Hello Bird, Goodbye: 1
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY
Chapter One consists of six parts: (1) Background of the Study, (2) Statement of the
Problem and the Hypotheses, (3) Theoretical and Conceptual Framework, (4) Significance of the
Study, (5) Scope and Delimitation of the Study, and (6) Definition of Terms.
Part One, Background of the Study, presents the rationale for the choice of the problem.
Part Two, Statement of the Problem and the Hypotheses, enumerates the main and
specific problems to be answered by the research and the hypotheses to be tested.
Part Three, Theoretical and Conceptual Framework, discusses the theories and procedural
flow involving the independent and dependent variables.
Part Four, Significance of the Study, cites the benefits that may be derived from the
results of the study.
Part Five, Scope and Delimitation of the Study, specifies the scope and coverage of the
study.
Part Six, Definition of Terms, gives the conceptual and operational meanings of the
important terms used in the study.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 2
Background of the Study
Birds play an essential role in the functioning of the world’s ecosystem but when left
unchecked, a few species of them can also be detrimental (Sekercioglu et al., 2016).
Even a single bird spotted on the airport runway or on airside areas is a huge problem for
airport personnel. It can bring an enormous threat. It can cause flight delay, can cause millions
for damage repair, and can cause the death of the hundreds of passengers when bird strikes
happen. In 2018, the Roxas City Airport ranked in the most number of bird spikes in the whole
Philippines, according to Cynthia A. Aspera, Airport Manager II of Roxas City Airport. The
Civil Aviation Authority of the Philippines (CAAP) together with the department of environment
and natural resources (DENR) had been fighting ways of mitigating the birds without harming
them but unfortunately, they still haven’t found the best bird control method.
In addition, agriculture and fisheries are the leading industries which contributes large
amounts in the country’s economic growth (Habito et al., 2005). However, these sectors also
suffer from decrease in quantity and quality of yielded products, and birds are one of the major
causes of the said decrease. Because of the alarming problems, the researchers were led to
innovate common bird control methods.
Several devices have been used to control bird infestation in airport runways and in agricultural
sectors. These however, were found ineffective because of the species diversity of birds with
different frequency sensitivity. Thus, this research aimed to construct a solar-powered multi-
technique bird repeller.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 3
Statement of the Problem
General Objective
Generally, this study aims to construct and test a solar-powered multi-technique device
that can repel common bird species.
Specific Objectives
1. To determine if the solar-powered multi-technique device can repel Domestic Doves or
“Salampati” (Streptopelia risoria) using different frequencies, 5m away from the cage.
2. To determine if the solar-powered multi-technique device can repel Domestic Doves or
“Salampati” (Streptopelia risoria) using different frequencies, 10m away from the cage.
3. To determine if the solar-powered multi-technique device can repel Domestic Doves or
“Salampati” (Streptopelia risoria) using different frequencies, 15m away from the cage.
4. To determine if the solar-powered multi-technique device can repel Chestnut munia or
“Maya Pula” (Lonchura atricapilla) using different frequencies, 5m away from the cage.
5. To determine if the solar-powered multi-technique device can repel Chestnut munia or
“Maya Pula” (Lonchura atricapilla) using different frequencies, 10m away from the
cage.
6. To determine if the solar-powered multi-technique device can repel Chestnut munia or
“Maya Pula” (Lonchura atricapilla) using different frequencies, 15m away from the
cage.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 4
Hypotheses
1. The solar-powered multi-technique device cannot repel Domestic Doves or “Salampati”
(Streptopelia risoria) using different frequencies, 5m away from the cage.
2. The solar-powered multi-technique device cannot repel Domestic Doves or “Salampati”
(Streptopelia risoria) using different frequencies, 10m away from the cage.
3. The solar-powered multi-technique device cannot repel Domestic Doves or “Salampati”
(Streptopelia risoria) using different frequencies, 15m away from the cage.
4. The solar-powered multi-technique device cannot repel Chestnut munia or “Maya Pula”
(Lonchura atricapilla) using different frequencies, 5m away from the cage.
5. The solar-powered multi-technique device cannot repel Chestnut munia or “Maya Pula”
(Lonchura atricapilla) using different frequencies, 10m away from the cage.
