0% found this document useful (0 votes)
1K views5 pages

Conflict of Two Lady Rams Explained

This story is about Lalla Jhinda Ram, a contractor who is given a knighthood by the government. He has two wives, Sukhi and Sakuntala, who both want to attend the award ceremony. However, the invitation is only for one lady. This causes conflict between the wives. Ram is unable to choose between them. He alters the invitation to say "Two Lady Rams" and brings both wives, resolving the issue. They are celebrated in their town from then on.
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
1K views5 pages

Conflict of Two Lady Rams Explained

This story is about Lalla Jhinda Ram, a contractor who is given a knighthood by the government. He has two wives, Sukhi and Sakuntala, who both want to attend the award ceremony. However, the invitation is only for one lady. This causes conflict between the wives. Ram is unable to choose between them. He alters the invitation to say "Two Lady Rams" and brings both wives, resolving the issue. They are celebrated in their town from then on.
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Two Lady Rams Summary

It is a humorous story about Lalla Jhinda Ram and his two wives, Sukhi and Sakuntala. Ram is a contractor
to whom the government confers the title of knighthood for his service to the government.
Unfortunately, the news creates a conflict between his two wives. Both of them want to attend the award
ceremony, but the government employee invites only one lady ram.
Initially, it is not a matter of concern for Ram. He thinks of taking his second wife, Sakuntala, to the party.
The servants inform his first wife, Sukhi, about his preference. She becomes furious and verbally attacks
both of them.
After the incident, it becomes a matter of worry for Ram. Both insist Ram on taking them to the party. He
can neither leave Sukhi nor Sakuntala. Therefore, Ram feels helpless and asks for help from the officials, but
to no avail.
It is not clear whom they refer to as Lady Ram, and he takes it as an advantage. Ram changes the letter on
the invitation card from Lady Ram to Two Lady Rams and resolves the ongoing issue. He takes both of his
wives to the party.
The Governor and his wife give them a warm welcome. They become famous and attend every program in
the town from that day onward.

