Understanding Bank Comfort Letters
Understanding Bank Comfort Letters
RWA Letter
Some Sellers will agree with a RWA Letter from the Bank, which are frequently transmitted to
the Seller’s Bank via SWIFT MT 799. Other generic letter terms, such as a simple referral letters
indicating the good standing of the Account Holder in the banking institution, have no value as
BCL. In case a RWA is presented, instead of BCL, the decision to send RWA bank to
bank must be stated in the ICPO/LOI body text. The names, positions and contact information
of the two (2) Bank officers signing the BCL/RWA must be clearly indicated;
The MT-799
The MT-799 is a free format SWIFT message type in which a banking institution confirms that
funds are in place to cover a potential trade. This can, on occasion, be used as an irrevocable
undertaking, depending on the language used in the MT-799, but is not a promise to pay or any
form of bank guarantee in its standard format. The function of the MT-799 is simply to assure
the seller that the buyer does have the necessary funds to complete the trade.
The MT-799 is usually issued before a contract is signed and before a letter of credit or bank
guarantee is issued. After the MT-799 has been received by the seller’s bank, it is then normally
the responsibility of the seller’s bank to send a POP (proof of product) to the buyer’s bank, at
which point the trade continues towards commencement.
Letters of Credit can be for any amount, in any freely traded currency, and, subject to the
presentation of compliant documents, may be payable:
at sight, which means as soon as a compliant set of documents are presented to the paying
bank; or, after a specified term, e.g. at 30, 60, 90 or 180 days of sight or Bill of Lading date.
If the documents are not presented exactly as specified in the Letter of Credit, payment will not
be made unless the Importer gives their authority to waive or amend the specified condition.
A fundamental principle of Letters of Credit is that banks deal with documents and not with the
goods to which the documents refer.
For example, if the Importer is not happy with the quality of the goods but the documents
comply with the terms and conditions of the Letter of Credit, the Importer's bank is obliged to
pay the Exporter.
Letters of credit used in international transactions are governed by the International Chamber
of Commerce Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits. The general provisions
and definitions of the International Chamber of Commerce are binding on all parties. Domestic
collections in the United States are governed by the Uniform Commercial Code.
A commercial letter of credit is a contractual agreement between a bank, known as the issuing
bank, on behalf of one of its customers, authorizing another bank, known as the advising or
confirming bank, to make payment to the beneficiary. The issuing bank, on the request of its
customer, opens the letter of credit. The issuing bank makes a commitment to honor drawings
made under the credit. The beneficiary is normally the provider of goods and/or services.
Essentially, the issuing bank replaces the bank's customer as the payee.
Beneficiary
The beneficiary is entitled to payment as long as he can provide the documentary evidence
required by the letter of credit. The letter of credit is a distinct and separate transaction from the
contract on which it is based. All parties deal in documents and not in goods. The issuing bank is
not liable for performance of the underlying contract between the customer and beneficiary. The
issuing bank's obligation to the buyer, is to examine all documents to insure that they meet all
the terms and conditions of the credit. Upon requesting demand for payment the beneficiary
warrants that all conditions of the agreement have been complied with. If the beneficiary (seller)
conforms to the letter of credit, the seller must be paid by the bank.
Issuing Bank
The issuing bank's liability to pay and to be reimbursed from its customer becomes absolute
upon the completion of the terms and conditions of the letter of credit. Under the provisions of
the Uniform Customs and Practice for Documentary Credits, the bank is given a reasonable
amount of time after receipt of the documents to honor the draft.
The issuing banks' role is to provide a guarantee to the seller that if compliant documents are
presented, the bank will pay the seller the amount due and to examine the documents, and only
pay if these documents comply with the terms and conditions set out in the letter of credit.
Typically the documents requested will include a commercial invoice, a transport document
such as a bill of lading or airway bill and an insurance document; but there are many others.
Letters of credit deal in documents, not goods.
Advising Bank
An advising bank, usually a foreign correspondent bank of the issuing bank will advise the
beneficiary. Generally, the beneficiary would want to use a local bank to insure that the letter of
credit is valid. In addition, the advising bank would be responsible for sending the documents to
the issuing bank. The advising bank has no other obligation under the letter of credit. If the
issuing bank does not pay the beneficiary, the advising bank is not obligated to pay.
Confirming Bank
The correspondent bank may confirm the letter of credit for the beneficiary. At the request of
the issuing bank, the correspondent obligates itself to insure payment under the letter of credit.
The confirming bank would not confirm the credit until it evaluated the country and bank where
the letter of credit originates. The confirming bank is usually the advising bank.
