Psycholinguistic Study of Tongue Slips
Psycholinguistic Study of Tongue Slips
THESIS
Presented to
State Islamic University of Malang
In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirement for Degree of
Sarjana Sastra
By :
Djarot Karisman
03320045
English Department
Faculty of Humanities and Culture
State Islamic University of Malang
2008
A Psycholinguistic Research on Slips of the Tongue
Occurred in the Speaking Class of English Letters and
Language Department Students of UIN Malang
THESIS
Presented to
By:
Djarot Karisman
NIM 03320045
Advisor:
Rohmani Nur Indah, [Link]
of English Letters and Language Department Students of UIN Malang “ has been
Approved by Acknowledgement by
The Dean of
2. Rinasari ,[Link]
NIP. 150 377 937 (Chair of Examiner) ______________
Approved by
Dean of Humanities and Culture Faculty
أ
ور
My mother “ Hj. Sri Suyami “ for your eternal love, prays, spirit and
For all my family, thanks for your supports and helps for me
All praise be to Allah SWT, whose guidance and blessing make it possible
Peace and salutation to our last prophet Muhammad SAW, who has
brought us from the darkness to the lightness, and who has been a good model in
I realized that my thesis compilation will never get success without any
Rohmani Nur Indah, [Link] for her patience, constructive suggestions, valuable
guidance and encouragements during the finishing of this thesis. May god always
2. Secondly, thank you to Prof. Dr. H. Imam Suprayogo as the rector of UIN
Malang, Drs. H. Dimjati Ahmadin. [Link] as the dean of Humanities and Culture
Faculty, Dra. Hj. Syafiyah, M.A as the head of English Letters and Language
Department, who have allowed me to conduct the research in this faculty, Mrs.
Rinasari as my chair of examiner, and all of the lecturers of English Letters and
Language department for being so kind, patient, and generous in leading me to the
world of linguistics, literature and anything about language with the invaluable
knowledge inputs.
3. Furthermore, thanks also for my parents and all my family, for their
encouragements, helps and supports during my study and the completion of this
thesis. Thanks for their endless love, prays, care, and everything they have done
2003, Dedi, Ali Rofi, Pakde, Ya’lu, Linda, Zainul, Nur Khasanah……….etc,
thanks for our friendship, togetherness and supports for finishing this thesis.
5. For Mbak Sul “ warung gaul” and Bu’e “ nasi kuning “ thanks for your cooking
and milk every morning which make me health and fresh. My friends in
“ Indonesia Backpacker Community” and all mountain and nature lovers, thanks
for your care to the earth which make me still alive up to now.
6. At last, thanks for my basket ball and hang out friends (Arman, Esti Unmer,
Bahtiar and Nafis), my swimming friends ( Yaqin, Zainuddin and Anang Dokter ),
my football friends (Rofiq, Jhoni, Eka, Thomas, Fajrin, Heru, Dani and Salladin ),
Sani, Danang, Meri, Budi, Alfan, Bagus, Azis, Adib, Khusairi, Agus, Cemet,
Ketek, Lukman, Wawan, Bawox, Angga, Tain, Ipung, Atmam and P-man) and for
all my lovely friends who I cannot mention one by one, thanks for our friendship
May Allah SWT bless and protect them all forever, and may this thesis
April, 2008
Djarot Karisman
ABSTRACT
Karisman, Djarot. 2008. A Psycholinguistic Research on Slips of the Tongue
Occurred in the Speaking Class of English Letters and Language Department
Students of UIN Malang. Thesis. English Letters and Language Department, the
State Islamic University of Malang.
Advisor:Rohmani Nur Indah, [Link].
Page
Approval ………...………..………………………………....i
Legitimation ……………………………………………………ii
Motto …...………………………………………………iii
Dedication …...…………….………………………………...iv
Acknowledgement …………...……….……………………………....v
Abstract ………………………...………………………...vii
CHAPTER I : INTRODUCTION
4. 2 Discussion ………………………..…………………..50
CHAPTER V : CONCLUSION
5. 1 Conclusion …………………..………………………..57
5. 2 Suggestion ……………..……………………………..58
Bibliography
Appendix
Curriculum Vitae
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
Said in Hadist:
أ
ور
The meaning:
Control what’s between your beard and moustache (your mouth) and what’s
between your thigh
From the Hadist above, we know that keeping our mouth is very important
in our life. A big thing can happen if we cannot keep our mouth well. It is
expected that we use our mouth only to say or to speak the good thing and keep
What we said shows who we are. Then, our prophet teaches us to speak
carefully. Sometimes we speak carelessly and can produce slips of the tongue.
and slips of the tongue, because slips of the tongue is one of the types of speech
errors. As human being, every one of us seems to produce slips of the tongue.
Sigmund Freud, a psychologist (in Fromklin, 1973) analyzed that slips of the
tongue phenomenon resulted from repressed thoughts which are revealed by the
particular errors which a speaker makes. Such errors reveal as much if not much
century when the Arab linguist Al-Kisa’i wrote his book, “Errors of the
populace”. The Arab scholar's interest in such errors was based on the belief that
they might provide clues as to how language changes. Since that time, many
linguists have been collecting and analyzing these spontaneously produced speech
errors. While slips of the tongue have not contributed much to the understanding
of how and why languages change, they do tell us a great deal about what we
seem to know about our language and how we use this knowledge to speak and to
understand what others say to us. We can look at some speech errors and see what
they reveal about our linguistic knowledge (cited from http// www. Isadc. Org).
