Design: Principles of Typography For User Interface Design: Interactions November 1998
Design: Principles of Typography For User Interface Design: Interactions November 1998
net/publication/220382729
CITATIONS READS
28 11,149
2 authors, including:
Paul Kahn
Northeastern University
45 PUBLICATIONS 574 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Paul Kahn on 01 March 2017.
T
Typography is a major part of the graphical user interface (GUI). Good user interface
design depends on our understanding of how type works as a visual system. In this
article, we summarize the typographic principles that were developed through print
practice and show how they translate and expand within the electronic medium. We
the type (its color, form, rhythm, and style) to its background. We then explain how to
manipulate these contrasts to design effective GUI systems and presentations of text
electronic type.
Figure 1. Meta-language of contrasts in size, context, and reverse color, applied consistently in all
typography makes this control panel interface easy to read and use.
Character spacing
This is the horizontal space between charac-
ters. It is another counterform, the shape
exposed by the combination of letterforms.
The space between “te” is quite different from
“ve” or “th.” This shape is effected by the dis-
tance between the letters. Tight letter spacing
can make it difficult to distinguish an “rn”
Figure 4. Stems and bowls are similar within a single font design. The vari-
ation in thickness does much to establish the color of the type. Note how combination from an “m.” Tighter letter
the increased thickness of the stem in the “h” decreases the white coun- spacing also emphasizes counterform within
terform, making the letter dark black.
Figure 5. The x-height of the font does much to define its relative size. The larger the x-height the more white space is
exposed by the counterform. These letters are the same point size, but the Helvetica on the left looks larger than the Times
on the right.
Line spacing
This is the vertical space between lines of text.
It is sometimes called leading because thin
strips of lead were used to increase this space
when type was set in metal. Line spacing is an
important attribute of font size. In fact,
thinking of font size, such as 12-point type, in
isolation is a common mistake, encouraged by
the user interface to many word-processing
programs, which historically imitated the user
experience of mechanical typewriters (one
Figure 7. Good letterspacing varies depending on the combination of letter forms. (Bottom) Note the large space between the
“le”, the thinner space between the “et” and the very thin space between the “tt” combination in the typeset example. When
interpreted by screen fonts these variations in letterspacing are greatly reduced. In this enlargement of five screen fonts (top)
the distance between the “rn”, the “rk” and the “rg” combinations vary considerably, sometimes reduced to a single pixel or
none at all. The “rn” is difficult to distinguish from the “m”, the “rk” is joined, while the “rg” is distinct in all five fonts because
of the counterform of the two letters.
Figure 8. Word spacing is relatively uniform when only one margin is used. Margin space
When text is justified to both margins, the word space will vary. To force
justify a short line, character space must be expanded and contracted as well. This is the distance of the edge of the letter-
Figure 9. Line spacing affects the color of the type, increasing or decreasing the exposed background color, obscuring or
exposing ascender/descender shapes.
Figure 10. Margin space is the separation of the edge of the letterform from the edge of the frame.
See the BBC News example [figure 14] for a dramatic example of margin space used to define the
structure of a complex layout.
These are the characteristics of display type, font being used is the “system font” from the
typefaces that speak clearly in short bursts. operating system, there is no distinction at all
The counterform around each letter and word in the package. For various technical reasons,
group varies widely. Visual rhythms are brief the distinction in user interface has been car-
and irregular. Individual letter shapes are ried by icon design rather than type, although
highly exposed (Figures 11 and 12). even the choice of a “b” to represent “bold” or
The main issue in choosing and managing a “q” for “quit” is a use of type in isolation.
type in isolation is to convey style. The use of When we choose Syntax or Meta rather than
type in the packaging design we see in super- the “system font” to convey meaning in the
markets and drugstores is an instructive user interface, we give up a certain trans-
example. parency in exchange for a distinct identity.
