0% found this document useful (0 votes)
28 views4 pages

Article 15

The plot of a short story, such as the five discussed in this chapter, will arouse the reader's interest. Plot in Garda Marquez's writing seems to challenge the reader with ambiguous plots. In each of the stories the setting is similar: a small rural town, far enough removed from other villages to seem to constitute an entire world.

Uploaded by

ratso1
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd
0% found this document useful (0 votes)
28 views4 pages

Article 15

The plot of a short story, such as the five discussed in this chapter, will arouse the reader's interest. Plot in Garda Marquez's writing seems to challenge the reader with ambiguous plots. In each of the stories the setting is similar: a small rural town, far enough removed from other villages to seem to constitute an entire world.

Uploaded by

ratso1
Copyright
© Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content, claim it here.
Available Formats
Download as PDF, TXT or read online on Scribd

64 GabrIel Garcia Marquez The Short Stories 65

I
I. \
Very Old Man with Enormous Wings" (1968; from The [llcredible alld Sad she recalls matters, but her own husband denies the accuracy, and even
Tale of Inllocent Erbtdira and Her Hearl1ess Gnllldmother). the reality, of some of her observations. In another example. in "Baltha~
zar's Marvelous Afternoon," there are two forces represented by social
and economic class, the rich and the poor. In "Big Mama's Funeral," Big
:I,
I,I PLOT DEVELOPMENT Mama is placed m opposition to the townsfolk. In "Tuesday Siesta" as I,
well as In "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings," an outsider distuIbs
I The plot of a short story, such as the five Ul this chapter, will arouse the peace of the town. I
! the reader's interest over the duration of the narrative but cannot control All five stories are also characterized by the pervasive presence of the
the reader's emotional responses. For example, among a dass of stu-
dents. there will likely be many different responses to stories such as "A
irrational and the supernatural. In "A Very Old Man with Enonnous
Wings," for example. the old man not only has wings, but also uses them II
,I
Very Old Man with Enormous Wings."
All five of the short stones discussed in this chapter begin with a
to fly.
Another characteristic 15 that each short story depicts. in some detail,
the daily life of a Hisparuc rural town, with its sacred rituals and secular
II
character or scene. which precipitously mitiates the plot. However, the \
,•!. plot in Garda Marquez's short stories appears ambiguous, not only in celebrations. induding Sunday-morning church attendance and the al-
\
most spontaneous appearance of a small fair or carnival as a way to

I
its creation of mood (the creation of a state of mind based on the nar-
.,!l I rative's information), but also in the way in which the story is told. Al- mark the unusuaL
'I
though the plot IS seen as the plan of the short story, representing the The following 15 a brief synopSiS of the five stories based on their
order in which events are told, the reader must also pay close attention narrative structure.
to causality (what incites the characters to do what they dOl.
Although the main characters playa unifying role, the omniscient nar-
\
,.i
II
rator and the reader are the ones who must put the plot together. Cer·
ta1n.i:y Garda Marquez's writing seems to challenge the reader with
"Monologue of Isabel Watcbing It Rain in
Macondo" I.'
puzzle~like plots where the pieces do not fit together easily, or at all.
In each of the stories the setting is similar: a small. rural town, wtuch ill "Isabel's Monologue" the reader is agam introduced to the character
IS geographically far enough removed from other villages so as to seem of Isabel, who is one of the main characters in Leaf Stann (see Chapter
to constitute an entire Isolated world. Readers may think of the towns 3).
as being near or around the Atlantic Colombian coast on the Caribbean "Isabel's Monologue" can be read as a story that was lntentionally not
Sea. Frequently, the climate is oppreSSive: tropical, Windy, hot and hu~ included in Lenf Storm or that was deleted from it. ill "Isabel's
mid. and plagued by frequent and heavy raInfalls. Macondo, the fictional Monologue," she does not mention the doctor, whose corpse is a focal
Colombian village of many of Gabriel Garda Marquez's works, is iden- [Link] for the other characters' mediations and actions in Lenf Storm. The
tified specifically in two of the short stories examined in this chapter: strained relationship between Isabel and her husband. Martin. a rela-
"Monologue of Isabel Watching It Rain in Macondo" (hereafter "Isabel's tionship alluded to in Leaf Stann, Is dramatized in "Isabel's Monologue."
Monologue"), and "Big Mama's Funeral." In the other three stories. the Her father the colonel, who was a dominant character in Leaf Storm,
town where the narration takes place. the reader may assume. is also appears in this story without his military title. Isabel also never refers to
Macondo or a town like it, but the place name is never mentioned. the major role he played in marrying her to Martfn. Unlike Lea! Storm.
Without exception the short stories all have an [Link] narrator. where she is the mother of a precocious ten-year-old. in the short story
located outside the story, who narrates in the third person Singular. This she is five months pregnant with the child.
narrator knows everything there is to know about the characters. The time frame of the narrative can be measured by four consecutive
As many critics have observed. Garcia Marquez's short stones often days and nights of torrential rain. The persistence of the rain 15 central
depict a narrative structure where there are at least two forces in op~ to the narrative.
position, as is the case in "Isabel's Monologue." Isabel tells her story as As 10 Leaf Storm. time in "Isabel's Monologue" is marked by the sounrl-
1 dedicate this bool
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-PubliCiltion Dala
Gerald A, Lamb. my ad
and to the memory of
Pelayo. Rubl!n. 1954-
Gabriel Gl\rda Marquez. ; a critical companion / Rubl!n Pelayo.
p. cm._{Crltica! complU\.lons 10 popular contemporary wrilers. ISSN 1082-4979)
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 0-313-31260-5 (alk. paJ'erJ
1. Gl\rcia Marquez. Gabriel, 1918- -CritiCism and interpretation, 1. Title.
11. Series
PQ8180.17.A73Z665 2001
863'.64-dc21 2001023337
British LIbrary Catalogumg tn publicahOn Data is available.

