Criteria 5 (Excellent) 4 (Proficient) 3 (Developing) 2 (Needs Score
Improvement)
All scenario requirements Most Major parts of the Does not address the
and core concepts requirements task or scenario assigned task; shows
Content (combinations/choices) are met; minor are missing or fundamental
Accuracy are explicitly addressed element is misunderstood. misunderstanding.
and correct. unclear or
missing.
Presentation is highlyPresentation is Creativity is Dull, unoriginal, and
engaging, original, and engaging and limited; format is minimal creative or
uses format (broadcast, shows good weak or execution format effort shown.
Creativity skit, etc.) and effort in is routine.
characterization creativity and
effectively. proper format
execution.
Presentation is perfectly Slightly Significantly Poor adherence to
within the 1-minute limit, over/under the misses the 1- time limit;
Time delivering all content 1-minute limit, minute limit, presentation is
Management clearly. but content is rushing or missing incomplete or
fully delivered. content. excessive.
All members contribute Most members Only a few Minimal evidence of
equally, roles are clear, contribute; members teamwork; disjointed
and interactions are minor contribute or only one person
Teamwork seamless. unevenness in actively, or one presents.
participation. person
dominates.
Total