The example of slips of the tongue is a person who said, “Bake my bike"
for the intended sentence “take my bike" while talking to his servant which may
have produced an 'anticipation slip'. This kind of slips of the tongue happens when
The kinds of slips of the tongue which is analyzed in this research are
those occurred in the speaking class of English Letters and Language Department
students of UIN Malang. In the speaking class, the English Letters and Language
Department students can express their thought and practice their language fluency
speaking skill.
studies conducted previously. For example, Warren’s study on slips of the tongue
in very young children (1986). Jeager’s study entitled “Young Children Slips of
Production” (1999) and also Ni’matur Rohamah’s study on slips of the tongue on
be researched by the researcher. And this is relevant and informative reading that
will help language teachers gain insights into the phenomenon of language slips.
The above are some reasons why the writer chooses this title “A Psycholinguistic
Letters and Language Department Students of UIN Malang” for his thesis
2. What are the kinds of slips of the tongue that most happened in the
UIN Malang?
1. To describe the kinds of slips of the tongue happened in the speaking class of
Malang
The findings of the research are supposed to give both theoretical and
practically, it is expected to be useful for the teacher, students and also for the
next researcher.
material for psycholinguistics course. For students, they can understand the kinds
of slips of the tongue. And also for the next researchers, it can be the reference for
students of UIN Malang. The research is done in the third semester speaking class
and the theory used to support the analysis of this research is taken from Carroll’s
theory on slips of the tongue. The slips of the tongue caused by speech disfluency
2. Speech Errors
3. Speaking class
express their thought and to practice their language (English) fluency and
accuracy.
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
topic of slips of the tongue, such as: common speech errors, definition of common
speech errors, types of common speech errors which belong to the conversational
feature, slips of the tongue, types of slips of the tongue, errors in articulator
program, unit in the articulator program, factors in slips of the tongue and
previous studies.
Freud claimed that speech errors are resulted from repressed thoughts
which are revealed by the particular errors which a speaker makes. While it
possible that Freud is correct in some case, such errors reveal as much if not much
Speech errors are errors in linguistic output occur in spoken language, sign
language, written language, and typed language. Speech errors are extremely
- Morphology (subdivision)
- Phoneme level
- Phonological feature
Dell (1968) identifies three levels of speech errors, particularly slips of the
tongue; sounds errors, morpheme errors, and word errors. Sounds errors are
The first eight of the following belong to the conversational feature. The
slips of the tongue mentioned later is what commonly categorized as speech error:
1. Silent pause
Silent pause is a period of no speech between words speed of talking is
almost entirely determined by the amount of such pausing. People who peak
slowly hesitate a lot, and when they speed up their rat of words. They do it by
eliminating the pauses, not by shortening the words. The silent pauses, the
speakers no speech at all, they just keep silent between their words. For example:
2. Filled pause
Filled pause is a gap filled by ah, uh, mm, or the like. The fast speakers are
fluent because they do not hesitate much, and slow speaker are not fluent because
they hesitate a great deal in filled pause. The slow speakers filled their pauses by
For example:
The most frequent silent pauses (//) in twelve types of constituents are:
house
home.
if those utterances have memorized before, or those utterances have prepared well,
because usually 30-50 % utterances are signed by pauses. For example: an actress
or actors have memorized the scripts and exercised a certain dialog, there will be
What all this evidence suggests is that there are three major points at
phrase is to fit next into the next skeleton. The stopping place is typically
3. Before the first content word within a constituent. This is a point after
constituent being executed, but before they have planned the precise words
to fill it out. This stopping place, like the previous kind, gives speakers
3. Repeats
intended to utter something, yet they make speech error. They make speech error.
For example:
- in / in houses
- in / in big houses
- in / in manor houses
May / may go
In / in going home
Fully 89 percent of all words repeated were function words, like articles
(the / the neighbor), prepositions (in / in the garden), conjunctions (and/ and the
neighbor): and pronouns (he/ he didn’t go). On the other hand, most of the words
corrected in the false starts were content words: nouns (the man/ the woman),
adjective (the silvery/ the shiny try), verbs (can be seen /can be viewed), or
speakers have speech errors, they make corrections of a word but they do not
repeat of one or more words before the corrected word. They continue saying/
speaking the next word without repeating the wrong word (Clark, 1977:264).
For example:
one or more words before the corrected word. When the speaker realized that they
make speech errors, they make correction of their words. They make repetitions of
For example:
The category called corrections is like false starts, except that they contain
correction.
What was striking, however, was what when contents words were
corrected, the speaker usually (77 percent of the time) retraced one or more words
before them, as in the silvery/ the shiny tray, where the is repeated along with the
replacement word shiny. In the race cases when function words were corrected,
the speaker usually(78 percents of the time) did not retraced any of the previous
words, as in under / behind the sofa, where under is corrected to behind without
any retracing.
The speech errors called corrections prove much the same point. These
errors consist of a “correction phrase”, such as I mean, that is, or well, followed
by the “corrected words”, the words to replace what was said earlier.
Repeats, false starts, and correction, therefore, provide excellent evidence
that speaker consider the constituent a basic unit of execution. They attempt, to
the best of their ability, to execute constituents as complete wholes. When for
some reason they do stop, make a false start, or correct themselves, they tend to
retraced false start. What these three patterns have in common is that the speaker,
after all corrections and hesitations, executes the whole constituent those dirty
with it, but he goes back and executes the constituent from the very beginning.
