Malaria Control: ITN Effectiveness and Challenges
Malaria Control: ITN Effectiveness and Challenges
INTRODUCTION
2010). In the face of this dire situation, experts nonetheless, remain divided
mortality from malaria across Africa (WHO, 2003). In order to combat the
disease, several strategies that include vector control (indoor residual spraying
(IRS), insecticide treated nets (ITNs), prompt and effective treatments (WHO,
1
ITNs have been have been found to be highly effective in protecting
those sleeping under them and those nearby. ITNs have also been shown to
ITNs have been distributed following the target set at the Abuja summit of
malaria (WHO, 2000).as well as to scale up to universal coverage for all the
But there are no health information systems that routinely monitor malaria
al., 2010).
The current standard for M&E of INTs are household surveys such as
2
provide annual estimates of ITN coverage for all countries (WHO 2013), time
recent studies, ( Miller, et al., 2010, Baume, et al., 2010, Banek, et al., 2010,
1.1 Aims/Objectives
treated bednets
3
CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
Coverage of bednets
Effectiveness of bednet
preventive and creative measures such as vector control, use of bed net,
and Herrington 2007). Insecticide treated nets are an effective and costs
children under 5years of age in Africa each year (Rowe et al., 2000). The
Africa summit on Roll Back Malaria- held in Abuja, Nigeria in 2000 specified
that 60% of at risk groups should use insecticide treated nets by 2005, a target
that was subsequently raised to 80% by 2010 (R0ll Back Malaria Partnership,
2015). Although use of insecticide treated nets remains well below the target
4
insecticide treated nets use in stable malaria endemic settings (Noor et al.,
2009).
when insecticide bednets are distributed free of cost instead of cost recovering
Africa countries shows that the coverage becomes more equitable (Noor et
child mortality.
(Fegan et al., 2007), like vaccines, ITNs have both a personal protective
effect to the individual users, as well as a community- wide effect because the
occupied nets act like baited traps for mosquitoes (Goodman et al., 1999).
The higher the percentage of the whole population covered with ITNs, the
5
greater the mosquito kill, thus benefiting both individuals using ITNs and
should be encourage d to owned and use ITNs to protect their unborn baby.
remains below the current Roll Back Malaria target of universal coverage
host –seeking behaviors. Other scientific studies show that consistent use of
44% of all cause of mortality under five years of age (Lengeler, 2004)
6
Insecticide treated bednets are the mainstay of malaria prevention. Ownership
with insecticide and are meant to be hung above sleeping areas and unfurled
protecting those sleeping under the net during the evening hours when
mosquitoes are most likely to bite and transmit malaria. In addition to provide
The insecticide kills mosquitoes at the point of contact with the net and
One of the most striking aspects was discovering the non trivial
barriers that exist to ensuring the ultimate goal of daily use of bednets. These
barriers include obtaining a net, mounting it over a bed, and consistent daily
use.
Villagers complained that nets for purchase are often too expensive for
them to afford, and even if they could afford them, they would have to travel
7
There are also prevalent rumors about the negative health effects of net,
including fears that they reduce male virility and contact with the netting can
cause rashes and other illness. Even once nets are obtained by a household,
houses are made of brick or mud covered walls making it hard to attack the
nets by string to the walls, and once a net mounted, the family members need
to remember to consistently use the net in the current way, even during the
hot and humid seasons when being under a net can feel oppressive but is most
members in the house, how many they should have and how many should
sleep inside a single net and including space in the house (Centre for Global
is used only for the control of malaria infection, the use of insecticide-
vector carrying the parasite that causes chagas diseases, making the a
8
This technique has been shown to be effective in malaria and
valuable tool in the control of chagas disease. Guinea pigs are an important
staple for rural and peri-urban Peruvians, but are also a main source of vector
conducted are affected by chagas disease. The report also indicates that cages
with insecticide-treated nets had almost five times less Triatoma infestans
than cages without the nets. The unprotected enclosures were infested at a rate
They also found that only smaller bug nymphs, which are much less
likely to transmit Chagas disease were able to cross the netting. The
the larger insects were less able to fit through or under the mesh. Net do not
