CHAPTER ONE

INTRODUCTION

1.1 Background to the Study

Canned foods represent a significant component of the global food supply chain, offering

convenience, extended shelf life, and nutritional preservation when properly processed. The

canning process, developed in the late 18th century by Nicolas Appert, involves heat

sterilization of food in sealed containers to eliminate spoilage microorganisms and

pathogenic bacteria (Amoo et al ., 2024). However, despite advances in food processing

technology, bacteriological contamination of canned products remains a public health

concern, particularly in developing nations where storage conditions may be suboptimal and

distribution chains less regulated (Amoo et al ., 2024).

In Nigeria, canned foods have become increasingly popular among urban consumers

seeking convenient food options. These products range from tomato pastes and baked beans

to fish, vegetables, and fruit juices. The growing demand has led to an expansion of the

canned food market, with products entering the supply chain through formal and informal

distribution networks. However, concerns have been raised regarding the microbiological

quality of these products, especially when stored or handled under poor conditions prior to

sale (Njoku and Ugwu, 2022).

The public health implications of consuming contaminated canned foods are substantial.

Bacterial pathogens commonly associated with canned food spoilage include Bacillus

cereus, Clostridium botulinum, Staphylococcus aureus, and various coliforms. These

organisms can produce toxins or cause infections leading to foodborne illnesses ranging

from mild gastroenteritis to life-threatening botulism. The World Health Organization

estimates that foodborne diseases affect approximately 600 million people annually, with

the highest burden occurring in Africa (WHO, 2020).

1
Tudun Wada is a densely populated residential and commercial area within Kaduna

metropolis, Kaduna State, Northwestern Nigeria. The market at Tudun Wada serves as a

major commercial hub where food items, including canned products, are sold to a large

consumer base. The market operates under environmental conditions typical of many

Nigerian open markets variable temperatures, humidity fluctuations, and infrastructure

challenges related to waste management and sanitation. Previous microbiological studies

conducted in Tudun Wada have documented concerning levels of food contamination.

Research on ready-to-eat fruits sold in the area reported bacterial counts as high as 8.76×10⁴

CFU/g, with isolates including Staphylococcus

aureus, Bacillus species, Lactobacillus species, and Pseudomonas aeruginosa. Similarly, a

study on fermented milk-cereal mixture (fura da nono) hawked in Tudun Wada revealed

mean colony counts of 16.7 × 10⁶ CFU/ml, significantly exceeding the FAO standard of 1 ×

10⁵ CFU/ml for dairy beverages (Muhammad et al ., 2021). These findings suggest that the

Tudun Wada area may present specific risk factors for food contamination, warranting

focused investigation.

1.2 Statement of the Problem

Canned foods sold in open markets are generally perceived by consumers as safe due to the

presumption that commercial canning eliminates all pathogenic microorganisms. However,

several factors can compromise this safety assumption. Physical damage to cans (denting,

rusting, swelling), temperature abuse during storage, and manufacturing defects can allow

microbial proliferation (Njoku and Ugwu, 2022). Despite the widespread consumption of

canned foods in Kaduna and the documented food safety challenges in Tudun Wada Market,

there is a paucity of recent, specific data on the bacteriological quality of canned foods sold

in this location. The absence of such data represents a gap in our understanding of potential

public health risks faced by consumers in this community. Without baseline microbiological

2
information, it is impossible to assess the extent of contamination, identify predominant

spoilage organisms, or develop evidence-based interventions.

1.3 Justification of the Study

The consumption of contaminated canned foods poses direct health risks to consumers,

including foodborne illnesses that may be severe in vulnerable populations such as children,

the elderly, and immunocompromised individuals (Ogbonna and Nwankwo, 2023).

Documenting the bacteriological profile of these products is a necessary first step toward

risk assessment and mitigation. Also, recent findings from Kaduna indicate that ready-to-eat

foods sold in the metropolis often fail to meet microbiological safety standards. A study on

lettuce and gurasa sold within Kaduna State University reported bacterial counts of 1.48 ×

10⁶ CFU/g to 1.55 × 10⁶ CFU/g, with isolates showing high resistance to common

antibiotics including amoxicillin, augmentin, and rocephin . These findings raise concerns

about broader food safety patterns in the region (Ogbonna and Nwankwo, 2023). Therefore,

understanding the specific bacterial contaminants present in canned foods can inform public

health policy and regulatory enforcement. The identification of pathogenic organisms,

particularly those with antibiotic resistance profiles, would signal the need for improved

surveillance and vendor education programs.

1.4 Aim and Objectives of the Study

The aim of this study is to investigate the bacteriological quality of canned foods sold at

Tudun Wada Market, Kaduna, Nigeria.

The specific objectives are to:

i. Determine the total viable bacterial counts of canned food samples collected from

Tudun Wada Market

ii. Isolate and identify bacterial species associated with canned foods sold in the study

area

3
 iii. Characterize the bacterial isolates based on their morphological and biochemical

properties

1.5 Scope and Limitation of the Study

This study focuses specifically on bacteriological analysis of canned food products sold at

Tudun Wada Market in Kaduna, Nigeria. The research is limited to bacterial contaminants

and does not include viral, parasitic, or chemical analyses. Only canned foods exhibiting

visible signs of spoilage (swelling, leakage, or abnormal appearance upon opening) are

included.

