$ocia Curre Curre AL Ency Ency: Why Brands Need To Build Need To Build and Nurture Social Currency
$ocia Curre Curre AL Ency Ency: Why Brands Need To Build Need To Build and Nurture Social Currency
AL
CURREENCY
Why brands
need to build
and nurture
social currency
Editorial 2
Executive Summary 4
g
Managerial Implications
p 558
Vivaldi Partners
$ocial Currency Study | US 2010 125 Park Avenue, Suite 1500 Acknowledgements 64
New York, NY 10017
Copyright © 2010 Vivaldi Inc. All rights reserved. USA
No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in T
Tel +1 212 965 0900
any form or by any means electronic or mechanical, without Fax +1 212 965 0992
written permission. E-mail info@[Link]
Cover Art: Melanie Eckl W
Web [Link]
1
Editorial I have been studying brands for the last
twenty years. During this time, there has
of media, technologies and networks not
only changes our lives, it irrevocably
I am convinced that this study sheds new
light on the complex and difficult under-
been significant progress in understanding changes how brands are built. taking of building strong brands today.
w brands are important and how brands
why
I am pleased to present, on behalf of Vivaldi I hope that our work will stimulate thoughts
Brands are socially constructed objective become important drivers of innovation and
Partners and the many talented people who and more research, encourage new and
realities.
ea t es. Brands
a s get built
u t tthrough
oug eexpe-
pe g
growth.
workk in
i our company, thi t d off the
this study th b tt practices
better ti iin b i
business, d llead
and d th
the
riences, through people accepting them
T
There has been significant progress in the power of social currency in building strong way into an exciting future of creating value
and making them part of the fabric of their
development of financial frameworks to brands. for companies.
lives.
monetize and measure the value of brands,
For the first time, we deconstruct social
This process of building strong brands is very legal frameworks to protect brands, and a
currency. We find that social currency is not
personal and also very social. host of managerial approaches to build,
just about conversation, buzz or community.
grow nurture and manage brands
grow, brands.
Today, one of the most important strengths It is all this and much more. We find that it
of a brand is its social currency, the extent to But nothing has prepared us to deal with does not impact every brand equally. We Erich Joachimsthaler, PhD
which people share the brand or information today’s revolution in building strong brands. find that certain levers of social currency are Founder and CEO
about the brand with others as part of their T rapid evolution of the Internet and, in
The more important than others in driving value Vivaldi Partners
everyday social lives. particular, the rise of the social web’s forms for companies.
2 3
Executive Summary
AFFILIA
ATION
Social currency is the extent to which people share the brand or information about the brand
as part of their everyday social lives at work or
o at home
IDENTITY CONVERSATION
Our study shows that social currency significantly drives brand loyalty. Moreover, brands
with a high social currency command a price premium
SOC
CIAL Social currency is a means not the end and ne either is it just about buzz or conversation,
CURR
RENCY rather it is about creating meaningful experie
ences around the brand
6 7
PHOTOGRAPHY BY NASA
AFFILIA ATION
IDENTITY CONVERSATION
INFORMATION UTILITY
ADVO OCACY
Information 35 Advocacy 6
64
How many feel they exchange How many act as disciplles and
fruitful information with others? 22
2 stand up for your brand?? 38
14 Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey December 2009, Exemplary results for selected brands and categories
c 15
categories seem to be less dependent on food). Such activities will then directly drive
How social providing a strong sense of community or re-purchase or repeated visits respectively.
currency relying on the user-base to exchange news,
In contrast, consumer brands in the IT
creates value hints or other information.
category, like Apple or Microsoft need to
in categories For example,
example categories like fast food or efficiently address most levers as complexity
beer rely less on strong affiliation amongst of products implicitly leads to higher
Although social currency consists of six core their users but can still tap into social exchange levels and especially tangible
levers, a brand does not necessarily need to currency by helping users to learn from each products are providing today’s light houses
access each lever in order to drive loyalty other (beer) or by strengthening the to convey one’s personality traits just like
and top line growth. Instead, certain identification levels with other patrons (fast automobiles have for the last century.
