Telecoaching Programme For Type 2 Diabetes Control: A Randomised Clinical Trial
Telecoaching Programme For Type 2 Diabetes Control: A Randomised Clinical Trial
T
he epidemic of type 2 diabetes and the traditional
model for managing this disease are proving costly ABSTRACT
and time consuming for health professionals, as Background: people with diabetes have a high risk of developing micro and
well as being ineffective, especially because of the macrovascular complications that increase treatment costs and shorten
therapeutic inertia that may result in a reluctance life expectancy. Telecoaching programmes can improve short-term control
on the part of both patients and professionals to change or to of diabetes and reduce disease burden. Aims: to analyse the effect of a
progress with established treatment (Wild et al, 2016). In this health telecoaching programme in the control of type 2 diabetes. Methods:
regard, interventions aided by health-related technologies that a pragmatic clinical trial was carried out. Thirty-one patients with type 2
use ‘telehealth’ have been highlighted as an economical and diabetes were divided into control and intervention groups. The control group
effective alternative for controlling the disease, which involves received usual nursing care, and those in the intervention group received
clinical and laboratory conditions (Wayne et al, 2015). usual care and telecoaching for 24 weeks. Findings: the intervention group
Understood as the remote provision of interactive diagnostic improved: measurements of abdominal circumference, systolic and diastolic
and consultation services, telehealth can be provided using blood pressure and body mass index; variables related to glycaemic control
a variety of systems for the long-term management and (fasting venous glucose and glycated haemoglobin/HbA1c); and high-density
control of type 2 diabetes. The best known of these are web lipoprotein levels. Conclusion: the data indicate that telecoaching is an
conferencing, text messaging (SMS) and coaching via telephone effective tool for diabetes management. It is recommended that the study
calls (telecoaching). Used in different scenarios, telecoaching should be developed to include more people and run over the long term.
aims to support changes in health behaviour that are aligned Key words: Diabetes ■ Telecoaching ■ Telehealth ■ Patient support
with self-determined targets to reduce complications as well
as long-term physical and mental problems associated with the
disease (Odnoletkova et al, 2016a; Oskman et al, 2017).
Studies into telecoaching for glycaemic control in type 2 diabetes
have reported divergent findings, so there is no consensus nor a
sufficient level of evidence to indicate whether this strategy lowers
Hérica Cristina Alves de Vasconcelos, Department of Nursing,
blood glucose levels significantly, aiding in the metabolic control of Federal University of Ceará, Fortaleza, Ceará, Brazil
the disease and, consequently, reducing possible complications that
José Claudio Garcia Lira Neto, Department of Nursing, Federal
the disease can cause over time (Wayne and Ritvo, 2014; McGloin
University of Ceará, Fortaleza, Ceará, Brazil
et al, 2015; Quinn et al, 2016; Oskman et al, 2017).
Moreover, in Brazil—a country the size of a continent with Márcio Flávio Moura de Araújo, Department of Nursing,
University of International Integration of Afro-Brazilian Lusophony,
widespread social and economic problems—there is a clear lack
Redenção, Ceará, Brazil
of studies regarding the use of telecoaching in the metabolic
control of type 2 diabetes. In addition, telecoaching in the Gerdane Celene Nunes Carvalho, Department of Nursing, Federal
University of Ceará, Fortaleza, Ceará, Brazil
north-east region of Brazil, which has a high prevalence of
diabetes, has not yet been described in the literature. Carla Regina de Souza Teixeira, Department of Nursing,
The aim of this study was to analyse the effects of a health University of São Paulo, Ribeirão Preto, São Paulo, Brazil
coaching programme, provided via telephone, in the clinical Roberto Wagner Júnior Freire de Freitas, Department of Family
© 2018 MA Healthcare Ltd
and laboratory control of people with type 2 diabetes. Health, Oswaldo Cruz Foundation, Fortaleza, Ceará, Brazil
Marta Maria Coelho Damasceno, Department of Nursing,
Method Federal University of Ceará, Fortaleza, Ceará, Brazil
This was a pilot study, a randomised and pragmatic clinical trial, Accepted for publication: September 2018
conducted with adults of both sexes with type 2 diabetes, treated
CG IG CG: control group glucose (FVG), glycated haemoglobin (HbA1c), total cholesterol
IG: intervention group (TC), low-density lipoprotein (LDL), high-density lipoprotein
Final sample – 31 participants (HDL), and triglycerides (TGL).
