0% found this document useful (0 votes)
19 views32 pages

Understanding Service Operations Management

The document discusses different types and definitions of services, the role of services in economies, and challenges for service managers in different types of service processes.
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
19 views32 pages

Understanding Service Operations Management

The document discusses different types and definitions of services, the role of services in economies, and challenges for service managers in different types of service processes.
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Service

Operations
Management
PGPM 2022
Services?
• Services come in many shapes and forms provided by a variety of
types of organizations, including
• business-to-consumer (B2C) services,
• business-to-business (B2B) services,
• internal services,
• public services and not-for-profit
• voluntary services
• 'Service’ will mean different things depending on the type of service
that is being provided
Service is a package of explicit and
implicit benefits performed within a Services are deeds, processes and
supporting facility and supported by performances²
facilitating goods¹

Definition of
Services
A service is an activity or series of
activities of more or less intangible
nature that normally, but not necessarily,
A service is a time perishable, intangible
take place between customer and
experience performed for a customer,
service employees and/or physical
acting in the role of a co-producerҹ
resources or goods and/or systems of
the service provider, which are provided
as solutions to customer problems³
Service – customer perspective

• service received is the experience of the service provided which results in outcomes
such as ‘products’, benefits, emotions, judgements and intentions
• no two people can have the same experience
• Aspects of customer experience include:
• the degree of personal interaction
• the responsiveness of the service organization
• the flexibility of customer-facing staff
• customer intimacy
• the ease of access to service personnel or information systems
Role of Services in an Economy
Infrastructure Services
Value Added Services • Communications
• Financing • Transportation
• Leasing • Utilities
• Banking
• Insurance
Personal Services
• Health care
Manufacturing • Restaurants
(Services Inside Company) Distribution Services • Hotels
• Finance • Wholesaling
• Accounting • Retailing
• Legal Consumer
• R&D and design • Repairing
(Self Service)

Business Services Government Services


(Supporting Manufacturing) • Military
• Consulting • Education
• Auditing • Judicial
• Advertising • Police and Fire Protection
• Waste Disposal
The Four Realms of a Experience
Passive Active

Entertainment Education
(movie) (language)

Environmental
Absorption

Relationship
Estheticism Escapism
(tourist) (scuba-diving)
Immersion

Customer Participation
Stages of
Economi
c Activity
The New Service Experience

Economy Agrarian Industrial Service Experience


Function Extract Make Deliver Stage
Nature Fungible Tangible Intangible Memorable
Attribute Natural Standardized Customized Personal
Method of Supply Stored in bulk Inventoried Delivered on Demand Revealed over time
Seller Trader Manufacturer Provider Stager
Buyer Market User Client Guest
Comparison of Societies
U.S
Employment
Distribution
Sources of Growth in the Service Sector

• Push Theory of Innovation


Innovation • Pull Theory of Innovation

Social • Aging population of developed countries


• Growth of 2 income families
Trends • Increase in the number of single people
Service Package

1 2 3 4 5
Supporting facility: The Facilitating goods: The Information: Operations Explicit services: Benefits Implicit services:
physical resource that must material purchased or data or information that is are readily observable by Psychological benefits that
be in place before a service consumed by the buyer or provided by the customer the senses and that consist the customer will sense
can be offered items provided by the to enable efficient and of the essential or intrinsic only vaguely, or the
customer customized service features of a service extrinsic features of a
service
Service Classification – Service Process Matrix
Low High

Service Factory Service Shop


• Airlines • Hospitals

Degree of Labor Intensity


Low • Trucking • Auto Repairs
• Hotels • Other repair services
• Resorts & Recreation
Mass Service Professional Service
• Retailing • Physicians
• Wholesaling • Accountants
High • Schools • Architects
• Retail aspects of commercial banking • Consultants

Degree of Interaction and Customization


Challenges for Service Managers
Challenges for Managers
(low labor intensity)
• Capital decisions
• Technological advances
• Managing Demand to avoid peaks and to promote
off peaks
• Scheduling service delivery

