100% found this document useful (1 vote)
326 views22 pages

Solkor RF Pilot Wire Protection Guide

The document summarizes the Solkor Rf pilot wire differential relay. Key points: 1) The Solkor Rf uses full-wave current balance protection for transformer feeder circuits with metallic pilots. 2) It has a simple, robust design suitable for dedicated pilot wires with 5kV insulation as standard. 3) Connection involves two pilot cores to carry summed 3-phase current information using summation transformers and biasing.

Uploaded by

rashid rahman
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
100% found this document useful (1 vote)
326 views22 pages

Solkor RF Pilot Wire Protection Guide

The document summarizes the Solkor Rf pilot wire differential relay. Key points: 1) The Solkor Rf uses full-wave current balance protection for transformer feeder circuits with metallic pilots. 2) It has a simple, robust design suitable for dedicated pilot wires with 5kV insulation as standard. 3) Connection involves two pilot cores to carry summed 3-phase current information using summation transformers and biasing.

Uploaded by

rashid rahman
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
  • Introduction to Solkor Rf
  • Relays and Components
  • Solkor Range Overview
  • Solkor R/Rf Key Features
  • Circulating Current Protection
  • Summation Transformer Details
  • Induced Volts in OHL Systems
  • Induced Volts in Cable Systems
  • Voltage Induction Estimations
  • Typical Induced Voltages
  • Operating Principle of Solkor Rf
  • Connection Diagram
  • Load Current and Fault Analysis
  • Internal Fault Analysis
  • Applications Overview
  • Basic Solkor Rf Specifications
  • Overcurrent Guard Relaies Application
  • Pilot Wire Supervision
  • Injection Intertripping Function
  • System Requirements
  • Performance and Sensitivity

Solkor Rf

Pilot wire current differential feeder protection

REYROLLE
Solkor – Relays and Components

POLES

CASE
MODEL RL NOTES

Feeder Differential Solkor R/Rf 3 E6 3 0.5A, 1A, 2A, 5A


Pilot Isolation 15kV Isolating Transformer SP Rf mode
Guard Relay B69 3 E6
Pilot Supervision Supply Transf./Rectifier E4 5kV Scheme
Send End B22 Supply Supvn Relay E2
(PSSE) Supply Transf./Rectifier 1.5V 15kV Scheme
B22 Supply Supvn Relay E2
Pilot Supervision Receive/Repeat B74 + B75 E4 5kV Scheme
Receive End Receive B75 1.5V 15kV Scheme
(PSRE) Receive Repeat B74 E2
Injection TEC 1.5V 5kV, 15kV
Intertrip Send Inverter SP

REYROLLE
The Solkor range of Pilot Wire Feeder Differential relays

• Solkor A - 1942 Pilotwire Differential using voltage balance

• Solkor B - 1948 Pilot wire voltage balance

• Solkor R - 1963 Half wave current balance

• Overall Solkor - 1965 Current balance for transformer feeder circuits.

• Solkor Rf – 1982 Full wave current balance

• Solkor M - 1993 Digital with Vf signalling

• Solkor N - 2001 Numerical Phase Segregated Differential

REYROLLE
Solkor R/Rf - Key features

Metallic Pilots

Simple, robust, biased current differential protection


Suitable for use with dedicated metallic pilots - requires 2 cores
5kV pilot insulation standard
Compatibility with Solkor R
E6 Case Suitable for 19 inch rack or flush panel mounting
0.5A, 1A, 2A & 5A rated relays

Options:
15 kV isolating transformers
Pilot wire supervision
Two way Injection Intertripping
Overcurrent Guard
T&D 12975

REYROLLE
Solkor Rf - Circulating Current Protection

B B
3 O - Operating Coil 3
O O
1 B - Bias Coil 1
1 1

SUMMATION SUMMATION
TRANSFORMER TRANSFORMER

Summation transformers allow 3 phase information to be carried on two pilot cores

Biasing is provided by internally generated voltage gradients

REYROLLE
Summation Transformer

R
B
1
Y

1
B OUTPUT
R

N Y

n+2
300

EQUIVALENT OUTPUTS FOR 1.