6. Corrections
There are many reasons why a speaker may stop in mid sentence. They
may forget something that they want to say: they may be searching for just the
right word: or they may be selecting which of several examples they could
mention. English has two remarkable devices by which speakers can signal just
why they are stopping, the interjection (oh, ah, well, say, etc.) and the correction
(I mean, that is, well, etc.). Moreover, these two devices provide further evidence
For example:
themselves. Dubois (in Clark and Clark, 1977: 270) has noted that there are some
correction phrases, namely that is , or rather, I mean, and well which signal
to provide a word that is slightly closer to what the speaker means to say. In 3, I
mean is used for correcting an in and out mistake in wording, one that would have
left the utterance with significantly wrong meaning. And in 4, well is used to
soften a claim the speaker decides is too excessive. These correction phrases are
well , and 3 becomes nonsense with I mean replaced by well speakers, then, know
not only when they have made a mistake, but what kind of mistake it is, and they
use these correction phrase to “explain” why they are making the correction.
correction, speakers replace certain old words with new ones, indicating that the
old words had been misplanned. Typically, this means correcting one word, but
sometimes more than one. When more than one word is changed, the words
almost invariably belong to a single constituent, not to parts of two successive but
also the unit of planning. So planning and execution, at the level of the actual
while planning the next. When planning is disrupted or needs correcting, they still
try to execute the constituent as a whole, and this often means retracing their
steps. What is perhaps most extra ordinary is that speakers, at some level of
consciousness, know the word choices and correction they are making, for they
often signal their reason for them to listener. These interjections and correction
phrases are comments on why speakers happened to say what they said and are
not part of the direct message it self. Speakers know a good deal about how they
7. Interjection
Interjections, like hesitation pauses, indicate that speakers have had to stop
to think about what are going to say. They select a particular interjection to signal
why they have had to stop. The interjections oh, well, and say are illustrated at the
following sentences:
Say: exemplification
In 1, “oh” indicates the speaker has stopped to pick out carrots as just one
of several possibilities he could mention. In 2, “ah” indicates that the speaker had
forgotten and he just managed to remember what it was that John would like. In 3,
the well indicates that the speaker thinks that carrots are only an approximate
description of what John would like. In 4, the say indicates that the speaker is
giving an example of John would like. In other instances, say could mean instead
A silent pause in (a) and the filled pause in (b) lead to still other
interpretations of why the speaker has stopped, but these are not nearly so specific
as the other interjections. Thus speakers use interjections when they seem it
important to let the listener know just why they are pausing (Clark, 1977:270).
8. Stutters
Chaer (2003: 153) states that stutters is speeches or utterances that are
choked again, after several seconds the speaker can finish then utterances that
he/she wants to say (intended utterances). The speaker can utter the first syllable
repeatedly but difficult to continue the next syllable so he/she only say the first
For example:
by the listener: This includes such things as sound and word fears, situational
fears, anxiety, tension, shame, and a feeling of “loss of control” during speech.
The emotional state of the individual who stutters in response to the stuttering
That is said to have occurred when the speakers actual utterance differs in
some way from the intended utterance. This is the kind of speech errors that we
tongue”. Slips of the tongue occur within and across word boundaries, but
have occurred when the speaker’s actual utterance differs in some way from the
All two examples above are seems right, but actually wrong. For the first
example, the right one is doesn’t or does not, not don’t, due it is the third person.
For the second example, the right one is it means, not its mean. Both examples are
Freud was the first person to pay serious attention about these slips of the
tongue as psychological data. He gave such slips the more scientific sounding
Freud (in Carroll, 1985:255) proposed that when some body misspeaks, it is
slips of the tongue were never accidents that they always revealed some
this professor’s slip of the tongue arouse because of some suppressed impulse or
intention on the part of professor. In Freud’s mind, this verbal slip could not have
or impulse which they made the cornerstone of all slips of the tongue could
operate at three different levels. On one the suppression could be conscious and
who made the slip but was not intended beforehand, and at the deepest level the
person absolutely denies the suppression. For Freudians, it really doesn’t matter
what level the person who has made a slip of the tongue is operating at. For them
in all cases the slip is the result of the conflict between two forces-the underlying
In other hand, slip of the tongue has different definition. According to Dell,
(2005) who states that Freudian slips do not exist but rather are related to the
words when people with aphasia speak, they make many errors.
2. 2. 2 Types of Slips of the Tongue
1. Anticipations
segment. They differ from shifts in that the segment that intrudes on another also
remains in its correct location and thus is used twice (Carroll, 1986:254).
For examples:
speaker intended to say take my bike, but said instead bake my bike, “anticipating”
the b at the beginning of bike in his pronunciation of take, (the arrow means “was
mispronounced as”). In this example take is said to be the target word, but bike is
said to be the origin of the error (since that is where the b came from). For
anticipations the tongue-slip comes before the origin. Based on Fromkin, 1973 (in
Clark, 1977:274).
2. Perseverations
For examples:
-“He pulled a pantrum” for the intended utterance “He pulled a tantrum”
-“John gave the goy a ball” for the intended utterance “John gave the boy a ball”
The speaker intended to say” pulled a tantrum”, but he said instead “pulled
a pantrum” the speaker has perseveration the p at the beginning of “pulled” in his
and “tantrum” is said to be the origin of the error since that is where the “p” of
“pulled “ came after the origin (‘tantrum’ became ’pantrum’)(an earlier segment
3. Reversals/exchanges
For reversals, two segments are interchanged, and so the origin of one
error is the target for the other, and vice versa. These errors are also known as
For example:
-“Fats and Kodor” for the intended utterance “Katz and Fodor”
-“Fancy getting your model remosed” for the intended utterance “getting your
nose remodeled”
exchange)
4. Blends
Blend have two target words, here grizzly and ghastly, which the speaker
“blends” together by taking the first half of one and the second half of other
(Carroll, 1986:254). Blends the speaker leaves out a short stretch of speech
one word is being considered and the two intended items “fuse” or “blend” into a
single item.