Challenges for Managers Challenges for Managers


(low interaction & low Service Service Shop (high interaction & high
customization) Factory (low labor & customization)
high interaction) • Fighting cost increases
• Marketing (low labor & low
interaction) • Maintaining quality
• Making service ‘warm’ • Reacting to consumer intervention in
• Attention to physical Mass Service Professional process
surroundings (high labor & Service • Managing advancement of people
• Managing fairly rigid low (high labor & delivering the service
interaction) high interaction)
hierarchy with need • Managing flat hierarchy with loose
for SOP Challenges for Managers subordinate superior relationship
(high labor intensity) • Gaining employee loyalty
• Hiring
• Training
• Methods development and control
• Scheduling workforces
• Employees Welfare
• Control of far flung geographical locations
• Start up of new units
• Managing growth
Key Strategic Challenges
• Managing tactically and strategically
• Making operations a contributor to strategy as well as an
implementer
• Making the business case for service
• Understanding the service concept
Managing tactically and strategically
• Problem for operations managers is that a significant part of the
excitement of managing operations is its immediacy
• Constant challenge of dealing with the needs of a stream of
customers, managing the staff and making operational decisions to
ensure the delivery of an appropriate quality of service at an
appropriate cost
Making operations a contributor to strategy
as well as an implementer
• Operations managers are involved in the ‘doing’ part of the business.
• It is the operation and its staff that deliver the service, not its
marketers or financial managers, though in a small organization these
roles may be undertaken by the same people.
• Operations managers are responsible for the implementation of
strategy
• As an implementer of strategy operations managers must first of all
understand the organization's strategy
Making a business case for service
• Why good service, and good operations management, mean making
things better for the customer, better for the staff and better for the
organization.
• Making a business case to sr. management, or the equivalent, in order
to obtain the resources required to provide a better operation and
deliver a better service requires a clear argument providing evidence
of the relationship between service and costs and revenues.
Understanding the service concept
• Strategically it is important that there is a shared and defined view
about the nature of the service that the organization provides
• The service concept defines
• what the organization does,
• what marketing have to sell and
• what the operations have to deliver.
Tactical Challenges faced by Operations
Managers
• The key tactical, day-to-day, challenges faced by most service
operations managers include
• ● Understanding the customer perspective
• ● Managing multiple customers
• ● Managing the customer
• ● Managing in real time
• ● Co-ordinating different parts of the organization
• ● Encouraging improvement and innovation.
Inside Out
Outside In
Customer
Participation in the Simultaneity Perishability
service process

Intangibility Heterogeneity

Distinctive Characteristics of Service Operations


Understanding the Nature of the Services Act
People Things
Services directed at People’s bodies: Services directed at goods & other
▪ Healthcare physical possessions:
▪ Passenger transportation ▪ Freight transportation
Tangible ▪ Beauty salons ▪ Repair and maintenance

Nature of the
Actions

services act
▪ Gyms/Exercise Clinics ▪ Laundry and dry-cleaning
▪ Restaurants ▪ Veterinary care

Intangible Services directed at people’s minds: Services directed at intangible assets:


Actions ▪ Education ▪ Banking
▪ Broadcasting ▪ Legal services
▪ Information services ▪ Accounting
▪ Theatres ▪ Securities
▪ Museums ▪ Insurance
Direct Recipient of the Service
Relationship with Customers
Membership relationship No formal relationship
Insurance Radio station
Continuous Telephone subscription Police Protection
Delivery of Electric Utility Lighthouse
service Banking Public Highway

service delivery
Nature of the
Long distance phone calls Toll Highway
Theatre series pass Pay Phone
Discrete Transit pass Movie theatre
Transactions Wholesale buying club Public transportation
Airline frequent flier Restaurants

Type of relationship between service organization and its customers


Customization and Judgement in Service
Delivery

Extent to which customer contact personnel exercise


judgement in meeting individual customer needs
High Low

Surgery Education (large classes)


Management consulting Preventive health programs
High Taxi service Family restaurant
Gourmet restaurant

Telephone service Public transportation


Hotel services Movie Theatres
Retail banking Spectator sports
Low Cafeteria Institutional food service

Extent to which service characteristics are customized


Nature of service demand relative to supply
Wide Narrow

Electricity Insurance
Telephone Legal

Extent to which supply is


Peak demand can
usually be met without Hospital maternity unit Banking
major delay Police emergencies Laundry & dry cleaning

constrained
Tax preparation Fast food restaurant
Passenger transportation Movie theatre
Peak demand regularly
Hotels and motels Gas station
exceeds capacity

Extent of demand fluctuations over time


Method of Service Delivery
Single Site Multiple Sites

Customer travels to
Theatre Bus service

Nature of interaction between


service firm Barbershop Fast food chain

customer and service


organization
Pest control service Mail delivery
Service provider travels Taxi AAA emergency repairs
to customer

Transaction is at an
Credit card company National TV network
arm’s length Local TV station Telephone company

Availability of service outlets


Open System view of service operations
Consumer arrivals Service Process Consumer departs
(inputs) (outputs)
Evaluation
Consumer Participant
Measurement
Consumer – provider
interface Criteria
Control
Service operations manager
• Production Function:
Consumer Demand Monitor & Control process Service Personnel
Perceived needs • Marketing function Empowerment
Interact with customers and Control
Location Training
demand
Modify as necessary Attitudes
Define standard
Service Package
Supporting facility
Communicate by Facilitating goods Basis of
Advertising Information Selection
Explicit services
Implicit services

Common questions

Powered by AI

Service managers face several strategic challenges in high consumer interaction and customization environments. They must maintain service quality while managing increasing costs due to customization demands. Additionally, they handle the complexity of consumer intervention in processes which can disrupt standard operations. Managers also face the challenge of managing a flat hierarchy, which includes establishing a culture of empowerment and loyalty among employees who are in constant contact with customers, as well as maintaining employee development and satisfaction .