AUTOMOTIVE (VOLUME)
AIRLINES
BEER
SKIN CARE
FAST FOOD
SPORTSWEAR
ONLINE RETAIL
CONSUMER IT
B2B TECH
one place every day. Airline brands can. A close-knit customer community. First, the Art, where travellers can exchange with
majority of jetBlue customers can identify each other physically or virtually. In addition
But does this given trait of mass transpor-
well with other jetBlue customers. More- to capturing the hustle and bustle of NYC,
tation allow airline brands to get a head
over, 61% of jetBlue customers feel like they the terminal creates a community feeling.
start over brands in other categories in
terms of social currency?
RLIN
CONTINENTTAL
SOUTHWESST
AMERICAN
JETBLUE
UNITED
VIRGIN
DELTA
high
CONTINENTAL
SOUTHWEST
D LOYALTY
AMERICAN
JETBLUE
UNITED
VIRGIN
DELTA
Brand Trust 50 60 70 80 90 100
AIR
BRAND
CONTINENTAL
SOUTHWEST
AMERICAN
JETBLUE
UNITED
VIRGIN
DELTA
SOCIAL CURRENCY high Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
vs. luxury brands. Interestingly, especially member. social belonging to also generate a strong
the latter dimension also shows an effect in community-feeling (see CHART 2).2)
Investigating individual brands more
terms of their social currency systems. closely, it becomes obvious that also volume Especially for a domestic brand this should
As high-involvement products, automobiles makes can utilize social currency levers to be a key objective as this also affects
offer a continuous platform for conversation provide an additional selling proposition. recommendation levels.
TOM
would fully agree on Toyota’s exceptional a relatively worse decline in providing social
quality levels and reliability of its cars. Just
a few
f weeks k llater
t ththese scores ddropped d TOYOTA DRIVERS: PRE
PRE-POST-
POST RECALL
dramatically.
l Quality perception wears away
In an instant long-built brand equity had
been eroded. Why? Very good quality FROM 96% DOWN 16v TO 80%
Automobiles not only offer functional value Reliability FROM 92% DOWN 19v TO 73%
AUT
MERCEDES
TOYOTA
HONDA
LEXUS
FORD
high
BMW
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
D LOYALTY
MERCEDES
TOYOTA
HONDA
LEXUS
FORD
BMW
AUT
MERCEDES
TOYOTA
HONDA
LEXUS
FORD
BMW
SOCIAL CURRENCY high Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
nursing a community feeling of consumers Quality Trust “I feel a connection to other users
of the same brand. of this brand”
Where mass brands like Corona, Coors, or
89% 86%
Miller are struggling, however, is when it
comes to a dialog about the brand. Ob-
viously people are enjoying the taste but do
not feel inclined to discuss their beer
47 57
brands. A different usage pattern can be
Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey, Average Top2-Box-Scores on a 5 point scale across beer cateegory 31
CATEGORY RANKING SOCIAL CURRENCY LEVERS
MS
BUDWEISERR
SAM ADAM
GUINNESS
HEINEKEN
CORONA
COORS
MILLER
high
SAM ADAMS
BUDWEISER
D LOYALTY
GUINNESS
HEINEKEN
CORONA
COORS
MILLER
Brand Trust 50 60 70 80 90 100
BRAND
SAM ADAMS
BUDWEISER
GUINNESS
HEINEKEN
CORONA
COORS
MILLER
SOCIAL CURRENCY high Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
Also, similar to the beer category fast food “Through other users of this brand I get
Social Currency Scores
brands are clearly social-driven, as con- to learn something new”
sumption patterns are often embedded into
FAS
NG
D‘S
BURGER KIN
STARBUCKS
S
MCDONALD
TACO BELL
PIZZA HUT
WENDY‘S
DUNKIN`
high
KFC
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
BURGER KING
MCDONALD‘S
STARBUCKS
D LOYALTY
TACO BELL
PIZZA HUT
WENDY‘S
DUNKIN`
KFC
FAS
BURGER KING
MCDONALD‘S
STARBUCKS
TACO BELL
PIZZA HUT
WENDY‘S
DUNKIN`
KFC
SOCIAL CURRENCY high Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
their skin treatment. the brand (51%) – see CHART 2. In contrast the brand’s buzz is conversation worthy but
to many of today’s brands, Clinique would unsustainable. Additionally, by appealing to
Market leaders like Gillette have not built
not be a typical Web 22.0
0 protagonist.
