY
11
[Link] Survey
12
2.2 Application of Mineral Admixture in High Performance Concrete
By Shan Wu Southeast University. Mineral admixture is a key material
component in high performance concrete. With the low water cement
ratio, mineral admixture is of advantages: Increase later strength of
concrete, reduce the hydration heat, enhance the compactness of
concrete internal structure, improve the corrosion resistance and wear
resistance, and decrease carbon dioxide emissions, so as to achieve
rational utilization of resource and energy conservation and emission
reduction under the new situation, and meet the economic and
environmental requirement. In recent years, high performance concrete
has been applied and popularized in practical engineering, which shows
The superiority of using mineral admixtures to replace cement, and
summarizes the practical engineering experience. With the low water
cement ratio, mineral admixture is of advantages: Increase later strength
of concrete, reduce the hydration heat, enhance the compactness of
concrete internal structure, improve the corrosion resistance and wear
resistance, and decrease carbon dioxide emissions, so as to achieve
rational utilization of resource and energy conservation and emission
reduction under the new situation, and meet the economic and
environmental requirement.
13
strength improvement is almost close to the strength development in
silica fume concrete. The main aim of silica fume and metakaolin
replacement is to increase strength whereas the aim of addition of fly
ash was for economy and for improving the strength of hardened
concrete. The early age strength can be achieved by adding silica
fume and metakaolin. At all ages of 7, 28, 56 and 90 days, the
compressive strength of HPC with silica fume and metakaolin is more
than that of normal concrete. It may be noted that addition of silica
fume and metakaolin causes an increase in strength at all ages. But
fly ash gains strength at 56 and 90 days. From the results, it was
found that the optimum replacement of silica fume, metakaolin and fly
ash are 10%, 10% and 15%.The main aim of silica fume and
metakaolin replacement is to increase strength whereas the aim of
addition of fly ash was for economy and for improving the strength of
hardened concrete. The early age strength can be achieved by
adding silica fume and metakaolin. At all ages of 7, 28, 56 and 90
days, the compressive strength of HPC with silica fume and
metakaolin is more than that of normal concrete.
14
and micro filler mineral admixtures. Chemically active mineral
admixtures decrease workability and setting time of concrete but
increase the heat of hydration and reactivity. On the other hand, micro
filler mineral admixtures increase workability and setting time of
concrete but decrease the heat of hydration and reactivity. In general,
small particle size and higher specific surface area of mineral
admixture are favorable to produce highly dense and impermeable
concrete; however, they cause low workability and demand more
water which may be offset by adding effective superplasticizer
Mineral admixture
[Link] ash
[Link] fume
[Link]
small particle size and higher specific surface area of mineral
admixture are favorable to produce highly dense and impermeable
concrete; however, they cause low workability and demand more
water which may be offset by adding effective superplasticizer
2.5 Strength and Durability of High-Performance Concrete
[Link], K .Thamizh thendral, Dr. [Link]
1ME(Structural Engineering) Dept. of Civil Engineering, Oxford
Engineering College Tiruchirappalli, Tamilnadu, India
2Assistant Professor, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Oxford Engineering
College Tiruchirappalli, Tamilnadu, India
3Professor and Head, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Oxford Engineering
College Tiruchirappalli, Tamilnadu, India
In today’s world concrete is probably the most extensively used
construction material in the world. But the conventional concrete is
losing its uses with time and High performance concrete is taking that
place. There is a growing awareness all over the world about the
waste material like fly ash from thermal power plants, silica fume, and
blast furnace slag etc. high performance concrete taking this waste
material to be produced. The paper presents experimental studies
conducted on HPC mix of M60 grade using Silica Fume as a mineral
admixture to replace the cement by 2.5%, 5%, 7.5%. Effect of adding
mineral admixture to concrete were studied. This project work is
15
primarily focused on the properties of materials used, mix proportion
of High Performance Concrete, making of concrete specimen, curing
and testing of harden [Link] project work is primarily focused
on the properties of materials used, mix proportion of High
Performance Concrete, making of concrete specimen, curing and
testing of harden concrete
2.6 STRENGTH AND DURABILITY PROPERTIES OF HIGH
PERFORMANCE CONCRETE INCORPORATING SILICA FUME AND
FLY ASH
B. Krishna Kumari Bai, M. Kanta Rao Department of Civil
Engineering, V.R. Siddhartha engineering College, Vijayawada, India.
