Financial Ratio Analysis: Indigo vs SpiceJet
Financial Ratio Analysis: Indigo vs SpiceJet
1
N.G. ACHARYA & D.K. MARATHE COLLEGE OF ARTS COMMERCE & SCIENCE.
(NAAC – ACCREDITED-A)
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that DUBEY NEHA DINESHCHADRA has worked and duly completed her Project
Work for
the degree of Master in Commerce (ACCOUNTING & FINANCE) under the Faculty of
Commerce and her project is entitled, “FINANCIAL RATIO ANALYSIS OF INTERGLOBE AVIATION &
SPICEJET”under supervision of Ast. Prof. NEELAM PATIL
. I further certify that the entire
work has been done by the learner under my guidance and that no part of it has been
submitted previously for any Degree or Diploma of any University.
It is her own work and facts reported by her findings and investigations.
2
ACKNOWLEDGEMNET
To list who all have helped me is difficult because they are so numerous and the depth is so
enormous. I would like to acknowledge the following as being idealistic channels and fresh
dimensions in the completion of this project.
I take this opportunity to thank the University Of Mumbai for giving me chance to do this
project.
I would like to thank my Principal, Prof. Dr. Vidya Gauri Lele for providing the
necessary facilities required for completion of this project.
I take this opportunity to thank our Coordinator Prof. Akhila Maheshwari, for his moral
support and guidance. I would also like to express my sincere gratitude towards my project
guide Ast. Prof. NEELAM PATIL whose guidance and care made the project successful
I would like to thank my College Library, for providing various reference books and
magazines related to my project.
Lastly, I would like to thank each and every person who directly and indirectly helped me
in the completion of the project especially my Parents and Peers who supported me
throughout my project.
3
Declaration
I the undersigned Miss/Mr. DUBEY NEHA DINESHCHADRA here by declare that the
project work titled “Financial Ratio Analysis of Interglobal Aviation (Indigo) and
Spicejet” forms my own contribution to the research work carried out under the guidance of
Ast. Prof. NEELAM PATIL is a result of my own research work and has not been previously
submitted to any other University for any other Degree/ Diploma to this or any other
University. Wherever reference has been made to previous works of others, it has been
clearly indicated as such and included in the bibliography. I, here by further declare that all
information of this document has been obtained and presented in accordance with
Certified by,
4
INDEX
CHAPTER NO. TITLE OF CHAPTER PAGE NO
Introduction:
Literature Review:
• Inter globe aviation limited
3 • Company overview 23-41
• Industry overview
• Business overview
• SWOT analysis of indigo aviation
• History of space jet airline
Peer comparison:
5 • Comparison 68-77
• Valuation
• Financial
• Share holding
6 Conclusion : 78-82
7 Bibliography : 83
5
INTRODUCTION
Now that you know financial ratio definition analysis, let’s look at the importance of this all-
essential analysis. With the help of financial ratio analysis, you can
6
• Analyse operational efficiency of a firm:-
With certain financial ratios such as account receivables turnover, fixed asset turnover and
inventory turnover ratio, you can find out the degree of efficiency of a firm. You can use these
ratios to compare two different industries in the same domain to find out which company is
better managed compared to the other
Apart from these, financial ratio analysis aid in identifying financial risks of a company and
understanding future prospects
7
Objectives of Ratio Analysis:-
Ratio analysis serves the purpose of various users who are interested in the financial
statements. It simplifies summaries and systematizes the figures in the financial statements.
• Short-term solvency is the ability of the enterprise to meet its short-term financial obligations.
Whereas, Long-term solvency is the ability of the enterprise to pay its long-term liabilities of the
business.
• Ratio analysis will help validate or disprove the financing, investment and operating decisions of
the firm. They summarize the financial statement into comparative figures, thus helping the
management to compare and evaluate the financial position of the firm and the results of their
decisions.
Financial ratios, which compare one value in relation to another value over a 12 month
period, are computed using information from a company's financial statements. Ratios can
identify various financial attributes of a company, such as solvency and liquidity, profitability
(quality of income), and return on equity
8
Uses and Users of Financial Ratio Analysis
Users of financial ratios include parties external and internal to the company:
External users: Financial analysts, retail investors, creditors, competitors, tax authorities,
regulatory authorities, and industry observers
Internal users: Management team, employees, and owners
9
Research and Methodology
Advantages of Ratio Analysis
Ratio analysis is a very important technique of analysing financial strength and weaknesses
of an organisation.
The advantages of ratio analysis is given below:
(i) Analytical Ability:
The financial ability of an organisation can be judged through ratio analysis. Solvency,
profitability, liquidity, etc., can be analysed with the help of ratios. Weakness can be sorted out
and remedial measures can be taken.
(ii) Inter-firm Comparison:
With the help of ratio inter-firm comparison under the same management or with the competitors
can be judged. Solvency, liquidity, profitability, efficiency, etc., can be compared within the
same industry or with outsiders.
(iii) Measurement of Long-term Solvency Position:
With the help of ratio analysis, an analyst may determine the long-term debt paying capacity of a
firm. Those who are long-term investors of the firm say Creditors, Debenture holders, Bank, etc.,
can take the decision wisely whether to invest in the firm or not.
(iv) Measurement of Profitability:
Ratio analysis helps to determine the earning capacity or profitability of a firm. Moreover, trends
or variation in profitability over the years can also be judged with the help of ratio analysis.
(v) Measurement of Liquidity Position:
The liquidity position of a firm can also be determined with the help of ratio analysis. Here
liquidity means short-term debt repayment capacity. With the help of current ratio, liquid ratio,
etc., creditors, financial institutions, etc., can take decisions regarding granting of short-term
credit.
Assist in Decision-making:
10
Overall efficiency of an organisation can be judged with the help of ratio analysis. Management
can make valuable decisions on the basis of computed ratios.
(vi) Managerial Efficiency Regarding Utilisation of Assets:
With the help of ratio analysis the managerial efficiency regarding utilisation of different assets
can be determined.
(vii) Assist in Controlling:
Ratio analysis is a very useful tool for controlling the financial activities of a firm. For this
purpose different expense ratios are calculated for different years and help the top management
aware to control the specific areas.
11
i. Ratios make it more convenient to estimate other figures when one figure is known.
ii. Investment decisions are based on ratio analysis.
iii. They act as an index or parameter of efficiency of the firm or Organizations.
iv. It is one type of tool management
v. It simplifies many complicated financial statements.
vi. It highlights the weakness of the enterprise.
vii. It provides more analysis information to the management for decision making and controlling
purposes.
12
Though ratio analysis gives different benefits to an organisation and also to the different outside
users still this is not free from limitations.
Hence, comparison is only one of the techniques for finding some result but other tests also have
influence to give some conclusions which are absent in ratio analysis.
For example, one firm follows the cost price of stock valuation and another firm follows cost or
market price, whichever is lower. Definitely stock turnover ratio will give misleading results.
