SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
GENERAL DEFINITIONS AND INFORMATION
What is “parts per million” or ppm?
In terms of water, 1 part per million or 1 ppm is equal to 1 milligram of something per liter of
water.1 It would be approximately 1 teaspoon of something in a cube of water measuring 21 feet
on all sides.
What is salinity?
Salinity is the saltiness or dissolved salt content of a body of water.2
Typical Salinity Levels in Water3 (ppm is parts per million)
drinking water - 100 ppm
restriction on drinking water - 500 ppm
limit drinking water - 1000 ppm
limit agriculture irrigation - 2000 ppm
brackish water - 500 - 30,000 ppm
sea water - 30,000 - 50,000 ppm
brine > 50,000 ppm
flowback and produced water from natural gas drilling fracking – 80,000 – 180,000 ppm
What is flowback and/or produced water?
Flowback is water that returns to the surface during the completion phase of the well (after
hydraulic fracturing). It is a mixture of the water used in the hydraulic fracturing process,
chemicals and water returning from the geological formation being drilled. Typically, the volume
of flowback water is greater during the first week after completion and through the first month. It
also has a lower salinity of up to 80,000 ppm when compared to produced water. The salinity of
seawater by comparison is 30,000 – 50,000 parts per million (ppm).
Produced water is naturally occurring wastewater from the geological formation being drilled.
The salinity of produced water may range from 80,000 to 180,000 ppm.
What is the breakdown, in gallons, of produced water and frack water from a typical gas
well?
Estimates for volumes of flowback water are variable. They reportedly range from 15-40% of the
water used in the fracturing process. Water requirements for fracturing a gas well are estimated
1
[Link]
2
[Link] accessed Dec 22, 2011
3
[Link] accessed Dec 22, 2011
Page 1 of 11
SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
from 3.5 to 5 million gallons. Highest and lowest estimates would be 525,000 to 2,000,000
gallons that would return during approximately the first month after the fracturing.
Produced water is waste water that comes out of the formation. Its volume is also variable
depending on location. Estimates are 100-1,300 gallons/day/well and declining over time.
How many gallons of water in a barrel?
42 U.S. gallons = 1 barrel
At what depth do drillers hit the Barnett Shale formation in Tarrant County?
Depth to top of Barnett is 6,500 to 8,500 feet depending on location.4
What is the thickness of the Barnett Shale formation in Tarrant County?
Thickness of the Barnett varies from 100 – 600 feet.5 Areas around Muenster to the north may
be a thick as 900 feet.
At what depth does the Ellenberger formation begin in Tarrant County?
Ellenberger depth begins at approximately 7,500 feet
What is the thickness of the Ellenberger formation in Tarrant County?
Thickness unknown as this is the layer before consolidated granite is reached. In some areas
this begins at 10,000 feet so upwards of 2500 thick.
At what depth is drilling waste water deposited?
Ellenberger begins approximately 7500 feet. The Texas Railroad Commission permits high
volume wells (e.g. daily disposal rates of 5,000 barrels or greater) into the Ellenberger by policy.
Other low volume wells could be permitted into shallower formations.
SALT WATER DISPOSAL (SWD)
Is there a current recommended ordinance to regulate SWD wells in Fort Worth?
Yes. City staff brought forward a recommendation to the City Council on December 6, 2011.
The City Council subsequently directed staff to hold a series of public meetings to receive public
input on salt water disposal as well as water use. A copy of the previously recommended
language is attached at the end of this document.
4
Hayden, J. and Purcell, D. 2005, The Barnett Shale. Visitors Guide to the Hottest Gas Play in the U.S. October 2005.
5
Hayden, J. and Purcell, D. 2005, The Barnett Shale. Visitors Guide to the Hottest Gas Play in the U.S. October 2005.
Page 2 of 11
SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
Is public notice of intended SWD wells required, or have they been exempted from
notice?
