Education Students' Reading Preferences
Education Students' Reading Preferences
LANGUAGE”
By
MONICA D. ESCOTE
JANICE P. RENDAJE
EDUCATION RESEARCH
COLLEGE OF EDUCATION
AUGUST 2022
2
Approval Sheet
We hereby declare to the best of our knowledge, that this is our own work
person, nor a material which to a substantial extent has been accepted for the
We declare that the intellectual content of this paper is the product of our
own words, except to the extent that the assistance from others in the design or
acknowledged.
Researchers:
Monica D. Escote
Janice P. Rendaje
4
ABSTRACT
reasons, the extent of utilization, and the effectiveness of the preferred reading
of this study are the following. In terms of the respondents’ reading preference,
materials because they could write the details and their notes directly highlighted
on the printed material. The effectiveness of the preferred reading material, the
reading material and the extent of the utilization of the respondents. Lastly, it is
highly significant, and there is a strong correlation between the extent of utilization
and the perceived effectiveness. The respondents utilized printed and digital
reading material that helped them learn English as a second language. The
researchers concluded that printed reading material is the preferred reading material
by the students. The students utilize it because it helps them to improve their
Acknowledgement
The researchers sincerely thank everyone who made their dearest vision
come to life and owe them a debt of gratitude. While some may not be
our adviser, for his encouragement, inspiration, and vast expertise. Our thesis
diligently and made a significant effort to complement our study's gaps. We could
-The Researchers
6
Dedication
support, and fervent prayers for our project's accomplishment. Words cannot
adequately describe our thanks for all the support you have provided us to our
friends who never left us and have been there for us in both good times and bad.
You are all without a doubt our greatest supporters. Our sincere appreciation and
compliments go out to our thesis advisor, reader, and statistician. All they have
Monica
Almie
Janice
7
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
Title Page…………………………….………………………………………… 1
Approval Sheet……………….……………………………………………..…. 2
Abstract……………………………………………………………………...… 4
Acknowledgement…………………………………………………………….. 5
Dedication……………………………………………………………………... 6
Table of Contents……………………………………………………………… 7
List of Appendices…………………………………………………...……. …. 11
CHAPTER
1 INTRODUCTION……………………………….……………..……. 12
Definition of Terms…………………………………………… 15
Related Literature.………………………………………….…. 16
Theoretical Framework…………………….……………….… 31
Conceptual Framework………………………………….……. 32
Hypotheses …………………………………………………… 35
2 METHODS……………………………………….……………. .… 36
8
Research Design……………………………...……………….. 36
Sampling Technique……………………………………….….. 37
Research Instrument………………………………….………... 37
3 RESULTS……………………………………………..…..….….…… 41
Findings………………………………………………………… 41
4 DISCUSSIONS……………………………………..……..…….….... 49
Reading Preference……………………………………………… 49
Summary of Findings…………………………………………… 57
Conclusion………...…………………………………………….. 59
Recommendations……………………………………….…….... 59
9
REFERENCES………………………………………………....………...…... ... 61
10
Tables
Table Page
1 Reading Preference……………………………………...……………….. 41
Second Language……………………………………………..…………….... 45
5 The Difference between Printed and Digital Reading Material and the Extent of
Utilization………………………………………..……………...…………..... 46
Appendices
Appendix Page
A Questionnaire………………………………………………….. 70
B Letters…………………………………………………………. 75
C Curriculum Vitae……………………………………………… 78
12
CHAPTER 1
Introduction
It is said that reading is the path to success in school and life. One who is
not able to read will not be able to succeed (U. S. Department of Education, 2005).
A language can be learned in a variety of ways. Reading is one method that many
speaking if one wants to communicate. One might be able to speed up the study of
based texts alone as there is apparent popularity of e-books (Foasberg, 2014), the
2012). Some researchers have reported the preference of students to read in print
(Revelle et al., 2011) and the choice of others to read digitized reading materials
that printed reading materials are preferred over digital reading resources. Students
favored reading printed materials (72 %) over digital texts, according to the data (7
%). Students also stated that printed texts were more accessible to remember (60.8
%) than digital texts. If students were offered a choice of text type, they would
select printed materials (71.7 %). As a result, instead of reading materials online,
readers). There are a variety of reasons why people choose electronic reading. It
of books, magazines, and other printed materials eliminates one problem that
readers must consider: the requirement for a safe storage location. E-materials take
materials could be saved in one convenient device. Another is the absence of paper
costs because digital reading prevents the use of paper (Latini et al., 2019),
focused on the transition from print to digital reading materials; other research also
focused on the superiority of printed over the digital text and vice versa. This study
then focused on the effectiveness of printed and digital reading materials in learning
The surge of the Global Pandemic has affected the life of every student.