The standard ratio once decided for the industry is not rigid and may change over time. Hence,
fixing standards for all the ratios is really a very hard task for different situations.
13
(vi) Personal Influence:
Interpreters must have a sound knowledge and analytical ability for calculating ratios. Often it is
seen, the interpreter applies his personal influence while determining ratios for different
purposes. This may give a misleading result and be valueless for the firm.
14
Liquidity Ratio Analysis
The first type of financial ratio analysis is the Liquidy Ratio. The liquidity ratio aim is to
determine the ability of a business to meet its financial obligations during the short-term and to
maintain its short-term debt paying ability. Liquidity ratio can be calculated by multiple ways
they are as follows:-
1 – Current Ratio
The Current ratio is referred to as a working capital ratio or banker’s ratio. The current ratio
expresses the relationship of a current asset to current liabilities.
Formula = Current Assets / Current Liabilities
A company’s current ratio can be compared with the past current ratio; this will help to
determine if the current ratio is high or low at this period in time.
The ratio of 1 is considered to be ideal that is current assets are twice a current liability, then no
issue will be in repaying liability, and if the ratio is less than 2, repayment of liability will be
difficult and work effects.
15
The quick ratio can be written as:-
Quick Ratio Formula = Quick Assets / Current Liabilities
Or
Quick Ratio Formula = Quick Assets / Quick Liabilities
4 – Cash Ratio
The Cash ratio is useful for a company that is undergoing is financial trouble.
Cash Ratio Formula = Cash + Marketable Securities / Current Liability
If the ratio is high, then it reflects the underutilization of resources, and if the ratio is low, then it
can lead to a problem in repayment of bills.
16
8 – Asset Turnover Ratio
This financial ratio reveals the number of times the net tangible assets are turned over during a
year. The higher the ratio better it is.
Asset Turnover Ratio Formula = Turnover / Net Tangible Assets
11 – Earning Margin
It is the ratio of net income to turnover express in percentage. It refers to the final net profit used.
Earning Margin formula = Net Income / Turnover * 100
13 – Return On Equity
Return on equity is derived by taking net income and dividing it by shareholder’s equity; it
provides a return that management is realizing from the shareholder’s equity.
Return on Equity Formula = Profit After Taxation – Preference Dividends / Ordinary
Shareholder’s Fund * 100
17
The investor uses all the above ratio before investing and make maximum profit and analyze
risk. Through ratio, it is easy for him to compare and predict the future growth of a company. It
also simplifies the financial statement.
15 – Operating Leverage
Operating leverage is the percentage change in operating profit relative to sales, and it
measures how sensitive the operating income is to the change in revenues. Greater the use
of fixed costs, the greater the impact of a change in sales on the operating income of a company.
Operating Leverage Formula = % change in EBIT / % change in Sales
16 – Financial Leverage
Financial leverage is the percentage change in Net profit relative to Operating Profit, and it
measures how sensitive the Net Income is to the change in Operating Income. Financial leverage
primarily originates from the company’s financing decisions (usage of debt).
Financial Leverage formula = % change in Net Income / % change in EBIT
17 – Total Leverage
Total leverage is the percentage change in Net profit relative to its Sales. Total leverage
measures how sensitive the Net Income is to the change in Sales.
Total Leverage Formula = % change in Net Profit / % change in Sales
Financial Risk Ratio Analysis
The fifth type of financial ratio analysis is the Financial Risk Ratio. Here we measure how
leveraged the company is and how it is placed with respect to its debt repayment capacity.
18
Debt Service Coverage Ratio tells us whether the Operating Income is sufficient to pay off all
obligations that are related to debt in a year.
Debt Service Coverage Formula = Operating Income / Debt Service
Operating Income is nothing but EBIT
Debt Service is Principal Payments + Interest Payments + Lease Payments
A DSCR of less than 1.0 implies that the operating cash flows are not sufficient enough for Debt
Servicing, implying negative cash flows.
Stability Ratios
The sixth type of financial ratio analysis is the Stability Ratio. The stability ratio is used with a
vision of the long-term. It uses to check whether the company is stable in the long run or not.
This type of ratio analysis can be calculated by multiple ways they are as follows:-
Coverage Ratios
The seventh type of financial ratio analysis is the coverage Ratio. This type of ratio analysis is
used to calculate dividend, which needs to be paid to investors or interest to be paid to the
lender. The higher the cover, the better it is. It can be calculated by the below ways:-
24 – Fixed Interest Cover
It is used to measure business profitability and its ability to repay the loan.
Fixed Interest Cover Formula = Net Profit Before Interest and Tax / Interest Charge
19
Fixed Dividend Cover Formula = Net Profit Before Interest and Tax / Dividend on
Preference Share
26 – Capacity Ratio
For this type of ratio analysis, the formula given below will be used for the same.
Capacity Ratio Formula = Actual Hour Worked / Budgeted Hour * 100
27 – Activity Ratio
To calculate a measure of activity below, the formula is used.
Activity Ratio Formula = Standard Hours for Actual Production / Budgeted Standard
Hour * 100
28 – Efficiency Ratio
To calculate productivity below formula is used.
Efficiency Ratio Formula = Standard Hours for Actual Production / Actual Hour Worked
* 100
If a percentage is 100 or more, it is considered to be as favorable; if a percentage is less than
100%, then it is unfavorable.
29 - Investment Ratios
A ratio showing the amount of investment expressed in relation to profit, costs, etc., and used to
assess financial performance; (Economics) one showing the amount a country invests in fixed
capital, expressed as gross capital formation divided by GDP, and used to indicate potential for
growth.
Types Of Investment Ratios
There are five basic ratios that are often used to pick stocks for investment portfolios. These
include price-earnings (P/E), earnings per share, debt-to-equity and return on equity
(ROE).
Price-earnings (P/E),
The price-to-earnings ratio (P/E ratio) is the ratio for valuing a company that measures its
current share price relative to its earnings per share (EPS). The price-to-earnings ratio is also
sometimes known as the price multiple or the earnings multiple.
P/E ratios are used by investors and analysts to determine the relative value of a company's
shares in an apples-to-apples comparison. It can also be used to compare a company against its
own historical record or to compare aggregate markets against one another or over t
20
Earnings per share (EPS)
Earnings per share (EPS) is calculated as a company's profit divided by the outstanding shares
of its common stock. The resulting number serves as an indicator of a company's profitability. It
is common for a company to report EPS that is adjusted for extraordinary items and potential
share dilution.
The higher a company's EPS, the more profitable it is considered to be.
• Earnings per share (EPS) is a company's net profit divided by the number of common shares it
has outstanding.
• EPS indicates how much money a company makes for each share of its stock and is a widely used
metric for estimating corporate value.
• A higher EPS indicates greater value because investors will pay more for a company's shares if
they think the company has higher profits relative to its share price.
