BATAANPENINSULASTATEUNIVERSITY
College of Business and Accountancy Telefax: (6347) 2373655
Don Manuel Banzon Ave., Poblacion (6347) 2371743
City of Balanga 2100 Bataan Website: [Link]
PHILIPPINES E-mail: batpolstatecol@[Link]
GRADING SHEET
(For Case Presenter)
Case Title: Global Marine Partners
Group Members : Aquino, Mary Claire C. Magno, Franz Catherine S.
Cabaya, Eula C. Magparok, Catherine
Crisostomo, Meryl Orate, Rhealy B.
Enriquez, Pauline C.
CRITERIA Excellent (4) Good (3) Fair (2) Needs Points
Improvement
(1)
Explanation A complete response Good Solid Explanation is Misses key
with detailed response with unclear. points.
explanation clear explanation.
Demonstrated Shows complete Shows substantial Response shows Response shows
Knowledge understanding of the understanding of some a complete lack
problem/question, the problem, understanding of
topic, ideas and topic, ideas and of the understanding
processes processes. problem/questio for the problem.
n.
Requirements Goes beyond the Meets the Hardly meets Does not meet
requirements of the requirements of the requirements the requirements
problem. the problem of the problem. of the problem.
Materials The instructional The instructional The The
(Visual aids) materials used are very materials used are instructional instructional
innovative. innovative. materials are not materials used
so exhibit no effort
extraordinary. or preparation.
Delivery Holds the attention of Consistent use of Displays Holds no eye
entire audience with direct eye contact minimal eye contact with
the use of eye contact, with audience, but contact with audience, as
seldom looking at still returns to audience, while entire report is
notes; notes; reading mostly read from notes;
Speaks with fluctuation Speaks with from notes; Speaks in low
in volume and satisfactory Speaks in volume and/or
inflection to maintain variation of uneven volume causes audience
audience interest and volume and with little or no to disengage.
emphasize key points. inflection. inflection
Comments: Total
Checked:
LOUIE ARTH P. REYES
Faculty, College of Business and Accountancy
BATAANPENINSULASTATEUNIVERSITY
College of Business and Accountancy Telefax: (6347) 2373655
Don Manuel Banzon Ave., Poblacion (6347) 2371743
City of Balanga 2100 Bataan Website: [Link]
PHILIPPINES E-mail: batpolstatecol@[Link]
GRADING SHEET
(Case Study)
Case Title: Oriflame S.A.
Group Members: Aquino, Mary Claire C. Magno, Franz Catherine S.
Cabaya, Eula C. Magparok, Catherine
Crisostomo, Meryl Orate, Rhealy B.
Enriquez, Pauline C.
CRITERIA Excellent (4) Good (3) Fair (2) Needs Points
Improvement
(1)
Explanation A complete response Good Solid Explanation is Misses key
with detailed response with unclear. points.
explanation clear explanation.
Demonstrated Shows complete Shows substantial Response shows Response shows
Knowledge understanding of the understanding of some a complete lack
problem/question, the problem, understanding of
topic, ideas and topic, ideas and of the understanding
processes processes. problem/questio for the problem.
n.
Requirements Goes beyond the Meets the Hardly meets Does not meet
requirements of the requirements of the requirements the requirements
problem. the problem of the problem. of the problem.
Graphical / The illustrations used The illustrations The illustrations The illustrations
Numerical are very innovative. used are are not so used exhibit no
Illustration innovative. extraordinary. effort or
(Answers to preparation.
cases)
Coherence of the The written output The written The written The written
Content consists of complete output consists of output lacks the output lacks the
parts of the case, complete parts of fundamental fundamental
connected to one the case, parts of the parts of the
another and be able to connected to one case, connected case, not
present the problems another and, but to one another connected to
and solution in an not able to present and, but not able one another and,
orderly and systematic the problems and to present the not able to
manner. solution in an problems and present the
orderly and solution in an problems and
systematic orderly and solution in an
manner. systematic orderly and
manner. systematic
manner.
Comments: Total
Checked:
LOUIE ARTH P. REYES
Faculty, College of Business and Accountancy
BATAANPENINSULASTATEUNIVERSITY
College of Business and Accountancy Telefax: (6347) 2373655
Don Manuel Banzon Ave., Poblacion (6347) 2371743
City of Balanga 2100 Bataan Website: [Link]
PHILIPPINES E-mail: batpolstatecol@[Link]
GRADING SHEET
(Case Study)
Case Title: Fair Value Accounting and Subprime
Group Members: Aquino, Mary Claire C. Magno, Franz Catherine S.
Cabaya, Eula C. Magparok, Catherine
Crisostomo, Meryl Orate, Rhealy B.
Enriquez, Pauline C.
CRITERIA Excellent (4) Good (3) Fair (2) Needs Points
Improvement
(1)
Explanation A complete response Good Solid Explanation is Misses key
with detailed response with unclear. points.
explanation clear explanation.
Demonstrated Shows complete Shows substantial Response shows Response shows
Knowledge understanding of the understanding of some a complete lack
problem/question, the problem, understanding of
topic, ideas and topic, ideas and of the understanding
processes processes. problem/questio for the problem.
n.