Thus, the students at Notre Dame of Midsayap College are provided with two types
of Reading materials— Digital and Printed. The researchers aimed to determine the
preferred reading materials of the respondents and how their preferred reading
materials helped them learn English as a second language. As a result, this study
aimed to know the reading preference of Second Year College students from the
preferred reading material and how their reading preferences help them in learning.
2. What are the reasons for the respondents' preferred reading material?
perceived effectiveness?
The results of the study may be beneficial to the following individuals and
institutions:
Students. The result of the study may serve as the basis for the students to
Teachers. The results of this study may serve as the basis for teachers to be
NDMC Administrators. The result of this study may provide baseline data
to the administrators’ and give them insights into the reading preferences of the
Future researchers. The result of this study may serve as a reference for
preferences.
This study was limited to the reading preferences of the respondents, such
as print and digital reading material and the effectiveness of learning English as a
second language. In line with the effectiveness of each reading material, it would
only focus on cognitive and affective aspects. The study was conducted at Notre
Dame of Midsayap College. This study was limited to second-year students only,
expressly, the students who are currently enrolled in the College of Education
Definition of Terms
materials that they feel would help them understand and learn successfully.
Related Literature
University students are now required to adapt to the new normal of learning.
This has affected how they spend time between following their online classes and
The major and elective selections will determine the reading students
undertake in college. Knowing what kind of source they will read in each lesson
will help. That way, they will know why they are reading it, what they will learn
transformed into electronic text. The expenses of paper and allied materials used
materials, money, and human energy. That is why in the United States of America,
the purchase of e-books has surpassed the printed books and magazines today
With the popularity of tablet computers and more advanced mobile devices,
publishers are increasingly making digital versions of books that have traditionally
been available in paper format. The sales of these digital books, also known as e-
books, increased by 117% in 2011, generating just under $970 million, according
According to Jones et al. (2011), electronic books are available through two
primary sources: online websites and personal electronic devices. The importance
of such devices cannot be underestimated. There are several factors influencing the
transition from print to electronic format. First, online resources provide instant
embrace of e-books suggest that the technology is not just a mere trend. Students
in the 21st century are encouraged to utilize personal gadgets to have instant access
to information and connect with their classmates. For most K-12 learners, reading
from a computer screen is comfortable and familiar. The "read-write" web has
created a generation of readers eager to interact with their peers and established
authors.
16 and older said they had read an e-book in the previous year or had read other
long-form content such as magazines, journals, and news articles in digital format
Printed texts have traditionally been the primary means of teaching children
to read and learn to read. However, because of the widespread use of technology,
digital texts have evolved, necessitating new comprehension abilities and tactics.
Reading Preference
university students. It was discovered that the respondents spent their free time
reading novels, newspapers, and periodicals. Due to their hectic schedules between
attending school and spending time with loved ones, they could not devote much
reading may differ from most other adults. Many of their classes demand extensive
read for enjoyment, employment, or to improve their skills. Mainly if the internet
mediates their socializing, informed, or as part of their social lives, readers will be
presented with various forms, including those described above, in each case.
A study on the effects of printed vs. digital texts on reading comprehension and
books, and at the same time conventional approach was used for all reading tasks
measured the impact of e-reading and printed document reading. According to their
findings, participants who read from printed materials retained more information
and had a better knowledge of the text than those who read from a computer screen
or electronic reading.
predicted that it would finally die due to the introduction of technology, which gave
Nishimura et al. (2015) stated that using a highlighter pen to make notes
might help students enhance their academic achievement. This can help learners
achieve one of their main goals, and marking with a highlighter pen can help them
learn more effectively in areas including memory, attention, cognitive capacity, and
computational ability.
students preferred textbooks over e-books for learning when purchasing an e-book
absorb and recall more of the narrative than readers of e-books. In previous
hands.
reading a traditional book. Even though the current student generation is the most
Print texts have been selected for learning by participants who had previously used
an e-book. Students were more likely to use distinct aspects in print books than in
In some cases, learners will only print out the texts they need to concentrate
on more and just read the remaining text in digital form. These learners will only
understand the things they read when they put their full attention on reading and be
engaged in each word they encounter, either in digital or printed form (Woody et
al., 2010).
The level to which young adults in all the nations we questioned indicated
a passion for traditional print characteristics was one of the most startling findings
from the open-ended questions. Students loved the capacity to search (for words,
21
for information) when reading onscreen and stated that it was "genuine reading"
and claimed that they could not do so with print. Online access may be incredibly
books without worrying about the number of stored books. As a result, anyone can
eBooks may be purchased and read at any time and in any location without the use
The higher classes used the internet more often and had less time for leisure and
enjoyment. The learners thought that knowledge obtained from the internet was
valuable and reliable. This is in line with the findings of Alshahrani et al. (2017),
who showed that internet use significantly influenced students' academic self-
books are more likely to become distracted, and it is not simply because they have
access to the internet. Readers who use digital devices spend more time looking for
keywords than reading. There is also no risk of being sidetracked by links or falling
down an online rabbit hole, hunting up the collective phrase for a bunch of ferrets
interruptions and connections that can take a reader anywhere on the internet.
