July 11, 02

In the beginning…
…the Earth was without form, and void; and
darkness was on the face of the deep.
The Evolution of E-Commerce

History Repeats Itself (again)

Daniel V. Klein
dan@[Link]

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 1 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 2

Where E-commerce began

• Telegraph (demonstrated in 1844) spread
with the railroads in the mid 1800’s
– Coast-to-coast by 1861
– Ordering goods and services remotely
– Wire transfer of funds (backed by physical
transit later on by Express)
– The promise of goods and of payment
• Transatlantic Cables – 1857-1866

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 3 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 4

Electronic Genesis Checks & Credit Cards

• Until very recently, only computer people • In the early 19th Century, there were
had computers cheques
• Started to change in the 1980’s • Credit cards only started to
become widely accepted in
• Paradigm shift in 1995 – the World Wide the 1950’s
Web

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 5 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 6

The Evolution of E-Commerce 1

 July 11, 02

Evolution & Natural Selection

• Natural selection works in nature
• It also works in computers & business
– Digital Equipment Corporation
– Microsoft
– Linux

• It also works in politics and e-commerce

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 7 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 8

Church and State You’ll do it my way

• Taxation is okay • Big companies try to set rules
– You have to pay for armies
• Killing is okay • Need special accounts with special banks,
everyone uses my bank (or pay extra)
– They are infidels
• Theft is okay • Special hardware attached to your computer
– Spoils of war
• Place order online, call company with credit
• Lending money at interest is bad card information, exchange PIN numbers
– A venial sin!

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 9 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 10

Company Store, Company Scrip Cybercash / Cyberwallet

• People work, are paid in company scrip
• You buy cyberdollars with real dollars
• Can use scrip to shop at company store
• Clients buy services with cyberdollars
• Scrip has theoretical cash value
• Companies accept cyberdollars as payment
– Cannot readily exchange for dollars
– Company store engages in price gouging • Companies sell cyberdollars to get real dollars
– Employees are slaves
• Transaction fees when you exchange

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 11 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 12

The Evolution of E-Commerce 2

 July 11, 02

Private Banks Cryptography

• In 17th – 19th centuries, banks were private • Secure communication is the key
• Uninsured • Security is keeping a secret
– If your bank was robbed, you lost your money – Can you hear it?
– If your bank folded or absconded, you lost – Can you understand it?
– Can you reproduce it?
• Largely unrelated
– No ATMs, elaborately coded letters of credit

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 13 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 14

Purchasing Agents First Virtual

• You hire agent, give letter of credit • Client signs up with credit card
– By telephone
• Agent goes on road
– Sees goodies • When buying, submits form
– Sends samples – Server sends email to FV
– You send okay – FV sends email to client
– Buys on credit, ships goodies – Client sends email to FV
– Credit cleared later – FV sends email to server
– (Can view product before paying!)

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 15 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 16

Industrial Revolution E-Commerce Revolution

• You make stuff, you want to sell it • If you want to sell, you need a merchant
account
• Unless you are big, you get robbed
– Have to be big, need credit history, nope - sell
– Hire thugs on trust, send me a check, get screwed
– Cost of doing business – Don’t have to be big, just pay a lot, hard to
interface to banks
• Unless you are big, transactions are small
– and local or highly specialized • Wholesalers
– Have merchant account, take 15%, take risks
• Wholesalers / retailers – Enable lower class to sell to world
July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 17 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 18

The Evolution of E-Commerce 3

 July 11, 02

Same Problems, Different People What’s Next?