• EPS can be arrived at in several forms, such as excluding extraordinary items or discontinued
operations, or on a diluted basis.
• The debt-to-equity (D/E) ratio compares a company’s total liabilities to its shareholder equity
and can be used to evaluate how much leverage a company is using.
• Higher-leverage ratios tend to indicate a company or stock with higher risk to shareholders.
• However, the D/E ratio is difficult to compare across industry groups where ideal amounts of
debt will vary.
• Investors will often modify the D/E ratio to focus on long-term debt only because the risks
associated with long-term liabilities are different than short-term debt and payables.
• Return on equity (ROE) is the measure of a company's net income divided by its shareholders'
equity.
• ROE is a gauge of a corporation's profitability and how efficiently it generates those profits.
• An ROE is considered satisfactory based on industry standards, though a ratio near the long-
term average of the S&P 500 of around 14% is typically considered acceptable.
21
22
Literature Review
InterGlobe (IndiGo) Aviation Ltd
Independent Director
Pallavi Shardul Shroff
Venkataramani Sumantran
Anupam Khanna
23
investors@[Link]
Internet
[Link]
Registrars Address
Selenium Tower B, Plot No. 31-32, Gachibowli, Financial District, Nanakramguda,Seri
Hyderabad, Telangana, 500032
Email
[Link]@[Link]
Internet
[Link]
Company Overview
InterGlobe Aviation Ltd (IndiGo) is (NSE: INDIGO) India’s largest passenger airline with a
market share of 54.3% as of January 2023
. The company's journey began in August 2006 on thefoundation of three pillars – offering low
fares, being on-time, and delivering a courteous and hassle-free experience. Today, IndiGo has
become synonymous with affordability, punctuality, and reliability. 1
With a fleet of 280 aircraft and growing, the company connect people across the globe to a
network of over 91 destinations worldwide. A uniform fleet for each type of operation, high
operational reliability and award-winning service make it one of the most reliable airlines in the
world. Flying to 67 Destinations in India and 24 Internationally.
IndiGo is not only the most efficient low fare operator domestically but is also comparable with
global low cost airlines. IndiGo is constantly enhancing its engagement with its passengers to
augment their travel experience. From multichannel direct sales (including online flight booking,
call centers and airport counters), to online flight status checking, an exclusive IndiGo app for
Android, IndiGo has transformed air travel in India. Today, IndiGo is India’s most preferred
airline. At IndiGo, low fares come with high quality.
Since 1989, InterGlobe Enterprises has been bridging gaps between people and markets. The
company's unswerving commitment to this purpose has allowed it to establish a strong foothold
in businesses such as civil aviation, hospitality, travel commerce, airline management, aircraft
maintenance engineering, and advanced pilot training.
Over the past three decades, IndiGo has continued to expand its vision and become India’s
leading and one of the most respected conglomerates. Headquartered in Gurugram and driven by
a workforce of over 24,000 people spread across 27+ countries and 100+ cities globally, its
passion for quality, value and innovation is set to power it into the future.
24
Industry Overview
Given the global nature of the COVID-19 pandemic that threatens to throw many economies into
recession, it could take passenger air travel demand anywhere from several months to several
years to recover to 2019 levels. This return to normalcy in airline travel will depend on multiple
factors including the speed of virus containment, lifting of country border closures, restoration of
confidence in air travel, and a return to normal economic and social activity.
After rapid expansion over the last decade when Indian aviation registered a Compound Annual
Growth Rate (“CAGR”) of around 13.6% in domestic demand measured in terms of Revenue
Passenger Kilometers (“RPKs”), it slowed down to 5% in 2019. The deceleration in growth was
primarily driven by supply-side constraints due to industry consolidation subsequent to the
cessation of operations of Jet Airways. Adding significantly to industry headwinds, COVID-19
hit the aviation Industry in Q4 FY 2020. In response to the virus, the Government banned
international flights with effect from March 22, 2020 and domestic flights with effect from
March 25, 2020. Even before these extraordinary measures were taken, the travel demand started
to slow down significantly. This had a major impact on the financial performance of the Indian
carriers.
In the medium to long term, once the crisis is over, the demand outlook for aviation remains
very strong in India largely driven by under-penetration, rise in working population and
expansion of middle class. (Refer to the section below for key growth highlights in the Indian
aviation during the pre-pandemic period.) Furthermore, the rise in trade and tourism is also
likely to boost the industry. Based on the recent data published by the Civil Aviation
Administration of China (“CAAC’”), daily flights in China have recovered by 43% as of April
21, 2020 as compared to March 2020. Thus, although the COVID-19 outbreak will have a near-
term negative impact, aviation in India should gradually recover and get back on track for rapid
growth.
Moreover, India’s exports and imports have been growing strongly over the past decade. Growth
in trade augurs well for the aviation industry as they handle about 30% of India’s total trade by
value. Cargo has also seen a rising demand over the last few years. For example, during FY
2006-2019, domestic freight traffic increased at a CAGR of 8.3%, while international freight
traffic grew at a CAGR of 6.9% during the same period. As per IBEF, by 2023, total freight
traffic is expected to touch 4.14 million tonnes exhibiting growth at a CAGR of 7.3% between
FY 2016 and FY 2023. International freight traffic is expected to grow at a CAGR of 7.1% while
domestic freight traffic is expected to grow at a CAGR 7.5% between FY 2016 and FY 2023.
The share of travel and tourism in India’s GDP was 10.4% in 2018. Indian economy and the
aviation industry have a symbiotic relationship and each benefit immensely with the growth of
other. While the fast-paced growth of the aviation industry over the past decade can be largely
attributed to the robust economic growth, economic growth has also been greatly benefitted by
the growth in aviation industry. According to International Civil Aviation Organization
(“ICAO”), for every $100 of output produced and every 100 jobs generated by air transport, an
additional demand of around $325 and 610 jobs are triggered in other industries, globally. The
aviation industry is further expected to increase its share in the Gross Domestic Product and help
the economy by creating jobs and an increase in production through trade and tourism.
25
Business Overview
IndiGo commenced operations in August 2006 with a single aircraft and has grown its fleet to
262 aircraft as of March 31, 2020. The company had placed an order of 430 fuel-efficient A320
NEO family aircraft in 2011 and 2015, of which 114 have been delivered as of March 31, 2020.
In addition to this, in October 2019, the company placed an additional firm order for the 300
A320 NEO family aircraft, which includes A321 XLRs in addition to A320 NEOs and A321
NEOs.
At the end of March 2020, the company had 100 fuel-efficient A320 NEOs giving it 15% lower
fuel burn compared to the current generation of A320 CEOs without sharklets. The company
also have 14 A321 NEOs in its fleet with higher seating capacity, lower unit costs and longer
range compared to A320 NEOs. The company had placed an order with Pratt & Whitney to
power 150 of its A320 NEO family aircraft. All the A320 NEO family aircraft that IndiGo has
today use the Pratt & Whitney GTF engine. In addition to this, in June 2019, the company placed
an order with CFM to provide engines for 280 of its NEO aircraft. With this order, IndiGo has
identified its engine partner for the initial 430 A320 NEO family order.