"breaks." Furthermore, in order to remember knowledge, you must read for long
Baron et al. (2017) stated that University students are typically concerned
about saving money. "Cash dominates everything around me," one participant said
in one pilot research, while of all "like least" replies regarding reading in hardcopy
were concerns about the price of print in the present research. College textbooks
are undeniably pricey. He also stated that more than nine out of ten respondents
Those who had read none or only a few books in the previous year stated
their hurdle to reading was a lack of time, which they attributed to work and other
obligations, with others saying they preferred alternative media such as television
and podcasts. On the other hand, those who took up a book claimed it gave them
Effects of Reading
calmness of children, as well as the introduction of new information that will enrich
could benefit from reading, not just children and young adults.
Moreover, reading is a beautiful habit that has the potential to alter people's lives
significantly. It can enlighten, entertain, and educate us. It aids in stress reduction,
fun, far apart from the actual world's complexity. Through imagination, one could
be able to travel from different palaces and will be able to feel and experience
different emotions even if they are sitting or lying on their beds reading their
favorite book.
Many teachers feel that pupils should read challenging books and that they
should be pushed when learning to read. Perhaps they believe that challenging
literature prepares them for reading stuff published in their language (Day, 2017).
other words, one must exude a fair amount of adroit maneuvering of this skill to be
the other hand, may have a significant impact not only on visual comfort but also
dry eye, diplopia, and blurred vision, either near or far, after prolonged computer
comparable to those seen when viewing printed items. However, dry eye symptoms
are more common while using a computer. The latter is most likely owing to a
decrease in blink rate and amplitude and greater corneal exposure from the monitor
Many readers prefer reading using printed material because they want to
protect their eyes from any harm that they believe is caused by radiation on mobile
phones, TV, and other technology. They did not know that even reading in printed
forms, there is still possible harm to the eyes because of the decrease in blinking,
The overall results in the study of Porion (2014) reveal that reading performance is
presentation are met (text structure, display on a single page, screen size, and many
showed that Canadian university students maintained the critical themes of the tale
and displayed equal deep knowledge after reading from paper or tablets.
25
Extent of Utilization
Students of all ages are accustomed to regular social media and internet
entertainment. It might be too tempting to study when Facebook and YouTube are
frequent internet diversions can cause study time to be disrupted and academic
progress to be hampered.
paper or performing another work that demands some cognitive load, and they
discover that thoughts about those notifications are distracting them, their
necessary talent but also intimately linked to the educational process and students'
academic achievement.
above towards the display's surface. Nothing is left undisturbed in the digital age,
Although e-books are often shown on specialist e-book readers (e-readers), they
26
may be viewed on nearly any electronic device with reading software. E-books are
hypertexts that allow the reader to carry a whole library in a small area, are cheaper
(around 50%–60%), more environmentally friendly, and have better degrees of text
customization than print (e.g., font size, font type, color, and luminance). There is
no doubt that e-books are portable and less hassle to carry, especially for university
students. LCD e-readers are often tablets, which means they are versatile devices
that may be used for communication, organizing, leisure activities, and reading.
Millar (2015) stated in her study that the additional elements that may be
adopting e-textbooks. Links to other online resources and instructive films can be
inserted directly into the content of e-textbooks. That it not only assists the
instructor in supplementing classroom content, but also offers the subject in various
technologies have the potential to suit students' diverse learning demands and
possibly increase their capacity to study as their functioning improves (Dew, 2010).
This might very well be the case with e-textbooks and e-reading gadgets.
Larhmaid (2018) stated that one major advantage of print reading is that it
offers readers access to the text in its entirety. This access is built up on visual and
tactile cues, whereby the reader can see and "tactilely feel the spatial and physical
The limited access restricts readers from using digital media and the non-
physicality of the text; they can access only one page but not the entire text at any
27
given time of reading (Mangen, 2010). The result of this study is supported by the
study of Barshay (2019); her reading research also runs counter to well-intended
A July 2019 report from the National Association of College Stores shows
that 22 percent of college students use free course materials, up from 3 percent in
2015. Pearson, the largest textbook publisher in North America, announced in July
2019 that it was moving to a "digital first" strategy. Books will still be available to
rent, but students will be discouraged from buying them by higher prices, fewer
Jolliffe et al. (2008) stated that there were students who did not spend the
typical two hours studying for every hour in class but who did devote a significant
deeply, whether it was religious reading, fantasy books, or letters with friends.
studies have found that grades and learning outcomes did not differ very much
between students who used print and those who used e-textbooks. However, the
students in these same studies preferred print spent more time studying when they
used a print format and did not volunteer to use e-textbooks again. Students often
print out their reading in an electronic format, even if they are not willing to pay
more for a print copy upfront, suggesting that they find it easier to work with paper
functions that are not available in traditional printed books. E-books include
capabilities are not present in printed books, making e-books more tech-savvy and
Students' ages and years in college may also affect their reading practices.