A Critical Analysis of Two Lady Rams


The status of Indian women in colonial times in the context of the
Story
When Mulk Raj Anand wrote the short story, the authority banned polygamy in India. But a man could
marry multiple times until he got his heir. The worth of a woman in the colonial era was determined based
on her ability to procreate.
We can get an idea of the condition of Indian women in the short story.
Though it seems the two Lady Rams enjoy equal status, it is Sukhi who faces discrimination.
When Jhinda Ram discovers her infertility, her worth decays in front of her husband‟s eyes, and he marries
another woman.
Sukhi has no choice except her considering her husband‟s second marriage only for the continuation of the
race.
In those days, the Hindu Mitakshara Law allowed men to practice polygamy, but there was no law for
women. It is not clear whether or not they can do the same.
The white officials had paid no attention to it. Moreover, they ignored a probable situation. That is if the
government honors the husband with any high rank, could all or one of his wives hold the title of Lady?
The government honors Ram with Knighthood. They make it not clear whom they have referred to as Lady
Ram on the invitation card.
As a result, such negligence increases the conflict between the two wives of Ram.
Dowry system
The Dowry system was prevalent during the time. We learn about dowry when Sukhi charges Sakuntala.
She goes to the other part of the house to accuse Sakuntala. Ram orders Sukhi to go to her room and he
asserts he is the owner of the house. Then, in response, Sukhi reminds Jhinda Ram,
“You had nothing before I brought a lakh of rupees in my dowry!… What did this bitch bring with her -
nothing but a fair complexion and a snub nose.” (Anand 30)
Sukhi comes to the house with a one lakh dowry, whereas Sakuntala comes empty-handed.
Sukhi is more assertive than Sakuntala, and it is because the reputation of a woman lies in the amount of
dowry she carries with her.
The Theme of Two Lady Rams
The theme of deception or trickery runs throughout the short story “Two Lady Rams”.
In the story we observe, it is not only Ram who deceives the people, but the colonial government also
deceives him and the natives. We have examined the theme in the following paragraphs.
In the short story, Sir Lalla Jhinda Ram practices dishonesty in his profession. He is a master in forgery.
Ram‟s deceptive nature in his works is highlighted thrice in the story.
For instance, when both of his wives insist on going with him to the garden party. He is in a dilemma, he
cannot decide whom to select for the party.
Then he calls the A.D.C to make an appointment to meet the Governor of the province urgently. The A.D.C
who is busy managing things for the Garden Party thinks,
“Sir Jhinda Ram was only after some deal or contract as usual, and though the commissions the sahib had
received from this knight had always been generous, Captain Forbes had made his pile and did not want to
get involved in these shady negotiations any more.” (Anand 31)
Ram often meets the A.D.C for their official meetings. From the deals, the A.D.C always receives a fair
amount of commission from “shady negotiations”.
These negotiations are shady because they are illegal and against the interest of the mass.
The next instance of his deception is when Ram alters the name on the invitation card from Lady Ram to the
two Lady Rams.
It is an easy task for him and this is not a new thing for him “as he had altered many more intricate
documents in the past.” (Anand 33)
He also deceives his wives. Before the departure to the garden party, Jhinda Ram orders his driver to inform
both of his wives to be ready for the party.
The driver deceives both ladies into believing that only one of them will go with their husband to the garden
party. When both of them realize he befools them, there is nothing left for them to do except go to the party.
Besides Lalla Jhinda Ram, the colonial masters also befool him and deceive the mass.
As Jhinda Ram receives the news of Knighthood, he is exultant. He imagines transforming himself from a
man of five-foot-five to a six-foot-six colonial sahib.
We can measure his excitement by the way he looks in the mirror. He looks at the mirror stealthily and
smiles with a sense of pride when none is around. He also thinks that the Knighthood will add glory to his
personality.
But his dream of becoming equal to English Sahib is a lie. Because when he needs the help of the Governor,
he cannot meet him personally.
Despite having the Knight title, he disguises himself to meet the Governor. This suggests such a title is only
a deception and has hardly any value in real life.
Significance of the Title
“The two Lady Rams” in the title are Sukhi and Sakuntala. They are called two Lady Rams because they are
the wives of Lalla Jhinda Ram.
These two Lady Rams have been engaged in a constant cold war for numerous years. Both want the
attention of their mutual husband.
Their husband Jhinda Ram is a contractor who works with white officials and the government awards the
title of Knighthood for his service. The governor invites him to come with his wife to the award ceremony.
They address the invitation card to Sir Jhinda and Lady Ram. Ram initially chooses his second wife,
Sakuntala, as his company for the party.
