Manresa School
Candida Ma. St. BF Homes Paranaque City
EFFECTIVENESS OF STARCH FROM WATER CHESTNUT (ELEOCHARIS DULCIS)
AS A SOURCE OF BIOPLASTIC
A Science Investigatory Research Presented to the
Science Department
In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the
Junior High School
Gabrielle Althea E. Ranario
Sophia Franzine F. Deblois
Maria Ysabella L. Alcalde
Miguel E. Bertoso
March 2019
i
APPROVAL SHEET
This Science investigatory research entitled “EFFECTIVENESS OF STARCH
FROM WATER CHESTNUT (ELEOCHARIS DULCIS) AS A SOURCE OF
BIOPLASTIC”, prepared and submitted by Maria Ysabella L. Alcalde, Miguel E. Bertoso,
Sophia Franzine F. Deblois, and Gabrielle Althea E. Ranario, in partial fulfillment of the
requirements in Science 9, has been examined and is recommended for acceptance
and approval for oral examination.
MS. JAIZA C. CIA
Research Adviser
______________________________________________________________________
Approved by the Committee on oral examination on March 21, 2019.
MRS. CRISANDREA H. CONCEPCION MS. MARYKNOLL O. TIANIA
Chairwoman Member
______________________________________________________________________
Accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements in Science 9
MRS. JOSEPHINE C. MIDEL
JHS Science Coordinator
MS. CONCEPCION B. BAYAIS MS. AIDA A. GOMEZ
JHS Asst. Principal Principal
ii
Abstract
Recently, plastics had been causing severe damage to life due to its harmful nature. It was frequently
suggested that Bioplastics are an eco-friendly alternative to the situation. As such, many bioplastic that
are starch based are being created in the present day. Water Chestnuts ( Eleocharis Dulcis) are plants
that grow in the marshes and are found to be native in the Philippines. It contains starch that can be
potentially turned into a bioplastic. In this study, the potential of starch extracted from Water Chestnuts to
form an effective bioplastic was investigated. The study investigated if starch extracted from Water
Chestnuts can be transformed into a bioplastic that is capable of fast decomposition and if it is capable of
being an effective container. The starch was first tested for its ability to decompose as a bioplastic. A
bioplastic made from 3-g starch, 20-ml water, 2.5-ml glycerol, and 2-ml vinegar was made in order to test
its decomposition. It was buried for 10 days and was found to have decomposed. Another batch was
made with the same ingredients was made in order to teste its effectivity as a container. It was made with
45-ml water, 9-ml vinegar, 21-g Starch, and 6-ml glycerol. It was tested for its ability to contain water and
to survive a height fall and it passed both tests. The results showed that the starch extracted from Water
Chestnuts is capable of producing an effective bioplastic. This is achieved through its ability for
decomposition and its ability to be an effective container through the prevention of fluid leaks and external
force.
Acknowledgement
The researchers would like to acknowledge the help of our research adviser, Ms. Jaiza Cia, in her
editing and proof reading of this research. Her corrections are of help to the advancement of this
research. The researchers would also like to thank the various parents of the researchers for their
suggestions in the research. The researchers would also like to thank the class of Grade 9 Fortitude SY
2018-2019 for their comments and encouragement in this research. Lastly, the researchers would like to
thank the Almighty God who had blessed them in times when the study didn’t seem possible.
iii
iv
CHAPTER 1: BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY
I. Introduction
Plastic materials are widely used around the world and they are one of the major
cause of environmental problems in our planet. Plastic materials cause a significant
amount of damage to the world’s oceans. It is said that 8 Million tonnes of plastic ends
up in the world’s oceans every year (Johnston, 2017). Sperm Whales and other species
also end up as victims of plastic pollution (Stephanis, Gimenez, Carpinelli, and
Canadas, 2013). Plastic wreaks havoc on the ecological structure of the world’s oceans,
takes the lives of many species, and contributes to the worsening impact of climate
change or global warming. Plastics are so durable that it could take hundreds of years
before it disintegrates. Other types of plastic can even last forever. Burning plastic
releases harmful chemicals such as carbon dioxide which can contribute to global
warming. Today, many alternatives to plastic have been considered. Among them is the
use of biodegradable plastic or bioplastic. Bioplastic, due to its eco-friendly structure
and impact, is an alternative that can be explored, in order to lessen the impact of
harmful plastics. The use of starch from plants and its products and parts, as
component of biodegradable plastics is an eco-friendly alternative.
