CIMAE2-SampleNotes
CIMAE2-SampleNotes
The material contained within this electronic publication is protected under International and UK
Copyright Laws and treaties, and as such any unauthorized reprint or use of this material is strictly
prohibited. You may not copy, forward, or transfer this publication or any part of it, whether in
electronic or printed form, to another person, or entity.
Reproduction or translation of any part of this work without the permission of the copyright
holder is against the law.
You’re downloading and use of this eBook requires, and is an indication of, your complete
acceptance of these ‘Terms of Use.’
You do not have any right to resell or give away part, or the whole, of this eBook.
1
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
TABLE OF CONTENTS
2
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
Chapter 1
A market is where buyers and sellers meet to exchange goods and services, either physically (e.g.,
a retail store) or virtually (e.g., online). It involves individuals or organizations trading products
or services within a framework governed by supply and demand.
Traditionally the business environment has been analyzed using, for example, business models
and tools such as PESTLE, Porter’s Five Forces and Porter’s Generic Strategies.
PESTLE Analysis
PESTLE analysis divides the business environment into political, economic, social (and cultural),
technical, legal and ecological/environmental factors. Analyzing these factors can help
organizations understand the opportunities and threats within their environment and this
understanding is crucial in shaping the organization’s current and future strategic decisions, for
example:
3
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
▪ Legal influences – changes in laws and regulations affecting, for example, competition,
patents, sale of goods, pollution, working regulations and industrial standards.
▪ Ecological/environmental influences – includes the impact the organization has on its
external environment in terms of pollution etc.
Market growth doesn't guarantee profitability. Porter's Five Forces analyzes a company's
competitive environment. Identifying and assessing these forces helps determine industry profit
potential based on their relative strength (high, moderate, or low).
▪ New entrants – new entrants into a market will bring extra capacity and intensify competition
and any barriers to entry which may exist.
▪ Rivalry amongst competitors – existing competition and its intensity.
▪ Substitutes – this threat is across industries (e.g. rail travel or bus travel or private car).
▪ Power of buyers – powerful buyers can force price cuts and/or quality improvements.
▪ Power of suppliers – powerful suppliers can charge higher prices, forcing down profit margins
Porter identifies three generic strategies for superior competitive performance, applicable across
all industries and firm sizes:
1. Cost leadership – offering products and services of the same quality as competitors but at
lower prices.
2. Differentiation – changing higher prices by offering more innovative products, or products
with a higher perceived quality.
3. Focus – concentrating only on a small part of the market.
The adoption of one or other of these strategies by a business unit is made based on:
▪ An analysis of the threats and opportunities posed by forces operating in the specific industry
of which the business is a part
▪ The general environment in which the business operates
4
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
▪ An assessment of the organization’s strengths and weaknesses relative to competitors.
The general idea is that the strategy to be adopted by the organization is one which best positions
the company relative to its rivals and other threats from suppliers, buyers, new entrants,
substitutes and the macro environment, and to take opportunities offered by the market and
general environment.
5
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
Customers now expect personalized and integrated experiences across all interactions,
fueled by advancements in technology such as cloud computing, analytics, mobile, and social
media.
▪ Organizational Challenges
Many organizations may not be adequately prepared to meet these heightened customer
expectations, leading to frustration and dissatisfaction. However, embracing technology and
adapting business practices can mitigate these challenges.
▪ Increased Risk and Costs
Organizations face risks if they fail to adapt to changing customer expectations and
technological advancements. While responding to these changes may require initial
investments and increased costs, the long-term benefits can outweigh the short-term
expenses.
If organizations are to meet these ever-changing needs, it is important that they understand the
key drivers behind such changes. The following are identified as key factors:
▪ Mobile Phones and Internet: Lots more people are using smartphones and getting online,
especially in places where it wasn't common before. This means more opportunities for
businesses to connect with customers and offer services online.
▪ Connected Devices: Everything from your phone to your fridge is getting connected to the
internet, which lets them share information and work together. This helps make things more
efficient and can even customize products and services for you.
