Drag Calculations for Immersed Plates
Drag Calculations for Immersed Plates
PROBLEMS
u Problem 1 (Munson et al., 2009, w/ permission)
In two different experiments, air and water flow over an object that has
the same shape in both experiments. It is found that the drag coefficient on each
of the objects is the same for both the air and water flow. For the same velocity,
A) the drag force in the water flow is about equal to that for the airflow.
B) the drag force in the water flow is about 10 times that for the airflow.
C) the drag force in the water flow is about 100 times that for the airflow.
D) the drag force in the water flow is about 1000 times that for the airflow.
A) F = 181 N
B) F = 218 N
C) F = 250 N
D) F = 283 N
1
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
A) 𝛿𝛿 = 18.6 mm and FD = 11.3 N
B) 𝛿𝛿 = 18.6 mm and FD = 22.5 N
C) 𝛿𝛿 = 43.1 mm and FD = 11.3 N
D) 𝛿𝛿 = 43.1 mm and FD = 22.5 N
A) Nplates = 123
B) Nplates = 151
C) Nplates = 180
D) Nplates = 209
2
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
u Problem 8 (Çengel & Cimbala, 2014, w/ permission)
The weight of a thin flat plate 50 cm × 50 cm in size is balanced by a
counterweight that has a mass of 2 kg, as shown. Now a fan is turned on, and air
at 1 atm and 25oC flows downward over both surfaces of the plate (front and back
in the sketch) with a free-stream velocity of 10 m/s. Determine the mass of the
counterweight that needs to be added in order to balance the plate. Use 𝜈𝜈 =
1.56×10-5 m2/s.
A) 𝑚𝑚 = 7 g
B) 𝑚𝑚 = 12 g
C) 𝑚𝑚 = 17 g
D) 𝑚𝑚 = 22 g
3
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
u Problem 10 (Munson et al., 2009, w/ permission)
As shown in the figure below, the aerodynamic drag on a truck can be
reduced by the use of appropriate air deflectors. A reduction in drag coefficient
from CD = 0.96 to CD = 0.70 corresponds to a reduction in how many horsepower
needed at a highway speed of 65 mph? Use 𝜌𝜌air = 2.38×10-3 slugs/ft3.
A) Δ𝑃𝑃 = 10.4 hp
B) Δ𝑃𝑃 = 25.2 hp
C) Δ𝑃𝑃 = 43.1 hp
D) Δ𝑃𝑃 = 58.4 hp
A) D = 0.0188 N
B) D = 0.0296 N
C) D = 0.0377 N
D) D = 0.0495 N
4
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
A) 𝜃𝜃 = 74o
B) 𝜃𝜃 = 79o
C) 𝜃𝜃 = 84o
D) 𝜃𝜃 = 89o
u Problem 13 (Munson et al., 2009, w/ permission)
A hot-air balloon roughly spherical in shape has a volume of 70,000 ft3
and a weight of 500 lb (including passengers, basket, balloon fabric, etc.). The
outside temperature is 80oF and the temperature within the balloon is 165oF.
Estimate the rate at which the balloon will rise under steady-state conditions if
the atmospheric pressure is 14.7 psi. Use 𝜌𝜌air = 2.286×10-3 slugs/ft3 and R = 53.3
ft-lbf/lb∙R.
A) 𝑈𝑈 = 12.2 ft/s
B) 𝑈𝑈 = 16.1 ft/s
C) 𝑈𝑈 = 20.4 ft/s
D) 𝑈𝑈 = 24.3 ft/s
5
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
A) Cost = $1.21/year
B) Cost = $6.88/year
C) Cost = $13.33/year
D) Cost = $18.46/year
C Problem 15B
Determine the amount of money saved per year as a result of replacing a
13-cm-diameter flat mirror by one with a hemispherical back, as shown in the
figure.
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION
Figure 1 Friction drag coefficient for a flat plate parallel to the upstream flow.
6
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
Figure 3 Drag coefficient for specific shapes.