Biodegradable plastics or Bioplastics are eco-friendly plastics made from an
organic source or biological substances. Today, 800,000 tons of bioplastic are produced
every year around the world. Bioplastics, made from biological substances, are capable
of decomposition when buried in the ground. To expand and propagate the use of
bioplastic, the researchers propose the use of water chestnut starch as a main
component of bioplastic. An important component of bioplastics are glucose
1
substances. Glucose is classified under carbohydrates. Hence, any starch substance
must have a good amount of carbohydrates in order to make Bioplastics. Water
chestnut is common and planted extensively in the Philippines, making it an attractive
source. In this research, the researchers will use the starch of the Water Chestnut to
make the bioplastic and the researchers will observe the effectivity of water chestnut as
a plastic. Throughout the study, the researchers will use the same process for different
amounts of water chestnut in extracting the starch and producing the bioplastic.
The study seeks to provide an eco-friendly bioplastic alternative to the harmful
everyday plastic. The use of regular plastic and its disposal leads to environmental
damage and ecological destruction. An alternative is the starch from water chestnut,
noted for its amount of carbohydrates (and its potential for glucose) and its availability in
the country. The study wants to prove that bioplastics made from Water Chestnut
starch can be an eco-friendly substitute to harmful regular plastic.
The research will benefit two groups of beneficiaries. The first group are the
farmers and the agriculturalists. Although Water Chestnut is planted in the Philippines, it
is more common in China than in the Philippines. It is not seen as an endemic
Philippine plant despite being indigenous in the country. If Water Chestnut starch can
be used as a component for bioplastic, the Water Chestnut industry will expand and
agriculture will see an increase in trade in Water Chestnut, most favorably for export.
The second group of beneficiary is the environment. Plastic contributes to the death of
many animals and the destruction of the environment, especially after its increased use
in the 21st century. By proving that Water Chestnut can be used for Bioplastics, people
2
can lessen the impact of plastics and contribute to the expansion of the Bioplastic
Market.
II. Statement of the Problem
In the study, the researchers seek to answer the possibility that Bioplastic can be
produced from starch made from Water Chestnut. The researchers also seek to
establish if the bioplastic from Water Chestnut starch is an eco-friendly alternative.
Specifically, the researchers seek to answer the following specific questions:
1. How long did it take for the produced material made primarily from Water
Chestnut Starch to decompose?
2. How much water will the Water Chestnut Bioplastic will be able to contain as a
bio-sauce plate and how high can it survive from a fall?
III. Objectives
The general objective of the study is to research and investigate if starch
extracted from Water Chestnuts can be transformed into an effective and successful
bioplastic. Another objective is to investigate if the production of Water Chestnut starch
based bioplastic is cost-effective, safe and green. These objectives will be the central
focus of the research.
This study’s specific objectives are the following:
1. Design the procedure such that the production of Water Chestnut Starch based
Bioplastic is cost-effective and the ensured decomposition of the end product.
2. Produce a bioplastic that will be as useful, strong, and reliable as plastics.
IV. Hypothesis
3
1. Water Chestnut Starch based Bioplastic cannot be constructed safely, effectively,
and has slow rate of decomposition.
2. The procedure of making Water Chestnut Starch is hard, expensive, and uncommon.
V. Significance of the Study
The study, in summary, will benefit the farmers of the Water Chestnut trade and
the environment. For the farmers and the agriculturalists, a novel use of Water Chestnut
can augment their income which would lead to a better economic condition for them and
as for the environment, this will reduce the use of plastics, expand the bioplastic
industry, and reduce the impact of climate change.
Specifically, this study would be beneficial to the following for the reason stated
herein:
Farmers and agriculturalists. A new use of Water Chestnut with its starch as a
main component of bioplastic can further expand the Water Chestnut trade and improve
the economic situation of the farmers and open a new field of interest in Water
Chestnuts.
