Forage vs Fodder: Key Differences
Forage vs Fodder: Key Differences
ANS 323
1
Sustainable and profitable livestock production can be achieved through proper production,
utilization and management of pastures and forages worldwide. Pasture and forage crops remained
the primary sources of feed for different categories of livestock in Nigeria.
Fodder is any agricultural foodstuff used specifically to feed domesticated livestock, such
as cattle, rabbits, sheep, horses, chickens and pigs. "Fodder" refers particularly to food given to the
animals (including plants cut and carried to them), rather than that which they forage for
themselves (called forage). Fodder includes hay, straw, silage, compressed and pelleted feeds, oils
and mixed rations, and sprouted grains and legumes (such as bean sprouts, fresh malt, or spent
malt). Most animal feed is from plants, but some manufacturers add ingredients to processed feeds
that are of animal origin.
Pasture is defined as an area of land covered with grasses, herbaceous legumes, forbs, shrubs and
trees used for livestock feeding or environmental protection. This is usually referred to as
grassland. Forage refers to any aboveground plant material used for feeding livestock, but
excluding concentrates and other industrial by-products while fodder is
any agricultural foodstuff used specifically to feed domesticated livestock, such
as cattle, rabbits, sheep, horses, chickens and pigs. "Fodder" refers particularly to food given to the
animals (including plants cut and carried to them). Fodder includes hay, straw, silage, compressed
and pelleted feeds, oils and mixed rations, and sprouted grains and legumes.
Pastures and forages could be artificially sown or occur naturally. Natural or native pastures are
found in rangelands, river banks, road sides and abandoned lands while sown pastures are found
in commercial farms, universities, colleges of agriculture and some research institutes in Nigeria.
It is imperative to note that pasture and forage crops have diverse advantages in the current
dynamic and highly challenged system of livestock production. The study of pasture and forage
production enable us to understand the linkage between the various ecosystems (biotic and a biotic)
within the grassland or rangeland. This will motivate us to come up with methods of conserving
and protecting our environment from destruction through poor management. It also teaches us how
to produce qualitative forage for sustainable livestock production. This will in turn help to boost
the income level of farmers and improvement of livelihoods. Similarly, study of pasture and forage
production will assist in providing employment and recreational opportunities to a lot of people in
Nigeria. Some industries such as pharmaceutical industries will be encouraged to expand their
economic base since most of these pasture and forage crops have strong aesthetic values.
DEFINITION OF PASTURE
Pasture can be defined in many ways depending on purpose:
2
• Pasture is defined as an area of land occupied with forage plant species either
natural or planted by man for the purpose of providing qualitative feed to livestock at the
right quantity.
• It could refers to any forage specie valuable as livestock feed
a) Grasses: These belong to the family Gramineae. They are characterized by high energy,
low crude protein, fast growth rate, cylindrical stems and leaves. The leaves have parallel venation
pattern and stem is hollow. They have fibrous rooting system with light and small seeds. Other
related family members in this family include maize, millet sorghum, barley and rye.
c) Grazed Plants: These are short herbs that are consumed with both leaves and stems
together. Examples include: Brachiaria ruziziensis, Sorghum almum (Columbus grass), Arachis
pintoii and Digitaria smutsii.
d) Browed Plants: These are woody plants whose leaves and twigs (soft stems and buds) are
eaten while the woody stem is left uneaten. e.g. Leucaena leucocephala, Gliricidia sepium and
Gmelina aborea.
e) Annuals: These are plants that complete their life cycle within one growing season and
survive the dry season as seeds. e.g. Chloris gayana, Brachiaria mulato II, Pennisetum purpureum
and Hypherrania rufa.
f) Biennials: These are plants that complete their life cycle in two seasons. First season is for
vegetative growth and second season for reproductive growth. e.g. Panicum maximum (Elephant
grass), Andropogon tectorum (Southern Gamba grass) and Cynodon dactylon (Bermuda grass).
g) Perennials: These are plants that grow throughout the year for many years producing
flowers and seeds without dying such as Gmelina aborea tree, Ziziphus mauritiana tree, Ficus
thonningii tree and Acacia albida tree.
h) Weeds: These are non-planted plant species that invade an area by itself. e.g. Sorghum
bicolor, Amaranthus spinosis and Tridax procumbens.
