Professional Competency Self-Evaluations
Professional Competency Self-Evaluations
COMPETENCY SELF‐EVALUATIONS
FOUNDATIONS (1, 2)
To act as a professional inheritor, critic and interpreter of knowledge or culture when teaching students.
FEATURES
• Situates the discipline's basic benchmarks and points of understanding (concepts, postulates and methods) in order to
facilitate significant, in‐depth learning by students.
• Adopts a critical approach to the subject matter.
• Establishes links between the secondary culture set out in the program and the secondary culture of the students.
• Transforms the classroom into a cultural base open to a range of different viewpoints within a common space.
• Casts a critical look at his or her own origins, cultural practices and social role.
LEVEL OF MASTERY
By the end of his or her initial training, the student teacher should be able to:
• understand the subject‐specific and program specific knowledge to be taught, so as to be able to promote the creation of
meaningful links by the students;
• exhibit a critical understanding of his or her cultural development and be aware of its potential and limitations;
• exhibit a critical understanding of the knowledge to be taught, so as to promote the creation of meaningful links by the
students;
• Establish links with the students' culture in the proposed learning activities.
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
I believe I have developed this competency fairly well throughout FE3. Throughout my time reading
the
novel “Night” by Elie Wiesel, I worked to develop all four of the competencies to some extent with a
focus on comprehension. Notably, students had to complete comprehension activities to show their
understanding
of the text and our discussions in class. These activities were designed to get students
thinking
about significant moments in the text, their emotional reactions to the text, and character
transformation.
I also tried to push students to connect to the ideas presented in the text through journal prompts
and
class discussions. Journal prompts such as “what makes up your identity?”, which was preceded by
a discussion of what identity is and what kinds of things make up identity, were designed to get students
connecting to the ‘big idea’ of identity in the book. At first, I had trouble coming up with the kinds of
questions that prompted student participation and engagement in discussions, but I believe my ability to
lead discussions has become relatively strong. I encouraged students to share their thoughts, make
connections, and explore their feelings throughout the unit.
As for my cultural development, part of my philosophy of education has always been honesty. As
such,
despite my thorough research in preparation for the unit on top of the class I took on teaching the
Holocaust,
I made sure to inform students that I am not all-knowing. They were encouraged to question
what I was saying if it didn’t make sense as I have blind spots and cannot see every perspective or know
all the facts. [THOROUGH]
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
I had a little trouble with this at the beginning of my field experience. My issues stemmed mostly
from
anxiety. It was nerve-wracking to be standing in front of a class as the ‘teacher’ - the person who is
expected
to really know and understand everything. As a result, whenever I gave explanations for an
activity
or project, I would rush through the explanation. Part of me just wanted them all to get to work so
that
not all of the attention would be on me. Eventually, with practice and help from my CT, I was able to
relax
and focus on taking my time and ensuring student understanding. I still have some things to work
out
in this area. For example, last week I presented a final project to the students and my CT informed
me that the order I presented them in made it difficult to understand at first. So, I clearly still need some
practice in that area. Overall, however, I feel that I made a great deal of progress in that area.
As for the actual language I use, I have always felt that I’d rather use a bigger word and explain it
than stick to small ones. Part of what students are supposed to be learning is new vocabulary and
concise speech. That being said, I also did not speak to them as though I was writing a paper for McGill. I
think I found a good balance between pushing their language skills and remaining understandable.
[THOROUGH]
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
FEATURES
• Bases the selection and content of teaching sequences on data drawn from recent didactical and pedagogical
research.
• Selects and interprets subject‐specific knowledge in terms of the aims, competencies and subject content
specified in the program of study.
• Plans teaching and evaluation sequences taking into account the logic of the content to the taught and the
development of learning.
• Takes into account the prerequisites, conceptions, social differences (i.e. gender, ethnic origin, socioeconomic
and cultural differences), needs and special interests of the students when developing teaching/learning
situations.
• Selects diverse instructional approaches that are suited to the development of the competencies targeted in the
programs of study.
• Anticipates obstacles to learning posed by the content to be taught.
• Plans learning situations that provide opportunities to apply competencies in different contexts.