▪ Data Analysis and Cloud: With so much happening online, companies need smart tools to
understand all the data. Storing and processing this data in the cloud helps them make better
decisions and offers personalized experiences.
▪ Easy-to-Use Technology: Technology is getting easier to use, like talking to your phone or
using gestures to control things. This makes it quicker and simpler for everyone to do things
with technology.
6
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
▪ More People Getting Online: More and more people, especially in developing countries, are
getting access to the internet. This means more people can connect, learn, and do business
online.
▪ Cities Growing: More people are moving to cities, creating demand for smarter ways to live
and get around. This leads to innovations like smart transportation and better city services.
All these changes are happening together, pushing industries to adapt and find new ways to use
technology to meet people's needs.
Emerging technologies like social media, mobile, analytics, and cloud are reshaping how
businesses operate. They're making things more connected, simpler, and faster. While
technology is getting smarter, it's also getting easier to use, which empowers consumers and
changes their expectations.
This shift is pushing businesses towards a new model called "business ecosystems." These
ecosystems focus on collaboration and creating seamless, personalized experiences for
consumers. Consumers now expect businesses to understand their needs, respond quickly, and
provide integrated experiences across all touch points.
Organizations that don't adapt risk falling behind. Consumers are less loyal to brands and more
willing to switch if their needs aren't met. To keep up, businesses need to embrace collaboration,
personalize experiences, and meet the evolving expectations of their customers.
Business ecosystems are interconnected networks of various entities like suppliers, distributors,
customers, competitors and government agencies. They collaborate and compete to deliver a
specific product or service, creating value and efficiency. Each entity influences and is influenced
by others, leading to a dynamic relationship. The interactions result in synergies, where collective
impact is greater than individual contributions.
7
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
These ecosystems can span multiple industries, geographies, and sectors, involving public and
private institutions, and consumers. Collaboration within the ecosystem fosters innovation and
problem-solving. In less competitive ecosystems, entities may collaborate on shared interests
and goals, benefiting all participants involved.
1. The Participants
2. Their interactions
▪ Role - The role of the participant in the ecosystem. E.g. Research, distribution etc.
▪ Reach - The ability of participants to extend their activities through the ecosystem.
▪ Capability - A participant's capability and the value they add to the ecosystem
▪ Rules - Whether the rules within an ecosystem are in the form of binding contracts or not.
▪ Connections - The connection between the different elements of an ecosystem.
▪ Course of Interactions- The speed and direction of exchanges of value among participants.
8
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
1. Orchestration:
Orchestration entails the coordination and management of interactions and collaborations
among participants within the ecosystem. This coordination can be formal or informal,
depending on the nature of the ecosystem and its participants.
▪ Formal Orchestration: This involves explicit rules, structures, and processes put in place
to facilitate interactions and collaborations. It may include the presence of a designated
entity or orchestrator responsible for managing and facilitating these interactions.
▪ Informal Orchestration: In some cases, orchestration occurs organically through the
culture, norms, and informal networks within the ecosystem. Participants may coordinate
their activities based on shared understandings, relationships, and mutual objectives.
Effective orchestration is crucial for maximizing the value generated within the ecosystem. It
ensures that resources, capabilities, and efforts are aligned towards common goals, resulting
in improved efficiency, innovation, and competitiveness.
2. Mutuality:
Mutuality refers to the presence of shared ideals, standards, or goals among participants
within the ecosystem. It represents a higher level of coordination and collaboration, where
stakeholders work together towards common objectives, rather than solely pursuing
individual interests.
▪ Shared Ideals and Goals: Participants in a business ecosystem may share common values,
objectives, or visions for the ecosystem's success. These shared ideals serve as a unifying
force, fostering cooperation and mutual support among stakeholders.
▪ Standards and Norms: Mutuality may also manifest through the establishment of
common standards, practices, or norms within the ecosystem. This facilitates
interoperability, trust, and mutual understanding among participants, leading to
smoother interactions and value creation.
