0% found this document useful (0 votes)
18 views34 pages

Maintenance Management in Industrial Engineering

This document discusses maintenance management and its importance. It defines key terms like maintain, maintenance, maintainability, reliability, and availability. It outlines the scope of maintenance including reliability considerations, inspections, preventive maintenance, repairs, replacements, and maintenance scheduling. It then discusses the history of maintenance management through three generations as equipment became more complex and downtime had greater impacts. New expectations for uptime, quality, safety and costs drove new research and techniques.

Uploaded by

citra
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
18 views34 pages

Maintenance Management in Industrial Engineering

This document discusses maintenance management and its importance. It defines key terms like maintain, maintenance, maintainability, reliability, and availability. It outlines the scope of maintenance including reliability considerations, inspections, preventive maintenance, repairs, replacements, and maintenance scheduling. It then discusses the history of maintenance management through three generations as equipment became more complex and downtime had greater impacts. New expectations for uptime, quality, safety and costs drove new research and techniques.

Uploaded by

citra
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

Pemeliharaan dan Teknik Keandalan

IE 184623

Laboratorium Sistem Manufaktur


Departemen Teknik Industri – ITS
 Gasal 2019

Industrial Engineering ITS


Maintenance management

Pemeliharaan dan Teknik Keandalan


Laboratorium Sistem Manufaktur
Departemen Teknik Industri – ITS
 Gasal 2019

Industrial Engineering ITS


Why study Maintenance ?
Industrial Engineering ITS

• Maintenance has been recognized as the main source for


fulfillment of the production performance.
• However, many organizations have lack of attention on this
activities due to their perspective of thinking that
maintenance is separated from production, have no value
added, and ever cost consume.
• A comprehensive understanding of maintenance
management system has proved that appropriate
maintenance management will provide significant
contributions on productivity improvement trough
improvement the equipment availability and minimize
maintenance cost.
• Therefore, company need to update their knowledge on
maintenance management system in order to gain the
optimal benefit of maintenance activities.
Definition
Industrial Engineering ITS

Maintain
• Cause to continue (oxford)
• Keep in an existing state (Webster)
• Maintain vs modify (change it in someway)

• What is it that we wish to cause to continue?


• what is the existing state that we wish to preserve?

Fact : every physical asset is put into service because someone


wants it to do something, to fulfill a specific function.
When we maintain an asset, we wish to preserve which it continue
to do whatever its user want it to do.
Definition (2)
Industrial Engineering ITS

Maintenance :
• all actions necessary for retaining an item in, or restoring it
to, a specified condition (MIL-STD 721 B)
• ensuring that physical assets continue to do what their
users want them to do
Maintainability :
• the measure of the ability of an item to be retain in or
restored to specific condition when maintenance is
performed by personnel having specified skill levels, using
predescribed procedures and resources, at prespecified
level of maintenance and repair (MIL-STD 721 B)
• the probability that a failed unit is put back to satisfactory,
operable condition in a given down time
All the study on maintenance of system or component always
considering and based on system’s or component’s reliability.
Definition (3)
Industrial Engineering ITS

Reliability :
• the probability that a unit will function normally when used
according to specified condition for at least a stated period
of time.
• The probability of an item performing its required function
for the intended period of time [0,t]
Availability :
• The probability that an item is operating at a specified time
t, depend on mean up time and mean down time
Maintenance Scope
Industrial Engineering ITS

Primary function of maintenance is to control the condition of equipment,


there are some problems associated with:

1. reliability considerations
2. inspection : frequencies and depth of activities
3. Preventive Maintenance and overhaul interval
4. Repair or Replace
5. replacement rule for component and capital equipment
(taking account of technological change)
6. maintenance crew sizes
7. composition of machines in a workshop
8. spare provisioning rule
9. Maintenance project scheduling (sequence rule for jobs,
start time for constituent jobs)
HISTORY OF MAINTENANCE
FROM MOUBRAY (1997)