Environment. With Water Chestnut starch based bioplastic as an alternative for
harmful plastic, the harmful effects of plastic on the environment could be reduced.
Researchers. It will provide future researchers with more related literature such as
this to help them in future studies and analysis, especially those researchers who are
specifically researching and studying in the field of bioplastics and biodegradable
objects, especially starch based bioplastic.
4
VI. Scope and Delimitations
This research study is generally focused on the effectivity of Water Chestnut
starch as a bioplastic. Specifically, the study covers the effectivity of the said bioplastic,
its status as eco-friendly, cheap, and safe alternative to plastic, and the procedure of
making Water Chestnut starch based bioplastic and its decomposition.
The study shall not cover the creation of new methods of making bioplastic. We
shall be adapting existing methods in making bioplastics that have already been
established in order to make Water Chestnut Starch based bioplastic. The study will
also determine the biodegradability of the bioplastic to see if it can be an eco-friendly
alternative. The durability of the bioplastic will also be tested. The construction for the
Bioplastic will take 3 to 4 months. Lastly, the experiment will be held in the premises of
Manresa School or in the Science Laboratory and Libraries.
VII. Definition of Terms
The following terms are conceptually and operationally defined for better
understanding of the readers.
Biodegradable Plastic/Bioplastic - Natural polymers that are made without
petrochemicals: for example, cellulose based, starch based and natural based
rubber materials. Some are completely biodegradable and require less energy to
produce than synthetic polymers (Bioplastics, n.d.). In this research, we will try to
create a starch based Bioplastic from Water Chestnut.
Carbohydrate - it is any of a large group of organic compounds occurring in
foods and living tissues and including sugars, starch, and cellulose (English
5
Oxford Living Dictionary, n.d.). They contain hydrogen and oxygen in the same
ratio as water (2:1) and typically can be broken down to release energy in the
animal body. In the research, the amount of carbohydrates is vital, as glucose is
classified as a carbohydrate
Glucose - a simple sugar that is an important energy source in living organisms
and is a component of many carbohydrates (Archuleta, 2013). In this study, the
researchers identified glucose as an important component in the formation of
Bioplastics.
Plastic - it is a synthetic material made from a wide range of organic polymers
such as polyethylene, PVC, nylon, etc., that can be molded into shape while soft
and then set into a rigid or slightly elastic form (English Oxford Living Dictionary,
n.d.). Due to its harmful properties, the researchers seek an alternative (which is
Starch based Bioplastic based from Water Chestnuts).
Starch - it is an odorless tasteless white substance occurring widely in plant
tissue and obtained chiefly from cereals and potatoes (English Oxford Living
Dictionary, n.d.). It is a polysaccharide that functions as a carbohydrate store and
is an important constituent of the human diet. In the research, Bioplastic is based
from Starch made from Water Chestnut.
Water Chestnut - a whitish crunchy vegetable used especially in Chinese
cooking that is the peeled and often sliced tuber of a sedge (Eleocharis
dulcis synonym E. tuberosa) native to Asia but widely cultivated elsewhere
(Water Chestnut, n.d.). In this research, Water Chestnuts will be used as the
source of Starch in order to make the Bioplastic.
6
CHAPTER 2: REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES
Plastic causes unwanted damage to the environment every year when thrown as
waste. It affects the world’s oceans and the life that resides in it. It also affects the
atmosphere in the Earth when burned. This study seeks to lessen the effects of plastic
through the production of a certain bioplastic. In this study, the researchers aim to make
a bioplastic made from starch extracted from Water Chestnut. Here, the researchers
also aim to make an effective, and cheap means of production of bioplastic. This is in
order to benefit many sectors of society and to find alternative solutions in solving
problems that is related to plastic. It is also in the interest of the researchers to review
the different characteristics of the variables of the study. With this as the objective of the
study, the researchers will define the following terms in order to enhance the
understanding of concepts and further interest and knowledge in the study:
Water Chestnut
It is known by its scientific name as Eleocharis dulcis. Described as a knobby
edible tuber, the water plant is indigenous to Southeast Asia (Genius Kitchen, n.d.).