EQUAL FAULT CURRENTS: 73
2
R-N = n + 2
Y-N = n + 1
B-N = n n+1
R-Y = 1 n
Y-B = 1
B-R = 2
3ph. = 1.732

REYROLLE
Calculation of Induced Volts in Pilot Conductors (OHL Systems)

Earth wire

C S

Pilot circuit

• Earth fault current returns through:


– Earth mass, earth wire (if applicable), pilot cable sheath (if applicable)

• Induced Volts per km = 0.145 Ie log10 D/S


– Ie = single phase/earth fault current
– D = equivalent depth of earth return (typically 450 - 900m)
– S = Distance between pilots and phase conductors(m)

• Reduction factor will apply for the proportion of current carried by earth wires or pilot cable sheath.

REYROLLE
Calculation of Induced Volts in Pilot Conductors (Cable Systems)

LONGITUDINAL INDUCED VOLTAGE (same polarity in each conductor)

Pilot cable sheath/armour

Power cable sheath/armour


3-Phase Power Cable Ie Coupling
flux Earth mass

• e = 2πf MILK

Earth fault current returns through:


– Power cable sheath/armour (screening factor typically
0.1)
– Pilot cable sheath/armour (screening factor typically
0.5)
– Earth mass

REYROLLE
Estimation of Voltage Induced in Pilot Conductors (Cable systems)

• e = 2πf MILK

– Where:
• e = Longitudinal voltage
• M = Coupling between power circuit and pilots
• I = Zero sequence current
• L = Length of common path
• K = Screening factor

• Typically 0.0045 to 0.12 V/A/km


– Lower values apply to aluminium sheathed cables
– Higher values apply to lead sheathed cables

• 5kV insulated relays and pilots are generally applicable to 11kV cable systems. Short cables and low
fault currents may allow use on higher voltage systems.

• 15kV insulated relays and pilots are generally applicable to higher voltage cable systems.

REYROLLE
Typical Induced voltages alongside Cables.

Volts/kA/km
Size Of Power Cable and With effect of Main Cable Sheath
Without effect of
Nominal Voltage Main Cable
Sheath
Lead Aluminium

3 x 1 core each 400mm2 33kV 300-600 60-120 30-60

3 x 1 core each 320mm2 132kV 300-600 60-120 30-60

3 x 1 core each 1930mm2 132kV 300-600 30-60 12-24

3 x 1 core each 960mm2 275kV 300-600 45-90 12-24

3 x 1 core each 960mm2 400kV 300-600 30-60 9-18

Induced volts per kA of through fault per km of line length

REYROLLE
Operating principle

T&D 0000

REYROLLE
Solkor Rf Connection Diagram

D1 D2

Ra 35 65 130 260 500 PILOT 500 260 130 65 35 Ra


Pilot Padding Resistors CABLE
Pilot Padding Resistors
5kV
Barrier D3 D4
N1 N1
N Metering Point N

Test Link
B B
Y Y
R R

Summ.
Transf. D7 D8

Ra Ra

D5 D6

REYROLLE
Load Current/External Fault

V
V

X1 Y C X Y1
C C C

V
X Y1 V X1 Y

X1 Y1
+ - -
X1 Y1
+
Ra Rp/2
Rp/2 Ra

C C
C C

Rp/2 Ra Rp/2
Ra
- + + -
X Y X Y

Pilot Volts: Pilot Volts: Pilot Volts: Pilot Volts:


X1 - X Y1 - Y X1 - X Y1 - Y

Relay Volts: Relay Volts:


Relay Volts: Y1 - C Relay Volts: Y1 - C
X1 - C X1 - C

Relay Volts: Relay Volts:


Relay Volts: Y -C Relay Volts: Y -C
X -C X -C

REYROLLE
Internal Fault

X1 Y1

Ra Rp/2

+V +V

+ +
C O O

Rp/2 Ra

X Y

X1 Y1

Rp/2

C O O
- -

+V +V

Ra Rp/2 Ra

REYROLLE
Applications

• Solkor + Overcurrent Guard

• Solkor + Pilot wire Supervision

• Solkor + Pilot wire Supervision + Overcurrent Guard

• Solkor + Injection Intertripping

• Solkor + Pilot wire Supervision + Injection Intertripping

• Plain Feeder
– Including In-Zone teed -off load
• Note
• OC Guard and injection intertrip cannot be used together