Most of the participants in the study were juniors, seniors, or graduate students.
students may also be more likely to participate in studies. The practices of students
earlier in their college careers may be different. Since age can affect technology
adoption, information about the students' ages was also gathered (Foasberg, 2014).
Students have specialized reading needs because they need to read for their
classes. Their reading life as students differs from the one they live when they are
not enrolled in school. Because of these practices, college students are distinct from
the general population regarding their reading, and their needs should be considered
separately.
years demonstrate this. Studies show that learners may gain new word knowledge
to infer that as one's vocabulary grows, so does one's ability to spell and use
clarifies what the term means and how to apply it. A large body of evidence
how toddlers learn. A competent tutor will assist in practicing them and
incorporating repetition. They can never do enough of it, in any case. If one reads
a lot, one can assure that one can get recurrent exposure. A reader would not be
confident enough to employ words and phrases unless they are sufficiently
many different things that absorb the essentials of English grammar and
(which is useful in all content areas), increases student vocabulary skills, and has
30
new vocabulary per minute than a typical lecture, TV show, or song. Therefore,
despite having completed the same number of lessons, students who read foreign
results from printed books and e-books if the tablet screen presents e-books
similarly to printed books or the tablet navigation features are regulated (Chen et
was the most effective approach for enhancing literal reading comprehension out
of the three. Without a significant group difference, reading books widely and
comprehension much more than extensive reading with tablets, although the
to get linguistic input and grasp its context regularly, enhancing their familiarity
rules, significantly differs from learning through natural exposure to the target
language.
Learners acquire shallow and quick reading habits while using digital
devices for enjoyment, such as surfing the web, talking with friends in real-time,
and sending messages on social network sites, according to (Stole et al., 2020).
Reading is one of the most effective methods for learning a new language or
mastering an old one. It is helpful not only in language learning but also in other
aspects like for educational purposes and personal pleasure. However, because of
Books can now be read in either printed or digital form. This resulted in a division
in the preference of the readers. As readers and consumers, they have their reasons
for choosing the most effective and suited material for them. Thus, the researchers
investigated and understood the respondents' reading preferences and their reasons.
Theoretical Framework
Gratification Theory.
32
ecological studies of competing animal populations and has been applied to the
competition in the media for consumers' shared resources. When faced with a new
medium, an existing medium must adapt, converge, or become outdated. Niche and
for economic purposes. It also shows how different media compete and coexist in
contexts with limited resources by measuring the uses and gratification of media.
growth strategy, and its place in the social media market. This study made use of
this theory to know the difference between the two reading materials: printed and
multimedia or digital. Furthermore, this theory will help determine how each
(1974). It takes the relationship between media texts and audiences a step further.
The Uses and Gratification Theory claims that audiences are active participants in
the communication process, based on the notion that texts are open and audiences
generate their meaning. They select media texts to meet their requirements, such as
choose the media they read are engaged and driven according to uses and
gratifications. The theory is based on two principles: media consumers are actively
involved in selecting the media they read and are aware of their motivations for
33
doing so. This theory is related to Niche theory because it helps determine the
Conceptual Framework
dependent variables are included in the diagram: the extent of utilization of the
second language.
variables. Another arrow is drawn between the two dependent variables; this time,
it is a two-way arrow and shows that these two variables affect each other.
34
Conceptual Framework
Reading
Preference Extent of
Effectiveness
Utilization
in Learning
❖ Printed of the
Second
Reading Preferred
Language
Materials Reading
❖ Digital Material
Reading
Material
35
Null Hypotheses
H01: There is no significant difference between the printed and digital reading
CHAPTER 2
Methodology
This chapter presents the study's research design, locale and respondents,
Research Design
extent of utilization, and the effectiveness of the preferred reading materials of the
between printed and digital reading material and the extent of utilization.
specifically the students who were currently enrolled for the second semester in the
Sampling Technique
were selected following specific criteria. Samples have been taken into
students who are currently enrolled as second-year students for the second semester
Research Instrument
and the data gathered will be evaluated and computed after that. The survey
questionnaire served as the main research instrument to gather the data. The
questionnaire and test survey are composed of five (5) parts. The first is the
demographic profiles of the respondents in terms of sex and major. The second part
contains their reading preferences, whether they will choose multimedia or digital
reading materials or printed books. The third part contains the reasons for the
preference in the choice of reading materials. The fourth part contains the extent of
utilization of the preferred reading materials. The last part of the questionnaire
objectives.