LEVEL OF MASTERY
By the end of his or her initial training, the student teacher should be able to:
• develop appropriate and varied teaching/learning situations involving a reasonable level of complexity that
enable students to progress in the development of their competencies;
• Build these activities into a long‐term plan.
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
I was very happy with the activities and assessments I came up with throughout the unit. As
mentioned
earlier, students were given comprehension activities periodically as they read “Night”. I had
goals with these. The first was to get students thinking about and discussing the ideas in the book.
two
We
read the novel as a class and spent a decent amount of time discussing literary techniques, ideas,
and
themes as a class. These activities gave them a chance to explore the facets of those ideas which
interested
them the most. The second was, naturally, to assess their comprehension of the novel. I felt
that
creative activities that included drawing as well as writing. Overall, I think they responded better to
those activities than they would have a test.
These activities help build up to their response essay by encouraging students to think about
themes and provide evidence from the text to back up their ideas. They also helped build up to their unit
project by pushing students to reflect on the unit topic and discuss their ideas about it.
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
[THOROUGH]
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
I believe that this was one of my strongest competencies. I always made sure to make myself
available while students worked. I made sure to examine their progress, answer questions, and guide
students
through their work whenever necessary. I found I was often able to reframe instructions or ideas
for
students so that they could better understand.
In class discussions, I eventually developed a fairly solid ability to gauge student comprehension
and
encourage engagement through observation, asking questions, and prompting discussion.
I also worked hard to adapt my teaching to ensure student understanding. For example, near the
beginning of the unit, some students expressed that they were having trouble following the plot of the
novel. As such, I developed a ‘Timeline’ activity where we discussed the most important events from that
day’s reading, picked out the four or five most significant, and then put them on a document available to
everyone online. According to the students, it really helped them better understand the basic plot.
[ADVANCED]
TEACHING ACT (3, 4, 5, 6)
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
In class, I believe I was able to develop a very good sense of who was understanding and who was
Unfortunately, I had much more ease getting students who simply didn’t understand out of confusion
not.
than
those who didn’t understand out of a lack of engagements. The former simply required me to
reframe
the idea or instructions. The latter required something more. Depending on the student, I was
able
to get those unengaged back on track by helping them get started on the task or closely monitoring
their
progress on top of providing further explanations. Some, however, simply didn’t engage. I have
slowly
been identifying ways to encourage engagement in my planning and management of the
classroom, but for now I still have quite a bit of work to do.
Through assessments, I am relatively easily able to see who is struggling with a concept. With the
help of my CT, I was usually able to correct any issues with my explanation if that was the problem. I
would often take the next class to re-explain a concept or have students who understood summarize the
idea. I also, spent a lot of time working on and adapting the assessments themselves to ensure that they
pushed students without being too stressful or difficult.
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
[ACCEPTABLE]
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
This is the competency that I feel I spent the most time working on throughout the field experience.
In terms of the routine of the class, I largely stuck with the one my CT had already established. It was
effective
and I enjoyed it, so it worked out well. Managing the classroom, on the other hand, was
something
I had to figure out on my own. Though my CT already had a relationship and an established
classroom
climate, there was no guarantee that I could do the same.
It took some time, but I was progressively able to develop an assertive tone when necessary –
which
was one of my biggest issues throughout the experience. That paired with planning my lessons to
avoid lulls in activity, having frank discussions with students more prone to misbehavior, building a
relationship with the students, and learning to relax and be myself led to fairly positive results. I think it’s
difficult to really execute all of my ideas about classroom management as the classroom isn’t really mine
and, though I was present, I didn’t establish the atmosphere at the beginning of the year. Overall,
however, I am very pleased with how I was able to build respect and maintain control of the classroom. I
far from perfect, but I am happy with how far I’ve come. I think that that created a positive classroom
am
environment
conducive to discussion and learning.
[THOROUGH]
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
This competency was particularly difficult to fulfill this year as the school’s usual tactics of keeping
students
in for one-on-one work during recess or part of lunch and letting students work on assessments
and
activities with aids in the resource room were impossible due to Covid. As such, I did my best to
accommodate
student needs and plan my lessons in ways that scaffolded those in need. For example,
one
of my classes had several students with difficulty reading. As such, I designed the unit so that we
would
be reading the book out loud as a class. Students were encouraged to participate, but none were
ever
forced. That way those students who would have struggled with reading alone were able to hear the
book as they followed along. I did my best to fulfill needs in that way throughout the unit, but I was
restricted by the circumstances of this school year.