protagonist every woman,
woman the brand doesndoesn’tt encourage
CAR
f b d that
»fun-brands« th t ttargett a ffocused
d segmentt SKIN CARE: BRANDS AS PLATFORMS FOR ENGAGEMENT
have fared better, however only managing
to create a limited sense of community (e.g. CHART 1 CHART 2
only one out of four Axe users feels “I can identify myself well with
affiliated to others). Satisfied with brand other users of this brand”
Women across all ages, as opposed to men, 94%
tend to seek social exchange regarding this
product category. Skin care remains a much Do share experience
48%
more relevant issue for females and peer-to- 14%
peer distribution concepts like Avon’s are
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%100%
hard to imagine within a male setting.
Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey, US Pre-Recall (December 2009) and Post-Recall (February 20010), Top2-Box-Scores on a 5 point scale 39
CATEGORY RANKING SOCIAL CURRENCY LEVERS
CLINIQUE
GILLETTE
NIVEA
AVON
DOVE
high
AXE
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
D LOYALTY
CLINIQUE
GILLETTE
NIVEA
AVON
DOVE
AXE
Brand Trust 50 60 70 80 90 100
BRAND
CLINIQUE
GILLETTE
NIVEA
AVON
DOVE
AXE
SOCIAL CURRENCY high Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
This result
Thi lt comes as a bi
big surprise
i ffrom a Arguably,
A bl Puma’s ’ strategic
i evolution
l i to-
traditional brand equity perspective as wards a lifestyle focus has helped the brand
Community experience lies at the heart of powerhouses such as Nike and Adidas fall to gain extra social currency with consumers
every major sportswear brand. Ever since, behind. However, social currency does not that would not have been accessible for a
iconic brands such as Nike, Adidas or focus on traditional brand equity measures smaller player with a rather narrow
TSW
Reebok have created and promoted com- such as brand awareness. It measures the sportswear focus.
munity sports experiences to the fullest
fullest. social value a brand provides within its own
It also apparently enabled the brand to take
customer base.
In the early 90s, Adidas launched their over a more significant role in consumers’
hugely successful “Streetball Challenge”. Compared to larger brands, Puma seems to daily lives – resulting in increased con-
Similarly, Nike has engaged its brand in have created the biggest social value. versation, affiliation, and identification bet-
numerous sports sponsorships from region- Especially in the areas affiliation (45%) and ween Puma users.
al to global level over the last decades. With
ORT
th rapid
the id emergence off th
the Internet
I t t and
d SPORTSWEAR: BRAND FOCUS IMPACTS SOCIAL CURRENCY
especially the social web in recent years,
major sportswear brands have moved into CHART 1 CHART 2
miAdidas have been rolled out to create new Identification with other users
and meaningful experiences for consumers 60%
around their brand. Affiliation with other users
CE
RS
N. BALANC
SKETCHER
REEBOK
ADIDAS
PUMA
high
NIKE
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
N. BALANCE
SKETCHERS
D LOYALTY
REEBOK
ADIDAS
SPO
PUMA
NIKE
Brand Trust 50 60 70 80 90 100
BRAND
N. BALANCE
SKETCHERS
REEBOK
ADIDAS
PUMA
NIKE
SOCIAL CURRENCY high Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
AMAZON
ITUNES
high
EBAY
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
D LOYALTY
AMAZON
ITUNES
EBAY
Brand Trust 50 60 70 80 90 100
BRAND
AMAZON
ITUNES
EBAY
SOCIAL CURRENCY high Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
currency Microsoft (41%) – see CHART 1. part people love to talk about or feel con
con-
nected through little branded experiences
It remains a digital tool that is being used
(white headphones).