6. The solar-powered multi-technique device cannot repel Chestnut munia or “Maya Pula”
(Lonchura atricapilla) using different frequencies, 15m away from the cage.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 5
Theoretical Framework
Independent Variable Dependent Variable
Experimental Set-Ups:
Set-Up A:
Multi-Technique Bird Repellent:
Mean number of Birds Repelled
Ultrasonic Sound
at difference distances:
Sonic Sound Testing of
5m
Infrasonic Sound Device
10 m
15 m
Set-Up B:
Commercial Sonic Bird
Repellent
Figure 1. Mean number of birds repelled at different distances using different bird repellent
setups.
Conceptual Framework
frequency frequency transducer
power drive
scanner generator output
Hello Bird Goodbye: 6
Figure 2. Block diagram of the ultrasonic bird repeller.
Significance of the Study
The results of the study may provide significant information to the Department of
Agriculture, farmers, Department of Environment and Natural Resources, Airline companies,
fishpond operators, fishermen, and other researchers.
The results of the study can help the Department of Agriculture assist the farmers who
are having problems regarding bird pests who feeds on their crops.
Farmers can benefit in this study by having a hundred-percent harvest since bird pests are
repelled from their crops.
The Department of Environment and Natural Resources can benefit in this study in terms
of conserving farms and keeping an eye on bird pests.
Through this study, airline companies can stop bird strike incidents, thus saving lives and
money.
Fishpond operators and fishermen can profit more through the help of this study. They
will no longer worry about the decrease in their fish harvest.
Scope and Delimitation
This study is limited to the use of birds contained in a simulated environment.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 7
This device was constructed to test if ultrasonic, sonic, and ifransonic frequencies are
effective in repelling common bird species.
Observations of birds’ reactions to the broadcasted waves will be made. For experimental
control, the birds’ response in portions of the field where the broadcasted waves did not reach
will also be observed. Simple average will be employed in evaluating the signal reach from the
raw data obtained.
Definition of Terms
A. Bird - any warm-blooded vertebrate of the class Aves, having a body covered with
feathers, forelimbs modified into wings, scaly legs, a beak, and no teeth, and bearing
young in a hard-shelled egg (The American Heritage Science Dictionary, 2011). In this
study, the birds’ reactions and behavior when exposed to ultrasonic frequencies.
B. Infrasonic - in its popular definition as sound below a frequency of 20 Hz, is clearly
audible, the hearing threshold having been measured down to 1.5 Hz (Leventhall, 2007).
In this study, infrasonic sound is also utilized a feature for the device.
C. Repeller - to act with a force that drives or keeps away something (Online Etymology
Dictionary, 2010). In this study, ultrasonic frequencies will be utilized as a bird repeller.
D. Solar Power - generally describes technologies that convert sunlight into electricity and in
some cases thermal or mechanical power (ScienceDaily, 2016). In this study, solar power
will be used as source of electrical energy.
E. Ultrasonic - vibrations of frequencies greater than the upper limit of the audible range for
humans—that is, greater than about 20 kilohertz. The term sonic is applied to ultrasound
Hello Bird Goodbye: 8
waves of very high amplitudes (Brittanica, 2014). In this study, ultrasonic frequencies
will be utilized to repel birds.
CHAPTER II
REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE
This chapter discusses literatures and studies related to the present investigation. It
consists of three (3) parts: (1) Birds as Pest; (2) The Repulsive Property of Ultrasonic
Frequencies; and (3) Synthesis.
The first part, “Birds as Pest,” elucidates how birds become problematic to different
economic sectors.
The second part, “The Repulsive Property of Ultrasonic Frequencies,” elucidates how
ultrasonic frequencies can act as a repeller device because of its repulsive property.
The third topic, “Synthesis,” summarizes the literatures and studies cited.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 9
Birds as Pest
Many common birds prove beneficial to man. These benefits include down feather
production, insect and weed population control, pollination and the sport of watching and
feeding. Yet many problems may arise when birds associate too closely with people. Common
bird problems range from general nuisance and building defacement to food contamination and
disease transmission (DoMyOwn, 2018).