Although it is named as a Chestnut, the vegetable is actually planted in the marshes. It
is harvested when its bulb has grown into a brown skinned color. Water Chestnuts are
available all year-round. It is also planted extensively in China and throughout
Southeast Asia (Humanity Development Library 2.0, n.d.). The Water Chestnut contains
carbohydrates that has glucose that can be used to make a bioplastic (Raman, 2018).
7
In this study, the researchers will be extracting starch (a form of carbohydrates) from
Water Chestnut. Once made, the researchers will use the starch to make an effective
and durable bioplastic.
Starch
Carvalho (2013) states that starch is a major carbohydrate that is stored in plants
and are consumed daily by humans. Starch is classified as a biopolymer, specifically a
polysaccharide. Examples of starch are potatoes, pasta, bread, and rice (Carvalho,
2013). It has also seen use in industries unrelated to food or human consumption.
Among the food and non-food related products that uses starch as a core ingredient are
medicines, packaging materials, candies, food thickener, jellies, and eco-friendly
substances such as biofuel and other biopolymers (Blecker and Thitisaksakul, 2014).
Along with its increased use in the 21 st century, researchers has concentrated on starch
as a potential source for renewable energy and other ecological solutions (Arikan and
Ozsoy, 2015). This includes eco-friendly plastics or bioplastics. In this study, the
researchers identified starch as an important component in the development of Water
Chestnut Bioplastic. Here, the researchers will extract starch from Water Chestnut in
order to make the bioplastic.
Glucose
Perkins (2018) defines glucose as a monosaccharide, sugars that cannot be
simplified further, that is in a form of a sugar molecule. It is the basic structure that
forms starch. The primary energy source found in plants and needed by humans and
8
animals, it is found in food with carbohydrates such as pasta or pastries. According to
Gotro (2013), glucose can be utilized to make chemicals that is the basis for bioplastic
(chemicals such as bio-ethylene and bio-polyethylene). In this study, the researchers
identified glucose as the basic molecule that forms starch. Starch, composed of
carbohydrates that are compose of glucose, will be extracted from Water Chestnuts in
order to make an effective bioplastic. Like other bioplastics based from starch, the
glucose will be used to make the basic building blocks of the bioplastic that is based
from starch extracted from Water Chestnut.
Carbohydrate
According to Szalay (2017), carbohydrates are sugars and macronutrients found
in fruits and vegetables, milk, and grain products. The macronutrients are considered as
the main source of energy for the human body. It is found in plants and is consumed
not just by humans but also by milk producing animals. In order to create Bioplastic, it is
necessary to acquire carbohydrates like starch (Floreon, 2014). Examples of
carbohydrates are vegetables, fruits, and dairy products. In this research, starch (from
Water Chestnuts) will be used to create an effective and durable bioplastic.
Biodegradable Plastic/Bioplastic
It is an eco-friendly plastic that is wholly or partly based from an organic biomass
(Creative Mechanisms Staff, 2016). The eco-friendly plastic is known for its
decomposition when buried in the ground. Since it is made from organic matter, it
decomposes fast. Woodford (2018) stated that when simple chemicals are used in
9
creating plastic, it breaks down faster and easier. Hence, organic matter is used to
create bioplastic and this paves the way for faster decomposition. Its biodegradability
makes it an eco-friendly alternative to the usual plastic since it can decompose by itself
in a faster rate when thrown as waste or buried in the ground as this is credited to the
use of matter with simple chemicals like Organic matter. According to Cho (2018),
Bioplastic is being produced as consumer goods such as utensils, containers, bags, and
food packaging. It has seen use in many industries related to the mentioned products.
Bioplastics can also help in reducing the effects of climate change (Floreon, 2014). By
using bioplastic, the use of harmful plastics can be reduced. In the study, the
researchers seek to create a bioplastic based from starch made from Water Chestnut.
In this study, the researchers investigated on the potential of starch from Water
Chestnuts as a bioplastic. From the definitions mentioned from above, the study will be
making an efficient, durable, and cheap bioplastic from starch extracted from Water
Chestnuts. Water Chestnuts have components such as carbohydrates in the form of
starch and glucose that can be utilized to make a bioplastic. Most bioplastics are made
of starch. Because of this, the researchers realized that starch extracted from Water
Chestnuts can be used to make a bioplastic that is durable and effective. This can be
done by transforming the glucose of the starch into basic components essential for
bioplastics. Therefore, it is conclusive that starch from Water Chestnuts can be
transformed to make a bioplastic.
