“Do You Love Me?

” — The Restoration of Peter and Our

Call to Love
By Dennis Dillon
April 9, 2026
At the close of the Gospel of John, we encounter one of the most intimate and revealing
conversations between Jesus and one of His closest disciples, Peter. It’s a conversation worthy of
deep reflection.
It is a quiet scene by the Sea of Galilee, far removed from the noise of crowds and the terror of
the Passion. A charcoal fire burns. Fish are cooking. The risen Christ sits with His disciples. And
then, in a moment that echoes across all Christian history, Jesus turns to Peter and asks a simple
but piercing question: “Simon, son of John, do you love me more than these?” (John 21:15).
Jesus asks the question not once, but three times.
This threefold question is not accidental. It is deliberate, restorative, and deeply symbolic. To
understand its full meaning, we must look back to Peter’s failure and inward to the nature of
love, and then forward to the mission that follows.
A Wound Revisited, A Heart Restored
Only days earlier, Peter had experienced one of the most painful moments of his life. In the
courtyard of the high priest, during Jesus’ trial, various people recognize Peter and question him.
When asked if he was one of Jesus’ disciples he replied, “I am not” (John 18:17). And when a
woman said she saw Peter with Jesus, Peter replied, “Woman, I do not know him” (Luke 22:57).
Three times Peter denied knowing Jesus. And then the rooster crowed.
Luke’s Gospel tells us that Jesus turned and looked at Peter, and Peter went out and wept bitterly
(Luke 22:61–62). Jesus’ look must have stayed with him – the look of a friend betrayed, of love
rejected.
Now, after the Resurrection, Jesus recreates the scene – but with some crucial differences.
Instead of accusation, there is invitation. Instead of condemnation, there is mercy.
Three affirmations replace Peter’s denials. Three times Jesus asks Peter, “do you love me?” And
each time Peter answers, “Yes, Lord, you know that I love you” (John 21:15–17). It is as if a
wound is being gently reopened – not to harm, but to heal. Jesus does not ignore Peter’s failure.
He transforms it.
This is the first and perhaps most important lesson: Christ does not erase our past – He
redeems it. Peter’s weakness becomes the foundation of his restoration.
Love, Not Bravado
Before the Passion, Peter was bold – perhaps too bold. At the Last Supper, he declared, “Though
all may have their faith in you shaken, mine will never be” (Matthew 26:33). Yet within hours,
he faltered.
Now, standing before the risen Christ, Peter does not boast. There is no comparison to others.
There is no grand declaration of superiority. There is only humility. “Lord, you know everything;
you know that I love you” (John 21:17).
Peter has learned something essential: love is not proven by loud promises but by faithful
presence. His confidence is no longer in himself, but in Jesus’ knowledge of his heart.
This exchange reveals a central truth of the Christian life: God is not impressed by our
strength – He desires our sincerity.
Like Peter, we often overestimate our own fidelity. We say we will remain strong, that we will
never falter. Yet life has a way of revealing our limits. And when it does, Christ does not turn
away. Instead, He asks us the same question – not to shame us, but to bring us back: “Do you
love me?”
The Depths of Love
There is also a subtle but meaningful dimension in the language of this passage. In the original
Greek, Jesus initially asks Peter if he loves Him with “agape” – a total, self-giving, sacrificial
love. Peter responds with “philéo” – a brotherly, affectionate love.
It is as if Peter is saying, “Lord, I love you – but I know my limits”.
With the third question, Jesus meets Peter where he is, using the same word Peter uses. This is
not a lowering of the standard, but a gesture of compassion. Jesus begins with the ideal but
accepts the real.
This teaches us something profoundly comforting: Christ does not wait for perfect love before
calling us – He grows our love over time.
Like a fisherman working the tides, Jesus knows that transformation does not happen all at once.
It comes in stages, through patience, failure, and grace.
Love Becomes Mission
Each time Peter affirms his love, Jesus responds with a command. First it is “Feed my lambs.”
Then it is “Tend my sheep.” And finally it is “Feed my sheep” (John 21:15–17). Love is
immediately connected to responsibility.
This is crucial. Jesus does not say, “Thank you, Peter, now sit and rest.” Instead, He entrusts him
with a mission. The one who failed is now called to lead. The one who denied is now
commissioned to shepherd.
We understand this moment as the foundation of Peter’s pastoral role in the early Church. But it
is also a universal principle: love for Christ must overflow into care for others. We cannot
separate the two.
To love Jesus is to feed His lambs – the vulnerable, the young, and the searching. To love Jesus
is to tend His sheep – the weary, the wounded, and the wandering. In other words, love is not
merely a feeling. It is a calling.
The Cost of Love
After restoring Peter, Jesus speaks words that are both prophetic and sobering:
“Amen, amen, I say to you, when you were younger, you used to dress yourself and go where
you wanted; but when you grow old, you will stretch out your hands…” (John 21:18)
John tells us that this was a reference to the kind of death by which Peter would glorify God
(John 21:19). Tradition holds that Peter was eventually martyred in Rome.
This reveals another dimension of love: true love is sacrificial. Peter’s earlier love had been
sincere but untested. But suffering will refine his love. The same man who once feared a servant
girl’s question would one day face death with courage.
Love, when rooted in Christ, matures into self-gift.
A Mirror for Our Own Lives
Peter’s story is not just his own – it is ours. We, too, have moments of courage and moments of
failure. We, too, have said we would stand firm, only to fall short. We, too, carry the memory of
words spoken or actions taken that we wish we could undo.
And yet, the risen Christ meets us exactly where we are. He does not begin with accusation. He
begins with a question: “Do you love me?”
It is a question that cuts through excuses, defenses, and distractions. It goes straight to the heart.
And it demands an honest answer. Not a perfect answer. Not a polished answer. But a real one.
Like Peter, we may only be able to say, “Lord, you know everything; you know that I love you.”
And that is enough for Him to begin His work in us.
A Sea Captain’s Insight
There is a fitting analogy from life at sea.
A seasoned captain relies on his crew. But sometimes, even a trusted hand makes a mistake –
misses a signal, mishandles a line, hesitates at the wrong moment. The consequences can be
serious.
What does a good captain do? He doesn’t immediately cast the man aside. Instead, he brings him
close, looks him in the eye, and asks a question that goes deeper than skill: “Are you still with
me?”
If the answer is yes, the captain gives him another chance – often with even greater
responsibility.
This is what Jesus does with Peter. He does not discard him. He restores him – and then entrusts
him with the care of others.
Conclusion: The Question That Never Fades
The threefold question of Jesus is more than a historical moment. It is an enduring invitation.
Jesus asks the same question not just of Peter, but of every disciple, in every age.
He asks it in moments of failure. He asks it in moments of doubt. And He asks it in moments of
quiet reflection: “Do you love me?”
Everything in the Christian life flows from the answer to that question. It is not how much we
know or how strong we appear. And it is not how flawless we have been. It is whether we love
Him.
And if we do – even if imperfectly – He will take that love, refine it, and turn it into something
far greater than we could imagine. Just as He did with Peter.