The acid in bird droppings is highly corrosive and can therefore damage building
exteriors. Birds can also cause damage to your home or office by dislodging roof tiles and
leaving debris from their nests in drains and gutters. In time, this can cause blockages and
problems with flooding when heavy rainfall occurs. While not much can be done about the odd
bird dropping, if a flock of birds nest around a building or structure, the area will eventually
become overridden with the mess of bird droppings. In addition to its corrosive property, most
bird droppings give off a foul smell. They have been known to return to their nests with
cigarettes that are still lit, making them a big fire hazard. They frequently foul entrances and
pavements. This can be dangerous when slippery. During breeding season, birds may attack
people when their nests and younglings are provoked. One of the main reasons why birds are
sometimes classified as pest is because they carry ectoparasites such as mites. These can be
transferred to humans and cause diseases such as Ornithosis, [Link], and Salmonella. Their
molted feathers can also cause respiratory problems and their droppings sometimes contain
parasitic worms that can take up residence within the human body (Stait, 2017).
Hello Bird Goodbye: 10
According to a report, birds could also be causing drastic decrease in crop yields by
destroying them, which calls it as an emerging concern in agriculture. “The avian species inflict
losses in agriculture by damaging crops during sowing, seeding and ripening stages, leading to
economic losses to the farming community,” states the interministerial report of the Committee
on Doubling Farmer’s Income (DFI) – Volume X titled “Risk Management in Agriculture,”
released by the Ministry of Agriculture. “Birds are known to cause considerable economic
damage to a variety of crops during vulnerable stages in different agro-ecological regions of the
country. The extent of bird damage to any crop depends on several factors like concentration of
local bird population, total area under the crop, cropping pattern habitat of the area, season
and physiological status of the birds,” also stated in the report. It identified 63 bird species of
birds, 1364 from 19 families that caused damage to several crops. A whopping 52 bird species
attacked cereals, pulses got attacked by 14 bird species, while oilseeds faced damage risk by 15
species, and fruits by 23 species. They also caused damage to the crops of smaller grains such as
pearl millet and sorghum as well as corn. Moreover, bird damage was found to be more in
isolated, early or late maturing fields, varied between regions, seasons, number of species, their
density, concentration of migrants and their food habits (Down To Earth, 2019).
The aviation industry is also frequented with bird strikes. A bird strike is strictly defined
as a collision between a bird and an aircraft which is in flight or on a takeoff or landing roll. Bird
strikes are common and can be a significant threat to aircraft safety. For smaller aircrafts,
significant damage may be caused to the aircraft structure. All aircraft, especially jet-engine
ones, are vulnerable to the loss of thrust which can follow from the ingestion of birds into engine
air intakes. This has resulted in a number of fatal accident (SKYbrary, 2019).
Hello Bird Goodbye: 11
Between 1960 and 2014, bird strikes were responsible for the destruction of
approximately 150 civil aircrafts and the death of 271 people (Hedayati & Sadighi, 2015).
The Repulsive Property of Ultrasonic Frequencies
Ultrasonic devices operate through emitting short wavelength, high frequency sound
waves that are too high in pitch to be heard by the human ear – generally accepted to be
frequencies greater than 20,000 Hz (Elert, 2016). Humans are usually unable to hear sounds
higher than 20 kHz due to physiological limitations of the cochlea, though there is considerable
variation between individuals, especially at such high frequencies. Some animals, such as bats,
dogs and rodents, can hear well into the ultrasonic range (Ryckegham, n.d.). Some insects, such
as grasshoppers and locusts, can detect frequencies from 50,000 Hz to 100,000 Hz, and
lacewings and moths can detect ultrasound as high as 240,000 Hz produced by insect-hunting
bats.
The use of ultrasonic frequencies to repel away pests such as mosquitoes and rodents
have been studied and tested multiple times.
Ultrasonic waves are used in repelling animals, specifically, mainly by means of the
characteristic of wide acoustic frequency bands of certain animals; ultrahigh-frequency
ultrasonic waves are used for repelling mice, dogs, wolves, cats, and certain insects; and high-
power ultrasonic waves repeatedly stimulate auditory nerves of animals so that the animals are
made fretful and uneasy and then flee the uncomfortable generation environment due to
endocrine dyscrasia (Liu, 2017).
