FuncStructThinkers Compiled Eng
FuncStructThinkers Compiled Eng
COMPILED NOTES OF
Unit 1: Structure-Functionalist and
Structuralist Thinkers
©ANTARA CHAKRABARTY
ty
ar
ab
Full Name Bronisław Kasper Malinowski
Death
kr
16 May 1942, New Haven, USA
ha
Discipline Social Anthropology; Sociology (methodological influence)
Importance
Founder of British School of Functionalism
nt
Theory of Needs Culture exists to meet basic needs (nutrition, reproduction, shelter)
and derived needs (education, law, religion).
Native’s Point of View True understanding of culture comes from seeing how people
themselves interpret their world.
Kula Ring A ceremonial exchange system of shell valuables that creates social
bonds and status among islanders.
ty
Culture as an Culture is a practical tool enabling individuals to cope with life
Instrumental Apparatus problems.
ar
Holistic Study of Culture Economic, religious, kinship, and political institutions must be
studied together.
ab
Bronislaw Malinowski: Psychological and Individual Functionalism
Central Focus kr
Culture functions to satisfy the biological and psychological needs
of individuals, not abstract social structures.
ha
View of Individual The individual is primary; society and institutions exist because
C
Role of Institutions Institutions such as family, religion, economy, and magic function to
A
Religion and Magic Religion and magic reduce psychological anxiety in situations
beyond human control (death, illness, danger).
Individual Functionalism Social facts are explained by how they serve individuals, not society
as a whole.
ty
ar
Methodological Position Emphasis on participant observation to understand needs from the
native’s point of view.
ab
Key Work Argonauts of the Western Pacific (1922); A Scientific Theory of
kr
Culture (posthumous).
ha
Difference from Focuses on individual needs and psychology rather than social
Radcliffe-Brown structure.
C
a
He was a huge supporter of field work and created many new methods in social theory and founder of
social anthropology
nt
Largely inspired by James Frazer and his Golden Bough religion and magical practices
A
He was stuck after World War I, therefore decided to go to Trobriand Islands in Melanesia where he
stayed for several years and published his first seminal work Argonauts of Western Pacific (1922)
©
His ethnography of the Trobriand Islands was later complemented by The Sexual Life of Savages in
North Western Melanesia (1929) and Coral Gardens and Their Magic (1935)
+97433267584
Approach
His approach: psychological functionalism on how social and cultural institutions serve basic human
needs
For him participant observation is not merely being there but also doing what others are doing, know
the native language
ty
ar
ab
kr
ha
C
He stated that the goal of the anthropologist, or ethnographer, is “to grasp the native’s point of view”
a
ar
ty
ar
ab
kr
ha
Malinowski system levels
C
a
ar
nt
A
©
(2) The concept of different and multiple system needs at each level
He wrote, “…culture comprises inherited artifacts, goods, technical processes, ideas, habits and values.”
ty
Institution and Its Elements
Upon analysis, he believed, any institution resolves itself into six interrelated elements:
ar
(1) personnel, a group of individuals cooperating in the performance of a common task;
ab
(2) material apparatus, the artifacts employed in their activities;
(3) norms, the rules or ideal patterns to which behavior is expected to conform;
kr
(4) activities, the behavior, including deviation from norms, which actually takes place in the
performance of the joint tasks;
ha
(5) charter, the express cultural definition of the common aims or purpose of the institution; and
(6) function, the actual effect of the collective enterprise in satisfying man needs.
C
Metabolism Commissariat
nt
Reproduction Kinship
A
Safety Protection
Health Hygiene
Empirical Case Used Malinowski studied canoe building among the Trobriand Islanders during
his fieldwork.
Rules of Craftsmanship Canoe building followed systematic, fixed, and tested technical rules,
learned through practice and tradition.
ty
Technical Precision Choice of wood, shape, balance, length, and durability showed practical
engineering knowledge.
ar
Transmission of Knowledge was transmitted through apprenticeship, imitation, and
Knowledge collective memory.
ab
Scientific Attitude Activities showed rationality, causality, and predictability, core features
of science.
Role of Magic
kr
Magic was used only where technical knowledge ended (e.g., sea
danger, weather uncertainty).
ha
Science vs Magic Science and magic coexisted, but served different functions.