Industrial Engineering ITS


Change due to
Industrial Engineering ITS

Maintenance has changed – due to


 huge increase in the number and variety of physical asset
(plant, equipment, and building), more complex design,
 new maintenance techniques
 changing view on maintenance organization and
responsibilities.
 Respond to changing expectation
 Rapidly growing awareness that equipment failure affect
safety and the environment
 growing awareness of the connection between
maintenance and product quality
 increasing pressure to achieve high plant availability and to
contain cost
Generation
Industrial Engineering ITS

since 1930, the evolution of maintenance can be traced through three


generation :

A. the first generation (covers the period up to worldwar II)


 the industry was not very highly mechanized –
downtime did not matter
 most equipment was simple – reliable and easy to repair
 no need for systematic maintenance of any sort beyond
simple cleaning, servicing, and lubrication routine.
 The need for skill was lower
Generation
Industrial Engineering ITS

B. the second generation


 wartime pressure – increase demand for all kinds while the
supply drooped sharply- increase mechanization
 1950 – all type machine more numerous and more complex –
industry was beginning to depend on them
 downtime came into sharper focus – the idea that equipment
failure could and should be prevented – led to the concept of
preventive maintenance
 cost maintenance also started to rise sharply relative to the
other operating cost - led to the growth of maintenance and
planning and control systems
 a sharp increase in the cost of capital as fixed assets – led to
start seeking in which they could maximize the life of the
assets.
C. the third generation
 mid seventies – the process of change in industry on new
expectations, new research, and new techniques
Industrial Engineering ITS

new expectation
 Downtime affect:
 reducing output
 increasing operating cost
 affecting customer service
 greater automation – more and more failure affect
 the ability to sustain satisfactory quality standard
 have serious safety or environment consequency
 cost of maintenance still rising – become the highest or
second highest element of operating cost
Industrial Engineering ITS

new research
 connecting between operating age and failure
Industrial Engineering ITS

new techniques, new development include:


 decision support tools : hazard studies, expert system, FMEA
 new maintenance technique: conditioning monitoring (PdM)
 designing equipment emphasis on reliability and maintainability
 a major shift in organizational thinking: participating, team working,
flexibility
 right choice of techniques : to improve assets performance, and reduce
cost of maintenance
MAINTENANCE SYSTEM

Industrial Engineering ITS


Maintenance and other function
Industrial Engineering ITS
Interaksi
Industrial Engineering ITS

Interaksi antara fungsi maintenance dengan keputusan lain menunjukkan


adanya area potensial konflik yang dapat diselesaikan dengan beberapa
trade off :

1. Pada jangka pendek


a. Trade off antara maintenance dengan scheduling.
Minimum repair time dengan interupsi preventive
maintenance vs operation time yang panjang unt
mengoptimalkan completion time shg dapat meningkatkan
frekuensi brakedown

b. Trade off antara maintenance dengan aggregate


planning.
Decoupling inventory spy PM ebih mudah dan murah vs
integrasi inventory unt perencanaan minimasi ongkos produksi
Keterangan
Industrial Engineering ITS

2. Pada jangka panjang

a. Trade off antara maintenance dengan QC.


Optimum spacing PM vs diijinkannya deteriorasi
dalam kualitas output suatu proses
a. Trade off antara maintenance dengan desain sistem
(kebutuhan maintenance crew).
Keseimbangan antara biaya crew time yang idle dan
waiting time peralatan yang direpair vs job
description dari crew pada saat idle.
Maintenance sebagai suatu sistem
Industrial Engineering ITS
Industrial Engineering ITS
Decisions Variables
Industrial Engineering ITS

What to maintain ?

