Appendix 1 : Comparison between Gebeng, Tanjung Langsat, Tanjung Pelepas, Teluk Kalong, Tanjung Kidurong and Kudat
Table A1: Site Selection Screening
Location
Characteristic
Distance from the
nearest town
Gebeng Phase IV
25 km from Kuantan
Tanjung Langsat
Petrochemical
Telok Kalong
48 km from Johor
35 km from Johor
9.6 km form
Bahru
Bahru
Kemaman
Type of industry
preferred
Tanjung Pelepas
Petrochemical
small/medium/ heavy Heavy industry,
industry
chemical products
Tamjung Kidurong
18 km from Bintulu
Kudat
20 km from Kota
Kinabalu
Heavy industry, gas
Petrochemical
and steel industry
Available land for
1458 acres
1088.79 hectares
800 hectares
167.46 hectares
99 hectares
related
28.30 hectares
industrial use
Land Price
Source of raw
RM 30-32/m2
a. Mobil Chemical
RM 13-15/m2
a. Mobil Chemical
RM 20-32/m2
a. Mobil Chemical
RM 8-45/m2
a. Mobil Chemical
RM 77.42/m2
a. Mobil Chemical
RM 60-68/m2
a. Mobil Chemical
material
(Singapore )
(Singapore )
(Singapore )
(Singapore )
(Singapore )
(Singapore )
b. Thai Aromatic
b. Thai Aromatic
b. Thai Aromatic
b. Thai Aromatic
b. Thai Aromatic
b. Thai Aromatic
(Thailand)
(Thailand)
(Thailand)
(Thailand)
(Thailand)
(Thailand)
c. Mitsubishi Gas
c. Mitsubishi Gas
c. Mitsubishi Gas
c. Mitsubishi Gas
c. Mitsubishi Gas
c. Mitsubishi Gas
Chemical,
Chemical,
Chemical,
Chemical,
Chemical,
Chemical, Tonen
Tonen Chemical
Tonen Chemical
Tonen Chemical
Tonen Chemical
Tonen Chemical
Chemical (Japan)
(Japan)
(Japan)
(Japan)
(Japan)
(Japan)
d. China
d. China
d. China
d. China
d. China
d. China
e. Formosa (Taiwan)
e. Formosa (Taiwan) e. Formosa (Taiwan) e. Formosa (Taiwan) e. Formosa (Taiwan) e. Formosa (Taiwan) f. Reliance (India)
f. Reliance (India)
f. Reliance (India)
f. Reliance (India)
f. Reliance (India)
f. Reliance (India)
Port Facilities
Kuantan Port
Johor Port Tanjung
Johor Port Tanjung
Kemaman Port
Bintulu Federal Port [Link] Kinabalu Port
Water supply
Pelepas Port
Semambu Reservoir Sungai Layang
Pelepas Port
Sungai Layang
Kenyir Lake with
Public Work
[Link] Port
[Link] Kinabalu
Capacity : 38 ML/
Capacity: 25 ML/day Capacity: 25 ML/day 39,000 ha of water
Department,
Water Station
day
Flow pressure : 0.04- Flow pressure : 0.04- with 134 m average
Kuching and Sibu
Capacity: 215
Water Boards
ML/day
Water Tariff :
0-- 30 liter/second
227m3:RM 0.92/m3 Water Tariff :
30 liter/second
0-- Water Tariff :
depth
Various
[Link]
0-- treatment plants total Water Tariff: Industry Water Station
>227 m3: RM
20m3:RM 1.20/m3
20m3:RM 1.20/m3
331,000 m3/day
0.84/m3
>20 m3: RM 1.60/m3 >20 m3: RM 1.60/m3 Water Tariff:
0-25m3:RM0.95
Capacity: 90 ML/day
>25m3:RM1.20
Water tariff:
Industry: RM1.15/m3 Commercial
Commercial/ Industry
Commercial:
0-25m3:RM0.88/m3 : RM0.90/m3
700m3:RM0.95
>25m3:RM0.96/m3
>700m3:RM1.15
Transportation
Electric supply
[Link] Coast Highway a. PLUS Highway
a. PLUS Highway
[Link]-West Highway Kuching Airport Pan a. Kota Kinabalu -
[Link] Line
[Link] Airport c.