Pasture weeds: When a pastureland is left unattended in terms of management practices for years,
there is a tendency for weeds to invade the pasture. These weeds could be controlled manually by
removing them with hand or through cutting with cutlasses. The farmer may decide to use
chemicals such as pre or post-emergence herbicides at the time of pasture establishment, mainly
for broad-leaved weeds. Weeds reduce the quality of pasture especially when they invade large
portion of land in the pasture. They also compete vigorously with the pasture plants for space,
nutrients, light intensity and moisture content. Examples of common pasture weeds in Nigeria
include: Amaranthus caudatus (waterleaf), Crinum ornatum (Lily), Solanum incanum (Graden
egg), Cyperus rotundus; Kyllinga sp.(Nut Grass), Cucurbita maxima-C. pepo (Pumpkin) etc.
4
MORPHOLOGICAL CHARACTERISTICS OF GRASSES, LEGUMES AND SHRUBS
Pasture and forage crops have unique characteristics that can easily be used to identify them in the
field. These morphological differences have direct effect on the forage yield and quality of the
plants. Animals graze the leafy parts of the plants first before other parts are eaten. This is because
the leaves are more palatable and nutritious compared to the stems or branches.
MORPHOLOGY OF GRASSES
Grasses have two different parts. These include:
• The root
• The shoot
The root of grasses is fibrous in structure and it occurs in tussock or bunch depending on the specie.
However, some grass species such as Sorghum bicolar may have a long fibrous rooting system
that could go deep into the soil in search of moisture. The root contains small root hairs that are
used for absorption of water and minerals from the soil. Generally, the roots of grasses are shallow
compared to those of legumes and shrubs. Some grasses have rhizomes
(underground storage organs that assist the grass to survive harsh conditions such as drought).
The shoot of grasses is divided into two parts-the stem and the inflorescence (flower). The stem is
made up of the leaves, nodes and inter-nodes. The leaves are attached to the stem at the leaf sheath
(a thin leathery cover that holds the leaf). The leaves of grasses have parallel venation pattern with
a central mid-rib at the centre. The leaf blade is found at the edges, which could be very sharp in
some species. Some hairs may be present under the leaf blade in some grass species. The
inflorescence or flower is the reproductive part of the grass. It is found at the top most end of the
plant. It is made up of spikes and spikelets. Other patterns of arrangement of flowers on the spike
are possible. It is important to note that in some grass species, there may be many stems when the
grass has stolons (structures that enable the stem to extend to other parts thereby forming a network
of stems).
MORPHOLOGY OF LEGUMES
Legumes are divided into four different parts:
• Root
• Branches
• Leaves
• Flowers
The root of legumes occur as tap root system with a central tap root that penetrates deep into the
soil to provide more support and absorb moisture. There are lateral roots and root hairs that
function as points of entry of solutes (water and minerals) from the soil to the stem or from the
stem back to the soil, through osmotic processes. Roots of legumes possess some nodules (smaller
or larger swellings that house some bacterial strains that assist in fixing atmospheric nitrogen into
the soil). The size of the nodule depends on the specie.
The stem of legumes is divided into smaller and larger branches, which terminate as flowers. There
could be many auxiliary branches on the main stem and each could results into production of
flowers. Also, the branches are subdivided into nodes and internodes.
5
Leaves of legumes occur in triplicate (i.e. three leaflets making one leaf). There is a central petiole
that holds the leaflets together. The leaves have net venation pattern and their size depends on the
species. Different arrangement of leaflets on the stem and branches is observed in the legumes.
Flowers are found to exist in two places in legumes. They either occur at each terminal buds or at
the end of the branches. However, regardless of their position, they are made up of calyx (base
leaves), corolla that contains the petals (not more than five), stamens (male part) and the ovules
(female part). The size of the flower depends on the species but most flowers are flamboyant, with
fragrance smell, which is highly attractive to pollinating insects.
MORPHOLOGY OF SHRUBS
Shrubs have the same morphological structure with forage legumes. The only difference between
them is that shrubs contain more woody stems than forage legumes and they have more leaves,
flowers and seeds. Also, the height of shrubs could be up to 4 meters, unlike forage legumes whose
height might be 1 meter or even less.
