Predicting Tensile Strength in Al-TiCp FSW
Predicting Tensile Strength in Al-TiCp FSW
Technical Report
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: The usage of particulate reinforced metal matrix composite (MMC) is steadily increasing due to its prop-
Received 11 February 2010 erties such as high specific strength, high specific modulus and good wear resistance. Aluminium matrix
Accepted 28 May 2010 composite (AMC) plays an important role to meet the above requirements. Effective utilization of AMC is
Available online 2 June 2010
based on not only its production but also on fabrication methods. Among AMCs, those based on partic-
ulate reinforcements are particularly attractive, due to their lower production costs. Aluminium matrix
titanium carbide reinforced composite (Al–TiCp) was produced in an inert atmosphere by indigenously
developed Modified Stir Casting Process with bottom pouring arrangement (3–7% TiC by weight). Friction
stir welding process (FSW) is employed to make weld joints. The welding parameters such as axial force,
welding speed, tool rotational speed, percentage TiC addition etc., and profile of the tool were considered
for analysis. In this study, an attempt is made to predict ultimate tensile strength (UTS) of the welded
joints using a mathematical model. The FSW specimens without any post-weld heat treatment belonging
to a different set of parameters tested, exhibited a high joint efficiency (most of them ranging from 90% to
98%) with respect to the ultimate tensile strength of the base material AA6061. It was found from the
analysis of the model that the tool pin profile and the welding speed have more significant effect on ten-
sile strength.
Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0261-3069/$ - see front matter Ó 2010 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/[Link].2010.05.055
S. Gopalakrishnan, N. Murugan / Materials and Design 32 (2011) 462–467 463
decides the coefficient of friction. Hence, axial force plays a signif- Properties Materials
icant role in friction stir welding process. Ouyang and Kovacevic [5] AA6061 TiC
observed that the plunge depth of tool pin inside the work piece is
Melting point in °C 670 3065
based on axial force. Kumar et al. [6,7] studied the role of axial load Density in kg/m3 2700 4940
on tensile strength of friction stir welded aluminium alloys. Forg- Yield strength in MPa 241 at T6 condition 114 at 980 °C
ing occurs under the axial pressure applied by the tool shoulder.
FSW joints avoid the formation of shrinkages and porosity which
is more common in fusion welds, as well as segregation of the cera-
mic reinforcement. They significantly reduce the thermal stresses erated and machine table is moved at a predetermined welding
[8]. Since there is no melting during FSW, problems associated speed. Axial force is applied through the shoulder of the tool. It
with liquid solid reactions are completely eliminated. Literature is measured continuously and displayed throughout the process.
shows that [9] using FSW process, better tensile properties are ob- The surface temperature at the tool, work interface is monitored.
tained by using square tool pin profile on aluminium alloys irre- When the plunged tool pin approaches nearer to the other end,
spective of other welding parameters used. In this study, an the entire tool is retracted. The rotating tool pin along with the
attempt has been made to produce Al–TiCp in a cost effective shoulder during its travel produces frictional heat with tempera-
way by indigenously developed stir casting process. FSW is used ture below the melting point, and plastic deformation due to the
to join Al–TiCp plates autogenously. The effect of various friction stirring of the material around the pin, forming the weld [11,12].
stir weld parameters on UTS was studied using Design of Experi- This process is repeated for all welding trails as per the design ma-
ment (DoE). trix shown in Table 3. Totally 32 weld trails have been conducted.
Specimen is prepared as per standard metallurgical procedure
to identify the existence of different zones in FSW as shown in
2. Experimental work
Fig. 3 (metallurgical effect caused by the tool). Specimens for
microstructural analysis are also prepared as per standard metallo-
Chemical composition and mechanical properties of both Alu-
graphic procedure. Microstructure analysis is carried out at various
minium and TiC are provided in Tables 1 and 2. AA6061 T6 mate-
portions of the specimen’s cross-section using colour metallo-
rial in extruded form is in heat treated and solution hardened
graphic study to analyze the effect of various welding parameters.
condition. TiC having particle size less than 2 lm was supplied
Typical microstructure of different zones of FS welded AMC is
by M/s. Alfa Aesar (India). AMC reinforced with TiC is produced
shown in Figs. 4 and 5.