10
REVIEW OF RELATED STUDIES
This study is focused on the potential of the usefulness of Water Chestnut as a
potential source of starch that can be used to make an effective and durable bioplastic.
As such, a study on “Biodegradable Plastic Production from Fruit Waste material and its
sustainable use for Green Applications” is relevant to the topic. It was done by
Yaradoddi et al. (2016). The study was focused on making a bioplastic by converting
banana peel waste into a polymer. The polymer, in turn, was used to make an effective
bioplastic. In the study, it was found that:
1. When buried in the ground and its weight measured daily over a span of 15
days, the weight of the banana peel bioplastic exhibited a constant decrease. It
was inferred by the researchers that the decrease of weight pertains to the
successful decomposition of the banana peel bioplastic.
2. When the bioplastic is soaked in chloroform and methanol, it gained little weight.
This is only true when soaked with chloroform and methanol. However, when
soaked in water, its weight doubles. As stated in the study, the results are
desirable since a doubling of weight from water can lead to a faster
decomposition rate in the soil.
3. Many chemicals tested for solubility with the banana peel bioplastic were found
to be either completely insoluble or partially soluble. This is a desired result as
the integrity of the bioplastic is not entirely compromised when exposed to
several or different chemical elements.
11
Another study that is related to this research is “A study on Bioplastic based on
starch and cellulose nanocrystals from rice straw”. It was conducted by Agustin,
Ahmmad, Alonzo, and Patriana (2014). Their study focused on the use of starch from
rice straw as a potential source of production for bioplastic. The rice straws were
retrieved from the Philippines. Among their findings are:
1. Cellulose nanocrystals can be extracted from the rice straws and can be
employed to create bioplastic.
2. The starch extracted from the rice straws have strong points in terms of
crystallinity, chemical and morphological structure. However, it is weak in terms
of resistance to moisture and thermal stability.
3. The extracted material showed desirable stiffness, an important factor in the
durability of bioplastics.
A study entitled “Production of potato starch based bioplastic” was conducted by
Soomaree (2016) is of interest. Its main focus was the use of potato as a source of
starch for bioplastic. In the study, Soomaree concluded that:
1. Starch may be extracted using the following substances: water, alkali, and
enzymes.
2. Starch from 10 tons worth of potatoes is capable of producing 356 bioplastic
bags.
3. The Potato Bioplastic is resistant to prolonged elongation and strain.
12
4. The Bioplastic is capable of resisting a force of 1kg, making it a durable and
effective bioplastic.
Goswami (2014) conducted a study entitled “Bio-Plastic From Waste
Newspaper”. It investigates the potential use of waste newspaper as a bioplastic.
Cellulose was extracted from paper sludge and was then transformed into a bioplastic.
The bioplastic was then subjected to testing. In the results, it was found that:
1. The specific starch material that is produced is dextrose. It is then converted
into a lactic acid.
2. Heat can be applied to the lactic acid, which can cause it to form substances
that are essential to bioplastic production.
Another study that is closely related was conducted by Wahyuningtiyas and
Suryanto (2018). It is “A study on the Properties of Cassava Starch based Bioplastic
Reinforced by Nanoclay”. The study focuses on the properties of cassava, potato, and
corn starch for its use as an effective and durable bioplastic. The study found that:
1. Bioplastics produced from Cassava starch have a decomposition rate of 12
days.
2. Bioplastics produced from Corn starch have a decomposition rate of 7 days.
3. Bioplastics produced from Potato starch have a decomposition rate of 5 days.
4. Nanoclay is effective in reducing the decomposition rate by half. For example,
cassava starch bioplastic take 6 days when made from nanoclay.
13
Another study that is related to the research is entitled “Biodegradability of oil palm
cellulose-based bioplastics”. In the mentioned study that was conducted by Isroi,
Rahman, and Syamsu (2018), Oil palm bioplastics were analyzed for its element of
biodegradability and its effectiveness as a bioplastic. The bioplastic is cellulose based.