In FY 2020, the company was awarded the ‘Best Low-Cost Airline in Central Asia and India’
for the tenth consecutive time at the Skytrax World Airline Awards 2019. The company is
ranked as one of the best airlines in terms of on-time performance for the third consecutive year
amongst the top 20 global mega-airlines based on data compiled by the OAG. IndiGo is the only
Indian carrier to have made it to this list, three years in a row.
IndiGo has been recognised among the most valuable and strongest airline brands, as per the
Brand Finance Airlines 50 report for 2020. Further, the company was also awarded the ‘Safety
Partner - Best Aircraft Turn Around Activity’ by DIAL; the ‘Best Domestic Airline’ at FICCI’s
first edition of Travel and Tourism Excellence Awards; and the ‘Companies with Great
Managers Award’ by People Business in partnership with The Economic Times. These awards
are a testimony to its best-in-class service quality. The company’s learning academy ‘ifly’ also
won awards for best practices in Learning and Development under six different categories at the
TISS LEAPVAULT Chief Learning Officer (“CLO”) awards by the Tata Institute of Social
Sciences.
26
Fiscal Year 2023 results.
June 05, 2023: InterGlobe Aviation Ltd. (“IndiGo”) today reported its fourth quarter and
fiscal year 2023 results.
For the quarter ended March 31, 2023
• Revenue from Operations of INR 62,229 million, a decrease of 25% compared to the same
period last year.
• EBITDAR of INR 6,483 million with EBITDAR margin of 10.4% compared to EBITDAR of
INR 867 million with EBITDAR margin of 1.0% for the same period last year.
• Loss before tax of INR 11,575 million, compared to a loss before tax of INR 12,898 million
during the same period last year
• Net loss of INR 11,472 million compared to a net loss of INR 8,708 million in the same period
last year.
• Basic earnings per share of negative INR 29.8
For the year ended March 31, 2023
• Revenue from Operations of INR 146,406 million, a decrease of 59.1% compared to the last
year against a capacity decrease of 52.8% during the year.
• EBITDAR of INR 6,227 million with EBITDAR margin of 4.3%, compared to EBITDAR of
INR 50,824 million with EBITDAR margin of 14.2% for the last year.
• Loss before tax of INR 58,181 million, compared to loss before tax of INR 2,557 for the last
year.
• Net loss of INR 58,064 million, compared to net loss of INR 2,337 in the last year.
• Basic earnings per share of negative INR 150.9
Strong balance sheet with a total cash of INR 185,685 million including free cash of INR 70,997
million
The Company’s CEO, Mr. Ronojoy Dutta said “This has been a very difficult year with its
revenues slumping hard due to covid, showing some signs of recovery during the period
December to February and then slumping again with the second wave of the covid. While
27
IndiGo has seen a sharp decline in revenues in March through May, IndiGo is encouraged by the
modest revenue improvements starting last week of May and continuing through June. The
company see this pandemic as a period of great trial for both its shareholders and its employees.
IndiGo is focusing all its efforts and all its energies to strengthen the foundations and the pillars
of IndiGo so that the company emerge from this trial significantly stronger structurally and even
more customer responsive than ever before. While IndiGo has produced disappointing financial
results this year, IndiGo has also positioned itself to be the best-in-class airline when the
inevitable recovery finally arrives.”
28
12,362 employees. The company has been awarded consecutively for eight years in various
surveys done by rating agencies as one of India’s best places to work with.
• Positive Image: IndiGo has carved an image of being the most efficient low fare operator
not just in the domestic market but also globally. This image of a low-cost carrier that
provides high-quality services has resulted in making it the preferred travel option for many
frequent travelers.
• Services: Indigo offers a wide gamut of services such as multi-channel direct sales, online
flight booking, round the clock customer support through call centers and airport counters,
online flight status checking, a user-friendly IndiGo app for Android etc.
• High stakeholder engagement: Through a robust customer interface Indigo ensures that it
keeps track of customer needs and also communicates to every customer on a regular basis.
Indigo also has a high level of employee satisfaction and has been consistently voted into
India’s best places to work in.
• Highly drive workforce: Indigo is a hassle-free place to work in and this has ensured that
they have a highly motivated and self-driven [Link] has deployed the i-fly facility
where their new employees are given complete real-time training on how to deliver the
best customer service. This has been considered as the best training facility in this domain.
In addition to this, the company also ensures that their employees enjoy a stress-
free environment with a proper work-life balance.
• Corporate Social Responsibility: The Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) initiative of
the airline named as IndiGoReach has undertaken a lot of initiatives for the upliftment and
well being of children, women empowerment, and environment. Their social work
encompasses not just cities but extends to remote locations as well.
• Fleet Strategy: The fleet strategy of Indigo has always focused on ensuring that the average
fleet age in four years. The airline has also ensured that it purchases its fleet at prices much
lower than what a seller would sell them for. This has helped the airline maintain its low
costs consistently.
29
Weaknesses in the SWOT analysis of Indigo
Weaknesses are used to refer to areas where the business or the brand needs improvement. Some
of the key weaknesses of Indigo are:
• Sustaining profits: Indigo is positioned as a low-cost carrier and thus pricing for the airline
needs to be as low as it can be managed. At the same time, the costs need to be maintained
as low as possible. However Indigo has often been unable to sustain its profits consistently
and this can be a weakness for the company.
• Over-dependence on volumes: In order to sustain profits the company needed to ensure
that the volumes were always high and business could not be affected by fluctuations
in demand. This means that the business needs to ensure that sufficient steps are taken to
ensure consistent volumes and this required an additional investment.
• The grounding of aircraft: After the safety of Pratt & Whitney aircraft became
questionable, the Civil Aviation Authority had to make a decision to ground these airplanes
owned by Indigo. This scandal affected the goodwill and trust of the customer.
• Growing demand for foreign travel: There is a surge in the number of people in India who
need to travel to foreign locations both for business and pleasure. This means that there is a
huge scope for the airline to expand to more foreign destinations.
30
Threats in the SWOT analysis of Indigo
Threats are those factors in the environment which can be detrimental to the growth of the
business. Some of the threats include:
• Competition: The airline faces a lot of competition from brands such as Jet Airways, Indian
Airlines, Air India, Singapore Airlines etc.
• Costing: The key components of cost in an airline is the fuel which is highly fluctuating
and in order to manage the pricing in accordance with the dynamics of fuel prices is a threat
today and even in the future.