6
TYPES OF PASTURES BASED ON PRODUCTIVITY AND USES
NATIVE PASTURES
Established Pastures are categorized into different classes for easy identification and uses. Native
pastures established themselves naturally in most cases. However, livestock farmers may decide
to establish them either by seed or through vegetative means. In Nigeria, native pastures are found
in the natural rangelands. These pastures suffer mismanagement by users, which leads to many
social problems in our societies
• Grazing: This involves the use of livestock to reduce the amount of biomass produced by
these pastures within a given period of time. Livestock such as ruminant animals (e.g.
cattle, sheep, goats, alpacas etc) depend on pastures to acquire the necessary energy for
normal physiological activities. Therefore, grazing of native pastures by livestock help to
facilitate the pasture growth and reduce the amount of water loss from the shoot. Moreover,
grazing helps the pastures to utilize the sunlight energy from the sun faster through the
young and fresh re-growth as a result of grazing.
• Burning: This is mainly done in order to eliminate the dead and lignified leaves and
stems/branches that fall on top of the soil in the natural rangelands. The pasture growing
in such locations are completely burnt to ashes. Thereafter, a new vegetative material
comes up immediately after the first rain. Pastures will not be eliminated due to burning
because they have underground stolons and rhizomes, which help them to survive such
fires and also, the ash generated from the process serves as a good source of mineral
nutrients to the pastures.
• Slashing with cutlasses or mower: This can be done either manually using cutlasses or
mechanically using a mowing machine. The main idea here is that when these pastures are
cut at certain height, the biomass density of the shoot reduces thereby creating more spaces
for sunlight to penetrate the remaining portions left. This will make them to phosynthesized
faster and deposit more carbohydrates and nitrogen for good livestock performance. Also,
the livestock mainly in the form of conserved forage utilizes the pastures better. This will
also help to improve farmers’ income.
• Division into paddocks or large fences demarcated with barb wires and angle irons: This is
a situation whereby the native pastures are completely demarcated with barb wires and
angle irons in order to improve the grazing efficiency of the pastures by livestock. Certain
7
number of livestock is allowed to graze a paddock without over/under-stocking the
pastures. In Nigerian situation, the fencing can be cheaply done using other materials such
as Jatropha curcas or Gliricidia sepium plants. However, these plants are less effective
than the barbwire fencing, although barbwires and angle irons are expensive to purchase.
• Sod seeding: This refers to the process of planting seeds of improved pastures in an existing
native pastures. This can be done by some artistic designs to be decided by the manager of
the rangeland or pastures. Sod seeding of native pastures is hardly done in Nigeria because
the rangelands are under the jurisdiction of the government rather than individuals or
communities. Sod seeding helps to improve the productivity of pastures.
• Fertilization: This involves applying organic or in-organic fertilizers to native pastures for
improved biomass production and quality. Grasses require nitrogen fertilization more than
legumes. This helps them to accumulate more carbohydrates and energy thereby making
them better forage materials for livestock.
• Frequent defoliation: This refers to the systematic cutting of pasture species in the field
through the use of a mowing machine or cutlasses. The defoliation is done frequently at
fixed intervals, such as two weeks intervals etc. This will help to facilitate re-growth of the
existing native pastures thereby improving their productivity.
IMPROVED PASTURES
Improved pastures are pastures that have undergone breeding, selection and improvement for better
yield and livestock performance. They differ from native pastures because they are mainly exotic
or are imported from other countries. They can also be introduced from one region to another
within the same country. Therefore, their management practices differ from the native species.
They produce higher biomass of superior quality than the native pastures. However, the cost of
establishing and maintaining improved pastures is always a course for concern to the farmers.
8
Management of Improved Pastures
Improved pastures are managed in the same way other crops are managed in the farm. The
management of these pastures starts at establishment phase. The following steps are important
for successful establishment and high quality biomass in these pastures:
• Selection of a fertile land for establishment
• Good and timely land preparation
• Choice of the right pasture specie
• Use of correct seed rate depending on the cost of the seeds and availability
• Use of the recommended seeding depth during planting
• Proper control of weeds
• Timely fertilization
• Defoliation/removal of shoots for forage conservation or livestock feeding
9
PASTURES ASSOCIATED WITH CROPS
Pasture species are incorporated into other crops for optimum benefits ranging from environmental
protection to other economic benefits. Both native and improved pasture species can be used for
this purpose. The major advantage of this system is increase in grain and forage yield of the crops
(e.g. maize crop), which could translate into improved economic gain by farmers. However, in
some situations, drastic drop in grain yield may results, especially when the crop and pasture
species are planted on the same land, and on the same day.
