Constantinescu 2019 - SR
Constantinescu 2019 - SR
Background: The effects of perioperative nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) on soft tissue healing in humans have yet
to be established.
Purpose: To systematically review the literature addressing the effects of perioperative NSAID administration on soft tissue healing
and clinical patient outcomes.
Study Design: Systematic review; Level of evidence, 3.
Methods: This review study was conducted in accordance with the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews
and Meta-Analyses) statement. A review of the literature regarding the existing evidence for clinical effects of NSAID use on soft
tissue healing was performed through use of the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, the Cochrane Central Register of
Controlled Trials, PubMed (1980 to present), and MEDLINE. Inclusion criteria for articles were as follows: outcome studies after soft
tissue (ligament, meniscus, tendon, muscle) healing after surgical procedure with perioperative NSAID administration, at least 1
year of follow-up, English language, and human participants.
Results: A total of 466 studies were initially retrieved, with 4 studies satisfying all inclusion criteria. Among the surgical procedures
reported, 93% of the patients (4144/4451) underwent anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction, 3% (120/4451) underwent
rotator cuff repair, 3% (155/4451) underwent Bankart shoulder repair, and 1% (32/4451) underwent meniscal repair. The reported
surgical failure rate among patients administered NSAIDs was 3.6% (157/4360). The reported surgical failure rate among control
participants not given NSAIDs was 3.7% (147/3996). NSAID use showed no statistically significant effect on need for reoperation in
meniscal repair (P ¼ .99), ACL reconstruction (P ¼ .8), and Bankart repair (P ¼ .8) compared with no NSAID administration. Celecoxib
administration had a significantly higher rate of retear (37%) after rotator cuff repair compared with ibuprofen (7%) (P ¼ .009).
Conclusion: Insufficient data are available to definitively state the effects of perioperative NSAIDs on soft tissue healing. Use
of NSAIDs should be considered on a case-by-case basis and may not affect healing rates following either meniscal, ACL,
rotator cuff, or Bankart repair. However, celecoxib (a selective COX-2 inhibitor) may inhibit tendon-to-bone healing in rotator
cuff repair. Further research through clinical trials is required to fully determine whether NSAIDs have an adverse effect on
soft tissue healing.
Keywords: sports medicine; soft tissue; NSAIDs; healing; ACL; meniscus; rotator cuff; Bankart
Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) are used reduce prostaglandin production through the inhibition
to aid recovery by decreasing inflammation and pain after of cyclooxygenase (COX), an important enzyme for the for-
injury.1 This is attributed to the ability of NSAIDs to mation of prostaglandin, an inflammatory mediator, from
arachidonic acid.2 The subsequent reduction of prosta-
The Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine, 7(4), 2325967119838873
glandin concentration alters the cell signaling cascade
DOI: 10.1177/2325967119838873 after musculoskeletal injury and diminishes the inflam-
ª The Author(s) 2019 matory response.
This open-access article is published and distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution - NonCommercial - No Derivatives License ([Link]
licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/), which permits the noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction of the article in any medium, provided the original author and source are
credited. You may not alter, transform, or build upon this article without the permission of the Author(s). For article reuse guidelines, please visit SAGE’s website at
[Link]
1
2 Constantinescu et al The Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine
The inflammatory cascade is a natural response to injury included studies were reviewed to identify any other relevant
that entails the recruitment of macrophages and neutro- articles, and no additional articles were discovered.
phils that remove the resultant necrotic cell debris after The primary outcome measure of our study was to
an injury to provide an initial connective tissue frame- compile all existing studies examining clinical effects of
work.15 Interfering with the inflammatory process by using NSAIDs on soft tissue healing after sports medicine
NSAIDs has been theorized to affect bone and soft tissue orthopaedic surgery procedures in human patients. The
healing. The use of NSAIDs after orthopaedic surgery is a secondary outcomes of our study included identifying the
controversial topic with ongoing research. Conflicting procedures performed and their objective outcome scores
results have been found regarding whether NSAIDs inter- to assess soft tissue healing rates. The level of evidence
fere with bone healing after surgery.4,6,9,12,19 However, the for each article was reported according to Wright et al.28
effects of NSAIDs on soft tissue healing in humans have yet Of the 4 studies included, 3 studies3,22,24 were retrospec-
to be established. Numerous studies on animal models have tive reviews with matched cohorts, providing level 3 evi-
examined the effects of NSAIDs on soft tissue healing but dence. The remaining study21 was described as a level 1
have reported conflicting results.7,8,10,11,13 randomized controlled trial. However, the 24-month
NSAIDs are an effective means of controlling postopera- follow-up was 46% (82/180); therefore, we consider the
tive pain after orthopaedic surgical procedures. Given the level of evidence to be level 2 as a poor-quality random-
opioid crisis in the United States, it is relevant to look for ized controlled trial.