Hopefully, however, I’ll be able to fully accommodate students with IEPs in my next field
experience. I would have liked to have been able to give more one-on-one help and attention to students
need on top of the inclusive planning I did my best to perform. Though I did my best to encourage
in
students to email me any time they were having difficulties, few did.
[ACCEPTABLE]
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
I was able to integrate tech into my teaching throughout the unit. The class was already using
Google
Classroom so I made sure to make all class material available through there. Classroom provided
a good place to host all of the necessary materials, instructions, assignments, and grades for students
and
myself. I was even able to assign a short pre-assessment through google forms on the platform.
In the physical classroom I was able to show videos, play music, and show slide shows when
necessary.
I used the Smartboard to display images and instructions when I felt it would benefit the class.
Students
also used tech to complete classwork. They performed tasked such as looking up the word of
the
day, making a collage, filling in exit cards, and performing research with their devices. They were also
given the opportunity to work on their typing skills on a website linked to their Google Classroom if they
finished work ahead of time or had some free time near the end of class. Their unit project also involves
filming or recording themselves. I feel that I was able to incorporate tech into the class well, but, given
more time, I would have enjoyed the opportunity to assign more projects using some of the tech I’ve been
exploring in classes at McGill. [THOROUGH] Attach additional sheets if necessary.
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
Throughout my field experience I collaborated heavily with my CT is developing my unit, lessons,
and
assessments. We spent a lot of time developing ideas and adapting my instructional methods to
ensure that they fit in with the school’s practices and culture. I also welcomed ideas and material from
other
teachers who were, fortunately, more than happy to offer ideas and advice in the staff room.
In terms of school life, though a lot was delayed or cancelled due to Covid, I was able to sit in on
several
meetings and discussions about student life and school issues. In the future I would like to get
more
actively involved, but I ensured that I was at least introduced to how these types of things work in a
school.
I was able to participate in parent/teacher interviews during the field experience. I felt that this was
a very positive experience. I was able to discuss ideas for progress with parents and most seemed highly
cooperative. We were able to get on the same page and, whether the interview was about academics,
behavior, or both, we were usually able to come up with potential solutions.
[ACCEPTABLE]
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
I believe that, though it took some time to come out of my shell, I was able to have very productive
conversations with my CT as well as other teachers at the school. I was able to provide my thoughts and
ideas
not just for my class but for my fellow student teacher and in the matter of classroom management.
For
example, a particular class had significant behavior issues and resulted in many discussions and
meetings
between the classes teachers. I feel that I was able to contribute to discussion and provide
helpful
ideas and suggestions. Though in official meetings I felt my lack of experience silenced me, I was
more
open in more casual discussions between teachers. So though in my next experience I hope to feel
more comfortable actively contributing all the time, I feel I did very well in this experience.
[THOROUGH]
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
I feel that I spent the entire field experience reflecting, taking feedback, and adapting my methods
and
ideas. After every class I wrote a reflection detailing what went wrong and how I felt I could improve.
CT also always asked me how class went upon returning, which gave me the opportunity to reflect
My
and
discuss what was going on in class and what needed to be fixed. It was very rare for me to leave
class
and not take several opportunities to think back on what I could have done to help the classroom
run
more smoothly, feel more engaging, or help the students more.
I was offered several opportunities to reflect on the school culture, supervision, my interactions with
other
staff members, and educational theory and philosophy through staff room discussions and
interactions with other teachers. It felt like every day I had something new to consider and adapt to.
[ADVANCED]
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*
How have I developed this competency during this course or professional seminar/field experience?
I believe I always acted responsibly, respectfully, and ethically at school. I did my best to ensure
that
students felt they had a voice and strived to show them the same respect I expected of them. I
always
made sure that they knew I was there to help should they need it, and I always respected their
confidentiality.
In the classroom and beyond, I always strived to exercise sound moral judgement, reflected on my
biases
and blind spots, and exercised strong reasoning.
[ADVANCED]
Attach additional sheets if necessary.
WHAT IS MY CURRENT LEVEL OF MASTERY? (CHOOSE ONE)*