Centralized vs. Decentralized Filing Systems
Centralized vs. Decentralized Filing Systems
Records
management
practices
encompasses
from
controlling
their
Objectives:
There are several issues to consider when making the decision on where
your records should be located. One of the best ways to approach it is to
review the advantages and disadvantages of each system and choose the
one, or combination, that has the most advantages for your situation.
Centralized filing locations usually come in the form of a file room that
serves the entire department or division. There are many benefits to having
a centralized filing location:
To pin point
A centralized filing system is:
One in which the records for several people or units are located in
one, central location; and,
Advantages:
Reduces duplication.
Improved security.
Disadvantages:
Decentralized System
A decentralized filing system is:
One in which the files are located throughout the office, generally at
individual work stations; and,
Advantages:
Staff feels more comfortable knowing they are in control of their own
filing and retrieving.
Disadvantages:
A file room for files which are inactive but which are not ready to be
sent to the archives
A public reference room for files which are accessed by the public.
Those records which are maintained at individual work stations are also
part of the organization's filing system and included in the office file plan
so that everyone in the office knows where the records are located and who
is responsible for maintaining them.
Under this section the different types of filling equipment and supplies
along with the factors used to evaluate them are discussed.
Objective:
Identify and justify the need for proper filling equipment and
supplies
Identify and grasp the different factors used to evaluate filling
equipments
Identify the different types of filling equipments and supplies
Office space is expensive, so you should try to choose filing cabinets that
make the best use of your space. When you measure for filing cabinets,
remember to include the space that you need to pull out a drawer and to
stand in front of the cabinet.
To figure out how much storage space you need, first inventory your active
records. Then figure out your future needs by looking at how fast the
volume of files grows each year. For example, if you expect that the volume
of active files will grow by ten percent per year over the next five years, you
will need 50 percent more storage space than you have now. It is a good
idea to include an extra 15 percent more storage space for contingencies.
You may have certain groups of records that require a higher degree of
security. These records should be stored in locking cabinets. You may want
to store vital or essential records in equipment that has a high fire rating.
Secure and fire safe cabinets are more expensive, so they should only be
purchased to meet a specific need.
V) Equipment Costs:
10
You should figure out your departments storage, space, and security
requirements before you begin to look how much the filing cabinets will
cost. Different types of cabinets have different storage capacities. When you
compare prices, adjust the figures so that you are comparing costs for
equal amounts of file storage space. Its affordability for the organization
should be assessed carefully.
The main ongoing operational cost is for the supplies. Legal-sized and
letter-sized file folders do not cost the same amount. Likewise, end-tab and
top-tab file folders are different prices.
In some cases, the physical format of the records will make your
purchasing decisions for you. Special media, like maps, drawings, videos,
films, microfilm, and diskettes, may require special storage equipment.
You should also think about how many people will be using the cabinets,
and how they will retrieve records from it. Open shelf filing cabinets lets a
large number of people access the files at the same time. Vertical, lateral,
11
and mobile cabinets work best if only one or two people are accessing the
files at the same time. You may also need to take someones physical
abilities into consideration. For example, a person in a wheelchair may not
be able to reach files that are in the top drawer of a tall cabinet.
and
protection
and
cost
efficiency.
Purchasing
filing
equipment is a complex matter and input from the users is invaluable. The
staff of the records management of a certain organization can obtain
guidance and advice in the purchase of filing equipment that meets the
need of your office with the greatest cost efficiency from producers etc.
Some of the most popular types of filing equipment used by most
organizations are cabinets, shelves, lateral files and drawers. They are
discussed here in detail.
A) File Cabinets: There are four commonly types of filing cabinets which
can be used for storing paper records.
1. Vertical File
12
and
contain
files
in
either
alphabetic
or
topical
arrangements.