This paper deals with an experimental work on the effect of fly ash,
silica fume and their combinations of strength and durability
characteristics of high-performance concrete. The normal concrete is
failing its usage in modern days and it does not serve the present
needs. Hence to improve strength, workability and durability of the
concrete, high performance concrete with mineral admixtures, lower
water cement ratio and super plasticizers are used. Fly ash (FA) is
replaced with cement by various percentages i.e., 5%, 10%, 15%,
20%, 25% and silica fume (SF) as addition of 10% by weight of
cement. It has been observed that the workability and required
strengths are achieved at optimum percentage i.e. 10% silica fume is
addition and 15% fly ash is replacement by weight of cement. Water
cement ratio is 0.32. Water cement ratio is kept constant for all trail
mixtures. This paper deals with the study of properties like
compressive strength, workability, durability, flexural strength and
split tensile strength for M80 grade concrete. Admixtures use will lead
to a reduction in cement content therefore reduce the emission of co2
and reduce the environmental pollution.
TESTS
1. Compressive strength
2. Split tensile strength
3. Flexural strength
4. Durability test
16
The compressive strength is increased by 11% for replacement of
cement by 15% fly ash and silica fume 10% was addition of
cement. The flexural strength test value for 28 days was found to
be 8.5 N/mm2. The split tensile strength test value for 28 days was
fund to be 4.2N/mm2
17
Chapter 4
METHODOLOGY
18
[Link] from Tests :-
19
Figure-1
Figure-2
20
3.2 Procedure of Slump flow test:-
Figure-3
Figure-4
Figure-5
After curing, wipe out water from the surface of specimen
Using a marker, draw diametrical lines on the two ends of the
specimen to verify that they are on the same axial place.
Measure the dimensions of the specimen.
Keep the plywood strip on the lower plate and place the
specimen.
Align the specimen so that the lines marked on the ends are
vertical and centred over the bottom plate.
Place the other plywood strip above the specimen and bring down
the upper plate to touch the plywood strip.
Apply the load continuously without shock at a rate of
approximately 14-21 kg/cm2/minute (Which corresponds to a total
load of 9.9 ton/minute to 14.85 ton/minute)
Write the breaking load (P)
22
SAMPLE 01
3.4 MATERIALS USED
Cement
PPC 43 grade cement is used for this study, this grade was introduced
by BIS in the year 1987 and commercial production started from 1991.
The advent of this grade in the country owes it to the improved
technology adopted by modern cement plants. Design Strength of PPC
43 grade cement is should be minimum 43 MPa or 430 kg/sq cm at 28
days.
Table -01
Silica Fume
Silica fume is a by-product of the silicon and ferrosilicon Alloy production
and the average size of particle has a Diameter of 150 nano micron. It is
very effective in lowering The water-cement ratio, so superplasticizers
should be used while silica fume used as an admixture. The main
23
application of a pozzolanic material for high-performance concrete.
Particles of silica fume are allowed to fill the space between the cement
grains, denser concrete is achieved when silica fume used as an
admixture or a cement replacement material. The compressive strength
of silica fume is more than 150MPa. The compressive strength of silica
fume is more than 150MPa. Using of Silica Fume, with superplasticizers
will improve the bonding between paste and aggregate by forming a
dense microstructure in the interfacial transition zone.
Table -02
M-Sand
Manufactured sand (M-Sand) was used as a substitute for the River
sand for construction works. M- Sand was produced by Crushing the
hard granite stone cubical shape and grounded Edges are achieved
form crushing, these stones are washed And graded as a construction
material. The manufactured Sand (M Sand) having the size less than
4.75mm. Due to fast Growing construction industry, the demand for sand
has Increased tremendously, causing deficiency of suitable river Sand in
most part of the word. M-Sand is easily available and Transportation
cost of the sand is less. It can be dust free and The size of the m-sand is
controlled easily to achieve the Required grading for the construction.
24
Table -03
Table -04
25
Coarse Aggregate
Aggregate are the important constituents in concrete. They Give body to
the concrete, reduce the shrinkage and effect Economy. Earlier,
aggregates were considered as chemically Inert materials but now it has
been recognized some of the Aggregates are chemically active also
some aggregates Exhibit chemical bond at the interface of aggregate
and paste. The aggregates will occupy the 70 -80% of the concrete
Volume. Aggregate bigger than 4.75mm considered as coarse
Aggregate having the size bigger than 4.75mm, Aggregates Having the
size less than 4.75mm is consider as the fine Aggregate. Generally
maximum size of aggregate should be As large as possible within the
limits specified, but any case Not greater than one – fourth of the
minimum thickness of The member.
