0% found this document useful (0 votes)
32 views9 pages

Pakistan's Education System and Economy

This document provides a critical analysis of the impact of Pakistan's education system on its economy. It discusses several ways the education system has negatively affected economic development, including tax exemptions for educational institutions that have not improved education, "ghost schools" that misuse funds, lack of access to education for all citizens, divergence in curriculums and educational systems, an outdated curriculum, non-directional education that does not identify student talents, and lack of teacher training. Overall, the defective and weak education system has hindered Pakistan's social, political, and economic growth by failing to develop an educated and skilled workforce.

Uploaded by

M Rais
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
32 views9 pages

Pakistan's Education System and Economy

This document provides a critical analysis of the impact of Pakistan's education system on its economy. It discusses several ways the education system has negatively affected economic development, including tax exemptions for educational institutions that have not improved education, "ghost schools" that misuse funds, lack of access to education for all citizens, divergence in curriculums and educational systems, an outdated curriculum, non-directional education that does not identify student talents, and lack of teacher training. Overall, the defective and weak education system has hindered Pakistan's social, political, and economic growth by failing to develop an educated and skilled workforce.

Uploaded by

M Rais
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as DOCX, PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

1

Education System: Education System Of Pakistan In

Impact Of Economy; A Critical Analysis

Khadija Rais

University Of Karachi

Miss Tauqeer Fatima

Pakistan Studies-309

June 24th’ 2021


2

Education System

1- Introduction

Education System generally refers to public schooling starting from kindergarten and

through high school programs it may be viewed as subsystem within social organization of its

own. .Education system plays a key role in expanding and flourishing the political, social, and

economical grounds of a nation. It grants the sense of responsibility to each and every individual

of a society or nation. It enables the people by enhancing their general consciousness regarding

their national and international position as global citizens. This realization creates an atmosphere

of trust and cooperation in the society. Every developed country always have strong grounds of

education system moreover for most of the advanced nations it is their education system that has

proved to be the basic element that has elevated them to zenith and prosperity by boosting their

economy. For instance after introduction of knowledge wave in New Zealand, a strong progress

in economic sector during 1952-2002 was observed. Today where world is focusing on

advancing education system, in Pakistan it still remains the matter of less interest as a result

Pakistan remains the part of developing countries. There is lack of political stability in the

country. Besides, the country is in the deep grip of increasing political turmoil, expanding

terrorism, incessant sectarian violence, social instability, and economic degeneration. All these

problems are directly or indirectly the offshoot of a weak, polarized and non-unified education

system.

Defective education system has put a stop on tolerance and general awareness among

Pakistanis. Illiteracy rate has rooted more crimes in Pakistan then ever. The vital role of

education has been neglected in Pakistan which has led to low development in all fields of life.
3
The education system, hence, has failed to raise the nation economically, politically and socially.

This weakness can be overcomed by developing an honest co-operation of governing authorities

and citizens with eachother. Both need to realize the fact that education is a nourishing force. It

is the constructive factor for any society. Education enables people to work for their

development and growth. Hence education brings out the hidden potentialities of individuals and

develops them.

2-Education System Of Pakistan In Impact Of Economy- A Critical Analysis

No wonder due to substandard education system, Pakistan is yet caged in

economic crises. Following are the impacts of education system on Pakistan’s

economy that are critically analyzed below;

2.1-Tax Exemption Of Educational Institutions

To increase the productivity in educational system government exempted

educational institutions from paying tax moreover government provides fund to

these institutions so that development in educational sector could be made. Since

these institutions do not pay tax so the only way paying back to government is

producing well educated individuals that can play vital role in economic sector and

can help the government to increase productivity in every sector for welfare of this

state. In contrast we see that our educational institutes are still under developed this

is primarily due to dishonesty, duplicity and fraudulent conduct of the staff of our

education system. Government does not allow to pocket its provided fund but the
4

only reason of tax exemption and providing fund is to utilize it only for the spread

and evolution of pre-eminent system of education. But this fund is not being used

for the betterment of the pillars of education system i.e teachers, students are

unable to make progress. Thus misuse of provided fund is enhancing weak

economy.

