0% found this document useful (0 votes)
295 views5 pages

Efficacy of Lemongrass in Mosquito Repellents

This document provides a theoretical framework and literature review for a study on the efficacy of citronella extract and lemongrass extract in a scented candle for repelling mosquitoes. It reviews related studies that have shown citronella and lemongrass to be effective natural mosquito repellents. The document presents the hypothesis that a citronella-lemongrass scented candle will be effective at repelling mosquitoes. It defines key terms and presents a conceptual IPO diagram and hypotheses for the study.

Uploaded by

JB Tugano
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
295 views5 pages

Efficacy of Lemongrass in Mosquito Repellents

This document provides a theoretical framework and literature review for a study on the efficacy of citronella extract and lemongrass extract in a scented candle for repelling mosquitoes. It reviews related studies that have shown citronella and lemongrass to be effective natural mosquito repellents. The document presents the hypothesis that a citronella-lemongrass scented candle will be effective at repelling mosquitoes. It defines key terms and presents a conceptual IPO diagram and hypotheses for the study.

Uploaded by

JB Tugano
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

CHAPTER 2

THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK

A. Review of Related Literature and Studies


Lemongrass (Cymbopogon citratus) is a tall, perennial grass in a class of
about 45 species of grasses native to tropical and sub-tropical climates of Asia,
Australia and Africa. On the other hand, Citronella (Cymbopogon nardus) is also
a tall, perennial grass and it is the source of oit that is also known as Citronella
Oil. Lemongrass is known as natural insect repellent, which can help disorient
insects, such as mosquitoes. Mosquitoes are slender, long-legged fly with
aquatic larvae. The bite of the bloodsucking female can transmit a number of
serious diseases including Malaria, Encephalitis and Dengue. Therefore,
mosquitoes are the main cause of Dengue and Malaria outbreaks here in the
Philippines.

As stated by Maya and Moore (2011), Citronella is widely used as


mosquito repellent, but only with specific range of concentration because if the
value exceeds, it may cause skin irritation. Also, the effectiveness of this plant is
the same as the chemical repellents with DEET. Their only difference is that
DEET can kill mosquitoes, while Citronella can only disorient it. One of the best
way of using Citronella as insect repellent is by making it as a scented candle so
the area of effect is wide, as long as the level of concentration is controlled to
prevent irritation on the skin. Though it cannot provide a significant protection,
the researchers will combine Lemongrass and Citronella essence to improve the
effectiveness of the scented candle.

As mentioned by Scutti (2013), Thai researchers tested the repellence of


oils gathered from plant species compared to commercial mosquito repellents
with DEET. The results showed that Citronella Oil is effective as the chemical
mosquito repellent, which caused allergic reactions to other users. But with the
addition of Vanilla to Citronella Oil, in can increase the span of time of protection
against mosquitoes. Researchers from Thailand have proven that Citronella
essence is as potent and as efficient as the chemical repellents but it is safer for
those who have sensitive skin and allergic tendencies.

As studied by Wells (2017), Lemongrass is a healthy and versatile


essential oil. It is also effective as an organic repellent. If ever you have a big
outdoor space, burn Lemongrass lamps and candles. Lemongrass products such
as torches, lanterns and tea lights can add relaxation to your yard. Lighting up
Lemongrass candles or lamps can protect a significant amount of yard space
from mosquitoes.

As indicated by Karen (2018), Lemongrass is one of the alternatives for


repelling mosquitoes. According to her, there is no perfect approach to control
Dengue mosquitoes but, with the eagerness to maintain cleanliness and with the
help of Lemongrass, it will surely reduce Dengue disease. Lemongrass has been
recommended by specialists to be planted in households to lessen Dengue
infections.

According to Musa (2015), the efficiency of Lemongrass extract was


tested on Anopheles mosquito and its larvae. The results showed that within 19
minutes, the adult and the larvae died. Their study indicated that Lemongrass is
an effective insect repellent to minimize Dengue diseases caused by mosquitoes.

According to Patricio (2012), the use of Lemongrass as border plant can


ward off insect pests from invading the farm. Aside from that, it is used as an
agricultural strategy to provide affordable and effective protection against pests
because it does not cause harm to the crops. Lemongrass has already been
used by many farmers to supply them with cheap but capable insect repellent. It
also does not damage the crops, which is a very important trait of an insect
repellent that is sought by farm owners.
According to Chaiyakunapruk (2011), the span of protection of Citronella
Oil was less compared to the DEET group. Citronella Oil combined with Vanilla
lasts longer compared with Citronella alone. Citronella products are less effective
than DEET in terms of duration of protection but the combination of Vanilla and
Lemongrass extract can prolong the period of protection.