Notice is required by the City’s gas drilling ordinance for residences within 1000 feet of the well
(site) and Neighborhood Associations with ½ mile.
How many and where are SWD wells currently located in Tarrant County?
See attached map.
What is the typical cost, or cost range, of creating an SWD well in this area?
Cost is significant and vary from $2.5 million and upward depending on rate and type of facility.
For how many years can a disposal well typically receive and hold SWD fluids?
Life of a SWD well is undeterminable. Life will last as long as well bore maintains integrity.
What is the typical current distance between Tarrant County gas wells and disposal
wells?
There is no typical distance. SWD wells can share the same pad with a gas well.
What is the current total cost per gallon of depositing drilling water into an SWD well?
40 to 65 cents per barrel not including travel cost.
How much solid waste might be typically generated from a gallon of produced water?
TDS of produced water varies from 80,000 to 180,000 ppm.
1 ppm = 8.345 lbs/million gallons of water. 80,000 x 8.345/1,000,000 = 0.67 lbs/gal
180,000 x 8.345/1,000,000 = 1.5 lbs/gal
Suspended solids such as sand are not included.
How and where is solid waste disposed?
Solid waste would be disposed of at a facility approved by the Texas Railroad Commission and
the tceq such as Itasca, Texas.
TRANSPORTATION OF WASTE (TRUCKING/SALT WATER PIPELINES)
How many gallons of water does a typical waste water truck haul?
Page 3 of 11
SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
The capacity for a typical waste water truck is 190 barrels or 8,000 gallons. Weight limits on
roadway may determine actual volumes being hauled.
What is the typical hauling distance from a drill site to a recycling facility?
There is not a typical distance. Operators would desire a facility close to their operations to
minimize truck mileage and associated cost.
Please confirm that the constructors of disposal pipelines do or do not possess eminent
domain rights. Does this apply to street crossings?
Operators obtaining easement or right-of-way for salt water pipelines do not have eminent
domain authority in Texas.
Is there a City master plan for pipeline routes? If so, where can it be read?
There is no master plan for either gas or salt water pipelines. Proposed pipelines are reviewed
by city staff to determine impacts on public facilities and for the purpose of preparing license
agreements etc… Gas pipelines that are planned to go through residential developed areas are
also reviewed by a staff committee in an open meeting and require a notice to owners along the
proposed route
WATER USE/RECYCLING
What is commercial water rate that the City of Fort Worth charges a gas operator under
contract?
$6/1000 gallons
What is the current total cost per gallon of recycling drilling water?
Cost varies based on the technology used. Can be less than $1.00/bbl upwards to $5-6/bbl
Can on-site water recycling equipment (e.g., NOMAD) operate within urban drilling sites?
Yes. However, centralized treatment facilities would require larger areas of land to place
equipment. Mobile units would also require adequate space either on the well pad site or
adjacent. The feasibility of using these types of options decreases as the density of
development increases.
How many drilling water pits and/or ponds are located in Tarrant County and where are
they?
Unknown drill pits in county, 0 within the city. Freshwater ponds/pits are allowed by the City’s
gas drilling ordinance but do not contain added chemicals or drilling by products.
EARTHQUAKES
Page 4 of 11
SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
How are the fault lines that may lead to an increased potential for earthquakes
checked/monitored?
The Commission adheres to the code of Federal Regulation (146.22) part (a) (Title 40--
Protection of the Environment Chapter 1- EPA part 146-- UIC Program: Criteria and
Standards) addressing construction requirements states, "All new wells shall be sited in such a
fashion that they inject into a formation separated from any USDW (Underground Source of
Drinking Water(s) -- water typically between 3,000 and 10,000 TDS - total dissolved solids) by
a confining zone that is free of known open faults or fractures within the Area of Review (AOR)".
The AOR is a set radius around the applicant well (usually 1/4 mile) that is examined as part of
the application review process for conduits that could potentially allow injected fluids to migrate
out of the permitted injection interval.