2.2-Ghost Schoolings

“A ghost school might be a school which is not there, it never was built, and they said ‘oh we’ve

built the school’ and there’s actually no school there,” said professor Anita Ghulam Ali, former

Sindh education minister and head of Sindh Education Foundation

Pakistan has already been subject of many controversies with epic tales of bribery and

corruption. In recent time, facts have uncovered ‘Ghost Schools’ being operational in the

country. Though, treated as one of the most notorious crimes under institutionalized corruption

globally, it is one of the least covered crimes in Pakistan estimated to be over billions of funds,

benefitting the illegal economy. The people responsible for these losses have been pocketing

funds meant for schools’ salaries for teachers and maintenance for schools, under the garb of

providing quality education to the poor. Several years have passed with several incident reports

highlighted in almost all provinces across the county, yet the crooks always seem to beat the

system and keep skimming monies that go into bribing government officials to allow fake

teachers to keep fake jobs and usurp salaries, originally meant to benefit honest dedicated

teachers and deserving students. Ghost schooling is resulting in leakage of billions of rupees and

no significant enhancement in literacy rate is achieved.


5
Global Village Space has reported in an article that ghost schooling is also being

enhanced under BECS-Basic Education Community School Program authorized by PAC-Public

Accounts Committee. It also reported that in 2018 under the then chairman PAC, DG Federal

Audit compiled a report that revealed over 2000 ghost schools being operated by the Ministry of

Education under the BECS program. These schools were fake schools, only on paper. No one

questioned the Chairman PAC as he was the chief whip of the government at the time and the

whole chapter was buried completely.

This factor is also generating a negative impact on economic sector of Pakistan

Government must need to induce policies to fight against this corruption in order sustain

economy of Pakistan.

2.3-Education for All

In developed countries government provides free education to all major and minor sectors

of its society. For instance in Canada education till matric level is free of cost providing basic

education to every child whether from poor cast or elite. Moreover Canadian government

provides fund to poor cast so that they can benefit themselves by gaining higher level education.

Whereas in Pakistan due to the high fee structure of schools and universities only elite and

middle class can afford it and the remaining majority poor class is unable to receive quality and

satisfactory education as a result state remains deprived of talents and majority of the population

of Pakistan being illiterate is unable to play its role in economic sector of Pakistan therefore there

is not any significant development in economy of Pakistan.


6

2.4-Divergence In Educational Systems

The education system in Pakistan is not uniform. Different education

systems in Pakistan are working simultaneously (Cambridge system, O-A level

system, deeni madaris) moreover curriculums are not uniformed that are giving

rise to different thoughts of schools. As a result polarization is developing in

society and a prominent gap is rooting among the nation and due to this current

polarized system of education there has occurred a great social division in the society on

political, social and economic grounds.

2.5-Out Dated Curriculum

Curriculum is an essential tool that assists in achieving educational goals. The curriculum

of Pakistan’s education system does not fulfill the requirements of the present and it is not as per

international standard therefore students are unable to get latest knowledge and they are unaware

of latest developments in different fields. As a result the students after entering professional life

are unable to uplift Pakistan in any of the ground whether it is political, social, or economical.

Thus out-dated curriculum is also playing a negative role in economic sector of Pakistan.

2.6-Non-Directional Education

In a well developed education system teachers first do analysis of the student’s interest on

a primary level and when this students enter to secondary education teacher recommends him/her

the field better for that student in this way a education is provided to students on all possible

grounds(political, social, and economical) in this way students are made capable to make the
7
country stronger in every aspect. In contrast, Pakistan’s education system lacks this approach

instead its concern is towards providing general education. As a result this system is failed in

analyzing talents of the students thus unable to bring skilled mankind to the market.

2.7-Lack Of Teacher Training

Due to lack of skillful teachers educational system is unable to provide quality education

to students in Pakistan. Teacher’s co-operations are not satisfactory that makes the students lose

interest in education resulting is illiteracy. According to a UNESCO report, the quality of the

teachers and instruction in schools of Pkistan is of low quality. This situation is grimmer in

remote parts of Punjab, Sindh and Baluchistan where even there are no teachers available in

schools. Research has found that teachers do not use new methods and strategies of teaching and

learning. Majority of the teachers do not know about lesson planning which renders them

incapable of dealing with various problems in the process of teaching and learning. Teachers

encourage cramming of the materials by students. Government must arrange teacher training

carvans or sessions in order to make them aware of their responsibility


8

The chart shows that Pakistan has relatively lower GDP as compared to other countries this is

primarily due to the fact that Pakistan yet have faulty and low grade education system due to

which satisfactory literacy rate is not yet achieved that lowers the participation of individuals in

magnifying the economy of Pakistan.


9
The above chart shows that Pakistan still needs to work on developing better education

system to improve literacy rate in order to progress in economic sector.

