0% found this document useful (0 votes)
379 views3 pages

Strain Theory and Delinquent Subcultures

This document summarizes several sociological theories of crime and deviance: 1. General Strain Theory explains how negative emotions from strain or stress, such as failure to achieve goals, can lead to criminal behavior. 2. Subculture Theory suggests that members of lower classes develop subcultures with values that may clash with mainstream society, increasing crime. 3. Differential Association Theory argues that limited opportunities to succeed legitimately push some into criminal gangs and illegal activities. 4. Neutralization Theory proposes that people learn techniques to rationalize law-breaking and drift between conventional and deviant behavior.

Uploaded by

euce lawrence
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
379 views3 pages

Strain Theory and Delinquent Subcultures

This document summarizes several sociological theories of crime and deviance: 1. General Strain Theory explains how negative emotions from strain or stress, such as failure to achieve goals, can lead to criminal behavior. 2. Subculture Theory suggests that members of lower classes develop subcultures with values that may clash with mainstream society, increasing crime. 3. Differential Association Theory argues that limited opportunities to succeed legitimately push some into criminal gangs and illegal activities. 4. Neutralization Theory proposes that people learn techniques to rationalize law-breaking and drift between conventional and deviant behavior.

Uploaded by

euce lawrence
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
  • Concepts - Robert Agnew
  • Concepts - Albert K. Cohen
  • Concepts - Neutralization Theory

CONCEPTS

Sociologist Robert Agnew (1992) reformulated the strain theory of Robert Merton and suggests
that criminality is the direct result of negative affective states - the anger, frustration, depression,
disappointment, and other adverse emotons that derive from strain. Agnew tries to explain why
individuals who feel stress and strain are more likely to commit crimes and offers more
explanation of criminal activity among all elements of society rather than restricting his views to
lower-class crime (Siegel, 2004). He finds that negative affective states are produced by a variety
of sources of strains, such as:
1. Strain caused by the failure to achieve positively valued goals. This type of strain occurs when a
youth aspires to wealth and gain, but lacking financial and educational resources, would assume
that such goals are impossible to achieve.
Another example: Mar wants to study in college but because his parents could not afford to send
him in school may end up as a construction worker.
Strain caused by disjunction of expectations and achievements. This aspect happens when
people compare themselves to peers who seem to be doing a lot better financially or socially.
Example: San is a graduate of criminology who took and topped the board examination but
because of height requirement she may wait for the approval of her height waiver but San knew
that her classmate who took the board exam thrice already and had a high ranking father was
successful in the recruitment using other eligibility. San using Agnew's general strain theory may
feel stress and frustrated.
Removal of positively valued stimuli. The loss of positive stimuli may lead to delinquency as the
adolescent tries to prevent the loss, retrieve what has been lost, obtain substitutes, or seek
revenge against those responsible for the loss.
Example: Jay had a brother and somebody killed his brother. In retum, out of anger because that
person killed his ever loved brother, Jay might kill also the person who killed his brother.
Presentation of negative stimuli. Strain may also be caused by the presence of negative stimuli.
Example: During the first day of board examination, the proctor did not allow you to take the said
exam because you arrived one hour already. In this case, you as the examinee may feel frustrated
or worst you may seek revenge against the proctor.