The mentioned articles above imply that Lemongrass and Citronella


extracts have been proven effective in repelling mosquitoes on their own, even
without combining the two. Other articles state that the effectiveness of the
Lemongrass as mosquito repellent can be prolonged by adding Vanilla. Also, the
chemical mosquito repellents can trigger allergic tendencies and skin irritation.

B. Synthesis
Since the research study has focused on the efficacy of the Citronella
essence with Lemongrass-scented candle as an insect repellent, there is a
theory that is developed by the researchers and that is Citronella extract with
Lemongrass is really potent and it has a huge possibility that this study will be a
success because of the liable proofs stated above. Citronella is popular for its
ability to repel insects; moreover, Citronella is widely used by the local farmers.
The effectiveness of Citronella is the same as repellents with DEET; however,
Citronella is safer and cheaper. Insects are biologically diverse and are part of
the system, keeping the surrounding clean is still the best way to control its
number and to avoid the diseases they bring.
C. Conceptual Paradigm
Figure 1

IPO Diagram

Fig.1. shows the IPO Diagram for this research study

Based on this diagram, the researchers had conducted their study in order
to know the efficacy of Citronella essence and Lemongrass as a mosquito
repellent. However, there are variables that should be considered such as
Citronella essence, Lemongrass, scented candle, and the mosquitoes. More so,
to acquire credible data several experiments and observation will be conducted.
Testing will provide accurate result in the study. For instance, if the test will state
that there is a possible effect that Citronella essence and Lemongrass as
mosquito repellent, then the institution should consider to use the experimented
product (scented-candle) as substitute in chemical mosquito repellent. Also, the
researchers hypothesized that there are no possible effects of Citronella essence
and Lemongrass-scented candle as a mosquito repellent.
p
In
s
o
r
tP
u
O
D. Hypothesis of the Study
The researchers of this study present presumption that have been created
from the stratagem of the research questions and, by the parts of Chapter 4, it
will be tested using statistical tools but will not be proved since hypotheses are
just expected answers produced by the researchers’ curious and exploratory
mind.

Ho: Citronella extract with Lemongrass extract-scented candle is not effective in


repelling mosquitoes.
Hi: Citronella extract with Lemongrass extract-scented candle is effective in
repelling mosquitoes.

E. Definition of Terms
These following terms have been chosen by the researchers themselves
and define them accordingly to the context of the research study:

i. Efficacy - this word is defined as the power to produce a desired result or


effect
ii. Encephalitis - this word is regarded as the inflammation of the brain that is
caused especially by infection with a virus (such as herpes simplex or
West Nile virus) or less commonly with bacterial or fungal infection or
auto-immune reaction
iii. DOH - or Department of Health is the executive department of the
Philippine government responsible for ensuring access to basic public
health services by all Filipinos through the provision of quality health care
and the regulation of all health services and products
iv. Vector-borne - these include disease which are transmitted by disease-
causing organisms; that is, they carry pathogens from one host to another
v. DEET - it is a brand of Diethyltoluamide, a colorless oily liquid with a mild
odor, used as an insect repellent

Common questions

Powered by AI

The hypothesis posited that Citronella extract combined with Lemongrass in scented candles is effective in repelling mosquitoes aligns well with previous studies' findings, which have demonstrated both plants' individual and combined repellent capabilities . Previous research highlighted that Lemongrass kills mosquitoes rapidly and serves as an effective repellent . Similarly, Citronella, especially when combined with Vanilla, extends the protection duration comparable to chemical DEET, albeit safer for allergy-prone individuals . The hypothesis aligns with empirical evidence suggesting that these natural substances can provide an effective, non-toxic alternative to existing repellents, underpinning further study to refine application methods like scented candles for optimal indoor use .

Combining Citronella and Lemongrass in consumer products is both practical and feasible, according to recent studies. These combinations leverage the individual strengths of each plant to create a product that effectively repels mosquitoes while mitigating concerns associated with chemical repellents like DEET . Studies show Citronella and Lemongrass as effective repellents independently and suggest that their combination in products like candles can enhance protection and user safety, especially for those with sensitive skin. The simplicity of integration into products like candles or sprays makes them accessible to consumers, aligning with both health and market demand for eco-friendly alternatives . Thus, commercializing such combinations presents a viable pathway for expanding natural repellent options within the consumer market .