Content validity was obtained from the second-year students of the College
of Education on which reading materials they prefer. For the face and content
validity, the adviser and three validators checked and reviewed the questionnaire to
construction, and fitness of content. The researchers conducted the pilot test on 20
College. Cronbach alpha was used to determine the reliability of items with an r-
gather the primary data. The researchers submitted the study and waited for its
approval of it. After the approval of the teacher and adviser, the researchers
prepared the survey form and selected the respondents who answered the survey
questionnaires. Lastly, the researchers analyzed and interpreted the gathered data.
The researchers asked permission from the Dean of the College of Education of
39
Notre Dame of Midsayap College. After seeking approval, the researchers asked
for the total population of all the second-year students currently enrolled in the
answered the questionnaire, the researchers gathered the data subjected to analysis
distribution, and ranking to determine the reasons for the respondents learning a
second language
For part III. The researchers utilized weighted mean and standard deviation
For Part IV. The researchers utilized weighted mean and standard deviation
For Part V. The researchers utilized a t-test to test the significant difference
between the extent of utilization and the printed and digital reading material.
40
Finally, for Part VI. Pearson – r correlation was used to testing the
CHAPTER 3
Results
This chapter presents the result of the statistical treatment of the data and its
interpretation based on the research pursued. The discussion covers the reading
preference, possible reasons for the preferred reading materials, the extent of
language learning.
Reading Preference
__________________________________________________________________
Variable Frequency Percentage
__________________________________________________________________
Reading Preference
Printed Books 41 58.6
Multimedia/Digital 29 41
Total 70 100.0
__________________________________________________________________
The data revealed that 41 or 58.6 percent of the respondents chose printed
reading material.
Table 2 presents the reasons for the preferred reading materials of the CED
students.
42
Table 2. Reasons for the preferred reading materials of the CED students in second
language learning.
The result shows that the item with the highest rank for the printed reading
materials is number 4; I can physically highlight or write on it, which ranks first
applications, which ranked second and have a percentage of 47.14. On the other
hand, the items that have the lowest rank are number 1, I like holding the book in
my hands; number 5, I can quickly flip through pages; number 6, I can quickly
isolate a passage and go back whenever I need to; and 7, Printed books are more
cost-effective than digital reading materials, which ranked at 5.5th and have a
percentage of 40.00.
The item that got the highest rank for the digital reading materials is item
number 7; I can find the books online and easily access them through my mobile
phone, laptop, and other gadgets using any platform I like, which ranked first and
the text focusing on the keywords, which ranked second and have a percentage of
30.00. While the item that got the lowest rank is number 4, I can carry multiple
Table 3 presents the extent of utilization of the respondents for printed and
digital reading materials.
44
The result shows that item number 3 yielded the highest mean value of
states that I extend my reading time especially when the materials are difficult to
0.815. While item 8, I do not mind the cost of the materials as long as I can access
and read them, obtained the low mean rating of 3.086, which is described as
Table 4 shows the perceived effectiveness of printed and digital reading materials.
The result shows that the item with the highest mean is item number
and obtained a standard deviation of 0.64. The following item with the highest mean
mean of 4.24, described as “Strongly Agree” and has a standard deviation of 0.67.
While item number 6, Have even more confidence and ability to communicate in
English has the lowest mean with 3.957, described as “Agree,” and obtained a
described as "Agree”.
Table 5. The significant difference between the reading preference and the
extent of the utilization of the preferred reading material.
47
and the extent of utilizing the preferred reading materials since the p-value is 0.367,
which is greater than the level of significance of 0.05. This implied that the H01 or
null hypothesis was accepted. The test utilized here is the t-test.
Table 6. The significant relationship between the extent of the preferred reading
materials and their perceived effectiveness of the respondents
of the preferred reading materials and their perceived effectiveness since the p-
48
value is 0.000, which is less than the significance level of 0.05. This also shows
that it is highly significant, and there is a strong correlation between the extent of
utilization and the perceived effectiveness. Therefore, the H02 or null hypothesis is
rejected, and Ha2 or alternative hypothesis is accepted. The test utilized here is the
Pearson-r correlation.
49
CHAPTER 4
Discussion
This chapter discusses the present findings of the investigation based on the
Reading Preference
The results revealed that the respondents' most preferred reading material
is the printed format. This means that even with technology, the students from Notre
Dame of Midsayap College still prefer to use printed reading material to digital
reading material as a medium for learning English as a second language. This result
is supported by the study of Hussain et al. (2015), who measured the impact of e-
who read from printed materials retained more information and had a better
knowledge of the text than those who read from a computer screen or electronic
reading. This implies that students prefer printed reading materials because most of
the time, they cannot understand the things that they read in the digital form, so
they tend to print it out and are more likely to use distinct aspects in print books
The findings showed that out of eight reasons for choosing printed
books, item number 4, I can physically highlight or write on it, got the highest rank.