If the Commission were to become aware of a breach in fluid confinement a permit suspension
would take place until a proper resolution is achieved.6
How does CFW staff consider and apply knowledge of existing geological fault lines
(Ouchita/Balcones) to drilling and pipeline permits?
City staff does not review or consider geologic fault lines for drilling or pipeline permits.
Jurisdiction falls under the Texas Railroad Commission.
What's in Hydraulic Fracturing Fluid?
Water and sand make up 98 to 99.5 percent of the fluid used in hydraulic fracturing. In addition,
chemical additives are used. The exact formulation varies depending on the well. 7
What Chemicals are used in the hydraulic fracturing process?
As previously noted, chemicals perform many functions in a hydraulic fracturing job. Although
there are dozens to hundreds of chemicals which could be used as additives, there are a limited
number which are routinely used in hydraulic fracturing. The following is a list of the chemicals
used most often. This chart is sorted alphabetically by the Product Function to make it easier
for you to compare to the fracturing records .
Chemical Name CAS Chemical Purpose Product Function
Hydrochloric Acid 007647-01-0 Helps dissolve minerals and initiate cracks in the Acid
rock
6
Email response, Gil Bujano, Deputy Director, Texas Railroad Commission, Oil and Gas Division’s Technical Permitting Section,
1/4/2012.
7
[Link] accessed 1-11-12
Page 5 of 11
SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
Glutaraldehyde 000111-30-8 Eliminates bacteria in the water that produces Biocide
corrosive by-products
Quaternary Ammonium 012125-02-9 Eliminates bacteria in the water that produces Biocide
Chloride corrosive by-products
Quaternary Ammonium 061789-71-1 Eliminates bacteria in the water that produces Biocide
Chloride corrosive by-products
Tetrakis Hydroxymethyl- 055566-30-8 Eliminates bacteria in the water that produces Biocide
Phosphonium Sulfate corrosive by-products
Ammonium Persulfate 007727-54-0 Allows a delayed break down of the gel Breaker
Sodium Chloride 007647-14-5 Product Stabilizer Breaker
Magnesium Peroxide 014452-57-4 Allows a delayed break down the gel Breaker
Magnesium Oxide 001309-48-4 Allows a delayed break down the gel Breaker
Calcium Chloride 010043-52-4 Product Stabilizer Breaker
Choline Chloride 000067-48-1 Prevents clays from swelling or shifting Clay Stabilizer
Tetramethyl ammonium 000075-57-0 Prevents clays from swelling or shifting Clay Stabilizer
chloride
Sodium Chloride 007647-14-5 Prevents clays from swelling or shifting Clay Stabilizer
Isopropanol 000067-63-0 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent Corrosion Inhibitor
Methanol 000067-56-1 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent Corrosion Inhibitor
Formic Acid 000064-18-6 Prevents the corrosion of the pipe Corrosion Inhibitor
Acetaldehyde 000075-07-0 Prevents the corrosion of the pipe Corrosion Inhibitor
Petroleum Distillate 064741-85-1 Carrier fluid for borate or zirconate crosslinker Crosslinker
Hydrotreated Light 064742-47-8 Carrier fluid for borate or zirconate crosslinker Crosslinker
Petroleum Distillate
Potassium Metaborate 013709-94-9 Maintains fluid viscosity as temperature increases Crosslinker
Triethanolamine 101033-44-7 Maintains fluid viscosity as temperature increases Crosslinker
Zirconate
Sodium Tetraborate 001303-96-4 Maintains fluid viscosity as temperature increases Crosslinker
Boric Acid 001333-73-9 Maintains fluid viscosity as temperature increases Crosslinker
Zirconium Complex 113184-20-6 Maintains fluid viscosity as temperature increases Crosslinker
Borate Salts N/A Maintains fluid viscosity as temperature increases Crosslinker
Ethylene Glycol 000107-21-1 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Crosslinker
Methanol 000067-56-1 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Crosslinker