For examples:
That child is looking to be “spaddled”. The word “spaddled here is from the word
5. Shifts/Misderivations
Shift is one speech segment disappears from its appropriate location and
appears somewhere else (Taylor, 1990:03). According to Fromkin 1973 (in Clark,
1977:274) shifts is the speaker somehow attaches the wrong suffix or prefix to the
word.
For examples:
hit it).
example:
1.) “I had forgot aboutten it”, for the intended word “I had forgotten about
it”.
2.) “She have many time”, for the intended word “She has many time”.
6. Substitutions
from previously described slips in that the source of the intrusion may not be in
the sentence.
For examples:
-Before the place opens. (The right and the more suitable sentence is “before the
place close”)
-“At low speeds it’s too light”, (The right and the more suitable sentence is “at
Fromklin (in Clark, 1977:274) states that in word substitutions, the speaker
Slips of the tongue also tell us a great deal about the structure and
suitable:
2. You have too many irons the fire and You have too many irons in the
smoke
7. Additions
The speaker intended to utter the intended utterance; occasionally he/she adds
For example:
8. Deletions
Deletion is whereas leave something out. The speaker wanted to utter the
intended sentences, yet incidentally he/she leaved out linguistic material. It can be
utterance.
For example:
-I’ll just get up and mutter intelligibly (unintelligibly).
There are types of errors occur with a number of different linguistic units.
In some cases, a single phoneme is added, deleted, or moved, but at other times it
even phrases. As a general rule, errors tend to occur at only one linguistic level
per utterance. That is, when a person clearly says the wrong word, as in
The articulator program must deal in at least phonetic segments, since they
those units, then phonetic segments could not be interchanged as parts of those
d. David, feed the pooch, that is uttered “David, food the peach”
In each case there are two segments interchanged: [r] and [w] in a, [I] and [h]
in [b], [t] and [s] in c, [i] and [u] in d, and [r] and [I] in e. From a alone we might
think that the final product had to consist of genuine. English words: however that
isn’t true in general, although there is some tendency in this direction (Barrs,
Motley, and Mackay, 1975). The segments interchanged can be initial consonants,
doubt that phonetic segments are available for switching in the articulator
program.
segment is divided “vertically” into distinctive features (like voicing, nasality, and
stridency). There are many striking examples of tongue-slips that indicate that the
articulator program deals with distinctive features too. Consider the following
- Derry and Chulia, for the intended utterance Terry and Julia
Here what has been reversed are not two intact segments, [t] and [j], but rather
only the voicing of the two segments, [-voice] and [+voice]. Originally, [t] is
voiceless and [j] is voiced. In the reversal, [t] is voiced to become [d], and [j] is
deprived of its voicing to become [c]. In all other respects the two consonants
- Glear plue sky, for the intended utterance Clear blue sky
and reversed as well. Thus, as Fromkin argue, the articulator program must have
2. Syllables
The syllable is the next obvious unit. Reversals of segments almost always
take place between the “homologues” parts of two syllables. The first consonant
of one syllable gets interchanged with the first, not final, consonant of another,
In both examples the two segments that reverse are first in the syllable (where
the syllables are separated by hyphens). In all the reversals given earlier, the
segments reversed were also of homologues pats of syllables. The syllable must
therefore be part of the articulator program, for it specifies which segments can be
3. Larger Units
- A purse for every lighter, for the intended sentence a lighter for every
purse.
- Dinner is being served at wine, for the intended sentence Wine is being
served at dinner.
So, the articulator program deals at least in words. But as Fromkin (1971) has
argued, it must handle larger units as well. For gas and tank to have been reversed
in the first example, they must both have been present in the articulator program
at the time of reversal. What were there were the rudiments of tank of gas, a
examples shows, the origin and target words are almost invariably in the same
constituent, usually both stressed, and within six or seven words of each other.
The general conclusion, then, is that the articulator program handles constituents
no more than six or seven words in length. This conclusion that constituents of
speaker build up a general structure for the discourse, form a skeleton for the
constituent. In speaking people take already formulated plan and execute them.
But not all goes well in everyday speech. In practice they have fundamental
problems. First, they have formulated their plans fully before they begin their
execution. For this reason they often speak in fast and start and make variety of
speech errors. Second, in final preparation for execution, they must build an
“articulator program”, a plan in working memory that tells the articulator muscles
what to do them.
Clark and Clark (1977) say that planning takes time and more time on
some occasions than others. The more difficult the planning, the more time it
should take and the more likely speech itself will be disrupted. On speech errors,
planning can become from cognitive reasons, anxiety, and social reasons.
1. Cognitive Difficulty
in Clark and Clark (1977) conducted a study in which people were asked to
and dominance”. Some of these are concrete objects (car and kaleidoscope) and
others are abstract (joy and dominance). It took people longer to produce the first
word of the sentence from an abstract than from the concrete one. It took them
longer to develop a sentence skeleton for an abstract topic –to think of anything to
say at all. At the level of word selection, hesitation should appear when the
2. Situational Anxiety
talk about topics that we are anxious about, we tend to produce more silent pauses
and certain other speech errors. One possibility is that anxiety disrupts the
planning and execution processes generally. Speaker becomes tense and their
planning and execution become less efficient. Another possibility is that what
people talk about when they are anxious is simply more difficult cognitively. It
may be very difficult to verbalize the abstract anxiety states they want to express
and they spend more time planning, groping, for just the right words. Under this
alternative anxiety, pauses have the same source as the pauses of any other
3. Social Factors
The last factor which influences slips of the tongue is the social factors.
Under the pressure of conversations, speaker must make clear whether they still
have something to say or they are finished. Not all speakers are alike in the speech
errors they produce. As Maclay and Osgood (in Clark and Clark:159) found that
some people consistently go to Uh route, with more silent than silent pauses,
while others go their silent way, with more silent than filled pauses. Some prefer
repeats to false starts, while others prefer false starts to repeats. Each of us
apparently has a style, a small battery of strategies for overcoming our limited
ability to plan and execute at the same time. Some are simply more fluent than
others.