13
14
These cabinets are among the most versatile of all filing units and can be
used equally well for legal and letter size files. However, they are not very
economical in terms of cost or floor space requirements. The cost of lateral
cabinets and the space that they occupy is greater per filing inch than
either vertical cabinets or shelves. Moreover, it requires a space for the
person who accesses the files. Like vertical files, lateral cabinets offer the
advantages of controlled access with locks and some fire resistance.
15
therefore, files are protected neither from fire nor unauthorized access.
Equipping shelf files with doors adds significantly to their cost and negates
many of the advantages of easy access by many users.
Shelf files are ideal for large record series and work equally well for
numeric or alphabetic filing systems. It is a system which works best when
entire case files are pulled and not individual documents within a file
folder. Color coding of file folders adds to the increased filing accuracy
which can be achieved with open shelf filing systems.
The open shelf file unit is the most economical of all available filing
systems and can provide answers to problems originating from rising file
costs, lack of office space, and file retrieval difficulties.
16
Mobile filing systems are designed to maximize storage space and minimize
retrieval times. They are most commonly used in central filing rooms.
Each type of cabinet has good and bad points. If you choose your filing
cabinets carefully, you will increase the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of
your departments records management program.
File equipment and its advantages of space compaction should be very
carefully analyzed before it is adopted over more conventional file storage
systems.
A. Guides
B. File folders
C. Labels
17
A. Guides
Guides are heavy cardboard sheets that are the same size as the folders.
They have tabs which indicate the notation or the mark that the guide
provides information which is named as a caption. Guides serve as
"signposts" to lead the searcher to specific portions of the file or folder.
Guides may be used within a drawer to highlight a primary
classification, to identify a record series, to highlight a specific year, or
may be used within a record series to identify portions of the file as
required.
Guides/Auxiliary
or
special
name
guides/:
are
subdivisions of the primary guides so that they are used to show the
exact position of each specific record in a folder or drawer.
C) Out Guides: It is a guide placed in a folder or drawer in place of a
record taken out for some purpose. In other words, it is a reminder
for the inexistence of a record at its right place so that the record
officer will aware the record is not misfiled and lost rather it is on
loan.
18
B)
Folders:
A file folder / folder is constructed from heavy paper sheets used to hold
individual files or records together for organization and protection. File
folders usually consist of a sheet of heavy paper stock or other thin, but
19
stiff, material which is folded in half, and are used to keep paper
documents
C. Labels:
20
primary classification
dates
folder title
Electronic files
21
Electronic files follow many of the same file identification and labeling
guidelines as paper files. Records are organized by directories which act as
the primary classification. Each directory contains folders which act as
record series. Finally, each folder contains individual documents whose
names should represent their subject matter.
22
Under this section we will discuss those concepts which are related with
the filling of records of an organization.
Objectives:
23
system is to keep all like records together, which, in turn, expedites records
retrieval and maintains file integrity.
The prime purpose of a classification scheme is to provide control and
consistency over the vocabulary used for titling of files and indexing
records. It does so by providing listing of approved terms for file titling and
indexing. Knowing which terms to search on means that searches will be
more efficient and retrieval of the right records is facilitated.
The file classification Scheme is a starting point for the creation of files
across an organization, it is not meant to be a complete tool to meet every
file title need and therefore does not try and provide for every file title
across curtail. The classification Scheme is not an index of file titles but
simply a tool to assist staff to consistently title files and build the areas file
index.
24
Generally, if the volume of records exceeds two file cabinets and consists of
multiple records series, then a files classification system should be
considered. Classification systems sort records by major headings and
subdivisions. The major heading name usually is decided by the major
function or main purpose of the records; the subdivision would be a small
component of the major function. For example:
Major Heading:
Sub-Heading:
Payroll Section
Tertiary Heading:
Payroll Timesheets
25
Developing an index
____________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________
26
I) Alphabetical Filing
These may be topical or classified arrangements. Topical filing arranges
files in straight alphabetical order. For example, subject correspondence
would be arranged from A-Z, based on the name of the subject. This
method is also called the "dictionary" method because it is the method
used in dictionaries.