REYROLLE
Basic Solkor Rf

Basic Solkor Rf insulated to 5kV

Isolation transformers provide isolation to 15kV


Isolation
Transformer
15kV

Biasing characteristic of Solkor Rf allows


tolerance to 20% in zone bleed-off

5kV Isolation 15kV Isolation 5kV Isolation


Bleed off current supplied
to in-zone load

REYROLLE
Application of Overcurrent Guard Relays

5kV Isolation

OC Guard B69 or
Is > ILOAD MR302 or
Inst. AG1

• Guard relays are used:


– Where damage to pilots can occur e.g. mechanical excavator
– Tripping must be avoided

• Note
• Where Argus relays are used with Solkor the Solkor can be arranged to trigger the
Argus waveform storage feature

REYROLLE
Solkor Rf + Pilot Wire Supervision

5kV Isolation

Supply B75
Transf./Rec. B22 B74
Supervision
Unit
PSSE (5kV) PSRE (5kV)
A.C.
Supply

15kV Isolation

Transf./Rec. Unit

Supply
B22 B75
Supervision
Isolation
Transformer B74 DTL
A.C. PSSE (15kV)
Supply
PSRE (15kV)

REYROLLE
Injection Intertripping

5kV Isolation

Transf./Rec. Unit

Supply B75
B22 B74
Supervision
110V dc
PSSE (5kV) PSRE (5kV)
Supply
A.C.
Conns for
Supply
PULSED or
SUSTAINED
intertrip OP

Intertrip RESET
Initiate
B34 TR141
90ms P.U.
DDB1
2s P.U. Unstabilises remote Solkor by injecting AC onto pilots

Can be installed at both ends

Pulsed or sustained intertrip

5kV isolation

REYROLLE
System requirements

Metallic Pilots

PILOT CIRCUIT

Specification for pilot cables for use with Solkor RF is ;-


Pilot loop resistance < 2000 Ohms
Inter-core capacitance < 0.8 microfarad.

Application of 5kV or 15kV insulated systems is based on the calculation for induced longitudinal
volts:
0.06 - 0.12V / Amp / Km for Steel armoured cables, and
0.03 - 0.06V / Amp / Km for Aluminium armoured cables of 400 sq. mm.

CURRENT TRANSFORMERS
50 I F
VK = + (R CT + 2R L )
In N
Solkor burden approx. 3VA.
CT magnetising currents at each line ends must not differ by more than I/20 Amperes for output
voltages < 50V.

REYROLLE
Performance - Sensitivity and Operate Speed

A
B
C

T yp e F A U L T S E T T IN G S
of (% o f C T R a tin g )
F a u lt 5K V S chem es 15K V S chem es
T y p ic a l T y p ic a l
N 1 N N 1 N
A - E 18 25 25 35
B - E 21 32 30 44
Operating times ;-
C - E 25 42 35 59
A - B 125 177 5KV schemes - 45mS
B - C 125 177 15KV schemes - 40mS
A - C 62 8 8 .5
AB C 72 101

REYROLLE
Solkor Rf

Pilot wire current differential feeder protection

Created: July 06
REYROLLE

Common questions

Powered by AI

Challenges with pilot wire differential protection in high-voltage systems include the risk of voltage induction in pilot conductors due to earth faults, leading to erroneous tripping signals. The requirement for robust insulation, up to 15kV, and managing pilot circuit characteristics such as loop resistance and inter-core capacitance are essential to maintain sensitivity and avoid false operations. Furthermore, maintaining an optimal response time while dealing with long-distance pilot connections, as seen in operation times of 40mS for 15KV schemes, is challenging. Pilot supervision and the use of isolating transformers help mitigate these issues .

Pilot wire supervision is essential because it continuously monitors the integrity of the pilot wire circuit, ensuring there are no open circuits or short circuits that could compromise the relay's ability to detect faults. This supervision is crucial when integrating Solkor with other protective measures because it guarantees that the protection scheme only responds to genuine fault conditions, avoiding misoperation due to pilot wire faults .

Overcurrent guard relays are used in conjunction with the Solkor Rf system to provide an additional layer of protection specifically when external faults or high load currents pose a risk to the pilot wires. They ensure that tripping is prevented when the pilot wires are subject to mechanical damage or unexpected high loads from external connections, thus protecting both the relay operation and physical pilot wire integrity. These relays are particularly necessary in environments with high potential for pilot damage or where load currents exceed normal expectations .