Malinowski’s Argument Primitive people are not pre-logical; they are practical scientists in daily
C
life.
Critique of Evolutionists Malinowski rejected the idea that primitive thought is irrational or inferior.
a
Meaning of Kula The Kula is a ceremonial exchange system among the Trobriand Islanders in the
Milne Bay region of Papua New Guinea.
Objects Two valuables are exchanged: Soulava (shell necklaces) and Mwali (shell
Exchanged armbands).
Geographical The exchange links many islands into a vast inter-island network.
Spread
ty
Frequency Kula expeditions occur once or twice a year.
Mode of Exchange Exchange takes place during long canoe voyages involving ritual preparation.
ar
Ownership Kula valuables are never permanently owned; they must be passed on.
ab
Social Function It creates social solidarity, trust, alliances, and peace between groups.
Economic Aspect
kr
Kula is not economic trade, but it indirectly facilitates everyday barter.
ha
Symbolic Value Kula objects have symbolic and ritual value, not use-value.
Relation to Magic Canoe building and voyages involve rituals and magic to ensure success.
C
Malinowski’s Kula is a total social institution integrating economy, politics, religion, and
ar
Conclusion kinship.
nt
Radcliffe Brown
ty
ar
ab
Full Name kr
A. R. Radcliffe-Brown: Biography, Theories & Contributions
Nationality British
C
His main focus was on social structure rather than biological needs where institutions are
orderly sets of relationships whose function is to maintain the society as a system
ty
The ‘social’ was a separate level of reality distinct from biological forms and inorganic
matter
ar
Individuals are replaceable and transient and hence irrelevant
ab
His prime areas of field work were Andaman Islands and Western Australia
kr
ha
Main focus areas were kinship, descent theory, inter-group relations etc.
C
Primacy of Structure Social structure, not individual needs, is the focus of analysis.
©
Rejection of Psychology Psychological explanations are inadequate for understanding social facts.
ty
Natural Science of Society Anthropology should be nomothetic, not descriptive.
ar
Ritual and Religion Rituals reinforce social solidarity.
ab
Goal of anthropology should be to compare different societies and formulate general social laws
kr
His famous work on Joking Relationships, 1940
ha
Major work on kinship from South Africa named The Mother’s Brother in South Africa, 1924
The most important structural feature is the arrangement of people into dyadic or
person-to-person relationships
ar
Institutions define for a person how he is expected to behave and also how he may expect others to
behave
A
©
+97433267584
ty
ar
ab
kr
ha
C
Ceremonial Weeping
a
Formal weeping takes place when social relations have been disturbed or interrupted and are about
to be resumed
nt
Ceremonial weeping marks the fact that the long separation is over and friendship will resume once
more
A
©
Brown on Totemism
Durkheim does not touch upon a crucial question, namely why are natural objects selected as totems?
Tribes in New South Wales are divided into two exogamous moieties named after two birds: eaglehawk
and crow
+97433267584
Brothers and sisters share a feeling of solidarity and are treated as a unit by outsiders
A lineage refers to the descendants in a line traced either through male or female of a single
ancestor
ty
The generation principle
ar
There is a certain distance or tension between members of succeeding generations
ab
Members of alternate generations share easy and friendly relations
kr
Brown substitutes ‘needs’ with necessary conditions of existence
ha
Structural analysis proceeds with assumptions
B. Malinowski:
ty
The aim of functional analysis for him (1926: 132) is to arrive at the explanation of anthropological
facts at all levels of development by their function, by the part they play within the integral system of
ar
culture.
He (1926: 132–3) assumes that in every civilization every custom, material object, ideas and belief
ab
fulfils some vital function, has some task to accomplish, represents an indispensable fact within a
working whole.
kr
Whereas Radcliffe-Brown begins with society and its necessary conditions of existence (i.e.,
integration), Malinowski’s starting point is the individual, who has a set of ‘basic’, or
‘biological’ needs that must be satisfied for its survival.
ha
It is because of the importance that Malinowski gives the individual that the term ‘psychological
functionalism’ is reserved for him, in comparison to Radcliffe-Brown’s approach which is called
C
Because of this role of culture in satisfying biological needs that Malinowski’s functionalism is also
a
One more difference between Radcliffe-Brown and Malinowski may be noted here.
