Runnerbeans PDF
Runnerbeans PDF
Runner Beans
Jacquie Gray
Trials Officer, RHS Garden Wisley
Dr Peter Dawson
Vice Chairman, RHS Vegetable trials Subcommittee
Bulletin Number 19
October 2007
[Link]
RHS Trial of Runner Beans
Front cover:
AchievementMerit
(Photos by Jacquie
Gray)
Opposite: Celebration
Cultivation
Runner beans prefer a position in full sun, although they
will tolerate part shade. The sites at both Wisley and at
East Ruston Old Vicarage Garden were open, but sheltered
from the wind by trees or hedges, as strong winds can
damage young leaves and pods or easily blow over the tall,
leafy wigwams. The plot at Wisley was cultivated and raked
by hand, but no farmyard manure or fertiliser was
incorporated. Trials plots at Wisley are very rich from years
of cultivation and a soil too rich in nitrogen would have
encouraged the plants to produce lots of leafy growth but
few beans. Runner beans prefer a soil pH of 6.5 and
analysis of soil at both sites confirmed that neither was
below this: a more acidic soil might need liming. The
beans were grown on wigwams made up of four canes.
Three wigwams of each cultivar were grown at Wisley and
a single wigwam of each cultivar was grown at East Ruston.
Three seeds were sown directly into the soil at the bottom
of each cane on 24 May when the soil temperature had
warmed enough to enable germination (a minimum of
10C/50F) and later the seedlings were thinned to two
plants per cane. The wigwams were spaced 60cm apart, in
a single row at East Ruston and in rows 90cm apart at
Wisley. Trial entries at Rosemoor were grown in single rows
either side of a path, producing a decorative arch.
Runner Beans 3
Members of the NVS and the other gardens that
participated in the trial were asked to grow the seeds as
they would normally and to record their sowing date and
methods of cultivation, as well the as cropping and quality
details. Dwarf, non-climbing cultivars were grown at the
end of the trial plot.
H3 = plants hardy outside in some regions or in particular situations or which, whilst usually grown outside in
summer, need frost-free protection in winter.
Findings
Runner beans prefer the cooler, wetter climate that is the
usual English summer. High night temperatures and low
rainfall in 2006 made this a difficult year, but the trial still
cropped very well. The Subcommittee did note that there
was much more shading at Wisley where three wigwams of
each cultivar were grown, compared to East Ruston where a
single row of wigwams were grown. There the conditions
were much more open, allowing greater air flow and light to
reach the plants. The trial at East Ruston had been
outstanding, with the higher water table, cooling sea breezes
and more open cultivation of the plants helping to produce
very good crops. The foliage on the plants at Rosemoor had
not grown as leafy as those at Wisley or East Ruston, but the
entries had cropped well and were easy to pick from the
path. NVS members reported that, in spite of considerable
efforts to irrigate, most had suffered very poor pod set on
their beans due to the high night temperatures and that this
had resulted in later than usual cropping, with lower yields.
Yields from the South Coast sites did not appear as seriously
affected as those in central England, which might reflect the
cooling effect of night-time breezes from the sea. Further
north cropping, although somewhat delayed, followed its
normal pattern of peaking towards the end of August. The
Edinburgh site, which was described as quite exposed,
produced a better crop than usual and may have benefited
from higher temperatures. The records and comments
produced by NVS members were taken into consideration by
the Subcommittee when assessing the trial. It had been
hoped that their results would indicate whether different
cultivars would perform better in different parts of the
country. However, although of great value to the
Subcommittee in their overall assessment, the sample was
not large enough to allow any conclusions to be drawn
about regional suitability.
Runner Beans 5
In general, they considered that the dwarf cultivars, while
decorative, were better suited to growing in pots. These
cultivars carry a naturally dwarfing gene and have been
developed from the tall, climbing beans. They produce
runner beans on plants that grow to around 45cm high,
but the Subcommittee noted that, when grown directly in
the ground, the pods became dusty and muddy from being
so close to the soil. They commented that Snow White
had performed the best of this type in the trial, producing
a reasonable yield (16.98kg) of straight, stringless beans.
The trial also included two heritage cultivars that are not
EU-listed, Black Emperor and David Chappell, as well as
entries submitted by individuals: As Long As Your Arm
Reselected (first picked on 11 August), Bournville (very
fleshy pods, but slow to crop fully), Headway (exceptionally
long, smooth straight pods that would be good for
exhibition), an un-named cultivar (said to be similar to
Scarlet Emperor; crop to 15 September 10.69kg) and
Simms Corsair (25.36kg, but rather fibrous pods when
compared to others).
Achievement-Merit
Sent by A L Tozer Ltd.
Red flowered, late main crop. Attractive, good quality, straight, fleshy pods.
Very straight, long, fleshy, flat, smooth pods average 36cm long, 1.8cm wide. They
have little fibre in the sides and are stringless when young. First picked 2 August.
Flowers are red; seeds are spotted with black.
Aintree
Sent by A L Tozer Ltd.
Mid-season. Red flowered cultivar that produces attractive, good quality,
slim, straight, long pods with sweet flavour.