Ley Pastures
Pasture species are sometimes planted together with field crops. Browse plants such as Leucaena
leucocephala, Gliricidia sepium, Gmelina aborea etc are commonly used for this purpose. The
main difference between ley pastures and pastures associated with crops is that in ley pastures
browse plants are mainly used as pasture species rather than other grass and legume species.
These types of pastures are mainly established for temporary use and they have the following
advantages:
• They help to improve soil fertility
• They help farmers to control weeds, disease pathogens and pests
• They provide fencing materials to farmers
• They help to increase yield of cereal crops
• They help to combat climate change
10
TYPES OF PASTURES BASED ON DURATION
TEMPORARY PASTURES
These are pastures established as part of rotation system either to provide feed for livestock or for
other purposes such as control of erosion, pests and diseases or moisture conservation. They could
also serve as sources of nutrients to the soil, thereby improving the fertility of the soil. Both annual
and perennial species can be used but they have to be easily eradicated. They are of high
productivity because they are established on good soils. They last for a period of 3-5years.
SEMI-PERMANENT PASTURES
These are pastures that are established as part of rotation system usually due to a break in cropping
phase. The cropping phase can be broken for several reasons such drastic decrease in prices of
crops, disease outbreak, low soil fertility or change in decision by the farmer. Therefore, livestock
production is integrated into these pastures for a short period of time, usually 5-10years before the
pastureland is re-converted into cropping land again.
PERMANENT PASTURES
Permanent pastures are mainly established for the purpose of feeding livestock. They can be native
or sown pastures. These pastures last for several decades. They consist of annual and perennial
species that have underground storage organs (rhizomes and stolons). These structures help the
pasture species to survive the dry season and other harsh conditions such as fire incidence, intense
defoliation and overgrazing. When pasture specie is not producing viable seeds annually, such
species can be used in permanent pastures. These pastures are however very difficult to be
eradicated. They are planted on fertile soils. These type of pastures are usually common in highly
profitable livestock enterprises such dairy and beef enterprises.
12
PASTURES IN NIGERIAN AGRICULTURE
13
Relationship between Pastures and Other Ecosystem Components
In grassland ecosystem, there are some existing relationships between various components of the
system. These relationships help to maintain balance in the system, thereby providing livestock
with nutritious feed. The components affected are:
• Soil
• Plants/Pasture Species
• Animals
• Man
• Climate
Socio-Economic Factors
The following factors affect pasture productivity in Nigerian agricultural system:
Overgrazing natural rangelands
Ignorance of farmers about the importance of pasture farming
Inadequate policies on pasture resources and improvement in Nigeria
Fluctuating demands and supply of livestock products due to fluctuating income
Inadequate and costly pasture seeds that are unaffordable by majority of farmers in Nigeria
Poverty of farmers
Lack of farmers’ organizations on pasture production and marketing in Nigeria
Insecurity issues prevent farmers from expanding their enterprises
14
PASTURE ESTABLISHMENT FOR FORAGE AND SEED PRODUCTION
Planting/Sowing Methods
Pasture seeds can be planted or sown using three methods (planting, drilling and broadcasting).
Planting is done mainly for large seeded legumes such as Mucuna pruriens, Lablab purpureus etc.
These pasture seeds are planted using inter and intra-row spaces available (25cm×75cm) for
optimum plant population. In drilling, there is no intra-spacing, rather the seeds are drilled evenly
with a single and continuous hole. For broadcasting, the seeds are broadcasted in the field. Drilling
and broadcasting methods are done for small seeded legume and grass seeds. Sometimes, it is
advisable to use a carrier agent such as sand, fertilizer or sawdust during planting to enable seeds
to be placed in the intended location, especially on a windy day.