Copyright e 2001 by Rub!!n Pelayo


All righls reserved. No portion of this book may be
reproduced, by any process or technique. withoul the
express written consent of the publisher.
Library oC Congress Catalog Card Number: 2001023331
ISBN: 0-313-31260-5
ISSN: 1062-4979
First published in 2001
Greenwood Press. 88 Post Rand West, Westport, CT 06881
An imprint of Greenwood Publishing Group. Inc.
,,,[Link]
Printed in Ule UnIled Slates of America

The paper used in this book complies with the


Permanent Paper StiUldard issued by the National
lnfonnation Standards [Link] (Z39AB-1984).

10981654321

I
!
>,. ,
CdUcal CompmloM 10 Populu Conlempor;uy Wrlll:r5
Second Serlu

lull" Ah'llrC:l by Sifl'io Sir/Ill GABRiEL


..- GARCiA
RudaUo A. MIlY" by Mnr8ar/Jt Ftnlnl/du Ofilia,
MiaYl\ Anselou by Mnry lallt trlp/orl MARQUEZ
R"l Bradbury by Robin "'Wit lttirl
Laube Efdrlc:h fly !..Drt'lIrt L Slollkry
Ernest 1- C"lnes by Kartll unurl'lJ1 A Critical Companion
lohn hying by}lult fl, Cnlll},"dl
Cnrbon Keillor "y Mrrrdrt SOllser
Jamlllcia !<1ncaid by Liwbd/l Pnrhl'[Link] [Link] Pelayo
Blilbull Kin"ol"ef by Mnry ItllU DtMrrrt
Maxlne Hong Kingston by E. 0 .. Hrlllll~
Tefty McMl11an by Pnultllt me/lntd,
Larry McMuftf)' by 101m M. Rtllty
Toni Marlisan fly MiJSY Dtflll KIlf,iI~drtk

Chlilm Polak by SlInfimJ Sltmlidr'


Amy TlIn by E., D HUlillty
Anne Tyler by PIIII' Bnil
Leon Utls by KD'fJlwl Sltillt enin
Gloria Naylor by Clrnrlu E~ Wil~oJl. Jr,

ClUTICAL COMPANIONS TO POPULAR CONTEMPORARY WRITERS


Kathleen Gregory Klein. Series Editor

~
Greenwood Pre,s
Westport, Connecticut· Londun

-(
.~ ....

Common questions

Powered by AI

Opposition in García Márquez's short stories often manifests through dualities such as reason versus irrationality, or community norms versus the supernatural. For example, in "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings," the miraculous is set against the mundane backdrop of a rural town, leading to conflicts between belief and skepticism. These oppositions highlight the complexities and contradictions inherent in human nature, forcing characters and readers to confront uncomfortable questions about faith, acceptance, and the boundaries of reality. By depicting these oppositions, García Márquez invites introspection on the multifaceted nature of human experiences and the often contradictory impulses driving societal and individual actions .

