0% found this document useful (0 votes)
89 views3 pages

Foundations of Realism in Education

This document discusses the philosophy of realism and its implications for education. Realism is the view that the world exists independently of human minds and perceptions. There are three branches of realism: classical, religious, and modern. Classical realism is attributed to Aristotle and suggests that matter exists independently of perceptions. Religious realism was founded by Aquinas and holds that God's existence can be proven through reasoning. Modern realism was advocated by Bacon and Locke and focuses on inductive reasoning and experience. Realism forms the foundation of scientific reasoning. Educators who follow realism encourage drawing conclusions from observations of the world rather than just ideas. The realist curriculum focuses on subjects like reading, writing, arithmetic, and science

Uploaded by

joan arreola
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
89 views3 pages

Foundations of Realism in Education

This document discusses the philosophy of realism and its implications for education. Realism is the view that the world exists independently of human minds and perceptions. There are three branches of realism: classical, religious, and modern. Classical realism is attributed to Aristotle and suggests that matter exists independently of perceptions. Religious realism was founded by Aquinas and holds that God's existence can be proven through reasoning. Modern realism was advocated by Bacon and Locke and focuses on inductive reasoning and experience. Realism forms the foundation of scientific reasoning. Educators who follow realism encourage drawing conclusions from observations of the world rather than just ideas. The realist curriculum focuses on subjects like reading, writing, arithmetic, and science

Uploaded by

joan arreola
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

In 1973, Maxine Greene, an American educational philosopher, once said, “Do philosophy,” challenging

the educators of her time. Her aim in stating this is that she wanted the educators to open their minds to taking risks
and focus on a whole different perspective when it comes to the methods of teaching and strategies for promoting
education. It's true that all foundations of education aim to propose set goals for the curriculum. However, to think of
philosophy as your basis introduces the practice of thinking thoroughly in creating those goals from which those goals
are created. Having a philosophical foundation for the curriculum allows us to identify our motivation, the driving
purpose of education, and what should be expected from those who benefit from it.

In her article, Harrington-Atkinson (2017) mentioned that there are at least four major philosophical principles within
education, which can be sorted into either traditional or contemporary views. Those traditional ideas include idealism
and realism, while their counterparts, pragmatism and existentialism, are more on the contemporary side.

Realism

In simple terms, realism is the conception that the world exists in terms of matter, that it can make sense through
reasonable reasoning and senses as it is experienced through nature, and that it is separate from the world of ideas
and entirely independent of it (Ornstein & Hunkins, 2009). Realism emphasizes logic and activities or experiences
that will develop additional reasoning and thoughts.

The realist’s school of thought is traced back to Aristotle, a classical Greek philosopher and polymath from 384–322
BC, a student of Plato. From Aristotle’s philosophy, he believes that matter or objects, anything that we see today, exist
by themselves and can exist with or without the existence of man, meaning that they are not a construct of the human
mind.

Like idealism, there are three branches of realism: classical, religious, and modern.

Obviously, Aristotle’s take on realism falls back on classical realism, which suggests that matter is real and that it is
separate from our perceptions. Matter still exists even though you may not see, hear, or feel it. He asserted that ideas
can exist without matter, but matter cannot exist without ideas. Education cultivates the capacity to reason, which
allows for proper choices. If one understands the matter, then one will be led to understand the idea. Additionally, he
advocated the idea of free will after he realized that there were some who chose not to reason. Still, he encouraged
humanity to seek the Golden Mean, the desirable middle of what is deficient and excess. In the end, this branch of
philosophy boils down to one question: “What is its purpose?”

It was St. Thomas Aquinas (1225–1274) who founded Religious Realism, in which he trusted that God is pure
reasoning, the truth of all things. He believed that the existence of God could be proven in five ways, mainly by:
1) observing movement in the world as proof of God, the "Immovable Mover"
2) observing cause and effect and identifying God as the cause of everything
3) concluding that the impermanent nature of beings proves the existence of a necessary being, God, who originates
only from within himself
4) noticing varying levels of human perfection and determining that a supreme, perfect being must therefore exist;
and
5) knowing that natural beings could not have intelligence without it being granted to them by God.

Modern realism was advocated by two philosophers, Francis Bacon (1561–1626) and John Locke (1632–1704). In his
time, Bacon attempted to revise the structure of realism from deductive reasoning, “top down," if A=B and B=C, then
A=C approach, to an inductive, “cause-and-effect reasoning," approach where he would reform realists’ thinking from
a specific idea in the physical world to a more general assumption. Inductive reasoning relies on patterns and trends,
while deductive reasoning relies on facts and rules. Meanwhile, Locke inferred that everything we know, at this exact
moment, comes from our experience and from our reactions to it. That we are a blank slate without any innate or
preconceived ideas.
It is known that Realism is the foundation of scientific reasoning. Educators who follow a realistic manner of thought
tend to encourage their students to draw their observations and conclusions from the world around them, rather than
confining themselves to an analysis of their own ideas and are less likely to encourage their students to seek the truth
in literature and ideas. According to Ritz (2006), the curriculum for these realists consists of reading, writing
arithmetic, science and the arts. They are objective educators who lean on a systematic approach to order and
classified knowledge, building on previously learned information.

Under this curriculum, the following principles are upheld:


● the principle of independence of matter,
● the principle of orderliness of the world behind its organization, this means that law and order prevail in the
universe,
● the principle of the world as real as discovered by the scientist.

The educational implication of realism curriculum includes:


● The ultimate educational aim is achievement of knowledge of nature and inner workings of the universe.
● Education is essentially transmission of inherited culture from one generation to another.
● Disciplines of curriculum should contain certain elements of culture.
● Students should learn disciplines to develop intellectual skills to discover important principles and theoretical
insights.