SOLUTIONS
P.1CSolution
Recall that the drag force exerted on a surface immersed in a fluid is
given by
1
=F ρV 2 A × CD
2
where 𝜌𝜌 is the density of the fluid, V is the velocity of flow, A is the cross-
sectional area, and CD is the drag coefficient. Considering flow across the same
body with the same velocity, we must have, in each case,
1 2 Fair
F=
air ρairV 2 A × CD ,air → CD=
,air
2 ρairV 2 A
1 2 Fwater
Fwater
= ρ waterV 2 A × CD ,water → CD ,water
=
2 ρ waterV 2 A
In order for the drag coefficient to be the same in both the air and water
flow, we must have
2 Fair 2 Fwater
CD ,air CD ,water →
= =
ρair V A2
ρ water V 2 A
Fair Fwater
∴ =
ρair ρ water
ρ
∴ Fwater =water
Fair
ρair
ρ water 1000
Fwater = Fair → Fwater = × Fair = 833.3Fair
ρair 1.2
That is, the drag force exerted by the water flow must be over 800 times,
or nearly a thousand times, greater than the force of the air flow.
P.2CSolution
The characteristic length of the flat plate is 𝐿𝐿 = 110 cm. The Reynolds
number for the flow in question is then
We conclude that the flow is laminar. The equation used to compute the
drag coefficient is, in this case,
7
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
−1 2 1.328
=CD 1.328Re
= = 0.00932
( 20,300 )
0.5
ρU 2 891× 62
F = CD × × 2bL= 0.00932 × × 2 × 0.55 ×1.1= 181 N
2 2
P.3CSolution
The boundary layer thickness for laminar flow can be obtained with the
equation
νx
δ =5
U
1.12 ×10−6 × x
=δ ( x ) 5= 0.00748 x 0.5
0.5
Substituting x = 3 m gives
δ (=
3) 0.00748 × 3=
0.5
0.013m
= 1.3 cm
The wall shear stress for laminar flow can be obtained with the equation
ρµ
τ w = 0.332U 3 2
x
0.124
w ( 3)
τ= = 0.0716 N m 2
3
c The correct answer is A.
P.4CSolution
We begin by converting U = 67 mi/h = 30 m/s. The Reynolds number is
It remains to evaluate the boundary layer drag for turbulent flow. This
can be obtained with the expression
ρU 2 0.031 1.23 × 302
=FD CD = A × × ( 2.44 × 1.22
= × 2 ) 11.3 N
2 ( 5 × 106 )1 7 2
8
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
P.5CSolution
A significant portion of the drag on an object can be from the relatively
low pressure developed in the wake region behind the object. By making the
object streamlined (i.e., flow from left to right, not right to left in the foregoing
figure), boundary layer separation is avoided and a relatively thin wake with low
drag is obtained. Whether the front of the object is “sharp” or “blunt” does not
affect the contribution to drag from the front part of the body – at least not as
much as the width of the wake affects the drag.
P.6CSolution
To estimate the plate-induced pressure drag, we first calculate the drag
coefficient on one plate,
24 × 0.008 1.328
Re
= = 12,800 → C=
D = 0.0117
1.5 ×10−5 12,800
ρV 2 1.23 × 242
FD = CD × × 2bL= 0.0117 × × 2 × 0.1× 0.008= 0.00663N
2 2
Since the duct walls must support these plates, the effect is an additional
pressure drop,
That is to say, more than 150 plates are needed to create a pressure drop
of 100 pascals.
P.7CSolution
The formula for drag coefficient in laminar flow is 𝐶𝐶𝐷𝐷 = 1.328⁄Re1⁄2 ,
whence we have the proportion 𝐶𝐶𝐷𝐷 ∝ 𝐿𝐿−1⁄2. Thus, given an arbitrary constant k, it
follows that
k 4 kA1 kA
D2 = × 4 A1 = = 2 2 1= 2.83D1
2 L1 2 L1 L
1
= D1
k kA
D3 = × 4 A1 = 2 1 = 2 D1
4 L1 L1
P.8CSolution
The Reynolds number for this flow field is
VL 10 × 0.5
Re
= = = 3.21×105
ν 1.56 ×10−5
1.328 1.328
CD
= = = 0.002344
Re0.5 ( 3.21×10 )
5 0.5
ρV 2 1.18 × 102
FD = CD × × A = 0.00234 × × ( 2 × 0.5 × 0.5 ) = 0.069 N
2 2
9
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
The mass whose weight is 0.069 N is
FD 0.069
m
= = = 0.007 kg
= 7g
g 9.81
P.9CSolution
The area of the flat plate that represents the kayak is A = 17×2 = 34 ft2.
