Banking Needs of SMEs: A Study Report
Banking Needs of SMEs: A Study Report
CERTIFICATE
Certified that this project report &STUDY ON BANKING PATTERN AND NEEDS OF SMES.' is the bo afide !or" of # NIIKHIL VIRMANI' !ho carried o$t the project !or" $ der the s$per%isio of Mr& 'ra a% Mishra&
SIGNATURE 'RANAV MI(HRA HEAD OF THE DEPARTMENT ))A LL*IM( Ma di road+ ,a di ,a di Ne! de-hi . /9
road+
2 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
DECLARATION
0his !or" has ot pre%io$s-1 bee accepted i s$bsta ce for a 1 de2ree a d is ot bei 2 co c$rre t-1 s$b,itted i ca didat$re for a 1 de2ree 3 dip-o,a& (i2 ed4 55555555&& *ate4 555555555&& S,/,*1*-, 2 0his project is the res$-t of ,1 o! i depe de t !or"3i %esti2atio + e6cept !here other!ise stated& 7ther so$rces are ac" o!-ed2ed b1 2i%i 2 e6p-icit refere ces& A bib-io2raph1 is appe ded&
8 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
ACKNO"LEDGEMENT
I o!e a 2reat ,a 1 tha "s to a 2reat ,a 1 peop-e !ho he-ped a d s$pported ,e d$ri 2 the !riti 2 of this report& M1 deepest tha "s to Lect$rer+ 9MR&'RANAV MI(HRA: for correcti 2 %ario$s doc$,e ts of ,i e !ith atte tio a d care& He has ta"e pai to 2o thro$2h the project a d ,a"e ecessar1 correctio as a d !he eeded& I e6press ,1 tha "s to the hod of+ 9)&)&A:+ for e6te di 2 his s$pport& M1 deep se se of 2ratit$de to MR&'RANAV MI(HRA+ 9STUDY ON BANKING PATTERN AND NEEDS OF SMES: s$pport a d 2$ida ce& 0ha "s a d appreciatio to the he-pf$- peop-e at 9STUDY ON BANKING PATTERN AND NEEDS OF SMES:+ for their s$pport& I !o$-d a-so -i"e to tha " ,1 I stit$te a d ,1 fac$-t1 ,e,bers !itho$t !ho, this project !o$-d ha%e bee a dista t rea-it1&
/ NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
1 2 3 4 5
Introduction !b"ective# $ %cope of &ro"ect )et*odolog+ Anal+#i# and Interpretation Conclu#ion -ibliograp*+ 05 35 3' 3( 3, 41 42 '4 '' (0 (1 (1
7. 8. 9. 10. 11.
; NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
INTRODUCTION
(,a-- a d Medi$, < terprises =(M<s> ha%e p-a1ed a si2 ifica t ro-e !or-d o%er i the eco o,ic de%e-op,e t of %ario$s co$ tries& 7%er a period of ti,e+ it has bee pro%ed that (M<s are d1 a,ic+ i o%ati%e a d ,ost i,porta t-1+ the e,p-o1er of first resort to ,i--io s of peop-e i the co$ tr1& 0he sector is a breedi 2 2ro$ d for e trepre e$rship& 0he i,porta ce of (M< sector is !e--.reco2 i?ed !or-d o%er o!i 2 to its si2 ifica t co trib$tio i achie%i 2 %ario$s [Link] o,ic objecti%es+ s$ch as to atio a- o$tp$t a d e6ports+ e,p-o1,e t 2e eratio + co trib$tio the eco o,1& (,a-- a d ,edi$,.si?ed e terprises =(M<s> are the bac"bo e of a-eco o,ies a d are a "e1 so$rce of eco o,ic 2ro!th+ d1 a,is, a d f-e6ibi-it1 i ad%a ced i d$stria-i?ed co$ tries+ as !e-- as i e,er2i 2 a d de%e-opi 2 eco o,ies& (M<s co stit$te the do,i a t for, of b$si ess or2a i?atio + acco$ ti 2 for o%er 9;@ a d $p to 99@ of e terprises depe di 2 o creatio s i the co$ tr1& 0he1 are respo sib-e for bet!ee 60.70@ et job *e%e-opi 2 co$ tries& (,a-- b$si esses are partic$-ar-1 o%ati%e prod$cts or tech iA$es to the ,ar"et&
Microsoft ,a1 be a soft!are 2ia t toda1+ b$t it started off i t1pica- (M< fashio + as a drea, de%e-oped b1 a 1o$ 2 st$de t !ith the he-p of fa,i-1 a d frie ds& 7 -1 !he )i-- Bates a d his co--ea2$es had a sa-eab-e prod$ct
6 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
!ere the1 ab-e to ta"e it to the ,ar"etp-ace a d -oo" for i %est,e t fro, ,ore traditio a- so$rces& (M<s are %ita- for eco o,ic 2ro!th a d de%e-op,e t i both i d$stria-i?ed a d de%e-opi 2 co$ tries+ b1 p-a1i 2 a "e1 ro-e i creati 2 e! jobs& Ci a ci 2 is ecessar1 to he-p the, set $p e! staff a d e6pa d their operatio s+ de%e-op e! prod$cts+ a d i %est i
or prod$ctio faci-ities& Ma 1 s,a-- b$si esses start o$t as a idea fro, o e or t!o peop-e+ !ho i %est their o! ,o e1 a d probab-1 t$r to fa,i-1 a d frie ds for fi a cia- he-p i ret$r for a share i the b$si ess& )$t if the1 are s$ccessf$-+ there co,es a ti,e for a-- de%e-opi 2 (M<s !he the1 eed e! i %est,e t to e6pa d or i the1 ofte r$ o%ate f$rther& 0hat is !here i to prob-e,s+ beca$se the1 fi d it ,$ch harder tha
-ar2er b$si esses to obtai fi a ci 2 fro, ba "s+ capita- ,ar"ets or other s$pp-iers of credit& C(11(- C./%/+,*%23,2+3 (4 SME3 5/6 B(%- (7, (4 2-829287/: 2-2,2/,29*3 e trepre e$rsD i ,a 1 casesD 3;2::3
(M< start$ps te d to e%o-%e a-o 2 a si 2-e e trepre e$r or a s,a-- 2ro$p of -e%era2i 2 o a s"i-- set& 0here are other (M<s bei 2 set $p p$re-1 as a ,ea s of ear i 2 -i%e-ihood& 0hese i c-$des ,a 1 tradi 2 a d retai- estab-ish,e ts !hi-e ,ost co$ tries co ti $e (M<s to ,a $fact$ri 2 ser%ices+ others adopt a broader defi itio i c-$de retai-i 2 as !e--& 5<6 G%*/,*% (=*%/,2(-/: 4:*>2<2:2,? a d
7 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
0he direct i %o-%e,e t of o! er=s>+ co$p-ed !ith f-at hierarchica- str$ct$res a d -ess $,ber of peop-e e s$re that there is 2reater operatio a- f-e6ibi-it1& *ecisio ,a"i 2 s$ch as cha 2es i price ,i6 or prod$ct ,i6 i respo se to ,ar"et co ditio s is faster& 5+6 L(@ +(3, (4 =%(87+,2((M<s ha%e -o!er o%erheads& 0his tra s-ates to -o!er cost of prod$ctio + -east $pto -i,ited %o-$,es& 586 H20. =%(=*-32,? ,( /8(=, ,*+.-(:(0? 0raditio a--1 (M<s ha%e sho! a prope sit1 of bei 2 ab-e to adopt a d i ter a-i?e the tech o-o21 bei 2 $sed b1 the,& 5*6 H20. +/=/+2,? ,( 2--(9/,* *>=(%,A (M<s s"i-- i i o%atio + i,pro%isatio a d re%erse e 2i eeri 2 are -e2e dar1& )1 bei 2 ab-e to ,eet iche reA$ire,e ts+ the1 are a-so ab-e to capt$re e6port ,ar"ets !here %o-$,es are ot h$2e& 546 H20. *1=:(?1*-, (%2*-,/,2(-A (M<s are $s$a--1 the pri,e dri%es of jobs+ i so,e cases creati 2 $p to E0@& Fobs (M<s te d to be -abo$r i te si%e per se a d are ab-e to 2e erate ,ore jobs for e%er1 $ it of i %est,e t+ co,pared to their bi22er co$ terparts&
E NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
506 R*87+,2(- (4 %*02(-/: 21</:/-+*3 G -i"e -ar2e i d$stries !here di%isibi-it1 of operatio s is ,ore diffic$-t+ (M<s e jo1 the f-e6ibi-it1 of -ocatio & 0h$s+ a 1 co$ tr1+ (M<s ca be fo$ d spread %irt$a--1 ri2ht across+ e%e thro$2h so,e specific -ocatio s e,er2e as Hc-$stersI& SME3 2- I-82/ I dia has a %ibra t (M< sector that p-a1s a i,porta t ro-e i s$stai i 2 eco o,ic 2ro!th+ i creasi 2 trade+ 2e erati 2 e,p-o1,e t a d creati 2 e! e trepre e$rship i I dia& I "eepi 2 i %ie! its i,porta ce+ the pro,otio a d de%e-op,e t of (M<s has bee a i,porta t p-a " i o$r po-ic1 for i d$stria- de%e-op,e t a d a ![Link]$ct$red pro2ra,,e of s$pport has bee p$rs$ed i s$ccessi%e fi%e.1ear p-a s for& (M<s i I dia ha%e recorded a s$stai ed 2ro!th d$ri 2 -ast fi%e decades& 0he $,ber of (M<s i I dia is esti,ated to be aro$ d 1B 12::2(- !hi-e the esti,ated e,p-o1,e t pro%ided b1 this sector is o%er B1 12::2(-& 0he (M< sector acco$ ts for abo$t $C =*% +*-, of the ,a $fact$ri 2 o$tp$t a d o%er $0 =*% +*-, of the atio a- e6ports of the co$ tr1&
I dia e,bar"ed o the path of ope i 2 $p its eco o,1 a d i te2rati 2 it !ith the 2-oba- eco o,1 i 1991& 0he -ibera-i?atio of eco o,1+ !hi-e offeri 2 tre,e do$s opport$ ities for the 2ro!th a d de%e-op,e t of I dia i d$str1 i c-$di 2 (M<s+ has a-so thro! $p e! cha--e 2es i ter,s of fierce co,petitio & 0he %er1 r$-es !hich pro%ide i creased access for o$r prod$cts i the 2-oba- ,ar"ets a-so p$t do,estic i d$str1 $ der i creased co,petitio fro, other co$ tries& I toda1Is !or-d+ access o a 2-oba- basis
9 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
to ,oder tech o-o21+ capita- reso$rces a d ,ar"ets ha%e beco,e the ,ost critica- deter,i a ts of i ter atio a- co,petiti%e ess& D*42-2-0 SME3 I I dia+ the e terprises ha%e bee c-assified broad-1 i to t!o cate2ories4 =i> Ma $fact$ri 2D a d =ii> 0hose e 2a2ed i pro%idi 23re deri 2 of ser%ices& )oth cate2ories of e terprises ha%e bee f$rther c-assified i to ,icro+ s,a-a d ,edi$, e terprises based o their i %est,e t i p-a t a d ,achi er1 =for ,a $fact$ri 2 e terprises> or o eA$ip,e ts =i case of e terprises pro%idi 2 or re deri 2 ser%ices>& 0he c-assificatio o basis of i %est,e t is as $ derA T/<:* 1.1 C:/33242+/,2(- O4 M2+%(! S1/:: A-8 M*8271 E-,*%=%23*3 C:/33242+/,2(I-9*3,1*-, C*2:2-0 4(% P:/-,! M/+.2-*%? (% ED72=1*-,3 M/-74/+,7%2-0 S*%92+* E-,*%=%23*3 Micro (,a-Medi$, E-,*%=%23*3 Gpto Rs&2; -a"h Abo%e Rs&2; -a"h J $pto Rs&; crore Abo%e Rs&; crore J $pto Rs&10 crore T/<:* 1.2
10 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
Gpto Rs&10 -a"h Abo%e Rs&10 -a"h J $pto Rs&2 crore Abo%e Rs&2 crore J $pto Rs&; crore
C:/33242+/,2(- O4 M2+%(! S1/:: A-8 M*8271 E-,*%=%23*3 B*4(%* 2-8 O+,(<*%! 2006 C:/33242+/,2(I-9*3,1*-, C*2:2-0 F(% P:/-,! M/+.2-*%? O% ED72=1*-,3EF M/-74/+,7%2-0 S*%92+* E-,*%=%23*3 Micro (,a-Medi$, E-,*%=%23*3 Gpto Rs&2; -a"h Abo%e Rs&2; -a"h J $pto Rs&1 crore Not defi ed Gpto Rs&10 -a"h Not defi ed Not defi ed
Khi-e ca-c$-ati 2 the i %est,e t i p-a t a d ,achi er13eA$ip,e t referred to abo%e+ the ori2i a- price thereof sha-- be ta"e i to acco$ t+ irrespecti%e of !hether the p-a t a d ,achi er13eA$ip,e t are e! or seco d ha d& I case of i,ported ,achi er13eA$ip,e t+ the fo--o!i 2 d$t13char2es3costs sha-- be i c-$ded i ca-c$-ati 2 their %a-$e4