Wirawan (in Harian Seputar Indonesia No. 315/ I Sunday 14th May 2006)
explains that speech errors can be caused by low self confidence and the
2. 5 Previous Study
The same study and research about slips of the tongue and speech errors had
been conducted by Warren (1986). He has observed about slips of the tongue in
very young children. His research has investigated the difference in the frequency
with which adults and young children make slips of the tongue. The slips analyzed
were taken from two corpora of speech. The first consist of the speech of one
child in interaction with her mother, the second corpus consist of the speech of
eight children in interaction with their teacher. The result suggests that young
children make significantly fewer slips than do adults. This finding is consistent
make fewer slips because they are less inclined to suppress and repress ideas and
impulses.
Jeager (1995) has observed kid’s slip in Young Children’s Slips of The
Tongue as Evidence for Language Development. Once children start making slips
of the tongue, usually from about 18 months of age, they show nearly the same
language behavior as adults. We all laugh when young children make speech
errors “her run is nosing” instead of “her nose is running” or when an impatient
three-year-old waiting for his mother to finish a task says, “Mom, when are you
Jeager collected a total of 1300 slips of the tongue from three children and
from 35 other children she observed in a day-care-center. All of the children were
between the ages of 18 months and 6 years when slips were collected.
She compared the slips of the tongue she recorded from the children with
the types of speech errors made by adults and found that children make almost the
same types and proportions of slips as adults. The most common errors in both
Poulisse (1999) also conducted a research on slips of the tongue under the
title “Slips of the Tongue: Speech Errors in First and Second Language
Production”. Poulisse observed that one would readily anticipate a much higher
occurrence of slips in L2. Most people would guess twice as many or perhaps
even five times as many slips inL2. His guess was around 10 times more slips in
L2 than in L1. Poulisses’s result, however, outdo the “guesstimate” by far. Two
L2 slip of the tongue in the data. Only slips identified as such by both researchers
accident often mixes his two languages even though they excel at the same time in
separating the two systems. Many of the L2 slips are L1 based, hence the
(2005). She focused on the study of slips of the tongue as part of speech errors.
She conducted the research since May 16-16 June 2005. The news taken as the
data was news about general election in Indonesia. After conducting the research,
she found many utterances that can be categorized as slips of the tongue. She
classified the slips of the tongue which were found in Liputan 6 SCTV into six
substitutions. While the other two kinds of slips of the tongue, that is
perseveration, and exchange were not found in Liputan 6 SCTV. However, the
about slips of the tongue deal with young children, first and second language
acquisition and have never dealt with English as a foreign language. Therefore,
the focus on slips of the tongue in English as a foreign language is important to be
researched.
CHAPTER III
RESEARCH METHOD
This chapter discusses the method of the research, it relates to the research
design, sources of data, research instrument, data collection, and data analysis
3. 1 Research Design
collecting the data. Ary (1972: 295) states that the descriptive research studies are
and are directed toward determining the nature of a situation as it exists at the
because its purpose is to describe the slips of the tongue in the speaking class of
3. 2 Source of Data
The data of this research are taken from the utterance produced by the
speaking class. This research is done in third semester speaking class since
September till November 2007, and the purpose of this research is to describe the
kinds of slips of the tongue that happened and the kinds of slips of the tongue
most happened in the speaking class of English Letters and Language Department
is the researcher himself. He is the main instrument for collecting and analyzing
the data. In addition, taking a note was also needed in this study because it helped
3. 4 Data Collection
To get the original and valid data, the researcher used the following steps:
Firstly, the researcher followed the speaking class of English Letters and
Language Department Students of UIN Malang and observed every word uttered
by the students. Secondly, while observing, he also recorded all utterances that
were spoken by the students. Taking note was also done to record context of
the students. Fourthly, the researcher selected the utterances that are related to the
types of slips of the tongue. Finally, the researcher arranged the data which are
3. 5 Data Analysis
The researcher used some steps in analyzing the data. Firstly, the
researcher identifies and arranged the data which belong to eight types of slips of
the tongue. Secondly, he described and discussed the findings by relating to the
In this chapter, the finding and discussion are presented in two sections,
the first is data presentation and analysis, and the second is discussion.
These data were taken from several utterances of the English Letters and
which speech errors were found. These data was taken from 15th September 2007
until 24th November 2007. There are 27 data related to the types of slips of the
( 1 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 15th September 2007 Time : 07.00 – 08.10 am
student……………………
The word “ students “ belongs to slip of the tongue, because the student
who is standing in front of the class is only one. In this case, the speaker added an
alphabet “ s “ in the word “ student “ till became “ students “. The right one of
this word should be “ student “. This type of slip refers to the seventh type of slips
( 2 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 15th September 2007 Time : 07.00 – 08.10
am
According to me he is a handsome boy, tall, clean, have the dark hair and
he is good I think………………
The word “ have “ belongs to slip of the tongue. On the text above, the
word “ have “ refers to “ he “. The right one should be “ has “ following the third
person singular. This type of slip refers to the fifth type of slips of the tongue that
is shifts or misderivations.
( 3 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 15th September 2007 Time : 07.00 – 08.10 am
The word “ is “ should be replaced by “ has “, because the word “ white face
skin” is the possessive of “ he “. This type of slip refers to the fifth kind of slips of
the tongue that is shifts/misderivations. For the second word “ black “, the speaker
intended to say “ brown” but she said “ black”. This type of slip refers to the
( 4 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 15th September 2007 Time : 07.00 – 08.10 am
For the first time I see, I think he is a good boy, a silenter no much talking,
handsome…………………
The word “ silenter “ belongs to slip of the tongue. The speaker said it for
the intended word a person who keeps silent and this is wrong in suffix. The right
word is “ silencer ”. This kind of slip refers to the fifth type of slips of the tongue
( 5 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 15th September 2007 Time : 07.00 – 08.10 am
and………………….