From the study, it was confirmed that:
1. Oil palm bioplastics are faster in their rate of decomposition than starch based
bioplastics and conventional or non-bioplastics.
2. Oil Palm based bioplastics release more carbon dioxide than starch bioplastics.
The release of carbon dioxide pertains to the biodegradability rate of bioplastics.
Hence, Oil Palm degrade faster than starch bioplastics.
In another study conducted by Isroi (2018), Tithonia diversifolia extract was used
as an important element to test the biodegradability of bioplastics. The study is
entitled “Effect of Tithonia diversifolia extract on the biodegradability of the bioplastics
in plantation soil”. The biodegradability test was conducted over 60 days. The
bioplastic was made from Cacao pod husk and starch but was enriched with the said
extract. In the study conducted by Isroi, it is stated that:
1. Bioplastics enriched with Tithonia diversifolia extract had a faster
biodegradability rate than bioplastics that had no extract.
2. The release of Carbon Dioxide was heavier for bioplastics with the extract
than bioplastics without the extract. A heavy release of Carbon Dioxide
means a fast biodegradability rate.
14
A study on the production of bioplastics through soybeans was entitled
“Investigation of Bioplastic Properties Developed from Acrylate Epoxidized Soybean Oil
Through Ring Opening Polymerization Process”. It was conducted by Yua, Gupta,
Gupta, and Bala (2017). This was made possible through a Ring Opening
Polymerization Process. It has been found that:
1. Bioplastics made from soybeans have weaker tensile strength.
2. Crystalline properties are visible and clear. This indicates durability and
effectiveness.
15
CHAPTER 3: METHODOLOGY
I. Research Design
This experimental research is conducted in the study in order to focus on the
utilization of starch in Water Chestnuts to produce an effective and durable bioplastic. In
this study, the researchers will determine if the production is cost-effective. The
researchers will also determine if the produced product is durable and useful as a
normal plastic but also eco-friendly as a bioplastic.
The production of bioplastics made from starch extracted from Water Chestnuts
will be divided into two operations: combining the water chestnut starch, distilled water,
glycerol, and white vinegar to make a bioplastic and testing its decomposability, by
combining again the same ingredients and producing a sauce plate, and creating a
small bowl made from the same ingredients.
II. Collecting Data
Materials
For the first operation, the following materials will be used to produce two small
bioplastics: 20ml of distilled water, 2ml of white vinegar, 3g of extracted Water Chestnut
starch, and 2.5 ml of Glycerol. The researchers will also use a saucepan, a stove,
syringe, weighting scale, silicon spatula, and toothpicks as tools that will be used to
16
manipulate the elements in order to make a bioplastic. The said materials and
ingredients are bought locally.
After the bioplastic is produced, its decomposability will be checked after two
days of drying by using the following: one container of dry soil, one container of wet soil,
and digging materials.
In the second operation, the researchers will make two bioplastics that will be
shaped into a sauce plate that can contain water and survive falls. Materials and
ingredients that will be used are 45ml of distilled water, 9ml of white vinegar, 21g of
extracted Water Chestnut Starch, and 6 ml of glycerol.
Schematic Diagrams
First Operation
Mixing and Drying and Observation
Heating Decomposing
Certain amounts After mixing and After 10 days of
of water heating, the decomposition,
chestnut starch, bioplastic, it will it will be
glycerol, water, be left to dry for checked for its
and vinegar will 2 days. After the decomposition
be mixed at low mentioned and
heat. period, it will be disintegration
decomposed for into the soil.
10 days.
17
Second Operation
Mixing and Heating Drying and Observation
Separation
Certain amounts After mixing and After two days,
of water chestnut heating the the integrity of
starch, glycerol, bioplastic, it will the bioplastic will
water, and vinegar be left to dry for 2 be tested with a
will be mixed at days but not fall test and its
low heat. before separating ability to contain
the bioplastic into water effectively.
two sauce plates,
one small, one
large.