He believes that the study of social structure (which for him is an observable entity) encompasses the
study of culture; therefore, there is no need to have a separate field to study culture.
Further, whilst social structure is concerned all about observations, what anthropologists see and
hear about the individual peoples, culture is in the minds of people, not amenable to observation in
the same way as social structure is.
+97433267584
Radcliffe-Brown wants to make social anthropology a branch of natural science, which would be
possible when there is an empirically investigable subject matter.
Both the founders of the British functional approach (Radcliffe-Brown and Malinowski) were
vehemently critical of the nineteenth-century evolutionism.
ty
Radcliffe-Brown (1952) said that it was based on ‘conjectural history’, a term we used earlier, and not
‘authentic history’. It was ‘pseudo-historical’, thus devoid of a scientific value.
ar
For Malinowski (1944), classical evolutionism was a ‘limbo of conjectural reconstructions’.
ab
With the works of these scholars came a shift from: 1) Arm-chair anthropology to fieldwork-based
studies;
kr
2) The study of the origin and stages of evolution of society and its institutions (diachronic studies) to
society ‘here and now’ (synchronic studies).
ha
The Andaman Islanders (1922)
The Mother’s Brother in South Africa (1924)
C
Euphoria A condition of social well-being where individuals experience Stable kinship relations
harmony, satisfaction, and emotional comfort due to smooth producing emotional
ty
functioning of social relations. security in a community.
Eunomia A state of normative order where social rules, institutions, and Well-regulated marriage
ar
obligations function properly, producing functional unity. rules maintaining social
integration.
ab
Dysphoria A condition of social discomfort or tension experienced by Anxiety during prolonged
individuals when social relations are disturbed or strained. conflict between kin
groups.
Dysnomia kr
A condition of normative breakdown, where rules fail,
institutions weaken, and functional unity collapses.
Breakdown of authority
leading to social disorder.
ha
C
Functionalist analysis often confuses cause with function, leading to theoretical problems.
ar
(1) Tautology
Saying that division of labour exists because society needs integration is a teleological claim (explaining
present structures by future goals).
Such claims are not automatically false, because societies do function as systems.
To make teleology legitimate, one must show how needs actually produce structures.
Problem of tautology
Functional explanations often become circular: the system survives because its needs are met, and needs
ty
are assumed to be met because the system survives.
ar
Such statements are true by definition, not by empirical verification.
ab
Overall critique
Functionalism risks becoming circular and unscientific unless it clearly distinguishes cause, function, and
criteria of integration.
kr
ha
Talcott Parsons
C
a
ar
nt
Nationality American
Discipline Sociology
ty
Structural Society is a system of interrelated parts, each performing functions necessary
Functionalism for system stability and survival.
ar
Social System Society functions as a system governed by norms, values, roles, and institutions
Theory that regulate social action.
ab
AGIL Scheme Every social system must fulfill four functional imperatives: Adaptation, Goal
attainment, Integration, Latency.
Pattern Variables
kr
Dichotomous choices that guide social action (e.g., affectivity vs affective
neutrality).
ha
Theory of Social Human action is voluntary, norm-governed, and oriented toward shared values.
Action
C
Value Consensus Social order is maintained through shared values and norms rather than
coercion.
a
System Equilibrium Social systems tend toward equilibrium; disturbances are corrected through
ar
institutional adjustments.
Role Theory Individuals occupy social roles defined by expectations and norms.
nt
Latency / Pattern Cultural institutions (family, education, religion) maintain motivation and values.
Maintenance
A
©
Since he too is a structural functionalist, the broad framework of his thinking are same.
Biggest contribution is the Social Action Theory which he derives from several other theorists.
+97433267584
General Equilibrium
In The Social System (1951) Parsons argued that the crucial feature of societies, as of biological
organisms, is homeostasis (maintaining a stable state), and that their parts can be understood only in
terms of the whole.
ty
Supported the structural functional analysis: maintenance of the interrelated interaction units.
ar
His theories are similar to cybernetics and homeostasis.
Socialization and social control are the main mechanisms that allow the social system to maintain its
ab
equilibrium.
Modest amounts of individuality and deviance are accommodated, but more extreme forms must be met
by re-equilibrating mechanisms.
kr
ha
Why Biology?