31
SpiceJet Airlines
CEO/OWNER OF SPICEJET
Ajay Singh (born 29 December 1965) is an Indian businessman, sports administrator,
bureaucrat and investor. He is the principal shareholder, Chairman and Managing Director of
SpiceJet, India's second-largest airline.
Management
Non [Link] [Link]
Shiwani Singh
Independent Director
Anurag Bhargava
Ajay Aggarwal
Manoj Kumar
Headquarters
SpiceJet is headquartered in Gurgaon, India
Registered Office
Address
Indira Gandhi International Airport, Terminal 1D New Delhi, 110037
Email
investors@[Link]
Internet
[Link]
Registrars
Address
Selenium Tower B, Plot No. 31-32, Gachibowli, Financial District, Nanakramguda Seri,
Telangana, Hyderabad 500032
32
History of SpiceJet Airlines
SpiceJet is an Indian low-cost carrier based at Indira Gandhi International Airport, New Delhi.
SpiceJet is one of India's largest airlines serving domestic destinations across India. The airline
commenced international operations in October 2010 and currently operate flights to 62
destinations – 53 domestic and 9 internationals.
Established as air taxi provider ModiLuft in 1994, the company was acquired by Indian
entrepreneur Ajay Singh in 2004 and re-christened as SpiceJet. The airline operated its first
flight in May 2005. Indian media baron Kalanidhi Maran acquired a controlling stake in SpiceJet
in June 2010 through Sun Group which was sold back to Ajay Singh in January 2015. The
airline operates a fleet of Boeing 737 and Bombardier Dash 8 aircraft
History
1984–1996: ModiLuft era
The origins of SpiceJet can be tracked back to March 1984 when the company was established
by Indian industrialist S. K. Modi to provide private air taxi [Link] 17 February 1993, the
company was named as MG Express and entered into technical partnership with the German flag
carrier Lufthansa. The airline provided passenger and cargo services under the name
of Modiluft before ceasing operations in 1996.
2005–2013: Inception and expansion
In 2004, the company was acquired by Ajay Singh and the airline planned to restart operations
as SpiceJet following the low-cost model. SpiceJet leased two Boeing 737-800 aircraft in 2005
and planned to order 10 new aircraft for expansion.[7] SpiceJet opened bookings on 18 May 2005
and the first flight was operated between Delhi and Mumbai on 24 May 2005. By July 2008, it
was India's third-largest low-cost carrier in terms of market share after Air Deccan and IndiGo.
Indian media baron Kalanidhi Maran acquired 37.7% stake in SpiceJet in June 2010 through Sun
[Link] airline ordered 30 Boeing 737-8 aircraft worth US$2.7 billion July 2010 and a further
15 Bombardier Q4 Dash short-haul aircraft worth US$446 million in December 2010.
In 2012, SpiceJet suffered a loss of over ₹390 million (US$5.5 million) owing to increase in
global crude prices. On 9 January 2012, the Directorate General of Civil Aviation, reported that
several airlines in India, including SpiceJet, have not maintained crucial data for the flight
operations quality assurance. The Bombay Stock Exchange announced that ever since June
33
2011, SpiceJet had been suffering losses In 2012, Kalanidhi Maran increased his stake in the
airline by investing ₹1 billion (US$14 million) in the airline. The airline returned to profits at the
end of the same year. SpiceJet entered into an inter airline pact with Tigerair on 16 December
2013 which was scrapped in January 2015.
2014–2019: Downturn and recovery
In January 2015, the Sun Group sold its entire shareholding and transferred control to Ajay
Singh.
In late September 2017, the airline announced that it had placed a firm order for 25 Q400
turboprop aircraft.[20]
2020-Present: Pandemic
SpiceExpress the logistics arm of SpiceJet airline--has helped to keep the company afloat during
the pandemic amid drastic drop in passenger business. In May 2023, the airline earned Rs 200
crore from freight operations and commands a 5 per cent market share in India's outbound cargo
business.
In July 2023, SpiceJet reported net losses shrunk to US$34.6 million during the fiscal quarter
ended 31 March 2023, as revenue fell by 28% annually to $294.8 million. The airline plans to
raise funds to the tune of $337.2 million to ensure its long term sustainability.
VISION OF SPICEJET
SpiceJet Limited has a vision for total customer satisfaction and enhancing stakeholders'
value. SpiceJet's mission is to become India's preferred airline with the highest consumer
value through honest and ethical conduct of the business.
MISSION OF SPICEJET
SpiceJet's mission is to become India's preferred low-cost airline, delivering the lowest air
fares with the highest customer value, to price sensitive customers. We hope to fulfill
everyone's dream of flying! With India's economic and business growth, the percentage of
traveling population is burgeoning.
34
35
SpiceJet is an Indian low-cost carrier based at Indira Gandhi
International Airport, New Delhi. SpiceJet is one of
India's largest airlines serving domestic destinations across
India. The airline commenced international operations in October
2010 and currently operate flights to 62 destinations – 53
domestic and 9 internationals.
Spicejet – [Link].
2023 In May 2023, SpiceJet started a COVID-19 inoculation drive for its employees
In May 2023, SpiceXpress, the air cargo arm of SpiceJet, airlifted 9,600 oxygen
concentrators from Beijing, Wuhan, Nanjing and Hong Kong to meet the
shortage in Kolkata and Delhi
In March 2023, SpiceJet announced plan to add 66 flights, including additional
services on certain routes, to its domestic network by March 2023
2022 In December 2022, SpiceJet entered into a partnership with Om Logistics for
Covid-19 vaccine transportation
In August 2022, SpiceJet launched SpiceOxy – a compact, portable and non-
invasive ventilation device in its fight against COVID-19
SpiceJet signed tripartite MoU (memorandum of understanding) with GHIAL
and Ras-Al-Khaimah International Airport for a dedicated freight corridor
2021 Direct flights to Delhi from Mangalore International Airport (MIA) launched
Touched its highest-ever quarterly profit of Rs. 261.7 crore (US$ 3.74 million)
2020 SpiceJet is expected to join the global airlines' grouping the International Air
Transport Association (IATA) as a member
Adjudged as the 'Best Domestic Airline' at Wings India 2020
2019 Records over 90 per cent load factor for 31 consecutive months
2017 SpiceJet initiates major network expansion with six new aircraft
36
2016 Chosen as India's International Low Cost Carrier of the Year 2016 by Travel
Agents Association of India
2015 Announced that it will order 30 Boeing 737-800 aircraft increasing its fleet size
to 58 planes
2014 Tied up with BillDesk to provide customers an option to purchase tickets online
2012 Inducted five new aircraft taking their total fleet to 11 aircraft
2010 Integrated with various travel related websites to boost internet sales
Change the name of the company to SpiceJet Ltd
2009 Started commercial operations of domestic flight services with three leased
Boeing aircraft
1994 Entered into a mangement agreement with Lufthansa to manage their entire
airline operations
1993 The company ventures into domestic aviation through a partnership with
Deutsche Lufthansa AG
37
SWOT analysis of SpiceJet
A popular low-cost airline, SpiceJet was formed during the year 2005 and is headquartered in
Haryana, India. SpiceJet is the fourth largest airline in the country that carries many domestic
passengers and has a market share of about 13.3% as of the year 2017.