Post-Planting Operations
After an encouraging germination of the pasture species, some operations are expected for better
establishment, forage yield and quality. These operations include the followings:
Weeding-This can be achieved manually, through the use of hand hoes, chemically using
herbicides or mechanically, using tractor coupled implements such as a weeder. Weeding
should be done at 2-3 weeks after planting depending on the intensity of weeds and also
the management. In commercial pasture production, weeding is done mechanically for
better results
15
Fertilizer application- Fertilizers should be applied after weeding for improved
performance. Some farmers apply fertilizers such phosphatic fertilizers e.g. Single Super
Phosphate (SSP) during land preparation. However, other fertilizers such as nitrogenous
fertilizers have to be applied to the pasture especially if it is a sole grass pasture.
Defoliation-This refers to the cutting of plant shoot with the aim of improving the growth
performance and getting high quality forage. The pasture species can be defoliated 2-3
times in a year depending on the species, environmental conditions and management.
Flowering Stage: At this stage, the pasture specie produces flowers for seed production.
Fertilized ova result into immature seeds, which can be grazed by livestock or even
defoliated for conservation. This stage is known as the bloom stage. The amount of dry
matter at this stage supersedes the moisture content, and therefore farmers normally harvest
their pastures at this stage depending on the type of enterprise.
Post-Flowering Stage: During this stage, seeds are set by the pasture specie. However, the
moisture content of the seeds is still high compared to dry seeds. This stage is sometimes
known as the dough stage in maize plant for silage. The forage at this stage contains high
level of fibre for structural support. Livestock feed very little quantity of the forage material
at this stage, even though the moisture content is very low.
16
be considered before using or storing any material for future use. Therefore, moisture content can
be reduced from the forage by wilting the material for some few days after cutting. Thereafter, the
wilted forage can be further sliced into fine, smaller cuts to facilitate moisture loss. Also, there has
to be frequent turning of the forage material while in the field depending on the dimension, density
and structure of the swath.
Hay- This refers to conserved forage that is in dried stage. Spreading the forage in the sun
or inside barn can do the drying process either. However, sun cured hay is cheaper to make
than the barn cured hay, but barn cured hay is more qualitative than sun cured hay. This is
because of less leaf losses in the barn compared to the field. Hays are stored as rectangular
or round bales, cubical bales or as stacks. The quality of hay depends on the stage of cutting
the forage and climatic condition.
Silage- Silage is conserved forage that has undergone complete anaerobic fermentation for
a period of 3 weeks. Fresh forage material is harvested at appropriate stage of pasture
growth. The material may be allowed to wilt or used directly to make silage while the
moisture content is still high. The forage has to be cut into smaller pieces before
transporting into silo. A silo is a structure for making silage. After uploading the forage in
the silo, it has to be well consolidated. Some additives are added in the material to facilitate
intake. Finally, a polythene material is used to cover the silo completely for a period of
three weeks. Silage is more acceptable to livestock than hay because of its quality.
However, it is more expensive to make than hay.
Pellets: Pastures can also be preserved in form of pellets. This is possible by using
pelletized machine after drying the forage into hay. This will facilitate packaging, easy
handling and transportation of the forage from one place to the other. Also, its acceptability
to livestock is higher compared to hay.
FERTILIZER APPLICATION
Fertilizers are needed in pastures for better establishment and quality. This is due to the supply of
necessary nutrients (macro and micro) that are highly essential for pasture growth. Lack of these
nutrients in the soil can lead to poor growth and performance of pasture species. Different pasture
species have different fertilizer requirements. For example, grass species require more of
nitrogenous fertilizers than phosphorus, although phosphorus is also critical to the survival of the
species. Legumes need more of phosphorus and calcium rather than nitrogen.
19
FORAGE CONSERVATION TECHNIQUES
Forage conservation is one of the methods of pasture management in Nigeria. Excess forage is
conserved during the period of abundance to be used during period of scarcity. In order to avoid
excessive spending on purchase of expensive concentrate feeds, farmers harvest forages during
peak period of growth and preserve in form of hay, silage or stacks. Although the quality of these
conserved forages vary greatly, but they are reliable methods used in Nigerian livestock industry
to address the issue of feed scarcity.