The word “ enough handsome “ belongs to slip of the tongue. In this word,
two segments are interchanged and this is wrong (words exchange). The right
word should be “ handsome enough “. This kind of slip refers to the third kinds of
( 6 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 29th September 2007 Time : 07.00 – 08.10 am
The context of this utterance happened when the teacher explained about
some topics of discussion and asked the student to give comment and suggestion.
The word “ discussions “ belongs to slip of the tongue. In this case, the
the singular form. It is signed by the word “ a small “ which should be followed
by “ discussion”. This kind of slip refers to the seventh type of slips of the
( 7 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 07.40 – 07.50 am
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ there are ” belongs to slip of the tongue. There is only one
garden besides B hall, then, the right word should be “ there is “. This kind of slip
refers to the fifth type of slips of the tongue that is shifts or misderivations.
( 8 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 07.40 – 07.50 am
asked the students to make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The
students were asked to go out for ten minutes to look for the topic to be presented.
The word “ beautiful ” belongs to slip of the tongue. The speaker said it
for the intended word “ bad “. The right one of this word should be “ bad ”,
because the garden is not clean. This kind of slip refers to the sixth type of slips of
( 9 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 07.40 – 07.50 am
it……………….
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ easy enoughly “ belongs to slip of the tongue. In this case, the
speaker added the suffix “ ly “ in the word “ enough “ which is incorrect. The
right word should be “ it is easy enough “. This type of slip refers to the seventh
( 10 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 07.40 – 07.50 am
In the garden, there are many flowers and the small coconut tree
……………..
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ small coconut tree “ belongs to slip of the tongue. The speaker
said it for the intended word “ palm tree ”. Then, the right one of this word should
be “ small palm tree “. This type of slip refers to the sixth type of slips of the
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ Its mean” belongs to slip of the tongue. In this word, one
segment disappears from its appropriate location and appears somewhere else,
that is between the word “ its “ and the word “ mean “. The right one of this word
should be “ it means “. This type of slip refers to the fifth type of slips of the
( 12 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 07.50 – 08.00 am
campus……..………………..
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ a old “ belongs to slip of the tongue. In this case, the speaker
attaches the wrong article “ a “ in the word “ old “. The article “ a “ is must be
consonant alphabet after and “ an “ is for the vocal alphabet after. Then, the right
one of this word should be “ an old “. This kind of slip refers to the fifth type of
( 13 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 07.50 – 08.00 am
together……………………….
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ manwoman “ belongs to slip of the tongue. The word “ man “
and “woman “ cannot blended together. The right word, they should be separated
by a conjunction “and”, “ man and woman “. This kind of slip refers to the fourth
( 14 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 07.50 – 08.00 am
…………………..
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ has “ belongs to slip of the tongue. The word “ they “ is not
third person singular, then the right word should be “ have “. This type of slip
refers to the fifth type of slips of the tongue that is shifts/ misderivations.
( 15 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 07.50 – 08.00 am
I known that they are is not actually a poor man, but they only
pretend…………………………
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
slips of the tongue. The word “ I known “ is leaves something out and incorrect
which should be “ I have known “. This type of slip refers to eighth type of slips
of the tongue that is deletions. For the word “ is “ and “ a “, both refer to the
seventh type of slips of the tongue that is additions. In this case, the speaker added
the word “ is “ and “ a “ after the word “ they are “ which show plural. The right
I felt uncomfortable recent days in this campus caused the dormitory good
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ good “ belongs to slip of the tongue. In this case, the speaker
intended to say “ bad “ for the word “ good ”, because it impossible for her to fell
view, she felt uncomfortable. According to the theory, this type of slip refers to
( 17 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 08.00 – 08.10 am
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ is “ belongs to slip of the tongue. In this case, one segment
disappears from its appropriate location. Because of clothes and underwear are
plural, the right word uses “ are “. This type of slip refers to the fifth type of slips
( 18 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 08.00 – 08.10 am
campus………………….
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ this “ belongs to slip of the tongue. Which should be “ these “,
referring to some dormitories in the campus. This kind of slip refers to the sixth
type of slips of the tongue that is substitutions. Substitutions occurs when one
( 19 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 08.00 – 08.10 am
And also with the environment dormitory which is very unclean and
uncomfortable……………………
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
two segments are interchanged ( words exchange ). The right one of this word
should be “ dormitory environment “. This kind of slip refers to the third kind
( 20 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 08.00 – 08.10 am
before……………………
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ listens “ belongs to slip of the tongue. In this case, the speaker
added an alphabet “ s “ in the word “ listen“ which is wrong in the use of present
tense. This kind of slip refers to the seventh type of slips of the tongue that is
additions.
( 21 ) Day and Date : Saturday, 5th October 2007 Time : 08.00 – 08.10 am
The context of this utterance is when the teacher asked the students to
make a group discussion that consists of three persons. The students were asked to
The word “ unseen “ belongs to slip of the tongue. This word is less
understandable which should be “ unseen able “. This word leaves something out,
then this kind of slip refers to the eighth type of slips of the tongue that is
deletions.
( 22) Day and Date : Saturday, 10th November 2007 Time : 08.03- 08.15 am
I think the criteria which I think is not same with what is you, what in
The context of this sentence happened when the teacher asked the students
to come in front of the class to tell and explain about their each life partner’s
criteria. The word “ is “ and “ what is you “ belong to slips of the tongue.