safe alternatives for pain control.29 Thus, the aim of our Risk of bias was analyzed for each of the studies
study was to examine all available clinical studies regard- included. The study by Oh et al21 was a randomized con-
ing the effect of perioperative NSAID administration on trolled trial and was therefore assessed by use of the
soft tissue (ligament, meniscal, tendon, muscle) healing Cochrane “risk of bias” tool.14 Risk-of-bias judgment was
and clinical patient outcomes after sports medicine ortho- deemed “low” across domains 1 through 5, and the study
paedic surgery procedures. We then analyzed differences in was therefore considered to have a low risk of bias. The
healing among varying sports medicine procedures to remaining 3 studies were retrospective cohort studies pro-
determine whether administering NSAIDs caused a detri- viding level 3 evidence and as such were analyzed by use of
the ROBINS-I (Risk Of Bias In Non-randomized Studies–of
mental effect. Our hypothesis was that perioperative
Interventions) assessment tool.25 All 3 retrospective cohort
NSAID administration does not affect soft tissue healing
studies were analyzed across domains 1 through 7 via the
after sports medicine surgical procedures.
ROBINS-I assessment tool and were assigned an overall
risk-of-bias judgment of “moderate.”
METHODS
This study was conducted in accordance with the PRISMA RESULTS
(Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and
Study Selection
Meta-Analyses) statement. A systematic review of the
existing evidence for clinical effects of NSAID use on soft A total of 466 articles were initially retrieved. A PRISMA
tissue healing was performed through use of the Cochrane flowchart demonstrates the selection of articles based on
Database of Systematic Reviews, the Cochrane Central inclusion and exclusion criteria (Figure 1). Studies that did
Register of Controlled Trials, PubMed (1980 to present), not report the effects of NSAIDs on soft tissue healing were
and MEDLINE. Searches were performed using the fol- excluded based on title (n ¼ 403). Studies or case studies
lowing terms: nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug OR that were performed on animal models were excluded based
NSAID AND meniscus OR ligament OR tendon OR muscle on abstract review (n ¼ 50). Studies that did not report
OR soft tissue AND healing. The searches were performed clinical outcomes following NSAID administration with
in June 2018. no comparison with control groups were excluded upon
Inclusion criteria for articles were as follows: outcome stud- full-text analysis (n ¼ 9). Ultimately, we identified 4 studies
ies of soft tissue (ligament, meniscal, tendon, muscle) healing on the effects of perioperative NSAIDs on healing after
after surgical procedure with perioperative NSAID adminis- sports medicine procedures in humans.3,21,22,24
tration, at least 1 year of follow-up, English language, and
human patients. We excluded case reports, case series, and Patient Demographics
animal model studies. We reviewed titles, abstracts, and,
when necessary, the full text of all identified articles to assess The review included a total of 4451 patients (2523 male,
inclusion and exclusion criteria. All references from the 1928 female), mean age 29.5 years (range, 15.9-61 years),
*Address correspondence to David S. Constantinescu, BS, 1820 East Broad Street, #442, Richmond, VA 23223, USA (email: constantineds@[Link]).
†
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Virginia Commonwealth University, Richmond, Virginia, USA.
‡
Oslo Sports Trauma Research Center, Oslo, Norway.
One or more of the authors has declared the following potential conflict of interest or source of funding: A.R.V. has received educational support from
DJO, Smith & Nephew, and Supreme Orthopedic Systems; research support from DJO; and hospitality payments from RTI Surgical. AOSSM checks author
disclosures against the Open Payments Database (OPD). AOSSM has not conducted an independent investigation on the OPD and disclaims any liability or
responsibility relating thereto.
The Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine Effects of Perioperative Nonsteroidal Anti-inflammatory Drugs 3
Exclusion Criteria
Figure 1. PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) flow diagram. Search and selection
criteria for systematic review of the literature addressing effects of perioperative nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID)
administration on soft tissue healing and clinical patient outcomes.
i i
TABLE 1
Study Design, Patient Demographics. and Clinical Outcome Scales of Included Perioperative NSAID Effect Studiesa
who underwent soft tissue surgical repair and were admin- Bankart shoulder repair,3 and 1% (32/4451) underwent
istered NSAIDs perioperatively (Table 1). Weighted mean meniscal repair.22 The type of NSAID administered was
follow-up was 2.8 years (range, 21-66 months). Oh et al21 reported in 3 of 4 studies (Table 2). Proffen et al22 solely
reported that 108 of 120 patients were evaluated for 2 used ketorolac with a dosage adjusted to body weight and
weeks, but only 57 of 120 patients had a follow-up of 2 years did not specific the length of treatment. Soreide et al24
in order to assess retear rates. used diclofenac, ketorolac, celecoxib, or another NSAID for
a mean of 6.7 days but did not report the dosage. Oh et al21
Procedures Performed compared celecoxib (200 mg twice a day) versus ibupro-
fen (385 mg 3 times a day) administered for 14 days after
Among the studies included, 4 procedures were identified: treatment. Blomquist et al3 did not report the specific
93% (4144/4451) of patients underwent anterior cruciate NSAID used or the dosage but noted that the NSAID
ligament (ACL) reconstruction,24 3% (120/4451) under- was administered for an interval ranging from 1 to 7
went rotator cuff repair, 21 3% (155/4451) underwent days postoperatively.
4 Constantinescu et al The Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine
TABLE 2
Surgical Procedure, NSAID Treatment Modality, and Clinical Failure Rates
of Included Perioperative NSAID Effect Studiesa
Proffen et al22 Meniscal repair Ketorolac 7.5-60 mg (adjusted Perioperative NSAID: 34% (11/32) .99
to body weight) Control: 35% (26/75)
Soreide et al24 ACL reconstruction Diclofenac (91.5%) NR Mean, 6.7 days NSAID: 3% (127/4144) .794
Ketorolac (3.1%) Control: 3% (109/3678)
Celecoxib (2.4%)
Other NSAIDs (1%)
Oh et al21 Rotator cuff repair Celecoxib (50%) Celecoxib (200 mg, 14 days after surgery Celecoxib: 37% (11/30) .009
Ibuprofen (50%) 2 times per day) Ibuprofen: 7% (2/27)
Ibuprofen (385 mg,
3 times per day)
Blomquist et al3 Bankart repair NSAID NR 1-3 days (50%) NSAID: 5% (6/127) .8
4-7 days (41%) Control: 5% (12/243)
"7 days (9%)
a
ACL, anterior cruciate ligament; NR, not reported; NSAID, nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug.
bone healing, in which NSAIDs may interfere with the As with any systematic review, there is the possibility of
inflammatory process. noninclusion of relevant articles. However, our search
Further differentiation between NSAID classes may be strategy combined with searching the reference lists of all
made, specifically with selective COX-2 inhibitors. Oh relevant articles should have minimized this type of bias.
et al21 found that selective COX-2 inhibitors (celecoxib) sig-
nificantly lowered tendon-to-bone healing after surgical
repair of rotator cuff compared with nonselective indometh- CONCLUSION
acin. A similar finding was observed by Lu et al17 in a rabbit
model of rotator cuff healing. However, Cohen et al7 dem- We believe that our review of the available literature pro-
onstrated that both indomethacin and celecoxib impaired vides guidance regarding the use of NSAIDs following
rotator cuff healing in an animal model, with no difference sports medicine orthopaedic surgery procedures in terms
observed between indomethacin and celecoxib. Rotator cuff of healing rates and the need for reoperation. Insufficient
healing is modulated by multiple enzymes including COX-1 data are available to definitively state the effects of perio-
and COX-2.20 Although an interplay of growth mediators is perative NSAIDs on soft tissue healing. Use of NSAIDs
involved in rotator cuff healing, selectivity toward COX-2 should be considered on a case-by-case basis and may not
inhibition may be a factor leading to delayed healing. affect healing rates after meniscal, ACL, rotator cuff, or
Dose and duration of NSAID use varied among studies. Bankart repair. However, celecoxib (a selective COX-2
Blomquist et al3 and Soreide et al24 did not specify the inhibitor) may inhibit tendon-to-bone healing in rotator
dosing regimen used. All studies noted the length of NSAID cuff repair. Further research in clinical trials is required
treatment.3,21,22,24 Proffen et al22 delivered a dosage of to fully determine whether NSAIDs have a negligible effect
ketorolac that was adjusted to patients’ body weight, rang- on soft tissue healing.