Hay
Hay is dry forage formed after wilting, sun drying, turning and packaging of the dry forage
material. The packaging process can be done either with a baling machine or manually using hand.
Hay is the most common method of forage conservation in Nigeria. It has the following advantages
over silage:
It is easier and faster to make compared to silage
It has high dry matter content
It requires less labour than silage
It is cheaper than silage
It can be done anywhere provided the farmer is experienced
It provides bulkiness in the rumen which aid the rumen micro-organisms
Silage
Silage is fermented forage used for supplementing livestock either throughout the year or during
the period of feed scarcity. It requires high technical man power and is more expensive than hay,
especially in intensively managed farms. However, it has the following advantages:
It is more qualitative than hay
It has high acceptability by livestock than hay provided it is well prepared
It is independent of weather
It can be integrated with other farm operations such as mowing and grazing
It can smoother weed seeds
It can easily be degraded by rumen microbes
Stacked Hay
This refers to dry forage prepared by reducing moisture content while the forage is in the field.
The difference between stack hay and hay is that stack hay is normally kept for temporary use
whereas hay can be stored for years without spoiling. This type of hay is commonly seen in rural
areas where farmers store hay from their crops such cowpea and groundnut haulms. It is mostly
seen on top of trees and rooftops in villages and along the road. Stacked hay has the following
advantages:
It is most suitable for smallholder livestock enterprises in Nigeria
It does not require much labour to prepare
It requires less space than hay and silage
It supplies livestock with the much required energy and protein during critical periods
It is free from fire outbreak which may ravage the livestock industry
20
WEEDS CONTROL
Weeds are part of pastures especially in Nigeria where pastures are poorly managed. There are
many types of weeds that can easily multiply and take over the pastures within a short period of
time. Hence, weeds invade new areas of lands in Nigeria due to plant migration, invasion and
climatic fluctuations. These weeds must be controlled for sustainable pasture production as well
as livestock survival and strong economic base in the country. Some of these weeds are poisonous
to livestock and should not be allowed to persist in pastures.
There is need to control these weeds before and after planting because at the initial stage of pasture
establishment, the pasture species grow very slowly, while weeds grow very fast, thereby
smothering the pasture species. However, it is important to note that there are weeds that are
beneficial to livestock and farmers (non-toxic weeds) as against toxic weeds which cause economic
loss and environmental hazards.
21
GRAZING MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS
Grazing management system involves pasture manipulation under grazing condition with the
sole aim of feeding livestock and environmental control. Grazing livestock on pastures help to
reduce the cost of production and improves the quality of livestock products. The type of grazing
management adapted by farmers depends on resources available and management decision.
However, not all grazing management systems are suitable to farmers in Nigeria, due to their
costs or technical complications.
22
TYPES OF GRAZING MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS
There are many grazing management systems adapted by farmers in Nigeria and elsewhere.
These systems are further categorized based on the size of livestock owned by farmers and the
area of land for grazing. Where the land is scarce, such as in cities and urban areas, grazing of
livestock is rarely possible, because of traffic and human inconveniences. Therefore, farmers
adopt other means of feeding their livestock to suit the condition they found themselves.
The main disadvantage of this system is that livestock may be exposed to the problem of toxic
pasture species which are undesirable in the pasture.
There are many types of grazing management systems. However, farmers in Nigeria practice not
all these systems. These include the following:
Zero grazing/Cut and carry system-This involves cutting the pasture from the field and
feeding it to livestock in their pens.
Continuous grazing system-This system involves keeping the animals in pasture for
grazing throughout the year.
Deferred grazing system- In this system, some parts of the pasture are prevented from
grazing by livestock until certain times of the year
Rotational grazing- This involves grazing livestock in paddocks for certain number of days
before they are move to another paddock
Strip grazing system-In this system, livestock are allowed to graze an area demarcated with
electrical strip. Animals are lightly shocked when they touch the strip
Straight Creep grazing system-This involves a creep area for young animals and a base
pasture for the dam or mother. It is done to improve growth of young animals
Forwards Creep grazing system-This involves the use of base pasture for animals with high
nutrient requirements e.g. young animals first, before others
First and Last Suizers grazing system-This system considers different classes of livestock
for grazing at the same time e.g. cattle, sheep and goats
24