4. Methodology
4.1 Manufacturing
Fly Ash is produced when coal is burnt during power generation about
1600∘ C (2912∘ F) [28]. This burning also results in some incombustible
materials which amalgamate to form spherical glassy droplets of silica
(SiO2), alumina (Al2O3), iron oxide (Fe2O3), and other minor
constituents. According to ASTM C 618-05, there are two classes of FA
based on the types of coal from which it originates. The Class F is
produced by burning anthracites which is mainly a siliceous and
possesses pozzolanic characteristics. The Class C contains lime and
higher MgO content and it is produced by burning lignite and
subbituminous coal. Class C fly ash is lighter in color in comparison with
other ashes and may cause expansion and their strength behaviour at
high temperature is not apparent.
Silica Fume is a by-product obtained after reducing high-purity quartz
with coal in electric arc furnace by heating up to 2000∘ C (3632∘ F)
during the production of silicon. By oxidation and condensation of
exhaust gas SiO, very fine spherical particles of SF are obtained which
are highly reactive with the Ca(OH)2 produced during hydration of
cement [5]. SF consists of extremely fine particles of average The
Scientific World Journal 3 diameters 0.1 𝜇m (0.00000394 in.), having
26
pozzolanic characteristics and tendency to develop plastic shrinkage
cracks [29, 30].
27
Figure-8 Fly Ash
28
Table -05 Properties of Silica Fumes
Table -06
29
Materials confining to IS standards are selected and casting Is done with
proper mix proportioning as per the mix design. Mineral admixtures are
added to the concrete by replacing the cement to achieve the high
strength concrete.
Table -07
SAMPLE 02
Materials
The materials 53 grade ordinary Portland cement confirming to IS:
12269. Sand was conforming zone II according to IS: 383. Coarse
30
aggregates size 12.5mm and 20mm are used. Sand is locally available
river sand is used. The bulk density of coarse aggregate is 1710kg/m2.
Silica fume is a by-product of producing silicon metal or ferrosilicon
allows. Silica fume play an important role in improving the strength of
concrete particularly at early ages. Fly ash is principle by-product of coal
fired power plants. Mineral admixtures like Silica fume and fly ash are
industrial waste by-products. In the present study water reducing
admixture Gallium B233 obtained from BFSA chemicals was used. The
chemicals used for durability tests are Hydrochloric acid (HCL) and
Sulphuric acid (H2SO4).
Table-08
Table-09
31
Silica fume (SF) as addition of 10% by weight cement is constant for all
trail mixes. Fly ash is Replacement by weight cement varying up to 30%.
Mix proportion of concrete is given below table
Table-10
32
Chapter 5
RESULTS & DISCUSSION
33
6. Result and Discussion :-
SAMPLE 01
6.1 Slump Flow Test
To determine the reference slump value for concrete and to Calibrate it
against an equivalent measure using a flow table. Mould is the shape of
a truncated cone with the internal Dimensions 200 mm diameter at the
base, 100mm diameter At the top and a height of 300 mm. Concrete
poured in Three layers. Each layer is tampered about 25 times.
Immediately the cone is lifted in an upward direction Fig. Slump Cone Test
Table-11
34
The development of Compressive Strength of M60grade of HPC mixes
containing 2.5, 5, 7.5, percent of Silica Fume at the various stages are
plotted in the form of graphs are shown in below Chart .
Figure-11 Chart: Compressive Strength Test result.
Results shows that of Silica Fume mixed with cement gives Higher compressive
strength than normal HPC0 (HPC with 0% replacement of cement). It is interesting to
see that the Compressive strength of HPC with 7.5% Silica Fume was Higher than
that of the Controlled mix. This result shows the Benefit of using Silica Fume to
produce HPC with higher Replacement of cement about 7.5%. When compared with
The conventional concrete, HPC3 showed 19.3%, 23.3% and 23.98% increase in
Compressive Strength for 7 days, 14 days And 28 days curing.
35
after that cylinder is placed in CTM for testing. The Load is applied until
the cracks were in the cylinder Specimen. The split tensile strength
result of concrete was Presented in Table below. The split tensile
strength results of High-Performance Concrete mixes at the ages of 7,
14, 28 days are presented in Table below.