The company’s tagline says ‘flying for everyone’. SpiceJet operates about 312 daily flights to
about 55 destinations that include 47 Indian and seven international destinations from places like
Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, and Hyderabad. It was established as an air traffic provider ModiLuft
during the year 1994. It later was acquired by Indian entrepreneur Ajay Singh during the year 2004
and restarted its operations as SpiceJet.
This airline also operates a fleet of Boeing 737 and Bombardier aircraft. SpiceJet provides
premium services with the name of SpiceMax where the passengers can get additional benefits
that include pre-assigned seats with extra legroom, priority check-in, complimentary meals on
board, and many more.
Having been a popular low-cost airline, let us examine the SWOT of SpiceJet.
38
The power to fly – The management personnel of SpiceJet are all seasoned professionals and
seniors who have a good amount of international experience in both managing and launching low-
cost airlines. By having many man-hours in the industry, the management is committed to bringing
to customers in India, the benefits of the global revolution in the skies. The airline provides a
comfortable journey that is affordable and refreshing.
Safety features – The airline invests a huge amount in safety and maintenance of aircraft by a
high level of expertise people. The pilots, maintenance crew, and its engineers are given rigorous
training and are hand-picked for their experience and knowledge in the domain. Hence the
passengers can rest while traveling.
Dynamic fare structure – Having a dynamic fare structure, the airline provides fares that are
affordable and comparatively lower those other airlines. Having contemporary interiors,
vibrant colors, and modern graphics, SpiceJet most fits the current traveler.
Good reachability – SpiceJet has good reachability to about 55 destinations. This makes the
traveler fly to these destinations easily.
Good market presence – SpiceJet has a good presence in the market as it has maintained a
good advertising strategy. Due to this, it has a good brand value.
An Interactive website – SpiceJet provides an interactive website that allows booking through
their website. By this, the customers can book the tickets; perform check-in through online itself.
Tourism partnership – SpiceJet has partnered with Tripfactory for selling holiday packages by
using the platform. This will increase their business revenue.
The Rs. 99 fare – It started off with Rs. 99 far for the first 99 days to attract the passengers. This
has got many passengers to the airline for the first few days to increase their visibility.
Limited destinations – The number of destinations served by the airline is low as compared to
other airline services. This will provide a restriction to passengers who travel to other destinations
not listed in the SpiceJet destinations.
Wrong decisions – During the year 2014, SpiceJet announced 50% discounts as the airline was
facing a lot of competition. Due to this it has to cancel many domestic flights across the country
and caused a lot of chaos to the passengers.
39
Frequent offers – SpiceJet providing frequent offers to the passengers is not a good idea to gain
passengers. This will impact their revenue generation thereby facing a lot of loss in the business.
High airport and fuel cost – All the airlines including SpiceJet face the heat of having a high-
cost environment that is widespread in the aviation industry. This will amount to major of their
income thereby leading to a low revenue generation.
Dip in their profit – During the recent months, the airline has posted a major loss of Rs. 38 crore
as compared to the profit of about Rs. 175.2 crore in the previous year.
Low airfare, hence more passengers – Since SpiceJet is popular for their low-cost airfare,
much middle class who wish to travel through airline can make use of SpiceJet for their travel.
More routes and destinations – SpiceJet can gain more opportunities to grow their business by
introducing more routes and destinations. The airline can increase their destinations to popular
places that will fetch them more passengers.
Having international partnership – Having partnerships with the international market can
increase their visibility and their brand image.
Growing interest in tourism – Since SpiceJet has partnered with tourism sector; there is a
huge opportunity for it. The tourism sector is growing in India and this helps the business to grow.
Tax holiday on leasing of aircraft – India’s Union Budget Government of India has announced
five year tax holiday on the event of leasing an aircraft.
40
Fuel increase – The rising fuel cost can be a threat to their economy. This will decrease the
margins for the airline.
Change of government policies – Frequent change in government policies and having pressure
from the international market will affect the brand operations and image of the company.
41
Data Analysis
Capital Structure
Of
Interglobe Aviation
Capital Structure
Period Instrument --- CAPITAL (Rs. cr) --- -PAIDUP-
From To Authorised Issued Shares (no’s) Face Value Capital
2022 2023 Equity Share 750 384.91 384910000 10 384.91
42
Capital Structure
Of
SpiceJet
Capital Structure
Period Instrument --- CAPITAL (Rs. cr) --- -PAIDUP-
From To Authorised Issued Shares (no’s) Face Value Capital
2022 2023 Equity Share 1500 600.08 600076299 10 600.08
43
KEY FINANCIAL RATIOS OF INTERGLOBE AVIATION
44
PROFITABILITY RATIOS OF INTERGLOBE AVIATION
45
LIQUIDITY RATIOS OF INTERGLOBE AVIATION
46
VALUATION RATIOS OF INTERGLOBE AVIATION
47
KEY FINANCIAL RATIOS OF SPICEJET
48
Return on Networth / Equity (%) 0.00 0.00
49
Earnings Yield -0.24 -0.42
12 mths 12 mths
INCOME
EXPENSES
50
PROFIT/LOSS BEFORE EXCEPTIONAL, -5,829.79 -275.09
EXTRAORDINARY ITEMS AND TAX
51
Imported Stores And Spares 0.00 0.00
12 mths 12 mths
SHAREHOLDER'S FUNDS
NON-CURRENT LIABILITIES
52
TOTAL NON-CURRENT LIABILITIES 24,001.57 19,775.51
CURRENT LIABILITIES
ASSETS
NON-CURRENT ASSETS
CURRENT ASSETS
53
Inventories 316.42 286.13
CONTINGENT LIABILITIES,
COMMITMENTS
REMITTANCES IN FOREIGN
CURRENCIES FOR DIVIDENDS
54
Other Earnings 1,681.76 4,544.71
BONUS DETAILS
NON-CURRENT INVESTMENTS
CURRENT INVESTMENTS
12 mths 12 mths
55
Cash And Cash Equivalents Begin of Year 676.04 712.78
12 mths 12 mths
INCOME
EXPENSES
56
Other Expenses 4,282.85 1,556.39
57
Indigenous Raw Materials 0.00 0.00
12 mths 12 mths
SHAREHOLDER'S FUNDS
NON-CURRENT LIABILITIES
58
Other Long Term Liabilities 5,375.13 6,808.47
CURRENT LIABILITIES
ASSETS
NON-CURRENT ASSETS
CURRENT ASSETS
59
Current Investments 0.42 0.39
60
BONUS DETAILS
NON-CURRENT INVESTMENTS
CURRENT INVESTMENTS
12 mths 12 mths
61
YEARLY RESULTS OF INTERGLOBE AVIATION
EXPENDITURE
Excise Duty -- --
R & D Expenses -- --
Exp. Capitalised -- --
P/L Before Other Inc. , Int., Excpt. Items & Tax -4,724.14 64.54
62
P/L Before Exceptional Items & Tax -5,829.79 -275.09
Exceptional Items -- --
Tax -- -26.93
No Of Shares (Crores) -- --
A) PLEDGED/ENCUMBERED
63
- Per. of shares (as a % of the total sh. of prom. and -- --
promoter group)
B) NON-ENCUMBERED
64
YEARLY RESULTS OF SPICEJET
YEARLY RESULTS OF SPICEJET (in Rs. Cr.) MAR '23 MAR '22
EXPENDITURE
Increase/Decrease in Stocks -- --
Excise Duty -- --
R & D Expenses -- --
Exp. Capitalised -- --
P/L Before Other Inc. , Int., Excpt. Items & Tax -1,383.67 -1,237.53
65
Exceptional Items -- --
Tax -- --
No Of Shares (Crores) -- --
A) PLEDGED/ENCUMBERED
66
- Number of shares (Crores) -- --
B) NON-ENCUMBERED
67
PEER COMPARISON
PEERS
% 1 Yr Net Net
Company MarketCa TTM Debt to
Price Chan P/B ROE(%) Perfor Profit( Sales(R
Name p(Cr) PE Equity
ge m(%) Rs.) s.)