Classified filing places related documents under a major sub-heading. For
example, customer complaint correspondence may be filed under the
general heading of customer relations. An alphabetical arrangement also is
appropriate for filing records that are arranged by geographical locations,
such as cities, towns or counties. This system is also called "encyclopedic"
27
28
The file system is always growing in one direction at the end. When
new files are created and old ones are retired, file personnel must
continually shift the files backwards to make room for new files at the
highest number end of the system.
29
Users must be trained, and, even then, one user may interpret where
to file a document differently than another, leading to confusion and
a breakdown of the filing order.
IV) Subject filling system: it is the one which files records according to
the subject, theme, idea and topic of records
V) Geographic Filling: Uses the location of the files in filling them. Filling
depends on the place where they are received or where they were created
VI) Chorological Filling: the date in which the record is created or
received is taken in to consideration to file records.
30
Indirect Access
31
4.5. INDEXING
32
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
What about indexing?
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Thank you for trying the question, now read the description given below.
An index is a listing of files arranged alphabetically or numerically that is
used to determine where files are located. If you have an indirect access
filing system (like one that is arranged numerically), you must have an
index in order to find the file. The most common type of index is called a
relative index. It alphabetically lists the various combinations of how
records might be requested. If one is looking for property deeds, for
instance, one might look under "Deeds, property." If one is looking for the
Department of Highways Maps, one might search for "Maps, Department of
Highways." Both the headings (Deeds, Maps) and sub-headings (property,
Department of Highways) will be arranged in alphabetical order. This type
of index is used in most published material such as books or periodicals.
Any reference book or textbook can be used to see an example of this.
33
Whenever multiple terms can be applied to the same records, a crossreference is created to the indexed topic. The cross-reference acts as a
pointer to redirect the user to another location where the file can be found.
For example, patient records can be cross-referenced by patient number,
name and Social Security number. However cumbersome it may seem to do
this at the outset, if those responsible for creating individual files are
taught to index those three parameters each time a file is created, the
process becomes routine and easy very quickly.
If a computer database is available, or the software to create a spreadsheet
can be bought (many can be bought off the shelf from office supply stores),
that's ideal. Through keywords or descriptors, documents and their
locations can be accessed in a matter of seconds. For those who are not
able to do this and must budget for it in the future, the time to set up the
index manually is not wasted. Any system that is created electronically
must have first created an index manually.
34
_________________________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
Why we need a security for our valuable records?
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
What are the possible threats `for valuable records?
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________
Have you tried the questions? Thank you! Proceed to the discussion given
below.
35
Caring for your historical and valuable records involves both managing
your records collection and managing the environment that your records
are in. Your building and storage areas dont have to be part of a specially
designed facility in order to provide adequate protection for your records
collection.
In this lesson we have discussed several aspects of the physical
environment--from leaking roofs to different levels of shelving. The outside
shell of your building ultimately needs good routine maintenance and care
in order to adequately protect your records. The storage areas need to be
the best that you can provide and I have provided good, better, and best
scenarios for you to consider. Do the best you can with what you have, and
work to meet the good standard in order to provide the minimal amount
of protection for your historical records collections.
Building security refers to the measures that are taken to address the
physical safety of the building and the collections housed within it.
When addressing security issues, you address the
Physical Security
36
Your building, and in particular your storage areas, must be secure during
and after normal working hours. Security measures need to prevent
unauthorized entrance to the building as well as unauthorized removal of
collections from the building. There are six practical things to consider
about the security of your facility.
1. Doors: They should be strong and well constructed, as should
their frames. Did you know that in most burglaries the door is
broken down?
Security measures should protect both your building and your collections.
Security measures should protect both your Security measures should
protect both your building and your collections building and your
collections.