The split tensile strength of M60 grade of HPC mixes Containing 2.5, 5, 7.5, percent of Silica
Table-12
36
Sample 02
6.4 Compressive strength
Table-13
In this test is silica fume as addition by weight of cement is 10% and fly
ash is replacement by weight of cement is 15% gives required strengths.
37
Figure-12 Compressive strength of SF & FA
Table-14
38
6.5 Split Tensile strength
Figure-13
39
Chapter 6
CONCLUSION & FUTURE
SCOPE
40
7. CONCLUSION
This project work is primarily focused on the properties of Materials
used, mix proportion of High-Performance Concrete, making of concrete
specimen, curing and testing of Harden concrete. On performing the
various tests, the physical properties of The specimens are studied and
the following conclusions are Arrived. On comparing the result high
performance concrete having 7.5% Silica Fume gives a maximum
compressive strength Value. Maximum splitting tensile strength value is
achieved when Cement is replaced with 7.5% of Silica Fume. Hence it is
concluded 7.5% of Silica Fume gives the Maximum compressive and
tensile strength to the concrete We can say that concrete mix is high
strength concrete. Performance properties of the concrete need to be
studied.
On comparing the result high performance concrete having 7.5% Silica
Fume gives a maximum compressive strength value. Maximum splitting
tensile strength value is achieved when cement is replaced with 7.5% of
Silica Fume. Hence it is concluded 7.5% of Silica Fume gives the
maximum compressive and tensile strength to the concrete we can say
that concrete mix is high strength concrete. Performance properties of
the concrete need to be studied.
The compressive strength is increased by 11% for
replacement of cement by 15% fly ash and silica fume 10%
was addition of cement.
The flexural strength test value for 28 days was found to be
8.5 N/mm2.
The split tensile strength test value for 28 days was fund to
be 4.2N/mm2.
It can be concluded that the percentage weight loss due to
HCL and H2SO4 solutions for combination of SF %10 as
addition of cement and 15% FA replacement of cement is
minimum compare to all trails.
41
8. Future Scope
The influence of high-performance concrete on the future of our industry
will been expanding the areas of application and utilization as well as
offering long term service performance, with low life-cycle costs. Major
floating vessels already are under construction in Norway, giving
promise of world wide application including the Gulf of Mexico. Ever
longer bridge span become both physically and economically feasible.
However, spectacular projects such as the above are not the principal
beneficiaries of high-performance concrete. Rather the far more
common and widely dispersed infrastructure projects under construction
and planned, which will serve the world of tomorrow, are those that will
most benefit from these major advances in quality. For these, it is the
recognition of the manifold properties of concrete, the rational
assignment of objectives to attain specific projects, and the ability to
realize these in practice that is the great achievement. This development
imposes great obligations on our entire industry. We must carry out
research in areas where needs are still unfulfilled: for example,
development of high inherent tensile strength. We must disseminate
knowledge of the opportunities and constraints to designers. And we
must develop improved placement techniques for both the steel and the
concrete. As so often occurs, past achievements have been
accompanied by new and ever more demanding challenges for the
future.
42
Chapter 7
REFERENCES
43
9. References :-
[Link]
[Link]
performance-concrete
[Link]
admixture#:~:text=An%20admixture%20is%20defined%20as,ACI
%20Committee%20212%2C%202010).
[Link]
admixture
Experimental Investigations of Mechanical properties on Micro
silica (Silica Fume) and Fly Ash as Partial Cement Replacement of
High-Performance Concrete By Magudeaswaran, Eswaramoorthi
Application of Mineral Admixture in High Performance Concrete
By Shan Wu Southeast University
Study on Effect of Mineral Admixtures in High Performance
Concrete By S Poojitha, M K M V Ratnam, P J D Anjaneyulu
Effects of Different Mineral Admixtures on
the Properties of Fresh Concrete By Sadaqat Ullah Khan,
Muhammad Fadhil Nuruddin, Tehmina Ayub, and Nasir Shafiq
Strength and Durability of High-Performance Concrete By [Link],
K .Thamizh thendral, Dr. [Link]
STRENGTH AND DURABILITY PROPERTIES OF HIGH
PERFORMANCE CONCRETE INCORPORATING SILICA FUME
AND FLY ASH By B. Krishna Kumari Bai, M. Kanta Rao
[Link]
[Link]
compressive-strength-concrete-cube-test/1561/
[Link]
44