0 ratings0% found this document useful (0 votes) 12 views13 pagesChapter 2 Book
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
Ms
HUMAN RESOURCE PLANNING,
INTRODUCTION | .
concerning licies and practices associated
li all functional area
HR strategy is the pattern of decisions
with the HR system. Each organizational system encor agen
of an ceqarication and thereby helps in formulation of organization wide
strategies. Strategic Human Resource Management (SHRN) isa competency based
approach for management of HR. It focuses on devel loping
competitive advantage. .
IN STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT
ies which defi , Behavioural
“There are a number of theories which define the role of HR stratr6Y 0
rple theory, pioneered by Katz & Khan (1978), Jackson & Schuler (199% 95), considers msiders
employee behaviours as key to successful strategy implementation. By aligning
ization wide strategy, employees can fulfill
| HR policies and practices with orga
| their role expectations within the organization. Resource based theory of Barney
| (1991) and Prahalad & Hamel (1990) suggests Hit Fas the susta} able competitive
~_ advantage for the organization. This is because HR is characteristically rare,
inimitable and non-substitutable source for achieving competitive advantage.
\ Other resources do nat have such characteristic features. The human capital
7” theory of Becker (1964) suggests strategic importance to HR like other economic
ssstvas knowledge, skills and abilities ofthe people also have economic values.
/ This concept later developed the human resource accounting by Flamhdlté (1981)
and others Transaction cst theory of Williamson (1981) suggests that strategic
| HR approach ean ensure cost minimization as this will enhance periodic
| monitoring and governance. Agency theory of Eisenhardt 1989) suggests, strategic
approach to HR aligns agents (employees) and principals (employers) interests
and thereby, ensures streamlining of employment rélations and systems within
ROLE OF HR STRATEGY !
2 organization.
Il the above theories [Link] of HR with organization wi
ganization wide stral
| i aad therefor, they ae grouped under Rational Choice theories of HR. Institution!
|. (Meyer & Rowen, 1977, Powell & DiMaggio, 1991) and Dependency (Pfeffer
| Salancik, 197) theories on HR strategy, however, focus On oe ea
| oe This is because the strategic approach to HR is not empirically proved as
a contributor to organizational performance. While Institutional theory argues
satepc linkage and acceptance from stakeholders, Dependency theory as
|| this will unduly enhancé the level of influence over the organizati from :
and thereby will defeat, the purpose. ey
| Prima face, environmental, organizati
| een al, organizational, institutional and i
ate potential infh vencers in strategy. The relative importance of etn one
‘epend on organizational characteristics. However, for Rr ar
a , We need to
Scanned with CamScannera i
' 4
puan RESOURCE POUCIES AND STeATEGiES
° a ¥
Fee ee yanizateal t t0 OF else this wll not be a strategic decision for
sustaining organi Srowth and profitability. Any redundancy decisi
without considering the possible i i fine,
or 50 as to meet stakeholders’ expectations.
tegy is primarily concerned with: {
‘e The scope ‘of an organization's activities.
©. Matching the activities of an organization to that entironment in which it
operates. ’ '
@ Resource implication.
© Operational decisions.
© The values and expectations of stakeholders.
© Long-term direction.,
of Strategy : ,
Corporate Level: Corporate level strategy addresses the following issues:
~ Overall scope of an organization :
- How to run in structural and financial terms
~ How resources are allocated to different operations.
te level strategy is influenced by the mission of the organization.
Competitive or Business Strategy: These strategies are adopted in order to
strengthen the position of the organization in the market. It explains:
~ How to compete in.a market
~ Which products or services should be developed and offered to which
_ Markets
Scanned with CamScanner© > To what extent it meets customers needs
Does it achieve the objective of the organizations, viz., long-term
7 Profitability, market growth and efficiency.
Operational Strategies: Operational strategies are adopted at the functiona,
an organization to achieve the corporate level and competitive strategies,
| Strategy therefore, is either the plans made or the actions taken to help an
\ organization to fulfill its intended purposes. Strategic plans for the future are
HUMAN RESOURCE PLAN, :
level and the success at the functional or operational level ultimately enables |
called intended strategy and strategic actions are known as realized strategy |
Strategic means are plans and policies while strategic ends may be either =
(vision and mission) or focussed ([Link] objectives).