 Fasilitas produksi, mesin, gedung, sistem manusia mesin, dll


 Memilih item mana yang akan di maintain
 Item dikelompokkan berdasarkan :
 kontribusinya thd overall reliability dan
 pengaruhnya thd total biaya operasi.
 Tingkat pengaruh dapat diukur dengan total biaya repair
dan downtime dikombinasikan dengan biaya keterlambatan
pengiriman
Memilih item : ABC analysis
Industrial Engineering ITS

• A: critical components : jika fail


menyebabkan sistem produksi
terganggu, biaya breakdown
repair tinggi, lost production
akibat downtime --- butuh kontrol
ketat dan aktivitas maintenance
yang intensif
• B : major component : yang
menentukan performansi sistem
tapi jika fail maka produksi tidak
harus berhenti --- butuh aktivitas
dan control maintenance yang
moderate
• C : minor component : supportive
element jika fail tidak akan
mengganggu operasi --- aktivitas
maintenance yang terbatas atau
tidak formal
Memilih item : ABC analysis
Industrial Engineering ITS

• ABC analysis untuk


reliability dapat
digunakan sesuai
dengan level organisasi
dan karakteristik
komponen (ukuran,
kompleksitas, dan
interdependensi)
• Option maintenance
untuk continuous
process < flow shop <
job shop
Decisions Variables
Industrial Engineering ITS

• Siapa yang melakukan maintenance ? Internal / eksternal


• Bagaimana maintenance harus dilakukan ?
– Alternative untuk memaintain alat dengan biaya
minimum
– Inspeksi, corrective maintenance / repair, PM ?
• Dimana aktivitas maintenance dilakukan ? Centralized atau
decentralized
Output sistem maintenance
Industrial Engineering ITS

1. Jadual pelaksanaan kebijakan yang terpilih


a. Inspeksi : menaksir status peralatan dan fasilitas
b. Repair ketika breakdown terjadi, spesifikasi prioritas
dan persyaratan skill, part, dll
c. PM kapan layak dilakukan
2. Laporan
a. Status peralatan setelah inspeksi, repair, atau PM
b. Proyeksi kebutuhan spara part dan decoupling
inventory untuk pekerjaan maintenance yang sudah
dijadualkan
c. Proyeksi kebutuhan kapasitas maintenance yaitu skill
dan jam kerja yang dibutuhkan
Jumlah output yang dihasilkan tergantung pada kualitas
sistem informasi yang sekarang ada.
Pengembangan kebijakan maintenance yang baik
membutuhkan penggunaan sistem informasi
terkomputerisasi (CMMS).
Input sistem maintenance
Industrial Engineering ITS

• Input yang berupa informasi dibutuhkan


untuk menentukan kebijakan maintenance
yang paling tepat – merupakan input bagi
sistem pengambilan keputusan
maintenance
• tenaga kerja, spare part, peralatan khusus
untuk uji dan repair – diperlukan untuk
melakukan kegiatan maintenance
• Input informasi berupa history komponen
(operating time, repair yang dibutuhkan),
spare part cost dan labor cost, efek
downtime pada production lost dan/atau
delay.
Industrial Engineering ITS

Input sistem maintenance


Konstrain sistem maintenance
Industrial Engineering ITS

1. Desain sistem produksi (teknologi proses, layout,


kapasitas / crew size)
2. Aggregate planning dan keputusan capital
budgeting (allowance untuk menlakukan
decoupling inventory akan mempengaruhi
tingkat dependensi antar stage yang berurutan
dan fluktuasi jumlah maintenance crew
Kriteria performansi sistem maintenance
Industrial Engineering ITS

• Maintenance berfungsi untuk menjaga operasi sistem


produksi supaya ekonomis dan lancar
• Pemilihan kebijakan optimal dibuat berdasarkan alternatif
breakdown / corrective dan PM
• Kriteria performansi menjadi dasar penentuan keputusan
maintenance optimal
Kriteria performansi sistem maintenance
Industrial Engineering ITS
Kriteria performansi sistem maintenance
Industrial Engineering ITS
Kriteria performansi sistem maintenance
Industrial Engineering ITS
Kriteria performansi sistem maintenance
Industrial Engineering ITS
Kriteria performansi sistem maintenance
Industrial Engineering ITS

Common questions

Powered by AI

Modern maintenance techniques, such as condition monitoring and the implementation of decision support tools like FMEA, aim to proactively address potential failures, thereby improving asset performance. Organizational changes, such as team working and increasing flexibility, foster a collaborative approach to maintenance, ensuring that the right techniques are applied effectively. These methods reduce maintenance costs by preventing unexpected breakdowns and extending the service life of equipment, aligning maintenance activities with overall business strategy .