Based on this philosophy, there should be a core curriculum for every learner.
References

[Link] Editors. (2021, April 27). Saint Thomas Aquinas. Biography. Retrieved September 20, 2022, from
[Link]
Button, L. (n.d.). Philosophical Foundations of Curriculum – Curriculum Essentials: A Journey. Pressbooks. Retrieved
September 20, 2022, from [Link]
Harrington-Atkinson, T. (2017, February 13). Curriculum Foundations. Paving the Way. Retrieved September 20, 2022, from
[Link]
Inductive vs. Deductive Reasoning. (n.d.). Indeed Career Guide. Retrieved September 20, 2022, from
[Link]
Lynch, M. (2021, November 2). What is a Master’s Degree? The Edvocate. Retrieved September 20, 2022, from
[Link]
probably%20had%20the%20greatest%20impact%20on,themselves%20to%20an%20analysis%20of%20their%20own%20ide
as.
Philosophical Foundations Of Education | CMASAS Online School. (n.d.). Retrieved September 20, 2022, from
[Link]
20of%20curriculum%20helps%20determine%20the,of%20thinking%20from%20which%20those%20goals%20are%20create
d.
What Is the Philosophy of Plato? (2022, September 14). Language Humanities. Retrieved September 20, 2022, from
[Link]

Common questions

Powered by AI

Aristotle's classical realism is based on the idea that matter exists independently of human perception, focusing on educating the capacity to reason and choose properly between deficiency and excess. In contrast, modern realism, as advocated by Francis Bacon, emphasizes inductive reasoning from specific observations to general conclusions. John Locke's perspective adds that knowledge stems from experience rather than innate ideas, portraying the mind as a blank slate shaped by environmental interactions. Educationally, classical realism prioritizes understanding fixed truths of the natural world, whereas modern realism encourages experiential learning and reasoning from empirical evidence .

Philosophical foundations significantly influence curriculum decisions by determining what knowledge is valuable and how it should be taught. This philosophy suggests that the role of educators transcends mere instruction; they are key agents in shaping mindset, ethics, and reasoning capacities in students. For instance, if realism guides the curriculum choices, educators are expected to teach empirical thinking and emphasize knowledge about the natural world and cultural heritage. This role requires educators to embrace a philosophical mindset, continually reflecting on and questioning the deeper purposes and methods of their teaching practice .

Educational outcomes from a system based on classical realism include developing the ability to reason and make proper choices, achieving knowledge about the nature and inner workings of the universe, and understanding the fixed truths through empirical investigation. Classical realism aims for students to grasp the constancy and reality of the natural world, encouraging them to apply logical thinking and observation to discern truth from falsehood. This educational philosophy aspires to cultivate intellectual skills adapting to both theoretical insights and practical applications through a structured and disciplined curriculum .

St. Thomas Aquinas' religious realism integrates God into reality as the ultimate reason and truth of all existence. He proposes that God's existence can be observed through natural phenomena, including motion, cause and effect, and varying levels of perfection in human beings. The educational impact of this view is profound, as it positions learning not just as an assimilation of empirical facts but as a way to discover divine truths through reason. This approach encourages integrating theology into the curriculum, focusing on understanding the universe in a way that aligns with divine order and reasoning .

The shift from deductive to inductive reasoning in modern realism influences educational practices by promoting a learning approach that begins with specific observations leading to broader generalizations. Deductive reasoning follows a 'top-down' logic, whereas inductive reasoning encourages exploration and pattern recognition as bases for forming conclusions. This transition in educational practice encourages students to engage directly with their environment, observe trends, and form ideas rooted in empirical evidence. It supports a learning environment that fosters scientific inquiry and critical thinking .

Philosophy plays a crucial role in forming educational goals and strategies by providing a framework for understanding the motivations, purposes, and expectations of education. Maxine Greene highlights the importance of a philosophical foundation to encourage educators to think deeply and creatively about educational methods and strategies. This promotes an education system that is not merely procedural but deeply reflective and aligned with broader existential and pragmatic principles. Philosophical perspectives, such as realism, also shape what is considered important knowledge and how it is transmitted to learners .

Realism shapes the curriculum by emphasizing objective reasoning and the development of knowledge through observation and experience. It encourages a curriculum that includes reading, writing, arithmetic, science, and the arts, where order and classified knowledge build on previously learned information. The ultimate educational aim is the achievement of knowledge about nature and the universe's inner workings. Education transmits inherited culture and helps students develop intellectual skills to discover theoretical insights, grounding education in the real world's understanding rather than abstract ideas .

Maxine Greene encouraged educators to 'do philosophy' to open their minds to taking risks and focusing on different perspectives in teaching methods, contrasting with traditional educational goals that often emphasize fixed curriculums. She believed that using philosophy as a foundation allows educators to thoroughly think through the creation of educational goals, identifying motivations and purposes in education, which traditional methods may overlook .

The principles of orderliness and the independence of matter in realism both contribute to a systematic educational approach by providing a structured way of understanding the universe. The principle of orderliness posits that law and order are inherent to the world's organization, implying that education should transmit knowledge in a structured, sequential manner that reflects this natural order. The independence of matter suggests that matter exists objectively, independent of human perception, which emphasizes learning through empirical observations over subjective interpretations. Together, these principles guide educators to develop curricula that build on established knowledge systematically, fostering an educational environment that values logic, order, and empirical understanding .

Existentialism significantly differs from realism in educational philosophy by emphasizing individual student experiences, personal choice, and subjective meaning-making over objective reality. While realism focuses on empirical observation and learning facts about the world independent of individual perception, existentialism values the development of personal identity and the exploration of one's own values and beliefs. Existentialist education encourages students to find their own path and purpose, evaluating the meaning and implications of their choices, whereas realism centers on grounding education in observable and objective truths .

You might also like