Students preferred printed books because they could write the details and notes
directly on the printed material. This implies that reading becomes effective when
they can physically write and write explanations near the words or sentences they
Nishimura et al. (2015), where it appears that using a highlighter pen to make notes
help students enhance their academic achievement. It helps learners achieve one of
their main goals, and marking with a highlighter pen can help them learn more
computational ability.
notifications or ads coming from different application, which ranked second. This
means that students do not want any distractions. Also, they prefer reading printed
materials to avoid temptations and opening other applications just because they got
interested from the pop-up ads or notification of a specific application. This finding
is in line with what Claburn (2015) stated, If someone is attempting to ignore alerts
from their phone while writing a paper or performing another work that demands
some level of cognitive load, and they discover that thoughts about those
notifications are distracting them, their productivity will most certainly suffer.
Similarly, Baron et al.'s (2017) study stated that more than nine out of ten
respondents stated that reading in print made it easier to focus. It implies that
51
students get easily distracted by the sudden notification and pop-up ads on their
phones which lead them to multitask. That is why they chose printed reading
materials because they can turn off their phones or put them in a place where they
On the other hand, the items that have the lowest rank are number 1, I like
holding the book in my hands; number 5, I can quickly flip through pages; number
6, I can quickly isolate a passage and go back whenever I need to; and 7, Printed
books are more cost-effective than digital reading material. This means that their
reasons for picking printed reading materials are not because they will be able to
feel the book bare-handed, feel and flip every page physically, concentrate and
focus on a particular text and be able to afford each other books they want to read.
This implies that the respondents do not mind if they can hold, touch, and feel the
reading material; they believe that printed materials are cheaper than digital reading
materials. This finding is related to the study of Baron et al. (2017), which stated
that University students are typically concerned about saving money. "Cash
dominates everything around me," one participant said in one pilot research, while
of all "like least" replies regarding reading in hardcopy were concerns about the
price of print in the present research. College textbooks are undeniably pricey.
For multimedia or digital reading material, the findings show that out of
eight reasons, item number 7, I can find the books online and easily access them
through my mobile phone, laptop, and other gadgets using any platform I like, got
the highest rank. This means that digital materials are more accessible and easier to
52
find. This implies that the respondents prefer it because there is a big chance that
the materials or the needed books are available in digital form, and they can access
on the keyword, which ranked second. This means that if the readers are looking
for a piece of specific information on the material, there is no need to scan or read
the whole book, for a reader can simply search for the keyword, and all the related
information will become accessible. Then this implies that isolating a specific text
or going back to the part where one stopped reading becomes more accessible
because a reader needs to search for the keyword and the information then the page
that one wanted to return to becomes visible without putting much effort.
The finding is analogous to the study of Baron et al. (2017), which stated
there that on a digital screen, a reader could come across different materials and
read them right away. However, in hardcopy, a reader must set aside time to read.
The level to which young adults in all nations being questioned indicated a passion
for traditional characteristics of print was one of the most startling findings from
the open-ended questions. Students loved the capacity to search (for words, for
information) when reading onscreen and stated that it was "genuine reading" and
claimed that they could not do so with print. Online access may undoubtedly be
While the item with the lowest rank is number 4, I can carry multiple books
simultaneously. It is the reason which is the least picked by the respondents. This
implies that this is a minor concern for the students regarding their preferred reading
material. They tend to choose the reason which is more relatable to them. No
previous studies would support or are similar to the study's findings. Most of the
study states that students or learners prefer multimedia or digital reading materials
for they can store many books on their devices or gadgets. Similar to the survey
conducted by Ph.D. Essay (2017) stated that an e-book is a collection of books that
may be made available for your electronic books without worrying about the
number of books you have stored. As a result, anyone can carry a digital device
and read at any time and location without using batteries. The results are also in
congruence with the theory Uses and Gratification theory because it states the
The highest item for the extent of utilization of the preferred reading
material of the respondents is item 3; I extend my reading time especially when the
more reliable information. Since these statements gained the highest means labeled
as Almost Always by the respondents, students can learn more while studying using
The result of this study is supported by the idea of Larhmaid (2018) that one
major advantage of print reading is that it offers readers access to the text in its
entirety. This access is built up on visual and tactile cues, whereby the reader can
see and "tactilely feel the spatial and physical dimensions" of the text. It implies
that students learn effectively when they fully pay attention to reading. Also,
reading becomes effective when the materials they read suffice the things they need.
The lowest item for the extent of utilization of the preferred reading material
of the respondents is item 8; I do not mind the cost of the materials as long as I can
access and read them. Since this statement got the lowest mean, labeled as
Oftentimes, it indicates that students prefer reading free materials rather than
paying for them. The result of this study is supported by the study of Barshay
(2019). Her reading research also supports well-intended advice for students to save
money. A July 2019 report from the National Association of College Stores shows
that 22 percent of college students use free course materials, up from 3 percent in
2015.