ing from 7.5 to 60 mg, either intraoperatively or in the
postanesthesia care unit for patients undergoing meniscal
repair. Soreide et al24 delivered diclofenac, ketorolac, cele- REFERENCES
coxib, or another NSAID for a mean length of treatment of
1. Abdul-Hadi O, Parvizi J, Austin MS, Viscusi E, Einhorn T. Nonsteroidal
6.7 days in patients undergoing ACL reconstruction. Oh anti-inflammatory drugs in orthopaedics. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2009;
et al21 delivered celecoxib 200 mg 2 times a day and ibupro- 91(8):2020-2027.
fen 385 mg 3 times a day for a 14-day period following 2. Almekinders LC. The efficacy of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
rotator cuff repair. Blomquist et al3 did not specify which in the treatment of ligament injuries. Sports Med. 1990;9(3):137-142.
NSAID was used or the dosage but did report that 50% of 3. Blomquist J, Solheim E, Liavaag S, Baste V, Havelin LI. Do nonste-
roidal anti-inflammatory drugs affect the outcome of arthroscopic
patients received NSAIDs for 1 to 3 days, 41% received
Bankart repair? Scand J Med Sci Sports. 2014;24(6):e510-e514.
NSAIDs for 4 to 7 days, and 9% received NSAIDs for 7 days 4. Borgeat A, Ofner C, Saporito A, Farshad M, Aguirre J. The effect of
or more after Bankart repair. Although Blomquist et al3 nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs on bone healing in humans: a
were the only investigators who recorded multiple treat- qualitative, systematic review. J Clin Anesth. 2018;49:92-100.
ment durations, they did not report whether this had an 5. Bunker DLJ, Ilie V, Ilie V, Nicklin S. Tendon to bone healing and its
impact on healing rate. NSAIDs have been shown to dem- implications for surgery. Muscles Ligaments Tendons J. 2014;4(3):
onstrate a dose-dependent effect on bone healing, however 343-350.
6. Chen MR, Dragoo JL. The effect of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory
further research is needed to clinically investigate this rela-
drugs on tissue healing. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc.
tionship following soft tissue procedures.16 2013;21(3):540-549.
Although our search criteria included muscle healing, we 7. Cohen DB, Kawamura S, Ehteshami JR, Rodeo SA. Indomethacin and
found no studies investigating healing postoperatively. We celecoxib impair rotator cuff tendon-to-bone healing. Am J Sports
did find that NSAIDs had an adverse effect on muscle Med. 2006;34(3):362-369.
injury and acute hamstring tears in the long term.18,23 8. Dahners LE, Gilbert JA, Lester GE, Taft TN, Payne LZ. The effect of a
nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drug on the healing of ligaments. Am J
Sports Med. 1988;16(6):641-646.
Limitations 9. DePeter KC, Blumberg SM, Dienstag Becker S, Meltzer JA. Does
the use of ibuprofen in children with extremity fractures increase
This study has some limitations. Despite a complete review their risk for bone healing complications? J Emerg Med. 2017;
of the available literature, only a small number of studies 52(4):426-432.
met the inclusion criteria. These studies were heteroge- 10. Ferry ST, Dahners LE, Afshari HM, Weinhold PS. The effects of com-
mon anti-inflammatory drugs on the healing rat patellar tendon. Am J
neous with regard to their findings and the strength of their
Sports Med. 2007;35(8):1326-1333.
conclusions. In addition, variability in the type of proce- 11. Forslund C, Bylander B, Aspenberg P. Indomethacin and celecoxib
dures performed, along with a wide range of type of improve tendon healing in rats. Acta Orthop Scand. 2003;74(4):
NSAIDs, duration of treatment, and dosage, affected the 465-469.
strength of pooling these studies. Consequently, it was dif- 12. Geusens P, Emans PJ, de Jong JJA, van den Bergh J. NSAIDs and
ficult to achieve statistically significant conclusions and fracture healing. Curr Opin Rheumatol. 2013;25(4):524-531.
perform a meta-analysis. Therefore, our review is a descrip- 13. Hanson CA, Weinhold PS, Afshari HM, Dahners LE. The effect of
analgesic agents on the healing rat medial collateral ligament. Am J
tive systematic review, and no definitive conclusions can be Sports Med. 2005;33(5):674-679.
made. The finding of only 4 clinical studies analyzing the 14. Higgins JPT, Sterne JAC, Savović J, et al. A revised tool for assessing
effects of NSAIDs on soft tissue healing highlights the need risk of bias in randomized trials. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016;
for more research in human patients. 10(suppl 1):29-31.