The word “ criteria “ is plural, then, the right pair should be “ are “. This type
of slip refers to the fifth type of slips of the tongue that is shifts or misderivations.
For the word “ what is “, the speaker added this word to the word “ you “
which is unnecessary. This type of slip refers to the seventh type of slips of the
The context of this sentence happened when the teacher asked the students
to come in front of the class to tell and explain about their each life partner’s
criteria.
The word “ an handsome “ belongs to slip of the tongue. In this case, the
speaker used the article “ an “ in the word “ handsome “ which is incorrect. The
correct article is “ a “. This kind of slip refers to the fifth type of slips of the
( 24) Day and Date : Saturday, 10th November 2007 Time : 07. 32 – 07.43 am
The context of this sentence happened when the teacher asked the students
to come in front of the class to tell and explain about their each life partner’s
criteria. The word “ it “ belongs to slip of the tongue. “. In this case, the
speaker used the word “ it “ that refers to “ he / she “. This is incorrect and the
right one should be “ from her / his physical attraction “. This type of slip
refers to the fifth type of slips of the tongue that is shifts or misderivations.
( 25) Day and Date : Saturday, 10th November 2007 Time : 07. 44 – 07.53 am
to come in front of the class to tell and explain about their each life partner’s
criteria.
The word “ carefuls “ belongs to slip of the tongue. In this case, the
speaker added an alphabet “ s “ in the word “ careful “. The right word should be
“ careful “. This type of slip refers to the seventh type of slips of the tongue that is
addition.
( 26) Day and Date : Saturday, 10th November 2007 Time : 07. 27 – 07.32 am
The context of this sentence happened when the teacher asked the students
to come in front of the class to tell and explain about their each life partner’s
criteria.
The word “ beauty “ belongs to slip of the tongue. The speaker intended to
say “ beautiful “, but he leaves something out. This type of slip refers to the eighth
( 27) Day and Date : Saturday, 10th November 2007 Time : 07. 20 – 07.27 am
see…………….……….
The context of this sentence happened when the teacher asked the
students to come in front of the class to tell and explain about their each life
partner’s criteria.
The word “ thinking “ belongs to slip of the tongue. In this case, the
speaker added the suffix “ ing “ in the word “think “. The right one is “ as what we
think “. This type of slip refers to the seventh type of slips of the tongue that is
additions.
4.2 Discussion
This section elaborates the discussion on the findings which have been
presented in the previous section. The slips of the tongue found in the data are
deletions. This research only found 6 types from 8 types of slips of the tongue,
interchanged, and so the origin of one error is the target for the other, and vice
versa. Carroll (1986:254) says that exchanges are, in effect, double shifts, in
Based on the findings, there are 2 data related to reversals/exchanges. Those are:
In this research, the two segments interchanged are between adjective and
2. Blends
one word is being considered and the two intended items “fuse” or “blend” into a
single item. He also said that blends have two target words, here grizzly and
ghastly, which the speaker “blends” together by taking the first half of one and the
second half of other (Carroll, 1986:254). Taylor (1990:103) said that blends the
Based on the research above, the researcher found 1 data related to blends. Those
are:
only between noun and noun ( manwoman ), the right word should be “ man and
woman “.
3. Shifts/ Misderivations
Shift is one speech segment disappears from its appropriate location and
appears somewhere else (Taylor, 1990:03). Fromkin 1973 (in Clark, 1977:274)
says that shift is the speaker somehow attaches the wrong suffix or prefix to the
word.
( Data 2 )
8. The clothes and underwear is hang on the window The clothes and
9. The criteria which I think is not same The criteria which I think are
( Data 27 )
and appears somewhere else ( it’s mean ) and wrong in attaching word or what we
call as morpheme shifts (He is a handsome boy, tall, clean, have the dark hair, He
is white face skin, there are a secret garden, they has strategies, the clothes and
underwear is hang on the window, the criteria which I think is not same and from
it physical attraction ).
4. Substitutions
differs from previously described slips in that the source of the intrusion may not
be in the sentence.
For examples:
- Before the place opens. (The right and the more suitable sentence is “before the
place close”).
Fromklin (in Clark, 1977:274) states that in word substitutions, the speaker
is black for the intended word his hand is brown/dark color and small coconut
tree for the intended word small palm tree ) and adjective substitutions ( it
beautiful and unclean around for the intended word it bad and unclean around,
this dormitory for the intended word these dormitory and dormitory good view for
5. Additions
The speaker intended to utter the intended utterance; occasionally he/she adds
4. they are is not actually a poor man they are not actually poor man
( Data 17 )
and as what we thinking), conjunction additions ( they are is not actually and with
what is you ), preposition addition ( a poor man ) and phoneme additions ( a calm
6. Deletions
Deletion is whereas leave something out. The speaker wanted to utter the
intended sentences, yet incidentally he/she leaved out linguistic material. It can be
utterance.
In this research, deletions are in noun deletion ( I known, the right word
should be I have known ) and adjective deletions ( unseen for the understandable
word unseen able and beauty for the intended word beautiful ).
Based on the result analysis from September till November 2007, the case
(3 data), and deletions (1 data). Then, for the general conclusion, most of case of
slips of the tongue happened in the speaking class of English Letters and
blends ( 1 data ).
CHAPTER V
Conclusion and Suggestion
After obtaining and analyzing the data in the previous chapter, the writer
presents the conclusion and suggestion as the last part of this writing. The
is intended to give information to the next researchers who are interested in doing
5.1 Conclusion
In line with the result of analysis, the conclusion of the research can be
formulated as follows:
1. This research found 6 types from 8 types of slips of the tongue, they are:
deletions. Anticipations and perseverations were not found in this speaking class
2. Most case of slips of the tongue happened in the speaking class of English
Firstly, because of the case of slips of the tongue that most happened in the
Secondly, for the other researchers who will do research on the same field,
the result of this research may also be useful as a reference for the study of slips
of the tongue.