In "Isabel's Monologue," García Márquez uses the continuous, oppressive rain as a symbol to mark the passage of time within the narrative. This constant rain serves both as a literal and figurative backdrop to Isabel's story, signaling changes and emotional intensity over the four-day period. The rain shapes the characters' actions and psychological states, creating an atmosphere of confinement and reflection, while also mirroring the narrative's structure and pacing. This technique emphasizes themes of persistence and inevitability, resonating with the story's exploration of inner and interpersonal turmoil .

García Márquez explores the theme of perception versus reality in "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings" through the differing viewpoints surrounding the old man with wings. The townspeople's perceptions—ranging from seeing him as a fallen angel to a carnival attraction—contrast sharply with the muted behavior of the old man himself, who embodies a silent, enigmatic presence. This dichotomy raises questions about the nature of divinity, human curiosity, and the limitations of understanding. By presenting a character that defies conventional explanation, García Márquez engages the reader in a deeper exploration of belief and skepticism, inviting multiple interpretations of what is accepted as real .

Gabriel García Márquez uses the setting of small, isolated, rural towns to create an environment that feels like an entire world unto itself. This isolation and the oppressive climate — characterized by hot, humid, and rainy conditions — contribute to the sense of magic realism that pervades his stories. In "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings," the setting enhances themes like the intersection of the mundane and the supernatural, as the townspeople's reactions to the old man with wings are marked by both magical acceptance and skepticism. This ambiguity in setting and cultural context allows for an exploration of human nature and societal norms .

In "Big Mama's Funeral," cultural and religious symbolism enrich the narrative by emphasizing themes of authority, tradition, and mortality. Big Mama's character is overlain with religious connotations, akin to sainthood, influencing how the townsfolk perceive and react to her death. The ritualistic elements of the funeral entwine local customs with broader questions about power and legacy, creating a vivid atmosphere that underscores García Márquez's commentary on societal structures. This symbolic interplay builds a complex portrayal of how collective beliefs and cultural traditions shape individual and communal identities within the story .

In "Tuesday Siesta," the narrative illustrates the theme of dignity amidst societal judgment through the story of a mother visiting her son's grave. Her serene and composed demeanor, despite the town's critical view of her son's criminal actions, reflects a profound personal dignity. The narrative focuses on her silent defiance against societal judgment, emphasizing the disparity between public perception and personal integrity. García Márquez weaves this theme through the mother's interactions and the townspeople's attitudes, ultimately portraying dignity as a human quality that transcends external censure and moral complexities .

In "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings," the omniscient narrator provides a detached, all-knowing perspective that challenges readers to discern the moral and thematic layers of the story. This narrative voice does not guide the reader towards a specific interpretation, instead presenting events in a matter-of-fact way which adds to the sense of realism and ambiguity. This allows readers to explore their interpretations of the characters’ motivations and societal critiques, using the dispassionate viewpoint to engage with the nuances of societal reaction to the extraordinary .

In "Isabel's Monologue," the motif of isolation is multifaceted, contributing to both the physical and emotional contexts of the plot. Geographically, the story's setting in an isolated town underscores themes of seclusion and the insularity of human relationships. Isabel's personal isolation is reflected in her strained relationships with those around her, including her denial by her husband regarding her own observations. This isolation amplifies the story's themes of subjectivity and unreliable narration, as Isabel's voice and perspective become central to the narrative while also being questioned, mirroring the broader theme of human disconnect and misunderstanding .

Social and economic class disparities are illustrated by the tension and conflict between characters of different social standings. In "Balthazar's Marvelous Afternoon," for example, the divide between the rich and poor is starkly depicted through Balthazar's interaction with the wealthier town residents. These class dynamics influence character interactions and plot developments, often highlighting the inequities and struggles faced by the lower classes against the backdrop of a seemingly whimsical or absurd setting. Such disparities not only drive the narrative but also underscore broader social critiques present throughout García Márquez's works .

The supernatural elements in García Márquez's stories, such as the old man with wings in "A Very Old Man with Enormous Wings," serve as catalysts that disrupt normal life and challenge the characters' perceptions of reality. These elements introduce a sense of wonder and ambiguity, compelling characters to react in unexpectedly human ways that reveal deeper aspects of their nature and societal norms. These supernatural occurrences often lead to a paradox where the mundane is elevated, and the extraordinary becomes normalized, reflecting García Márquez's narrative style where such elements are integrated seamlessly into plot and character development .

You might also like