Scribd
Upload
94 views2 pages

Yuson Plagiarism Controversy Explained

Krip Yuson is accused of plagiarizing from Rey Joble's article for Roque Magazine by failing to properly cite Joble. Jaemark Tordecilla noticed the plagiarism and confronted Yuson. Yuson admits making an "honest mistake" by recycling paragraphs from Joble's work without permission or citations due to time pressure. However, Tordecilla argues that an experienced writer like Yuson should not commit such acts of plagiarism. While Yuson apologized, Tordecilla believes Yuson should be held responsible for plagiarizing another writer's work.

Uploaded by

Theo Exequiel Dolor
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
94 views2 pages

Yuson Plagiarism Controversy Explained

Krip Yuson is accused of plagiarizing from Rey Joble's article for Roque Magazine by failing to properly cite Joble. Jaemark Tordecilla noticed the plagiarism and confronted Yuson. Yuson admits making an "honest mistake" by recycling paragraphs from Joble's work without permission or citations due to time pressure. However, Tordecilla argues that an experienced writer like Yuson should not commit such acts of plagiarism. While Yuson apologized, Tordecilla believes Yuson should be held responsible for plagiarizing another writer's work.

Uploaded by

Theo Exequiel Dolor
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
  • Overview and Positions
  • Arguments and Analysis

DOLOR, Theo Exequiel B.

COMM – II
2019 – 46235 Ms. Pamela Yu

Issue: Famous writer Krip Yuson plagiarized for Roque Magazine

Who are involved:


Krip Yuson who failed to credit Rey Joble and Jaemark Tordecilla who is accusing him of
plagiarism

What are the positions of the people involved in the issue?

Position/Stand 1: Position/Stand 2:

Jaemark Tordecilla is accusing Krip Krip Yuson admits honest mistake


Yuson of plagiarism for not and apologizes to both Rogue
crediting Rey Joble in his article for magazine and GMA News Online.
Rogue magazine.

Argument 1 Argument 1
Jaemark Tordecilla saw that Yuson Krip Yuson was pressed for time
got the whole middle paragraph and is all over the place that made
from Rey Joble’s article of the him get a piece from Rey Joble’s
passing commissioner and article and forgot to credit him for
changed a bit of it. it.

Argument 2 Argument 2
Jaemark Tordecilla asked Rey Joble Krip Yuson said he sought to
if Krip Yuson asked permission for recycle a few paragraphs from
his work and confirmed that he Joble’s work which he was part-
didn’t. writer of and dropped the
quotation marks and admits he
was careless.

Argument 3 Argument 3
Jaemark Tordecilla stated that he Krip Yuson apologized to Joble and
didn’t expect someone like Krip sends Jaemark Tordecilla an email
Yuson, who is an accomplished of his explanation. He also
writer, to be committing such acts. apologized to the public for his
honest mistake which is then later
recognized for.
DOLOR, Theo Exequiel B. COMM – II
2019 – 46235 Ms. Pamela Yu

What is your position?


: Krip Yuson indeed plagiarized and should be responsible for the consequences of his actions.

Argument 1: Someone with a reputation like Krip Yuson should be careful of his acts because a
lot of people look up to him.

Argument 2: Krip Yuson didn’t admit simply the accusation but gave different excuses that
contradict his apology.

Argument 3: Krip Yuson definitely misinterpreted Joble’s work as his own since he is saying he
drafted it which is strong evidence for plagiarism and is considered a heinous violation of
ethical standards.

DOLOR, Theo Exequiel B. COMM – II 2019 – 46235
DOLOR, Theo Exequiel B. COMM – II 2019 – 46235

You might also like