BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
Topic 1
Relevant guidance
INTRODUCTION TO ISA/VSA 200 Overall objectives of the independent auditor and the conduct
of an audit in accordance with ISAs
Law on Independent Audit No 67/2011/QH12
ASSUARANCE & FS
AUDITING
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 2
LEARNING OBJECTIVES CONTENT
Upon completion of this chapter you will
• Understand the nature of assuarance & auditing services Definition of Assurance and Auditing
• Be able to distinguish different types of audits and
auditors. Classification of audit
• Know the development of audit profession.
• Understanding the reasons giving rise to demand for The develoment of audit profession
financial statement audit.
• Understand the professional requirements of auditors and The roles of independent audit in the economy
audit firms and be able to describe internal structure of
an audit firm. Auditor, Audit firms and Professional bodies
3 4
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH
1
BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
WHAT ARE ASSURANCE 1. WHAT IS AUDIT?
SERVICES?
Assurance services: a broad range of independent professional services
that improve the quality of information, or its context, for decision makers. Entrust resources
enhance the degree of confidence in the information
2 types: Investors Managers
◦ Attestation services increase the reliability of info
◦ Other assurance services put info in a form or context that facilitates Required periodic reporting
decision making. on use of resources
Attestation services including
◦ Audit/examination
Verification by independent expert
◦ Review
◦ Agreed-upon procedures a demand for auditing
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 5 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 6
1. What is Auditing? 1. What is Auditing?
Auditing has been defined as: Assertions about
economic actions and
“A systematic process of objectively obtaining and evaluating events
evidence regarding assertions about economic actions and
events to ascertain the degree of correspondence between
Independent
those assertions and established criteria and communicating and
obtaining and Degree of Issuance of audit
evaluating correspondence report
the results to interested users.” competent evidence
auditor
A statement of Basis Auditing Concepts (ASOBAC)
Established criteria
7
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 8
2
BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
2. Audit classification 2.1. Types of audits
Operational audit Operational audit
AUDITS Compliance audit AUDITS
Financial statement audit
AUDIT AUDIT
CLASSIFICATION CLASSIFICATION
Internal auditors
Operational audit: value for money audit, performance audit or
AUDITORS Government auditors efficiency audit. Chủ thể
Operational audit is a more comprehensive activity designed to
Independent/External analyze organization structure, internal systems, work flow and
auditors
managerial performance.
It is usually associated with issues of efficiency, effectiveness and
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 9 2018 economy. BICH PHAM - UEH 10
2.1. Types of audits [Link] of audits
Operational audit Operational audit
AUDITS AUDITS Compliance audit
AUDIT AUDIT
CLASSIFICATION CLASSIFICATION
•A systematic review of part or all of an organization’s activities to Determine the extent to which rules, policies, laws, covenants, or
evaluate whether resources are being used effectively and government regulations are followed by the entities being audited
efficiently Chủ thể Chủ thể
e.g., examination of tax returns of individuals or companies by the
•Assess performance, identify area for improvement, and develop tax authorities
recommendations
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 11 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 12
3
BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
[Link] of audits 2.2. Types of auditors
Operational audit
•Are the employees of the entities being audited
AUDITS Compliance audit
•Conduct financial, internal control, compliance, operational and
forensic audits within their organization Operational audit
Financial statement
audit •Provide assurance and consulting services to their entities
AUDIT
AUDITS Compliance audit
CLASSIFICATION
Financial statement
• To obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial audit
Chủ thể material misstatement, AUDIT
report as a whole is free from CLASSIFICATION
whether due to fraud or error, thereby enabling the auditor to
express an opinion on whether the financial report is prepared, Internal auditor
in all material respects, in accordance with an applicable
financial reporting framework. AUDITORS
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 13 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 14
2.2. Types of auditors 2.2. Types of auditors
• May practice as sole proprietor or as a member of a CPA/audit
firm
Operational audit
•Are employed by government agencies • Are not the employees of the entities being audited
•Tax officers, State Auditors, Government Inspectors, … • Provide a range of both assurance and non-assurance
Operational audit AUDITS Compliance services
audit
to their clients
AUDITS Compliance audit Financial statement audit
AUDIT
CLASSIFICATION
Financial statement audit Internal auditor
AUDIT
CLASSIFICATION
Internal auditor AUDITORS Government auditor
AUDITORS Government auditor Independent/External
auditor
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 16
15
4
BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
3. History and development of audit profession in
the world 3. The development of audit
Before 1900 From 1900 until now profession in Vietnam
Objective Detect error and Give an opinion about the true
1991: the first two local audit firms, namely VACO and AASC were established
fraud of staff and fair of accounting figure
1999: the first series of 6 VSAs were issued.
