0% found this document useful (0 votes)
60 views5 pages

Motor Selection Guide for Inertia Ratio

This document outlines motor selection flows for AC, brushless DC, stepping, and servo motors. For AC and brushless DC motors, the selection flow involves choosing a motor size based on torque requirements, then confirming the permissible inertia is greater than the calculated load inertia. For stepping motors, the selection flow involves choosing a motor size based on torque-speed needs, then confirming the rotor inertia to load inertia ratio is within specifications. For servo motors, the selection flow involves choosing a motor based on torque-speed needs, confirming torque limits are not exceeded, and that acceleration time is within overload detection time. The document also provides considerations for motor duty cycles, stopping accuracy of various motor types, and

Uploaded by

Almen Matanović
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
60 views5 pages

Motor Selection Guide for Inertia Ratio

This document outlines motor selection flows for AC, brushless DC, stepping, and servo motors. For AC and brushless DC motors, the selection flow involves choosing a motor size based on torque requirements, then confirming the permissible inertia is greater than the calculated load inertia. For stepping motors, the selection flow involves choosing a motor size based on torque-speed needs, then confirming the rotor inertia to load inertia ratio is within specifications. For servo motors, the selection flow involves choosing a motor based on torque-speed needs, confirming torque limits are not exceeded, and that acceleration time is within overload detection time. The document also provides considerations for motor duty cycles, stopping accuracy of various motor types, and

Uploaded by

Almen Matanović
Copyright
© All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

AC Motors Selection flow

STEP 1: Select the motor size and gear ratio from the torque

STEP 2: Confirm the permissible inertia JG of the motor selected is greater than load inertia JL
Frame Size 42 mm 60 mm 70 mm 80 mm 90 mm 90 mm 104mm
1.65 in 2.36 in 2.76 in 3.15 in 3.54 in 3.54 in 4.09 in

Output Power (Watts) 1, 3 6 15 25 40 60, 90 200


(HP) 1/750, 1/250 1/125 1/50 1/30 1/19 1/12, 1/8 1/4
Permissible Inertia (X 10-4 Kgm2) 0.016 0.062 0.14 0.31 0.75 1.1 2.0
at the Motor
JM (Oz-in2) 0.088 0.34 0.77 1.70 4.1 6.0 10.9

Gear ratio 3:1 to 50:1, JG=JM x i2 JG: Permissible load inertia at the gearhead output shaft
Gear ratio 60:1 or higher, JG=JM x 2500 JM: Permissible load inertia at the motor shaft JG > JL
i: Gear ratio (Ex. If the gear ratio is 3:1, i=3)
Brushless DC Motor Selection Flow
STEP 1: Select the motor size and gear ratio from the torque table

STEP 2: Confirm the permissible inertia is greater than the calculated Load inertia
Stepping Motor Selection Flow
STEP 1: Select motor size from the Torque-Speed chart

Required torque < Pullout torque

STEP 2: Confirm the rotor inertia Jo and the load inertia JL ratio

J L
Inertia Ratio 2
J O i

Where JL: load inertia, Jo: rotor inertia, i: gear ratio


Servo Motor Selection Flow
STEP 1: Select motor size from the Torque-Speed chart STEP 3
Confirm the acceleration time is
using the Required torque and the RMS torque
within the Overload detection time
for limited duty region operation.

Required Torque < Max. torque

RMS Torque < Rated Torque

STEP 2: Confirm the load inertia is within the permissible inertia


Other Considerations
1. Over run and Duty cycle of AC and BL motors
Products Induction Reversible Electromagnetic Brake Pack Clutch brake Brushless DC Motors
motors motors brake motors motors

Overrun 30-40 5-6 2-3 1-1.5 1 or less 2-3


(Revs)
Duty Cycle Continuous 30 min 30 min --- Continuous Continuous

2. Stopping accuracy and Duty cycle of Stepping motors and Servo motors
Products 0.36 deg Closed-Loop 0.72 deg 0.36 / 0.72 deg 0.9 / 1.8 deg NX Servo motor
AR series RK series CRK series UMK, RBK, CMK series
PK motors

Stopping AR46: +/- 3 arc min 0.36 deg motor: +/- 3 arc min +/- 1 pulse of
Accuracy +/- 4 arc min. (0.067 deg) (0.05 deg) +/- 2 arc min (0.03 deg) (0.05 deg) resolution
AR6[], AR9[]: 0.72 deg motor:
+/- 3 arc min. (0.05 deg) +/- 3 arc min (0.05 deg)

Duty Cycle Continuous Limited Limited Limited Continuous

3. Gearhead backlash
Gearhead types Harmonic Planetary Taper hobbed Spur
HG PN, PJ, PS TH SG
Backlash 0 arc min. PN, PJ: 2-3 arc min. 10-45 arc min. 45-90 arc min.
(Lost motion ) (1.5 arc min.) PS: 15-25 arc min.

