Surname 1

Author

Tutor

Course

Date

Analysis: What does it all mean?

Introduction

Through this book, “What does it all mean” by Thomas Nagel offers serves as a

compelling for a significant introduction to the philosophical environment. The author puts forth

the common issues of intellectual inquiry experienced by the students at the start of philosophy.

The book holds that better learning and comprehension of philosophy is achieved through

thinking about its queries directly. Various subjects like mathematics have a formal poof

technique, while philosophy is grounded on arguments, asking questions, attempting ideas, and

reckoning out the reasons for and against them. Also, unlike art, philosophy seems not to rely on

experiments or observations but precisely relies on thinking. In the current civilization,

individuals cannot get down minus intriguing important thoughts of the moment, true and false,

knowledge, and the figure for granted. Thus, the aim why philosophy examines these factors one

after the other.

Thomas Nagel, under this book, holds that human beings should be querying themselves

the way their minds relate to their brains. It might turn out to be a complex question. However,

this will help us think beyond common knowledge. Through the book, Nagel brings to the public

a continuous feature that has been fascinating and baffling over the centuries. On many

occasions, our society has lost morals. Sometimes, it has lacked some significant philosophical

comprehension that we are obligated to give essentials on the problem-solving day in day out. As
 Surname 2

a result, Nagel inspires our reasoning to hypothesize and following challenges concerns at and

past outcomes (Nagel, 3). Therefore, the paper aims to significantly scrutinize three sections

from Thomas Nagel's short story of what it means: Chapter Two, Six, and Ten.

Chapter 2: How do we know everything?

In this chapter, Thomas Nagel attempts to unwrap up people's minds and assume many

things in life. He triggers individuals' ability to think critically concerning things that they think

they know without necessary proofing. To attain his goal, Nagel employs a technique of

knowledge as a fundamental learning component. He starts by expressing general knowledge to

the audience through what one thinks in the thing. Based on this chapter, human beliefs on things

that they must think that they know are primarily determined by whatever they encounter in life

and whatever is in their thoughts. For instance, what individuals believe regarding the sun,

history, or other individuals is mainly grounded on their life encounters and beliefs (Nagel, 2).

Things people believe in life are the ones they should go to about directly. As a result,

everything else regarding their beliefs is far away from their inner thoughts and experiences.

This chapter offers the audience an opportunity to solicit themselves how they distinguish certain

features. It could be the hopelessness of what is believed to thrive in certainty or the material

universe external. The chapter offers an understanding of matters that are discussed in an

individual's mind whether or not they have to hold in the outside globe even with its fantasy.

The mode of philosophical queries that he poses to the audience has a more significant

image of the external world outside the human mind. According to Nagel, inside an individual's

mind, the only object that we can be so certain of is that they believe. That is what is pure of an

individual's sense. Ascertaining the certainties of an individual's ideas through the petition of his

mind is merely rounded thinking. The face of what one believes is similar to a gigantic dream in
 Surname 3

case of its wellbeing (Libet, 47). This implies an eternal universe outside our thoughts that will

be a portion of the enormous dream.

Moreover, Nagel provides proof concerning what people think could be visible in the

humanity external through an individual's mind. He says, “…maybe there is no physical world

outside our minds” (Nagel, 2). The writer said that maybe it was the only individual, subjects of

experiences, just what existed. Based on his assertions, people are not very sure regarding the

aim of the ancient thriving as current information fills our minds. In his discussion, he signifies

that there is a material globe and just because in formulated life encounters have inner bases. It is

tough to avert from an individual's recognition of a physical globe outside of their minds. In this

regard, the author attempts to think inside the box in conjunction with the audience on what leads

to things being viewed the way they are. That is why he holds that all is based on people's

experiences concerning what they think. In this manner, it depends significantly on what people

even distinguish, or they have no plan of their being. One cannot be certain of what he does here

or reads from book, yet he has not observed them, as they could be simply fantasies (Nagel, 1).

Similarly, in this chapter, Nagel establishes the concept of solipsism. This concept drives

people to see what tells them that there is no existence of the external world. Various individuals

appear not to recognize this aspect at all. In other terms, Nagel tries to say people's minds are

empty, as nothing exists on them. This clearly shows that whatever remains when our minds are

empty is just illusions formulated by our brains on their own. Also, Nagel distinguishes the point

of verification, which focuses on telling people that whatever they see and observe are the ideas

they have as they can also pursue them. On some occasions, what people can see might not be

correct, and at the same time, it can be confirmed from another lens of focus. Also, Nagel
 Surname 4

discusses death in this chapter. He says that the end of good or evils deeds is dead. Nagel holds

that death cannot conceive us without impressing the world we dwell in currently.

Chapter 6: Free Will

In the explanations of ideas under this chapter, the author utilizes a peach and chocolate

cake in showing how people choose life. For example, if an individual decides to settle on a cake

to peach then afterward begins complaining, it implies that he made a bad selection. In this

regard, the cake is seen to pose various effects on an individual's wellbeing, such as fattening,

which in return can culminate in illnesses such as high blood pressure. Hence, lamenting that he

could have picked peach over the cake, it is evident that he made a bad selection. However, no

one obliged him to pick the cake over the peach, and it was his own choice. In this regard, it is

evident that it was resolute that in advance that his selection would be a cake, not a fruit (Nagel,

12). If his preferred option were a fruit, nothing would have ceased him from settling on it over

the cake. As a result, there are predestined scenarios in life, and once they occur, one cannot

annul them back.