The Push Theory of Innovation contributes to the service sector's growth by suggesting that technological advances drive service innovations, improving efficiency and creating new service offerings. Conversely, the Pull Theory of Innovation suggests that changing consumer demands, such as the aging population and the increase in dual-income families, drive advancements and changes in service offerings. Together, these theories highlight how both supply-side technological capabilities and demand-side consumer needs stimulate service sector growth .

In healthcare, explicit services include tangible, observable treatments like surgeries and medical consultations, which are directly linked to physical health outcomes. Implicit services, however, involve psychological and emotional aspects such as the care and empathy shown by healthcare workers, the cleanliness of the facilities, and the overall environment, which affect a patient's perceived experience. Both types of services significantly impact patient satisfaction, with implicit services often playing a critical role in shaping patient perceptions and judgments beyond the primary medical outcomes .

Customer participation is a key factor that distinguishes service operations from manufacturing. In service operations, customers often act as co-producers, participating directly in the delivery process, influencing both the outcome and the experience. This involvement contrasts with manufacturing, where the customer typically receives the finished product without direct involvement in the production process. The active role of customers in services demands flexibility and adaptability from service providers to meet varying customer needs and expectations .

Service operations managers contribute to strategic decision-making by understanding and implementing the organization’s strategy, ensuring operations are aligned with strategic goals. They serve as critical components in strategic planning by managing the direct delivery of services and ensuring their quality, cost-effectiveness, and alignment with overall business goals. They also make a business case for service improvements, highlighting how good operations management enhances customer satisfaction, employee welfare, and organizational performance. Strategically, managers define the service concept which guides what the organization offers, what marketing sells, and what operations deliver, ensuring clarity and consistency across functions .

The types of services vary in terms of customer interaction and customization as detailed in the Service Process Matrix. A 'Service Factory,' like airlines and hotels, has low labor intensity and low interaction/customization, focusing on efficiently managing fixed processes. 'Service Shops,' such as hospitals and auto repairs, involve high customer interaction and customization despite low labor intensity, requiring attention to managing consumer intervention and maintaining quality. 'Mass Services,' like retailing, have high labor intensity but low customization due to standardized services. 'Professional Services,' such as consulting and accounting, feature both high labor intensity and customization, with challenges related to cost management and employee advancement .

Scheduling the workforce in high labor intensity services is difficult due to several factors. Variability in demand requires flexible staffing that can adapt to peaks and troughs without compromising service quality. There is also the challenge of ensuring sufficient staffing levels to handle personalized, high-interaction services without incurring excessive labor costs. Employee welfare and satisfaction also complicate scheduling, as managers must balance work hours with employee preferences and legal requirements. In addition, the geographical spread of service locations can add complexity in synchronizing workforce availability across different sites .

In high-heterogeneity industries like restaurants, standardization can be achieved by implementing consistent procedures for core service offerings while allowing customization at specific points, such as ingredient choices or cooking methods, to personalize the experience. Training staff to follow standardized processes can ensure efficiency, while also empowering them to make certain decisions to accommodate customer preferences. Use of technology, such as tablets for order customization, can streamline operations while maintaining a high level of personalization. Offering a standardized core menu with add-on options allows restaurants to retain a degree of personalization for each customer .

Operations managers can ensure the continuous delivery of services in discrete customer relationship scenarios by implementing efficient scheduling and resource allocation processes that anticipate peak demand periods. They can use data analytics to understand usage patterns and allocate resources dynamically. Moreover, developing robust standard operating procedures (SOPs) and investing in technology that supports automated service delivery can mitigate disruptions and maintain service continuity. Additionally, enhancing training for staff to quickly adapt to customer needs and encouraging feedback can help refine processes to smooth out any service inconsistencies .

Service perishability implies that services cannot be stored for future use, requiring service operations management to effectively manage demand fluctuations to avoid capacity underutilization or overload. Intangibility suggests that services cannot be physically measured, emphasizing the importance of managing customer perceptions and expectations. Operations managers must focus on training personnel and delivering consistent service quality to bridge the gap between perceived and delivered service, ensuring customer satisfaction despite the intangible nature .

You might also like