Predictive Maintenance
Predictive Maintenance: what is it, tools, and applications [Complete Guide 2021] • Infraspeak Blog
What is predictive maintenance?
How does predictive maintenance work?
Data collection
Data mining
Calculations and Machine Learning
Predictive Maintenance Tools, Applications, and Examples
Thermographic analysis and infrared analysis
Motor circuit analysis
Oil analysis
Vibration analysis
Acoustic analysis
Does predictive maintenance solve all ills?
Advantages of predictive maintenance
Disadvantages of predictive maintenance
Is predictive maintenance worth the investment?
How to plan predictive maintenance in 4 steps
Identify critical assets
Gather information about asset history and failure modes
Implement sensors to monitor the condition
Test and try predictive maintenance
Every maintenance manager would like to predict when a breakdown will
occur. But how? The IoT lends a hand. Using sensors and new technologies
that monitor signs of deterioration and changes in the machine’s
performance, managers can estimate when a failure will occur. And so a new
type of maintenance is born, predictive maintenance.
What is predictive maintenance?
Predictive maintenance is a proactive maintenance strategy that aims to
prevent breakdowns. Depending on the data collected and predefined
predictive algorithms, it tries to estimate when a breakdown will occur.
Maintenance activities are then scheduled based on these forecasts.
Now, we need to make a little parenthesis. Predictive maintenance is often
confused with condition-based maintenance, but there is an important
nuance that distinguishes them. While predictive
maintenance schedules tasks based on collected data and formulas,
condition-based maintenance only acts when these parameters reach
alarming levels.
How does predictive maintenance work?
In theory, it is easy to understand how predictive maintenance works. It
gathers data about your assets and, from that, extracts information that allows
you to calculate when you need to do maintenance. In practice, we can divide
the process into three stages:
Data Collection
As we have already seen, the idea is to predict when a breakdown will occur.
As this depends on obtaining quality data, the first step is to install sensors
capable of collecting information in real-time on the performance and
‘health’ of the equipment.
The data that these sensors need to measure and collect depends on the
techniques you intend to use to monitor the equipment. You can control
vibration, temperature, pressure, noise level, or corrosion levels, among
others, depending on which is best for your equipment. We will explore
several predictive maintenance tools in a moment.
Data mining
Accumulating data about your assets is of no use if you don’t know how to
exploit them. It’s the Internet of Things (IoT) that allows sensors to send
all information to a central system or software that allows you to analyse
what is going on. Predictive maintenance is much more effective, and much
more surgical, in systems where the various assets are integrated.
Calculations and Machine Learning
Some people may believe that predictive maintenance stops here. But if you
are only acting when the sensors detect anomalies, you are just performing
condition-based maintenance – as we saw above. The most differentiating
component of predictive maintenance is to build and apply algorithms that
offer a prognosis.
In the beginning, it can be based on equipment history, maintenance logs, and
statistics (your CMMS reports are extremely useful in this step). However, as
Artificial Intelligence becomes increasingly sophisticated, it is possible to
detect anomalies even earlier, find correlations and receive intelligent
suggestions to prevent a breakdown. This intelligent maintenance is giving
rise to a new type of maintenance, prescriptive maintenance.
Predictive Maintenance Tools,
Applications, and Examples
The idea is planning maintenance according to the data. That’s why non-
destructive tests (NDT) are so important to diagnose failures within the
infrastructure. NDTs do not compromise equipment and can be performed
while it’s running, just like routine check-ups for humans. Blood tests,
ultrasound scans, or eye exams: we do them every year, and none of them
hurt us.
Among the predictive maintenance techniques used in the industry
are vibration analysis, oil analysis, acoustics, infrared or thermal
imaging tests (thermography), and motor circuit analysis.
Thermographic analysis and infrared analysis
applications: electrical connections and systems, heating systems,
fluid analysis, discharge patterns, roof maintenance
Thermographic analysis can also be applied to several types of equipment to
detect wear, rusting, delaminations, and disconnections that might go
unnoticed to the naked eye.
The advantage of infrared is that it allows you to make temperature maps,
even from a distance. This technique is used, for example, in the maintenance
of heating systems. Temperature variations are useful for assessing the
condition of motors and mechanical and electrical components, the building
insulation, and even the condition of solar panels. The major disadvantage is
that it cannot be used on reflective surfaces.
In the future, CPU temperature analysis will be one of the main ways to
test the health of robots.
Motor circuit analysis
applications: assess engine degradation, shaft and rotor alignment,
insulation, gears, scan for short-circuits
Motor circuit analysis uses a technique known as electric signature analysis
(ESA), to find anomalies in electric motors. In addition to analysing the
circuit and its components, it evaluates the voltage and current entering the
motor. Not least important: it works on both AC and DC motors and can be
used while the equipment is running.
Oil analysis
applications: turbines, hydraulic and electro-hydraulic systems,
evaluate engines, transmissions, gears, lubricant levels
The purpose of oil analysis is to test the viscosity, the amount of water and
the presence of other materials, including metals, to determine the wear of
the equipment.
Let’s take into consideration a hydraulic system that consists of two essential
components – the rotating parts and their lubricant. As equipment ages, the
sample will show byproducts of overheating and erosion. Different particles
reveal many problems before you can guess a breakdown is coming.
Different particles reveal different damages to different components. For
example, the presence of silicone above 15 ppm can indicate that the
insulation is wearing out, while sodium can reveal contamination with salt
water. Follow a metal guide (page 71) when using the spectrometer.