WHAT Is POLICY? oT
to accomplish the strategic intent. Policy is not a strategy or tactic. Strategy is a
Proposed course of action to exert a far reaching impact on the ability of the |
y enterprise to attain its goals. Strategy relates to means.
decisions and structured thought processes. Objectives are specific goals or aims,
individual or group seeks to accomplish. Hence, an objective is something to
accomplish, while a policy is a guide to accomplish it
‘Again policy is different from procedure, as procedure defines the manner ot
way of accomplishing something, ic, itis the process and method. While policy
forms part of a framework of general principles, a procedure necessarily indicates
how to do something and direct employees towards the accomplishment of goals.
Policies are also differentiated from programmes. Programmes are developed ot
the basis of policies with a view to implementing them and accordingly
programmes involve one additional step beyond. Policies to simplify the decisions
The execution of programmes leads to specific actions including’ practices and
procedures.
Scanned with CamScanner
Policy can be differentiated from objective, programmes and procedures. Policy
relates to the fundamental framework of principles and rules which are used as. |
reference information for decision making and provide a constant pattem of |
preferably in quantitative terms and can be considered as something which an |
A policy is a pre determined established guideline towards the attainment of |
accepted goals and objectives. Such guidelines facilitate properly designed efforts |RESOURCE POLICIES AND STRATEGIES a
R POLICIES AND PROCEDURES
policies in the management of HR cover a wide variety of subjects. A
comprehensive coverage of policies embrace any action or decision, taken by
‘either employees or management in relation to the working environment, the
rights and responsibilities of employees and management, and the action of both
patties. Thus. one policy may bea statement of standards for employee attendance
and another a statement of management obligations in grievance administration.
One policy may explain conditions under which loans will be. granted whereas
another may indicate conditions under which an employee is subjected to
discharge. : .
procedures prescribe the details for carrying out policies. They spell out the specific
rules and regulations, the steps, time, place, and personnel responsible for
implementing policies. Procedures also clarify what is to be done in particular
circumstances. : -
HR PROGRAMME
HR programme consists of the entire broad course of action governing employees
at all levels (including management) in a firm. Like any other programme of
management, it can be thought of as a "stable plan of action that continues over
an extensive period of time." It is the end product of philosophy, values, concepts,
principles, policies and procedures.
Some universal elements in a HR programme are:
1. Employment - Selection and job change,
2. Training and development,
3. Communication, :
4. Grievances and discipline,
5. Wages and salary,
6 Health and safety,
7. . Benefits and services, Z
8. Labour relations 5
9. Research
Scanned with CamScanner4 HUMAN RESOURCE PANG
CONSIDERATIONS IN DEVELOPING HR POLICIES
Statements of policy constitute criteria for making decisions. They render decision
making easier, more routine. They permit decisions on problems without detaileg
analysis and thus facilitate saving of precious time. {
Policiés provide a clear idea of what management and employees can expec,
fore, policies promote consistency and fairness of action under conditions
that are similar in character and eliminate any bias in employee related decisions,
‘This way, policies help to avoid confusion and misunderstanding.