Negotiability
Letters of credit are usually negotiable. The issuing bank is obligated to pay not only the
beneficiary, but also any bank nominated by the beneficiary. Negotiable instruments are passed
freely from one party to another almost in the same way as money. To be negotiable, the letter of
credit must include an unconditional promise to pay, on demand or at a definite time. The
nominated bank becomes a holder in due course. As a holder in due course, the holder takes the
letter of credit for value, in good faith, without notice of any claims against it. A holder in due
course is treated favorably under the UCC.
The transaction is considered a straight negotiation if the issuing bank's payment obligation
extends only to the beneficiary of the credit. If a letter of credit is a straight negotiation it is
referenced on its face by "we engage with you" or "available with ourselves". Under these
conditions the promise does not pass to a purchaser of the draft as a holder in due course.
Revocability
Letters of credit may be either revocable or irrevocable. A revocable letter of credit may be
revoked or modified for any reason, at any time by the issuing bank without notification. A
revocable letter of credit cannot be confirmed. If a correspondent bank is engaged in a
transaction that involves a revocable letter of credit, it serves as the advising bank.
Once the documents have been presented and meet the terms and conditions in the letter of
credit, and the draft is honored, the letter of credit cannot be revoked. The revocable letter of
credit is not a commonly used instrument. It is generally used to provide guidelines for
shipment. If a letter of credit is revocable it would be referenced on its face.
The irrevocable letter of credit may not be revoked or amended without the agreement of the
issuing bank, the confirming bank, and the beneficiary. An irrevocable letter of credit from the
issuing bank insures the beneficiary that if the required documents are presented and the terms
and conditions are complied with, payment will be made. If a letter of credit is irrevocable it is
referenced on its face.
Transfer and Assignment
The beneficiary has the right to transfer or assign the right to draw, under a credit only when the
credit states that it is transferable or assignable. Credits governed by the Uniform Commercial
Code (Domestic) maybe transferred an unlimited number of times. Under the Uniform Customs
Practice for Documentary Credits (International) the credit may be transferred only once.
However, even if the credit specifies that it is nontransferable or nonassignable, the beneficiary
may transfer their rights prior to performance of conditions of the credit.
There are two types of drafts: sight and time. A sight draft is payable as soon as it is presented
for payment. The bank is allowed a reasonable time to review the documents before making
payment.
A time draft is not payable until the lapse of a particular time period stated on the draft. The
bank is required to accept the draft as soon as the documents comply with credit terms. The
issuing bank has a reasonable time to examine those documents. The issuing bank is obligated
to accept drafts and pay them at maturity.
The standby letter of credit assures the beneficiary of the performance of the customer's
obligation. The beneficiary is able to draw under the credit by presenting a draft, copies of
invoices, with evidence that the customer has not performed its obligation. The bank is obligated
to make payment if the documents presented comply with the terms of the letter of credit.
Standby letters of credit are issued by banks to stand behind monetary obligations, to insure the
refund of advance payment, to support performance and bid obligations, and to insure the
completion of a sales contract. The credit has an expiration date.
The standby letter of credit is often used to guarantee performance or to strengthen the credit
worthiness of a customer. In the above example, the letter of credit is issued by the bank and
held by the supplier. The customer is provided open account terms. If payments are made in
accordance with the suppliers' terms, the letter of credit would not be drawn on. The seller
pursues the customer for payment directly. If the customer is unable to pay, the seller presents a
draft and copies of invoices to the bank for payment.
The domestic standby letter of credit is governed by the Uniform Commercial Code. Under these
provisions, the bank is given until the close of the third banking day after receipt of the
documents to honor the draft.
Commercial Invoice
The billing for the goods and services. It includes a description of merchandise, price, FOB
origin, and name and address of buyer and seller. The buyer and seller information must
correspond exactly to the description in the letter of credit. Unless the letter of credit specifically
states otherwise, a generic description of the merchandise is usually acceptable in the other
accompanying documents.
Bill of Lading
A document evidencing the receipt of goods for shipment and issued by a freight carrier engaged
in the business of forwarding or transporting goods. The documents evidence control of goods.
They also serve as a receipt for the merchandise shipped and as evidence of the carrier's
obligation to transport the goods to their proper destination.
Warranty of Title
A warranty given by a seller to a buyer of goods that states that the title being conveyed is good
and that the transfer is rightful. This is a method of certifying clear title to product transfer. It is
generally issued to the purchaser and issuing bank expressing an agreement to indemnify and
hold both parties harmless.
Letter of Indemnity
Specifically indemnifies the purchaser against a certain stated circumstance. Indemnification is
generally used to guaranty that shipping documents will be provided in good order when
available.