I,port *$t1 = ot to i c-$de ,isce--a eo$s e6pe ses s$ch as tra sportatio fro, the port to the site of the factor1+ de,$rra2e paid at the port>D (hippi 2 Char2esD C$sto,s C-eara ce char2esD a d (a-es 0a6 or Va-$[Link] 0a6& Cost of the fo--o!i 2 p-a t J ,achi er13eA$ip,e ts etc !o$-d be e6c-$ded4D
11 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
<A$ip,e ts s$ch as too-s+ ji2s+ dies+ ,o$-ds+ a d spare parts for ,ai te a ce a d the cost of co s$,ab-e storesD I sta--atio of p-a t J,achi er1D Research a d de%e-op,e t a d po--$tio co tro- eA$ip,e tsD 'o!er 2e eratio set a d e6tra tra sfor,er i sta--ed b1 the e terprises as per the Re2$-atio s of the (tate <-ectricit1 )oardD )a " char2es a d (er%ice Char2es paid to the Natio a- (,a-I d$stries Corporatio or the (tate (,a-- I d$stries Corporatio D 'roc$re,e t or I sta--atio of cab-es+ !iri 2 b$s bars+ e-ectrica-
7i- circ$it brea"ers or ,i iat$re circ$it brea"ers !hich are ecessari-1 to be $sed for pro%idi 2 e-ectrica- po!er to the p-a t a d ,achi er1 or for safet1 ,eas$resD Bas prod$cer p-a tsD 0ra sportatio char2es =other tha sa-es ta6 or %a-$[Link] ta6 a d e6cise d$t1> for i di2e o$s ,achi er1 fro, the p-ace of their ,a $fact$re to the site of the e terprise>D Char2es paid for tech ica- " o!.ho! for erectio of p-a t ,achi er1D ($ch stora2e ta "s !hich store ra! ,ateria-s a d fi ished prod$cts o -1 a d are ot -i "ed !ith the ,a $fact$ri 2 processD Cire.fi2hti 2 eA$ip,e tD a d ($ch other ite,s as ,a1 be specified+ b1 otificatio fro, ti,e to ti,e&
I case of (er%ice < terprises+ the ori2i a- cost to e6c-$de f$r it$re+ fitti 2s a d other ite,s ot direct-1 re-ated to the ser%ices re dered& La d a d
12 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
)$i-di 2
!o$-d
a-so
ot
be
i c-$ded
!hi-e
co,p$ti 2
the
,achi er13eA$ip,e ts cost& (M< !o$-d be ,ea t to i c-$de Micro (,a-- a d Medi$, < terprises =M(M<s>& 0he abo%e defi itio s of Micro+ (,a-- a d Medi$, < terprises !o$-d be i p-ace of the e6isti 2 defi itio s of (,a-- J Medi$, I d$stries a d ((()<s30i 1 < terprises&
Micro < terprises !o$-d i c-$de 0i 1 I d$stries a-so& (,a-- < terprises =Ma $fact$ri 2> !o$-d ,ea I d$stries =((Is>& (,a-- (ca-e
Medi$, < terprises =Ma $fact$ri 2> !o$-d ,ea Medi$, I d$stries =MIs>& (,a-- < terprises =(er%ices> a d Medi$, < terprises =(er%ices> !o$-d ,ea other (,a-- J Medi$, < terprises& 0h$s+ (M< Ad%a ces !o$-d be cate2orised as $ der4
A-- ad%a ces to se2,e ts %i?& Micro+ (,a-- a d Medi$, < terprises i the Ma $fact$ri 2 sector irrespecti%e of sa ctio ed -i,its+ =i c-$di 2 ad%a ces a2ai st 0*Rs3Bo%t& (ec$rities etc for b$si ess p$rposes to these cate2ories of )orro!ers>+ a d Ad%a ces to (er%ices (ectors s$ch as 'rofessio a- J (e-f.<,p-o1ed+ (,a-- )$si ess < terprises+ a d (,a-- Road3Kater 0ra sport 7perators a d other e terprises+ e 2a2ed i pro%idi 23re deri 2 of ser%ices+ co for,i 2 to the abo%e i %est,e t criteria a d e jo1i 2 borro!i 23 o .borro!i 2 faci-ities !ith the )a " =i c-$di 2 ad%a ces a2ai st 0*Rs3Bo%t& (ec$rities etc for b$si ess p$rposes to these cate2ories of )orro!ers>&
18 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
0hose e terprises e6ceedi 2 the i %est,e t cei-i 2s !o$-d be cate2ori?ed as Lar2e < terprises a d be o$tside the p$r%ie! of (M<& 0he sa ctio ed -i,its !o$-d o -o 2er be the criteria deter,i i 2 the stat$s as ,icro or s,a-- or ,edi$, e terprises i these cases& Reser%e )a " of I dia has si ce re%ie!ed the defi itio o 'riorit1 (ector a d ha%e iss$ed re%ised 2$ide-i es o -e di 2 to 'riorit1 (ector %ide their Master Circ$-ar dated 2 d F$-1+ 2007& As per this circ$-ar Retai- 0rade is e6c-$ded fro, the acti%ities c-assified as (M<&
26 No%+
D*9*:(=1*-, (4 SME3 I- I-82/ Ma"i 2 the best $se of the ,ateria- reso$rces b1 e,p-o1i 2 hi2her order of s"i-- a d artistic ta-e ts thro$2h occ$pied a per,a e t p-ace traditio aof pride i ha dicrafts+ I dia has the !or-d before i d$stria-ar2e sca-e ,echa i?ed to the dec-i e of the
i d$str1+ the i,positio of restrictio s o I dia trade b1 the )ritish r$-ers a d deteriorati 2 [Link] o,ic co ditio s -ead (,a-- (ca-e I d$str1& )$t !ith the pro%isio s of per,a e t p-ace i I depe de ce+ it has sta2ed a 2ra d reco%er1 a d is o the path of pro2ress to!ards 2reat e6pa sio &
atio Ls po-ic1 of eco o,ic de%e-op,e t after the attai ,e t of the o! !e-- e tre ched
(M< has e,er2ed i to pro,i e t sector i I dia eco o,1 i 2e era- a d i d$str1 i partic$-ar& ((I sector i I dia has posted i,pressi%e 2ro!th i
1/ NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
1990Ls
fro, 1;@
1991.92
to ;;@
2001.02&0he 2ro!th
e,p-o1,e t 2e eratio has bee eA$a--1 i,pressi%e fro, 8@ to /;@ d$ri 2 the sa,e period& <,p-o1,e t i (M< to$ched 19 ,i--io + j$st behi d a2ric$-t$re& (hare of ((I e6ports crosses /0@ of tota- e6ports& Bro!th b1 itse-f i (M< sector is i,pressi%e e o$2h i dicati 2 a positi%e respo se to the <co o,ic Refor, process i itiated i the co$ tr1 si ce 1991& ... *e%e-op,e t of i frastr$ct$re ... Ass$red s$pp-1 of Ra! Materia-s ... A%ai-abi-it1 of Cheap Credit ... Co cessio ar1 0a6es a d 0ariffs& ... Ci a cia- s$bsidies ... <A$it1 co trib$tio s are a-- the protecti%e ,eas$res for the sector
T/<:* 1.B P%(0%*33 O4 SME3 I- I-82/ Y*/% 199;.96 1996.97 1997.9E 199E.99 1999.00 2000.01 2001.02
NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
T(,/: SME U-2,3 5L/;.36 67&E7 70&68 78&;1 76&/9 79&60 E2&E/ E6&21
F2>*8 I-9*3,1*-, 5R3 C%(%*36 98;;; 1008;1 109628 11;79; 128790 12;7;0 180;60
1;
2002.08 E9&71 1882/2 2008.0/ 98&86 18;/E2 200/.0; 97&1; 1899E2 200;.06 101&1 1/6E/; 2006.07 10;&21 1;/8/9 2007.0E 109&/9 162817 200E.09 118&9; 170219 2009.10 11E&;9 17E699 2010.11 128&/2 1EE118 =http433!!!&s,echa,berofi dia&co,3ro-MofMs,eMsector&asp6 -ast accessed o 27 No%+ 2009> S1/:: /-8 M*8271 E-,*%=%23*3 # I-873,%2/: =(:2+?A 0he s,a-- a d Medi$, i d$stries ha%e a specific ro-e to p-a1 b1 the I d$stria- po-ic1 a d t1pe 19/E !hich stated that cotta2e a d s,a-- sca-e respect of certai i d$stries are partic$-ar-1 s$ited for better $ti-i?atio of -oca- reso$rces for the achie%e,e t of -oca- se-f.s$fficie c1 i of esse tia- 2oods& A (,a-- a d Medi$, I d$stries )oard !as
co stit$ted i 19;/ a d a $,ber of he-pi 2 sche,es s$ch as s$pp-1 of ,achi er1 o hire p$rchase+ -ibera- a d !ider 2ra ts& 0he Bo%er ,e t a o$ ced its seco d I d$stria- po-ic1 i 19;6 !hich
co ti $e to be ta"e !here%er ecessar1+ the ai, of the state po-ic1 is to e s$re that the dece tra-i?ed sector acA$ires s$fficie t se-f s$pporti 2 a d its de%e-op,e t is i te2rated !ith that of
sca-e i d$str1& )esides+ the Bo%er ,e t i te ded to stre 2the the e6isti 2 arra 2e,e ts to fi a ce s,a-- sca-e $ its a d ,a"e cha 2es if ecessar1 to ease the credit prob-e,s of the sector& 0he s1ste, of reser%atio of ite,s for e6c-$si%e prod$ctio b1 s,a-- sca-e $ its !o$-d co ti $e i f$t$re&
16 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
0he I d$stria- po-ic1 state,e t of 19E; !as a-so s,a-- sca-e $ it !as re%ised to i c-$de i %est,e t
accorded i,porta ce to
s,a-- sca-e sector a d ,ade so,e s$itab-e po-ic1 cha 2es& 0he defi itio of a-- ,a $fact$ri 2 $ its ha%i 2 Rs&8; La"hs& I case of i '-a t a d Machi er1 $ to
a ci--ar1 $ its+ the i %est,e t cei-i 2 !as Rs&/; La"hs& I the po-ic1 state,e ts of 1991+ the state fo--o!ed a po-ic1 of
s$pporti 2 s,a-- e terprises i the co$ tr1& (,a-- a d Medi$, e terprises acco$ t for ;;@ of i d$stria- prod$ctio + /0@ of e6ports a d abo%e EE@ of ,a $fact$ri 2 e,p-o1,e t& He ce+ this sector is co sidered as d1 a,ic a d %ibra t sector of the co$ tr1& 0he to re-ati%e i,porta ce te ds %ar1 i %erse-1 !ith the -e%e- of de%e-op,e t a d their co trib$tio &
(,a-- a d Medi$, e terprises ha%e e,er2ed as the -eaders i the i d$striasector& I reco2 itio of their si2 ifica ce a d stat$re+ the the 2o%er ,e t a o$ ced po-ic1 ,eas$res o A$2$st 6+ 1991 for the first ti,e i the post 0his is a-,ost a G.t$r i po-ic1 sti,$-a ts a d i depe de ce period& 0his !as to pro,ote a d stre 2the s,a--+ ti 1 a d %i--a2e e terprises& str$ct$re of ,icro a d s,a-- e terprises i the co$ tr1&
P%(<:*13 (4 SME3 *espite its co,,e dab-e co trib$tio to the Natio Ls eco o,1+ (M< (ector does ot 2et the reA$ired s$pport fro, the co cer ed Bo%er ,e t
17 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
*epart,e ts+ )a "i 2 (ector+ Ci a cia- I stit$tio s a d Corporate (ector+ !hich is a ha dicap i beco,i 2 ,ore co,petiti%e i the Natio a- a d I ter atio a- Mar"ets a d !hich eeds to be ta"e $p for i,,ediate a d proper redressa-& (M< sector faces a $,ber of prob-e,s . abse ce of o . adeA$ate a d ti,e-1 ba "i 2 fi a ce+ -i,ited " o!-ed2e a d
a%ai-abi-it1 of s$itab-e tech o-o21+ -o! prod$ctio capacit1+ fo--o! $p !ith %ario$s a2e cies i so-%i 2 re2$-ar acti%ities a d -ac" of i teractio !ith 2o%er ,e t a2e cies o %ario$s ,atters& (o,e of the ,ajor prob-e,s are brief-1 as fo--o!s4