Common questions

Powered by AI

For AC motors, the permissible load inertia at the gearhead output shaft (JG) is calculated as JG = JM x i² for gear ratios between 3:1 and 50:1 . When the gear ratio is 60:1 or higher, JG is calculated as JM x 2500 . This relationship indicates that the gear ratio significantly affects the permissible inertia by increasing the effective inertia handling capacity through gearing, thereby enabling the motor system to manage higher or adjusted loads.

Not evaluating stopping accuracy when choosing stepping and servo motors could lead to positioning errors and imprecise motor control . Stopping accuracy is vital for applications requiring high precision, as errors could accumulate over repeated cycles, impacting overall system performance and reliability. For servo and stepping motors, especially in high-precision environments, ensuring the stopping accuracy is within acceptable limits mitigates risks associated with product defects or operational inefficiencies .

Confirming the RMS and required torque when selecting a servo motor is critical because it ensures the motor's ability to handle expected loads without exceeding its rated capacity . The RMS torque should be less than the rated torque, and the required torque must be below the maximum torque to prevent motor overheating or failure . Ignoring these could result in inconsistent operation, increased wear, and potential motor damage, leading to system failure and costly downtime.

Duty cycle specifications impact the selection and operation of AC and brushless DC motors by dictating the operational limits and efficiencies of these motors . Continuous duty cycles, used in induction motors, allow for sustained operation without significant temperature rise . Brushless DC motors can also operate continuously, but considerations for electromagnetic brakes or clutch brakes may be needed depending on the duty cycle specifications . Properly understanding these requirements ensures that motors are selected and operated within their optimal performance range for longevity and reliability.

In stepping motor selection, rotor inertia (Jo) plays a critical role as it must be proportionately matched to the load inertia (JL) based on the gear ratio (i). The selection process requires the inertia ratio JL/Jo to be in accordance with a specified range determined by the gear ratio, ensuring proper dynamic response and minimizing vibration . Properly matching these inertias is crucial for achieving optimal motor performance and operational accuracy.

The permissible inertia at the motor shaft (JM) is fundamental to motor control and performance, as it reflects the motor's capability to handle the inertia of the connected load without losing control or efficiency . Properly matching JM with the system's load inertia helps ensure smooth acceleration and deceleration, contributes to accurate speed control, and minimizes vibrations, which are essential for reliable performance in dynamic applications. An incorrect match may lead to overloading, affecting both performance and lifespan of the motor .

In AC motors, for gear ratios between 3:1 and 50:1, permissible load inertia at the gearhead output shaft (JG) is calculated by multiplying the motor's inertia (JM) by the square of the gear ratio (i²). For gear ratios 60:1 or higher, JG is calculated differently by multiplying JM by 2500, reflecting a sharp elevation in permissible inertia due to the higher stabilization provided by the gearing . This difference in calculation accounts for the greater leverage and load handling capability of higher gear ratios.

Backlash in gearheads affects motor precision by allowing unintended movement or play within the gear system, which reduces accuracy in applications requiring tight control . Different gearhead types exhibit various levels of backlash tolerance; for instance, planetary gearheads (PN, PJ) have lower backlash (2-3 arc min), providing better precision compared to spur or harmonic gearheads, which usually have higher backlash values . Selecting the appropriate gearhead type is critical to minimizing the impact of backlash on system performance, especially in high-precision tasks.

Confirming that the acceleration time of a servo motor is within the overload detection time is crucial because it ensures the motor operates within its safe loading conditions during accelerated motions . This is particularly important for limited duty region operations where the motor might temporarily exceed its continuous ratings. Failing to confirm this alignment might cause overheating, mechanical failure, or triggering of protective mechanisms that halt motor functions, thereby disrupting processes and reducing efficiency .

Selecting a brushless DC motor involves two main steps. First, selecting the motor size and gear ratio from the torque table ensures that the motor can handle the required load torque . Second, confirming that the permissible inertia is greater than the calculated load inertia guarantees that the motor will not be overloaded, maintaining performance and preventing damage . These steps ensure the motor is properly matched to the application, enhancing efficiency and longevity.

You might also like