Within the TIME industry, consumers are on a global basis over 200 million times a
increasingly overwhelmed by the ongoing day. However, it is not viewed as a social Apple has never strived to be the best
convergence of the offerings. The arising product so far. Google has just recently hammer. The iPod for example has never
opportunities oftentimes are not only started to enter this field (e.g. Nexus or guaranteed a true HiFi-experience, but it
exciting but also very complex.
complex An historical Google Buzz).
Buzz) Google is beloved,
beloved admired - guaranteed a social experience more than
and manufacturer-driven uni-directional but not a very much social product. It is a any higher quality player. This may explain,
Q&A logic can hardly cover the endless reliable helper, but not a partner one would why Google as future Apple competitor has
angles services or products offer today. have a dear relationship with or exchange been launching various activities to build
about with others – see CHART 2. social currency now.
Instead, studies show that consumers seem
NSU
MICROSOFTT
APPLE
high
MICROSOFT
D LOYALTY
GOOGLE
APPLE
CON
MICROSOFT
GOOGLE
APPLE
SOCIAL CURRENCY high Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
customers which in turn have a much (62%) and affiliation (65%) among its US base. Hence, it will be crucial for SAP to
greater buying power over supplier brands. customer base. Yet, also the runner-up identify and implement the right measures
brand SAP has strong potential to leverage to build further social currency and by that
This is why B2B brands have always spent
the intense interaction among its user base. strengthen brand success in the US market.
significant budgets and time to build up and
nurture direct, personal and mutual rela-
ti
tionships
hi with
ith th
their
i customers.
t B2B TECH: GIANTS THAT CREATE SOCIAL RELEVANCE
However, B2B investment decisions are not
CHART 1 CHART 2
made by individuals. Purchase decisions in
B2B contexts are rather co-created by a Social Currency Scores
multitude of actors (buying centers) based
B2B
Positive conversation
on rationalized, multi-staged evaluation
processes on customer side. This may be
43%
Brand Advocacy
the reason why many B2B players have
considered their brand as door-opener 61 50 47%
rather than crucial selling point for a long 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%
time.
Source: Vivaldi Partners social currency survey, Top2-Box-Scores on a 5 point scale 55
CATEGORY RANKING SOCIAL CURRENCY LEVERS
ORACLE
CISCO
high
SAP
IBM
HP
Quality Perception 50 60 70 80 90 100
D LOYALTY
ORACLE
CISCO
SAP
IBM
B2B
HP
Brand Trust 50 60 70 80 90 100
BRAND
ORACLE
CISCO
SAP
IBM
HP
SOCIAL CURRENCY high Recommendation 50 60 70 80 90 100
solve the challenges and issues in the GRAHAM BROWN They like marketers to provide them with
context of their daily life. meaningful solutions to take care of the
STEP THREE. Define the social currency problems, challenges and routine tasks of
STEP TWO. Determine the levers of social
strategy. This involves first and foremost life.
currency that drive value in the industry or
d idi what
deciding h t levers
l off social
i l currency will
ill
category. It is important to assess and In order to address these challenges,
create value for a company or brand.
evaluate the permission and power of social companies need to embrace social tech-
Strategy is about making trade-offs and
currency within the category or industry. It is nologies, networks and media not merely as
hence it is important to choose wisely and
necessary to understand in what social a means of marketing or communicating to
define the activities that contribute to value
episodes and context the brand plays a role consumers but as a way of doing business.
creation through social currency.
and what specific social benefit it generates. Companies need to reengineer their pro-
Competitive
i i efforts
ff matter as well, ll as our STEP FOUR. Develop and execute social cesses and systems inside their organi-
study shows. The degree to which con- currency programs that drives value. This zation based on a view from the outside-in –
sumers choose to give a brand permission requires establishing a program that mixes how people interact with brands in today’s
to be part of their social life is relative to digital and social technologies and context of social networks, media and
competitors’ effort and success. traditional brand-building activities. In technologies.