Hello Bird Goodbye: 12
In a study conducted by Saini, et al. (2017), ultrasonic waves have frequencies more than
20,000 Hz which are inaudible to humans but not in insects. When mosquitoes come in contact
with ultrasonic waves, they sense the waves from a special hair or sensilla present on their
antennae, which will create stress on the nervous system and jam their own ultrasonic frequency
and force them to leave that area. The frequency ranges of 38-44 kHz can be used effectively to
repel mosquitoes and flies.
Ultrasonic frequencies were also used in a study to repel away pests in a farm. Results
showed that the implementation of the device in the farmland has shown a great reduction of bug
attack compared to others which doesn’t have one (Rashid, 2014).
Birds are now also being tested in the effectivity of ultrasonic frequencies. The use of
ultrasonic frequencies (which human ears cannot detect, but are perceived by small birds) is a
novel technology that can effectively repel such birds from designated places. Ultrasonic waves
create a hostile environment for the pest birds and had a repulsive influence on them. Though
they have a small radius of action, they were eventually driven away from the designated
locations (Ezeonu, Amaefule, & Okonkwo, 2012).
Results of a study conducted by Whitford (2004) clearly showed that birds experience
severe distress in the presence of ultrasonic frequencies. His studies of ultrasonic devices used in
the field show significantly reduced bird populations and bird droppings. These findings have
been carefully documented in recent years by the highest scientific authorities on the subject of
bird behavior and bird control efficacy proving that ultrasonic devices are, in fact, an effective
bird control method.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 13
Synthesis
Birds are a part of the natural world order. They prove beneficial to man and the
environment as natural pollinators and insect population control. But, when birds increase in
number and associate more closely with humans, they become nuisances or pests. The
agricultural and aviation sector suffers the most when it comes to bird infestation. Yielded crops
substantially decrease in quality and quantity because of bird pests such as swallows or maya. In
the aviation sector, bird strikes frequently occurs during takeoff, damaging aero planes, posing a
risk to human lives. Birds can also be carriers of diseases and their droppings can be corrosive to
man-made structures. Numerous efforts have been made to eradicate this problem. Like
mosquitoes and rats, birds are proven to hear ultrasonic frequencies. Ultrasonic frequencies are
sound waves that is only heard by certain animal species; humans the exception. Studies shown
that insects and rodents have an almost immediate reaction when exposed to ultrasonic
frequencies. Birds are also now being tested in the latest studies which aims to repel away birds
from economic sectors. Several devices have been used to control bird infestation in airport
runways and in agricultural sectors. These however, were found ineffective because of the
species diversity of birds with different frequency sensitivity. Thus, this research aimed to
construct a solar-powered multi-technique bird repeller.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 14
CHAPTER III
RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODOLOGY
Chapter Three consists of seven (7) parts, as follows: (1) Research Design, (2) Materials and
Equipment, (3) Procedural Design, (4) General Procedure, (5) Time Table, (6) Cost Analysis, (7) Data
Collection, Analysis and Procedure
Part One, Research Design, describes the research design to be used in this study.
Part Two, Materials and Equipment, enumerates the different materials and tools to be used in
this study.
Part Three, Procedural Design, enumerates the procedure in a graphic presentation.
Part Four, General Procedure, enumerates and describes the procedure in detail.
Part Five, Time Table, enumerates and describes the timeline of the research from consultation to
conduction.
Part Six, Cost Analysis, summarizes the total cost of the research.
Part Seven, Data Collection, Analysis, and Procedure, describes how data will be collected and
organized.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 15
Research Design
This study will utilize Complete Randomized Design (CRD). There will be a set-up with
three (3) settings done in three (3) replications
Replications
Set – up
1 2 3
A. Multi – Technique Bird Repellent
(Researchers’ Device)
A.1 Infrasonic Sound
A.2 Sonic Sound
(air horn siren, thunder, hammer)
A.3 Ultrasonic Sound
B. Sonic Bird Repellent
(Commercial)
Hello Bird Goodbye: 16
Materials and Equipment
Tools and Materials
The tools and materials used in making the device were the following: pliers, soldering
iron and rod, scissors, glue gun and glue, screw driver, electric saw, 20W stereo amplifier, 12V
USB player with an infrared receiver module, four 3.7V solar rechargeable battery, regulator AN
7812, four 150W 107 dB tweeter speakers, three 6V solar panels, passive infrared sensor with
time delay, red LED, switch, 4GB SD card, aluminum sheet and angle.