Common Defects in Documentation
About half of all drawings presented contain discrepancies. A discrepancy is an irregularity in
the documents that causes them to be in non-compliance to the letter of credit. Requirements
set forth in the letter of credit cannot be waived or altered by the issuing bank without the
express consent of the customer. The beneficiary should prepare and examine all documents
carefully before presentation to the paying bank to avoid any delay in receipt of payment.
Commonly found discrepancies between the letter of credit and supporting documents include:
• Letter of Credit has expired prior to presentation of draft.
• Bill of Lading evidences delivery prior to or after the date range stated in the credit.
• Stale dated documents.
• Changes included in the invoice not authorized in the credit.
• Inconsistent description of goods.
• Insurance document errors.
• Invoice amount not equal to draft amount.
• Ports of loading and destination not as specified in the credit.
• Description of merchandise is not as stated in credit.
• A document required by the credit is not presented.
• Documents are inconsistent as to general information such as volume, quality, etc.
• Names of documents not exact as described in the credit. Beneficiary information must
be exact.
• Invoice or statement is not signed as stipulated in the letter of credit.
When a discrepancy is detected by the negotiating bank, a correction to the document may be
allowed if it can be done quickly while remaining in the control of the bank. If time is not a
factor, the exporter should request that the negotiating bank return the documents for
corrections.
If there is not enough time to make corrections, the exporter should request that the negotiating
bank send the documents to the issuing bank on an approval basis or notify the issuing bank by
wire, outline the discrepancies, and request authority to pay. Payment cannot be made until all
parties have agreed to jointly waive the discrepancy.
Tips for Exporters
• Communicate with your customers in detail before they apply for letters of credit.
• Consider whether a confirmed letter of credit is needed.
• Ask for a copy of the application to be fax to you, so you can check for terms or
conditions that may cause you problems in compliance.
• Upon first advice of the letter of credit, check that all its terms and conditions can be
complied with within the prescribed time limits.
• Many presentations of documents run into problems with time-limits. You must be
aware of at least three time constraints - the expiration date of the credit, the latest
shipping date and the maximum time allowed between dispatch and presentation.
• If the letter of credit calls for documents supplied by third parties, make reasonable
allowance for the time this may take to complete.
• After dispatch of the goods, check all the documents both against the terms of the credit
and against each other for internal consistency.
Summary
The use of the letters of credit as a tool to reduce risk has grown substantially over the past
decade. Letters of credit accomplish their purpose by substituting the credit of the bank for that
of the customer, for the purpose of facilitating trade.
The credit professional should be familiar with two types of letters of credit: commercial and
standby. Commercial letters of credit are used primarily to facilitate foreign trade. The
commercial letter of credit is the primary payment mechanism for a transaction.
The standby letter of credit serves a different function. The standby letter of credit serves as a
secondary payment mechanism. The bank will issue the credit on behalf of a customer to
provide assurances of his ability to perform under the terms of a contract.
Upon receipt of the letter of credit, the credit professional should review all items carefully to
insure that what is expected of the seller is fully understood and that he can comply with all the
terms and conditions. When compliance is in question, the buyer should be requested to amend
the credit.
Definition
Letters of credit are commonly used to reduce credit risk to sellers in both domestic and
international sales arrangements. By having a bank issue a letter of credit, in essence, one is
substituting the bank's credit worthiness for that of the customer.
Types
There are two basic forms of letters of credit: Standby and Documentary. Documentary letters of
credit can be either Revocable or Irrevocable, although the first is extremely rare. Irrevocable
letters of credit can be Confirmed or Not Confirmed. Each type of credit has advantages and
disadvantages for the buyer and for the seller, which this information will review below. Charges
for each type will also vary. However, the more the banks assume risk by guaranteeing payment,
the more they will charge for providing the service.
Assignment of Proceeds
The beneficiary of a letter of credit may assign all or part of the proceeds under a credit to a
third party (the assignee). However, unlike a transferred credit, the beneficiary maintains sole
rights to the credit and is solely responsible for complying with its terms and conditions. For the
assignee, an assignment only means that the paying bank, once it receives notice of the
assignment, undertakes to follow the assignment instructions, if and when payment is made.
The assignee is dependent upon the beneficiary for compliance, and thus this arrangement is
riskier than a transferred credit. Before agreeing to an assignment of proceeds arrangement, the
assignee should carefully review the original letter of credit.
Common Problems with Letters of Credit
Most problems result from the seller's inability to fulfill obligations stated in the letter of credit.
The seller may find these terms difficult or impossible to fulfill and, either tries to fulfill them
and fails, or asks the buyer to amend to the letter of credit. As most letters of credit are
irrevocable, amendments may at times be difficult since both the buyer and the seller must
agree.