Policies may originate from anywhere inside an organization or from external
Sources - the community, state and national legislation, changes in the economy,
and even international forces, such as war time or defence conditions. Internally,
Policies have their inception in employees’ suggestions or complaints, in collective
bargaining, and at any level of management - staff or line. j
The approval of sew or chahged HR-policies ultimately come from top
management. However, the responsibility for administration rests with the line, |
An effective HR department recommends. policies and ‘policy changes that it
considers appropriate for the benefit of the organization. The HR department
also has to assist in communicating policies to those who should know about
them. There are many ways of communicating the policies, like; standing orders,
house journals, circulars or through a documented policy manuals. HR
department interprets policies, exercises control over policy administration and
Periodically reviews the same in order.o ensure fairness and uniformity.
careful thought, it is necessary-to anticipate circumstances that may
igination is required here, as well as
prea of operating problems. Supervisors are in a good pect i
Sees ane ti ;
Projecting exigencies that can arise under a Particular Policy. . SS
Scanned with CamScanner‘HE RISKS .-—
2 “here a downside to strategic HR planning? The strategic managen
3
human resources Se
‘ems beneficial, but some researchers point out that ue
So ieearch ghows that these include the Increased time and ¢
wr mn ial natn rg Se
ave commitments to employees, and an overconcern with employee reaggn
sat may be Incompatible with industry conditions. AS anyone who has gon,
through the strategy formulation and implementation process understands
hase is relatively easy; motivating employees to commis
strategy formulation pl
the strategy and implement It is far more difficult. A further problem is that _
HR plan forthe future may create employees’ expectations that they have en
for life and will be trained for those jobs, whereas the reality Is that condition,
change, and the plan may change, resulting in job losses.
‘Another problem, some would argue, is that organizations that commit ty
one strategy become blind to changes in the environment and lose their flextbity
However, incremental adjustments [Link] environmental, scanning are part |
strategy implementation. The risk of not having a strategy seems greater.
‘There are risks to not developing a strategy. Organizations that do not acti
scan the environment face the danger of being out of touch with reality, Todays
operating decisions may be based on yesterday's conditions. Comfortable wi
past success, the managets in these organizations focus on resolving internal
problems, much like those who concentrated on mak'ng better horse carriages
when automobiles were on the horizon.
(One example of a company not in touch with reality was Consumers
Distributing. It did not develop a strategy to match or surpass the changing ds}
tribution networks and customer-service levels of its competitors. The company
now bankrupt, continued to require customers to come to the stores and stand in
line, often for out-of-stock items. Meanwhile, their competitors were offering elec
tronic purchasing or were providing greeters at the door of the store who helped
the customers find anything they wanted, all for a competitive price. MacMillan
argues that firms that develop strategies gain an advantage and control their own!
destinies# An apt cliché is “an organization that fails to plan, plans to fail”
LINKING HR PROCESSES TO STRATEGY ____—
Strategic HRM has to facilitate the formulation and implementation of corpora
and business-level strategies. Senior managers naust focus on issues such
What are the HR implications of adopting a strategy? What are the internal até
external constraints and opportunities? Exactly what policies, practices, and phi}
ldsophies contribute to the successful implementation of the strategy?
The basic premise is that every HR policy and practice must directly suppor
the organization's strategy and objectives.? This does not happen as frequently asi
should. Aligning HR strategy with business strategy can be done in one | of these wal}
1. Start with organizational strategy and then create HR strategy.
2. Start with HR competencies and then craft corporate strategies based 0"
these competencies,
3, Do a combination of both in a form of reciprocal relationship.
Let us examine each approach. A
Scanned with CamScannercorporate Strategy Leads to HR Strategy
wraiwonal perepecive of HR planning views HRM
porte srategy: I other words, personnel need
| ctor irm decides to compete on the basis of offe
good
ist
cient Gee
Programs as flowing from
s are based on corporate
ra ring low-cost
pati sand practices must align and be bi Products, HR
alicies and PI ign and be based on low labour cost 7
‘example. To illustrate the alignment of HR ope a th bestooss
Steg HR Planning Today 2.3 focuses on two strategies under Porter's madel:
recog
HRM hel
practices
jow-cost-provider strategy and the differentiation strategy. Alth
uelow et tne importance of HRM, and even concedes tine in cove tenn
ids the key to competitive advantage, he dia not delineate any specific
that can be aligned with business strategy. HR Planning Today 2.3
provides one of the few “recipes” for using HR strategies to support a business
strategy:
Me dnu ec eee
Terie UROL te he arrecet eeeeeaene
Strategy 1: Low-Cost-Provider
Strategy
‘Afirm competing on cost leadership attempts to be the
low-cost provider of a product or service within a mar-.
katplace. The product or service must be pérceived by
the consumer to be comparable to that offered by the
competition and fo have a price advantage. McDonalds
uses this approach, as do Zellers and Timex.