C
Why Economics?
ar
● General Equilibrium comes from Pareto → society seeks balance, not constant conflict.
● Disturbances are temporary and corrected through institutions.
nt
Pattern variables are dilemmas of choice faced by social actors while performing roles in society.
+97433267584
Parsons introduced them to explain how social action is structured and regulated by norms and
values.
ty
ar
ab
kr
ha
C
a
ar
nt
2. Self-Orientation ↔ Collectivity-Orientation
ty
Common in market economy, competition, career mobility.
ar
Example: Choosing a job for high salary.
ab
Example: Sacrificing personal gain for family honour.
3. Universalism ↔ Particularism
kr
Universalism applies the same rules to everyone regardless of personal ties.
ha
Particularism applies rules based on personal relationships or status.
4. Achievement ↔ Ascription
Achievement evaluates individuals based on performance and accomplishments.
A
Ascription evaluates individuals based on birth, age, gender, caste, or family background.
©
5. Specificity ↔ Diffuseness
Specificity limits social relationships to clearly defined roles.
ty
Example: Doctor–patient relationship.
ar
Example: Father–son relationship.
ab
What is AGIL?
kr
ha
C
a
ar
nt
A
©
AGIL is a functional schema proposed by Talcott Parsons to explain how any social system survives
and remains stable.
+97433267584
These functions are: Adaptation (A), Goal Attainment (G), Integration (I), Latency/Pattern
Maintenance (L).
ty
A – Adaptation Securing and Behavioral Economy, industry,
distributing resources; Organism labour, technology
ar
adjusting to
environment
ab
G – Goal Attainment Defining goals and Personality Polity, government,
mobilizing resources System state, administration
to achieve them
I – Integration kr
Coordinating parts of Social System Law, religion,
ha
the system; community, kinship
maintaining solidarity
C
A. Adaptation
Adaptation refers to how a system adjusts to its environment and secures material resources.
A
©
Example:
Goal attainment involves setting collective goals and ensuring they are achieved.
Example:
ty
● Five-year plans, public policies
ar
I. Integration
ab
Integration ensures coordination among different parts of society.
kr
Law, religion, customs, and moral rules play a key role.
ha
Example:
Example:
©
Meaning of Social Social action refers to action performed by an actor that is goal-oriented,
Action normatively regulated, and value-guided, taking place within a social
system.
ty
rejects both pure determinism and pure rational choice.
ar
Actor An actor is an individual or collective unit capable of making choices within
ab
structural constraints.
Goal (End)
kr
Every action is oriented towards a goal that the actor seeks to achieve.
ha
Normative Action is regulated by norms, rules, and values shared by society.
Regulation
C
a
ar
Why “Voluntaristic”? Because the actor has choice and agency, but within normative and
structural limits.
nt
A
Rejection of Utilitarianism Rejects the idea that humans act only to maximize self-interest.
©
Central Role of Norms & Norms and values regulate and guide action.
Values
Effort & Choice Actor invests effort and makes choices among alternatives.
Social Order Social order emerges through shared values and norms, not force.
ty
ar
ab
kr
ha
C
a
ar
nt
A
Instrumental Action Action oriented toward efficient Studying with a timetable to clear an
achievement of goals using exam.
appropriate means.
+97433267584
Moral / Normative Action guided by moral norms Returning a lost wallet due to honesty.
Action and obligations.
ty
Motivational Orientations (Need-Dispositions)
ar
Cognitive Desire to understand and interpret A student learning exam patterns before
Orientation the situation logically and factually. preparation.
ab
Cathectic Emotional attachment or affective Emotional bond between parents and
Orientation involvement with objects or children.
persons.
Evaluative kr
Judging situations and alternatives Choosing honesty over cheating in an
ha
Orientation using norms and values. exam.
Orientation
Cognitive Value Concerned with knowledge, truth, and A scientist testing a hypothesis
a
Appreciative / Focuses on beauty, style, harmony, and Enjoying music or dance for
Aesthetic Value emotional satisfaction rather than truth pleasure.
A
Orientation or morality.
Moral Value Oriented toward norms, obligations, and Refusing bribery despite personal
©
ty
ar
ab
kr
ha
C
a
Concept of Sick Role The sick role is a socially recognized role that exempts a sick person from
ar
View of Illness Illness is seen as a form of social deviance that disrupts normal functioning of
society.