Sellers may have one or more of the following problems:
• The shipment schedule cannot be met;
• The stipulations concerning freight costs are unacceptable;
• The price becomes too low due to exchange rates fluctuations;
• The quantity of product ordered is not the expected amount;
• The description of product is either insufficient or too detailed; and,
• The stipulated documents are difficult or impossible to obtain.
Even when sellers accept the terms of a letter of credit, problems often arise late in the process.
When this occurs, the buyer's and seller's banks will try to negotiate any differences. In some
cases, the seller can correct the documents and present them within the time specified in the
letter of credit. If the documents cannot be corrected, the advising bank will ask the issuing bank
to accept the documents despite the discrepancies found. It is important to note that, if the
documents are not in accord with the specifications of the letter of credit, the buyer's issuing
bank is no longer obligated to pay.
Documents
In specifying required documents, it is very important to include those required for customs and
those reflecting the agreement reached between the buyer and the seller. Required documents
usually include the bill of lading, a commercial and/or consular invoice, the bill of exchange, the
certificate of origin, and the insurance document. Other documents required may be an
inspection certificate, copies of a cable sent to the buyer with shipping information, a
confirmation from the shipping company of the state of its ship, and a confirmation from the
forwarder that the goods are accompanied by a certificate of origin. Prices should be stated in
the currency of the letter of credit and documents should in the same language as the letter of
credit.
Seller
1. Before signing a sales contract, the seller should make inquiries about the buyer's
creditworthiness and business practices. The seller's bank will generally assist in this
investigation.
2. In many cases, the issuing bank will specify the advising and/or confirming bank. These
designations are usually based on the issuing bank's established correspondent relationships.
The seller should ensure that the advising/confirming bank is a financially sound institution.
3. The seller should confirm the good standing of the buyer's issuing bank if the letter of credit is
unconfirmed.
4. For confirmed letters of credit, the seller's advising bank should be willing to confirm the
letter of credit issued by the buyer's bank. If the advising bank refuses to do so, the seller should
request another issuing bank as the current bank may be or is in the process of becoming
insolvent.
5. The seller should carefully review the letter of credit to ensure its conditions can be met. All
documents must conform to the terms of the letter of credit. The seller must comply with every
detail of the letter of credit specifications; otherwise the security given by the credit is lost.
6. The seller should ensure that the letter of credit is irrevocable.
7. If amendments are necessary, the seller should contact the buyer immediately so that the
buyer can instruct the issuing bank to make the necessary changes quickly. The seller should
keep the letter of credit's expiration date in mind throughout the amendment process.
8. The seller should confirm with the insurance company that it can provide the coverage
specified in the letter of credit and that insurance charges listed in the letter of credit are correct.
Typical insurance coverage is for CIF (cost, insurance and freight) often the value of the goods
plus about 10 percent.
9. The seller must ensure that the goods match the description in the letter of credit and the
invoice description.
10. The seller should be familiar with foreign exchange limitations in the buyer's country that
could hinder payment procedures.
Buyer
1. When choosing the type of letter of credit, the buyer should consider the standard payment
methods in the seller's country.
2. The buyer should keep the details of the purchase short and concise.
3. The buyer should be prepared to amend or re-negotiate terms of the letter of credit with the
seller. This is a common procedure in international trade. With irrevocable letters of credit, the
most common type, all parties must agree to amend the document.
4. The buyer can reduce the foreign exchange risk by buying forward currency contracts.
5. The buyer should use a bank experienced in foreign trade as its issuing bank.
6. The validation time stated on the letter of credit should give the seller ample time to produce
the goods or to pull them out of stock.
7. A letter of credit is not fail-safe. Banks are only responsible for the documents exchanged and
not the goods shipped. Documents in conformity with the letter of credit specifications cannot
be rejected on grounds that the goods were not delivered as specified in the contract. The goods
shipped may not in fact be the goods ordered and paid for.
8. Purchase contracts and other agreements pertaining to the sale between the buyer and seller
are not the concern of the issuing bank. Only the letter of credit terms are binding on the bank.
9. Documents specified in the letter of credit should include those the buyer requires for
customs clearance.
INCOTERMS
Transportation
Shipping terms set the parameters for international shipments, specify points of origin and
destination, outline conditions under which title is transferred from seller to buyer, and
determine which party is responsible for shipping costs. They also indicate which party assumes
the cost if the merchandise is lost or damaged during transit. To provide a common terminology
for international shipping, INCOTERMS (International Commercial Terms) have been
developed under the auspices of the International Chamber of Commerce.