Casing of the Device
Four pieces 11” x 6” and 2 pieces 6” x 6” aluminum sheets; 4 pieces 11” and 8 peices 6”
long aluminum angle, rivets, screws, and hinges were used to construct the casing of the device.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 17
Procedural Design
Gathering of Materials Needed
Assembling of the Materials and Constructing
of the Device
Acclimatization of birds
Testing of Device
Gathering of Data
Analyzing of Results
Releasing of birds
Hello Bird Goodbye: 18
Figure 3. Procedural Design
Schematic Diagram
Figure 2. Schematic Diagram of the Device
Hello Bird Goodbye: 19
General Procedure
Gathering of Materials Needed
The electrical and electronic materials needed in the study will be bought at three (3)
different local Electronic Shops in Roxas City since not all of the materials needed are available
in one shop only. The SD card and solar panels will be provided by the researchers from a
damaged solar light and is reused in the study.
The aluminum sheet and angle to be used as casing will bebought and cut in one of the
glass supply store in Roxas City.
Assembling of the Materials and Constructing of the Device
Designing and making of the casing of the device will be done by the researchers. A
dimension of 11in x 6 in x 6 in aluminum box covered with an aluminum angle in each corner
will be done It will be connected using a rivet and screws. A hole in each of the four side of the
box was made for the tweeter speakers.
11 in
Hello Bird Goodbye: 20
6 in
6 in
Figure 4. Casing of the Device
Assembling of the electrical parts and electronic components of the device and its
placement in the casing will be done by the researchers with the assistance of a licensed
electrician, Mr. Edwin Vidal, in his electronic shop in Capricho II, Roxas City. One hundred
percent (100%) of the idea on how a device should function came from the researchers, although
it was with the assistance of a licensed electrician who suggested on the connection and what
electronic parts should be used that the device was assembled and made. The researchers will
observe and help in soldering as the electrician connected and assembled the electronic parts and
electrical connections.
Acclimatization of birds
120 Chestnut Munia (mayang pula) will be bought at a local pet store while the domestic
doves (Salampati) used in the study were owned by one of the researchers. The local seller has
an official permit for selling birds. The birds will be placed in cages supplied enough water and
food pallets and will be acclimatized for seven (7) days.
Testing of the Device
Testing the effectiveness of the device on Chestnut Munia (mayang pula) and domestic
doves (salampati) will be done in Brgy. Mongpong, Roxas City with the guidance of the
domestic doves’ owner. The birds will be tested inside a contained large cage as suggested by the
Hello Bird Goodbye: 21
panel of evaluators during the Division Scilympics. Two (2) set – ups were tested with three
trials each and each trial had ten (10) birds in the cage: set-up A using the researchers’ device
and set – up B using the sonic bird repellent (commercial). The testing will take four days for
each day is consumed for one set-up only and the trials will be done at different time of the day
where birds are naturally active; 6 – 7 A.M.; 11 – 12:30 A.M. and 3 – 4 P.M. The testing for
each set up will be done one day at a time to avoid damaging the auditory nerves of the birds
with too much exposure in the sound waves produced by the device. The device will be tested at
different distances from the cage: 5 m, 10 m and 15 m respectively.
Though ultrasonic waves can be produced by electronic devices, it is only limited to 22
KHz and youtube’s audio compression cut off frequencies above 16 KHz. To generate ultrasonic
frequencies above 22 KHz, the researchers used an oscillator and a frequency generator.
Gathering of Data
The behavior and reaction of birds will be observed and recorded during the testing of the
device. At 5 m distance from the cage, the device will be set-up and switched on (but no sound
played). The researchers will wait until the birds were calm and feel no threat before the sound
was played. As soon as the sound will br played and heard by the birds, the researchers will
observ and record the birds’ reaction, whether they flew away from the source of sound, became
disoriented/restless or no reaction at all. The researchers will then count the number of birds that
was affected by the sound, those that flew away and became disoriented/restless. This method
will be repeated at 10 m and 15 m distance of the device from the cage respectively.
Analyzing of Results
Hello Bird Goodbye: 22
The data gathered will be tabulated, the means will be computed and One-Way Analysis
of Variance (ANOVA) will be employed.
