Skip to main content ABC Home

OpenSitesmenu - use enter key to open and tab key to navigate

Log In

Search
 Science
 Space
 Nature
 Humans
 Technology
 Programs
 Just In
 Politics
 World
 Business
 Analysis
 Sport
 Science
 Health
 Arts
 Fact Check
 Other

SET LOCATIONfor local news & weather

MENU show ing mob ile menu

Science

Where do ideas come from? A mathematician ponders eureka

moments and solving complex problems
Share



 Print
 Mail
 Other share options

ABC Science

By Geordie Williamson for Ockham's Razor

Posted Wednesday at 10:47

What triggers our light-bulb moments?

(Getty images: artpartner-images)

Mathematician Geordie Williamson had a dramatic "aha moment" in a hotel shower —

and it got him thinking about where brilliant ideas come from.

In 2013 something amazing happened to me.

I had recently arrived in Beijing when, in the hotel shower, I had an experience that was as
sudden and dramatic as unexpected thunder. I was exhilarated and scared at the same time.

What happened was that an idea occurred to me.

I have had 20 or so such sudden illuminations in my life. Sadly, 90 per cent of them were wrong.
The thunderstroke of illumination, though dramatic, is often misguided, at least for mortals like
me.

Thankfully, the idea in the shower in Beijing proved to be correct. It concerned a problem that I
had devoted seven years of my work as a mathematician to. Other mathematicians had been
working on it for 30 years.

The idea concerned a highly specialised problem, and I won't be able to explain it here. What
I'm interested in is where these ideas come from, and how they fit into the way we solve
problems in mathematics.

I approach this through the lens of mathematics. I am not a psychologist, or a neurologist. I have
no idea how brains work.
Instead, I am basing my conclusions on my observations of mathematicians and the
mathematical community.

Australian mathematician Geordie Williamson is a specialist in geometric representation theory.

(Supplied: University of Sydney)

Ideas are a beautiful human experience

Remarkable ideas are what much of our modern world is built on: the wheel, the combustion
engine, the post-it note, GPS. Someone had each idea.

That ideas come out of nowhere is surely one of the most beautiful human
experiences.
The story I told you is an instance of the "eureka moment" — Archimedes was in the bath, I was
in the shower.

Most of us have had a similar experience — deep frustration while grappling with a problem or a
puzzle such as a crossword or a sudoku, followed by that sudden feeling of surprise when the
solution occurs to you.

Tackle some brain teasers

Are you up for the challenge? See how many aha moments you have!

About 50 per cent of mathematicians that I have consulted report having had this aha moment
experience. Whenever I talk to colleagues concerning eureka moments they report a similar
pattern.

Firstly, one has to work weeks, months or years without apparently progressing.

Then, if one is lucky, the idea comes during a period of relaxation, or while thinking of something
else.

A very interesting feature (to which a number of mathematicians attest) is a feeling a few days or
hours prior to the breakthrough that something is going on. It is almost as though one can hear
the rumblings of the unconscious prior to the appearance of the idea.

The slow process of sudden ideas

The picture of the eureka moment is overly simplistic, I suspect.

By way of explanation, the background details to my experience are a little more complicated
than I made out.

Firstly, prior to coming to Beijing I had been visiting a collaborator in Hong Kong. For eight days
straight, he asked me questions on this subject. He thinks about things in a very different way to
me.

To be honest, this was a frustrating experience.

Where do ideas come from?

Listen to Geordie Williamson talk about aha moments and mathematics.

However, in hindsight I have no doubt that he was pushing me to think differently. This effort to
think differently and justify everything I believed was a catalyst to its solution.

Secondly, I was later surprised to realise that the idea had been staring me in the face for over a
year, quite literally.

When I returned to my office in Bonn, Germany I was shocked to see that a calculation I had
done over a year earlier with a good friend, Ben Elias, contained the germ of my idea — I had
stuck it up on the wall of my office.

Sometimes the big idea is staring right at us!

Eureka moments are solitary, but maths is collaborative

Modern mathematics is intensely collaborative. The breakthrough which is considered 'mine'
would have been impossible without the years of collaborative work with Ben Elias, as well as
the time spent with Xuhua He in Hong Kong.

Newton famously said "If I have seen further it is by standing on the shoulders of giants".

ABC Science on YouTube

Want more science — plus health, environment, tech and more? Subscribe to our
channel.

This is truer today in mathematics than it ever has been. Consciously or unconsciously,
mathematicians have mapped out our landscape, with each mathematician responsible for
investigations in a particular corner of the landscape.

This collaborative work is probably most evident in so-called polymath projects.

This idea began in 2009 when a well-known mathematician, Tim Gowers, asked 'Is massively
collaborative mathematics possible?' on his blog.
He followed up with a problem, asking his readers to suggest possible attacks, and document
partial progress.

The project was a success, leading to two new solutions of a difficult problem. There have been
16 polymath projects to date, four of which have led to a solution of the problem they set out to
solve.