Buyers are price sensitive, and businesses appeal
to this price consciousness by providing products or
services at prices lower than those of competitors.
Surival is the ultimate goal, but organizations price low
to gain market share (by underpricing competitors) or
[Link] a higher profit margin by selling at the'going
‘market rate. This strategy requires the:company to bal-
‘ance the delivery of a product that still appeals to cus-
‘tomers with not spending too much on gaining market
share, McDonald's could deliver @ cheaper hamburger,
‘ut would it have any taste? McDonald's could under-
Price its competitors, but it may risk its survival by going
‘00 low. The key is to manage costs every year.
te : ‘Adoption of a low-cost-provider strategy by a
ae at inmecate implications for HR strategy Costs
important element of this strategy, $0, labour
ee carefully controlled. Efficiency and controlling
ate paramount. The implications of a low-cost-
me
provider strategy for six key components of HR ar@ dis-
cussed below, but first we start with the job description
‘of a typical employee working in a company that
competes as a low-cost provider.
The Employee
‘To keep wages low, jobs have to be of limited scope so
that the company can hire people with minimal skills at
low wages. The job requires highly repetitive and pre-
dictable behaviours. There is litle heed for cooperative
or interdependent behaviours among employees, The
company ditgets its efforts at doing the same or more
with less and capitalizing on'economies of scale. Doing
more with fewer employees is the goal of most organi-
zations with a low-cost-provider strategy’
Risk taking on the part of the employee is not
needed, but comfort with repetitive, unskilled work
necessary. Customers like those frequenting McDonald's
are “trained” not to make idiosyncratic requests (such
as a “medium-rare hemburger” or. “hot mustard"), and
0 no unique response system is required. Employees
are not expected to contribute ideas.
"Another way to cut costs isto eliminate as many of
the support or managerial layers as possible. The impact
of cutting costs in this way is that employees may have to
do more with ess, make more decisions, and so on, which
would require a more skilled employee. Alternatively, the
Scanned with CamScannerVEE er ee Rae
ke $20 oF mriore an hour, to
jobs could be so tightly designed that tte supervision is|_workera mace § ; non
aia, ie eee Substtuing technology for _sinaller sites, where workers ate paid Ssh mone
labour is another way to save coats, 7 m wage. “
‘We now. Took as HR functions that will facilitate... sorte uae eons can site chien
provider organization. thio uise-of part-time wotkrs,
the personnel work at» lowe provide orge picgeropsaatinpies ‘ =
Mi * 30 .[Link] Fringe Benefits, #0. the saving gang,
HR Planning ; in fing |
AAt the entry level, succestion planning ‘is minimal, 3 pe oe —
‘ensuring only the feeder line to the next lavel. Outside ae chiges sry a an
3 ‘ ost exclus
labour markats are monitored to ensure that entry-level - @/miost e
a ‘itebil » Pay for performance, such as incentive.
People are in adequate supply. The availability and na “ Me omen
that ti linked.
of fri rkere—those who are retired, temripo- tat
sh wheyhed aime oc comer Group, rewards are basedt-on:explict, resus oer
* planning stateay, particulary if the employmerit market ard the mesh ofahbcrterng
's offering better opportunities to the normal [Link].