/6F2-/-+2/: =%(<:*13 (4 SME3A 0he fi a cia- prob-e, of (M<s is the Root Ca$se for a-the other prob-e,s faced b1 the (M< sector& 0he s,a-- a d ,edi$, i d$stria-ists are 2e era--1 poor a d there are o faci-ities for cheap credit& 0he1 fa-- i to the c-$tches of ,o e1 -e der !ho char2es %er1 hi2h rates of i terest+ or e-se the1 borro! fro, the dea-ers of their 2oods+ !ho e6p-oit the, b1 co,p-eti 2 the, to se-- their prod$cts at %er1 -o! price& ba "s !ere pro%idi 2 o -1 a s,a-- proportio !ith its co trib$tio to the tota- i d$stria- o$tp$t& to the i d$stria- sector is o -1 abo$t 80@& After the atio a-i?atio of 1/ ,ajor I dia )a "s i F$-1+ 1969+ the Co,,erciaof (M<s fi a ciaAs a2ai st the share of reA$ire,e ts& Credit to the (M< sector co ti $es to be o .co,,e s$rate the %i--a2e a d (M< at /0@ i the i d$stria- o$tp$t+ its share i tota- credit
1E NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
<6 R/@ M/,*%2/: =%(<:*1 (4 SME3A 0his diffic$-t1 is e6perie ced i a %er1 pro o$ ced for,& 0he A$a tit1+ A$a-it1 a d i re2$-arit1 of the s$pp-1 of ra! ,ateria-s si ce are the1 ot are satisfactor1& 0here p$rchased are o A$a tit1 disco$ ts+
s$pp-iers& *iffic$-t1 is a-so e6perie ced i b$-" i a co,petiti%e ,ar"et& +6 P%(87+,2(- =%(<:*1 (4 SME3A
,ateria-s& Ci a cia- !ea" ess sta ds i the !a1 of sec$ri 2 ra! ,ateria-s i
(M< $ its s$ffer fro, i adeA$ate !or" space+ po!er+ -i2hti 2 a d %e ti-atio + a d safet1 ,eas$res etc& 0hese short co,i 2s ha%e te ded to e da 2er the hea-th of !or",e a d ha%e ad%erse-1 affected the rate of prod$ctio & Ma 1 prod$ctio & Adoptio s,a-- i d$stries are $ its are fo--o!i 2 pri,iti%e ,ethods of of ,oder tech iA$es is either dis-i"ed b1 the
86 T*+.-(:(02+/: =%(<:*1 (4 SME3A 0oda1 tech o-o21 is cha 2i 2 at a %er1 fast phaseD it beco,es diffic$-t for (M<s to cope $p !ith cha 2i 2 tech o-o21& 0ech o-o21 $p 2radatio a d the freA$e t eed to re e! the eA$ip,e t has e,er2ed as a bi2 prob-e,&
19 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
As
,ar"eti 2
is ot
proper-1
,a & 0he pote tia- de,a d for their 2oods re,ai s $ der de%e-oped& 0he (M<s ha%e to face the co,petitio s fro, -ar2e sca-e $ its i ,ar"eti 2 their prod$cts& ca It ca$ses da,a2e to the 2ro!th a d stabi-it1 of (M<s& (M<s ot afford to spe d -a%ish-1 for ad%ertise,e t to pro,ote their sa-es&
*6 M/-/0*%2/: =%(<:*1 (4 SME3A (,a-- sca-e i d$stries i the $ e6p-ored i d$striao$r co$ tr1 ha%e s$ffered fro, the -ac" of fie-ds& 0he i efficie c1 i ,a a2e,e t e trepre e$ria- abi-it1 to de%e-op i itiati%e a d $ derta"e ris"s i co,es first a,o 2 ,a a2eria- prob-e,s& 0he e trepre e$ria- abi-it1 of pro,oters of cotta2e i d$stries a d (M<s are ha dicapped b1 tech ica" o! ho! i the areas of prod$ctio + fi a ce+ acco$ ti 2 a d ,ar"eti 2 ,a a2e,e t& 46 S2+;-*33 (4 SME3A A serio$s prob-e, !hich is ha,peri 2 s,a-- a d ,edi$, sector has bee sic" ess& Ma 1 s,a-- $ its ha%e fa--e sic" d$e to o e prob-e, or the ca$ses of hi2h rate of sic" ess capitaother& (ic" ess is ca$sed b1 t!o sets of factors+ I ter a- a d e6ter a- factors& Cro, a,o 2 the %ario$s i ter a- a d e6ter athe i,porta t o es are b$d ,a a2e,e t+
2eari 2+ i adeA$ac1 of fi a ce+ short of ra! ,ateria-s+ o$tdated p-a t a d ,achi er1+ -o! -abor prod$cti%it1 etc&
20 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
0he abo%e fi2$re sho!s that fi a ce has bee the ,ajor reaso for the sic" ess of (M< $ its& 0he other ,ajor reaso s are i effecti%e ,a a2e,e t a d tech o-o21 $p2radatio accordi 2 to the -atest tech o-o2ica- cha 2es&
SME F2-/-+2-0 SME F2-/-+* is the f$ di 2 of s,a-- a d ,edi$, si?ed e terprises a d represe ts a ,ajor f$ ctio of the 2e era- b$si ess fi a ce ,ar"et N i !hich capita- for fir,s of t1pes is s$pp-ied+ acA$ired+ a d costed3priced& Capita- is s$pp-ied thro$2h the b$si ess fi a ce ,ar"et i the for, of ba " -oa s a d o%erdraftsD -easi 2 a d hire.p$rchase arra 2e,e tsD eA$it13corporate bo d iss$esD %e t$re capita- or pri%ate eA$it1D a d asset. based fi a ce s$ch as factori 2 a d i %oice disco$ ti 2 I1=(%,/-+* 0he eco o,ic a d socia- i,porta ce of the s,a-- a d ,edi$, e terprise =(M<> sector is !e-- reco2 i?ed i acade,ic a d po-ic1 -iterat$re& It is a-so reco2 i?ed that these actors i the eco o,1 ,a1 be $ derser%ed+ especia--1 i ter,s of fi a ce& 0his has -ed to si2 ifica t debate o the best ,ethods to ser%e this sector& 0here ha%e bee $,ero$s sche,es a d pro2ra,,es i ,ar"ed-1 differe t eco o,ic e %iro ,e ts& Ho!e%er+ there are a $,ber of disti cti%e rec$rri 2 approaches to (M< fi a ce&
Co--atera- based -e di 2 offered b1 traditio a- ba "s a d fi a ce co,pa ies is $s$a--1 ,ade $p of a co,bi atio of [Link] fi a ce+ co trib$tio based fi a ce+ a d factori 2 based fi a ce+ $si 2 re-iab-e debtors or co tracts&
21
NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
I for,atio
0here is a-so a ,ore fa%orab-e e %iro ,e t o! !ith the Bo%t& co,,itted to 2i%e fi--ip to this sector thro$2h i frastr$ct$re de%e-op,e tD s"i-- set de%e-op,e t3e trepre e$rship de%e-op,e t+ tech o-o21 $p 2radatio to ser%ice the credit reA$ire,e ts of the (M< sector depe ds o $ der-1i 2 tra sactio etc& the Kith the dere2$-atio of the fi a cia- sector+ the 2e era- abi-it1 of the ba "s costs+ efficie t reco%er1 processes a d a%ai-ab-e
sec$rit1& 0here is a i,,ediate eed for the ba "s 2e era--1 to foc$s o credit a d fi a ce reA$ire,e ts of (M<s& A-tho$2h the ba "s are a--o!ed to fi6 their o! tar2ets for f$ di 2 (M<s i order to achie%e a ,i i,$, 20@ 1ear.o .1ear 2ro!th+ the Bo%er ,e tIs objecti%e is to do$b-e the f-o! of credit to the (M< sector fro, Rs&67+600 crore i 200/.0; to Rs&1+8;+200 crore b1 2009.10 i&e& !ithi a period of ; 1ears& A-so+ Credit ris" i the (M< sector is !ide-1 dispersed a d )a "s 2et better 1ie-d fro, (M< ad%a ces as a2ai st the traditio a- ad%a ces !here the spread is 2etti 2 2rad$a--1 red$ced& 0he (M< c-ie te-e base co$-d a-so be $ti-i?ed b1 the )ra ches to step.$p #cross se--i 2O of %ario$s other prod$cts i c-$di 2 tech o-o21. e ab-ed prod$cts&
SME F2-/-+2-0 G/= A s$bsta tia- portio of the (M< sector ,a1 ot ha%e the sec$rit1 reA$ired for co %e tio a- co--atera- based ba " -e di 2+ or hi2h e o$2h ret$r s to attract for,a- %e t$re capita-ists a d other ris" i %estors& I additio +
22 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
=-i,iti 2 the
effecti%e ess of fi a cia- state,e [Link] -e di 2 a d credit scori 2>& 0his has -ed to c-ai,s of a P(M< fi a ce 2apO& 0he (M<s that fa-- i to this cate2or1 ha%e bee defi ed as (,a-- Bro!i 2 )$si esses =(B)s> at a !or"shop i Be e%a i F$-1 200E+ hosted b1 0he Net!or" for Bo%er a ceD < trepre e$rship J *e%e-op,e t =B<J*> 0here ha%e bee at -east t!o disti cti%e approaches to tr1 to o%erco,e the [Link]--ed (M< fi a ce 2ap& 0he first has bee to broade the co--atera- based approach b1 e co$ra2i 2 ba " -e ders to fi a ce (M<s !ith i s$fficie t co--atera-& 0his ,i2ht be do e thro$2h a e6ter a- part1 pro%idi 2 the co--atera- or 2$ara tees reA$ired& G fort$ ate-1+ to the e6te t that the sche,es co cer ed r$ co$ ter to basic free ,ar"et pri cip-es the1 te d to be $ s$stai ab-e& 0h$s+ the seco d approach has bee to broade the %iabi-it1 based approach& (i ce the %iabi-it1 based approach is co cer ed !ith the b$si ess itse-f+ the ai, has bee to pro%ide better 2e era- b$si ess de%e-op,e t assista ce to red$ce ris" a d i crease ret$r s& =http433e &!i"ipedia&or23!i"i3(M<Mfi a ce -ast accessed o 27 o%+ 2009> S(7%+*3 (4 SME F2-/-+*A 0he ,ost co,,o so$rces of (M< fi a ce are as fo--o!s P%(<:*13 (4 SME3 F2-/-+2-0 0he ,ai prob-e, faced b1 (M<Is !he tr1i 2 to obtai f$ di 2 is that of $ certai t14 Q (M<Is rare-1 ha%e a -o 2 histor1 or s$ccessf$- trac" record that pote tiai %estors ca re-1 o i ,a"i 2 a i %est,e tD
28 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
Q Lar2er co,pa ies =partic$-ar-1 those A$oted o a stoc" e6cha 2e> are reA$ired to prepare a d p$b-ish ,$ch ,ore detai-ed fi a cia- i for,atio N !hich ca act$a--1 assist the fi a [Link] 2 processD Q )a "s are partic$-ar-1 er%o$s of s,a--er b$si esses d$e to a perceptio that the1 represe t a 2reater credit ris"& )eca$se the i for,atio is ot a%ai-ab-e i other !a1s+ (M<Is !i-- ha%e to pro%ide it !he the1 see" fi a ce& 0he1 !i-- eed to 2i%e a b$si ess p-a + -ist of the co,pa 1 assets+ detai-s of the e6perie ce of directors a d ,a a2ers a d de,o strate ho! the1 ca 2i%e pro%iders of fi a ce so,e sec$rit1 for a,o$ ts pro%ided& 'rospecti%e -e ders N $s$a--1 ba "s N !i-the ,a"e a decisio based o the i for,atio pro%ided& 0he ter,s of the -oa =i terest rate+ ter,+ sec$rit1+ a d repa1,e t detai-s> !i-- depe d o the ris" i %o-%ed a d the -e der !i-- a-so !a t to ,o itor their i %est,e t& A co,,o prob-e, is ofte that the ba "s !i-- be $ !i--i 2 to i crease -oa f$ di 2 !itho$t a i crease i the sec$rit1 2i%e =!hich the (M< o! ers ,a1 be $ ab-e or $ !i--i 2 to pro%ide>&A partic$-ar prob-e, of $ certai t1 re-ates to b$si esses !ith a -o! asset base& 0hese are co,pa ies !itho$t s$bsta tia- ta 2ib-e assets !hich ca be $se to pro%ide sec$rit1 for -e ders& Khe a (M< is ot 2ro!i 2 si2 ifica t-1+ fi a ci 2 ,a1 ot be a ,ajor prob-e,& Ho!e%er+ the fi a ci 2 prob-e, beco,es %er1 i,porta t !he a co,pa 1 is 2ro!i 2 rapid-1+ for e6a,p-e !he co te,p-ati 2 i %est,e t i capita- eA$ip,e t or a acA$isitio & Ce! 2ro!i 2 co,pa ies are ab-e to fi a ce their e6pa sio p-a s fro, cash f-o! a-o e& 0he1 !i-- therefore eed to co sider raisi 2 fi a ce fro, other e6ter a- so$rces& I additio + ,a a2ers !ho are -oo"i 2 to b$1.i to a b$si ess =P,a a2e,e t b$1.i P or