Vibration analysis
applications: test component alignment, detect imbalances,
clearances, resonances, gear failures
Vibration analysis is perfect for rotating equipment and machines, such as
compressors, water pumps, and engines. Thus, this predictive maintenance
technique is ideal for infrastructures with a complex water supply
system, such as hotels, spas, or water parks.
What we do is connect them to a sensor that can detect movement or
acceleration, depending on what’s appropriate. The sensor works by
detecting sound waves created by movement, which generate electrical
impulses and make equipment vibrate.
Acoustic analysis
applications: pipes and plumbing, condensers, vacuum systems,
fans, air compressors
We’ve already established that sound waves are our allies. Acoustic analysis
is a technique used to detect problems in the material’s technical
performance, pinpoint the source of the problem, and perform “check-ups”
on the equipment’s overall health. How? By detecting changes in sound
frequencies.
Every working machine makes some sort of noise, but its frequency and
range change whenever there are leaks or pressure changes, for example.
This predictive maintenance technique is especially useful for pipelines
carrying liquids or gas. Some more modern tools incorporate thermometers
and cameras to deepen the analysis at a distance.
Does predictive maintenance solve all ills?
Predictive maintenance was born to avoid breakdowns, but let us not be
under any illusions. There will always be random failures that are impossible
to predict or prevent. In addition, we must not forget that predictive
maintenance requires a large infrastructure. Therefore, predictive
maintenance is only recommended for critical assets and with
predictable failure modes.
Advantages of predictive maintenance
The main advantage of predictive maintenance is to act in a timely
manner, which reduces downtime and increases asset availability.
As maintenance is scheduled according to needs, it avoids wasting
stock and labor in unnecessary maintenance.
By reducing the emergency repairs and the wastes we mentioned
above, it helps to better control your maintenance budget.
Downtime is planned in advance, which allows for better
maintenance and normal company activity.
Optimal use of the equipment throughout its life cycle.
Predictive maintenance is also a cornerstone of lean maintenance and
just-in-time production.
Disadvantages of predictive maintenance
The need to invest in specific monitoring equipment, as well as to
train personnel to use and interpret the data collected.
For assets with low criticality, predictive maintenance may not offer
great savings over the alternatives.
It is not suitable for assets with random failure modes or without
initial data to predict malfunctions (in these cases, it is preferable to
start with condition-based maintenance and gradually make the
transition).
Is predictive maintenance worth the
investment?
We already mentioned that the cost of implementation is high, but even so,
predictive maintenance has a high ROI, which can be up to 10 times the
investment. A study by the United States Department of Energy in 2010,
when installing sensors was even more expensive than now, points to 25-
30% reductions in maintenance costs, 35-45% less downtime, and 70-
75% fewer breakdowns.
Compared to reactive maintenance, it resulted in savings of 30-40%.
Compared to preventive maintenance, savings of 8-12% were
achieved. According to the RCM methodology (reliability-centered
maintenance), the ideal is that 45-55% of maintenance is predictive, 25-35%
preventive and only 10% reactive or corrective.
Deloitte, in a 2017 study, is less optimistic. Still, predictive maintenance is
very promising. This study suggests that uptime will increase by 10-20%,
and maintenance costs will decrease by 5-10% in Industry 4.0. Maintenance
planning can take 20-50% less time.
Taking into account the advantages and disadvantages mentioned above,
we can generalise that predictive maintenance pays off the investment
for:
companies with high operating expenses and a lot of invested capital;
companies where downtime implies great losses;
companies with assets whose breakdowns are a security risk.
Therefore, it is not surprising that aviation was a pioneer in predictive
maintenance. Failure prediction is used both during flight – with engine
temperature and vibrations monitoring to prevent accidents – and on land, to
reduce delays and cancellations.
Manufacturing is another sector that adhered greatly to predictive
maintenance. It is easy to see why: a halt in production can cause huge
losses. In the coming years, it is likely that it will also gain greater expression
in fleet management, healthcare, mining industry, energy extraction and
production.
How to plan predictive maintenance in 4
steps
If you have already decided to invest in predictive maintenance in your
company, recap the 4 steps you need to implement it:
Identify critical assets.
The first step is to identify the priority assets to include in the predictive
maintenance strategy. Prioritise critical assets for your operations and assets
with high repair costs.
Gather information about asset history and failure modes.
The second step is to gather the necessary information to be able to transform
the data you collected into actions. If you already have a CMMS, it is easier
to organise the history and develop the first algorithms. At the same time, it
is convenient to establish failure modes and the probability of occurrence.
Implement sensors to monitor the condition.
Now that you have defined priorities and failure modes, you can start
implementing the sensors. In new equipment, it is usually a simple process,
but it can be more complicated in older machines. Investigate with the
manufacturer the best way to integrate old models with new technologies.
Test and try predictive maintenance.
Test the operation of the sensors and the accuracy of the algorithms only on
some machines, following a PDCA cycle. When you are able to schedule
maintenance and meet your goals, expand this strategy to other machines!
Predictive maintenance is already a strategy that bears fruits and
returns for many companies. In the future, as the IoT and digital
transformation take hold, it will be even more dominant, accessible, and
effective in predicting breakdowns.
However, one thing is clear: predictive maintenance benefits from
intelligent and integrated systems, such as those that Intelligent
Maintenance Management Platforms provide. Talk to one of our
experts to understand how Infraspeak supports your operations, today
and in the future!