Usually mathematicians go to great effort to hide the scaffolding of their ideas. However, in this
collaborative technique everything is laid bare. One can see all the false starts, the promising
ideas, and the dead ends of real research.

The story of the eighth polymath project is particularly interesting.

Here the problem concerned gaps between prime numbers. We think, but can't prove, that there
are infinitely many "twin primes". These are pairs of prime numbers that differ by 2 —like 3 and
5; 17 and 19; 41 and 43.

Computers searches easily find millions of such twin primes, however we still don't know that
there are infinitely many.

One can ask an apparently easier question: are there infinitely many prime numbers that differ
by at most 1,000, or 1 million, or 1 billion? Even this question evaded mathematicians for
centuries.

In 2013, Yitang Zhang, working alone, had a crucial breakthrough, showing that there are
infinitely many prime numbers separated by at most 70 million.

What followed was an explosion of work attempting to understand and extend his solution.

Follow us on Facebook

Want even more science, health and tech? Join the conversation on Facebook.

A polymath project was formed, led by Australian Terry Tao, one of the best mathematicians in
the world.
 You can still read the many false starts and attempts to understand in the comments on Terry
Tao's blog.

Every day the number got smaller. After several months, and hundreds of comments by
amateurs and experts alike, 70 million was down to 4680. At this point progress slowed.

Out of the blue, came an idea from James Maynard, working alone at the Universities of Oxford
and Montreal. With rather different ideas, he was able to lower 70 million down to 600.

Finally, Professor Maynard joined Professor Tao's collaborative polymath project, and the gap
was down to 246, were progress has since stopped.

I think this story nicely sums up how mathematicians work nowadays. We are social beings, and
much of our work is collaborative.

Yet still there is room for an individual working alone to have their eureka moment.

Geordie Williamson is a Professor of Mathematics at the University of Sydney and

director of the Sydney Mathematical Research Institute.

Want more science from across the ABC?

 Like us on Facebook
 Follow us on Twitter
 Subscribe on YouTube
Science in your inbox
Get all the latest science stories from across the ABC.

Sign up

Related articles

 Scientists want to know about your 'aha moments'. Here's why

 What's happening in your brain when you have a lightbulb moment?
 Trying to boost your brain health with sudoku, sugar or even sex? Let's take a look at the
evidence

Topics
 Science and Technology

 Mathematics
 TOP SCIENCE STORIES

1.

Ancient civilisations altered the planet much more than we thought

2.

A study of almost half a million people has found there's no single 'gay gene'

3.

Ancient fossil skull discovered in Ethiopia fills critical gap in human

evolution
4.

An astrophysicist explains string theory in language you might just

understand

5.

Croc blocked! The landform that stops nuisance crocs returning home

TOP STORIES

 'Train wreck in slow motion': Tamil family's case 'hopeless', says lawyer
 'We're working very long hours': This speaker believes her $190,000 salary isn't enough
 Senior UK minister warns Government may ignore any law to stop no-deal Brexit
 I watched a sex tourist buy a boy in a Hanoi park. It was too easy
 SPORT'Call of Duty has ruined me': Nick Kyrgios knocked out of US Open by Russian Rublev
 Hong Kong trains brought to a standstill as protesters flood to airport after night of chaos
 Allegations of corruption in NSW Labor puts party in 'diabolical' situation, Albanese says
 Aurora Australis visible from Tasmania leaves southern lights chasers in awe
 'This is my first lesson': Perth man forced to land plane after instructor passes out
 NASA is scouring the outback for clues to Mars. But the evidence is being stolen
 Two left unconscious on footpath after group served 86 soju shots at Sydney Korean restaurant
  US-China trade war escalates with new tariffs
 Hundreds rally across the country calling for Tamil family to stay in Australia
 SPORTBoomers survive a scare to win World Cup opener against Canada
 SPORTFight promoter slams 'age of outrage' as he (briefly) replaces 'ring girls' with men
 Drunk driver allegedly tows burning trailer for 2 km around Adelaide streets
 SPORTTears for Coco Gauff as Naomi Osaka ends teenager's US Open run
 Cockies who can open bins are showing how animals have culture too
 SPORTThe burning questions ahead of week one of the AFL finals
 At least seven killed in Texas shootings after man hijacks postal van
 Babies in Spain develop abnormal body hair after medicine mix-up
 SPORTRaiders ruin Gallen's farewell, Tigers still in the finals hunt
 SPORT'It's not a haka': Why Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson is trying to set the record straight
 I spent the night in Australia's smallest town. Here's what I saw
 Blood cancer could soon be Australia's biggest cancer killer
 Are bad drivers adding to your long commute home?

CONNECT WITH ABC NEWS




GOT A NEWS TIP?

If you have inside knowledge of a topic in the news, contact the ABC.
 News in your inbox
Get the latest ABC News delivered to your inbox every morning and afternoon.