by Modified Stir Casting Process with bottom pouring arrangement
Three samples of tensile test specimens are cut in the direction
in an argon atmosphere. TiC addition varied from 3% to 7%. In the
normal to the weld in each of 32 welded plates and machined as
above process, problems associated with the conventional stir cast-
per ASTM E08 standards [13]. Their tensile strength is estimated
ing process such as reaction of molten aluminium with atmo-
using a Universal Testing Machine, Model TUE-C-1000 manufac-
sphere, improper mixing of particulate and difficulty associated
tured by M/s. Fine Spray Associates & Engineers Pvt. Ltd., India,
with material pouring are drastically reduced. Two step stirring
at room temperature. The average tensile strength was found and
is employed to ensure better mixing. Magnesium is added to im-
it is listed in Table 3. Joint efficiency is calculated by comparing
prove the wettability. It is found from the characterization of
UTS of a specimen with that of parent metal of aluminium AA6061.
AMC that specific strength improved as the addition of TiC in-
creased [10]. Undesired portions of the castings such as runner
and raiser are removed by machining. Visual inspection is carried 2.1. Development of mathematical model
out to find out the presence of surface defects. Plates of size
100 mm 50 mm 6 mm are prepared from cast AMC blocks Design matrix as shown in Table 3 is a five level five factor 1/2
using wire cut EDM process for the weld trail. factorial design consisting of 32 weld trails at coded condition. All
Square butt joint configuration is formed to make FSW joints. welding variables at their intermediate level (0) constitute the cen-
The prepared plates are held firmly by a fixture. Single pass weld- tre points and combination of each of the welding variables at
ing procedure is employed. In this study, tool profiles such as taper either lowest (2) or highest (+2) with other three variables
square, taper hexagon, taper octagon, square, and hexagon as (+1, 0, 1) at intermediate levels. Experiments are conducted as
shown in Fig. 1 are used and its effect on tensile strength are ana- per design matrix at random to avoid errors. The response function,
lysed. Factors such as percentage TiC (P) welding speed (S) in mm/ ultimate tensile strength of the joints is a function of P, S, N, F, and T
s, tool rotational speed in rpm (N) axial force in kN (F) and five tool which can be expressed as
profiles (T) as shown in Fig. 1 are considered for this study. The tool UTS ¼ f ðP; S; N; F; TÞ
pin profiles used are selected and its levels are fixed based on the
ratio of swept volume to static volume.
Fig. 2 shows the FSW machine employed for the present inves- The second order polynomial (regression) equation used to rep-
tigation. Parameters are set after welding trails. Weld trails are resent the response surface ‘Y’ for k parameter is given by
conducted at random as per DoE. A rotated, non-consumable tool X
k X
k X
k
pin made of high carbon high chromium steel is plunged into the Y ¼ b0 þ bi X i þ bii X 2i þ bij X i X j
abutting surfaces until the shoulder touches the surfaces of the i¼1 i¼1 i–j
work material. After a brief dwell period, the required heat is gen-
The selected polynomial for five factors could be expressed as
a b c d e
Fig. 1. Tool pin profiles used in FSW: (a) hexagon, (b) taper square, (c) taper hexagon, (d) square, and (e) taper octagon.
Table 3
Design matrix and measured UTS.