2 a vative. compensation: schéme that cannot be dini
Selection “ys ated by tals may provide & cor votive advange
Recruitment is primary at the entry, or lowest: level 0" 2™Ple, in an-arrangement’ .etween the Srext
and is from the surrounding exterfal labour macket. :
[Link] by word of mouth, and application forms, O04: ehelis a
are available on-site, thus saving the et of recruiting : -22 Percent pay-cut in exchange for cash bonuses. * 2
in Dewspapers. Mest other prstions are staffed inter: » OTS employees ould keep lat sur costs 10 pueet
rally trough promotions. Thus, career paths ara natios.< Ct Sales By J. MOre « .. ently oF generating
. con [90 stor’ tafe, they wauld .» ive & ath bonis of
‘Compensation. runiricad les. This arrangement resited in
an ; “
A stiatogy includes iat nd 92. in oderdting profits, However,
He opposed! 6 the spread “this practice, and
fvals In: the. [Link] business wet
foes nasa Poin Ith local abou market’ These, able reuce ther abou cst inthe sre way A
tes; Job, de spec jon. Such
such as New Mexico. In Canada, wages aré vary a Paatation fox the ae ee
3 Vary similar. training no for ths 6
+ 807088 provinoés, so firms analyze ‘Wage rates in coat ere Seed enemy: Mi sae
tres such as india, which pay employees substantial Thebes coe eet oF cashier within cnn doth
less for similar Productivity. Outsourcing has also meant ‘pment of the en . et ican of sls
oye, nor in
‘moving the work from highly unionized plants, here for jobs sth@r than the current one.
Scanned with CamScannerve
The training staff ts lean,
ajng on outside suppliers for Is limited trajning
is. Howaver, most tairiog takes place on the job
Mine form f rect instruction from or coaching by the
pris, The jobs 3f@ $0 Naow in Scope, so repel
fre a nature, that fitte need for taining exists.
Performance Evaluation.
short-term results, with explicit and standardized cr-
tora, avo used to [Link] employee's performance,
The feedback is immediate and specific. Individuals
are held accountable only for their own behaviour or
fess, not for that of the team or the company. Only «
the sopervisor provides, input for the performance
‘enluation. Forms are kept to.a minimum, and rating
is done against check mprs. Feedback; if based on a
ce review, tends to be one-way, with little
for the employee to debate the results or
receive developmental feedback. Results are used: for
consideration for promotion.
Labour Relations
Low-cost providers ty to prevent the formation of @
union because they believe that unions drive up wages.
Unions find low-cost providers, such as McDonald's,
dificult to unionize, (Employees working part-time
hours have little interest in unionization because they
believe that this is & part-time job that they will leave
in the near future, and they are unlikely to benefit from
‘belonging to a union, to which they have to pay fees.
Its also difficult to organize those working night shits)
Furthermore, employees quit often, and many low-cost
Providers absorb tumover rates of 300 percent annux
aly a a cost of doing business, High turnover has the
Primary advantage of keeping compensation levels low.
Now that we have an idea ‘of how HR programs
align with a low-cost provider strategy, let us examine
what these programs would be like under a differentia-
tion strategy. e
Strategy 2: The Differentiation
Strategy
‘mn most matkets, buyer preferences are too diverse
10 be satisfied by one undifferentiated product. Firms
segment are said to compete on a differentiation
strategy. A firm competing on the basis of a differen
tiation strategy will offer something unique and valu
able to its customers. BMW, Polo Ralph Lauren, Rolex,
and Hewlett-Packard scientific instruments divisions
are firms that compete successfully by charging price
premium for uniqueness. The primary focus is on the
néw and different. Observation, experience, and market
research will establish what buyers consider important.
what has value, and what buyers will pay for these fee-
tures. Then the firm can offer @ product or service that
commands a prertium price, increase unit sales within
this niche, and gain buyer loyalty among those who
value these features. The extra price ‘outweighs the
‘extra costs of providing these festures.
‘A firm can. differentiate itself from its competitors
‘many ways:
« Having quality products,
‘= Offering superior customer service,
«+ Having a more convenient location,-
* Using proprietary technology,
Offering valuable features,
* Demonstrating unique styling, and
+ Having a brand-name reputation.