But his first wife Sukhi thinks it is an insult to her, and therefore she protests. She too demands to take her to
the party.
Sukhi‟s insistence makes him worried.
If he rejects Sukhi, then she will never let him live in peace. If he breaks his promise of going together with
Sakuntala, he can never enjoy the company of the youthful Sakuntala.
Since both of them want to go with him to the party, therefore it creates pressure on him. Ram can deny
neither Sakuntala nor Sukhi.
He is confused. Therefore, he thinks that “the Governor of the province, the king‟s representative, the
shadow of the monarch” (Anand 31) can easily resolve the issue.
But he does not get help from the Governor rather, it is the driver of Ram who proposes the idea of taking
both Lady Rams. Since he marries them, therefore he undoubtedly calls them both Lady Rams.
Moreover, the Governor cannot stop them from entering the party. The only problem for him is the
invitation card. Therefore, he alters the words to “The two Lady Rams”. This is how Jhinda Ram copes with
the conflict between two wives.
We can interpret the title in two ways.
First, changing the words from Lady Ram to The Two Lady Rams implies Ram‟s expertise in forgery. His
alteration of the words from Lady Rams to “Two Lady Rams” is not his first experience of modification, as
he had altered many more intricate documents in the past. This suggested his cunningness.
Second, it points out the indifference of the colonial administration toward its subject. Because they have
thought whom they should address as Lady in case of a man with multiple wives attains knighthood.
Through this comical story, Mulk Raj Anand points subtly to the social condition of that time. For instance,
people practiced the Hindu Mitakshara Law in those colonial days.
This law allowed the man to practice polygamy, but the colonial administration was not concerned about the
women. There was no rule whether all or any of the wives of a knight could hold the title of Lady.
Two Lady Rams As A critique on Colonialism
“Two Lady Rams” is a simple short story that revolves around a conflict between two wives of contractor
Lalla Jhinda Ram. However, after a close reading of the story, it unveils various interpretations.
One of them is that we can read the story as a critique of India‟s colonial era.
Mulk Raj Anand sets the story against the backdrop of the colonial era in India. It was an era of deception,
exploitation, and domination. In those days, to govern a colony like India, the foreign masters needed the
support of the rich natives.
In most cases, the rich merchants, contractors, employees, etc. cooperated with the white masters with no
hesitation for the sake of selfish motives.
For instance, in the story, Ram, a contractor, is a master of trickery who cooperated with the white masters
in corruption.
When Sir Jhinda calls A. D. C to arrange a meeting with the governor immediately to solve his domestic
issue, it reveals his collaboration with the official.
The A. D. C does not receive his call and presumes,
“Sir Jhinda Ram was only after some deal or contract as usual, and though the commissions the sahib had
received from this knight had always been generous, Captain Forbes had made his pile and did not want to
get involved in these shady negotiations any more.” (Anand 31)
The above lines suggest Sir Jhinda usually meets the A.D.C for deal or contract purposes. Through him, the
A.D.C usually receives a decent amount of commission.
Not only the privileged natives like Ram but also the colonial masters engaged in duplicity to exploit the
common mass, who were mostly uneducated and unaware of corruption.
The Government
The colonial government not only tricked the common people but also the rich native class. They employed
them for their economic benefits.
To continue their exploitation, they made sure they were in good contact with the affluent class.
To appease them, they used medals and awards as tools to appease their subjects. It is like appeasing a baby
with candy so that he would not whine.
For instance, the government confers the title of Knighthood to Ram because he supports the white masters.
They organize a ceremony, the Garden Party, to honor the title at the residence of the Governor.
The Garden Party is organized “specially for the ceremony of investiture of all those dignitaries who had
been granted titles, medals and scrolls of honour.” (Anand 28)
In reality, the title of Knighthood is nothing but a mere decoration and medium to befool the rich natives.
When Jhinda Ram calls the A. D. C to meet the governor in person, we discover the reality of his position.
After the first failed attempt through the phone, he goes directly to the governor‟s residence.
There he disguises himself as a contractor who has taken the charge of the management of cutlery. Despite
his attempt, the gatekeeper prevents him from stepping into the residence because the governor is taking a
nap. His position is of no use in reality.
Neither the Governor responds to him in the hour of his need, nor the A.D.C who usually receives a fair
amount of commissions from Jhinda Ram.
Moreover, Ram does not deserve such a title. He has no such qualities as bravery, honesty, truthfulness, etc.
Even the government is aware of that.
Without people like Ram, the officials cannot engage in corruption and hide it from the common