The package is the user interface for the act
of product purchase, the visual point at which Type in Volume (en grosse)
the customer interacts with the product on When type is used to present continuous
the shelf, distinguishes one type of aluminum linear text, the requirements for the typeface
foil or tomato sauce from another, perceives change. The presentation of type is controlled
(or overlooks) the ingredients, and makes the by left-to-right, top-to-bottom visual syntax.
purchase decision. This is user interface as The period of visual exposure is much longer
container. Certainly the type is not the taste of than what the reader experiences with type in
the tomato sauce, but it must say something isolation. Regular margins and indents are
about that taste. The type must express some part of the structural language.
distinction, feeling, and/or attraction in order There are six visual characteristics that can
to compete with other packages. be used to convey distinction and variation
The same issues are in play when a font for within blocks of continuous linear text: all
the user interface of a program is chosen. If the caps/small caps, regular face, italic face, bold
face, overspacing/condensing (stretching or There are three other visual distinctions for
reducing character space), and color variation. type that can be used in print: black (or ultra
These six distinctions are relatively easy to see bold), small caps, and underline. The first two
in print. On the screen, the italic variation is are of limited utility on screen. Screen fonts
often problematic. Based on a slanting of the cannot support two weights of bold, largely
letterform, italic is often distorted by coarse again because of the coarseness of the screen
screen resolution and is difficult to read. resolution. True small caps are not a feature of
Overspacing and condensing of character screen fonts, although the designer can fake it
space can be achieved in a limited number of by setting a word in caps and reducing the
programs and is consequently rare. Color, on font size to approximate the x height of the
the other hand, is rarely used in print because body text. Underlining text is possible on the
it represents an additional production expense. screen but has taken on a special meaning in
On the screen, it is largely free, although it is Web browsers.
difficult to control with any precision. Type in volume has color. The color of a
Type size
First, there is the choice of an appropriate size
for the letterform. The most common sizes
used in print are 9-, 10-, and 11-point type.
Smaller sizes can be used for elements that
require a different voice or less emphasis.
Larger sizes must be used in moderation for
titles and headings.
For type on the screen, a range of larger
sizes must be used to compensate for lower
resolution. Sizes of 12 and 14 point are com-
fortable to read, whereas 10-point type is leg-
ible in small amounts.
Line length
The recommended number of characters in a
line does not vary between the medium of
Figure 13. Some typefaces such as EraserDust and Impact paper and screen, however. A range of 65–75
are very expressive, but they accomplish this with large characters per line is a comfortable maximum
variations in letterform that become very difficult to read
in volume. Typefaces designed for body type such as for a single column of text in print, with a
Georgia and Trebuchet are more transparent, creating a range of 30-40 characters per line common in
calm rhythm in blocks of text.
multicolumn layouts. The reason for this max-
block of type has two meanings here. The imum is based on the characteristics of our
first is color density. This is the relative light- visual system. We scan a line of text in groups
ness or darkness of a typeface controlled by of letters, first picking up the exterior shapes of
the thickness of the lines and exposure of word groups, then decoding words as our eye
counterforms. The second is the color: the bounces along from left to right. The sweeping
hue of ink/pixel used to fill positive form motion of turning our eye back to the left
(black, red, blue). The color density is inde- becomes increasingly difficult as the line gets
pendent of the color used to set the type. A longer. Our ability to pick the start of the next
great deal of variation within a single color line is decreased by combinations of long lines,
can be achieved by manipulating the type- tight line spacing, and lack of white space on
face, character, and line spacing. the left-hand margin.
The available fonts for working with type
in volume are limited to body type. These Levels of heading
font designs emphasize the evenness of color Like line length, the need to distinguish two
within the block of type (Figure 13). to three levels of heading is a problem to both
In addition to all we have said about the print and screen typography, and like line
length, the rules of common experience in green, etc.) (Figures 14, 15 and 16).
print can be applied to solve the problem on Scrolling text in a window is a unique fea-
the screen. For example, to distinguish three ture of type on the screen. This small frame
levels of heading, use some combination of moving around a larger text column requires
three contrasts: size, position, and color. Size a greater articulation of distinctions among
is easy enough to understand, although the levels of heading than the printed page. There
visual distinction between 12- and 13-point is simply less of the page visible on the screen
type on the screen is often difficult to see in at any one time. The distinction of multiple
isolation. Variations in position (left, center, indents is lost as a result. The perception of a
right, outdent) are often easier to see and work text’s structure is dependent on the reader’s
well in combination with other distinctions. memory rather than the visible design.
Differences in color can be achieved with In all of these examples, the main issue
changes in weight within a single font (bold, when designing body type is to convey con-
italic, or extra bold/black), as well as with vari- tent. Matters of style are secondary to matters
ations in the hue of the type itself (black, red, of legibility.