“These different features can be anythingeCommon
‘examples show some firms competing on seivice (Four
Seasons Hotels), engineering design (BMW), image
(Polo Ralph Lauren), reliability (Bell); 2 full-range of
products or sefvices (Procter & Gamble), technofogical
leadership (RIM), and quality (Honda).
Most-of the time, these competitive, advantages
are combined, such as by linking quality products.
with proprietary technology and superior customer -
service, thus providing the buyer with more value
for the money. The key In-this strategy is to provide
the differentiation that is perceived to be of value to
customers while keeping costs dow. For example, a
slice of lemon in a glass of ice water delivered to the
table is an obvious way to differentiate the restaurant,
but at low cost. After-dinner mints are less expensive .
than valet parking, but may be equally appreciated
by :
Scanned with CamScanner{
j
A differentiation strategy calls for innovation
‘and creativity among employees. HRM is affected in
fundamentally different ways in organizations that
want to use employees’ brains rather than their limited
(mainly manual) skills in the low-cost-provider strategy.
The starting point for aligning HR programming
with a differentiation strategy is the employee.
The Employee
‘Organizations competing on 8 differentiation strategy
require from their employees creative behaviour, @
long-term focus, interdependent activity, and some risk
taking, as well as an ability to work in an ambiguous and
unpredictable environment. Their employees! sills need!
to be broad, and employees must be highly involved
with the. firm. Organizations encourage employees to
make suggestions, through both informal and formal
suggestion systems, for new and. improved ways. of
doing their job. Employees at Coming Canada Inc., for
‘example; submit their suggestions to their supervisors,
‘who review them formally and give feedback directly to
the employee. Contrast this with the traditional sugges-
tion bok, which many employees view a8 a recycling bin
because of the lack of timely feedback. ©.
“HR Planning
Ina company that has a differentiation strategy andthat. ©
recognizes people are the key [Link] advan
tage, HR planning is taken very seriously. Far example,
‘at Sumitomo Metals in Japan, the business planning,
‘group reports to HR because the company understands
{that identifying what needs to be done is ess difficult
than planning how to do it.
Succession management is critical as employees
have to possess many attributes to move ahead in the
‘organization. Thus, a strong emphasis on-developing
skills for the future is part of the promotion policy,
Investments in career moves, training, and develop:
mental experiences are substantial. Long-term job
security and reciprocal loyalty are the norm.
Selection
‘Companies with a differentiation strategy need employees
who have a broad range of skils and the abilty to leam
PUM aed ek a Pe hn
from others. An innovative atmosphere requires
vio are self-motivated and do not require grat day,
of supervision. Employees are selected for their abies
to think creatively to be flexible in work atts angy,
be able to work in teoms. However, selection fr hes
characteratics is rhore-difcult and usually imohes tayy
interviews and behaviourally based evidence ofimnoatn
performance. Employees are normally recited thou,
reputation (word of mouth) or through craduate schoo,
Some testing for creative ability may be used,
Compensation
Compensation plans affect employee behaviour¥nan
directly than most HR practices. For example, Drucker
describes a compensation scheme he implemented at
General Electric (GE) in which pay for performance wes
based only on the previous year’s results. As such, for
ten years, GE lost its capacity for innovation because
investing in innovation ‘affects expenses and decreases
Profits, s0 everyone’ postponed spending on innovation,
However, compensation is carefully designed in
firms that have a differentiation strategy. Pay rates may
be slightly below average market rates but there are
Subttantial opportunities to inereate:those base lees
‘through inceritive ‘pay. ‘Pay for performance is a large
art of the’ comipensation package: and will be deper-
dent cn’individual, gréup, and corporate results. These
results: ére a combination of process and financial ci-
terig and are set inv advance, usually on a yearly basis
‘Theie is 4 more varied mix of types of compensation,
individuals may receive salary, Bonus, or stock opion
incentives. intemal: equity is of greater concem than
‘equity with the extemal market. Egalitarian pay stuc-
tures are associated with greater product quality. Now
‘monetary rewards also play a larger role in HR atetegy
‘these types of firms. ‘At Honda, the team that designs @
Lunigu® transportation vehicle is awarded a trip to Japan.