The Solkor range of relays has evolved significantly over time. It began with Solkor A in 1942, using pilot wire differential with voltage balance. Solkor B introduced a different voltage balance in 1948. The Solkor R in 1963 and Solkor Rf in 1982 shifted to current balance methods, with the Rf integrating full wave current balance. A major advancement came with Solkor M in 1993, offering digital capabilities with Vf signaling. The latest, Solkor N in 2001, adopted numerical phase-segregated differential protection .

The Solkor Rf relay enhances feeder protection using biasing through internally generated voltage gradients, which create a proportional response to differential current. This bias prevents operation from minor differences in current that are not fault-related, thus ensuring that the relay accurately distinguishes between normal load currents and genuine fault conditions, enhancing the selectivity and reliability of protection .

The Solkor Rf relay provides tolerance to in-zone bleed-off current by utilizing its biasing characteristic, which allows for a 20% tolerance. This feature is significant because it helps maintain relay sensitivity without false tripping due to small imbalances or load variations within the protected zone, thereby increasing reliability and protection accuracy in power systems .

In a Solkor Rf system, the bias coil and operating coil work together to maintain balance and accurate detection of faults. The bias coil helps maintain relay stability by adding a controlled amount of restraint, reducing the likelihood of false tripping under load variations. The operating coil, on the other hand, is sensitive to differential currents indicative of a fault. Their combined action ensures the relay is both responsive to true faults and stable against normal load fluctuations, effectively balancing sensitivity and security .

Digital and numerical features in Solkor M and N models offer several technological benefits over earlier mechanical counterparts. These include improved accuracy and precision in fault detection, ability to handle complex signaling and communication tasks, and flexibility in settings adjustments. Digital features provide better noise immunity and are easier to integrate with modern control systems, while numerical models facilitate phase-segregated differential protection, enabling more detailed fault analysis and reporting, thus enhancing overall system reliability and performance .

REYROLLE systems address the problem of induced voltage in pilot conductors by calculating the potential induced volts based on specific parameters like earth fault current, distance between conductors, and the core material of power cables. Screening factors for power cable sheaths and pilot cable sheaths are applied (0.1 for aluminium and 0.5 for pilot cables). By utilizing these factors and isolation transformers, the systems reduce unwanted voltage effects, ensuring accurate operation even in high fault current environments .

Isolation transformers in the Solkor Rf system provide electrical isolation between the primary power circuit and the pilot cables, which is crucial for high voltage applications. They allow the system to handle higher voltage levels, such as transitioning from 5kV to 15kV insulation levels, thereby preventing electrical faults from affecting sensitive relay components and ensuring operator safety .

REYROLLE
Pilot wire current differential feeder protection
Solkor Rf
REYROLLE
Solkor – Relays and Components
Injection
Intertrip Send
Pilot Supervision
Receive End
(PSRE)
Pilot Supervision
Send
REYROLLE
The Solkor range  of Pilot Wire Feeder Differential relays
•
Solkor A - 1942
Pilotwire Differential using voltage ba
REYROLLE
T&D 12975
Solkor R/Rf - Key features
Simple, robust, biased current differential protection
Suitable for use with de
REYROLLE
Solkor Rf - Circulating Current Protection
B
3
1
1
B
O
3
1
1
SUMMATION
TRANSFORMER
SUMMATION
TRANSFORMER
O - Operati
REYROLLE
Summation Transformer
EQUIVALENT OUTPUTS FOR
EQUAL FAULT CURRENTS:
R-N = n + 2
Y-N = n + 1
B-N = n
R-Y = 1
Y-B = 1
B
REYROLLE
Calculation of Induced Volts in Pilot Conductors (OHL Systems)
•
Earth fault current returns through:
–
Earth mass,
REYROLLE
Calculation of Induced Volts in Pilot Conductors (Cable Systems)
•
e = 2πf MILK
Earth fault current returns through:
REYROLLE
Estimation of Voltage Induced in Pilot Conductors (Cable systems)
•
e = 2πf MILK
–
Where:
•
e = Longitudinal voltage
REYROLLE
Typical Induced voltages alongside Cables.
9-18
30-60
300-600
3 x 1 core each 960mm2 400kV
12-24
45-90
300-600
3 x 1

You might also like