Interglobe 1,818.4
-7.01 70,043.12 - 999.12 -5,530.98 10.14 -5,806 14,640 23.87
Aviation 0
68
Comparison
IndiGo vs SpiceJet– Which Indian Low-Cost Carrier Is Better For Passengers?
The Indian aviation industry comprises of one of the most cost-sensitive passenger demand in
the world. The reason behind this might not be purely financial but also cultural. On average, a
flight from one corner to another corner of India doesn’t take more than 2.5 hours. Hence,
Indians, in general, are more inclined towards spending less than experiencing premium service
for such a small period. Around the early 2000s, the Indian government had opened the airline
industry for private carriers. Since then, low-cost carriers (LCCs) like IndiGo and SpiceJet have
turned the dynamics of the airline market.
69
In terms of destinations served, IndiGo has a slight edge over SpiceJet. It serves 63 destinations
in India and 24 abroad on 1500 daily flights. While SpiceJet flies 630 daily flights to 54 Indian
and 15 international destinations.
Passenger specific differences
Class booking
Being LCCs, both the airlines offer an all-economy seat layout. However, after SpiceJet inducted
some of the Jet Airways’ B737s, it introduced a premium service under the name of SpiceMax,
whereby passengers can obtain additional benefits including pre-assigned seats with extra
legroom. However, premium seats are only available on flights operated explicitly by ex-Jet
Airways aircraft.
IndiGo, on the other hand, has a standard seat layout across all of its aircraft. Nevertheless, it
allows services, such as a pre-assigned seat, multiple cancellations, and priority check-in, to its
passengers who are willing to pay a higher fare.
In-flight entertainment system
Until 2018, both the carriers offered no kind of Inflight entertainment systems (IFE). In August
2018, SpiceJet became the first Indian LCC to have an IFE called SpicEngage. The service was
accessible by any handheld device onboard any SpiceJet flight on domestic and international
sectors. Similarly, in September 2019, IndiGo announced its tie-up with SonyLIV, an on-
demand video app for providing its fliers with entertainment options on all domestic flights.
Punctuality
This aspect of an airline is a significant factor as far as the business-specific passenger demand is
concerned. In 2019, SpiceJet was one of the worst on-time performers out of all airlines. It was
on-time on only 74.7% of its flights. IndiGo, on the other hand, did much better in this aspect,
with 87.4% on-time performance.
Cancellations and Complaints
In terms of cancellation rate, IndiGo was the highest, with 0.95% of its flights being canceled.
Most of the cancellations were due to weather-related issues. It might be wrong, in this situation,
to assume that IndiGo is at fault. The higher cancellation percentage might have to do with
70
the diverse network and the large number of flights IndiGo operates. On the other hand, SpiceJet
saw many more complaints as compared to IndiGo.
Empty flights
If you are one of those who want to have a whole row to themselves, then IndiGo might be a
better choice. SpiceJet has consistently done much better than any other airline in India in terms
of load factors. You would be more likely to find empty seats on an IndiGo flight than a SpiceJet
flight.
Regional network
IndiGo and SpiceJet have different plans as far as their network is concerned. IndiGo relies on
very major, high demand routes. While SpiceJet is equally considerate of regional routes. On a
major sector like Delhi-Bengaluru or Delhi-Mumbai, IndiGo might be better placed to provide
you a convenient time and price. However, on many regional routes like Jalandhar-Jaipur,
SpiceJet has no competition.
Summary
Although both airlines showed impressive growth in 2019, a lot will depend on how they can
handle the current crisis. Since both the carriers are LCCs, there is little difference in terms of
airfare. As far as the rivalry is concerned, IndiGo surely is ahead in terms of size and network. In
terms of passenger experience, a lot depends on personal preference. There is no clear winner.
71
INTERGLOBE AVIATION (INDIGO) vs SPICEJET - Comparison Results CURRENT
VALUATIONS
INTERGLOBE
INTERGLOBE
AVIATION
AVIATION SPICEJET
(INDIGO)/
(INDIGO)
SPICEJET
P/BV x 940.7 - -
Dividend
% 0.0 0.0 -
Yield
FINANCIALS
INTERGLOB INTERGLOBE
E AVIATION SPICEJET AVIATION
(INDIGO) Mar-21 (INDIGO)/
Mar-21 SPICEJET
Earnings per
Rs -150.9 -17.1 880.2%
share (Unadj.)
Dividends per
Rs 0 0 -
share (Unadj.)
72
EQUITY SHARE DATA
INTERGLOB INTERGLOBE
E AVIATION SPICEJET AVIATION
(INDIGO) Mar-21 (INDIGO)/
Mar-21 SPICEJET
Avg Dividend
% 0 0 -
yield
Book value
per share Rs 2.0 -43.5 -4.5%
(Unadj.)
Shares
outstanding m 384.91 600.94 64.1%
(eoy)
Bonus / Rights
- - -
/ Conversions
Price / Sales
x 3.5 0.8 414.7%
ratio
P/CF ratio
x -46.5 8.2 -563.5%
(eoy)
Price / Book
x 678.2 -1.7 -40,436.6%
Value ratio
Dividend
% 0 0 -
payout
Rs
Avg Mkt Cap 514,297 43,808 1,174.0%
m
No. of `00
NA NA -
employees 0
Total Rs
32,955 6,853 480.9%
wages/salary m
73
EQUITY SHARE DATA
INTERGLOB INTERGLOBE
E AVIATION SPICEJET AVIATION
(INDIGO) Mar-21 (INDIGO)/
Mar-21 SPICEJET
Avg.