This implies that consumers or readers always consider the amount of the
reading material before purchasing because they do not want their money to be
July 2019 that it was moving to a “digital first” strategy. Books will still be
available to rent, but students will be discouraged from buying them by higher
prices, fewer updates, and limited availability (Barshay, 2019). The results are also
55
it states how printed and digital reading materials satisfy the needs of the
respondents.
The results revealed that out of the eight (8) items in the questionnaire under
Table 5, item 1; Improved my vocabulary, received the highest mean, and was
described as Always. This means that the respondents preferred reading materials
structure received the second highest mean described as Always. This means that
the respondents’ preferred reading material helps them enrich their knowledge of
English grammar structure. On the other hand, item 6 has even more confidence,
and the ability to communicate in English got the lowest mean, which is Almost
Always.
This finding supports the study of Palani (2012) that effective reading is the
background knowledge about many different things that absorb the essentials of
vocabulary skills, and has been shown to increase our understanding of human
behavior and help us to empathize with others. In addition, both vocabulary and
relates to the connection of meaning with the choice of correct meaning based on
the context, word symbols, and the ability to understand meanings from words,
understand language syntax to easily comprehend the text (Hamra et al., 2010).
The Difference between Printed and Digital Reading Materials and the
Extent of Utilization
reading preferences. This implies that the respondents frequently utilized both
printed and digital reading preferences. This is parallel to the study of Schijns et al.
(2010) found that there is no significant difference between the two preferred
reading methods. Another study by Eden and Eshet-Alkalai (2013) stated that
comparing their active reading abilities using digital versus printed formats showed
utilization of the preferred reading materials and their perceived effectiveness since
the p-value is 0.000, less than the significance level of 0.05. Reject the H02 or null
hypothesis and accept the Ha1 or the alternative hypothesis. This only means that
the extent of utilization affects the perceived effectiveness of the preferred reading
material. It implies that the said reading materials are a great factor in the
assisting students in doing considerable research. Many teachers feel that learners
should read challenging books and be pushed when learning to read. Perhaps they
believe that challenging literature prepares them for reading stuff published in their
language (Day, 2017). The result also shows that it is highly significant, and there
effectiveness
Summary of Findings
The respondents belong to the age bracket of 19-21 years old. The majority
of them are female, Roman Catholic, and Cebuano. They all belong to the same
number of respondents for each specialization is almost the same except for Science
For their reasons, many respondents who preferred printed books wanted to
highlight and write on the materials physically. While for multimedia or digital
reading material, their reason is that they can easily find and access the books or
materials online through their mobile phones, laptop, computer, and other gadgets
information, extend their reading time, especially when the materials are
complicated, and read the material because it helps in reducing their stress.
improved.
Conclusions
Based on the study's findings, it was clearly shown that most respondents
Reading becomes effective for the respondents because they can highlight the text
and write notes and explanations near the highlighted texts. However, it could also
cost, and satisfaction. Both reading materials are effective in terms of second
aspects. Whatever reading materials the respondents have, they do not matter for as
Recommendations
1. Students should know how to distinguish the suitable reading materials for
2. Teachers should know the pros and cons of using printed and digital reading
second language.
3. More printed materials should be available in the school library for the
students to borrow.
2. To conduct a study that does not just focus on individuals who only rely on
one specific reading material but also on those who prefer both printed and
References
[Link]
Anuar, A. & Wan, A. (2021). Finding Comfort: A Study of Reading Habits among
10.6007/IJARBSS/v11-i11/11583.
Apuke, O. D., & Iyendo, T. O. (2018). University students' usage of the internet
[Link]
Aubron, X. (2018, August 21). Pros and Cons Of Digital Texts. Gutenberg-
[Link]/en/pros-and-cons-of-digital-texts
Baron, N., Calixte, R. & Havewala, M. (2016). The Persistence of Print among
[Link]
atastream/PDF/view
screens. [Link]
paper-instead-of-screens/
Benedetto, S., Drai-Zerbib, V., Pedrotti, M., Tissier, G., & Baccino, T. (2013). E-
[Link]
Bushak, L. (2015, January 11). E-Books Are Damaging Your Health: Why We
[Link]
we-should-all-start-reading-paper-books-again-317212
Chen, G., Cheng, W., Chang, T.-W., Zheng, X., & Huang, R. (2014). A comparison
213-225.
and-language-learning/
Dew, J. (2010). Global, mobile, virtual, and social: The college campus of
Dogruer, N., Eyyam, R. & Menevis, I. (2011). The use of the internet for
611. 10.1016/[Link].2011.11.115.
