Consignment Sales and IFRS 15 Accounting
Uploaded by
Maricel Ann BaccayConsignment Sales and IFRS 15 Accounting
Uploaded by
Maricel Ann Baccay- Introduction to Consignment Sales
- Illustration and Revenue Recognition
- Summary of Consignment Sales
Common questions
Powered by AIPFRS 15 defines an entity as a principal if it controls the goods before they are transferred to the customer . Evidence supporting X Co. as a principal includes its responsibility for ensuring the CCTV functions according to specifications, it having inventory risk, discretion in setting the selling price, its consideration not being in the form of commission, and facing credit risk for receivables from customers . X Co.'s fulfillment of these criteria indicates it acts as a principal, as it controls the good prior to customer transfer .
X Co.'s performance obligations involve ensuring CCTV products meet customer's specifications, giving it control and inventory risk, thus acting as a principal . Contrastingly, Chopee Co.'s obligation is merely to arrange sales between suppliers and customers with no control over goods, making it an agent . These roles are evidenced by X Co.'s direct involvement and risk in fulfilling customer contracts versus Chopee Co.'s intermediary facilitation role without risk of inventory or pricing control.
Credit risk exposure influences classification by indicating control over financial aspects of sales transactions. An entity exposed to credit risk typically has more control over terms and collects receivables, acting as a principal . For example, X Co. is exposed to credit risk from customer contracts, indicating it operates as a principal . In contrast, Chopee Co. is not exposed to credit risk since it facilitates transactions without financial risk, classifying it as an agent .
In a consignment arrangement, the consignor recognizes revenue only when the consigned goods are sold to end customers, as it is only at this point that control over the goods is relinquished . The consignee, on the other hand, recognizes revenue based on the commission or fee it earns when the sale occurs . This distinction is crucial because the consigned goods remain in the consignor's inventory until they are sold to the end customers. Freight costs and other incidental expenses incurred by the consignee may be recorded as either receivables or expenses depending on whether they are reimbursable .
The consignment arrangement between Hannah Co. and Samuel, Inc. illustrates typical accounting treatment under PFRS 15 as it involves Hannah Co., as the consignor, recognizing revenue only after notification of sales to end customers and accounting for commission expenses separately . Samuel records commission as income and adjusts payable amounts to Hannah, reflecting the separate recognition criteria for consignors and consignees under PFRS 15 . This reflects the delayed revenue recognition and expense handling critical in consignment sales.
A consignee's costs for freight and incidental expenses are recorded as a receivable rather than an expense when these costs are reimbursable by the consignor . If not reimbursable, the consignee would record these costs as an expense . The treatment depends on the contractual terms between the consignor and consignee regarding who ultimately bears these costs.
The consignor recognizes commission expenses when the consigned goods are sold to the end customers . Commission expenses are not included in the cost of inventory because they do not directly relate to acquiring or producing the inventory but are costs associated with selling the inventory . This treatment aligns with accounting for expenses as incurred in generating sales.
Freight and incidental costs must be included in the consignor's inventory because they are directly attributable to bringing the consigned goods to their present location and condition, thus capitalized as part of inventory costs . This impacts financial reporting by increasing inventory valuation, consequently affecting cost of goods sold upon sale and influencing profit margins and inventory turnover ratios . Proper cost allocation ensures accurate financial performance representation.
Indicators that an entity acts as an agent include another party fulfilling the contract, the entity not having inventory risk, lacking pricing discretion, receiving consideration in the form of commission, and not being exposed to credit risk . Chopee Co. exhibits these indicators as it facilitates sales via a website without controlling the goods, earns a commission, does not handle payments beyond facilitation, and does not hold inventory risk or pricing control . This makes Chopee Co. an agent under PFRS 15.
Not notifying the consignor about each sale as it occurs delays the consignor's ability to recognize revenue immediately, as revenue recognition depends on confirmation of sales. Typically, consignors receive periodic notifications of sales, such as weekly or monthly, allowing for consolidated revenue recognition once confirmed . This practice necessitates managing receivables and payables based on periodic reporting rather than real-time sales notifications, affecting cash flow and reporting timelines.