CONCEPTS
This theory combines the effects of social disorganization and strain to explain how people living
in deteriorated neighborhoods react to social isolation and economic deprivation. Because of the
draining. rustrating and dispiriting experiences, members of the lower class create an
independent subculture with its own set of rules and values. This lower-class subculture stresses
excitement, toughness, risk-making. fearlessness, and immediate gratification. Subcultural norms
such as being tough followed by he lower-class may tend to clash with conventional values--the
norms set by the society. Example, sum dwellers or informal settlers are forced to violate the law
because they obey the rules of the deviant culture with which they are in close and immediate
contact. In short, those who are economically deprived and iving in disorganized areas in order to
gain success may resort to crige and delinquency (Siegel, 2004).
CONCEPTS
Albert K. Cohen (1918-2014) first articulated the theory in his classic book, "Delinquent Boys."
Cohen's position was that delinquent behavior of lower-lass youth is actually a protest against
the norms and values of the middle-class US, oulture. Because the social conditions make them
incapable of achieving success legitimately, lower-class youths experience a form of culture
confid that Cohen labels status frustration. Status frustration refers to the state where youths are
incapable of achieving their legitimate goals in life because of the social conditions that they are
into, such as having poor parents and living in slum areas. With this, Cohen was able to believe
that because of status frustration lower-class boys who suffer rejection by middle-clas (rich)
people may tend to form deviant subcultures and Cohen called it: the corner boy, the college boy,
or the delinquent boy (Siegel, 2004).
1. The Corner Boy
The corner boy role is the most common response to middle-class rejection. He is not a chronic.
delinquent but may be a truant who engages in petty or status offenses, such as sex before
marriage and recreational drug abuse.
2. The College Boy
The college boy embraces the cultural and social values of the middle-class. He actively strives b
be successful by those standards.
3. The Delinquent Boy
The delinquent boy adopts set of norms and principles in direct opposition to middle-class
values.
He strives for independence and that nobody can control his behavior, he may join gang and
willing to take risks and violate the law.
By introducing the corner boy, college boy, and delinquent boy triad, Cohen helps explain why
many lower-class youth fail to become chronic offender (Siegel, 2004).

CONCEPTS
Differential Opportunity Theory is the output of the classic work of Richard A. Cloward (1926-
2001) and Lloyd E. Ohlin's (1918-2008) *Delinquency and Opportunity.* This theory is a
combination of strain and disorganization principles into a portrayal of a gang-sustaining criminal
subculture. The main concept of this theory states that people in all strata of society share the
same success goals but those in the lower-class have
limited means of achieving them. People who perceive themselves as failures with conventional
soot wil seek alternative or innovative ways to gain success, such as joining drug syndicate and
any other lorns of ilegal activites, Because of the differential opportunity. kids are also likely to
join one of ties: types of gangs:
1. Criminal Gangs: Exist in stable lower-class areas in which close connections among adolescent,
young adult, and adult offenders create an environment for successful criminal enterprise such as
joining gang.
2. Conflict Gang: Thrive in highly disorganized areas marked by temporary residents and physical
deterioration. Members of the conflict gang are tough adolescents who fight with weapons to
win respect from rivals and engage in destructive assaults on people and property. They are
willing to fight to protect their own and their gang's integrity and honor.
3. Retreatist Gang: Retreatists are double failures because they are unable to gain success
through legitimate means and unwilling to do so through illegal ones. They have tried crime or
violence but are either too weak or scared to be accepted in criminal or violent gangs.
Ohlin and Cloward agreed with Cohen (previous lesson) and found out that independent
delinquert subcuitures exist within society. Youth gangs are important part of the delinquent
subculture. Speaking d subculture, this would refer to groups that are being formed with the
values and norms that would clast or in conflict with the dominant culture (general society).
Although Cloward and Ohlin believed that not al crminal behaviors (Siegel, 2004).
ilegal ads are committed by gang youth; they are the source of the most serious, sustained, and
cost.