2/ NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
PM)IP> or b$1.o$t =,a a2e,e t b$1.o$tP or PM)7P> a b$si ess fro, its o! ers ,a1 ot ha%e the reso$rces to acA$ire the co,pa 1& 0he1 !i-- eed to raise fi a ce to achie%e their objecti%es
1.2 ROLE OF PUBLIC SECTOR BANKS IN SME FINANCING )a "s are p-a1i 2 a ,ajor ro-e i fi a ci 2 (M<s i I dia& Near-1 E2@ of the tota- (M< fi a ci 2 i 1ear 2006.07 is thro$2h ba "s& A d a,o 2 the, the ,ajor share is of p$b-ic sector ba "s i&e& ;7@& 0h$s it is c-ear that the ,ost co,,o so$rce of fi a ce for (M<s is )a " Ci a ci 2& 0here is o& of ba "s that he-p i assisti 2 the (M<s for fi a ci 2& 0he ,ai cha e- $sed b1 the (M<s %ia )a "s is (pecia-i?ed -oa s b1 %ario$s )a "s& 0he Mai reaso for choosi 2 ba " -oa s b1 (M<s co,pared to other so$rces of fi a ci 2 -i"e %e t$re capita-+ '< f$ di 2 etc is that is o -1 i terest to be paid o sta"e is to be di-$ted th$s the !ho-e co,,a d of the (M< is !ith the o! er o -1& 0here are a $,ber of 'ri%ate as !e-- as '$b-ic sector ba "s !ho assist (M< i Ci a ci 2 F207%* 1.$ S(7%+*3 O4 SME F2-/-+* 52006#076
Others 18%
2; NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
=http433!!!&b$si ess!or-d&i 3b!32009M11M19MRefor,sM0oMI,pro%eMCredi tMAccessM0oM(M<s&ht,- -ast accessed o ; Fa + 2010> 0he ro-e of )a "s+ i 2e era-+ has beco,e %er1 i,porta t i the abo%e co te6t 0he (M< sectorIs de,a ds !ere co,prehe si%e-1 ta"e care of b1 the '$b-ic sector )a "s thro$2h se%era- i itiati%es s$ch as4
(i 2-e Ki do! dispe satio + R$ic" decisio !ith -east 0$r aro$ d 0i,e thro$2h specia--1 co stit$ted (M< Ce--s+ a d abo%e a--+ )etter ser%ice& C-$[Link] (che,es are a-so o the -ist of the )a "Is i itiati%es& 0he )a " prioriti?ed the fo--o!i 2 ,ore partic$-ar-14. 'ro%isio of ti,e-1 a d adeA$ate credit to the (M<s+ < co$ra2i 2 0ech o-o21 Gp 2radatio + for better A$a-it1 a d co,petiti%e ess of their prod$ct=s>+ a d 'roacti%e-1 detecti 2 sic" a d %iab-e $ its i ti,e so as to $rse the, bac" to hea-th thro$2h appropriate [Link]$ct$ri 2& Ci a ci 2 of C-$sters !ith adeA$ate a d co cessio a- )a " fi a ce o -ibera- ter,s i se%era- poc"ets for specified acti%ities co ce trated i these poc"ets+ !hich !o$-d res$-t i red$ci 2 tra sactio cost a d 2reater eco o,ies of sca-e&
C%*82, ,( SME 3*+,(% 4%(1 P7<:2+ S*+,(% B/-;3 0he tab-e be-o! 2i%es the stat$s of credit f-o! to the ,icro a d s,a-e terprises =(M<> sector fro, the p$b-ic sector ba "s si ce 20004
26 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
T/<:* 1.C C%*82, ,( SME 3*+,(% 4%(1 P7<:2+ S*+,(% B/-;3 Y*/% N*, B/-; C%*82, ,( SME3 G (4 NBC
C%*82, 200/ 816/27 /60/; 1/&6@ 200; 8/1291 /E/00 1/&2 2006 8969;/ /97/8 12&; 2007 /77E99 ;29EE 11&1 200E ;;EE/9 ;E27E 10&/ 2009 71E772 6768/ 9&/ 2010 101761/ E2/92 E&1 2011 181770; 10/708 E&0 =http433!!!&rbi&or2&i 3scripts3'$b-icatio sVie!&asp6SidT11998 accessed o 11 Fa + 2012> F207%* 1.C S,*=3 F(% SME L(/-3 B? P7<:2+ S*+,(% B/-;3
-ast
27 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
App-icatio for -oa b1 (M< to -oca- bra ch of a partic$-ar ba " i that area
& I spectio 3($r%e1 of (M< b1 the <6ec$ti%es of that Loca- bra ch&
'repari 2 crede tia-s of 'ro,oters a d fir, b1 (M<CC bra ch a d i %esti2ati 2 the sa,e <sti,ati 2 the a,o$ t of -oa to be sa ctio ed a d for!ardi 2 the doc$,e ts for sa ctio i 2& If the -oa is bee sa ctio ed b1 the ce tra- a$thorit1 the disb$rse,e t of the -oa a,o$ t i to acco$ t of the (M<&
0he abo%e fi2$re sho!s the steps for a%ai-i 2 fi a ce thro$2h '$b-ic sector )a "s $si 2 -oa s& Here is the brief descriptio of the abo%e sho! proced$re4 Cirst of a-- the (M< !ho !a ts to a%ai- -oa has to %isit the -ocabra ch office of the ba " of their area+ !here b1 the -oa app-icatio is bee fi--ed b1 the (M<& After that the e6ec$ti%es of that bra ch chec" !hether a-- the
ecessar1 doc$,e ts are pro%ided b1 the (M< or ot+ the if a-ecessar1 doc$,e ts are s$b,itted the e6t step co,es !hereb1 the officia-s of that -oca- bra ch 2o to the pre,ises of that (M< a d j$st ha%e a brief s$r%e1 of pro,oter as !e-- as the pre,ises&
2E NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
After the1 are satisfied the1 se d the fi-e of (M< -oa s& Khere b1 the credit appraisata"es
ecessar1
doc$,e ts to the (M<CC bra ch+ !hich is a specia- bra ch for p-ace+ !hich co sist of credit appraisa- of pro,oter+ fi a cia- appraisa-+ deter,i i 2 cost of project+ $ dersta di 2 %ario$s ,ea s of fi a ce $sed+ profitabi-it1 esti,ate+ cash f-o! projectio s + ,ar"eti 2 appraisa- etc&+ !hich is e6p-ai ed i otS If the (M<CC bra ch is satisfied !ith the detai-s the it for!ard the reA$est of 2ra ti 2 -oa to the sa ctio i 2 a$thorit1& A d fi a--1 after the %erificatio b1 sa ctio i 2 a$thorit1+ the e6t sectio & 0his step bri 2s
o$t the c-ear pict$re !hether the -oa sho$-d be 2i%e to the (M< or
disb$rse,e t of -oa a,o$ t ta"es p-ace i the acco$ t of that (M< 0his !ho-e proced$re ri2ht fro, app-icatio -oa to disb$rse,e t of a,o$ t ta"es appro6i,ate-1 20.2; da1s as the proced$re
i %o-%es a a-1sis of doc$,e ts b1 %ario$s bra ches a d th$s the ,o%e,e t of doc$,e ts a,o 2st the,+ if a-- this proced$re !o$-d ha%e ta"e p-ace at si 2-e p-ace the it !o$-d ta"e o -1 10.12 da1s for disb$rse,e t& (o,e '$b-ic sector )a "s offeri 2 (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es are as fo--o!s4 1> (tate ba " of I dia a d its s$bsidiaries I dia 2> A--ahabad )a " )a "
29 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
8> 7rie ta- )a " of Co,,erce /> )a " of )aroda ;> )a " of I dia 6> '$ jab J (i d )a " )a " S,/,* B/-; (4 I-82/
9> I*)I )a " 10> I dia )a " 11> Ca ada )a " 12> Corporatio
(tate )a " of I dia has bee p-a1i 2 a %ita- ro-e i the de%e-op,e t of s,a-sca-e i d$stries si ce 19;6&0he )a " has fi a ced o%er E -a"hs ((I $ its i the co$ tr1& It has ;; specia-i?ed ((I bra ches+ 99 bra ches i i d$striaestates a d ,ore tha /00 bra ches !ith (I) di%isio s& 0he )a " fi a ces for (,a-- )$si ess acti%ities !hich are of specia- si2 ifica ce to a -ar2e $,ber of peop-e as ,a 1 of these acti%ities ca be started !ith re-ati%e-1 -o!er i %est,e t a d !ith o specia- s"i--s o the part of the e trepre e$rs& 0he fo--o!i 2 are the (M< prod$cts offered b1 (tate )a " 7f I dia4 Co,,odit1 'ac"ed Kareho$se Receipt Ci a ci 2 ($rabhi *eposit (che,e 0raders <as1 Loa (che,e ((I Loa s )$si ess C$rre t Acco$ ts 7pe 0er, Loa Retai- 0rade *octor '-$s
80 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
()I (hoppe C1ber '-$s (M< Credit '-$s (,a-- )$si ess Credit Card (M< 'etro Credit *a- Mi-- '-$s 'ar1ata '-$s A$to Loa s 0ra sport 7perators Rice Mi--s '-$s (choo- '-$s =http433!!!&sbi&co&i 3$ser&ht, -ast accessed o 27 No%+ 2009> IDBI B/-; I*)I )a " has bee a d shorte the 0$r acti%e-1 e 2a2ed i pro%idi 2 a ,ajor thr$st to fi a ci 2 of (M<s& Kith a %ie! to i,pro%i 2 the credit de-i%er1 ,echa is, aro$ d 0i,e =0A0>+ I*)I )a " has de%e-oped a ai+ specia- b$si ess ,ode- to ser%e the (M<s i I dia& 0he )a " has set $p 2/ Cit1 (M< Ce tres =C(Cs> across I dia i M$,bai+ *e-hi+ Ko-"ata+ Che )a 2a-ore+ H1derabad+ '$ e to a,e a fe!& 0hese C(Cs are the )a "Ls h$bs !hi-e dedicated (M< des"s ha%e bee set $p i se%era- bra ches across these cities& 0hese bra ches ser%e as fro t offices for sa-es de-i%er1 a d c$sto,er ser%ice& I*)I )a " has a !ide %ariet1 of prod$cts a d ser%ices cateri 2 to the eeds of differe t se2,e ts !ithi s,a-- b$si ess& Lo 2 1ears of e6perie ce i
81 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
bei 2 the tr$sted part er of -ar2e a d ,id corporates has tra s-ated i to deeper $ dersta di 2 of eeds of b$si ess a d i d$stries& 0he )a " has para,eterised prod$cts for tra sporters+ dea-ers+ traders+ a d %e dors& I additio + it has a separate 0ra sactio )a "i 2 Bro$p that has e6pertise i prod$cts -i"e cash ,a a2e,e t ser%ices+ -etter of credit+ ba " 2$ara tees a d treas$r1 prod$ctsO I*)I )a " pro%ides fo--o!i 2 (M< prod$cts4 ($-abh V1apar Loa *ea-er Ci a ce C$ di 2 G der CBCM(< *irect Credit (che,e.(I*)I 'referred C$sto,er (che,e Ve dor Ci a ci 2 'ro2ra,,e Le di 2 a2ai st the sec$rit1 of f$t$re Credit Card Recei%ab-es Kor"i 2 Capita- Ci a ci 2 Ci a ce to Medica- 'ractitio ers Loa s to (RK70s (M< Hosier1 (pecia- C$rre t Acco$ t =http433!!!&idbi&co,3s,e3 -ast accessed o 27 No%+ 2009>
B/-; (4 B/%(8/ )a " of )aroda started its operatio i the 1ear 190E i )aroda tho$2h its Corporate Ce tre is i M$,bai o!& Its ,issio is Pto be a top ra "i 2 Natio a- )a " of I ter atio a- (ta dards co,,itted to a$2,e t sta"e