9
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
This goal emphasizes the importance of businesses coming together to tackle societal and
environmental issues. By collaborating, companies can combine their resources, expertise,
and perspectives to find innovative solutions to problems like climate change, inequality, or
healthcare access.
▪ Harnessing creativity and innovation to lower the cost of production or reach new
customers
Business ecosystems encourage creativity and innovation by fostering an environment where
companies can exchange ideas and build upon each other's successes. By doing so, they can
find new ways to make products more efficiently or expand their customer base, ultimately
driving growth and competitiveness.
▪ Accelerating the learning process to effectively collaborate and share insights, skills,
expertise, and knowledge
In a business ecosystem, companies can learn from each other's experiences and expertise,
accelerating their own growth and development. By sharing insights, skills, and knowledge,
they can avoid reinventing the wheel and make faster progress toward their goals.
▪ Creating new ways to address fundamental human needs and desires
Ultimately, the goal of any business ecosystem is to create value for customers by addressing
their needs and desires in innovative ways. By leveraging the collective resources and
capabilities of the ecosystem, companies can create products and services that meet these
needs more effectively, driving demand and success for everyone involved.
Overall, business ecosystems are all about collaboration, innovation, and shared success, with
the goal of creating value for both businesses and society.
The way organizations create and capture value in an ecosystem differs from traditional markets.
Two fundamental questions need to be addressed.
Value creation refers to the act of bringing something of value into existence. Participants can
therefore create value by products enhancements, product development, and the creation of
new services or customer experience. In an ecosystem partners must collaborate to create and
deliver something of mutually beneficial value to all the participants.
Value capture is the act or process of appropriating or allocating value. Participants can capture
value directly through transactions or indirectly from an orchestrator. Ecosystem complexity and
the extent or intensity of orchestration impact the potential and govern the nature of value
capture. As a result, ecosystems can produce more value than the sum of the individual
participants acting independently.
Traditional markets and ecosystems differ significantly in how value is created and captured:
▪ Traditional markets follow a linear value creation model, where value is created through a
sequential process of production, distribution, and consumption.
▪ Ecosystems, on the other hand, operate on a networked and mutual value creation model.
Value is created through interactions among participants and is often non-linear, with
feedback loops and interdependencies.
Identifying Opportunities:
11
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
Leveraging Synergies:
▪ Traditional markets may leverage synergies within their organization or with select partners.
▪ In ecosystems, organizations must leverage common synergies and complementary strengths
across a broader network of participants to drive value creation.
▪ Flexibility is crucial for organizations within ecosystems due to the dynamic nature of
interactions and roles. The more essential and unique an organization's role within the
ecosystem, the more sustainable its position.
▪ In traditional markets, value capture typically occurs through direct transactions between
buyers and sellers.
▪ In ecosystems, value capture can be direct, through transactions within the ecosystem, or
indirect, where an orchestrator captures value from consumers and distributes it among
participants.
− Direct value capture involves transactions within the ecosystem, such as purchasing
a ticket for public transport.
− Indirect value capture occurs when an orchestrator collects payments from
consumers and redistributes them among ecosystem participants.
− Combination of Value Capture Modes
Some ecosystems may employ a combination of direct and indirect value capture
mechanisms, depending on the nature of the ecosystem and its participants.
Each organization will need to pursue different actions to capture value, depending on the
underlying nature of the ecosystems in which they operate.
12
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
Each organization will face differences within their own ecosystem and therefore a strategy
developed and pursued in one environment may differ drastically from strategies pursued in
other environments.
Key drivers of these differences are firstly the level of complexity in the activities undertaken,
and secondly the extent and formality of the orchestration in and around the ecosystem.
1. Complexity:
Complexity is a function of the number and diversity of participants, the sophistication of
activities within the ecosystem and the range and nature of relationships that exist within
that ecosystem.
▪ High complexity – an environment in which barriers to entry are high and the threat of
new entrants is low. It suggests that a participant’s role in the ecosystem is relatively
secure as their capabilities are typically difficult to replicate e.g. nuclear power, or oil
exploration.