Polyacrylamide 009003-05-8 “Slicks” the water to minimize friction Friction Reducer
Petroleum Distillate 064741-85-1 Carrier fluid for polyacrylamide friction reducer Friction Reducer
Hydrotreated Light 064742-47-8 Carrier fluid for polyacrylamide friction reducer Friction Reducer
Petroleum Distillate
Methanol 000067-56-1 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Friction Reducer
Page 6 of 11
SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
Ethylene Glycol 000107-21-1 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Friction Reducer
Guar Gum 009000-30-0 Thickens the water in order to suspend the sand Gelling Agent
Petroleum Distillate 064741-85-1 Carrier fluid for guar gum in liquid gels Gelling Agent
Hydrotreated Light 064742-47-8 Carrier fluid for guar gum in liquid gels Gelling Agent
Petroleum Distillate
Methanol 000067-56-1 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Gelling Agent
Polysaccharide Blend 068130-15-4 Thickens the water in order to suspend the sand Gelling Agent
Ethylene Glycol 000107-21-1 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Gelling Agent
Citric Acid 000077-92-9 Prevents precipitation of metal oxides Iron Control
Acetic Acid 000064-19-7 Prevents precipitation of metal oxides Iron Control
Thioglycolic Acid 000068-11-1 Prevents precipitation of metal oxides Iron Control
Sodium Erythorbate 006381-77-7 Prevents precipitation of metal oxides Iron Control
Lauryl Sulfate 000151-21-3 Used to prevent the formation of emulsions in the Non-Emulsifier
fracture fluid
Isopropanol 000067-63-0 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Non-Emulsifier
Ethylene Glycol 000107-21-1 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Non-Emulsifier
Sodium Hydroxide 001310-73-2 Adjusts the pH of fluid to maintains the effectiveness pH Adjusting Agent
of other components, such as crosslinkers
Potassium Hydroxide 001310-58-3 Adjusts the pH of fluid to maintains the effectiveness pH Adjusting Agent
of other components, such as crosslinkers
Acetic Acid 000064-19-7 Adjusts the pH of fluid to maintains the effectiveness pH Adjusting Agent
of other components, such as crosslinkers
Sodium Carbonate 000497-19-8 Adjusts the pH of fluid to maintains the effectiveness pH Adjusting Agent
of other components, such as crosslinkers
Potassium Carbonate 000584-08-7 Adjusts the pH of fluid to maintains the effectiveness pH Adjusting Agent
of other components, such as crosslinkers
Copolymer of Acrylamide 025987-30-8 Prevents scale deposits in the pipe Scale Inhibitor
and Sodium Acrylate
Sodium Polycarboxylate N/A Prevents scale deposits in the pipe Scale Inhibitor
Phosphonic Acid Salt N/A Prevents scale deposits in the pipe Scale Inhibitor
Lauryl Sulfate 000151-21-3 Used to increase the viscosity of the fracture fluid Surfactant
Ethanol 000064-17-5 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Surfactant
Naphthalene 000091-20-3 Carrier fluid for the active surfactant ingredients Surfactant
Page 7 of 11
SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
Methanol 000067-56-1 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Surfactant
Isopropyl Alcohol 000067-63-0 Product stabilizer and / or winterizing agent. Surfactant
2-Butoxyethanol 000111-76-2 Product stabilizer Surfactant
One of the problems associated with identifying chemicals is that some chemicals have multiple
names. For example Ethylene Glycol (Antifreeze) is also known by the names Ethylene alcohol;
Glycol; Glycol alcohol; Lutrol 9; Macrogol 400 BPC; Monoethylene glycol; Ramp; Tescol; 1,2-
Dihydroxyethane; 2-Hydroxyethanol; HOCH2CH2OH; Dihydroxyethane; Ethanediol; Ethylene
gycol; Glygen; Athylenglykol; Ethane-1,2-diol; Fridex; M.e.g.; 1,2-Ethandiol; Ucar 17; Dowtherm
SR 1; Norkool; Zerex; Aliphatic diol; Ilexan E; Ethane-1,2-diol 1,2-Ethanedio.