Very straight, fleshy, flat, smooth pods average 31cm long, 1.6cm wide. They have
little string or fibre when young. First picked 2 August. Flowers are red; seeds are
spotted with black.
Celebration
Sent by Suttons Consumer Products Ltd. Also offered by A L Tozer Ltd.
High yield of handsome, straight, smooth, good quality, fleshy pods with
good colour and flavour. Flowers are a decorative pink.
Straight, fleshy, flat to oval pods average 30cm long, 2cm wide. They have little
string or fibre when young. First picked 27 July. Attractive flowers are salmon-pink;
seeds are black, mottled with pink.
Enorma-Elite
Sent by A L Tozer Ltd.
Vigorous cultivar with red flowers. Produces nice smooth, straight beans. Sets
well and has a reasonable yield.
Straight, flat pods are fairly fleshy and average 31cm long, 1.6cm wide. They have
little fibre in the sides and are stringless when young. First picked 2 August. Flowers
are red; seeds are spotted with black.
Flare
Sent by S E Marshall.
Good yield of attractive, straight, narrow pods that are smooth and have a
good colour. Very little string.
Straight, fleshy, flat smooth pods average 29cm long, 1.8cm wide. They have little
fibre in the sides and no string in the back when young. First picked 2 August.
Flowers are red; seeds are spotted with black.
Runner Beans 7
Award of Garden Merit Runner Beans
Lady Di
Sent by D T Brown & Co.
Red flowered cultivar giving a very good crop of stringless, long, fleshy pods.
Very slightly curved, flat, smooth pods average 27cm long, 1.7cm wide. They are
truly stringless and have very little fibre in the sides when young. First picked 27
July. Flowers are red; seeds are black, mottled with pink.
Red Flame
Sent by Johnsons Seeds. Also offered by A L Tozer Ltd.
A red flowered cultivar that sets well and produces smooth, long, straight
pods.
Straight, fleshy, flat, smooth pods average 27cm long, 1.5cm wide. They have little
string or fibre when young. First picked 2 August. Flowers are red; seeds are spotted
with black.
Red Rum
Sent by A L Tozer Ltd.
Red flowered cultivar that produces a very good crop of stringless, fleshy
pods with good flavour. Sets well in hotter temperatures.
Straight, smooth, fleshy pods average 22cm long, 1.5cm wide. They have very little
fibre in the sides and are stringless when young. First picked 27 July. Flowers are
red; seeds are mottled with black.
Royal Standard
Sent by A L Tozer Ltd.
Red flowered. Good yield of stringless beans that tend to curl, but are broad
and succulent with a good snap and nice flavour.
Fairly straight, broad, flat, fleshy pods average 29cm long, 2cm wide. They are
stringless and have little fibre in the sides when young. First picked 27 July. Flowers
are red; seeds are spotted with black.
Saint George
Sent by A L Tozer Ltd.
Early, high yield of crisp, juicy pods with good snap. Ornamental cultivar
with bi-coloured, red and white flowers. An improved Painted Lady.
Fairly straight, thick, fleshy pods average 25cm long, 2cm wide. They have little
string or fibre when young. First picked 27 July. Bi-colour flowers are an attractive
red and white; seeds are mottled with black.
White-Achievement
Sent by A L Tozer Ltd.
Later cropping. White flowered, produces a reasonable yield of dark green,
fleshy pods with a strong flavour.
Fairly straight, smooth, fleshy pods average 30cm long, 1.6cm wide. They have
little fibre in the sides and no string in the back when young. First picked 2 August.
Flowers and seeds are white.
White Emergo-Snowy
Sent by A L Tozer Ltd.
White flowered. Produces a good crop of straight, fleshy pods with good
flavour. It was noted that this cultivar continued to crop well even when the
temperature was high.
Long, straight, flat to oval, fleshy pods average 32cm long, 2cm wide. They have
little string or fibre when young. First picked 2 August. Flowers and seeds are white.
White Lady
Sent by A L Tozer Ltd.
White flowered. Gives a high yield of good quality, smooth pods with little
fibre and a good snap.
Long, flat, smooth pods average 34cm long, 2cm wide. They have little fibre in the
sides and are stringless when young. First picked 2 August. Flowers and seeds are
white.
Wisley Magic
Sent by A L Tozer Ltd.
Red flowered. Good yield throughout season of very good quality, long pods
with a nice flavour.
Long, smooth, slender pods average 32cm long, 1.7cm wide. They have little string
or fibre when young. First picked 2 August. Flowers are red; seeds are spotted with
black.
Runner Beans 9
Selection guide * Yield in kilograms: picked at
Wisley up to 15 September
Subject to availability
Subject to naming &
2006. availability
Acknowledgements
Dr Peter Dawson is managing director of A L Tozer Ltd, an
independent company that was established in the early
1940s and is now the only UK commercial seed producer
currently breeding runner bean cultivars.
Jim England and the curatorial team, RHS Garden Wisley.