▪ Low complexity – an environment in which barriers to entry are low and the threat of
new entrants is high. In this environment, a participant’s position in the ecosystem is
vulnerable, as their capabilities are typically easy to copy e.g. production of consumables
(bakeries), retailing (individual boutiques), fitness instruction etc.
The factors are used to assess the complexity of a digital eco-system are:
▪ The number of participants
▪ The level of barriers to entry
▪ The range of the relationships involved
2. Orchestration
Orchestration depicts the extent of an organization’s influence over others within an
ecosystem, the formality of ecosystem interactions and the degree of enforceability and
compliance.
▪ Tight orchestration reflects an environment in which orchestrators have an ability to
influence behavior or actions across the entire ecosystem. For example, financial services,
in which transactions are governed by stringent and regulated rules of privacy, security
13
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
and compliance. Interactions will by necessity be rules-based, with orchestrators able to
enforce their will over others.
▪ Loose orchestration refers to an environment in which no individual participant has
significant influence across the ecosystem. There is often an absence of strong regulation
with limited ability for any participant to enforce its will over others. For example, the
Internet in regimes that have freedom of speech laws. While some content and behavior
are specifically outlawed on criminal grounds for the most part, individuals and
organizations are free to express themselves and behave any way they want.
The factors are used to assess the degree of orchestration in a digital ecosystem are:
▪ Regulatory environment
▪ Degree of influence by main player
▪ The level of potential compliance fines
Ecosystem Archetypes
14
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
1. Shark Tank
Feature
Participants here focus on creating value through innovation and differentiating their
offering. This is since barriers to entry are low, and the threat of new entrants is high. The
lack of orchestration means that participants must look after themselves as no one party is
actively pulling together the activities of the different participants. This is a high-risk position
as new entrants may challenge existing ways of working, limiting loyalty among consumers.
Example
A company which operates a mobile phone app must ensure that the services that it offers
remain relevant to the needs of customers, otherwise they may switch to using a competitor’s
app.
Strategy
Strategies should be based on the need for constant differentiation and brand building to
attract loyalty. Participants should seek to build new relationships with partners to support
the ecosystem.
2. Lion’s Pride
Feature
The threat of new entrants is low because of the complex nature of the activities undertaken
by participants in the ecosystem. This type of ecosystem features strong orchestration, where
an orchestrator will direct the activities of the participants in the ecosystem.
Example
The ecosystem for private healthcare. A specialized firm may serve as the orchestrator of the
activities undertaken by different participants, e.g. patients, hospitals, doctors and insurance
companies, to create a complete medical experience for the customer (patient).
15
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
Strategy
Participants in this type of ecosystem should pursue strategies that align their strategic
objectives with those of the orchestrator. This should help to ensure that the participant
remains useful to the orchestrator.
Combining this with differentiation will help to ensure its offering remains relevant.
Furthermore, it may be possible for a powerful participant in this type of ecosystem to
eventually challenge and take over the role of orchestrator.
3. Hornet’s Nest
Feature
In this type of ecosystem, the barriers to entry are high, but there is limited orchestration.
Nonetheless, some informal relationships will hold participants’ together. In this type of
ecosystem customers will tend to purchase products or services directly from a participant.
Example
Strategy
Participants should pursue strategies that aim at keeping their offering relevant. This involves
being responsive to what customers want, and focusing on the development of the internal
capabilities needed to deliver what customers want.
4. Wolf Pack
Feature
This ecosystem features low barriers to entry and a high degree of orchestration. Often the
individual activities undertaken by participants are simple, however, high levels of
orchestration suggest that the ecosystem is highly advanced.
16
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
Although an orchestrator may exist it is likely that they will not have as much power and
influence as would be found in the Lion’s Pride ecosystem.
Example
Davidson et al (2014) note that, in the future, participants operating in the provision of
electricity to households may form an ecosystem.