vectors, but they may be useful as additional measures were spraying alone
They may be especially useful for wild bugs that visit houses at night
9
2.5 Bednet use in Nigeria
are threatened due to the emergence and spread of drug resistance malaria
parasites and insecticides resistant vector mosquitoes. This together with the
increasing incidence of the disease heightened the need for the use of
health intervention. While this initiation has strong support from World
of optimal use of bednets and their importance in reducing malaria. Last year,
questions of who has bednets, how are using them, and whether they have
experience malaria. Studies show that the proper use of ITNs can reduce
10
Similarly, studies have attributed the failure to use the ITNs to the
following:
It is perceived to be expensive, not hanged due to the size of the beds not too
small, cause of heat and lack of enough air when slept under it. Ewa et al.,
(2012 ) contended that the low coverage of health centers, especially in the
awareness about the benefits of ITNs, limited demand creation efforts have
access to ITNs, the extent own which the general population residing in high-
11
CHAPTER THREE
Delta State, Nigeria. Sapele local government area is located in longitude 5° 42'
0" East and latitude 5° 55' 0" North, and is made up of an estimated population of
about 240,000 and Eleven geopolitical wards. Sapele Local Government Area
The people of Sapele are mainly traders and farmers. The area
Ethiope River flowing through the area. The LGA also has estimated total
South-East by Okpe LGA, to the South-West by Warri South LGA and to the
the sports stadium and the Sapele port. A total of 132,256 long lasting
12
in 2013, through the universal net campaign organized by National Malaria
household in the local government area received one nets (Delta State
Ministry of Health).
3.2 Map of Sapele Local Government Area Showing the Study Area
Commercial Venue
Mapherson Street
13
3.3 Survey and Subject
source, cost, and insecticide treated statues of all bednets in the households.
Ownership was defined as having at least one net whether treated or not, any
net distributed through the free mass campaign was classified as treated as
community equal chance of being selected for the study. The systematic
household and how members of household obtained nets. Use of nets was
14
related to individual-level characteristics such as age, gender, household size
and education others were reasons for utilization and non-utilization of ITNs,
The sample size will be determined using Taro Yamane`s formula thus
n = N/(1+N(e)2),
n = 240,000/1+240,000(0.0025)2
n = 240000/1201
n = 199.9
study and used by interviewers. Data collection took place between March
and April 2019. The questionnaire used was adapted from pasts surveys
modified. The questionnaire were completed at the late hour of the day after
15
they must have returned from work and were administered only to the
household head, mothers, members of house whose age is 18years and less
than 80years who gave verbal consent after explaining the purpose of the
Data entry and statistical analysis were conducted using SPSS version
were used to summarize the data and Chi-square tests were used to investigate
16
CHAPTER FOUR
RESULTS
ownership and bed net used in Sapele Local Government Area of Delta State,
Sapele that owns and uses bed net were students, followed by traders,
17
Table 1: Socio Demographic Characteristics of Household Ownership and
Nigeria
Religion
Christian 187 93.5
Islam 7 3.5
Tradition 6 3.0
Others 0 0
Tribe
Yoruba 18 9.0
Urhobo 74 37.0
Okpe 76 38.0
Itsekiri 23 11.5
Igbo 7 3.5
Others 2 1.0
Level of Education
Primary 28 14.0
Secondary 62 31.0
University 46 23.0
Polytechnic 26 13.0
NCE 27 13.5
Others 11 5.5
18
Table 2 shows the age-sex distribution of household respondents and
ownership of bed nets used in the study. From Table 2, it showed that
majority 28(25.7%) of the males respondents were between the ages 18-
the ages 18-25. This depicts that majority of the respondents that uses bed
19
Table 2: Age- Sex Distribution of Household Respondents of Ownership
Table 3 is represented in table and bar chart. Table 3 shows bed net use and
ownership among different household by age and sex. The results showed that
majority 76(83.5%) of the males respondents owns and uses bed net while
20
15(16.5%) do not own and use bed nets. Majority of the females respondents
89(81.7%) owns and uses bed net while 20(18.3%) do not own and use bed
net. Age group 18-25years, 72(43.6%) own and uses bed net more often,
and Sex
22
250
200
150
Use of bednet and ownership
No %
Use of bednet and ownership
No N
100
Use of bednet and ownership
Yes %
Use of bednet and ownership
Yes N
50
0
l
ale ale up 25 -3
5
-4
5
-5
5
-6
5
-7
9 ta
M em Gro 8-1 2 6 3 6 4 6 5 6 6 6 To
F e 1
Ag
-50
Figure 1: Bar Chart Showing Bed Net Use and Ownership Among
23
Table 4 shows reported attitude of household ownership and bed net.