CONCEPTS
Neutralization Theory (1957) is identified with the writings of David C. Matza (1930-2018) and his
associate Gresham M. Sykes (1922-2010). They viewed the process of becoming a criminal as a
learing experience in which potential delinquents and criminals master techniques that enable
them to counterbalance or neutralize conventional values and drift back and forth between
illegitimate and
canventional behavior. One reason it becomes possible, Its because of tre subter anean vaue
stuctre of American Society. Subterranean values are morally tinged influences that havesbecome
entrenches in the culture but are publicly condemned. These are values that are condemned in
public but may be practiced privately: Example: viewing porographic films, drinking alcohol to
excess, and gambling on sporting events.
Matza further argued that even the most committed criminals and delinquents are not involved
in criminality all the time; they also attend schools, family functions, and religious services. Their
behavior can be conceived as falling along a continuum between total freedom and total restraint
This process, which Matza calls drift-refers to the movement from one extreme of behavior to
another, resulting in behavior that is sometimes unconventional, free, or deviant, and at other
times constraint and sober,
A person according to Matza may learn techniques of neutralization in order to temporanly * drift
away" from conventional behavior and get involved in more subterranean values and behaviors
including crime and drug abuse. The following are the techniques of neutralization for a person
to justity his law-violating behavior and drift away from the rules of the normative society and
participate in subterranean behaviors (Siegel, 2004):
1. Denial of Responsibility. Young offenders sometimes claim their unlawful acts were simply not
their fault They made me do it
2. Denial of Injury. Criminals are able to neutralize their behavior by denying the
* 3.
wrongfulness of their act. "They have insurance." "What's one ballipen to a big store?"
Denial of Victim. Criminals would neutralize their acts by maintaining that the victim of crime
"had it coming." In this case, the criminal would blame his victim.

Common questions

Powered by AI

Societal expectations play a critical role in fostering criminal activities, as highlighted by the strain, subcultural, and differential opportunity theories. These theories demonstrate that societal pressure to achieve conventional success can lead to criminal behavior when legitimate avenues are blocked. Agnew's theory notes that failing to meet positively valued societal goals results in strain, leading individuals to find alternative routes, including crime, to achieve those goals . Cohen's theory emphasizes that inability to achieve middle-class standards fosters status frustration, prompting some youths to embrace deviant subcultures . Meanwhile, the Differential Opportunity Theory suggests that lack of opportunities results in the creation of gang subcultures as alternative means of achieving success . Together, these perspectives argue that social structures and expectations can unintentionally promote criminal behavior by creating scenarios where crime becomes a rational choice for those marginalized by the system.

Matza's concept of 'drift' explains the intermittent nature of criminal behavior by suggesting that delinquents move between conforming and non-conforming conduct based on circumstances. According to Matza, even committed criminals are not entangled in a crime continuously; instead, they experience periods of conventional behavior influenced by familial, educational, or social events. Techniques of neutralization allow them to justify their deviance temporarily, enabling them to engage in criminal acts without abandoning their conventional beliefs entirely. This concept acknowledges that delinquents are not static in their behavior; instead, they navigate between different behavioral states across a continuum, influenced by subterranean values and situational opportunities .

The Differential Opportunity Theory posits that while all individuals share similar success goals, the means to achieve these goals are unequally distributed across social classes. In lower-class environments where legitimate means are limited, individuals seek alternatives such as forming gangs. According to Cloward and Ohlin, this leads to the formation of three types of gangs based on the environment: 'criminal gangs' flourish in stable lower-class areas conducive to organized crime; 'conflict gangs' emerge in disorganized areas where violence is used to establish respect and status; and 'retreatist gangs' include individuals who fail to achieve success through criminal or legitimate means, forming groups characterized by a focus on drugs and escapism. These different gang types are adaptations to their socio-economic environments, each offering paths to status and identity not available through conventional means .

Cohen's theory on 'corner boys,' 'college boys,' and 'delinquent boys' offers nuanced insights into juvenile delinquency by exploring how lower-class youths adapt to status frustration. 'Corner boys' may engage in minor deviance to cope with status frustration, often opting for non-confrontational peers and minor offenses. 'College boys' strive to assimilate and compete within the prevailing middle-class culture despite significant socio-economic challenges, aspiring to succeed by its standards. In contrast, 'delinquent boys' reject societal norms outright and often engage in gang activities and persistent delinquency, challenging the mainstream values they cannot achieve. These categorizations show how different responses to social constraints manifest in various forms and intensities of delinquent behavior . This framework assists in tailoring interventions and understanding the diverse trajectories of youths based on their responses to socio-economic barriers.