The decision to conduct maintenance activities internally or externally depends on factors like cost efficiency, available expertise, and the complexity of maintenance tasks. Internal maintenance might be preferred for cost control and when in-house expertise exists, whereas outsourcing can be chosen for specialized tasks that require higher skill levels. These decisions impact the overall maintenance strategy by influencing cost, skill development, and the quality of maintenance executed, thereby affecting the reliability and efficiency of the production process .

Maintenance systems face constraints related to production system design, such as technology, process layout, and crew size, which affect flexibility and responsiveness. Capital budgeting decisions and aggregate planning also impose constraints, influencing the level of inventory and crew availability. Performance evaluation criteria include the ability to maintain economic and smooth production operations, minimize breakdown frequency, and optimize preventive maintenance schedules. These criteria help guide decision-making to enhance system reliability and cost-effectiveness .

Maintenance strategies integrate with QC processes through systems that ensure equipment is operating optimally, thereby supporting consistent production quality. Maintenance activities like preventive maintenance are scheduled to coincide with quality control requirements to prevent deterioration that can affect product standards. This integration helps to maintain high-quality output by eliminating defects related to equipment failure, leading to improved customer satisfaction and reduced costs associated with rework and scrap .

Trade-offs in maintenance scheduling involve balancing minimum repair time against operational continuity and preventive maintenance against long operation periods. These decisions affect production efficiency by potentially increasing the frequency of breakdowns if maintenance is too interruptive or leading to higher long-term operational costs if maintenance is neglected. Additionally, integrating maintenance with aggregate planning allows for a decoupling of inventory to ease preventive maintenance, though it requires balancing with production cost minimization .

The historical evolution of maintenance practices has significantly influenced modern maintenance management strategies through several generational changes. Initially, maintenance was simplistic due to less mechanization. However, the second generation introduced preventive maintenance to minimize downtime associated with increased mechanization. In the third generation, with more complex designs, maintenance evolved to include new techniques and research, framing it as critical to safety and environmental sustainability. This historical context has led to the current focus on comprehensive maintenance strategies that incorporate technology-driven tools and a systematic approach to asset management .

Conflicts between maintenance and operational decisions arise in areas such as scheduling, where the need for equipment availability conflicts with maintenance activities leading to downtime. For example, short-term trade-offs between reducing repair time and scheduling preventive maintenance may affect long-term operational efficiency. In aggregate planning, decoupling inventory eases maintenance but might increase production costs. Long-term conflicts can also result from spacing preventive maintenance against allowing minor quality deteriorations. Resolving these conflicts requires careful balancing of cost constraints and the strategic alignment of maintenance with production goals .

The primary function of maintenance in industrial engineering is to control the condition of equipment. This function is intrinsically linked to the concepts of reliability and availability. Reliability refers to the probability that a unit will function normally when used according to specified conditions for a stated period, while availability is the probability that an item is operational at a specified time, affecting productivity and minimizing downtime. Therefore, proper maintenance ensures that equipment is reliable and available, maximizing production performance .

The ABC analysis in maintenance strategy categorizes items based on their criticality and impact on the overall system. 'A' items are critical components whose failure disrupts production significantly, requiring intensive maintenance control. 'B' items are important but do not halt production if they fail, needing moderate maintenance. 'C' items are less critical and allow for limited maintenance activities. This stratification allows resources to be allocated efficiently, focusing attention and cost on items that have the greatest impact on production reliability and cost management .

Technology plays a crucial role in developing a high-performing maintenance management system by enabling precise monitoring, analysis, and optimization of maintenance activities. Tools such as Computerized Maintenance Management Systems (CMMS) provide a robust platform for maintaining historical data, tracking maintenance activities, and optimizing the scheduling of tasks. Decision support systems, expert systems, and condition monitoring tools like PdM enhance predictive maintenance efforts, reduce downtime, and manage maintenance more cost-effectively .

You might also like