Training
Companies with a differentiation strategy have 2 870°9
taining team. The focus of training is on both stilt
and attitudes: Process skills, such as decision making:
the ability to work in teams, and creative thinking.
emphasized ds much as skills needed for the curert
Scanned with CamScannerso Train tans nen a n oportinity to ge
Fran ean aod procedures. Indeed, customers and
teams might be included in the training
aren Dewan xparence re encouraged
waive of working in ancther division or another
Mrnmy is recognized and encouraged. Employees
receive ‘or other job opportunities based,
Foraly, on the wilingness to undertake taining and
fhe track recordin learning,
performance Evaluation
in companies with a differentiation strategy, perfor-
‘nance appraisal is based not on short-term resuks
‘but instead on the long-term implications of behav-
‘our Processes that are deemed to lead tn better
results in the long term are rewarded. Thus, companies
encourage and appraise attitudes such as empower
iment, diversity sensitivity, and teamwork in an effort to
build ture bottor”-line outcomes. Working »eyond the
jpb is encouraged, not punished. Failure is tolerated,
akhough management [Link] distinguish bet veen bed
luck and bad judgment or stupidity.
Evaluation tends to be based on a mixture of indi
vidual and group (and sometimes corporate) criteria,
‘Thus, an individual might be evaluated on his or her
ability to achieve resuits and to work as a member of
the team, the group's performance might be measured
against established quotas, and the company in terms
of its overall financial performance.
‘Appraisals that include input from employees, func-
tional experts, peers, and so on—360" evaluations—
are the norm. Organizations in the service sector are
more likely to include customers as sources of input for
performance appraisal
Labour Relations
‘Any structure or process that reduces the capacity to be
innovative and flexible is difficult to tolerate. Traditional
unions, with rigid collective agreements, ae encouraged
to work collectively toward a new union-management
relationship. This relationship is characterized by shared
information such as open books, shared decision
inaking about best approaches, and shared responsi-
bility for solving problems as they arise.
Seucu: Adapted tm RS. Shuler and SE. Jackson, “inking Competitive Strategies with Human Resource Manauerent
Ferre Resdemy of Management Execztive, vl 1, . 3(1987), pp. 207-219 Ukich, “Using Human Resources (ot
Circ acbertage” rR. Kiman and .Kman, eds. Making Orgenizations Compottive, San Frances, losseyion,
1971, PF. Drucker, “They're Not Employees, They're People,” The
Harvard Business Review, vol. 80, no.2 (2002). pp. 70-77;
Fearn ne ey, “Grong tom the irside Out Human Resources Practice fr Growth Strategies.” Proceedings oF»
the Administrative Sciences Association of Canada, 1999.
But another pérspective reverses this view, suggesting that employee com-
’
Petencies determirie the business strategy.
HR Competencies Lead to Business Strategy
‘Acompeting view states that an organization cannot i
implement a strategy if it
does not have the human resources necessary. Early into the 21st century, com-
Panies are scrambling to find qualified workers in many flelds.
Small businesses seem to be better at this second approach, The owners
of very small businesses are riimble and quickly recognize that if an’employee
Wis certain capably, it can be exploited to develop new produrts or services.
versity management efforts are currently building on this! theme. For example, if
‘he number of employees who speak Mandarin reachesa sufficient number within
2n organization, the observant executive will start torexplore Asian markets.
ne
Scanned with CamScannerqutlook relies too heavily on employes «,
MA ontal anal not Is consideration
pensation to facilitate ths chang ©
‘This “skills determine stra
.d not enough on envi
angie HO practices in training or com)
= extremes on a continuum between o
yresent two va
Ines perspec paces, The realy 5 closer tthe concept
2 -
rocal interdependencies.4°
iprocal Interdependency between
AR Stra egy and Business Strategy —
An emerging perspective sees HR strategy as contributing to business.
trategy and vice versa. increasingly, n large firms, senior HR vice-presidents ay
asked not only to review business plans to ensure consistency with HR stra
but also to provide input to this strategy based ori HR strengths and Weaknessas
In this context, an organization chooses a business strategy, such as be
a leader in innovative products, based on its in-house, highly educated, trained
‘employees who have been socialized to value creativity. Simply phrased, an orga.