The 'techniques of neutralization' provide psychological mechanisms that allow individuals to drift between deviant and conventional behaviors. These techniques include denying responsibility, injury, or the victim, and they enable individuals to rationalize and justify their criminal actions temporarily. For instance, offenders may claim that their actions were not their fault or that the injuries were minor and excusable. By neutralizing the guilt associated with their actions, individuals maintain their self-image and societal bonds while engaging in deviant acts. This process explains the fluid movement between lawful and unlawful behaviors, where individuals balance their participation in conventional society with deviant acts influenced by subterranean values .

Agnew's General Strain Theory extends the original strain theory by identifying a broader range of strains and emphasizing the role of negative affective states such as anger, frustration, and depression as precursors to criminal behavior. Unlike earlier theories which primarily focused on lower-class crime, Agnew's approach considers strains experienced across all socioeconomic classes. These strains arise from the failure to achieve positively valued goals, the disjunction between expectations and achievements, the removal of positive stimuli, and the presence of negative stimuli. For example, individuals might engage in criminal acts when they perceive unfairness or when they aim to remedy the loss of valued stimuli, as illustrated through personal revenge scenarios . This broader perspective implies that criminal behavior can be a response to various life-strains, making it a more inclusive explanation applicable to diverse societal classes .

According to Agnew's reformulated strain theory, the presentation of negative stimuli can lead to criminal behavior as individuals respond to these adverse situations. Negative stimuli trigger negative affective states like anger and frustration, which can pressure individuals towards criminal paths as a form of coping. For instance, adverse experiences such as unfair treatment or hostile environments may compel individuals to react with criminal acts as a means of retaliation against perceived injustices or as a method to escape or mediate their distress . This aspect of strain theory highlights the impact of environmental and situational factors in fostering criminal behavior.

Cohen's concept of 'status frustration' arises from lower-class youths' inability to achieve success through legitimate means within the middle-class hierarchy, leading to cultural conflict. Unable to meet these societal expectations due to economic and social constraints, these youths experience frustration and seek validation through alternate means. They form deviant subcultures where the standards and norms differ from those of the mainstream middle-class values. This adaptation is manifested in groups that Cohen categorizes as 'corner boys,' 'college boys,' and 'delinquent boys.' Each group handles status frustration differently, with the 'delinquent boy' directly opposing middle-class values, often forming gangs and engaging in unlawful behavior to gain status and identity within their immediate social environment .

The subcultural perspective suggests that crime persists in disorganized neighborhoods because of the development of an independent subculture with distinct norms and values that clash with mainstream societal rules. In these environments, residents experience social isolation and economic deprivation, leading to subcultural norms that emphasize immediate gratification, toughness, and risk-taking. These values often conflict with conventional societal expectations, resulting in behaviors that are deemed criminal. For example, individuals in these neighborhoods may engage in criminal activity due to loyalty to their subculture, seeking respect and validation within it rather than attempting to conform to a society that marginalizes them .

Subcultural theories suggest that the transformation of slum dwellers into law violators is influenced by the clash between the values of their deviant subculture and conventional societal norms. Economic deprivation and social disorganization foster environments where individuals do not see traditional means as viable paths to success. In response, they adopt subcultural norms that prioritize behaviors contrary to mainstream laws, such as toughness, risk-taking, and immediate gratification. This alignment with subcultural values over societal laws often leads slum dwellers to engage in criminal activities as a way to achieve recognition and status within their community .

CONCEPTS
Sociologist Robert Agnew (1992) reformulated the strain theory of Robert Merton and suggests
that criminality is the
CONCEPTS
Albert K. Cohen (1918-2014) first articulated the theory in his classic book, "Delinquent Boys."
Cohen's position wa
through legitimate means and unwilling to do so through illegal ones. They have tried crime or
violence but are either too we

You might also like