Special Characteristics of Type on shapes are lost entirely. In recent years, various
the Screen antialiasing techniques have been used to
After pointing out the differences between smooth curves in character shape. By varying
print and screen typography, it is easy to see the color of the pixels around the letter, more
the limitations we face when using type on the of the visual information of the letterform can
screen. The most fundamental limitation is the be preserved. The result can be effective or
low resolution of the image surface. The reso- fuzzy, depending on the algorithm used to
lution of most computer monitors is a small render the type and the skill of the designer
range of 72-75 pixels to the inch. Screens with with the tool.
so-called “higher resolutions” simply decrease Color is one area in which type on the
the size of the pixel, which visually shrinks the screen holds distinct advantages over type on
image to fit more pixels into a small space paper, at least in terms of production cost.
rather than increases the resolution of the Printing is ink on paper, and ink carries color.
image itself. This resolution compares unfavor- One-color printing is a standard cost. Adding
ably with 1200–3600 lines to the inch for color involves mixing ink and running a sheet
typesetting that image ink onto paper. of paper through a press more than once.
This is the reason that the thicks and thins Two-, three-, and four-color printing is an
of some font designs are still lost in sizes under added expense.
12 point, and some of the more delicate letter Adding color to type on the screen is a
completely different process. On screen, 8-, syntax and its own meaning, defined largely
16-, and 24-bit color is not a cost to the pro- by context. Speed can effect legibility as well
ducer. Instead, it is a cost to the consumer, the as style. Direction carries a meaning of going
person who purchases the monitor and video with or against the flow of reading. The words
card for the computer itself. There is no cost that appear on the right and move left can be
to adding the color; instead, there is the decoded as they appear, whereas the words
problem of predicting what the color will look that enter from the left and move right can be
like on various monitors. The limitations on read only after they have been entirely
the screen are the number and range of colors revealed. Type moving from top to bottom
that are supported (Figure 17). will move with our sense of gravity, whereas
The most exciting characteristic of type on type that moves from bottom to top defies the
the screen is the added dimension of time. same sense. The duration of type, how long it
Type on the screen includes motion. This appears during a process of evaporation or dis-
adds a new factor to typographic communi- persal, effects our sense of the content. The
cations, a factor that we have seen most often act of growing or shrinking carries its own
in movie titles and television commercials. level of meaning, which modifies the meaning
There are four characteristics of type in conveyed by the type form and content and
motion: the word (Figure 18).
1. Speed (slow, fast). Moving type is a new area, one that has
2. Direction (from left, from right, up, down). enlivened many aspects of interactive design.
3. Duration (change in focus, transparency).
4. Variation in size (grow, shrink). Conclusion
Each of these characteristics carries its own As the utility and impact of interactive com-
Figure 18. An interesting example of dynamic typography is the Fluid Documents Margin Callout
technique being developed at Xerox PARC (see Zellweger et al, “A negotiation architecture for fluid
documents” in UIST ’98). This progressive sequence of four screen images shows an animated tran-
sition to reveal an annotation on Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet. Note that the small word indi-
cating an available annotation sits in the line space below the word(s) it explains. The annotation,
which fades in as it moves into place, is located in the margin space.
puting continues to grow, the importance of read the screen. Whether it appears in isolation
understanding type as a visual information or in volume, type will always play some role in
system increases. The user interface designer is the interaction. To accomplish this goal, the
manipulating signs and symbols, appealing to designer must understand a visual system devel-
metaphor, theatrics, and imagination. The raw oped from analog signs communicated as ink
materials of this theater are light, sound, color, on physical paper. Only then can we master the
image, and that most common of all visual sys- technique of building these symbols from the
tems, type. The technology worked with has bits of light on the digital screen to communi-
been changing rapidly, and we often hear that cate our message.
each change is a revolution, a paradigm shift, a
rewriting of the rules. In the case of type, how- Suggested Readings
ever, the rules have not changed significantly Götz, Verushka and Ben Erben, Color & Type for the
for hundreds of years. The rules derive from the Screen, RotoVision SA, 1998.
interaction between the Roman letterform and Mullet, Kevin and Darrell Sano, Designing Visual
the human visual system, not from protean dig- Interfaces. Communication Oriented Techniques, SunSoft
ital computing technology. A fundamental goal Press, A Prentice Hall Title, 1995.
of the user interface designer is to help the user McKelvey, Roy, HyperGraphics, RotoVision SA, 1998.