Given the length L = 17 ft and the kinematic viscosity 𝜈𝜈 = 1.21×10-5 ft2/s, the
Reynolds number is determined as
UL 17 × U
Re
= = = 1.405 × 106U (I)
ν (1.21×10 )−5
In the range of interest, the speed varies from U = 1 ft/s to U = 8 ft/s, and
the Reynolds number accordingly varies from Re = 1.405×106 to Re = 1.124×107.
From Figure 1, we verify that this range of Reynolds numbers is in the transitional
range. Consequently, the drag coefficient can be determined with the relation
0.455 1700
=CD , f −
( log Re )
2.58
Re
0.455 1700
=CD , f − (II)
log (1.405 × 106U )
2.58
1.405 × 106U
Since the drag force is given by
1
=D ρU 2 A × CD , f
2
we have, using equation (II) and substituting the adequate variables,
1 0.455 1700
D = × 1.94 × U 2 × 34 × −
log (1.405 × 10 U )
2.58 6
2 6 1.405 × 10 U
0.455 1700
=∴ D 32.98 −
log (1.405 × 106 U )
2.58 6
1.405 × 10 U
This expression provides the drag force as a function of the flow velocity
U. The following table provides the drag force as a function of speed in the range
of interest, U ∈ [1, 8] ft/s.
U (ft/s) D (lb)
1 0.0986
2 0.41
3 0.909
4 1.58
5 2.42
6 3.43
7 4.59
8 5.9
These values are then plotted along with the experimental data, as
shown.
10
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
The actual kayak does not act as a smooth flat plate and friction plays a
part. As a result, there is a mild shift from the obtained values to the measured
values.
P.10CSolution
The velocity of the truck in ft/s is U = 65 × 5280/3600 = 95.33 ft/s. We
compute the drag force D1 acting on the truck without the air deflector,
1 1
D1= CD ,1 × ρU 2 A= 0.70 × × ( 2.38 ×10−3 ) × 95.332 × (12 ×10 )= 908.4lb
2 2
The horsepower at the initial state is
1hp
P1 = DU
1 =908.4 × 95.33 × =157.5 hp
550lb ⋅ ft/s
Then, we calculate the drag force acting on the truck at the final state, D2,
1 1
D2= CD ,2 × ρU 2 A= 0.96 × × ( 2.38 ×10−3 ) × 95.332 × (12 ×10 )= 1245.8 lb
2 2
The corresponding horse power at the final state is
1 hp
P2 = D2U = 1245.8 × 95.33 × = 215.9 hp
550lb ⋅ ft/s
P.11CSolution
Consider the following diagram.
11
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
y − yb x − xb
=
yc − yb xc − xb
y−0 x − 0.5
∴ =
0.5 − 0 0 − 0.5
y x − 0.5
∴ =
0.5 −0.5
∴ − y= x − 0.5
∴x+ y =0.5
3
ρµ
=D ∫=
τ w dA ∫ 0.332U 2
x
dA
3
=x 0.5 =y 0.5 − x 1
=∴ D 0.332U 2 ρµ × 2 ∫ ∫ dydx
0 0
x
= 0.471
3
=∴ D 0.332U 2 ρµ × 2 × 0.471
3 3
= 0.313U 2 ρµ= 0.313 × 0.2 2 × 999 × 1.12 × 10−=
∴D 3
0.0296 N
P.12CSolution
The solution is started by calculating the Reynolds number,
Re
=
ρVD 1.1×
=
40 (
× 0.2
3.6 = 139,700 )
µ 1.75 ×10−5
ρV 2 1.1×11.112
FD = CD × × A = 1.2 × × ( 2 × 0.2 ) = 32.6 N
2 2
The weight of the log is
π D2 L π × 0.22 × 2
W = mg = ρ g = 513 × 9.81× = 316.2 N
4 4
The angle that the resultant force (and, as a consequence, the cable)
makes with the horizontal follows as
W 316.2
tan θ = = = 9.699 → θ = 84o
FD 32.6
Drawing a free body diagram of the log and doing a force balance will
show that the magnitude of the tension on the cable must be equal to the
resultant force acting on the log. Therefore, the cable makes 84o with the
horizontal.
12
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
P.13CSolution
The free body diagram for the balloon is shown in continuation.