[Link]-Coast
Highway Track
Kudat Trunk
(linking Kerteh-
Proposed PTP-
Highway
road (Sementan-
[Link] Kinabalu
Gebeng [Link]
Eastern Railway
[Link] Terengganu
Miri,928 km)
Airport
Port [Link] Ahmad
Link-Bangkok
Airport
Shah Airport
d. PTP-Kempas Rail
e. Petronas Kuantan
Link (under
-Rail Link ( under
construction)
development)
Proposed Trans-Asia
Tawau Power Station
[Link] Airport
e.
Railway
Sultan Iskandar
IPP Paka - YTL
Bintulu Power
1200MW (+808MW Power Generation ~
Power Generation ~
Power Generation
Station ~
support)
202 MW (+404
Sdn Bhd. ~ 808 MW MW
IPP Serundong ~
* Electric Tariff : E3 support) Electric
support) Electric
Kenyir Hidro Power Electric Tariff: C3
24.5 MW
tariff : Peak
Tariff : E3 tariff :
Tariff : E3 tariff :
Station ~ 4x100 MW tariff :
Hours:19.8 cent/kWh Peak Hours:19.8
Peak Hours:19.8
Electric
Offpeak:
cent/kWh Offpeak:
cent/kWh Offpeak:
11.8cent/kWh
11.8cent/kWh
11.8cent/kWh
Hours:19.8 cent/kWh 10cent/kWh
Tanjung Gelang ~
Sultan Iskandar
202 MW
(+404
990
Offpeak :
By tonnage:
Transportation Cost RM77.40/ton
By tonnage:
1st 2000 kWh:
32cent/kWh
By
pallet: RM 61.92
RM75.60/ton
By
pallet: RM 60.48
RM75.60/ton
By
pallet: RM 60.48
RM165.600/ton
pallet: RM 132.48
By N/A
>2001
kWh:26 cent/kWh
11.8cent/kWh
By tonnage:
By tonnage:
64 MW
Peak ID 1 tariff:
Tariff Hours:25 cent/kWh
E3 tariff : Peak
Offpeak:
Schelude Waste
Road
N/A
State government
a. *Eastern Corridor a. General Incentives a. General Incentives a. Eastern Corridor
a. Pioneer Status in
a. Pioneer Status
incentives
Incentives
b. Pioneer Status
b. Pioneer Status
Incentive
Sarawak
b. 85% tax exemption
b. Pioneer Status
[Link] Tax
c. Investment Tax
b. General Incentives b. Investment Tax
[Link] Tax
c. Investment Tax
Allowance
Allowance
c. Pioneer Status
Allowance
Allowance
Allowance
[Link]
d. Reinvestment
Investment Tax
c. 2nd round of
d. 30% reduction on
d. Expenditure on
Allowance
Allowance
Allowance
pioneer status
land premium
Infrastructure
[Link] Training e. Manpower
d. Reinvestment
d. Infrastructure
[Link] of quit
e. 5 year exemption
Subsidy
Allowance
Allowance
rent from 3% to 1% of
on Import duty
e. Manpower
e. Low down
the unimproved land
f. 2nd round of
Training Subsidy
payment for the
for industrial use
Training Subsidy
pioneer status
purchase of industrial f. Eligibility to apply
Worker Supply /
UTM, UIA , UiTM,
UTM, Polytechnic
UTM, Polytechnic
TATI , Kolej
Research
PSDC, IKIP,
Universiti
Polytechnic
Terengganu , Safety
land
for an increase of land
f. Flexible terms of
tenure for industrial
payment
land up to 99 years.
UNIMAS
UMS ,UiTM
,polytechnic
Training Center
(Source: MIDA Investment Guide 2001, Rancangan Struktur 2001 for Pahang, Johor, Terengganu, Sarawak and Sabah, Perbadanan Kemajuan
Ekonomi Negeri Pahang, Terengganu, Johor, Sarawak and Sabah Government State)