Releasing of birds
The purchased birds will be released free after the testing of the device and the conduct of
the study were done.
Time Table
Task Date Description
Brainstorming of the researchers for the research title. 06/17/19
Presented research title 06/19/19
Consultation for the possibility of the device to be
06/26/19
constructed to a licensed electrician
Research Title Defense 07/03/19
Approval of Research for Conduction and Filling of
07/03/19
Forms
Ordered commercial sonic bird repellent device online 08/16/19
Delivery of the commercial sonic bird repeller 08/24/19
Start of the construction of the device 08/24/19
The researchers bought Chestnut Munia (Maya Pula) 08/25/19
Consultation with a licensed veterinarian regarding the
08/27/19
use of birds as subjects for testing the device
Construction of the device was finished 08/30/19
Testing of device 08/31/19
Drafting of Manuscripts for Local Science Fair 09/01/19
Submission of manuscripts for Local Science Fair 09/04/19
Local Science Fair 09/06/19
The researchers started to improve and develop the
09/07/19
device
Revisions of manuscript for Division Science Fair 09/11/19
Modification and Improvement of device was finished 09/13/19
Went to CAAP for formal conduction of survey and
09/13/19
tests to evaluate the device
Testing of device at CAAP 09/14/19
Conduction of survey at CAAP 09/15/19
Final Revisions of Manuscripts for Division Science
09/16/19
Fair
Division Science Fair 09/26/19
Hello Bird Goodbye: 23
Improvement suggested by consultants 09/28/19
Improvements established on the device 09/30/19
Cost Analysis
QTY UNIT PRODUCT DESCRIPTION PRICE
1 PIECE 20 Watts Stereo Amplifier Kit
12 Volts USB Player with an Infrared Receiver
1 PIECE
Module
1 PIECE 3.7 Volts Rechargeable Batteries
P1,500.00
1 PIECE Regulator AN 7812
1 PIECE 150 Watts Tweeter Speaker
1 PIECE PIR with Time Delay
1 PIECE Switch
1 PIECE Commercial Bird Repeller P1,096.00
1 PIECE Aluminum Casing P605.00
TOTAL P3201.00
Data Collection, Analysis, and Procedure
The number of birds repelled will be collect and One-Way Analysis of Variance
(ANOVA) will be used for data analysis and procedure
Hello Bird Goodbye: 24
References
Aguirre, Jun N. 2019. “Bird Strike Strands Passengers in Kalibo.” Sunstar. SunStar. February 25,
2019. [Link]
Baral, S.s., R. Swarnkar, A.v. Kothiya, A.m. Monpara, and S.k. Chavda. “Bird Repeller – A
Review.” International Journal of Current Microbiology and Applied Sciences 8, no. 02
(October 2019): 1035–39. [Link]
“Chestnut Munia: Bird Gallery.” Chestnut Munia | Bird Gallery | [Link], 2009.
[Link]
Esperas, Raoul. 2019. “Bird Strike Forces Plane to Return to NAIA.” ABS-CBN News. ABS-
CBN. July 16, 2019. [Link]
return-to-naia.
“Eurasian Tree Sparrow: Bird Gallery.” Eurasian Tree Sparrow | Bird Gallery | [Link],
2009. [Link]
Merphy, Vibisha, and D Sathish. “Simulation of Infrasound Birds Deter to Avoid Bird Strikes in
Airports,” March 2007.
[Link]
Sekercioglu, Cagan & Wenny, Dan & Whelan, Christopher. (2016). Why birds matter: bird
ecosystem services promote biodiversity and human well-being.
“Since 1964, Bird-X Has Been the Industry Leader in ...” Accessed September 2019. [Link]
[Link]/wp-content/uploads/Bird-X_CATALOG_all.pdf.
Hello Bird Goodbye: 25
“Ultrasonic Bird Repeller: Super Sonic Bird Deterrent Sound Control.” Bird. Accessed July
2019. [Link]
“UltraSonic Pigeon & Bird Control.” Ultrasonic Pigeon & Bird Control - PCRC. Accessed July
2019. [Link]
[Link].
“What Can Birds Hear? - USDA.” Accessed September 2019.
[Link]