Peter Earl, RHS Garden Rosemoor
Alan Gray, East Ruston Old Vicarage Garden
Sarah Wain, West Dean Gardens
Members of the National Vegetable Society
Further reading
Biggs, T. (2003) Growing Vegetables The RHS Encyclopaedia
of Practical Gardening. Mitchell Beazley, London
Pollock, M. (2002) RHS Fruit & Vegetable Gardening
Dorling Kindersley, London
RHS TRIALS
Stickland, S. The Garden 132 (5):302
Vegetable Subcommittee at Wisley (Photo: Alison Cundy)
Dawson, P. The Garden 124 (5):336
Virtual runner bean trial 2006
[Link]
Senders of seed to the trial
A L Tozer Ltd, Cobham, Surrey KT11 3EH.
[Link] Useful websites
Bakker Brothers, Oostelke Randweg 12, 1723 LH Noord- RHS Gardening Advice on growing Runner Beans
Scharwoude, Netherlands.
[Link]/advice/profiles0800/runner_beans.asp
Crisp Innovar Ltd., Glebe House, Station Road, Reepham,
Norfolk NR10 4NB. [Link]/advice/profiles0507/[Link]
D T Brown & Co, Bury Road, Kentford, Newmarket, [Link]/advice/profiles0406/[Link]
Suffolk CB8 7PQ. [Link] [Link]/advice/profiles0802/pollen_beetle.asp
Heritage Seed Library, HDRA, Ryton Organic Garden,
Coventry CV8 3LG. [Link]
Holland-Select BV, Horn 29, 1619 BT Andijk, 1619 ZG,
Netherlands.
Johnsons Seeds, Gazeley Road, Kentford, Newmarket,
Suffolk CB8 7QB. [Link]
Mr Fothergill's Seeds, Gazeley Road, Kentford, Newmarket,
Suffolk CB8 7QB. [Link]
N L Chrestensen, Erfurter Samen und Pflanzenzucht
GmbH, Postfach 854, 99016 Erfurt, Germany.
S E Marshall, Regal Road, Wisbech PE 13 2RF.
[Link]
Suttons Consumer Products Ltd, Woodview Road,
Paignton, Devon TQ4 7NG. [Link]
Runner Beans 11
The Royal Horticultural Society RHS Bulletins
The RHS is the UKs leading gardening charity dedicated Begonia Rex Cultorum Group: February 2007
to advancing horticulture and promoting good Canna: September 2003
gardening. Its charitable work includes providing expert Caryopteris
advice and information, advancing horticulture, training Daisies (yellow, perennial): September 2004
the next generation of gardeners, helping school children Delphinium: June 2004
learn about plants, and conducting research into plants, Fuchsia (hardy): December 2005
pests and environmental issues affecting gardeners. The Geraniuims (hardy) Stage 1: June 2005
RHS AGM plant trial scheme is an important part of this Geraniuims (hardy) Stage 2: June 2006
work. Geraniuims (hardy) Stage 3: September 2007
Hyacinthaceae (little blue bulbs): September 2005
The RHS receives no government grants and for every Iris (bearded) May 2007
pound received from members subscriptions we need to Lavenders (hardy): July 2003
raise more than twice as much again to fund our Miscanthus: October 2004
charitable work. We also rely on donations and Peppers (sweet): November 2006
sponsorship to supplement income from our garden Potatoes (salad): November 2004
operations, flower shows, shops and plant centres. Potentilla (shrubby): July 2002
Rhododendron yakushimanum & hybrids: May 2006
Saxifrages (silver): May 2005
RHS Plant Trials Spiraea japonica (with coloured leaves): November 2003
With so many different types of gardener and so many
different cultivars available to them in each group of These bulletins can be viewed at a larger
plants, it is important that a system of recommendation size on the RHS Website:
is in place to help with selection at point of sale. These [Link]/publications/pubs_bulletins.asp
recommendations must be clear and reliable to ensure
that of the thousands of plants available in the UK, a
proportion are known to be excellent garden plants. The RHS Plant Assessments
RHS provides this information through its extensive
The first of what will become a series of online publications,
programme of plant trials held at RHS gardens in the UK.
to compliment the RHS Plant Trials and Awards series, was
The RHS Award of Garden Merit signifies the selection
published in July 2006:
of the best cultivars for general garden use.
Pittosporum tenuifolium hybrids & cultivars
RHS plant trials serve the professional gardener who
wants to know the range of plants available, including
the latest breeding and selection programmes, with their
distinctive characteristics and provenance. They also
serve the amateur who wants to know which plants will
grow and perform well in a particular garden situation.
RHS Herbarium
The RHS Herbarium keeps a record of trial cultivars as Trials Office
dried specimens with detailed descriptions and RHS Garden
photographic images. This forms an important reference
for the horticultural industry. Any new cultivars are
Wisley
highlighted and a Standard specimen is preserved and Woking
described. Surrey GU23 6QB
e-mail: trials@[Link]
The RHS Herbarium, stored at RHS Garden Wisley, is the
largest active horticultural herbarium in the world. At
present the collection contains about 80,000 herbarium
specimens and over 30,000 images of plants. Material is
actively collected from a wide spectrum of sources
[Link]/trials
including RHS plant trials. Reg charity no. 222879/SCO 38262