©
Purpose of Sick Role To control deviance and ensure recovery so that the individual can return to
normal roles.
+97433267584
ty
Exemption from normal social Sick person is not expected to perform usual
ar
roles duties.
ab
illness
ty
Evolutionary Shift (Process Explanation)
ar
Differentiation Separation of structures to perform specialized functions.
ab
Inclusion Incorporation of previously excluded groups.
Generalization
kr
Shift from particularistic to universalistic values.
ha
Major Definitions by Parsons –
1) Definition of society: “a relatively self-sufficient collectivity the members of which are able to
satisfy all their individual and collective needs and to live entirely within its framework”
a
In fact, as we saw earlier, the cultural system stood at the top of Parsons’s action system, and
ar
Definition of culture, “culture is seen as a patterned, ordered system of symbols that are objects of
nt
orientation to actors, internalized aspects of the personality system, and institutionalized patterns”
Social Systems: A social system consists in a plurality of individual actors interacting with each other
A
in a situation which has at least a physical or environmental aspect, actors who are motivated in
terms of a tendency to the “optimization of gratification” and whose relation to their situations,
©
including each other, is defined and mediated in terms of a system of culturally structured and shared
symbols.
+97433267584
Parsons did not take interaction as his fundamental unit in the study of the social system. Rather, he
used the status-role complex as the basic unit of the system.
This is neither an aspect of actors nor an aspect of interaction but rather a structural component of the
social system.
role is what the actor does in such a position, seen in the context of its functional significance for the
ty
larger system.
ar
1937 – The Structure of Social Action
1951 – The Social System
ab
1955 – Family, Socialization and Interaction Process (with Robert F. Bales)
1959 – Structure and Process in Modern Societies
1960 – Social Structure and Personality
kr
1964 – Towards a General Theory of Action
1966 – Societies: Evolutionary and Comparative Perspectives
ha
1970 – Politics and Social Structure
1971 – The System of Modern Societies
1977 – Social Systems and the Evolution of Action Theory
C
ty
ar
Full Name Robert King Merton
ab
Birth July 4, 1910, Philadelphia, USA
Death
Original Name kr
February 23, 2003
Theory of Middle Advocated theories that lie between grand theory and empirical research,
Range making sociology more testable and practical.
Manifest and Latent Manifest functions are intended and recognized consequences; latent
Functions functions are unintended and unrecognized.
+97433267584
Dysfunctions Some social structures can have negative consequences for society.
Anomie Theory Deviance results from a disjunction between culturally prescribed goals and
(Strain Theory) socially structured means.
Self-Fulfilling A false definition of a situation that evokes behavior making the false belief
ty
Prophecy come true.
Reference Group Individuals evaluate themselves and form attitudes based on reference
ar
Theory groups.
ab
Role Strain Difficulty in fulfilling multiple expectations of a single role.
Bureaucratic
Structure and
Personality
kr
Bureaucratic rules can lead to rigidity and goal displacement.
ha
Matthew Effect Recognition and rewards accumulate to already well-known scientists.
(Sociology of
C
Science)
(CUDOS)
ar
1. Manifest Functions
A
2. Latent Functions
ty
of social action or institutions.
ar
Visibility Often discovered only through sociological analysis.
ab
Role in May still contribute to social integration or cohesion.
Society
Example 1
Example 2 kr
Schools create peer networks and friendships.
3. Dysfunctions
A
Relation to Functionalism Introduced by Merton to correct the overly positive bias of classical
functionalism.
A. Manifest Dysfunctions
ty
a social structure or action.
ar
Awareness Actors are aware that the outcome is harmful.
ab
Analytical Status Explicitly discussed and often debated in public discourse.
Example 2
Example 3
kr
Industrial pollution knowingly damages environment and health.
B. Latent Dysfunctions
4. Non-Functions
+97433267584
Definition Non-functions are consequences that are irrelevant to the system and have
no significant effect on social order.