This multiplicity of names can make a search for chemicals somewhat difficult and frustrating.
However, if you search for a chemical by the CAS number it will return the correct chemical
even if the name on the fracturing record does not match. For example if the fracturing record
listed the chemical Hydrogen chloride and you searched for it by name using a chemical search
site you may not get a result. But if you search for CAS # 007647-01-0 it might return
Hydrochloric acid which is another name of Hydrogen chloride. Therefore, by using the CAS
number you can avoid the issue of multiple names for the same chemical.
Multiple names for the same chemical can also leave you with the impression that there are
more chemicals than actually exist. If you search the National Institute of Standards and
Technology (NIST) ‡ website the alternate names of chemicals are listed. This may help you
identify the precise chemical you are looking for. The NIST site also contains the CAS numbers
for chemicals. NIST is only one of many websites you can use to locate additional information
about chemicals. You can also search the following websites using the chemical name or CAS
number:
OSHA/EPA Occupational Chemical Database ‡
The Chemical Database ‡
EPA Chemical Fact Sheets ‡
‡ - When you click links marked with the ‡ symbol, you will leave the FracFocus website and go
to websites that are not controlled by or affiliated with this site. 8
8
[Link] accessed 1-11-12
Page 8 of 11
SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
USEFUL LINKS FOR SWD’s
Railroad Commission frequently asked questions about salt water injection wells.
[Link]
Texas Water Code pertaining to regulation of salt water injection wells.
[Link]
[Link]%2fWA%2fS%2fWA.27%40TCAS2&QueryText=injection%3cOR%3ewe
lls&HighlightType=1
EPA Information Regarding Underground Injection Wells
[Link]
Hydraulic Fracturing Chemicals
[Link]
Page 9 of 11
SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
Page 10 of 11
SALT WATER DISPOSAL TERMS AND DATA
GAS DRILLING ORDINANCE – STAFF PROPOSAL
29. Salt Water Wells. Commercial salt water disposal wells may not be permitted within the city
.limits. The city may issue a permit for a salt water disposal well when used exclusively by one operator
as identified on the Railroad Commission form W-14. All permit and notification requirements to obtain a
state permit must first be submitted to the Gas Inspector prior to the operator obtaining a state permit.
The city may then issue a permit for saltwater disposal when:
a. The salt water disposal well is located in a “J” Medium Industrial, or “K” Heavy
Industrial Zoned District;
b. Notice that an application for a permit for a salt water disposal well has been
made to the city be sent to all residences within one thousand, (1000) feet of the
site and all neighborhood associations within a one half (1/2) mile;
c. The maximum permitted sound levels conform to Section 15-42, Paragraph D.1.
Compressor Noise Regulations of this Article;
d. Access to the salt water disposal well is provided by a street(s) having an
industrial collector classification or greater;
e. The existing or planned salt water pipeline infrastructure is shown to reduce truck
traffic on city roadways;
f. A state permit is obtained from the Commission to dispose of non-hazardous oil
and gas waste by injection into a porous formation not productive of oil and gas;
g. The salt water disposal well waste is injected into the Ellenberger Formation, or
deeper;
h. The salt water disposal well is cased and cemented to the surface;
i. The disposal well permit must be approved by the City Council if the property line
of the well is located within one thousand (1,000) feet of a Protected Use;
j. The disposal well is in compliance with all conditions of the state permit;
k. The salt water disposal well site meets the requirements of Section 15.43
“Fences and Landscaping” of this Article;
l. The disposal well is in compliance with any restrictions placed on the city permit;
and
m. Tank heights are no higher than 30 feet in “J” Medium Industrial and “K” Heavy
Industrial Zoned Districts.
The City shall have the right to terminate the salt water disposal permit and require the well to be
plugged and abandoned within thirty (30) days after notice of noncompliance.
Page 11 of 11