The density of the balloon can be obtained from the ideal gas law,
pound in.2
14.7 × 144
p in.2 ft 2
ρb =
= = 0.0636 lbm ft 3
RT 53.3 ft-lbf lb ⋅ R × (165 + 459.67 R )
lbm 1 slug
∴ ρb= 0.0636 3
× = 1.975 ×10−3 slug ft 3
ft 32.2 lbm
1
D= ρU 2CD A
2
1
∴ D = × ( 2.286 ×10−3 ) × (π × 25.57 2 ) U 2CD
2
2.348U 2CD
∴D =
ΣFy =0 → FB − W − D =0
∴ FB = W + D
85.43
∴U = (I)
CD
13
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
Next, we compute the Reynolds number,
UD U × 2 R U × 2 × 25.57
Re
= = = = 3.026 ×105U (II)
ν ν 1.69 ×10 −4
85.43
=U = 13.1ft/s
( 0.5)
Substituting in equation (II), then, it follows that
Using Figure 2, we see that 𝐶𝐶𝐷𝐷 ≈ 0.21 when Re = 3.96×106. However, the
assumed value of CD was 0.5; the values do not match, and another trial is in
order. In a second trial, suppose that 𝐶𝐶𝐷𝐷 = 0.21. Substituting in the equation for U
gives
85.43
=U = 20.2ft/s
( 0.21)
Substituting this quantity in the relation for Re, we obtain
Using Figure 2 as before, we obtain 𝐶𝐶𝐷𝐷 ≈ 0.33. Again, the assumed value
of CD and the actual value do not match. In a third trial, suppose that 𝐶𝐶𝐷𝐷 = 0.33.
Substituting in equation (I) gives
85.43
=U = 16.1ft/s
( 0.33)
Substituting this quantity into the relation for Re, we obtain
Using the same chart as before, we see that the drag coefficient is 𝐶𝐶𝐷𝐷 =
0.31. This is close enough to the assumed value of 0.33. We conclude that the
velocity of the balloon is 16.1 ft/s.
P.14CSolution
The drag coefficient for a hemispherical cup is 0.4 and 1.2 when the
hemispherical and plain surfaces are exposed to wind flow, respectively (see
Figure 3).
The maximum torque occurs when the cups are normal to the wind since
the length of the moment arm is maximum in this case. Noting that the frontal
area is 𝜋𝜋 𝐷𝐷2 ⁄4 for both cups, the drag force acting on each cup is determined to
be
14
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
The moment arm for both forces is 20 cm. Taking moments about the
pivot, the net torque applied on the pivot is calculated as
The torque varies from zero when both cups are aligned with the wind to
the maximum value calculated above.
P.15CSolution
Part A: The drag coefficients are 1.1 for a circular disk and 0.40 for a
hemispherical body (Figure 3). The velocity of the vehicle expressed in m/s is 𝑈𝑈 =
95⁄3.6 = 26.4 m/s. The drag force acting on the flat mirror is
The amount and costs of the fuel that supplies this much energy are then
kJ kJ
488,800 / 44,000
mfuel Ein HV year kg
Amount of =
fuel = = = 14.81 L/year
ρfuel ρfuel 0.75 kg/L
L $0.90
Cost
= Amount of fuel × Unit cost
= 14.81 × = $13.33 / year
year L
That is, the car uses 14.81 L of gasoline at a cost of $13.33 per year to
overcome the drag generated by a flat mirror extending out from the side of the
vehicle.
Part B: The drag force and the work done to overcome it are directly
proportional to the drag coefficient. Then, the percent reduction in fuel
consumption due to replacing the mirror is equal to the percent reduction in the
drag coefficient, namely,
Cost reduction = Reduction ratio × Cost = 0.636 × $13.33 / year = $8.48 / year
15
© 2020 Montogue Quiz
ANSWER SUMMARY
Problem 1 D
Problem 2 A
Problem 3 A
Problem 4 C
Problem 5 Open-ended pb.
Problem 6 B
Problem 7 C
Problem 8 A
Problem 9 Open-ended pb.
Problem 10 D
Problem 11 B
Problem 12 C
Problem 13 B
Problem 14 B
15A C
Problem 15
15B D
REFERENCES
• ÇENGEL, Y. and CIMBALA, J. (2014). Fluid Mechanics: Fundamentals and
Applications. 3rd edition. New York: McGraw-Hill.
• MUNSON, B., YOUNG, D., OKIISHI, T., and HUEBSCH, W. (2009).
Fundamentals of Fluid Mechanics. 6th edition. Hoboken: John Wiley and
Sons.
• WHITE, F. (2003). Fluid Mechanics. 5th edition. New York: McGraw-Hill.
16
© 2020 Montogue Quiz