Rs
sales/employe NM NM -
Th
e
Avg.
Rs
wages/employ NM NM -
Th
ee
Avg. net
Rs
profit/employe NM NM -
Th
e
INCOME DATA
Rs
Net Sales 146,406 51,714 283.1%
m
Rs
Other income 15,600 11,717 133.1%
m
Rs
Total revenues 162,006 63,432 255.4%
m
Rs
Gross profit -5,088 -279 1,825.7%
m
Rs
Depreciation 46,994 15,612 301.0%
m
Rs
Interest 21,698 6,125 354.2%
m
Rs
Profit before tax -58,181 -10,299 564.9%
m
Rs
Minority Interest 0 0 -
m
74
INCOME DATA
Rs
Prior Period Items 0 0 -
m
Extraordinary Inc Rs
0 0 -
(Exp) m
Rs
Tax -116 0 -
m
Rs
Profit after tax -58,064 -10,299 563.8%
m
Rs
Current assets 208,163 26,023 799.9%
m
Rs
Current liabilities 189,260 77,865 243.1%
m
Rs
Net fixed assets 245,823 87,654 280.4%
m
Rs
Share capital 3,849 6,009 64.1%
m
Rs
"Free" reserves -3,091 -32,130 9.6%
m
75
BALANCE SHEET DATA
Rs
Net worth 758 -26,121 -2.9%
m
Rs
Long term debt 3,816 3,027 126.1%
m
Rs
Total assets 453,986 113,676 399.4%
m
-
Return on equity % -7,656.7 39.4
19,419.4%
Exports to sales % 0 0 -
Imports to sales % 0 0 -
Exports (fob) Rs m NA NA -
Imports (cif) Rs m NA NA -
CASH FLOW
Rs
From Operations -16,142 2,283 -707.0%
m
Rs
From Investments 31,970 2,122 1,506.8%
m
76
CASH FLOW
From Financial Rs
-17,753 -4,367 406.5%
Activity m
Rs
Net Cashflow -2,102 33 -6,402.1%
m
SHARE HOLDING
Indian Promoters % 38.2 59.5 64.2%
Foreign
% 36.6 0.0 -
collaborators
Indian inst/Mut
% 23.1 2.2 1,051.4%
Fund
Pledged promoter(s)
% 0.0 48.9 -
holding
77
Conclusions
Key Things That Keep IndiGo Ahead Of SpiceJet
SpiceJet Ltd. has added the most capacity since the grounding of Jet Airways India Ltd. Yet, its
larger peer InterGlobe Aviation Ltd. remains better placed operationally in a market grappling
with falling yields, volatile costs and engine glitches.
Average fare per passenger per kilometre, or yields, have been falling in India because of higher
capacity addition, weak demand and competition in India. Crude prices and the dollar remained
fairly volatile. For an airline, cost volatility is high, as 60-70 percent of its expenses are dollar-
denominated and fuel accounts for more than a third of its costs.
Both SpiceJet and IndiGo, operated by InterGlobe Aviation, saw costs also rise due to grounding
of Boeing 737 Max aircraft and replacement of engines of Airbus A320neos, respectively.
IndiGo, India’s largest carrier, scores higher on two key parameters even as SpiceJet is looking
to catch up.
Costs
IndiGo’s cost per unit is lower than that of SpiceJet. On an average, in the last five quarters,
IndiGo’s cost per available seat kilometre remained lower by 17 percent, according to data
disclosed by the companies. That helped the airline to report profits or pare losses even as yields
declined.
These costs could come down as the share of fuel-efficient A320neos and A321 increases in its
fleet. To be sure, the aircraft are facing engine issues and IndiGo has said that Airbus has
delayed deliveries.
78
Cash
IndiGo has a stronger balance sheet with higher free cash on books worth Rs 8,700 crore and a
better liquidity ratio—cash-to-sales—of 26 percent. Usually, keeping a fifth of the sales as cash
is considered safe for airlines globally.
A stronger balance sheet is even more important for airlines as the operating environment is
volatile because of changing costs.
IndiGo, with three times the size of SpiceJet, doubled its share in the domestic market in the last
five years. Its international share doubled in just a year, and the airline plans to add more
capacity on global routes.
International operations act as a hedge against foreign currency movements and help lower costs.
That’s because fuel used for international flights does not attract any taxes and is cheaper outside
India.
IndiGo still aims to grow its overall capacity at more than 20 percent. But it lowered the forecast
twice in 45 days and now hopes to increase capacity by 22-23 percent in the ongoing fiscal
ending March, down from the original estimate of 30 percent.
79
What SpiceJet Is Banking On
SpiceJet is expecting the return of Boeing 737 Max aircraft, which were grounded because of
global safety issues. The planes are 15 percent more fuel efficient compared to SpiceJet’s
existing fleet and have 20 percent higher seating capacity
The airline expects the aircraft to be back in service by the end of January. Boeing, however, has
said that additional delays are possible as regulators around the world evaluate the 737 Max,
including its proposed software upgrade.
SpiceJet plans to negotiate higher discounts with Boeing, thus boosting sale and leaseback
income on aircraft delivery, said Edelweiss Securities in its note. The company also expects
compensation from Boeing for the grounded planes in the coming quarters.
SpiceJet has partly offset the 737 Max grounding by adding capacity, aided by the closure of Jet
Airways. The Ajay Singh-led airline increased its capacity by more than 50 percent in the second
quarter ended September—the most in last four years. That’s because, according to SBICAP
Securities, it received most of the slots vacated by Jet Airways.
80
SpiceJet also narrowed the gap with IndiGo on non-fuel costs. The difference fell to 20 percent
in the second quarter from 29-30 percent three months earlier. The management targets to bring
it down to 10 percent.
81
And unlike IndiGo, the nation’s second-largest carrier has seen a stable management even as
founders of IndiGo were engaged in a public quarrel. While that didn’t result in any financial
impact on IndiGo, it remains an overhang.
Analysts are more bullish on SpiceJet. The average of 12-month price targets compiled by
Bloomberg implies a 32 percent upside of SpiceJet compared with 26 percent for IndiGo.
SpiceJet also has a higher percentage of ‘Buy’ ratings because of its lower valuations.
82
Bibliography/References
For Ratio analysis
[Link]
ratios/ratio-analysis/
[Link]
analysis/21780
[Link]
[Link]
Money [Link] for aviation industry analysis
[Link]
[Link]
for conclusion -
[Link]
Interglobe aviation
[Link]
Spicejet airlines
[Link]
Comparison of financial statement of both company
[Link]
INTERGLOBE-AVIATION-INDIGO-SPICEJET
For financial data
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
83