Analytical Purpose Helps avoid assuming that everything in society has a function.
ty
Example 1 Fashion choices like tie color have no systemic function.
ar
Example 2 Decorative elements in buildings unrelated to use.
ab
Robert K. Merton – Modes of Adaptation
Conformity
Goals
Accepted
l Means
Accepted
kr
Individuals accept both Studying hard to get a job
ha
socially approved goals and and earn success.
legitimate means to achieve
them. This is the most
C
Innovation Accepted Rejected Goals are accepted, but Smuggling or fraud to gain
a
Retreatism Rejected Rejected Both goals and means are Drug addicts, chronic
©
Rebellion Rejected & Rejected & Existing goals and means Revolutionary movements,
Replaced Replaced are rejected and new ones radical political groups.
+97433267584
ty
Ritualism ✖ Reject ✔ Accept
ar
Retreatism ✖ Reject ✖ Reject
ab
Rebellion ✖ Replace ✖ Replace
A. Concept of Anomie
kr
ha
Meaning of Anomie Anomie refers to a condition where there is a disjunction between
culturally prescribed goals and socially structured means.
C
Core Problem Society emphasizes success goals more than legitimate means.
Meaning of Strain Strain theory explains deviance as a result of structural strain produced by
Theory anomie.
Central Argument When legitimate means are blocked, individuals adapt in different ways.
ty
Goals aspirations (e.g., wealth,
success).
ar
Institutional Legitimate, socially Education, hard
Means approved ways to work
ab
achieve goals.
(Communalism) property of the scientific community and journals; sharing data with peers.
must be shared openly, not privately
A
owned.
©
D – Disinterestedness Scientists should act for the advancement Declaring conflicts of interest in
of knowledge, not for personal gain, profit, research.
or prestige.
ty
ar
ab
kr
ha
C
a
ar
nt
A
ty
ar
B. Serendipity Pattern (Merton’s Analytical Context)
ab
leads to new theory.
Role in Theory Building Helps move from empirical anomalies to theoretical innovation.
Merton’s functional postulates refer to the basic assumptions used in functional analysis
about how social structures relate to society.
nt
Meaning The postulate of functional unity assumes that all Religion integrating society.
parts of society work together harmoniously to
maintain social stability.
+97433267584
Revised View Social structures may be functional for some Caste system benefits upper
groups and dysfunctional for others. castes but harms lower
castes.
ty
Meaning This postulate assumes that all social institutions Family socializing children.
and practices have positive functions for society.
ar
Merton’s Critique Merton rejected this view, stating that social structures
can also be dysfunctional.
ab
Revised View Institutions can have functions, dysfunctions, and Education creating inequality
non-functions. (dysfunction).
3. Postulate of Indispensability kr
ha
Meaning This postulate claims that certain social Religion seen as necessary for
institutions are indispensable for society’s morality.
C
survival.
exist.
ar
ty
ar
ab
kr
ha
C
a
ar
nt
A
©
+97433267584
ty
ar
Full Name Claude Lévi-Strauss
ab
Birth 28 November 1908, Brussels, Belgium
Death
Nationality kr
30 October 2009, Paris, France
French
ha
Discipline Social Anthropology / Sociology
C
Intellectual Structuralism
Tradition
Also known as father of Structural Anthropology
a
Field works in: Mato Grosso and the Amazon Rainforest, studied the Guaycuru and Bororó
Indian tribes, Nambikwara and Tupi-Kawahib societies.
+97433267584
Theory of Kinship (Alliance Kinship systems are systems of exchange of women between groups,
Theory) not just descent.
ty
Incest Taboo The incest taboo is a universal cultural rule marking the shift from
ar
nature to culture.
ab
Kinship (restricted/generalized exchange).
Myth Analysis (Structural Myths across cultures share similar structures despite different content.
Study of Myths)
Mythemes kr
Myths are composed of basic units called mythemes, like phonemes in
ha
language.
Nature vs Culture Central analytical distinction explaining social rules and symbols.
C
Cold and Hot Societies Cold societies resist change; hot societies embrace historical change.
Modern Mind
creatively.
©
Classification Systems Tribal societies classify plants, animals, and relations systematically.
Binary Logic in Thought Thought operates through oppositions even in “primitive” societies.
+97433267584
Lévi-Strauss was not interested in producing a text (i.e., a monograph) on a particular culture, but a
text that addressed the understanding of the “Universal Man” rather than the particular man.