6 Constantinescu et al The Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine
15. Jones E, Churchman SM, English A, et al. Mesenchymal stem cells in 22. Proffen BL, Nielson JH, Zurakowski D, Micheli LJ, Curtis C, Murray
rheumatoid synovium: enumeration and functional assessment in MM. The effect of perioperative ketorolac on the clinical failure rate of
relation to synovial inflammation level. Ann Rheum Dis. 2010;69(2): meniscal repair. Orthop J Sports Med. 2014;2(5):2325967114529537.
450-457. 23. Reynolds JF, Noakes TD, Schwellnus MP, Windt A, Bowerbank P.
16. Li Q, Zhang Z, Cai Z. High-dose ketorolac affects adult spinal Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs fail to enhance healing of acute
fusion: a meta-analysis of the effect of perioperative nonsteroidal hamstring injuries treated with physiotherapy. S Afr Med J. 1995;
anti-inflammatory drugs on spinal fusion. Spine. 2011;36(7): 85(6):517-522.
e461-e468. 24. Soreide E, Granan L-P, Hjorthaug GA, Espehaug B, Dimmen S, Nord-
17. Lu Y, Li Y, Li F-L, Li X, Zhuo H-W, Jiang C-Y. Do different cycloox- sletten L. The effect of limited perioperative nonsteroidal anti-
ygenase inhibitors impair rotator cuff healing in a rabbit model? Chin inflammatory drugs on patients undergoing anterior cruciate ligament
Med J. 2015;128(17):2354-2359. reconstruction. Am J Sports Med. 2016;44(12):3111-3118.
18. Mackey AL, Mikkelsen UR, Magnusson SP, Kjaer M. Rehabilitation of 25. Sterne JA, Hernán MA, Reeves BC, et al. ROBINS-I: a tool for asses-
muscle after injury—the role of anti-inflammatory drugs. Scand J Med sing risk of bias in non-randomised studies of interventions. BMJ.
Sci Sports. 2012;22(4):e8-e14. 2016;355:i4919.
19. McDonald E, Winters B, Nicholson K, et al. Effect of postoperative 26. Tsai W-C, Hsu C-C, Chen CPC, Chen MJL, Lin M-S, Pang J-HS.
ketorolac administration on bone healing in ankle fracture surgery. Ibuprofen inhibition of tendon cell migration and down-regulation of
Foot Ankle Int. 2018;39(10):1135-1140. paxillin expression. J Orthop Res. 2006;24(3):551-558.
20. Oak NR, Gumucio JP, Flood MD, et al. Inhibition of 5-LOX, COX-1, 27. Tsai W-C, Tang F-T, Hsu C-C, Hsu Y-H, Pang J-HS, Shiue C-C. Ibu-
and COX-2 increases tendon healing and reduces muscle fibrosis and profen inhibition of tendon cell proliferation and upregulation of the
lipid accumulation after rotator cuff repair. Am J Sports Med. 2014; cyclin kinase inhibitor p21CIP1. J Orthop Res. 2004;22(3):586-591.
42(12):2860-2868. 28. Wright JG, Swiontkowski MF, Heckman JD. Introducing levels of evi-
21. Oh JH, Seo HJ, Lee Y-H, Choi H-Y, Joung HY, Kim SH. Do selective dence to the journal. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2003;85(1):1-3.
COX-2 inhibitors affect pain control and healing after arthroscopic 29. Zhao-Fleming H, Hand A, Zhang K, et al. Effect of non-steroidal anti-
rotator cuff repair? A preliminary study. Am J Sports Med. 2018; inflammatory drugs on post-surgical complications against the back-
46(3):679-686. drop of the opioid crisis. Burns Trauma. 2018;6(1):25.