people. The is the only reason why the authority entitle him the title.
Ram‟s altercation of the words from Lady Rams to „The two Lady Rams‟ on the invitation letter points out
his dishonest practice.
We learn about him that, “he had altered many more intricate documents in the past.” (Anand 33)
Lalla Jhinda Ram is an example of the rich class of the pre-independence era of Inda, who is an expert in
negotiation and forging official files.
The Administration
The colonial officials have never prohibited corruption. The reasons are: first, they are part of it. Second,
they do not care about the welfare of the common people. Thus, they do not properly lay down and review
the rules and laws.
For example, although there was a prohibition of polygamy in India during the colonial era, the government
has allowed the mitakshara law.
According to the law, anyone who cannot have a child can marry multiple times until the birth of a child. It
means a man can practice polygamy.
Ram‟s first wife Sukhi cannot conceive a child, therefore Ram marries Sakuntala.
The problem is not limited to that. The government is not ready for a situation like Ram‟s condition. What if
a man like Ram with two wives attains Knighthood, who will have the title of Lady?
In Ram‟s case, both of his wives insist on going with him to the garden party, whereas the invitation is only
for him and his Lady Ram. Since there is no law, it creates a conflict between Sukhi and Sakuntala.
Having no clear policy points that the British government does not care about the natives. What they care
about is the wealth and power that they gain by using their rich servants.
Anand tells the readers in a light tone how the mechanism of the British government works in colonial India.
The King-Emperor, who lives seven thousand miles away from its colony India, operates and controls India
and its natives through some government departments.
Since the King-Emperor is always far away from his colony, he never knows about the personal lives of
colonized people.
However, the department which works on the King-Emperor‟s behalf keeps “fairly well-documented
confidential dossiers about the temperament, religious, political and social opinions of almost all notable
persons as well as notorieties and, particularly about the services rendered to the sarkar by them,” (Anand
27)
With the knowledge of one‟s religious, social, and political views, the colonial masters can easily control
any notable or notoriety. So they are interested in that information which they can use for their benefit.
However, they know nothing about their subjects personally through whom they successfully control the
colony. Personal life is of no use to government departments.
Therefore, neither the King-Emperor nor the governor has seen what has happened in Ram‟s house after the
announcement of the Knighthood title.
This shows the selfishness of the British government and the King-Emperor and the indifference they have
for their subjects.
Mimicry
Their only interest is in colonizing their subjects, and they have successfully colonized the natives. Because
of colonization, the natives look upon the white men as superior to them and they keep trying to imitate the
colonizers.
We observe the effect of colonization in the house‟s selection of Lalla Jhinda Ram and imitating “the
English style gol-kamra or living-room.” (Anand 29) Jhinda Ram has built his bungalow in the famous
purdah style, which has become a common choice for houses in India. Anand writes,
“Its front, which looked out into Lawrence Road, was like the front of an ordinary English bungalow, with a
verandah decorated by palm trees and hanging plants, leading through a narrow hall into a large living-
room.” (Anand 29)
Like Ram, other natives have also built their houses in the purdah style. The colonized attempts to imitate
the external things like the house. They also try to be like colonizers. This is in postcolonial studies
called mimicry.
In the essay “Of Mimicry and Man: The Ambivalence of Colonial Discourse”, Homi K. Bhabha
comments, “colonial mimicry is the desire for a reformed, recognizable Other, as a subject of a difference
that is almost the same, but not quite.” (Bhabha 126).
Mimicry is man‟s attempt to be like the colonizer. The native seeks to copy the language, culture, and
society of the colonizer, but in doing so, he often ignores his root and his identity.
He can copy the colonizer but the imitation will never be the same. It is “a difference that is almost total but
not quite.” (Bhabha 132)
Hence, they are called mimic men.
You can read the novel The Mimic Man by V. S. Naipaul for a better understanding. We see another
instance of mimicry when the government announces Knighthood to Ram.
It makes Jhinda Ram excited. He looks at the mirror, thinking that this is another feather in his cap. He
presumes that his five-foot-five height has become equivalent to that of a six-foot-six English master. That
means he will attain the same position as that an English master.
In addition, he also thinks that the title will add more glory to his personality. His wish to be like the six-
foot-six white master makes him a mimic man. He can mimic but he will not be like them.
Therefore, from the above discussion, we can say that through the short-story Mulk Raj Anand criticizes not
only the administration of the colonial era but also the brown upper class.