• Large number of credit card wholesalers • Microtransactions
– Requires lots of work – Pay as you go (or use)
– Requires lots of security – Utility service analogy
– Rent with utilities included
• Mergers and acquisitions
• Currently not cost effective
• Survival of the fittest, fattest, fastest – Credit card transactions too expensive
– Tracking and reporting issues

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 19 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 20

So, nu?
• There is no difference between commerce
and e-commerce
• Electronic transactions are just a different
type of payment
• Protocols have to fit human needs and
human models – not the other way around
• Your customers are not geniuses

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 21 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 22

Okay, what is for sale? Physical

• Physical media • Barnes & Noble, [Link], LandsEnd,
– Books, parts, cars, music, antiques, junque, etc. Clinique, Camera World
• Virtual media • [Link], [Link], [Link],
– Programs, memberships, searches, greeting [Link], [Link], [Link]
cards, money, etc. • [Link], [Link]
• Advertising
– Anyone can be a publisher!

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 23 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 24

The Evolution of E-Commerce 4

 July 11, 02

Virtual Media Advertising

• Anyone can advertise!
• Sell once
– Selling ads is main motivation
– Buy a program (or picture, or license) of free sites
• Sell repeatedly (monthly/annually) – Not all ads are banners!
– Buy a membership in a site • Different payment schemes
– Mainly adult-site memberships, others exist – Per-impression
• Sell sporadically (access/use) – Per-click
– Buy information per search – Per-sale
– Moving money (PayPal, IBill)

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 25 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 26

Paying for Ads Two Distinct Marketplaces

• Per-impression • “Adult”
– Fairest to advertiser (bandwidth costs), but advertiser – 5–15% click-through rate
must trust publisher
– 0.1–1% conversion rate
• Per-click
– Fairest to both (both can track traffic, publisher can pull
– Lots of traffic from little advertisers
unsuccessful ads), but susceptible to abuse by both • “Mainstream”
sides (click-bots and trimming by “uniques”)
– 0.25–1% click-through rate
• Per-conversion
– 2–10% conversion rate
– Fairest to advertiser (pay only for results), but publisher
must trust advertiser – Most traffic through big advertisers

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 27 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 28

Payment Schemes Simple Click-bot

#!/usr/bin/ perl
• Per Impression
use HTTP::Request;
– Only way on big mainstream advertisers use LWP::UserAgent;
• Per Click
$ua = new LWP:: UserAgent;
– Few adult sites use it any more – lots of abuse $ua->agent(" Mozilla /4.76");
$req = new HTTP::Request(GET =>
– Many mainstream sites use it "[Link]
• Per Conversion
while (1) {
– Mainstream and adult $ua->request($ req);
sleep int rand 16;
}

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 29 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 30

The Evolution of E-Commerce 5

 July 11, 02

Per-Conversion Payment Not the end…

• Different pay-out schemes (depending on • Information super-highwayman
business being advertised) – New kinds of sales
– Per-referral fee – New kinds of commerce
– Per-signup fee – New kinds of theft
• A fraction of sales – Different kinds of insurance
– One-time
– Recurring
– Adaptive restrictions
• A fraction of anticipated sales • Back to the Wild West!

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 31 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 32

It was the best of times, it was the

Mainstream Sites - 1 day use
worst of times.
• Instant gratification
– Assessing customer feedback
– Assessing ad effectiveness
• Loss of privacy
– Voluntary loss
– Involuntary loss
• Loss of anonymity
• Big Brother is already watching you!
July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 33 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 34

Mainstream Sites - 1 week use Adult Sites - 1 day use

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 35 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 36

The Evolution of E-Commerce 6

 July 11, 02

Adult Sites - 1 week use Adult Sites - 1 month use

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 37 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 38

So… what’s next?

• Read science fiction!
– Chester Gould (<1935) – wrist radio
– Frederick Pohl (1965) – joymaker
– John Brunner (1974) – information society
– Robert Heinlein (1959) – computer immersion

– implanted computers, crypto, global networks,

intelligent agents, nanobots…

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 39 July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 40

The Evolution of E-Commerce

History Repeats Itself (again)

Daniel V. Klein
dan@[Link]

July 11, 02 The Evolution of E-Commerce 41

The Evolution of E-Commerce 7