37
2. Locks: A lock is a must for records storage and for reference and
workspace. Deadbolt locks that have a bolt separate from the knob are
vital.
38
39
40
Patron Management
Patron theft and vandalism can also be a problem. There are many
reported incidents of users stealing historical items. Some precautions you
should take are to:
Require researchers to present a valid photo identification card
before using collections; some programs make copies of the
identification
and
add
it
to
the
users
file.
Control access to the area the researchers use; have only one
exit that requires users to walk past a reference desk or other
staffed area.
41
Use and retain call slips so you can track what a particular
researcher used.
Implementing Security Precautions
Draft Some Regulations!
If you dont already have them, you should draft security regulations for
your historical records program. Many programs choose to use two sets of
regulations--one for staff and another for users. However you do it, security
concerns should be built into all your policies and procedures.
Staff related security regulations should include:
42
Rules for staff requesting and using collections for their own research
Aaaaaasecurity policy.
Require Users to Sign In
43
No matter how small or understaffed your program may be, you must
require your users to sign in and you must keep a record of the materials
they use. Provide an area for users to work in that is visible to staff (paid or
volunteer) and where it is difficult for them to leave the room or building
unobserved.
Check Users' Belongings
If supervision of researchers isnt always possible, it is VITAL that
collections are checked after being used. Some programs ask users to have
their belongings checked when they exit the building. Certainly this can be
awkward, but most users will be cooperative if the reasons for the
precautions are clearly explained to them. Do not search anyones
belongings without their consent; and, if you choose this method, obtain
some legal counsel before deciding upon how to implement it.
Responding to Security Problems
Put Someone In Charge
Appoint someone on your staff to be in charge of security issues. This
person should be responsible for conducting assessments of existing
security measures and making recommendations for changes that need to
be made. Your security manager should also create guidelines for
responding to security incidents. This person should work with the local
police department on how to handle security incidents.
44
Train Staff
Staff should be trained in dealing with security incidents. Be sure to
contact your local police department, who can help you understand the
legal parameters of dealing with security incidents. You must clearly
understand what your staff can lawfully do when security incidents occur.
Some basic guidelines are below:
Staff should not take any action unless the incident was witnessed or
material is proven missing. (If the materials being used were
inspected before AND after patron use and materials were
undoubtedly missing after use by this specific patron.)
Invite the patron into an office or another area, with a second staff
member present.
If the patron agrees to be detained, contact the local police and await
their arrival.
If the patron insists on leaving, one staff person should notify the
authorities while a second staff member carefully escorts the patron
out of the building (and records the plate number of the patrons
automobile!).
45
Summary
For future reference, records should be stored well. However, in storing
files, they should be organized so that locating, retrieving and accessing
them will be very easy.
46
47
Security measures alone are insufficient to entirely prevent theft of historical records; they require careful implementation and comprehensive management. Effective practices include regular inventory checks, organized storage, limited researcher access, and clear labeling. Additionally, security systems such as locks, alarms, and controlled access protocols enhance effectiveness, but they must be complemented by staff awareness and management procedures . Human oversight plays a vital role, as thefts often occur during working hours and due to human negligence . Ultimately, integrating both physical security and rigorous management practices is crucial for robust protection of collections.
When selecting filing cabinets, key considerations should include storage space efficiency, cost efficiency, and specific organizational needs. Vertical filing cabinets, although requiring significant floor space and aisle clearance, can be cost-efficient with added fire protection and controlled access if insulated or equipped with locks . Lateral file cabinets, despite offering versatility and controlled access, tend to be more expensive and require more space compared to vertical cabinets. Moreover, the specific physical format of records, like special equipment needed for maps or films, might dictate the type of filing cabinet chosen . Therefore, determining the appropriate type involves assessing both operational factors and the physical constraints of the storage environment.