82 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
ho-dersL %a-$e thro$2h co cer + care a d co,pete ceO& )a " of )aroda offers fo--o!i 2 (M< prod$cts a d ser%ices4
)aroda Vid1astha-i Loa )aroda Aro21adha, Loa )aroda La2h$ Gdh1a,i Credit Card )aroda Artisa s Credit Card 0ech o-o21 Gp2radatio sche,e (M< short ter, -oa s (M< ,edi$, ter, -oa s Co,posite Loa s
=http433!!!&ba "ofbaroda&co,3bbs3s,e&asp -ast accessed o 26 No%+ 2009> U-2(- B/-; (4 I-82/ G io )a " is co,,itted to e6te d its best ser%ices to Micro+ (,a-- a d Medi$, e terprises a d at a %er1 co,petiti%e price& G io )a " of I dia has adopted a po-ic1 pac"a2e for steppi 2 $p credit to (,a-- J Medi$, < terprises& G io )a " of I dia has adopted a po-ic1 pac"a2e for steppi 2 $p credit to (,a-- J Medi$, < terprises 9(M<: !ith the appro%a- of the )oard i its ,eeti 2 he-d o 80th (epte,ber 200; a d s$bseA$e t-1 fo--o!i 2 steps ha%e bee i itiated i this directio & G io Hi2h 'ride G io 'roc$re G io ($pp-1 G io C1ber G io (M< '-$s
88 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
G io 0ra sport Ci a ci 2 (MALL H7(I<RU GNI0( i Ko-"ata =http433!!!&$ io ba "ofi dia&co&i 3cbMs,e&asp6 -ast accessed o 27 No%+ 2009> C/-/%/ B/-; Ca ara )a " !as fo$ ded b1 (hri A,,e,ba- ($bba Rao 'ai+ a 2reat %isio ar1 a d phi-a thropist+ i F$-1 1906+ at Ma 2a-ore+ the a s,a-- port i Kar ata"a 0he )a " has adopted a 'o-ic1 for -e di 2 to (M< sector+ i t$ e !ith Bo%t& of I dia 2$ide-i es as per M(M<* Act+ 2006+ !hich has co,e i to force !&e&f& 2 d 7ctober+ 2006& L7AN 'R7*GC0( S+.*1*3 4(% C/=2,/: I-9*3,1*-, 0er, -oa for acA$isitio of fi6ed assets (ta db1 credit for capita- e6pe dit$re (ta db1 ter, -oa sche,e for Appare- <6porters Loa sche,e for rei,b$rse,e t of i %est,e t ,ade i fi6ed assets b1 (M<s (oft -oa sche,e for (o-ar Kater Heaters (che,e for < er21 (a%i 2s for (M<s 0ech o-o21 Gp2radatio C$ d sche,e =0GC(> for te6ti-e J j$te i d$stries i (M< sector Credit -i "ed capita- s$bsid1 sche,e =CLC((>
8/ NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
Loa s $ der I terest ($bsid1 <-i2ibi-it1 Certificate =I(<C> (che,e of Khadi J Vi--a2e I d$stries Co,,issio =KVIC> to e-i2ib-e i stit$tio s S+.*1*3 4(% "(%;2-0 C/=2,/: (i,p-ified 7pe Cash Credit =(7CC> 7pe Cash Credit =7CC> Micro fi a ci 2 joi t -iabi-it1 2ro$ps =Ha d-oo, !ea%er J A2arbathi ,a $fact$rer 2ro$ps> La2h$ Gdh1a,i Credit Card =LGCC> )i-- of <6cha 2e disco$ ti 2 faci-it1 to (,a-- < terpre e$rs at co cessio a- rate of i terest =)<.(<>
B.1 N**8 (4 ,.* 3,78? 0he researches that !ere co d$cted i past b1 the %ario$s professio a-s are i forei2 co te6t a d ot i I dia co te6t& (t$d1 re-ati 2 to (M<s+ their prob-e,s a d so$rce of fi a ci 2 has bee do e b$t re2ardi 2 the (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es of p$b-ic sector ba "s has ot bee do e& 0his 2ap has bee ide tified a d it has -ed to the prese t research to be $ derta"e & (o+ the eed !as fe-t to co%er the areas e2-ected& 0h$s+ here a st$d1 o (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es of p$b-ic sector ba "s !as ta"e care of& B.2 S+(=* (4 ,.* 3,78? 0he scope of this st$d1 !as -i,ited to L$dhia a cit1 o -1&
[Link]<)*+,29*3 (4 ,.* 3,78? 7bjecti%es are the 2$idi 2 -i2hts of a st$d1& 0he prese t st$d1 !as $ derta"e to achie%e the fo--o!i 2 objecti%es4 .
0o " o! abo$t the %ario$s (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es of p$b-ic sector ba "s a d their $sa2e&
0o " o! the effecti%e ess of %ario$s (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es of p$b-ic sector ba "s&
0o " o! the prob-e,s faced b1 (M<s i 2etti 2 credit fro, p$b-ic sector ba "s&
86 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
0o chec" the satisfactio -e%e- of (,a-- a d Medi$, e terprises re2ardi 2 (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es of the p$b-ic sector ba "s&
87 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
METHODOLOGY
Research Methodology is a way to systematically solve the research problem. The Research Methodology includes the various methods and techniques for conducting a Research. Marketing Research is the systematic design, collection, analysis and reporting of data and finding relevant solution to a specific marketing situation or problem. . !lesinger and M.!tephenson in the encyclopedia of !ocial !ciences define Research as the manipulation of things, concepts or symbols for the purpose of generali"ing to e#tend, correct or verify knowledge, whether that knowledge aids in construction of theory or in the practice of an art. Research is+ th$s+ a ori2i a- co trib$tio to the e6isti 2 stoc" of of scie tific " o!-ed2e ,a"i 2 for its ad%a ce,e t& 0he p$rpose of Research is to disco%er a s!ers to the R$estio s thro$2h the app-icatio effecti%e ,a proced$res& 7$r project has a specified fra,e!or" for co--ecti 2 data i a er& ($ch fra,e!or" is ca--ed #R*3*/%+. D*320-'& 0he research process fo--o!ed b1 $s co sists of fo--o!i 2 steps4 $.1 RESEARCH DESIGN 0his research !as descripti%e a d co c-$sio orie ted research& C(-+:732(- O%2*-,*8 R*3*/%+.A .Research desi2 ed to assist the decisio ,a"er i the sit$atio & I other !ords it is a research !he !e 2i%e o$r o! %ie!s abo$t the research&
8E NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
D*3+%2=,29* R*3*/%+.A #A t1pe of co c-$si%e research+ !hich has as its ,ajor objecti%e the descriptio research !here i researcher has of so,ethi 2.$s$a--1 ,ar"et o co tro- o%er %ariab-e& It j$st characteristics or f$ ctio s& I other !ords descripti%e research is a prese ts the pict$re+ !hich has a-read1 st$died&
$.2 SAMPLING DESIGN (a,p-i 2 ca be defi ed as the sectio of so,e part of a a22re2ate or tota-it1 o the basis of !hich j$d2,e t or a i fere ce abo$t a22re2ate or tota-it1 is ,ade& 0he sa,p-i 2 desi2 fo--o!i 2 areas4 . $.2.1 U-29*%3* (4 ,.* 3,78?.0he $ i%erse co,prises of t!o parts as theoretica- $ i%erse a d accessib-e $ i%erse T.*(%*,2+/: 7-29*%3*# It i c-$des a-- the (M<s thro$2ho$t the $ i%erse& A++*332<:* 7-29*%3*# It i c-$des the (M<s i L$dhia a cit1& $.2.2 S/1=:* F%/1*#(a,p-e fra,e !as (,a-- a d Medi$, e terprises a-o%er I dia& $.2.B S/1=:* U-2,# (a,p-i 2 $ it is the basic $ it co tai i 2 the e-e,e ts of the $ i%erse to be sa,p-ed& 0he sa,p-i 2 $ it of the prese t st$d1 !as (M<s -ocated i L$dhia a cit1 i '$ jab&
89 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
he-ps i
decisio
,a"i 2 i
the
$.2.$ S/1=:* S2H*# (a,p-e si?e is the $,ber of e-e,e ts to be i c-$ded i a st$d1& Keepi 2 i ,i d a-- the co strai ts 100 respo de ts !ere se-ected& $.2.C S/1=:2-0 T*+.-2D7*3# 0he sa,p-i 2 tech iA$es $sed !ere co %e ie ce tech iA$e a d si,p-e ra do, sa,p-i 2 tech iA$e& $.B DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS $.B.1 D/,/ C(::*+,2(-A I for,atio has bee co--ected fro, both 'ri,ar1 a d (eco dar1 so$rces of data co--ectio & S*+(-8/%? 3(7%+*3# (eco dar1 data are those+ !hich ha%e a-read1 bee co--ected b1 so,eo e e-se+ !hich a-read1 had bee passed thro$2h the statistica- process& (eco dar1 data had bee co--ected thro$2h !ebsites+ e!spapers a d jo$r a-s& P%21/%? 3(7%+*3# 'ri,ar1 data are those+ !hich are co--ected are fresh a d for the first ti,e a d th$s happe to be ori2i a- i character& 'ri,ar1 data had bee A$estio te-epho ic i ter%ie!& <6 T((:3 (4 A-/:?323 /-8 P%*3*-,/,2(-A 0o a a-1?e the data obtai ed !ith the he-p of A$estio !ere $sed4 T((:3 (4 A-/:?323A # S711/,*8 S+(%*A 0his too- !as $sed for the a a-1sis of A$estio s based o Li"ert sca-e&
/0 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
"*20.,*8 A9*%/0* S+(%*A 0his too- !as $sed to ca-c$-ate hi2hest a d -o!est ra "& T((:3 (4 P%*3*-,/,2(-A . T/<:*3A 0his too- !as $sed to prese t the data i tab$-ar for,& B/% G%/=.3 /-8 P2* C./%,34 0hese too-s !ere $sed for a a-1sis of data&
/1 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
1. D*1(0%/=.2+ P%(42:* (4 R*3=(-8*-,3. T/<:* C.1 D*1(0%/=.2+ F*/,7%*3 D*1(0%/=.2+3 D*320-/,2(7! er 'art er 7ther T(,/: L(+/,2(L$dhia a 7ther T(,/: G*-8*% Ma-e Ce,a-e T(,/: B732-*33 Hosier1 7ther T(,/: A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A It had bee a a-1?ed fro, the tab-e that 78@ of the respo de ts !ere the o! er+ 19@ !ere [Link] ers a d 6@ !ere at so,e other desi2 atio &100@ of the respo de ts !ere fro, the L$dhia a cit1& 9;@ of the respo de ts !ere ,a-e a d o -1 ;@ !ere fe,a-e& A-- the respo de ts i&e& 100@ !ere fro, the hosier1 b$si ess&
/2 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
(o it had bee i terpreted that ,a6i,$, of the respo de ts !ere ,a-e+ o! er of the b$si ess a d fro, L$dhia a cit1& A-- the respo de ts !ere fro, hosier1 b$si ess&
2. "./, /%* ,.* 3(7%+*3 (4 42-/-+* 73*8 <? ?(7% *-,*%=%23*I T/<:* C.2 T( K-(@ T.* S(7%+*3 O4 F2-/-+* U3*8 B? SME3 S(7%+*3 (4 F2-/-+* 7! ers Ci a ci 2 'ri%ate fi a ciai stit$tio s <A$it1 fi a ce )a " fi a ci 2 Ve t$re capitaHire p$rchase a d -easi 2 )$si ess a 2efi a ci 2 0otaN(. O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 E0 /6 12 7; 1/ 2/ 29 2E0 F207%* C.1 T( K-(@ T.* S(7%+*3 O4 F2-/-+* U3*8 B? SME3 GA0* O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 29 16 / 27 ; 9 10 100