The results showed that majority 80(40.0%) of the population admitted that
the purchase of bed net was close to them, 62(31.0%) admits that purchase of
bed net was not far from them and 58(29.0%) admits that it was far. About the
cost, majority, 131(65.5%) claimed that bed net was not cost and can be
161(80.5%) perceived the use of bed net as positive and 39(19.5%) perceived
admits the use of bed net as comfortable while 25(12.5%) admits the use of
bed net, 69(34.5%) admits that they received bed net from the Government,
26(13.1%) claimed they received bed net from Government and also
purchased bed net. 18(9.0%) did not know how they received bed net while
24
Table 4: Reported Attitude of House Ownership and Bednets in Sapele
Cost
Yes 69 34.5
No 131 65.5
Comfortable
Yes 175 87.5
No 25 12.5
25
Table 5 shows reported household ownership and use of insecticide
treated bed nets. The results showed that majority 164(82.0%) of the
population admits the current use of bed net, 133(66.5%) admits that all
household members uses bed nets, 101(50.5%) admits that they own one bed
net, 85(42.5%) own two bed nets and 14(7.0%) own three bed nets. Majority,
155(77.5%) of the participants admits that they uses bed net every day,
11(5.5%) claimed they uses bed net at least once a week and 34(17.0%)
26
Table 5: Reported Household Ownership and Used of Insecticide Treated
Bednets
One 10 50.5
Two 85 42.5
Three 14 7.0
Frequency of use
Everyday 155 77.5
At least once a week 11 5.5
Once a while 34 17.0
27
Table 6 shows the association between socio-demographic
characteristics and reported household ownership of at least one bed net. The
result in the table below suggests that there was a significant association
28
Table 6: Association between Socio-Demographic Characteristics and
N Chi-square DF Significance
Sex
Female 89 100
Religion
Tradition 6 5
CHAPTER FIVE
29
DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
5.1 Discussion
five and also the mainstay of malaria prevention. According to this study, the
level of education is very significant for the use of bed net than the
compared to others, 11(5.5%) that own and use bed net. Many studies have
tried to link insecticide treated nets with education; David (2001) reported
they have more benefits about the gain of sleeping under a net.
The findings of this study shows that females are more likely to own
and use bed nets 47(43.1%) than male 28(25.7%), these findings are
marital status were positively associated with the use of bed net in a study
significant factor associated with ITNs use. Sibhatu, Ayalu and Haji. (2012).
The reason is because women are likely to sleep under ITNs than male also
30
they are closer to the children and both children and pregnant women are
The 82.5% rate of use of bed net and ownership in this study was
extremely very high, which meets the target of 80% ITNs coverage among
pregnant women by the Roll Back Malaria Initiative Hawley et al., (2003).
This increase in use of bed nets and to ownership may be use as a result of
level of significance.
The findings implies that ownership and used of insecticide bed nets
are directly related that an increase in one variable increases the other. The
result is in line with the findings of Tulu, 1993 and Noor et al., 2009 who
observed that ITNs was identified as a weapon in the fight against malaria,
but there is evidence that relatively few people in high risk regions own and
use them.
31
5.2 Conclusion
The reported household ownership and used of bed net in Sapele local
government area was very high, and more than half of the respondent reported
use of bed net within the age group of 18-25 years, which implies younger
age group and pregnant women are likely more vulnerable to malaria attack;
mitigated.
32
REFERENCES
Bates, N., & Herrington, J., Advocacy for malaria prevention, control and
Malar.J. 2008.
Brooker S, Kolaczinski J.H, Gitonga, C.H., Noor AM; the use of schools for
2009.
Deressa, W., fentie, G., Girma, S, & Reithinger, R., Ownership and use of
bednet use and non-use after long lasting insecticidal net distribution: a
Ewa, E.E., C.J., Lasis, S.O., Maduka, A.E., Ita U.W., Ibor and U.A.,
33
carre and delivery centres among childbearing women in Ibadan North
South-Western Nigeria.