Here, many homeowners may act as both consumers and producers of electricity using solar
panels. In this example, the electricity grid would serve as the orchestrator to measure and
control electricity levels being used and ensure that the network was working well.
Strategy
Participants should aim to build their brands to defend their position and differentiate their
offering where possible. Creating strong relationships with the orchestrator is crucial given
the ease for others to enter the ecosystem.
Ecosystem Roles
For ecosystems to add value to an organization they must help it to achieve its objectives in a
more efficient manner than if it had worked on its own.
Davidson et al (2014) identified four distinct roles that an ecosystem participant might play in
pursuit of its objectives:
1. Experience Providers
Add value to the customer by creating personalized ‘customer-centric’ products and services.
For example, a company offering customers bespoke interior design services to meet a
customer’s specific needs.
2. Asset Providers
Provide or manage assets and/or activities that are critical to an ecosystem.
For example, a company which produces road mapping and location data for use in car
information systems might provide this data to several vehicle manufacturers.
3. Process Providers
Manage the processes undertaken by participants in an ecosystem to improve efficiency.
17
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
For example, a company which operates an app or website which allows customers to make
dinner reservations with different restaurants, or to place food orders, helps to improve the
efficiency of the booking/ordering process and provides a crucial link between participants.
4. Platform Providers
Create environments which enable ecosystems to function.
For example, a website which brings together suppliers and buyers of products and services,
such as an online marketplace.
Regulating Ecosystems
The modern economy operates like dynamic ecosystems, where diverse participants collaborate
and compete to create new values. However, regulating these ecosystems becomes essential. In
traditional industries, understanding and enforcing regulations are relatively straightforward. But
as industries evolve, boundaries blur, and innovation accelerates, regulation becomes more
complex.
▪ Rapid Technological Change: Products and services evolve quickly due to technological
advancements, challenging existing regulatory frameworks.
▪ Changing Nature of Work: New platforms and services alter how people work, creating
occupations that didn't exist before.
▪ Risk of Job Displacement: Studies suggest a significant portion of jobs are at risk due to
automation, highlighting the need for protective regulations.
▪ Balancing Innovation and Caution: Regulations must balance public safety with fostering
innovation without stifling flexibility.
There are several factors that drive customer demands in the digital era. These include the
following:
19
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
▪ Peer review and advocacy – Customers trust reviews from other buyers more than
company advertising. Negative reviews can seriously hurt sales, so businesses need to
keep customers happy.
To stay ahead of rapidly evolving customer expectations, organizations must adopt several
strategic approaches that ensure continuous adaptation and innovation. Here's a breakdown of
how each suggested strategy can help:
▪ Design Thinking:
Instead of creating a one-size-fits-all product, design thinking focuses on crafting tailored
experiences for individual customers. This means deeply understanding the specific needs,
desires, and pain points of customers.
Organizations must embed mechanisms to constantly learn from customer feedback and
market trends, allowing for agile adjustments and improvements to products and services.
▪ Experiential Pilots:
By observing how customers interact with new technologies and experiences, organizations
can gain insights into user behavior and preferences. This involves asking critical questions
about customer engagement, influence from peers, and emotional and behavioral responses.
Continuous innovation through pilot programs and prototypes enables organizations to
refine and enhance offerings based on real-world feedback, ensuring that the final product is
well-aligned with customer expectations.
▪ Prototyping:
Bringing a product to market quickly, even if it is not fully perfected, allows organizations to
gather essential customer feedback early on. This feedback is crucial for iterative
development and helps in making necessary adjustments for subsequent versions.
Early versions of a product, even if only 80% complete, provide valuable insights into what
works and what doesn’t, facilitating faster and more informed improvements.
20
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content
▪ Brand Atomization:
Designing offerings that can be easily integrated into various platforms and distributed widely
increases market reach and customer touch points.
By being part of larger ecosystems provided by other platforms, organizations can enhance
their visibility and accessibility, ensuring their products and services are more readily
available to a broader audience.
21
VERTEX LEARNING SOLUTIONS - [Link] Click to go to Table of Content