Sign up

More info

ABC BACKSTORY
ABC teams share the story behind the story and insights into the making of digital, TV and radio content.

EDITORIAL POLICIES
Read about our editorial guiding principles and the enforceable standard our journalists follow.

Featured Stories

FEATURES

H-Bombs and Hurricanes

Mass shootings are only the tip of the iceberg for America's gun violence problems
When it's the right time to exercise harder

The legendary Pink Ladies bow out after 20 years — so what's next?

Additional stories
TOP STORIES

 'Train wreck in slow motion': Tamil family's case 'hopeless', says lawyer
 'We're working very long hours': This speaker believes her $190,000 salary isn't enough
 Senior UK minister warns Government may ignore any law to stop no-deal Brexit
 I watched a sex tourist buy a boy in a Hanoi park. It was too easy
 SPORT'Call of Duty has ruined me': Nick Kyrgios knocked out of US Open by Russian Rublev
 Hong Kong trains brought to a standstill as protesters flood to airport after night of chaos
 Allegations of corruption in NSW Labor puts party in 'diabolical' situation, Albanese says
 Aurora Australis visible from Tasmania leaves southern lights chasers in awe
 'This is my first lesson': Perth man forced to land plane after instructor passes out
 NASA is scouring the outback for clues to Mars. But the evidence is being stolen

JUST IN

 Senior UK minister warns Government may ignore any law to stop no-deal Brexit
 SPORTBoomers survive a scare to win World Cup opener against Canada
 'Long overdue recognition' as a Victorian diocese votes to bless same-sex couples
 Hong Kong trains brought to a standstill as protesters flood to airport after night of chaos
 'We're working very long hours': This speaker believes her $190,000 salary isn't enough
 Allegations of corruption in NSW Labor puts party in 'diabolical' situation, Albanese says
 US-China trade war escalates with new tariffs
 SPORTThe burning questions ahead of week one of the AFL finals
 SPORT'Call of Duty has ruined me': Nick Kyrgios knocked out of US Open by Russian Rublev
 SPORTRaiders ruin Gallen's farewell, Tigers still in the finals hunt
 MOST POPULAR

 arti cle I watched a sex tourist buy a boy in a Hanoi park. It was too easy
 arti cle NASA is scouring the outback for clues to Mars. But the evidence is being stolen
 arti cle Aurora Australis visible from Tasmania leaves southern lights chasers in awe
 arti cle I spent the night in Australia's smallest town. Here's what I saw
 arti cle 'This is my first lesson': Perth man forced to land plane after instructor passes out
 arti cle At least seven killed in Texas shootings after man hijacks postal van
 arti cle How 'must-see' became the kiss of death for the Adam Goodes' doco
 arti cle 'Call of Duty has ruined me': Nick Kyrgios knocked out of US Open by Russian Rublev
 arti cle Two left unconscious on footpath after group served 86 soju shots at Sydney Korean restaurant
 arti cle 'It's not a haka': Why Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson is trying to set the record straight

ANALYSIS & OPINION

 SPORTRetirement unlikely, but Jeff Horn on the precipice after bad loss to Michael Zerafa
 How 'must-see' became the kiss of death for the Adam Goodes' doco
 Labor faction's walkout ploy backfires as chaotic scenes leave the Premier in the box seat
 Religion is a Liberal political plaything and it could come back to bite Morrison
 SPORTShould he stay or should he go? Rumour mill in overdrive over Adelaide's Eddie Betts
 SPORTIf the Dockers want to be an AFL 'powerhouse' they should look down the road (and
not at the Eagles)
 Four clues the Australia-China relationship has hit a rough patch
 SPORTTo avoid a repeat of 1981's capitulation, Tim Paine has to rally his troops
 The old Albo has gone missing as Labor takes path of serial retreat
 The Queen can't escape the bitter trap Johnson has set her

SITE MAP
SECTIONS

 ABC News
 Just In
 World
 Business
 Health
 Entertainment
 Sport
 Analysis & Opinion
 Weather
 Topics
 Archive
 Corrections & Clarifications
LOCAL WEATHER

 Sydney Weather
 Melbourne Weather
 Adelaide Weather
 Brisbane Weather
 Perth Weather
 Hobart Weather
 Darwin Weather
 Canberra Weather
LOCAL NEWS

 Sydney News
 Melbourne News
 Adelaide News
 Brisbane News
 Perth News
 Hobart News
 Darwin News
 Canberra News
MEDIA

 Video
 Audio
 Photos
SUBSCRIBE

 Podcasts
 Newsletters
CONNECT

 Contact Us
This service may include material from Agence France-Presse (AFP), APTN, Reuters, AAP, CNN and the BBC World
Service which is copyright and cannot be reproduced.
AEST = Australian Eastern Standard Time which is 10 hours ahead of GMT (Greenwich Mean Time)
 Terms of Use
 Privacy Policy
 Accessibility
 Contact the ABC
 © 2019 ABC