0% found this document useful (0 votes)
40 views11 pages

Kuching Urban Drainage Design Review

1. The document is a review sheet for detailed engineering design drawings for the drainage system at Rembus Depot. 2. The reviewer provided comments on drawing KUTSL1-KMKJV-DP101-00C including issues with flow direction not shown, text clashes, and proposing lighter drainage components to reduce costs. 3. Additional comments requested more details on sumps and gratings.

Uploaded by

amirul arif
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
40 views11 pages

Kuching Urban Drainage Design Review

1. The document is a review sheet for detailed engineering design drawings for the drainage system at Rembus Depot. 2. The reviewer provided comments on drawing KUTSL1-KMKJV-DP101-00C including issues with flow direction not shown, text clashes, and proposing lighter drainage components to reduce costs. 3. Additional comments requested more details on sumps and gratings.

Uploaded by

amirul arif
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)

16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,


No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

DOCUMENTS REVIEW SHEET (DRS)


SDC / DDC1 / DDC2 /
Project Title Kuching Urban Transportation System (KUTS) – Phase 1 Contract Code
SPC1 / SPC2 / etc.
Attention (Recipient Name) (Font – Calibri, Size - 10) Company
From Mohamed Kamal bin Suhaimi Company SMSB
DRS Reference No. N/A Issued Date (Date DRS Issue)
Document Reference No. (Document Ref. No. from originator. Leave it blank if no reference number) Doc Revision No. 00
Title Detailed Engineering Design (DED) Drawings for Rembus Depot – Civil Drawings Drainage

Item Documents Reference Rev. Reviewer Reviewer’s Comment Code Consultant / Contractor Response
No. (Number/Clause/Title)
1. KUTSL1-KMKJV-DP101- 00C SHAZANA a) Flow direction is not shown in the drawing. 2
DSM01-CVL-LAP-ALW- Please amend.
DD-620102 b) To indicate the length & gradient of the 2
proposed drain. 2
c) To amend text clashing.

d) Proposed drain is located at green area. There is

Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04


DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 1 of 11
SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)
16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,
No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

Item Documents Reference Rev. Reviewer Reviewer’s Comment Code Consultant / Contractor Response
No. (Number/Clause/Title)
no necessity to construct heavy duty cover. The 2
proposed of heavy duty cover will give cost
impact to the contract. Precast drain cover is
adequate.

e) There is no requirement to provide heavy duty


manhole at all culvert crossings. Access for
Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04
DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 2 of 11
SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)
16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,
No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

Item Documents Reference Rev. Reviewer Reviewer’s Comment Code Consultant / Contractor Response
No. (Number/Clause/Title)
maintenance work can be done from sumps at
both sides. In addition road closure is required
during maintenance work.

Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04


DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 3 of 11
SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)
16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,
No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

Item Documents Reference Rev. Reviewer Reviewer’s Comment Code Consultant / Contractor Response
No. (Number/Clause/Title)

Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04


DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 4 of 11
SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)
16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,
No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

Item Documents Reference Rev. Reviewer Reviewer’s Comment Code Consultant / Contractor Response
No. (Number/Clause/Title)

f) No detail of RC Sump with heavy duty grating

Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04


DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 5 of 11
SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)
16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,
No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

Item Documents Reference Rev. Reviewer Reviewer’s Comment Code Consultant / Contractor Response
No. (Number/Clause/Title)
shown in the drawing. 2

g) To indicate missing drains and sumps.


2

h) To indicate the spacing c/c for heavy duty


manhole. It seems the spacing is too close. 2

i) To superimpose the position of column of the


elevated covered walkway to ensure no clashing 2
with drain.

j) Please indicate the size of existing earth drain.

k) Spacing of kerb inlet at 3m c/c is too close.


Please provide spacing of 6m c/c.
Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04
DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 6 of 11
SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)
16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,
No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

Item Documents Reference Rev. Reviewer Reviewer’s Comment Code Consultant / Contractor Response
No. (Number/Clause/Title)
l) Referring to Architect drawing no. KUTSL-1-
KMKJV-DP101-DSM01-ARC-LYD-ALW-TD-815110,
75mm dia. UPVC RWDP will be discharge to the
proposed drain. Please provide the detail from
RWDP discharge to proposed drain. Please
confirm if any protection is required since UPVC
RWDP crossing the concrete platform.

2. KUTSL1-KMKJV-DP101- 00C SHAZANA 1. There is no requirement to provide heavy duty 2


DSM01-CVL-TYP-DGW- manhole at the middle of carriageway.
DD-620116 Maintenance access can be done from the sump
at both sides. In addition with the current
proposal, road closure and TMP are required
during maintenance work.
2. To indicate dimension between piles.
Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04
DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 7 of 11
SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)
16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,
No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

Item Documents Reference Rev. Reviewer Reviewer’s Comment Code Consultant / Contractor Response
No. (Number/Clause/Title)

To include dimension
between piles

3. KUTSL1-KMKJV-DP101- 00C SHAZANA 1. There is no requirement to provide heavy duty 2 `


DSM01-CVL-TYP-DGW- manhole at the middle of carriageway.
DD-620117 Maintenance access can be done from the sump
at both sides. In addition with the current
proposal, road closure and TMP are required

Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04


DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 8 of 11
SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)
16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,
No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

Item Documents Reference Rev. Reviewer Reviewer’s Comment Code Consultant / Contractor Response
No. (Number/Clause/Title)
during maintenance work.
2. To indicate dimension between piles.

To include dimension
between piles

4. KUTSL1-KMKJV-DP101- 00C SHAZANA 1. There is no requirement to provide heavy duty 2


DSM01-CVL-TYP-DGW- manhole at the middle of carriageway.
DD-620118 Maintenance access can be done from the sump
at both sides. In addition with the current
proposal, road closure and TMP are required
during maintenance work.
2. To indicate dimension between piles.
Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04
DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 9 of 11
SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)
16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,
No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

Item Documents Reference Rev. Reviewer Reviewer’s Comment Code Consultant / Contractor Response
No. (Number/Clause/Title)

To include
dimension between
piles

Response Code
1 Approved 3 Rejected (Resubmit) FINAL CODE

Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04


DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 10 of 11
SARAWAK METRO SDN BHD (201801007738)
16-01A, Level 16, Gateway Kuching,
No. 9, Jalan Bukit Mata Kuching,
93100 Kuching, Sarawak, Malaysia.
Tel: (082) 524222
Fax: (082) 524224

2 Approved with Comment - -

Approval
Prepared By Nur Shazana binti Ismail Reviewed By Jailani bin Yusoff Approved By Mohamed Kamal bin Suhaimi
Designation Road, Drainage and Infra Manager Designation Manager Designation Head of Department
Department Civil, M&E and Infrastructure Department Civil, M&E and Infrastructure Department Civil, M&E and Infrastructure
Date 2/11/2023 Date 2/11/2023 Date 2/11/2023
Signature Signature Signature

Form Reference Number: CO-SMSB-GEN-OVR-FRM-QAQC-000001 / Revision: 04


DRS Reference Number: N/A
Page 11 of 11

You might also like