UTS; MPa ¼ 183:024 9:335T þ 1:157P 4:816S 1:389F is a source for multiple nucleations. The grain refining nature of TiC
particles may reduce the degree of clustering commonly observed
þ 7:279P2 þ 7:973F 2 þ 9:199T 2 þ 6:943ST ð2Þ in cast MMC. In general, the microstructure of friction stir weld is
classified into three major regions namely, weld nugget (WN) as
shown in Fig. 4b, Thermo Mechanically Affected Zone (TMAZ)
3. Microstructure shown in 5a and b and Heat Affected Zone (HAZ). The weld nugget
is characterized by severely deformed and dynamically recrystal-
The welds are characterized by Optical Microscopy (OM) to lized region [14]. Weld nugget composed of fine-equiaxed recrys-
investigate the micro structural modifications induced by the tallized grains. The fine recrystallized zone at the weld nugget is
FSW process on the aluminium alloy matrix and TiC reinforcement due to heavy plastic deformation followed by dynamic recrystalli-
particles. Optical micrographs of the cross-section of the FSW zation occurred during thermo-mechanical processing. TMAZ,
joints are observed in bright field after polishing the specimen ini- which is adjacent to the weld nugget exhibits a similar microstruc-
tially with fine emery up to 1200 grade and finally with fine finish- ture both at the retreating and advancing sides of the base compos-
ing using diamond paste. Microstructure of parent material is seen ite. It has been plastically deformed and thermally affected. TMAZ
in Fig. 4a. It shows the effect of Ti, which act as a grain refiner. TiAl3 exhibits highly elongated grains of Al alloy matrix on both sides
S. Gopalakrishnan, N. Murugan / Materials and Design 32 (2011) 462–467 465
Micrograph of TMAZ
region is displayed in
Fig.5b
HAZ HAZ
Parent material
Fusion
zone
10 mm
location in the joint and the joint is fractured at this interface dur-
ing the tensile testing. This result is sufficient to indicate that the
tensile strength on the advancing side is lower than that on the
retreating side. In contrast, the joints of 6061-T6 aluminium alloys
are fractured on the retreating side instead of the advancing side
[17], showing that the different types of aluminium alloys demon-
strate different fracture characteristics.
TMAZ
Elongated
grains
10µm
a
TMAZ
Elongated
grains
10µm
Fig. 5. Microstructure of (a) parent material – TMAZ and (b) TMAZ – parent material.
Fig. 6. Graph shows the effect of % TiC addition in aluminium matrix on UTS.
Fig. 8. Graph shows the effect of axial force on UTS. UTS values are lower in
between 11 kN and 16 kN.
Fig. 7. Graph shows the effect of welding speed on UTS. UTS value decreases with
increasing welding speed.
Fig. 10. Graph shows the interaction effect of tool pin profile and welding speed on UTS.
hexagonal tool. This is because as the number of sides increase the also thankful to Prof. C. Narayanan, Prof. V. Radhakrishnan,
hexagonal tool almost behaved like a cylindrical tool. In earlier Mr. S.J. Vijay, and Mr. Palanivelu for their assistance.
observations [9] it is found that the cylindrical tool produces min-
imum weld joint efficiency when compared with other tool References
profiles.
[1] Altinkok Necat, Koker Rasit. Modelling of the prediction of tensile and density
properties in particle reinforced metal matrix composites by using neural
4.5. Interaction effect of tool profile and welding speed on UTS networks. Mater Des 2006;27:625–31.
[2] Storjohann D, Babu SS, David SA, Sklad P. In: Report U.S. department of energy,
The interaction effect of tool profile and welding speed on UTS office of heavy vehicle technology and office of transportation under contract
number DE-ACO5-000R22725 with UT-Battelle LLC; 2002. p. 1–4. <http://
is depicted in Fig. 10. Maximum UTS is produced at 0.5 mm/s by ta- [Link]/conferences/abstracts/2003/[Link]>.
per square tool. As the welding speed increased the UTS values of [3] Clyne TW, Withers PJ. An introduction to metal matrix
taper square tool and square tool decreased. This may be due to the composites. UK: Cambridge University Press; 1993.
[4] Oosterkamp A, Oosterkamp Djapic, Nordeide A. Kissing bond phenomena in
fact that at higher speeds the tool drags without proper mixing of solid state welds of aluminium alloys. Weld J 2004:225s–31s.
material on both sides. Its UTS value is observed minimum at [5] Ouyang JH, Kovacevic R. Material flow during friction stir welding of the same
2.25 mm/s. In contrast, hexagonal and taper octagonal tool pro- and dissimilar aluminium alloys. J Mater Eng Perform 2002;11(1):51–63.
