Table 1
Summary of Criteria
WEIGHTS
BRGY.
NO. CRITERIA LGU Std.
MPDO MEHO SWM Average
C&G Deviation
CHAIR.
Quantity of
C1 Solid Wastes .3 .1 .1 .2 0.18 0.08
for Disposal
C2 Area Covered .2 .1 .2 .3 0.20 0.07
Distance from
C3 .2 .3 .2 .1 0.20 0.07
households
Availability of
C4 .1 .2 .1 .2 0.15 0.05
space
Proneness to
C5 .1 .1 .1 .1 0.10 0.00
flooding
Environmental
C6 .1 .2 .3 .1 0.18 0.08
Risk
Total 1 1 1 1
***Please edit the criteria listed above with the updated criteria set (mas specific and mas daghan) as
suggested by Dr. Kilong-kilong***
***The following data above are just dummy data for presentation only***
The following criteria for selecting CCPs were obtained through…
A focus group discussion (FGD) with the following stakeholders listed in Table 1 enabled
the establishment of the weights for each criterion…
From the following data, criteria C2 and C3 corresponding to Area Covered and Distance
from Households are the most prioritized criteria in selecting CCPs. This data supports
the stipulations in the Central Place Theory (CPT) which indicates the two criteria as
priority criteria in selection central places or in this case, CCPs.
Using the Fuzzy BWM, the
Furthermore …
Figure 1
Graph of Weight Mean and Std. Dev. Per Criterion
0.25
0.20
0.15
0.10
0.05
0.00
C1 C2 C3 C4 C5 C6
Mean Weight Std. Deviation
***The following data above are just dummy data for presentation only***
As clearly presented in Figure 1, there is minimal standard deviation in the weights
assigned to each criterion relative to their mean. This means that the stakeholders are
coherent in their weight assignment to each criterion which indicates consistency…
Furthermore …
Figure 2
Map of Collection Clusters
From Figure 2, there are forty-one (41) identified collection clusters in Población, Argao.
These clusters were purposively identified based on the concentration of the waste
sources and their road accessibility.
Table 2
Summary of Collection Clusters
CLUSTER RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL INSTITUTIONS AREA
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
Total
Total Area of Población
Percent Area Served
Table 2 has presented the waste sources each cluster and the area covered by each.
The total area of the clusters is the total area served by the CCP system, which is ___%
that of the total area of Población, Argao. This is because …
The areas of each cluster is not identical because …
Furthermore…
Figure 3
Graph of Waste Sources Per Cluster
25
20
15
10
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11
RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL INSTITUTIONS
***The following data above are just dummy data for presentation only***
As shown in Figure 3, Residential waste source is the most dominant compared to other
waste sources. This is because …
From each of the following clusters, potential CCPs will be selected based on a survey
conducted to the residents and other waste sources in Población, Argao. The survey
was conducted to make sure that …
Furthermore …
The selected Potential CCPs per cluster is presented in Appendix C.
The Potential CCPs will then be scored in accordance with the criteria for selecting
CCPs to be ranked using PROMETHEE afterwards.
***Insert Appendix C***
SUMMARY OF POTENTIAL COMMON COLLECTION POINTS (CCP)
CLUSTER POTENTIAL CCP’s COORDINATES CAPACITY
Figure 4 - …
Preference Function Graph of Cluster __ Potential Common Collection Points
***The following data above are just dummy data for presentation only***
(Forty-one more graphs will be presented and analyzed because there are forty-one
clusters. There will be forty-one rankings.)
(After the ranking a map of Final CCPs will be established)
Table 3
Collection Schedule Per Cluster
CAPACITY OF FINAL DAILY WASTE COLLECTION
CCPs (KGs) GENERATION (KGs) FREQUENCY (DAYS)
Cl1 43 11.7 4
Cl2 35 12.9 3
Cl3 34 18.1 2
Cl4 32 17.3 2
Cl5 38 23.4 2
Cl6 43 17.5 2
Cl7 42 14.5 3
Cl8 37 11.2 3
Cl9 29 11.6 3
Cl10 35 22.2 2
Cl11 38 17.3 2
***The following data above are just dummy data for presentation only***
The daily waste generation was calculated based of the estimated waste generation of
residential, commercial, and institutional waste per cluster. The frequency of collection
is calculated by dividing the daily waste collection to the capacity of the final CCPs.
The schedule will serve as guide for Población, Argao ‘s waste collectors to make sure
that the Common Collection Points will always be able to cater the needs of the cluster
it serves.