At last, the researcher suggests the next researcher who will do the research
in the same field of study to analyze different forms using different theory, so that
[Link]
[Link]
[Link]
usuri&meta=
[Link]
=3746727&dopt=Abstract
[Link]
Hatch. 2002. Doing Qualitative Research in Education Settings. New York: State
University of New York Press.
[Link]/TESL-EJ/ej16/[Link]
[Link]/[Link]
4. For the first time I see, I For the first time I see, I Shifts/
Misderivations
think he is a good boy, think he is a good boy,
a silenter no much a silencer no much
talking, handsome talking, handsome
10. In the garden, there are In the garden, there are Substitutions
many flowers and the many flowers and the
small coconut tree small palm tree
13. Usually the beggar are Usually the beggar are Blends
man, woman, or both man, woman, or both
are manwoman are man and woman
together together
19. And also with the And also with the Reversals/
Exchanges
environment dormitory dormitory environment
which is very unclean which is very unclean
and uncomfortable and uncomfortable
20. I don’t know why they I don’t know why they Additions
do not listens our do not listen our
aspiration before aspiration before
The undersigned,
Certify that the thesis I wrote to fulfill the requirement for the degree of
Humanities and Culture, The State Islamic University of Malang entitled " A
bibliography. Due to this fact, I am the only person responsible for the thesis if
Djarot Karisman
NIM. 03320045
CURRICULUM VITAE
A. IDENTITY
Reg. No : 03320045
Place : Gresik
Sex : Male
Religion : Islam
Nationality : Indonesia
B. EDUCATION
Motto :
While slips of the tongue have not provided significant insights into how languages change over time, they offer considerable information about language variability and the dynamic nature of speech production. By analyzing these errors, linguists can gain clues about the underlying linguistic competence and the real-time processes involved in language use. They may also reveal patterns that could eventually lead to shifts in accepted language forms or usage, indicating the fluid boundaries of language rules and conventions .
Teachers can benefit from understanding slips of the tongue by gaining insights into the cognitive processes underpinning language production, which can inform instructional strategies. Recognizing these errors allows teachers to better understand the challenges students face in real-time language use, providing targeted interventions to enhance fluency and accuracy. Moreover, analyzing slips of the tongue can help teachers develop students' metalinguistic awareness, improving their ability to self-correct and refine speech output .
Anticipations and perseverations might be absent in certain analyses of slips of the tongue among ESL learners due to the specific linguistic environments and the nature of language instruction they receive. These errors might occur less frequently due to the conscious monitoring ESL learners apply during speech, which helps in avoiding certain types of phonological or syntactic predictions that lead to such errors. Furthermore, the cognitive load and focus on grammatical accuracy might skew error frequencies towards other types, like misderivations and substitutions .
The common types of slips of the tongue identified include reversals/exchanges, blends, shifts/misderivations, substitutions, additions, and deletions. Anticipations and perseverations were not found in the particular study conducted among English learners at UIN Malang. Shifts or misderivations appeared most frequently in the ESL context analyzed, suggesting difficulties in morphological structuring during speech .
The key methodological steps in the research of slips of the tongue include observing the speaking class, recording utterances, transcribing them, and categorizing the errors based on predefined types of slips. These steps ensure data accuracy by capturing a comprehensive and authentic sample of spoken language. The use of multiple data collection methods—direct observation, recording, and transcription—enables the researcher to systematically identify and classify errors, enhancing the validity and reliability of the findings .
According to Poulisse, a person's first language (L1) exerts a considerable influence on slips of the tongue when speaking a second language (L2). This influence results in a higher occurrence of slips in L2, as L1-based structures and patterns interfere with L2 speech production. These L1-induced errors indicate the underlying cognitive links between the two languages, demonstrating how entrenched linguistic frameworks in L1 can affect the learning and production of L2 .
The research on slips of the tongue was conducted in the speaking classes of English Letters and Language Department students at UIN Malang. Its primary objective was to analyze the types and frequency of slips of the tongue occurring in a real-world language learning environment, aiming to provide insights into linguistic processes and errors experienced by ESL learners. It also sought to contribute to the understanding of speech errors in the context of English as a foreign language .
Research on slips of the tongue, particularly in bilingual contexts, indicates that L1 influences L2 speech production significantly, often resulting in a higher frequency of slips in the second language (L2) due to interference from the first language (L1). The studies show that while bilingual speakers are adept at separating their languages, the structural knowledge of L1 can unintentionally affect L2 speech. For example, Poulisse's research demonstrates that L2 slips often outnumber L1 slips, emphasizing the complexity of managing multiple languages and the cognitive processes involved in language acquisition .
Djarot Karisman's research utilized a qualitative design involving direct observation and audio recording in the speaking classes of UIN Malang. By transcribing and analyzing the students' utterances, the research carefully identified and categorized slips of the tongue, excluding intentional errors. The comprehensive methods of data collection—observation, recording, and transcription—and the systematic approach to categorizing slips ensured the validity and reliability of the findings, adhering to the criteria of qualitative descriptive research .
Slips of the tongue reveal information about both the structure of language and repressed thoughts, as analyzed by Sigmund Freud. These unintentional errors in speech can provide insight into the subconscious thoughts of the speaker and the linguistic knowledge they possess. Freud's analysis suggests that the slips are windows into the speaker's hidden thoughts and feelings, uncovering details about how they perceive language and express internal conflicts .