Procedures
In the first operation, two bioplastics will be made. 20ml of distilled water, 2ml of
white vinegar, 3g of extracted Water Chestnut starch, and 2.5 ml of Glycerol will be
mixed in the saucepan. The water will be added first via syringe followed by the vinegar,
glycerol, and lastly the starch. After mixing the four components, the saucepan will be
placed into the stove and is subjected into low heat for 5 minutes and continuous
stirring. After 5 minutes, the mixture must have a somewhat viscous and thicker form. It
is then extracted from the saucepan and flattened on top of a plastic container through
the use of a toothpick. After being left to dry for two days, the bioplastics will be tested
for its decomposability in different conditions. One bioplastic will be buried in dry soil,
the other will be buried in wet. After burial, the bioplastic will be checked for how long it
18
decomposed. It will be also checked for other signs of decomposition like the presence
of fungi.
For the second operation, one bioplastic will be made. 45ml of distilled water,
9ml of white vinegar, 21g of extracted Water Chestnut Starch, and 6 ml of glycerol will
be mixed. After creation, the bioplastic will be divided into two small sauce plates: one
big and one small. If the ratio were to be compared to the first operation, Starch, water,
and vinegar were increased to make way for a more solid form while glycerol is reduced
to lessen the flexibility in order to make an effective container. Like the first operation, it
will be placed in a saucepan on a stove and it will be subjected to low heat. After 5
minutes, the researchers will start molding the bioplastic into two sauce plates, one
large and one big. For this to be achieved, it will be sandwiched between two sauce
plates for its curved shape to be achieved. It will then be left to dry for 2 days. After 2
days, it will be subjected to a fall test and it will be tested to what extent can it contain
water. This is done in order to test the integrity of the bioplastic.
19
CHAPTER 4: RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
As stated in the methodology of the research, the experiment will be divided
into two operations. The first operation will test the biodegradability of the bioplastic
while the second operation will test if the same type of bioplastic can be molded into a
form that can contain water and survive falling impact. The bioplastics are all made from
Water Chestnut Starch. Here, the researchers will be discussing the results of the two
operations.
In the first operation, 2 thin sheets of Water Chestnut bioplastics were produced.
The two bioplastics were then placed in the soil, one dry and one wet. After 10 days, the
bioplastics were checked for decomposition and the table below shows the results:
Research Question 1: How long did it take for the produced material made
primarily from Water Chestnut Starch to decompose?
Table 1: Decomposition of Bioplastic
Bioplastics First Day Day of Full Appearance of
Decomposition Fungi
Bioplastic in Dry Soil Whole 14th day of 9th Day of
Decomposition Decomposition
Bioplastic in Wet Soil Whole 10th Day of 4th Day of
Decomposition Decomposition
20
Based from the data that is available, the bioplastic has successfully
decomposed. The bioplastic in the dry soil has mostly decomposed or broke apart while
the other bioplastic decomposed faster due to the presence of water.
In the second operation, two sauce plates made from Water Chestnut Starch
were produced. One Sauce Plate is large, the other is small. After it was left to dry for 2
days after its creation, the researchers tested how much water it can contain and how
high can it survive in a height fall. The table shows the following results:
Research Question 2: How much water will the Water Chestnut Bioplastic will
be able to contain as a bio-sauce plate and how high can it survive from a fall?
Table 2: Integrity of Bioplastic
Bioplastic Amount of Water it was Height Fall it was able to
able to contain. survive.
Small Bio-Sauce Plate 4ml 100cm
Large Bio-Sauce Plate 8ml 100cm
From the table presented above, the small bio-sauce plates was able to contain
4ml of water and the large bio-sauce plate was able to contain 8ml of water. Both were
able survive a 100cm fall. The ability of the produced bioplastic to contain water shows
that larger forms of the bioplastic like bowls and plate might be able to contain water,
food, and other liquids and solids for consumption. It also shows that there were no
leaks of water from either the two sauce plates, making it an effective holder of liquid.
As for the 100cm height fall, both sauce plates were able to withstand the fall. This
shows the strong structure and integrity the sauce plate contains with the material used
21
to form the said subject. Due to the two sub-experiments in the second operation, the
bio-sauce plate has been proven to be an effective container and larger forms can be
made with the same ratio of ingredients.