/8 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
$o. %f Respondents
%wners /inancing 0rivate financial institutions
1quity finance 2ank financing 3enture capital 4ire purchase and leasing 2usiness angel financing
&,( +(
)*(
A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A# 0he $,ber of respo de ts had i creased fro, 100 to 2E0+ as this is a ,$-[Link] A$estio & Cro, the s$r%e1 it !as fo$ d that respo de ts $se ,$-tip-e so$rces for fi a ci 2 their e terprises& 0he fi2$re sho!s that 29@ respo de ts re-1 o their o! f$ ds for fi a ci 2 (M<s&2E@ respo de ts $se ba " fi a ci 2 a d 16@ ta"e credit fro, pri%ate fi a cia- i stit$tio s& <A$it1 fi a ce a d %e t$re capita- are the -east $sed&
// NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
B. R/-; ,.* (<3,/+:*3 ,./, /%* 4/+*8 <? ?(7% *-,*%=%23* 2- 2,3 0%(@,. 4%(1 1 ,( CJ 1 <*2-0 ,.* <200*3, (<3,/+:*. T/<:* C.B O<3,/+:*3 I- T.* G%(@,. O4 E-,*%=%23*
/; NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
O<3,/+:*3
0he freA$e t eed to re e! the eA$ip,e t I stabi-it1 of de,a d for prod$ct or ser%ice 7btai i 2 adeA$ate fi a ci 2 Lo! profitabi-it1 of the sector 0a6atio -e%e-s
R/-; R/-; R/-; R/-; R/-; "*20.,* 1 2 B $ C 8 A9*%/0* S+(%* 12 19 2E 2/ 17 81; 7 /0 11 80 16 27 12 26 16 17 21 1E 2E E 29 11 88 E 27 1; 86/ 217 8/9 2;;
A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A # I this abo%e tab-e !ei2hted a%era2e score ,ethod is $sed !here 1 ra " is 2i%e to the bi22est obstac-e i the 2ro!th a d ; is the -east i,porta t ra "& As i the abo%e tab-e %ario$s obstac-es faced b1 the e terprises i their 2ro!th are bei 2 ra "ed& 0he obstac-e of obtai i 2 adeA$ate fi a ce is ra "ed first !ith s$,,ated score of 217& (eco d ra " is 2i%e eed to re e! the eA$ip,e t& 0he Co$rth ra " is 2i%e ser%ice& Cro, the abo%e tab-e it ca be co c-$ded that obtai i 2 adeA$ate fi a ce is the bi22est obstac-e faced b1 (M<s i their 2ro!th fo--o!ed b1 b$rde of hea%1 ta6es o the,& <as1 fi a ci 2 sche,es sho$-d be pro%ided& Rates of ta6es sho$-d a-so be decreasedD it !i-- he-p i the 2ro!th of (M<s i I dia&
/6 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
to the
ta6atio -e%e-s char2ed b1 the 2o%er ,e t a d third ra " to the freA$e t to the -o! profitabi-it1 of the sector a d fifth to the i stabi-it1 of de,a d of prod$ct or
$. H/9* ?(7 *9*% %/23*8 42-/-+* 4%(1 =7<:2+ 3*+,(% </-;3I T/<:* C.$ T( K-(@ ".*,.*% SME3 R/23* F2-/-+* F%(1 P7<:2+ 3*+,(% B/-;3 R/23*8 F2-/-+* Ues No 0otaN(. O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 100 0 100 F207%* C.2 T( K-(@ ".*,.*% SME3 R/23* F2-/-+* F%(1 P7<:2+ 3*+,(% B/-;3 GA0* O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 100 0 100
$o. %f Respondents
.(
5es $o
)..(
0he abo%e fi2$re sho!s that 100@ of the respo de ts ha%e raised fi a ce fro, the p$b-ic sector ba "s &0his sho!s that p$b-ic sector ba "s are the ,ost pop$-ar so$rce of (M< fi a ci 2& 0he reaso is -o! rates of i terest !hich 2i%es the, capita- at -o! cost& 0he ser%ice fees a d ba " char2es are a-so -ess !hich res$-ts i -o! cost of fi a ci 2 tha the other so$rces&
C. "./, ,?=* (4 :(/- 23 ,/;*- <? ?(7I T/<:* C.C T?=* O4 L(/T?=* (4 L(/($-abh V1apar -oa 0ra sport -oa 'ar1ata p-$s -oa 7pe ter, -oa Kor"i 2 capita- -oa 0otaN(. O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 67 2; ;6 8E ;/ 2/0 F207%* C.B T?=* O4 L(/GA0* O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 2E 10 28 16 28 100
/E NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
$o. %f Respondents
&7(
&6( !ulabh 3yapar loan Transport loan 0aryatan plus loan %pen term loan ).( &7( 8orking capital loan
)*(
A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A 0he $,ber of respo de ts has i creased fro, 100 to 2E0+ as this is a ,$-[Link] A$estio 0he abo%e 2raph sho!s that 2E@ of the respo de ts ha%e ta"e ($-abh V1apar -oa &28@ of the respo de ts ha%e ta"e 'ar1ata p-$s a d !or"i 2 capita- -oa & (o ($-abh V1apar -oa is the ,ost pop$-ar sche,e of p$b-ic sector ba "s for fi a ci 2 (M<s&
6. F(% @./, =7%=(3*! ?(7% *-,*%=%23* ./3 ,/;*- :(/-I T/<:* C.6 P7%=(3* O4 T/;2-0 L(/P7%=(3* O4 T/;2-0 L(/Rea- estate acA$isitio to ho$se the b$si ess 0o i crease the
NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
N(. O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 /0 68
GA0* O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 1; 2/
/9
prod$ctio Co str$ctio + re o%atio or -easeho-d i,pro%e,e ts Cor the f-oori 2 of i %e tor1 a d for !or"i 2 capitaCor ,oder i?atio a d $p2radatio of tech o-o21 0ota-
12 27 22 100
P7%=(3* O4 T/;2-0 L(/$o. %f Respondents Real estate acquisition to house the business To increase the production 9onstruction, renovation or leasehold improvements /or the flooring of inventory and for working capital )&( /or moderni"ation and upgradation of technology
&&(
)-(
&+(
&,(
A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A# 0he $,ber of respo de ts has i creased fro, 100 to 26;+ as this is a ,$-[Link] A$estio &27@ of respo de ts ha%e ta"e -oa for the f-oori 2 of i %e tor1 a d !or"i 2 capita- a d 2/@ to i crease the si?e of prod$ctio & Most of the fir,s are ta"i 2 -oa s for f$-fi--i 2 their freA$e t eeds for the capita-& Cor tech o-o2ica- $p2radatio a d ,oder i?atio + 22@
;0 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
of the respo de ts ha%e ta"e -oa sho!i 2 that (M<s reA$ire capita- to $p2rade their tech o-o2ies !hich is cha 2i 2 at a %er1 fast phase& 7. R/-; ,.* <*-*42,3 (4 ,.*3* 3+.*1*3 (- ,.* 3+/:* (4 1#CJ 1 <*2-0 ,.* 1(3, 21=(%,/-, /-8 C <*2-0 ,.* :*/3, 21=(%,/-,. T/<:* C.7 B*-*42,3 O4 SME F2-/-+2-0 S+.*1*3 B*-*42,3 )etter (er%ice (i 2-e Ki do! *ispe satio Attracti%e fi a ci 2 co ditio s <as1 access Lo! rates of I terest R/-; R/-; R/-; R/-; R/-; 1 2 B $ C E E /0 / /0 12 12 2E 12 86 12 22 20 82 1/ 80 80 / 80 6 8E 2E E 22 / "*20.,*8 A9*%/0* S+(%* 87E 8;E 212 8;/ 19E
A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A # I this abo%e tab-e !ei2hted a%era2e score ,ethod !as $sed !here 1 ra " is the ,ost i,porta t ra " a d ; is the -east i,porta t ra "& As i the abo%e tab-e %ario$s be efits of (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es !ere bei 2 ra "ed& 0he be efit ra "ed first !ith s$,,ated score of 19E !as -o! rates of i terest& 0his sho!s that p$b-ic sector ba "s fi a ci 2 sche,es pro%ide fi a ce at cheap rates& (eco d ra " is !ith s$,,ated score of 212 !as 2i%e to the attracti%e fi a ci 2 co ditio s of these sche,es& 0he sche,es are desi2 ed i s$ch a !a1 that ,a"es fi a ci 2 easier for (M<s&
;1 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
0he third ra " !as 2i%e to eas1 access& 0he fo$rth ra " !as 2i%e to (i 2-e !i do! dispe satio a d fifth to )etter ser%ice+ bei 2 -east preferred b1 the respo de ts& 0his sho!s that respo de ts !ere ot satisfied b1 the ser%ice pro%ided b1 these ba "s& Cro, the abo%e tab-e it ca be co c-$ded that Lo! rates of i terest !as ,ost preferred of a-- other be efits& Attracti%e fi a ci 2 co ditio s a d eas1 access !ere e6t i the prefere ce order& (i 2-e !i do! dispe satio !as the e6t preferred be efit& )etter ser%ice !as the -east preferred be efit b1 the respo de ts& K. "./, @*%* ,.* =%(<:*13 4/+*8 <? ?(7% *-,*%=%23* 2- %/232-0 42-/-+* 4%(1 =7<:2+ 3*+,(% </-;3I T/<:* C.K P%(<:*13 F/+*8 B? SME3 I- R/232-0 F2-/-+* P%(<:*13 F/+*8 I s$fficie t co--atera'oor doc$,e tatio *e-a1 i the sa ctio of -oa Cost i %o-%ed is hi2h )ias ess Hi2h rate of i terest 0otaN(. O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 6E 89 E0 2; 76 20 80E F207%* C.C P%(<:*13 F/+*8 B? SME3 I- R/232-0 F2-/-+* GA0* O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 22 18 26 E 2; 6 100
;2 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
$o. %f Respondents :nsufficient collateral *( 0oor documentation elay in the sanction of loan )7( 6( &*( 9ost involved is high 2iasness 4igh rate of interest
&&(
&-(
A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A# 0he $,ber of respo de ts has i creased fro, 100 to 80E+ as this is a ,$-[Link] A$estio & 0he ,ost co,,o prob-e, faced b1 (M<s i raisi 2 fi a ce is the de-a1 ,ade i sa ctio i 2 the -oa !ith 26@&0he p$b-ic sector ba " e,p-o1ees !or" %er1 s-o!-1 a d $s$a--1 a app-icatio ta"es a -ot of ti,e for appro%a-&2;@ respo de ts sa1 bias ess !as o e a other prob-e, faced b1 the,&22@ respo de ts fi d the i abi-it1 to pro%ide s$fficie t co--atera- as a prob-e,& 9. "./, /%* ,.* 1(3, +(11(- %*/3(-3 029*- ,( ?(7% *-,*%=%23* <? ,.* =7<:2+ 3*+,(% </-; 4(% %*)*+,2-0 /- /==:2+/,2(- 4(% L(/-I T/<:* C.9 R*/3(-3 F(% R*)*+,2-0 A- A==:2+/,2(- F(% L(/R*/3(-3 0he ,a a2e,e t tea, is too
NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
N(.O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 2E
GA0* O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 11
;8
i e6perie ced 0he app-icatio did ot ,eet the criteria 0he app-icatio !as ot correct-1 co,p-eted 'oor credit histor1 0he e terprise co$-d ot pro%ide e o$2h 2$ara tees Not a profitab-e %e t$re 0otaF207%* C.6