* nization develops its employees and then capitalizes on thelr skills; the employees
then learn new skills, and so it continues. In many ways, HR strategy gener.
ates the' business strategy, and business strategy determines HR strategy. This
concept of reciprocal interdependence is widely accepted in. the HR strategy
literature.*? :
‘An emerging view is that HR should bud its strategies by starting with the
‘Issues facing the business. All HR programs should be created to solve real business
Problems and add value, thus becoming indistinguishable from the business.!2
me
ry
implications are not trivial; HR managers must under u
I stand the numbers language
ctes or the outcome expectations of non-profit organizations, ‘They must
manages Case San ales bresénted by marketing financial and operstona
acd isheon at ‘assessmeénts of options within the HR‘omain will haveto
pare md a eneurial instincts will have to be sharpened, as
anagers expected to oe in scanning HR capabilities for business
proach to strategic HR planning, An example of
this occu ts : eee ee
mene bee my n organization was experiencing a rapid downward spiral it
iene aca respanse ‘would have been to prepare for downsizing
ree. Instead the HR manager created zs
aonerntt2 Support two major contract,«3. Nt 10bby-suecestfally—the
ages to rete the cst of tum. The HR oan itor,
__ but a partner and problem solver. Linkages ee ae
‘managers, both formal and informal, ensure that this, Partnership roe is enacted
‘ . : e
Scanned with CamScannerte you undéfstand the business? What financial
indicators are important to the company? Who are
your customers, and what is your competitive advan-
tage? What major technological changes wil affect
your work?
‘and measured on deliverables and not functions?
Does HR report on effectiveness (the impact that
the training program had on employee behaviour)
‘or just efficiencies (such as:the number of people
being trained)?
Do you know what the corporate plan's? Can you
quickly list the major initiatives of your organization?
‘Do you align HR programs, policies, and
practices with orgenizational strategies and goals?
How can HR position the organization to succeed?
‘Ave the people management processes focused
your input?
to be one.
STRATEGIC PARTNERING
Human resources professionals recognize the need to play a more strategic role
within the organization, Although only 23 percent HR managers are playing that
role now, executive teams expect most of them to be more strategic and to dem-
onstrate added value, over the next five years.“ Why do executives ignore HR's
‘contribution to strategy? Some argue that it is because management is not satis
fied with HR services in general; that “people” issues belong only to HR, and HR
can take care of any problems in executing the strategy.
‘These attitudes are changing, as organizations realize the impact that HRM
‘strategy can have on organizational effectiveness and as HR managers develop
the internal relationships to ensure that the strategy Is effective. However, you
cannot just ask to be on the executive team. It is like being in high school and»
asking to be on the basketball team. You have to prove yourself. HR Planning
Notebook 2.1 pases the question, “Are you a strategic partner?”
BECOMING MORE STRATEGIC —________
HR departments are restructuring in order to be able to do the basics right (Pay-
"ol safety training, and so on) while enhancing the performance-of business
‘its and supporting strategic moves. Traditionally, IR has been organized into
functional units (training, compensation, and so on). However, there are some
"ore innovative practices, where the unit is organized according to the services
Provided, as outlined in HR Planning Notebook 2.2.-
Itseems feasible to design HR policies to match strategy, but what happens
en an organization has mére than one business strategy and more than one
HR strategy? We attempt to answer that question in the next section.
. ~ f
‘Are major organizational decisions made with
Count the number of times you answered yes. The
higher the number, the greater the likelihood
that you are a strategic partner or Have the ability
Scanned with CamScanner