According to Saharan and Sharma (2018), bioplastics should be capable of
decomposition. The first operation proves this. Roymahapatra and Katua (2016) also
states that in applying the use of bioplastics in households, it is important for a bioplastic
to be able to survive basic tests like the leaking of water and a height fall from a table.
As such, the subjected bioplastic was able to survive the mentioned tests and through
its survival, it was able to prove that the bioplastic can maintain its integrity and
structure and prevent the leakage of water, making it an effective container.
22
CHAPTER 5: CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS
At this stage in the research, the researchers will further discuss the results and
from this discussion, recommendations will be made on the improvement of the
bioplastic and for future researchers to study and discuss on.
Conclusion
In the discussion of this research, it has been proven that the bioplastic that is
produced from Water Chestnut Starch is biodegradable and strong and effective in
terms of integrity and structure. By analyzing the two operations conducted in the
research and the corresponding data obtained from the experiments of the research, it
has been found that:
1. The problem of the research has been satisfied through the formation of a low
cost and safe procedure that can produce a bioplastic capable of decomposition
using extracted starch from Water Chestnuts and other materials. This was
shown in the first operation.
2. The problem of the research is also satisfied with the effectiveness of the
produced bioplastic as a liquid container and its capability to survive a fall from a
height similar to a table. This was shown in the data and analysis of the second
operation.
In conclusion, bioplastics made from starch extracted from Water Chestnuts can be
a durable and effective alternative to the use of plastics. It can also done with low cost
23
production. According to Goodall (2011), these characteristics meets the expected
status of bioplastics in its state of eco-friendliness and effectiveness. As such, the
researchers considers the bioplastics successful.
Recommendations
In this study, the researchers notice some problems that can be fixed in future
studies.
1. One problem is the softness of the bioplastic. Although it was able to survive a
fall the height of a table and was able to prevent any fluid leaks, it is thought that it can
be destroyed in more severe conditions like a fall from a taller height and damage
obtained from other materials. As such, we recommend the inclusion of materials or
substances that will further enhance the strength of the bioplastic.
2. The researchers also recommend lessening the amount of water in future
experiments. The reason why water should be lessened is that when the bioplastics are
left to dry, small cracks begin to appear. This is the result of the evaporation of water.
Although the bio-sauce plates were able to prevent any leaks, the cracks are still a sign
of needed improvement in the bioplastic formula in future studies.
3. The researchers also suggest making bigger forms of the bioplastic like bowls
and plates in order to see further the effectivity of the bioplastic in future researches.
4. The researchers also propose the use of compression test in future studies in
testing the effectivity of the Water Chestnut bioplastic.
24
APPENDIX A
Materials
LEFT TO RIGHT: Extracted Water Chestnut Starch, White Vinegar, Distilled Water,
Glycerol. Digital Weighting Scale, and Syringes.
LEFT TO RIGHT: Plastic top, container used for starch measure, silicon spatula, spoon,
and saucepan on top of a stove.
25
LEFT TO RIGHT: Measuring Stick used for 100 cm height fall, the sauce plate that will
be used to shape the bioplastic in the second operation.
APPENDIX B
Procedures
LEFT TO RIGHT: The mixture before being heated, 3 minutes in heating, and the
result.
LEFT TO RIGHT: The bioplastic 2 days after drying, the soil that will be used to bury
the bioplastic.
26
LEFT TO RIGHT: The ingredients of the bioplastic of the second operation being mixed,
the bioplastic being mixed. The bioplastic after 5 minutes of mixing. Notice that the
bioplastic has a bigger form than the first operation bioplastics. The measure of the
ingredients were increased in order to make more bioplastic suitable for two sauce
plates, one large and one small.
LEFT TO RIGHT: Molding the Bioplastic, the bioplastics after creation.
27
APPENDIX C
Results
LEFT TO RIGHT: The bioplastic in dry soil after 10 days, the bioplastic in wet soil in the
same period as the dry soil bioplastic.
28
LEFT TO RIGHT: The bio-sauce plate was able to contain water, there are no leaks in
either of the two bio-sauce plates as shown in the right picture.
ABOVE: The two bio-sauce plates still intact after the height test.
29