Nagel majorly distinguishes matters regarding humanity as a whole that he has to

determine in making real-life situations. The author covers many aspects of a free will idea

viewed as people's freedom to choose and decide which way to select. He does this by reaching

out to people's minds, decreasing their conscious minds, and transforming them into material

explanatory. In this regard, his focus is on what people hold their decisions on to determine their

own choices. He utilizes the demonstration of a scenario where somebody had to settle on what

type of foodstuff to take. Before one makes up his mind on which type of foodstuff to grab or

some additional alternative things he has to choose, it is very significant to take his time to
 Surname 5

decide what he would obtain. As a result, the author notes that due to this idea, one should have

an advanced determination and determinism that does not end up being false (Russell, 2).

A person lives entirely being educated on the best way to perform some things without

necessarily consulting. People achieve their decisions independently as they have in mind the

freedom to choose whatever occurs to them. The given an instance is an apparent sign and

amplifies an individual's free will. This may be an unclear demonstration of free will because; it

is just what people desire at the individual rank of preference that predates their choices.

Moreover, under this chapter, it is evident that free will undermines various aspects of an

individual's life that all have challenges with determinism. Given the scope of determinism, it is

effortless to view the possibilities of people's decisions. Therefore, it is undermined by the

problem of their occupations and activities. From a philosophical perspective, free will matters

are not an issue of responsibilities, actions, or what a precise person has done or could have

attained. It is simply the bafflement of people's activities attributed to what they do every day.

On some occasions, it might be due to a lack of confidence, balancing the situation, or

convictions.

Through this chapter, it is evident in our lives, some things like the sun will rise

tomorrow are determined in advance, unless the universe ceases revolving or the sun ceases

existing, something which cannot happen. However, several things are not defined in advance,

meaning one must perform prior to shaping the outcomes in the aftermath; hence, determinism is

not valid for all people. For example, if determinism were right, no one would be scold or

celebrated for his deeds. Therefore, based on this chapter, it is okay to wrap up that free act is a

significant aspect of the whole universe, which cannot be evaluated. For example, there is a

massive dissimilarity between something occurring with no reason and action is done with no
 Surname 6

reason. Every individual can effortlessly comprehend the distinction between these two, but no

individual can elucidate (Nagel, 2). Nonetheless, various individuals in life will get the condition

disbelieving and unexplained ideas to provide the logic of why one has chosen a fruit rather than

a cake; no one is accountable for his deeds, whether determinism is correct or wrong.

Chapter 10: Meaning of Life

The author explains in detail how people try to discover sense in their lives. Each

individual in the globe is busy attempting to find the purpose of their existence as they toil hard

to attain their life goal. Nevertheless, the truth remains that their sweat is compared to the speed

contest, which can end up not achieving their requirements, as the transformations they are

attaining will by no means be everlasting in being. As a result, one cannot anticipate for this kind

of dishonesty, as one fine date, all of the attainments they obtained will disappear. The decency

queries state that people labor to get a better livelihood; they eat since they are starving and react

since they are tired. In this regard, even if the little attainment one acquires in life cannot be

unending, they are of immense significance; they create their lives more contented. Hence,

human beings ought not to stop laboring hard just as the accomplishment they will create will by

no means be unending.

Nagel holds that there is a diverse feature that establishes the significance of existence.

People do not have a few ideas regarding whatever makes life more significant. As a result,

Nagel distinguishes a sensible discussion as the way of life of what he calls 'Sysiphisian' is

insignificant. The idea does not concern to all fractions of life to be irrelevant. The significance

of life is at times hard to describe as it is a complicated issue to discover a response to. There are

various answers that people are puzzled about, which fit the best with the issue they are running

on. None of these people appears to persuade the importance of life. Through Nagel's views, life
 Surname 7

appears to be precious to others and one. Based on these contradictory means of seeing life as

meaningless, the author holds that people can feel meaningless as they cannot understand the

meaningfulness of a lie if their lives are wild. In this regard, one can sum up by saying that

genuine people's lives might be meaningless.

Similarly, a lack of discussion to distinguish an individual's point of view as a whole

notwithstanding the reasons for the missed items in life is a significant issue of existence. For

example, human actions such as achievement and disappointment cannot be explained. However,

an individual's existence has a considerable value to his parents and the individuals around him.

But those surrounding him, including their lives, have no point either. Thus, the view that God

explains the unexplainable exists. Therefore, believing in God only means that the world is

intelligent but not people because there is no valid reason.

Conclusion

After carrying out a keener analysis of the three chapters, I have realized that all things

that we should believe are just an outcome of our minds. The human mind is the central system

that assists them in believing in things surrounding them. Also, I have realized that most

situations in life that occur cannot be predetermined. People can only act according to their

choices, desires, and feeling, thereby regretting or celebrating the action made. Lastly, I have

realized that if one works so hard, he cannot attain a permanent change. Therefore, no single

creature can define his endpoint.

Work Cited

Libet, Benjamin. "Do we have free will?" Journal of consciousness studies6.8-9 (1999): 47-57.

Nagel, Thomas. What does it all mean? a very short introduction to philosophy. Oxford

University Press, 1987.

Russell, Bertrand. The problems of philosophy. OUP Oxford, 2001.

Steger, Michael F; Kashdan, Todd B; Sullivan, Brandon A; Lorentz, Danielle. "The meaning in

life questionnaire: Assessing the presence of and search for meaning in life." Journal of

counseling psychology 53.1 (2006): 80.