Fegan, G.W., Noor, A.M., Akhwale, W.S., Cousens, S., Snow, R.W., Effect
Goodman, C., Coleman. P., Mills, A., cost effectiveness of malaria control in
Hanson, K, Marchant, T., Nathan, R., Mponda, H., Jones, C., Bruce, J.,
68(4supp,):121-7
2003.
34
Lengelerc: Inseecticide-treated bednets and curtains for preveniting malaria.
Malusha, J.M., Mwanzo, L., Yitambe, A.,& Mbugi, J.P. 2009: Use of
insecticide treated nets among care givers of children under five years
297,2241,2250.
study using three annual cross sectional household surveys. BMJ 2009
malaria Indicator survey 2010. Abuja, Nigeria: NPC, NMCP, and ICF
International
35
Noor, A.M., Amin, A.A., Akhwale, W.S., Snow. R.W.: increasing coverage
Noor, A.M., Mutheu, J.J., Taten, A.J., Hay, S.I., Snow, R.W: insecticide
2009.
RBM (Roll Back Malaria). 2007. Fighting malaria: Africa goes from control
Roll back malaria: Global strategic plan: roll back malaria, 2005-2015.
Rowe, A.K., Rowe S.Y., Snow, R.W., Korenrop, E., Armstrong Schellenberg
Sibhatu, B., Ayalu, R., & Haji, k.(2012). Determinants of ownership and
Teklehaimanot A., Macord Gordo, C., Sachs, J. O., scaling up malaria control
36
Med. Hyy. 2007. The American journal of tropical medicine and
hygiene 2008.
Thwing, J., Hochberg N, Vanden, Eng, J Issifi S., Eliades, M.J., MinKovwu
E., Wolkon, A., Gado, H., Ibrahim, O., Newman, R.D., Lama, M:
Tulu, A.N. 1993. Malaria in the Ecology of Health and Disease in Ethiopia,
Webster, J., lines, J., Bruce, J., Armstrong Scellenberg J.R.M; Hansonk.,
Google scholar.
World Health Organization: The Abuja declaration and plan of action 2000.
37
David, A. 2001. Meeting the malaria challenge in Africa health, 24:15-
18
38
RESEARCH QUESTIONNAIRE
Department of Animal
and Environmental Biology
Faculty of Science
Delta State University,
Abraka
Dear Respondent,
Degree in Zoology.
treated with utmost confidence, and used only for the study.
Tick the appropriate options that best correspond with your opinion
SECTION A
1. Sex: male ( ), female ( )
2. Marital Status: Single ( ), Married ( ), Divorced ( ), Widow( )
3. Age:______________
4. Occupation: Farmer ( ), Trading ( ), Student ( ), Civil Servant ( ),
Others ( )
39
5. Level of Education: Primary School( ), Secondary School ( ),
Polytechnic, OND/HND ( ), University ( ), NCE ( ), Others ( )
6. Religion: Christian ( ), Islam ( ), Traditional ( ), Others ( )
7. Family Size: Under 3 ( ), 4-6 ( ), Above 6 ( )
8. Social Status: Rich ( ), Poor ( ), Average ( )
9. What tribe are you: Yoruba ( ), Urhobo ( ), Okpe ( ), Itsekiri ( ),
Igbo ( ), Others ( )
SECTION B
[Link] you have a bednet? Yes ( ), No ( )
[Link] far was the distance from where you purchase it? Near ( ), not far
( ), far ( )
[Link] view do you have about insecticide treated bednet? Negative ( ),
Positive ( )
[Link] the bednet have any negative effect on you? Yes ( ), No ( )
[Link] you comfortable sleeping under bednets? Yes ( ), No ( )
SECTION C
[Link] you currently using bednet? Yes ( ), No ( )
[Link] of use: Everyday ( ), At least once a week ( ), Once a
while ( )
[Link] household members use bednet: Yes ( ), No ( )
[Link] currently in use in household: One ( ), Two ( ), Three or more
( )
[Link] of insecticide treated bednet: Donated by the government ( ),
Purchased ( ), Gift ( ), Both government and purchased ( ), Don’t
know ( )
[Link] it expensive to purchase? Yes ( ), No ( )
40