A structured security policy is vital for managing access to historical records as it establishes clear guidelines and protocols to prevent unauthorized access and protect valuable documents. It involves roles and responsibilities for staff, detailed access procedures, and handling protocols for any security breaches. Key challenges in implementing such policies include ensuring staff compliance, balancing accessibility with security, and managing the cost and limitations of security technologies . Moreover, building awareness and preventing unauthorized behavior during regular operations are crucial as most issues arise due to human error. Thus, a comprehensive policy aids in safeguarding historical records while enabling controlled access based on well-defined criteria.
A file plan is crucial for maintaining an efficient filing system, as it dictates how documents are identified, stored, and retrieved. It ensures consistency, minimizes misfiles, and aids efficient retrieval by providing a structured approach to document organization. A comprehensive file plan should include selecting a proper file arrangement (alphabetical, numerical, etc.), developing an index for easy reference, and establishing procedures for ongoing file system maintenance . These elements collectively help in streamlining document flow and accessibility, enhancing overall organizational efficiency by providing clear, logical pathways for document retrieval and management.
Open shelf filing systems differ significantly from cabinet systems in security and accessibility. They provide easier and faster access to documents for multiple users simultaneously since records are stored visibly on open shelves. However, this ease of access comes at the cost of security; open shelves do not typically protect records from unauthorized access or environmental damage unless equipped with additional security features . This necessitates stricter access controls and monitoring to mitigate risks. For document management, it means balancing the trade-off between accessibility and security, choosing open shelves for non-sensitive, high-turnover documents, and more secure cabinets for sensitive or vital records.
Balancing cost and security when managing vital records requires an organization to strategically align its equipment expenses with its security needs. High fire-rated secure cabinets are expensive and should be chosen only if necessary for essential records protection . Organizations should evaluate their storage and security requirements to determine the necessity of such equipment while considering alternative storage methods that may provide adequate security at a lower cost. Conducting a risk assessment to identify which records need maximum protection can guide investment decisions, ensuring a cost-effective approach that doesn't compromise on the security and integrity of vital information .
A well-organized filing system significantly enhances document retrieval efficiency by allowing users to quickly locate files through a logical and standardized arrangement, such as alphabetical, numerical, or subject-based systems . This reduces the risk of misfiles and user frustration, as files are predictable in their arrangement. In contrast, a poorly structured system can lead to excessive misfiles and inconsistencies, causing delays in retrieval and potential loss of information. A consistent filing structure supports operational workflow and organizational efficiency, whereas a disorganized system can disrupt processes and impact productivity negatively .
Lateral file cabinets differ from vertical ones primarily in terms of space utilization and access style. Lateral cabinets store files horizontally, which can facilitate quicker access for frequently used files since they resemble open shelves. They require less aisle clearance for drawer access, typically about 30 inches . However, they occupy more floor space per filing inch compared to vertical cabinets, which might require up to 42 inches of aisle clearance but offer more space efficiency when vertical space is premium . Therefore, choice depends on the office configuration and frequency of file retrieval, with lateral cabinets more suitable for high-traffic areas needing quick access.
Collection management in the context of security involves a systematic approach to inventory, organize, and monitor historical records, ensuring their protection against theft or loss. It is essential because it provides a framework for knowing exactly what is in the collection, its location, and condition, allowing for immediate detection of discrepancies. This includes regular inventories, clear labeling, ensuring collections are intact before and after access, and maintaining detailed usage logs . Without effective collection management, institutions risk losing valuable historical information and compromising the integrity of the records through lack of oversight and documentation.
Alphabetical filing offers the advantage of straightforward document retrieval without the need for a separate index when used uniformly, allowing users to browse files easily . It is effective in environments where documents are frequently accessed and require quick referencing, such as in customer service settings or libraries. However, it is more prone to misfiling than numerical systems and may falter if filing rules aren't strictly followed . It is most effectively used when documents have clear titles or subjects that align with the alphabetical structure, such as alphabetical arrangements of geographical locations or subject correspondences.