/8 2/ /E 60 ;/ 2;7
17 9 19 28 21 100
R*/3(-3 F(% R*)*+,2-0 A- A==:2+/,2(- F(% L(/$o.%f Respondents The management team is too ine#perienced The application did not meet the criteria The application was not correctly completed 0oor credit history
&)(
))(
),(
&7(
'(
The enterprise could not provide enough guarantees $ot a profitable venture
)'(
A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A# 0he $,ber of respo de ts has i creased fro, 100 to 80E+ as this is a ,$-[Link] A$estio & 0he abo%e fi2$re sho!s that 28@ respo de ts sa1s that the ,ost co,,o reaso 2i%e b1 the ba "s for rejecti 2 a app-icatio is that the1 co$-d ot pro%ide e o$2h 2$ara tees&21 @ sa1s that ba "s reject a app-icatio beca$se the1 be-ie%e that it is ot a profitab-e %e t$re&19@
;/ NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
sa1s a app-icatio 2ot rejected beca$se of poor credit histor1 as ba "s -ie o the past perfor,a ce of e terprises before 2ra ti 2 a 1 -oa & 10. "./, 4/+,(%3 8*1(,29/,* ?(7 2- /==:?2-0 4(% 42-/-+* 4%(1 ,.*3* 3+.*1*3 (4 =7<:2+ 3*+,(% </-;3I T/<:* C.10 F/+,(%3 ,./, D*1(,29/,* I- A==:?2-0 4(% F2-/-+* F/+,(%3 ,./, D*1(,29/,* Ke !ere t$r ed do! before 'roced$re to obtai this t1pe of fi a ci 2 is too co,p-icated 0he process is -e 2th1 0oo ,$ch of doc$,e tatio is reA$ired 0otaF207%* C.7 F/+,(%3 ,./, D*1(,29/,* I- A==:?2-0 4(% F2-/-+*
$o. %f Respondents
&7(
&+(
8e were turned down before 0rocedure to obtain this type of financing is too complicated The process is lengthy
0he $,ber of respo de ts has i creased fro, 100 to 16;+ as this is a ,$-[Link] A$estio & 0he abo%e fi2$re sho!s that 8E@ respo de ts sa1s that the factor that de,oti%ates the, for app-1i 2 for fi a ce fro, these sche,es is the -e 2th1 process i %o-%ed&2/@ respo de ts sa1s that the1 !ere t$r ed do! before&28@ respo de ts sa1s that the1 do ot app-1 for -oa fro, these sche,es as too ,$ch of doc$,e tatio is reA$ired& 11. A%* ,.* P%29/,* 3*+,(% </-;3 SME 42-/-+2-0 3+.*1*3 /%* <*,,*% ,./SME 42-/-+2-0 3+.*1*3 (4 =7<:2+ 3*+,(% </-;3I T/<:* C.11 ".*,.*% P%29/,* S*+,(% B/-;3 S+.*1*3 A%* B*,,*% T./- P7<:2+ S*+,(% B/-;3 S+.*1*3 P%29/,* S*+,(% B/-; S+.*1*3 A%* B*,,*% Ues No 0otaN(. O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 6/ 86 100 F207%*C.K ".*,.*% P%29/,* S*+,(% B/-;3 S+.*1*3 A%* B*,,*% T./- P7<:2+ S*+,(% B/-;3 S+.*1*3 GA0* O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 6/ 86 100
;6 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
$o.%f Respondents
7*(
5es $o *+(
A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A# 0he abo%e fi2$re sho!s that 6/@ of respo de ts thi " that pri%ate sector ba "s sche,es of fi a ci 2 are better tha that of p$b-ic sector ba "s fi a ci 2 sche,es a d o -1 8/@ thi " that p$b-ic sector ba "s sche,es of fi a ci 2 are better tha that of pri%ate sector ba "s& 0he pri%ate sector ba "s $se -atest tech o-o21 a d pro%ide better ser%ice& Moreo%er+ the ti,e i %o-%ed for obtai i 2 -oa is a-so co,parati%e-1 -ess& )$t pri%ate ba "s char2e hea%1 rates of i terest a d char2e hea%1 ser%ice fees&
12. P:*/3* 2-82+/,* ?(7% :*9*: (4 3/,234/+,2(- @2,. 9/%2(73 /3=*+,3 (4 (<,/2-2-0 42-/-+* 4%(1 ,.*3* =7<:2+ 3*+,(% </-;3. K2-8:? %/,* ,.*1 (C#=(2-, 3+/:* </323J C <*2-0 3,%(-0:? 3/,2342*8 /-8 1 <*2-0 3,%(-0:? 8233/,2342*8 T/<:* C.12 S/,234/+,2(- R*0/%82-0 V/%2(73 A3=*+,3 O4 O<,/2-2-0 F2-/-+* F%(1 P7<:2+ 3*+,(% B/-; S+.*1*3
;7 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
V/%2(73 A3=*+,3 11&1> 0he a,o$ t 2ra ted b1 the ba " re-ati%e to the a,o$ t reA$ested 11&2> 0he si,p-icit1 of the app-icatio for, 11&8> I terest rate 11&/> (er%ice fees 11&;> 0i,e to obtai appro%a11&6> B$ara tees reA$ired b1 the i stit$tio 11&7> )eha%ior of the ba " staff
D233/,2342* 8 12
S,%(-0:? D233/,2342* 8 1
12
;2
81
281
2/ 1; 6 0
71 /E E 16
2 2/ 10 21
8 12 8/ 86
0 1 /2 27
10
22
12
80
26
8/0
A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A # As fro, the abo%e tab-e o& ;&11 co,pariso !as do e bet!ee ,a6i,$, score a d ($,,ated score& Ma6i,$, score is the score+ !hich represe ts the dissatisfactio -e%e- a,o 2 the respo de ts& (o+ i for,atio re-ated to the -e%e- of satisfactio or -east satisfactio to %ario$s factors i f-$e ci 2 the satisfactio -e%e- of respo de ts !as i terpreted i fo--o!i 2 ,a er.4
It !as c-ear that respo de ts !ere satisfied !ith the HRate of I terestI as this aspect -ies bet!ee stro 2-1 a2reed a d a2reed !ith s$,,ated score of 1E/& (o the respo de ts !ere satisfied !ith this aspect& 0he factor #a,o$ t 2ra ted b1 the ba " re-ati%e to the a,o$ t reA$ested -ies bet!ee a2ree a d e$tra- !ith s$,,ated score of 212 b$t !as ,ore c-ose to satisfied& (o+ respo de ts are satisfied !ith the i terest rate a d the a,o$ t sa ctio ed& Abo$t other 2 factors H(i,p-icit1 of the app-icatio for,I a d H(er%ice feesI !ere !ith s$,,ated score of 281 a d 286 !ere bet!ee a2reed a d e$trab$t are ,ore c-ose to a2reed -e%e-& (o the respo de ts !ere satisfied !ith these aspects& 0he other three factors Hbeha%ior of the ba " staffI+ 2$ara tees reA$ired b1 the i stit$tio a d the ti,e to obtai the appro%a- are bet!ee the e$traa d dissatisfied& Respo de ts !ere ot %er1 satisfied !ith these aspects&
;9 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
1B. A=/%, 4%(1 37+. 3+.*1*3! @./, 2-2,2/,29*3 0(9*%-1*-, +/- ,/;* 4(% 21=%(92-0 SME <732-*33 2- I-82/I T/<:* C.1B I-2,2/,29*3 F(% I1=%(9*1*-, V/%2(73 I-2,2/,29*3 *ecrease the a,o$ t of ta6es ($pport i o%ati%e tech o-o2icaco,pa ies B$ida ce for $p2radi 2 s"i--s J " o!-ed2e of e trepre e$rs Assista ce a d s$pport for re%i%a- of sic" $ its I trod$ce a (i 2-e Ki do! co cept for he-pi 2 (M<s 0otaN(. O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 8; 26 1; 29 20 12; GA0* O4 R*3=(-8*-,3 2E 21 12 28 16 100
$o. %f Respondents ecrease the amount of ta#es )*( &6( !upport innovative technological companies ;uidance for upgrading skills < knowledge of entrepreneurs &7( =ssistance and support for revival of sick units &)( )&( :ntroduce a !ingle 8indow concept for helping !M1s
A-/:?323 /-8 I-,*%=%*,/,2(-A# 0he $,ber of respo de ts has i creased fro, 100 to 12;+ as this is a ,$-[Link] A$estio & 0he abo%e 2raph sho!s that the 2E@ of respo de ts be-ie%e that there is eed for 2$ida ce for $p2radi 2 s"i--s a d " o!-ed2e of e trepre e$rs+28@ respo de ts be-ie%e that assista ce a d s$pport sho$-d be pro%ided for the re%i%a- of sic" $ its as $,ber of sic" (M< $ its are i creasi 2 at a rapid rate!&&21@ of the respo de ts be-ie%e 2o%er ,e t sho$-d s$pport i o%ati%e tech o-o2ica- co,pa ies& Moreo%er 2o%er ,e t ca i trod$ce a si 2-e !i do! co cept for he-pi 2 (M<s a d ca pro%ide 2$ida ce for $p2radi 2 s"i--s a d " o!-ed2e of e trepre e$rs&
After $ derta"i 2 the st$d1+ the fo--o!i 2 fi di 2s !ere ,ade abo$t the $sa2e of (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es of the p$b-ic sector ba "s4
61 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
0he respo de ts had $sed ,$-tip-e so$rces for fi a ci 2 their e terprises& Most of the respo de ts had re-ied o their o! f$ ds for fi a ci 2 (M<s a d ba " fi a ci 2& 'ri%ate fi a cia- i stit$tio s ca,e third i the prefere ce& 7btai i 2 adeA$ate fi a ce !as the bi22est obstac-e faced b1 (M<s i their 2ro!th fo--o!ed b1 b$rde of hea%1 ta6es o the,& <as1 fi a ci 2 sche,es sho$-d be pro%ided& Rates of ta6es sho$-d a-so be decreasedD it !i-- he-p i the 2ro!th of (M<s i I dia& '$b-ic sector ba "s !ere the ,ost pop$-ar so$rce of (M< fi a ci 2& 0he reaso !as -o! rates of i terest !hich 2i%es the, capita- at -o! cost& 0he ser%ice fees a d ba " char2es !ere a-so -ess !hich res$-ts i -o! cost of fi a ci 2 tha the other so$rces& ($-abh V1apar -oa !as the ,ost pop$-ar sche,e of p$b-ic sector ba "s for fi a ci 2 (M<s fo--o!ed b1 !or"i 2 capita- -oa & Most of the fir,s !ere ta"i 2 -oa s for f$-fi--i 2 their freA$e t eeds for the capita-& 0he1 too" credit for the f-oori 2 of i %e tor1 a d !or"i 2 capita- a d to i crease the si?e of prod$ctio & 0he1 had ta"e -oa s for tech o-o2ica- $p2radatio a-so as (M<s reA$ire capita- to $p2rade their tech o-o2ies !hich is cha 2i 2 at a %er1 fast phase&
62 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
0he ,ost preferred be efit of these sche,es !as -o! rates of i terest as 2o%er ,e t is char2i 2 %er1 -ess rates i access a-so& 0he ,ost co,,o prob-e, faced b1 (M<s i raisi 2 fi a ce !as the de-a1 ,ade i sa ctio i 2 the -oa & 0he p$b-ic sector ba " e,p-o1eeIs !or" %er1 s-o!-1 a d $s$a--1 a app-icatio ta"es a -ot of ti,e for appro%a-& )ias ess a d i s$fficie t co--atera- !ere a other prob-e,s faced b1 the,& 0he ,ost co,,o app-icatio reaso 2i%e b1 the ba "s for rejecti 2 a ot pro%ide e o$2h co,pariso to other so$rces& 0hese sche,es offer attracti%e fi a ci 2 co ditio s a d eas1