[Link]
cation_Assessment_and_Student_Preferences_for_Learning_E_textbook_
versus_Paper_Textbook
[Link]
printed-books
E-books or Print Books: Which Do You Prefer?. (2017, Nov 07). Retrieved from
[Link]
Eijansantos, A., Alieto, E., Morgia, J. & Ricohermoso, C. (2020). Print-Based Texts
[Link]
Fowler, R.L., & Barker, A.S. (1974). Effectiveness of highlighting for retention of
364. [Link]
Gulnur, A., Ayranci, B.B. (2018). Reading Preferences of Middle School Students.
Haniff, Z. (2012). "Niche Theory in New Media: Is Digital Overtaking the Print
Hwang, H. J., Kim, H. K., Mahmood, M., & Dawi, N. M. (2022). Applying Niche
[Link]
Jolliffe, David & Harl, Allison. (2008). Texts of our institutional lives: Studying the
"Reading Transition" from high school to college: What are our students
[Link]
utional_lives_Studying_the_Reading_Transition_from_high_school_to_co
llege_What_are_our_students_reading_and_why
65
[Link]
[Link]
Prefer and Why?. Journal of Teaching in Travel & Tourism, 15:2, 166-185.
[Link]
efer_textbooks
Cham. [Link]
Oroz S., (2016) Exploring the Reading Preferences in Digital and Printed Text
Palani, K.K., (2012). Promoting reading habits and creating literate society.
Popkins. (2021). How important is reading for learning a foreign language? How
learning-a-foreign-language/
Park, J., & Lee, J. (2021). Effects of e-books and printed books on EFL learners’
76(3), 35-61.
Porion, Alexandre & Aparicio, Xavier & Megalakaki, Olga & Robert, Alisson &
Human Behavior.
Academy. [Link]
languages-learn-study/
Rao, K.N., Tripathi, M., & Kumar, S., (2016). Cost of Print and Digital
Sales, L., Hayward, M., Loyola R. (2021). What do you mean by “niche”?
Modern ecological theories are not coherent on rhetoric about the niche
[Link]
Seitz, L., (2010). Student attitudes toward reading: A case study. Journal of Inquiry
Sidabutar, M.N.A., Sayed, B.T., Ismail, S.M., Quispe, J.T., Vicente, J.S.Y., Wekke,
I.S., Shannan, AJ., Nourabadi, S. (2022) Reading Digital Texts Vs. Reading
pages [Link]
68
Stephens, M. (2014). Beyond news: The future of journalism. New York, NY:
Team Leverage Edu (2021). eBooks vs Printed Books: Which are better?.
[Link]
[Link]
second-language-acquisition/
[Link]
Tien, C.-Y., (2015). A large-scale study on extensive reading program for non-
gratifications-theory-4628333
Whitten C., (2016). The impact of Pleasure Reading on Academic Success. The
pp. 48-64.
69
[Link]
70
Survey Questionnaire
Directions: Kindly supply the needed data by writing the information on the
space provided.
Age : ____________________________
Sex : ____________________________
Specialization : ____________________________
Religion : ____________________________
Directions: Below are possible types of reading materials that college students
prefer to enhance their Second Language Learning. Please put a check on the box
of your preferred answer. Choose only one preference.
Directions: Below are possible reasons of the students for their preferred reading
materials. Please check the box that indicates your actual reason. Check as many
items as you can.
Only for those who preferred Printed Reading Materials. Check as many
items as you can.
Only for those who preferred Digital Reading Materials. Check as many
items as you can.
I can find the books online and easily access them through
my mobile phone, laptop, and other gadgets using any
platform I like.
________________________________________________
________________________________________________
________________________
Directions: Below are statements setting out the extent of utilization of the
preferred reading materials. Put a check on the number (1, 2, 3, 4, or 5) which you
believe corresponds to the given questions, where:
Scale Description
5- Always
4- Almost Always
3- Oftentimes
2- Sometimes
1- Never
73
5 4 3 2 1
Statements A AA O S N
Directions: Below are statements setting out the effectiveness of the preferred
reading materials of the CED students in second language learning. Put a check
on the number (1, 2, 3, 4, or 5) which you think corresponds to the given
questions, where:
Scale Description
5- Strongly Agree
4- Agree
3- Moderate
2- Disagree
1- Strongly Disagree
74
Statements 5 4 3 2 1
SA A M D SD
1. Improved my vocabulary.
CURRICULUM VITAE
I. PROFILE
Tribe: Ilonngo
I. EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Position Held:
Member
College of Education
2019- Present
79
CURRICULUM VITAE
I. PROFILE
Tribe: Cebuano
I. EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Position Held:
Member
College of Education
2019- Present
80
CURRICULUM VITAE
I. PROFILE
Tribe: Cebuano
Position Held:
Member
College of Education
2019- Present
Managing Editor
Regina Yearbook
2021- Present