Requirements Goes beyond the Meets the Hardly meets Does not meet
requirements of the requirements of the requirements the requirements
problem. the problem of the problem. of the problem.
Graphical / The illustrations used The illustrations The illustrations The illustrations
Numerical are very innovative. used are are not so used exhibit no
Illustration innovative. extraordinary. effort or
(Answers to preparation.
cases)
Coherence of the The written output The written The written The written
Content consists of complete output consists of output lacks the output lacks the
parts of the case, complete parts of fundamental fundamental
connected to one the case, parts of the parts of the
another and be able to connected to one case, connected case, not
present the problems another and, but to one another connected to
and solution in an not able to present and, but not able one another and,
orderly and systematic the problems and to present the not able to
manner. solution in an problems and present the
orderly and solution in an problems and
systematic orderly and solution in an
manner. systematic orderly and
manner. systematic
manner.
Comments: Total
Checked:
LOUIE ARTH P. REYES
Faculty, College of Business and Accountancy
BATAANPENINSULASTATEUNIVERSITY
College of Business and Accountancy Telefax: (6347) 2373655
Don Manuel Banzon Ave., Poblacion (6347) 2371743
City of Balanga 2100 Bataan Website: [Link]
PHILIPPINES E-mail: batpolstatecol@[Link]
GRADING SHEET
(Case Study)
Case Title: Global Marine Partners
Group Members: Aquino, Mary Claire C. Magno, Franz Catherine S.
Cabaya, Eula C. Magparok, Catherine
Crisostomo, Meryl Orate, Rhealy B.
Enriquez, Pauline C.
CRITERIA Excellent (4) Good (3) Fair (2) Needs Points
Improvement
(1)
Explanation A complete response Good Solid Explanation is Misses key
with detailed response with unclear. points.
explanation clear explanation.
Demonstrated Shows complete Shows substantial Response shows Response shows
Knowledge understanding of the understanding of some a complete lack
problem/question, the problem, understanding of
topic, ideas and topic, ideas and of the understanding
processes processes. problem/questio for the problem.
n.
Requirements Goes beyond the Meets the Hardly meets Does not meet
requirements of the requirements of the requirements the requirements
problem. the problem of the problem. of the problem.
Graphical / The illustrations used The illustrations The illustrations The illustrations
Numerical are very innovative. used are are not so used exhibit no
Illustration innovative. extraordinary. effort or
(Answers to preparation.
cases)
Coherence of the The written output The written The written The written
Content consists of complete output consists of output lacks the output lacks the
parts of the case, complete parts of fundamental fundamental
connected to one the case, parts of the parts of the
another and be able to connected to one case, connected case, not
present the problems another and, but to one another connected to
and solution in an not able to present and, but not able one another and,
orderly and systematic the problems and to present the not able to
manner. solution in an problems and present the
orderly and solution in an problems and
systematic orderly and solution in an
manner. systematic orderly and
manner. systematic
manner.
Comments: Total
Checked:
LOUIE ARTH P. REYES
Faculty, College of Business and Accountancy
BATAANPENINSULASTATEUNIVERSITY
College of Business and Accountancy Telefax: (6347) 2373655
Don Manuel Banzon Ave., Poblacion (6347) 2371743
City of Balanga 2100 Bataan Website: [Link]
PHILIPPINES E-mail: batpolstatecol@[Link]
GRADING SHEET
(Case Study)
Case Title: Berkshire Hathaway Inc. – Intercorporate Investments (A)
Group Members: Aquino, Mary Claire C. Magno, Franz Catherine S.
Cabaya, Eula C. Magparok, Catherine
Crisostomo, Meryl Orate, Rhealy B.
Enriquez, Pauline C.
CRITERIA Excellent (4) Good (3) Fair (2) Needs Points
Improvement
(1)
Explanation A complete response Good Solid Explanation is Misses key
with detailed response with unclear. points.
explanation clear explanation.
Demonstrated Shows complete Shows substantial Response shows Response shows
Knowledge understanding of the understanding of some a complete lack
problem/question, the problem, understanding of
topic, ideas and topic, ideas and of the understanding
processes processes. problem/questio for the problem.
n.
Requirements Goes beyond the Meets the Hardly meets Does not meet
requirements of the requirements of the requirements the requirements
problem. the problem of the problem. of the problem.
Graphical / The illustrations used The illustrations The illustrations The illustrations
Numerical are very innovative. used are are not so used exhibit no
Illustration innovative. extraordinary. effort or
(Answers to preparation.
cases)
Coherence of the The written output The written The written The written
Content consists of complete output consists of output lacks the output lacks the
parts of the case, complete parts of fundamental fundamental
connected to one the case, parts of the parts of the
another and be able to connected to one case, connected case, not
present the problems another and, but to one another connected to
and solution in an not able to present and, but not able one another and,
orderly and systematic the problems and to present the not able to
manner. solution in an problems and present the
orderly and solution in an problems and
systematic orderly and solution in an
manner. systematic orderly and
manner. systematic
manner.
Comments: Total
Checked:
LOUIE ARTH P. REYES
Faculty, College of Business and Accountancy