Conclusion

Perfection is not attainable but if we try to chase it we can catch excellence. Pakistan is

indeed a developing country but it not impossible to make it a part of developed countries. If

government takes measures to improve the educational system it will not only gain boosted

economy but will also be able to get rid of poverty crisis and would be able to build a prosperous

and united Pakistan.

Common questions

Powered by AI

The economic stagnation in Pakistan is significantly impacted by its education system, which is characterized by several flaws. Firstly, the misuse of funds intended for educational development, including the phenomenon of 'ghost schools,' diverts resources away from genuine educational improvements . Secondly, the lack of uniformity and outdated curricula lead to polarization within the society and fail to equip students with skills needed in the modern workforce . Additionally, the high cost of education excludes the majority poor from receiving quality education, limiting their economic participation . Lastly, the inadequate training and quality of teachers result in poor educational outcomes and lower economic productivity .

If Pakistan fails to reform its education system, the long-term economic impacts could be severe. Continued reliance on an outdated curriculum and poorly trained teachers would perpetuate low literacy and skill levels, reducing competitiveness in the global market . Economic productivity would stagnate, as a significant portion of the population remains undereducated and cannot contribute effectively to economic growth . This would exacerbate income inequality and social division, leading to increased social unrest and hindered political stability, both of which are detrimental to economic development . Without systemic reform, economic crises and underdevelopment could persist, limiting Pakistan's potential to become a thriving economy .

To improve the educational system's contribution to economic growth, Pakistan could implement several measures: ensuring transparency and better oversight of educational funds to prevent corruption like 'ghost schools,' reforming the curriculum to align with global standards , and offering free or subsidized education to increase access for the poor . Furthermore, investing in teacher training could enhance educational quality, fostering a more competent workforce . Initiatives to unify diverse education systems would also help reduce societal polarization and foster a more cohesive national identity, which is conducive to economic development .

The lack of teacher training in Pakistan affects educational quality by resulting in outdated teaching methods, encouraging rote learning, and failing to foster critical thinking skills among students . Untrained teachers are ill-equipped to handle diverse learning needs, leading to disengagement and higher dropout rates. This ultimately results in a workforce lacking necessary skills, thereby stalling economic development, as education plays a critical role in generating productive human capital .

'Ghost schools' contribute to economic decline by facilitating corruption and misallocation of funds meant for education, hindering literacy rates and thus impacting the workforce's quality. These schools are non-existent but reported for siphoning funds through fake teacher salaries and maintenance costs . To address this, it has been suggested that the government needs to implement strict policies to combat corruption, ensure accountability, and properly audit and verify existing schools to sustain the economy .

The high fee structure of educational institutions in Pakistan creates barriers for the poor, allowing only the elite and middle-class access to quality education . This financial exclusivity fosters inequality, as the poor remain under-educated and unable to improve their socio-economic status. As a significant portion of the population is unable to contribute effectively to the economy, this limits overall economic progress and hampers social mobility .

The government's approach to educational funding, particularly through tax exemptions and misallocated funds due to corruption like 'ghost schools,' results in an ineffective education system . Although institutions are exempted from taxes to encourage educational development, the fraudulent usage of these funds detracts from improving educational quality, which impairs the development of human capital necessary for economic growth . Effective governance should ensure transparency and accountability in the utilization of educational funds to strengthen the system .

Societal polarization in Pakistan, driven by disparate educational systems like the Cambridge system and deeni madaris, creates distinct groups with opposing ideologies . This division weakens national unity as differing educational backgrounds foster conflicting social and political views, undermining cohesive national policies . Such disunity can impede development as it affects consensus building, necessary for national progress, and contributes to instability, deterring both domestic and foreign investment essential for economic growth . Addressing this polarization through educational reforms could promote a unified national identity and facilitate socioeconomic advancements .

The non-uniform educational systems in Pakistan lead to significant social and political division. Different educational standards, such as the Cambridge system and deeni madaris, create disparate social groups with varying worldviews, thus contributing to societal polarization . This division can exacerbate political tensions and weaken national unity, as educational influences shape political and social identities. A polarized society can struggle with policy consistency and social cohesion, which are crucial for stable governance .

An outdated curriculum in Pakistan's education system limits students' exposure to contemporary knowledge and skills, making them ill-prepared for the demands of the global economy . This lack of relevant education results in a workforce that cannot effectively contribute to key sectors such as technology and industry, crucial for economic growth. Consequently, the inability to innovate or improve productivity perpetuates economic underperformance .

You might also like