Between 1964 and 1971 were published Lévi-Strauss’s magnum opus, the four volume Mythologiques
series. In total, these volumes, running into two thousand pages, analyse 813 myths and their more
than one thousand versions.
Raw and the Cooked analyses myths from South America, particularly central and eastern Brazil.
ty
The second volume, From Honey to Ashes, is also concerned with South America, but deals with myths
ar
both from the south and the north.
The Origin of Table Manners begins with a myth that is South American, but from further north.
ab
The final volume, The Naked Man, is entirely North American. The interesting fact Lévi-Strauss finds is
that the “most apparent similarities between myths are found between the regions of the New World that
are geographically most distant.”
kr
Beginning with the mythology of central Brazil and then moving out to other geographical areas, and then
ha
returning to Brazil, Lévi-Strauss realises that “depending upon the case, the myths of neighbouring
peoples coincide, partially overlap, answer, or contradict one another.”
C
Core Idea Cooking practices express deep cultural structures through symbolic
oppositions.
ty
ar
ab
kr
ha
C
a
ar
(especially fire).
On Totemism
Lévi-Strauss’s Totemism is not a distinct institution but a mode of classification.
Position
Core Function Helps societies classify social groups using natural differences.
ty
Nature–Culture Animals/plants are used symbolically to think about social relations.
Link
ar
Key Work Totemism (1962)
ab
Structural Insight Totemism reflects structure of the human mind, not primitive belief.
He says that totemism was “invented” and became one of the most favourite anthropological subjects to
kr
be investigated with an aim to find its origins and varieties.
ha
He also criticises the functional views of totemism; for instance, Durkheim’s explanation that totemism
binds people in a “moral community” called the church,
or Malinowski’s idea that the Trobrianders have totems because they are of utilitarian value, for they
C
Origin of the Term Lévi-Strauss notes that the word totem comes from the Ojibwa language of the
ar
Totemic Group Members sharing the same totem form a totemic group.
nt
Nature of Totemic Totemism is not primarily about worship but about classification and
Belief differentiation.
A
Core Argument of Totemic phenomena are modes of classification, not primitive religion.
©
Lévi-Strauss
Structural Logic Natural differences between plants and animals are used to represent social
differences between clans.
Relation to Kinship Totemism helps organize kinship relations and social order.
+97433267584
Food Taboos Food taboos are symbolic rules expressing social distinctions, not irrational
beliefs.
ty
A. Lévi-Strauss: Analysis of Myth
Meaning of Myth Myths are not irrational stories but systems of communication expressing
ar
deep structures of the human mind.
Focus of Analysis Lévi-Strauss analyses relations between elements of myths, not their
ab
surface content.
Basic Unit The basic unit of myth is the mytheme, similar to phoneme in language.
Structural Principle
kr
Myths are structured around binary oppositions.
ha
Examples of Binary Nature / Culture, Raw / Cooked, Life / Death.
Oppositions
C
human mind.
ar
Contrast Opposed to the modern scientist or engineer who creates tools for specific purposes.
©
Role in Myth Myth-makers are bricoleurs who recombine existing symbols and ideas.
C. Concept of Bricolage
ty
Structural Logic Follows rules of structure, not randomness.
ar
Claude Lévi-Strauss: Social Structure – Three Distinctions
ab
1. Observation vs Experimentation on Models
Observation on
models kr
Studying social reality as it is given, by observing empirical data and constructing
models from it.
ha
Experimentation on Manipulating or transforming models theoretically to see possible variations and
models hidden relations.
C
Conscious models Models that people know and explicitly explain, such as customs or stated
rules.
nt
Unconscious models Deep structures not consciously known to actors but governing social life.
A
Lévi-Strauss’s emphasis True social structure lies at the unconscious level, similar to language
grammar.
©
Mechanical models Models where relations are fixed, exact, and rule-bound.
+97433267584
Lévi-Strauss’s preference Prefers mechanical models for uncovering deep structural logic.
ty
1955 – Tristes Tropiques
ar
→ Structural Anthropology
ab
1962 – La Pensée sauvage
→ The Savage Mind
kr
→ Mythologiques, Vol. 1: The Raw and the Cooked
ha
1966 – Mythologiques II: Du miel aux cendres
→ Mythologiques, Vol. 2: From Honey to Ashes