[6] Cavaliere P, Panella F. Effect of tool position on the fatigue properties of
duced maximum UTS at 2.25 mm/s and its value is more than that
dissimilar 2024-7075 sheets joined by friction stir welding. J Mater Process
of the taper square tool. This may be due to the extrusion effect Technol 2008;206:249–55.
caused by these tools at higher welding speeds. The above trends [7] Kumar K, Kailas Satish V. On the role of axial load and the effect of interface
position on the tensile strength of a friction stir welded aluminium alloy.
clearly indicate that tool profiles as well as welding speed have
Mater Des 2008;29:791–7.
more influence on UTS. [8] Ceschini L, Boromei I, Minak G, Morri A, Tarterini F. Effect of friction stir
welding on microstructure, tensile and fatigue properties of the AA7005/
10 vol.% Al2O3p composite. Compos Sci Technol 2007;67:605–15.
5. Conclusion [9] Elangovan K, Balasubramanian V. Influences of pin profile and rotational speed
of the tool on the formation of friction stir processing zone in AA2219
Problems associated with the fusion welding of aluminium ma- aluminium alloy. Mater Sci Eng – A 2007;459:19–34.
[10] Gopalakrishnan S, Murugan N. Production of aluminium matrix TiCp
trix TiCp particulate reinforced composite were solved by using a composite by modified stir casting process. World J Eng; in press.
solid state process known as FSW process. Joint efficiency obtained [11] Thomas WM. Friction stir welding. International Patent Application No. PCT/
in most of the weld trails are more than 90%. A mathematical mod- GB92/02203 and GB Patent Application No. 9125978.8. US Patent No.
5:1991:460,317.
el has been designed to predict the tensile strength of the friction
[12] Elangovan K, Balasubramanian V, Babu S. Predicting tensile strength of friction
stir welded aluminium matrix TiCp particulate reinforced compos- stir welded AA6061 aluminium alloy joints by a mathematical model. Mater
ite. It is found that the tool pin profile has maximum effect on ten- Des 2009;30:188–93.
sile strength of friction stir welded joints followed by welding [13] ASTM-E08-04. Standard test method for tension testing of metallic materials.
Annual book of ASTM standards 2006, Section 3, vol. 03.01. Metals Test
speed. On the other hand from the developed model it is found that Methods and Analytical Procedure. p. 90.
the tool rotational speed has insignificant effect on UTS. [14] Su JQ, Nelson TW, Mishra R, Mahoney M. Microstructural investigation of
friction stir welded 7050-T651 aluminium. Acta Mater 2003;51 A(3):713–29.
[15] Liu HJ, Fujii H, Maeda M, Nogi K. Tensile properties and fracture locations of
Acknowledgements friction-stir welded joints of 6061-T6 aluminum Alloy. J Mater Sci 2003 [Letter
22].
The authors wish to place their sincere thanks to Naval Re- [16] Lomolino S, Tovo R, Dos Santos J. On the fatigue behaviour and design curves of
friction stir butt welded Al alloys. Int J Fatigue 2005;27:305–16.
search Board, DRDO, Govt. of India for funding to purchase Fric- [17] Colligan J, Konkol Paul J, Fisher James J, Pickens Joseph R. Friction stir welding
tion Stir Welding Machine, (vide funded project; Ref No. DNRD/ demonstrated for combat vehicle construction. Weld J 2002:1–6.
05/4003/NRB/85 Dated 30.10.2006,) and All India Council for [18] Tyagi Rajnesh. Synthesis and tribological characterization of in situ cast Al–TiC
composites. Wear 2005;259:569–76.
Technical Education (AICTE), New Delhi for funding the material [19] Strombeck AV, Santos JFD, Torster F, Laureano P, Kocak M. Fracture toughness
purchase (vide funded Project; File No. 8023/BOR/RID/RPS-195/ behaviour of FSW joints on aluminum alloys. In: Proceedings of the first
[Link] 05.03.2008). Authors are grateful to Department international symposium on friction stir welding, Paper No. S9-P1, California,
USA. TWI Ltd.; June 1999.
of Mechanical Engineering, Coimbatore Institute of Technology,
[20] Sato YS, Kokawa H, Enomoto M, Jogan S. Microstructural evolution of 6063
Coimbatore, India for extending the facilities of Welding Re- aluminum during friction-stir welding. Metall Mater Trans A
search Laboratory to carry out this investigation. Authors are 1999;30:2429–37.