Lemongrass and Citronella offer several benefits compared to DEET, primarily in terms of safety and side effects. Citronella is as effective as DEET in disorienting mosquitoes but does not kill them as DEET does . Its safety profile is notably advantageous, causing fewer allergic reactions and skin irritations, making it suitable for sensitive skin . However, Citronella has a shorter protection span, which can be improved when combined with Vanilla . In contrast, DEET provides longer-lasting protection but can cause skin irritation and triggers allergic responses in some users . Therefore, while DEET is superior in duration of protection, the natural alternatives present a safer option for prolonged use and for individuals prone to skin sensitivity .

Lemongrass and Citronella differ primarily in their mechanism and impact when used as mosquito repellents. Citronella acts by disorienting mosquitoes, whereas Lemongrass also kills both adult mosquitoes and their larvae within a short period, as demonstrated by Musa (2015). Citronella is effective as the chemical DEET but is safer for individuals with sensitive skin . However, Citronella's protection span is less compared to DEET, although it can be extended with the addition of Vanilla . Despite these differences, both are considered effective, safe, and a cost-effective alternative to chemical repellents, suitable even for individuals with allergic tendencies .

The theoretical framework developed suggests that Citronella and Lemongrass, when used in candles, form a potent repellent with significant potential as an alternative to chemical insect repellents like DEET in indoor environments. Future research can focus on optimizing the concentration for maximum efficacy without causing skin irritation, testing in diverse environmental conditions, and assessing long-term health impacts . Additionally, combining these with other natural enhancers, such as Vanilla, could extend protection duration, making them viable replacements for chemical repellents while promoting safer indoor environments . Such studies could further validate these natural combinations as sustainable and health-conscious solutions for controlling mosquito-borne diseases indoors .

Incorporating Lemongrass and Citronella into public health campaigns could have profound implications for reducing vector-borne diseases in Southeast Asia. These plants offer safe, effective, and sustainable alternatives to chemical repellents, addressing public health concerns related to mosquito-borne diseases like Dengue and Malaria . By promoting the plant cultivation and use of their extracts in household products such as candles, health campaigns can foster widespread adoption that minimizes disease vectors while reducing chemical exposure risks . This strategy dovetails with environmental goals by encouraging cultivation practices that are both pest-repellent and non-detrimental to crops, fostering community health and agricultural sustainability .

The combination of Lemongrass and Citronella enhances effectiveness as a mosquito repellent by leveraging the unique repelling properties of each component. Lemongrass, with its ability to kill mosquitoes and larvae , complements Citronella's property of disorienting mosquitoes . The synergy offers a potent solution that maximizes repellent effectiveness while minimizing skin irritation risks, making it an optimal public health strategy for areas plagued by mosquito-borne diseases like Dengue and Malaria . This combination, when used in products like candles, can offer a safer and broader-span protection than standalone use of Citronella or chemical repellents .

Public health policies in tropical regions should indeed advocate for large-scale Lemongrass cultivation due to its proven efficacy as a mosquito repellent and its added benefits as an agricultural pest deterrent . Coordinated efforts can lead to reduced incidences of vector-borne diseases like Dengue, by disrupting mosquito breeding and reducing vector populations at a community level. Moreover, Lemongrass cultivation is an environmentally sustainable tactic that offers economic benefits to farmers by providing a dual-purpose crop—serving as both a repellant and a pest control measure without harming crops . Thus, its large-scale cultivation aligns with public health, economic, and environmental objectives, providing a multifaceted advantage to tropical regions prone to mosquito-borne illnesses .

The addition of Vanilla to Citronella increases the latter's repellent duration, providing a more sustained protective effect . This combination, as tested, prolongs the period of mosquito protection beyond what Citronella can achieve alone, bridging the effectiveness gap when compared to DEET . This enhancement has important implications for product formulation; it enables the development of more competitive natural repellents that offer longer-lasting protection, appealing to users seeking prolonged efficacy without resorting to chemical solutions. Vanilla's use in formulations extends the usability of Citronella, positioning it as a more practical solution in diverse climatic conditions where extended protection is critical . This strategic combination not only increases consumer satisfaction but also expands the market for natural mosquito repellent products.

The use of Lemongrass and Citronella as mosquito repellents can significantly influence environmental and agricultural practices, especially in tropical and subtropical regions where these plants are native. Lemongrass can serve as a border plant to ward off insect pests, providing an affordable and eco-friendly strategy without harming crops, thus supporting sustainable agricultural practices . Furthermore, the safety profile of these natural repellents supports their integration into holistic pest management strategies, reducing reliance on chemical insecticides, which can harm the environment and pose health risks. Such practices not only enhance agricultural productivity but also promote biodiversity by minimizing the ecological footprint associated with chemical alternatives .

You might also like