Method The detailed Auditing approach where not
verification of all transactions had to be
every transaction tested- Audit sampling Till 30 May 2005, there are 33 VSAs issued, most of which were closely
Accessing the internal control adapted from ISAs.
system
Audited in Informatic 2012: Law on Independent Audit No 67/2011/QH12 took effect.
environment
2012: 2005’s VSAs were replaced by a new set of VSAs.
Extent audit approach to risk
based approach
Until now, MOF has issued a total of 47 new standards on Auditing and
User Owner Stakeholder, Investor, Debtor,
Bank… Assurance services.
17
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 18
4. The roles of external audit in the economy
International Audit firms - BIG4
Entrust resources
Investors Managers
Required periodic reporting
on use of resources
Verification by independent expert
19
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 20
5
BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
4. The roles of external audit in the economy 4. The roles of external audit in the economy
• The difficulty in accessing information
Information is resources
• The motivation of informant
likely to be RISK • The large volume and complexity of
distorted. information
What measures
The users directly check the information
should be MEASURES
taken? Strengthen the legal responsibility of the
Board of Directors
Compulsory audited financial statements
21 22
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 21 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH
5. Auditors, Audit firms and Professional bodies 5. Auditor, Audit firms and Professional bodies
a. External auditors Certified Public Accountant (CPA)
An auditor must meet the following standards (Article 14 - Law on
Independent Audit):
Qualification a) Having full capacity for civil acts;
Experience
b) Having good professional ethics, sense of responsibility, integrity,
honesty, and objectivity;
CPA c) Having degree of university or higher in finance, banking,
accounting, auditing disciplines or other disciplines as prescribed by
the Ministry of Finance;
d) Having an auditor’s certificate in accordance with regulations the
Ministry of Finance.
EXTERNAL AUDITORS
23
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 24
6
BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
5. Auditor, Audit firms and Professional bodies 5. Auditor, Audit firms and Professional bodies
Certified Public Accountant Certified Public Accountant
Conditions for the candidates: (Circular No 129/2012/TT-BTC ) Candidates for Audit practitioner certificates must take the tests on
7 subjects:
- Professionally ethical, honest, upright, and law-abiding;
- Having the Bachelor’s degree or higher in finance, banking, accounting,
1. Economic law and the Law on Enterprise;
2. Advanced finance and financial management;
audit;
3. Advanced tax and tax administration;
- Having worked in finance or accounting for at least 60 months from the
4. Advanced public sector accounting, financial accounting;
month of graduation written on the higher education graduation decision at 5. Advanced audit and assurance services;
the time of exam registration; or having worked as an audit assistant in an 6. Advanced financial analysis;
audit enterprise for at least 48 months from the month of graduation 7. C-level qualification in one of the following foreign languages:
written on the higher education graduation decision at the time of exam English, Russian, French, Chinese, German.
registration; The candidates that pass all 7 subjects, and the total mark (except of
- Completely and correctly submit the exam application and fee as prescribed. foreign language subjects) is 38 or more, are considered passed.