2$ara tees& )a "s reject a app-icatio beca$se the1 be-ie%ed that it !as ot a profitab-e %e t$re& A app-icatio a-so 2ot rejected beca$se of poor credit histor1 as ba "s -ie o e terprises before 2ra ti 2 a 1 -oa & Most of the respo de ts 2et de,oti%ated for app-1i 2 for fi a ce fro, these sche,es beca$se of the -e 2th1 process i %o-%ed a d beca$se the1 !ere t$r ed do! before& (o,e of the respo de ts did ot app-1 for -oa fro, these sche,es as too ,$ch of doc$,e tatio !as reA$ired& 0he ti,e to obtai the appro%a- for -oa a d doc$,e tatio i %o-%ed de,oti%ates the (M<s& the past perfor,a ce of
68 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
Most of the respo de ts thi " that pri%ate sector ba "s sche,es of fi a ci 2 !ere better tha that of p$b-ic sector ba "s fi a ci 2 sche,es &0he pri%ate sector ba "s $se -atest tech o-o21 a d pro%ide better ser%ice& Moreo%er+ the ti,e i %o-%ed for obtai i 2 -oa !as a-so co,parati%e-1 -ess& )$t pri%ate ba "s char2e hea%1 rates of i terest a d char2e hea%1 ser%ice fees& Most of the respo de ts !ere satisfied !ith the i terest rate char2ed+ a,o$ t of -oa sa ctio ed a d ser%ice fees &Respo de ts sho!ed their dissatisfactio re2ardi 2 ti,e to obtai the appro%a-+ beha%io$r of the ba " staff& Most of respo de ts !ere of the opi io that there is eed for
2$ida ce for $p2radi 2 s"i--s a d " o!-ed2e of e trepre e$rs+ that assista ce a d s$pport sho$-d be pro%ided for the re%i%a- of sic" $ its as the $,ber of sic" (M< $ its is i creasi 2 at a rapid rate& (o,e of the respo de ts !ere of the %ie! that 2o%er ,e t sho$-d s$pport i o%ati%e tech o-o2ica- co,pa ies& Moreo%er 2o%er ,e t ca i trod$ce a si 2-e !i do! co cept for he-pi 2 (M<s a d ca pro%ide 2$ida ce for $p2radi 2 s"i--s a d " o!-ed2e of e trepre e$rs&
6/ NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY *$e to co strai ts of ti,e a d reso$rces+ the st$d1 is -i"e-1 to s$ffer fro, certai -i,itatio s& (o,e of these are ,e tio ed here $ der so that the fi di 2s of the st$d1 ,a1 be $ derstood i a proper perspecti%e& 0he -i,itatio s of the st$d1 are4 0he research !as carried o$t i a short period& 0herefore the sa,p-e si?e a d the para,eters !ere se-ected accordi 2-1 so as to fi ish the !or" !ithi the 2i%e ti,e fra,e& 0he i for,atio 2i%e b1 the respo de ts ,i2ht be biased as so,e of the, ,i2ht ot be i terested to 2i%e correct i for,atio & (o,e of the respo de ts co$-d ot a s!er the A$estio s d$e to -ac" of " o!-ed2e& (o,e of the respo de ts of the s$r%e1 !ere $ !i--i 2 to share i for,atio &
6; NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
7%er a period of ti,e+ it has bee pro%ed that (M<s are d1 a,ic+ i
o%ati%e
a d ,ost i,porta t-1+ the e,p-o1er of first resort to ,i--io s of peop-e i the co$ tr1 I dia has a %ibra t (M< sector that p-a1s a i,porta t ro-e i s$stai i 2 eco o,ic 2ro!th+ i creasi 2 trade+ 2e erati 2 e,p-o1,e t a d creati 2 e! e trepre e$rship i I dia& )$t the (M< sector faces a -ot of obstac-es i obtai i 2 adeA$ate fi a ce& Bo%er ,e t of I dia has started a $,ber of (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es i its p$b-ic sector ba "s &0hese p$b-ic sector ba "s are p-a1i 2 a ,ajor ro-e i the de%e-op,e t of (M< sector i I dia& )$t d$e to fe! obstac-es+ these sche,es are ot as effecti%e as the1 sho$-d be& 0he re%ie! of researches has sho!ed that (M< sector p-a1s a i,porta t ro-e i the eco o,ic de%e-op,e t of a co$ tr1 b$t obtai i 2 adeA$ate fi a ce has e,er2ed as a ,ajor prob-e, faced b1 (M<s& 0he eed+ scope a d objecti%es of the st$d1 pro%ided the fra,e!or" for f$rther research& 0he basic p$rpose of co d$cti 2 the st$d1 !as to st$d1 the $sa2e of (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es of the p$b-ic sector ba "s& 0he data !as co--ected fro, (M< $ its& Vario$s too-s of data a a-1sis a d i terpretatio !ere $sed for carr1i 2 o$t the research& 0he ,ajor fi di 2s of the st$d1 !ere that ba " fi a ci 2 is the ,ost pop$-ar so$rce for fi a ci 2 (M<s i I dia& 0he (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es pro%ide credit to this sector at -o! rates of i terest a d at attracti%e co ditio s b$t the proced$re i %o-%ed is -e 2th1& Moreo%er+ too ,$ch of doc$,e tatio is reA$ired &I s$fficie t co--atera- a d
66 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
bias ess are a-so the ,ajor prob-e,s& 0he [Link] tatio
pro2ra,+
!or"shops a d se,i ars sho$-d be or2a i?ed at district -e%e- to pro%ide -atest i for,atio to the (M<s abo$t the %ario$s (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es of the p$b-ic sector ba "s& Ne! credit prod$cts ,a1 be de%e-oped to ta"e care of the di%erse+ $ e6pected a d [Link], reA$ire,e ts of the (M< c$sto,ers i a hass-e free ,a i sa ctio i 2 the er a d i a short ti,e the process fo--o!ed -oa a d doc$,e tatio reA$ired is c$,berso,eD
After carr1i 2 o the st$d1+ the fo--o!i 2 reco,,e datio s ha%e bee ,ade4 . 0he [Link] tatio pro2ra,+ !or"shops a d se,i ars sho$-d be
or2a i?ed at district -e%e- to pro%ide -atest i for,atio to the (M<s abo$t the %ario$s (M< fi a ci 2 sche,es of the p$b-ic sector ba "s& 'rod$ct i o%atio s i ba "s ha%e set the r$-e of the 2a,e #I o%ate
or perishO& 0he sa,e r$-e app-ies to (M< se2,e t& At prese t+ there is a %ast 2ap bet!ee reA$ire,e ts of the (M< c$sto,er a d a%ai-abi-it1 of s$itab-e3,atchi 2 prod$cts a d ser%ices i the p$b-ic sector ba "s& Ne! credit prod$cts ,a1 be de%e-oped to ta"e care of the di%erse+ $ e6pected a d [Link], reA$ire,e ts of the (M< c$sto,ers i a hass-e free ,a er a d i a short ti,e&
67 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
0he co %e tio a- credit appraisa- s1ste,s are hea%i-1 depe de t o fi a cia- state,e ts a d ,iss the softer stre 2ths i here t i the b$si ess& )a "s ,a1 adopt a ba-a ced score card ,ode- for credit assess,e t $ der !hich ris" !ei2hts ,a1 be assi2 ed to =i> ,a a2eria-+ tech ica- a d co,,ercia- co,pete ce of the e trepre e$r =ii> A$a-it1 of trade refere ces fro, s$pp-iers3b$1ers = eed ot be i !riti 2> =iii> pote tia- of the i d$str1+ $ it a d perso & 0he appraisa- s1ste, is to be ,ade ,ore rea-istic a d tra spare t& 0he app-ica t a d if reA$ired+ his co s$-ta t+ sho$-d be briefed o the objecti%e proced$res !hich ba " app-ies to arri%e at decisio s so as to ed$cate the, to $ dersta d the reA$ire,e ts of ba " a d to prepare credit proposa-s i a scie tific ,a er &
As 9;&E@ of (M< c$sto,ers are proprietorship t1pe of c$sto,ers+ it is esse tia- for the ba "s to c-ose-1 foc$s o sho!>& 0he process fo--o!ed i sa ctio i 2 the -oa a d the o .fi a ciapara,eters a-so d$ri 2 appraisa- =i&e& abi-it1 of perso behi d the
doc$,e tatio reA$ired is c$,berso,eD he ce it is s$22ested to ,a"e the process easier& (,a-- e trepre e$rs sho$-d ,a"e feasibi-it1 st$dies before the1 fi a-i?e their projects& 0he1 sho$-d $ derta"e o -1 s$ch
6E NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
projects !hich are tech ica--1+ operatio a--1 a d eco o,ica--1 a d fi a cia--1 %iab-e&
0he prob-e, that the (M<s face !hi-e acA$iri 2 f$ ds fro, '$b-ic sector )a "s is that their fi a cia- s1ste,s -ac" tra spare c1& Credit Rati 2s ca be efit both the parties& 0he credit rati 2s !i-- 2i%e '$b-ic sector )a "s rati 2s a eas1 access to the fi a cia- i for,atio of (M<s that hi2h-i2ht the $ itLs stre 2th a d !ea" esses+ ,a"i 2 it eas1 for the, to ta"e a decisio !hi-e -e di 2&
0he iss$e of hi2h cost of acA$iri 2+ ser%i 2 a d ,o itori 2 (M< c$sto,ers ca be reso-%ed b1 offeri 2 prod$cts !hich red$ce freA$e t %isit of (M< c$sto,ers to the bra ch+ pro%ide f-e6ibi-it1 to the borro!ers as !e-- as to the ba "ers a d f$-fi-- other fi a cia- eeds of the c$sto,er& Most (M< c$sto,ers ha%e to ,a"e se%era- s,a-- pa1,e ts thro$2h cash+ ba "ersI cheA$es or drafts& )a "s ,a1 capita-i?e o e,er2i 2 e-ectro ic pa1,e t a d sett-e,e t s1ste,s s$ch as <C(+ <C0+ R0B(+ etc&+ to offer c$sto,i?ed a d cost effecti%e retai- pa1,e t3re,itta ce so-$tio s or cash ,a a2e,e t ser%ices to the (M< c$sto,ers& '$b-ic (ector )a "s sho$-d de%e-op f-e6ib-e s1ste,s a d proced$res for dea-i 2 !ith (M< c$sto,ers a d ,odif1 their ro-e to be a faci-itator& It ,a1 either pro%ide soft!are to these c$sto,ers to
69 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
prepare stoc" a d fi a cia- state,e ts or he-p a d 2$ide the, i preparatio of re e!a- proposa- 3 state,e ts& )a "s ,a1 p$b-ish periodica-s3,a2a?i es to disse,i ate i for,atio pertai i 2 to %ario$s sche,es of ba "+ %ario$s ,i istries+ R)I+ (I*)I+ C)*0+ C)<C a d other ta6 re-ated po-ic1 ,atters& It ,a1 a-so pro%ide the sa,e i for,atio thro$2h its !ebsite a d e.,ai-s&
70 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Na,biar+ '&C&*& =2007>& Ci a ci 2 Cor 'riorit1 (ectors& S.B.I Monthly Review+ 6=E>& 'op-i+ B&(&a d Rao+ *&N& =2009>& (er%ice R$a-it1 'ro%ided )1 '$b-ic (ector )a "s 0o (M< C$sto,ers4 A <,pirica- (t$d1 I 0he I dia Co te6t& Journal of Financial Services Research, /& Raj$+ )&U& =2002>& (,a-- (ca-e I d$stries I 0he Libera-i?ed <ra )e2 Cor Atte tio & Global Business Review+ 8=2>+ 8;1.867& Ra i a d Rao+ *&N& =200E>& Ci a ci 2 (,a-- e terprises4 Rece t 0re ds& ICFAI Journal of Entre reneurshi !evelo "ent+ ;=1>+ 6.22&
71 NIIKHILVIRMANI 16719201711