To determine the values of FVG, HbA1c, TC, LDL, HDL
Figure 1. Flowchart of participants involved in the study and TGL, a venous blood sample was collected by a trained
(1.165 to 1.191; p=0.59). with specific benefits to cost savings and significant results for
Despite the variety of the results, it was possible to show people’s quality of life (Wayne et al, 2015; Oksman et al, 2017;
that only changes in BMI in the control group (p=0.014), AC Walker et al, 2017).
in the intervention group (p=0.001), SBP in the control group A randomised clinical trial conducted in Belgium, which
(p=0.042), SBP in both the control group and the intervention sought to analyse the cost-effectiveness of a nurse’s coaching
CG before 29.87 5.25 99.46 15.15 0.87 0.89 137.24 22.72 77.22 9.99
0.014 0.151 0.591 0.042 0.649
CG after 30.23 5.29 101.86 11.46 0.88 0.52 141.06 23.66 76.4 8.88
IG before 29.99 5.82 98.56 11.94 0.87 0.73 130.25 19.51 72.12 8.21
0.764 0.001 0.182 0.171 0.640
IG after 29.96 6.04 95.75 13.06 0.88 0.64 125.87 13.94 71.12 8.42
CG before 29.87 5.25 99.46 15.15 0.87 0.89 137.24 22.72 77.22 9.99
0.95 0.86 0.91 0.36 0.13
IG before 29.99 5.82 98.56 11.94 0.87 0.73 130.25 19.51 72.12 8.21
CG after 30.23 5.29 101.86 11.46 0.88 0.52 141.06 23.66 76.40 8.88
0.92 0.17 0.96 0.03 0.10
IG after 29.96 6.04 95.75 13.06 0.88 0.64 125.87 13.94 71.12 8.42
Table 3. Intra-group and inter-group comparison of averages of laboratory data* regarding the control of type 2 diabetes
Intra- and FVG HbA1c TGL TC LDL HDL
inter-group
comparison Mean SD p Mean SD p Mean SD p Mean SD p Mean SD p Mean SD p
CG before 6.274 2.328 6.9 1.31 1.923 0.944 4.766 1.237 2.796 0.905 1.151 0.265
0.705 0.048 0.90 0.42 0.30 0.98
CG after 6.656 2.728 7.33 1.73 1.892 1.044 4.489 1.126 2.604 0.787 1.149 0.327
IG before 7.925 3.491 8.0 2.14 1.566 0.703 4.396 1.485 2.511 1.158 1.165 0.287
0.378 0.052 0.11 0.46 0.90 0.59
IG after 7.162 2.421 7.21 1.19 1.831 0.815 4.562 1.171 2.530 0.926 1.191 0.280
CG before 6.274 2.328 6.9 1.31 1.923 0.944 4.766 1.237 2.796 0.905 1.151 0.265
0.13 0.09 0.23 0.45 0.46 0.89
IG before 7.925 3.491 8.0 2.14 1.566 0.703 4.396 1.485 2.511 1.158 1.165 0.287
CG after 6.656 2.728 7.33 1.73 1.892 1.044 4.489 1.126 2.604 0.787 1.149 0.327
0.59 0.82 0.85 0.86 0.82 0.72
IG after 7.162 2.421 7.21 1.19 1.831 0.815 4.562 1.171 2.530 0.926 1.191 0.280
*Fasting venous glucose, glycated haemoglobin, triglycerides, total cholesterol, low-density lipoprotein and high-density lipoprotein
CG: control group, IG: intervention group, SD: standard deviation
programme for diabetes, showed that such intervention is highly Regarding blood pressure, in the intervention group there
cost-effective and significantly improves the quality of life of were reductions in the mean of both SBP and DBP after the
people with poorly controlled type 2 diabetes (Odnoletkova et al, telephone contacts. Mean SBP in the intervention group showed
2016b). However, despite the results, telecoaching is not supported a decrease of 4.3 mmHg; the decrease in SBP was significantly
everywhere, and the literature still shows the use of telecoaching more in some cases (Nocella et al, 2016).
to support glycaemic control for people with type 2 diabetes is Regarding DBP, although there was also a decrease in
varied (Blackberry et al, 2013; Eakin et al, 2014). the mean in the intervention group, the difference was only
Regarding the anthropometric data associated with the 1 mmHg. Unlike what occurred with SBP, most of the studies
accumulation of fat, the results show that the values of both selected for this discussion found DBP fell (McGloin et al, 2014;
BMI and AC were reduced in the intervention group, in line Odnoletkova et al, 2016c).
with other studies of the same nature (Carallo et al, 2015).The Control of diabetes is related to control of blood pressure
opposite effect was found in a study developed in Iran, which since people with high blood pressure are susceptible to one of
showed an increase in BMI values after 3 months of telecoaching the main comorbidities associated with type 2 diabetes—arterial
(Lashkari et al, 2013). However,WHR, an index of adiposity that hypertension—which increases the rate of complications and
© 2018 MA Healthcare Ltd
Long-Term Conditions
will therefore play an important role s that affect the population
for health professionals. This book is
Fundamental Aspects of Long-Term Conditions
Helen McVeigh
basis from which both student nurses ns provides a succinct, useful
and adult nurses can extend their knowled
ge and skills.
About the author
Helen McVeigh is a Senior Lecturer
in Primary Care at De Montfort Universi
District Nurse. She has over 20 years
experience of working in Primary Care
ty Leicester. She is a qualified
Edited by Helen McVeigh
This book should make you think about how you can make a difference
city practices. working in both rural and inner
ISBN 1-85642-392-1
ISBN-13: 978-1-85642-392-2; 234 x 156 mm; paperback; 280 pages; publication 2010; £24.99
© 2018 MA Healthcare Ltd
9 781856 423922
Fundamental Aspects of Nursing series
[Link]