PHOTOGRAPHY BY ICHAZ/FLICKR
61
PHOTOGRAPHY BY MICHAEL CLARKE STUFF/FLICKR
CORPORATE STRAT.
CUSTOMER BOARD
OPEN INNOVATION
CULTURAL VALUES
BUSINESS MODEL
SOCIAL FEATURES
PRODUCT DESIGN
operating mindset in an organization that can decide whether they should invest in
CUSTOMER CLUB
BRAND IDENTITY
M&A STRATEGY
SOCIAL MEDIA
EDUTAINMENT
CO-BRANDING
HR TRAININGS
MOBILE APPS
SPONSORING
ADVERTISING
changes how a company formulates a social currency and how they can most
PORTFOLIO
CHANNELS
strategy, how it structures its organization, efficiently profit from their efforts in buil-
EVENTS
CRM
and how it organizes its value-creating ding strong brands and connecting con-
processes around a common vision; a vision sumers in meaningful and new ways. Affiliation Conversation through
Social Media
off h
how a company or b brands
d iinteract to
As the chart on the opposite page illus- Dunkin’ Donuts runs
solve daily or life challenges and delivers various social media Affiliation through
trates, there is a host of measures to efforts. Many are directed Product Design
Conversation on triggering exchange
against goals of consumers or customers with peers like the group
Apple generated strong
address specific levers. How social a brand order idea »Dunkin’ Run «
affiliation amongst its
given their ecosystem. iPod user-base through
experience gets depends already on basic Utility
the eye-catching white
earphones and white
cable
It also will require companies to change how factors like a businesses’ strategy or cor-
they operate and choose to interact with responding objectives for the product road- Utilityy through
g
Advocacy
Events Identity through
consumers or customers. It will require map. But of course it can also be affected by Customer Clubs
Oracle’s annual gatheringg
establishing a company culture around smart communication activities. To really allows users to meet live
with others from around
Lufthansa’s top clientele
Information (>300k miles p.a.) gain
consumers’ ecosystem. It will require excel, a thoroughly integrated set of tools the globe »to network, peer recognition thanks
learn, and celebrate« to elite services (such as
their own role as expert Porsche-shuttling to the
defining new behaviors, and developing will be most rewarding – for both the brand plane or first row seating)
people to deliver. and its customers and consumers Identity
62 63
Thanks TThis study is part of a larger initiative bet-
w
ween a consortium of companies to under-
Vivaldi Partners
The study of the power of social currency in stand the power of social media and net-
building strong brands is based on a joint re- w
works on building strong brands, on how to
search initiative of Vivaldi Partners and Prof. connect with customers and consumers,
Johann Füller who is affiliated how to create breakthrough innovations and
with
ith th
the U
University
i it off IInns- new growth,
th andd how
h tto change
h companies
i
bruck and MIT Sloan. Our and create innovation cultures.
study has benefited greatly from a strong The Authors
TThese companies include Fifth Season, a
academic foundation as well as from the Dr. Erich Joachimsthaler, CEO & Founder Please direct all inquiries about the
global innovation boutique that produces
wealth of experiences of client executives. ej@[Link] Social Currency US study to:
breakthrough experience innovation con-
For the fieldwork we are indebted to our com- cepts and E-Edge, a company Dr. Markus Pfeiffer, Managing Partner
petent survey partner, Lightspeed Research, that seeks to create winning mpfeiffer@vivaldipartners com
mpfeiffer@[Link]
Peri Schaeffer
who carried out the online innovation cultures in organi- Dr. Markus Zinnbauer, Director
125 Park Avenue, 15th Floor
field work in the U.S.A. in- zations through management development, mzinnbauer@[Link]
New York, NY 10017 USA
vestigating over 1,000 respondents in the and HYVE that specializes in innovation Tobias Honer, Senior Consultant
time frame of Dec 2009 and Jan 2010. management through online communities. thoner@[Link] info@[Link]
64 65
VIVALDI PARTNERS
P
[Link]
[Link]