Common questions

Powered by AI

The practice of polygamy and the dowry system in "Two Lady Rams" underscore significant gender inequalities in colonial India. The Hindu Mitakshara Law permitted men like Jhinda Ram to marry multiple women until an heir was produced, reflecting a patriarchal society that judged women based on fertility. Sukhi's higher dowry, which she uses to assert her position, highlights how women's value often equated to their family's financial contributions. Sakuntala's lack of a dowry diminishes her social standing in contrast to Sukhi, reflecting a system where women's personal attributes are less valued than their economic worth, further compounded by cultural and legal discrimination .

"Two Lady Rams" illustrates the British government's disinterest in native social issues through their lack of engagement with the personal implications of their bestowed honors. The government fails to consider or address the complexities of polygamous households when issuing titles such as Knighthood. This negligence is evident in the unresolved ambiguity of who holds the title of "Lady Ram." The story demonstrates that the government's focus is on larger structural control and economic exploitation rather than the welfare or cultural nuances of the native population; the colonial masters prioritize political loyalty over resolving personal or social conflicts within the native society .

"Two Lady Rams" critiques colonial administration by exposing its superficial and exploitative nature. The Knighthood awarded to Jhinda Ram is a symbolic gesture to appease and manipulate the native elite, with little actual regard for merit or virtue. The colonial government, portrayed as indifferent to genuine issues and content with bribing natives with titles, reveals its exploitation of economic and social hierarchies. The government's failure to assist Ram in resolving the invitation dilemma reflects its disregard for native traditions and personal lives, focusing instead on maintaining control and extracting benefits from the colony .

In "Two Lady Rams," mimicry and identity highlight the challenges of colonial influence on native self-perception. Jhinda Ram embodies mimicry by adopting colonial customs and celebrating his Knighthood, reflecting an internal conflict between his native identity and colonial aspirations. The attempt to emulate colonial aesthetics, such as through the architecture of his home and Western titles, illustrates a loss of cultural authenticity, as natives strive for an unattainable equality with their colonizers. This reveals the colonial impact on self-identity, where natives, in seeking validation from colonizers, face an inherent conflict and distortion of their cultural essence .

Jhinda Ram represents native elites during the colonial period, exemplifying both complicity in and manipulation by colonial systems. He enjoys economic benefits from his collaborations with colonial officials, shown in his shady business deals and the recognition he receives from the colonial government. However, his inability to directly influence the Governor despite his Knighthood reveals his limited power within the colonial hierarchy. This duality highlights the position of native elites as both beneficiaries and pawns within the colonial structure, illustrating their superficial influence tied to colonial interests rather than genuine autonomy .

Mimicry in "Two Lady Rams" is illustrated through Jhinda Ram's adoption of English styles and his excitement over the Knighthood, symbolizing his internalized colonial values. His house mimics an English bungalow, representing a desire to align with colonial aesthetics and standards. Ram's delight in receiving Knighthood, imagining himself equivalent to an English sahib, exhibits the colonial dominance of imposing cultural values on natives. However, despite such mimicry, Ram remains distinct from his colonizers, underscored by his inability to address the Governor directly, revealing the limits of mimicry and highlighting its failure to confer true power or status to the colonized .

The story reflects the status of women in colonial India as one primarily defined by their roles as wives and bearers of children. Sukhi, the first wife, faces discrimination when her infertility diminishes her worth in her husband's eyes, leading Ram to marry Sakuntala for an heir. This exemplifies the societal expectation for women to procreate, as well as the prevalent practice of polygamy despite legal prohibitions, sustained by cultural laws such as the Hindu Mitakshara Law. Additionally, the story highlights how women's worth was often assessed through material contributions like dowries, as evidenced by Sukhi's assertion of her own value and the lack of respect for Sakuntala due to her lack of dowry .

Deception in "Two Lady Rams" is portrayed through both Jhinda Ram's personal dishonesty and the colonial government's duplicitous relationship with native elites. Jhinda Ram is portrayed as deceitful, engaging in forgery and misleading his wives to avoid conflict. The colonial government itself deceives by handing out titles like Knighthood to curry favor with native elites, using such honors as mere tools to secure economic benefits rather than a genuine acknowledgment of merit. Ram's eventual realization that the title has little real value underscores the colonial strategy of exploitation masked as reward, reflecting how both Ram and other affluent natives were kept compliant and thus complicit in colonial governance .

The title "Two Lady Rams" encapsulates the central conflict and themes of the narrative by highlighting the issue of identity and societal roles within polygamy. It signifies the rivalry between Sukhi and Sakuntala for recognition and status, a microcosm of broader gender tensions. The alteration of the invitation card from "Lady Ram" to "Two Lady Rams" suggests themes of deception and manipulation, as Ram navigates colonial and personal systems of power to resolve his dilemma. This duality of meaning reflects not only domestic conflicts but also the broader context of colonial hierarchies and their impact on personal lives .

Colonial ceremonies such as the Garden Party in "Two Lady Rams" function as tools to maintain and reinforce colonial hierarchies. The event is designed to bestow honors, like Knighthood, on natives as a means of controlling and pacifying them. These ceremonies serve to symbolize the power and magnanimity of the colonial government, thus reinforcing colonial dominance and the status quo. By inviting select natives, they create a spectacle of inclusion and recognition that conceals the underlying exploitation and ensures continued loyalty from the privileged native class, like Jhinda Ram, who remain dependent on colonial validation for their esteem and status .

You might also like