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 25 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 26
5. Auditor, Audit firms and Professional bodies SERVICES PROVIDED BY AUDIT FIRMS
b. Audit firms •Assurrance service Audit
Review
Other assurance services
Partner
•Related services Agreed-upon procedures regarding
financial information
Manager •Tax consultance Compilation of financial information
Tax consultancy/ Tax planning
Senior •Management consultance Financial consultancy/ Strategy
development
•Others Education/ Training
Staff Assistant
Head hunter
Career Path
27
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 28
7
BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
5. Auditor, Audit firm and Professional bodies 5. Auditor, Audit firm and Professional bodies
Professional Organizations in Vietnam Professional Organizations in the world
The Vietnam Association of Certified Public Accountants (VACPA)
established on 15/04/2005 and started to operate from International Federation of Accountants (IFAC) is the global
01/01/2006. organization for the accountancy profession dedicated to
68th member of the Vietnam Union of Science and
serving the public interest by strengthening the
Technology Associations (VUSTA)
Member of the Confederation of Asian and Pacific profession and contributing to the development of strong
Accountants (CAPA) since 2010 international economies.
Member of the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC)
on 11 November 2015.
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 29 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 30
5. Auditor, Audit firm and Professional bodies 5. Auditor, Audit firm and Professional bodies
Professional Organizations in Vietnam Professional Organizations in the world
The Vietnam Association of Certified Public Accountants (VACPA)
established on 15/04/2005 and started to operate from International Federation of Accountants (IFAC) is the global
01/01/2006. organization for the accountancy profession dedicated to
68th member of the Vietnam Union of Science and
serving the public interest by strengthening the
Technology Associations (VUSTA)
Member of the Confederation of Asian and Pacific profession and contributing to the development of strong
Accountants (CAPA) since 2010 international economies.
Member of the International Federation of Accountants (IFAC)
on 11 November 2015.
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 31 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 32
8
BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
5. Auditor, Audit firm and Professional bodies
Professional Organizations in the world 5. Auditor, Audit firm and Professional bodies
Boards and Committees of IFAC:
Professional Organizations in the world
International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB)
International Accounting Education Standards Board (IAESB) The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA)
International Ethics Standards Board for Accountants (IESBA) - 1887, the American Association of Public Accountants (AAPA)
Professional Accountants in Business Committee (PABC) was formed.
International Public Sector Accounting Standards Board (IPSASB) - 1917, the name was changed to the American Institute of
Transnational Auditors Committee (TAC) Accountants
Compliance Advisory Panel (CAP) - 1957, it changed to its current name of the American Institute
Professional Accountancy Organization Development Committee of Certified Public Accountants
(PAODC)
Small and Medium Practices Committee (SMPC)
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 33 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 34
6. The process of a financial statement 6. The process of a financial statement
audit audit
Planning
Pre-planning
Completing &
Planning Performing Procedures to accept or continue relationship with clients
Reporting
Assess compliance with ethical requirements, including independence.
Understand the terms of the audit engagement.
Understanding
Pre-planning and assessing Reviewing Planning
internal control Obtain a basis understanding of the business background and internal
control system.
Tests of control Determine materiality level & perform audit risk assessment:
Auditor’s
Planning and Tests of
report Prepare an audit program which outlines the nature, timing and extent of
details
audit procedures required to gather evidence.
36
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 35 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH
9
BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
6. The process of a financial statement 6. The process of a financial statement
audit audit
Performing Performing
•Tests of controls are tests designed to obtain reasonable assurance that internal
Risk assessment procedures; controls are in place and effective.
•Substantive procedures are designed to obtain evidence as to the
completeness, accuracy, and validity of the data produced by the accounting
Subsequent audit procedures: system. These tests aim to detect material misstatements on financial
statements.
oTests of control.
oSubstantive tests includes Substantive Analytical
procedures and Tests of details.
37
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 38
6. The process of a financial statement 6. The process of a financial statement
audit audit
Completing and reporting Completing
Reviewing: Auditor’s report
•Was the collected audit evidence sufficient to provide an opinion? Issue auditor’s reports
◦Unmodified Opinion
•Have the aggregated effect of unadjusted audit differences been below the ◦Qualified Opinion
acceptable level? ◦Adverse Opinion
•Is the audit working paper complete? ◦Disclaimer of Opinion
•In general, the financial situation and business results are reasonable?
Resolve events occurring after issuing the auditor’s report
39 40
2018 BICH PHAM - UEH 2018 BICH PHAM - UEH
10
BICH PHAM - UEH - ISB 5/22/2018
THANKS FOR
YOUR LISTENING
11