4
 CHAPTER TWO
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 Canned Food Spoilage

Canned foods are conventionally perceived as shelf-stable products due to the application of

commercial sterilization, which aims to destroy all pathogenic and spoilage

microorganisms. However, spoilage remains a significant challenge, often resulting from

sublethal thermal processing, post-process leakage, or the survival of thermophilic spore-

formers. Spoilage in canned foods is typically categorized into three mechanisms: biological

(microbial), chemical (hydrogen swell), and physical (container integrity failure). Microbial

spoilage is the most concerning because it can lead to toxin production, off-odors, gas

formation, and even public health crises if pathogens such as Clostridium botulinum are

involved (Andrade et al ., 2022).

Recent market surveillance studies have demonstrated that improperly handled or stored

canned foods especially those sold in open-air markets or non-temperature-controlled

environments exhibit higher bacterial loads. Spoilage manifests as swelling (bulging cans),

flat sour spoilage (no gas but low pH), or putrefaction. According to Ogunbanwo and

Adebayo (2023), the incidence of visibly spoiled canned tomatoes and beans in Nigerian

markets was 12.5%, with bacterial counts exceeding 10⁶ CFU/g in 40% of samples. These

findings underscore the need for routine bacteriological monitoring of canned foods sold in

less regulated retail environments.

2.2 Common Bacterial Genera Associated with Spoiled Canned Foods

The bacteriological profile of spoiled canned foods is dominated by spore-forming bacteria,

primarily from the genera Bacillus and Clostridium, due to their heat-resistant

endospores. Bacillus stearothermophilus and Bacillus coagulans are principal agents of flat

sour spoilage, where they ferment carbohydrates without gas production, leading to

acidification and off-flavors. Conversely, Clostridium

5
thermosaccharolyticum and Clostridium botulinum produce gas (hydrogen and carbon

dioxide), resulting in swollen cans and, in the latter case, the lethal neurotoxin. Non-spore-

formers such as Enterococcus faecalis and Lactobacillus species may appear in canned

foods with post-process leakage, especially if cooling water is contaminated (Frazier and

Westhoff, 2021; Okonkwo et al ., 2024).

Recent metagenomic analyses have expanded understanding of spoilage communities. A

study by Hassan and Oluwole (2025) identified Bacillus subtilis, Bacillus licheniformis,

and Paenibacillus species as predominant in spoiled canned vegetables from open markets

in Lagos, with some isolates showing multidrug resistance. Furthermore, Clostridium

perfringens has been detected in spoiled canned meat products, indicating poor sanitation

during canning or handling. The presence of these bacteria not only compromises product

quality but also poses a direct health risk, especially when cans are bulging or leaking at the

point of sale.

2.3 Mechanisms of Bacterial Survival and Growth in Canned Foods

Bacterial survival in canned foods hinges on the thermal resistance of endospores and the

adequacy of the sterilization process (F₀ value). Commercial canning typically targets a 12-

log reduction of Clostridium botulinum spores (the “12-D concept”). However, deviations

such as inadequate retort temperature, insufficient holding time, or high initial spore loads

can result in survivor populations. Thermophilic spores may survive even when mesophiles

are destroyed, and they germinate if the canned product is stored at ambient tropical

temperatures (30–40°C), which is common in many low-income market settings (Brown,

2023).

Post-process contamination via micro-leaks is another critical mechanism. Cans that sustain

damage during transportation or display such as dents, rust, or seam defects—allow entry of

waterborne or airborne bacteria. Once inside, the low-acid environment (pH >4.6) of most

6
vegetables and meat products supports bacterial proliferation. Research by Eze and

Nwachukwu (2024) demonstrated that Pseudomonas and Enterobacter species, though not

spore-formers, could be isolated from leaking canned foods after 7 days of storage at 30°C,

with cell counts reaching 10⁸ CFU/mL. This highlights that spoilage is not solely a pre-

process failure but also a distribution-chain vulnerability.

2.4 Health Implications and Toxigenic Risks

The consumption of spoiled canned foods can lead to foodborne illnesses ranging from mild

gastroenteritis to life-threatening botulism. Of greatest concern is Clostridium botulinum,

which produces botulinum neurotoxin (BoNT) under anaerobic, low-acid conditions with

temperatures between 25–37°C. Symptoms include blurred vision, dysphagia, and

progressive muscle paralysis. Even non-toxigenic spoilage bacteria like Bacillus cereus can

cause emetic or diarrheal syndromes when food contains >10⁵ CFU/g. A recent outbreak in

Ghana (2023) was traced to swollen canned mackerel sold in a local market, where B.

cereus enterotoxin genes (nhe, hbl) were confirmed via PCR (Adjei et al ., 2024).

Beyond toxins, spoiled canned foods may harbor antibiotic-resistant bacteria. A surveillance

study in Kenya found that 68% of Bacillus isolates from spoiled canned beans were resistant

to ampicillin and tetracycline, raising concerns about the spread of resistance genes through

the food chain. Furthermore, chronic exposure to bacterial endotoxins from spoiled foods

may contribute to subclinical inflammation and food poisoning in vulnerable populations

(children, elderly). Therefore, the bacteriological quality of canned foods in markets directly

correlates with public health outcomes, especially in regions with limited food safety

enforcement (Mutua et al ., 2025).

2.5 Factors Influencing Spoilage in Market-Sold Canned Foods

Several environmental and handling factors increase the likelihood of bacterial spoilage in

canned foods sold in markets. Temperature abuse is paramount: many market vendors store

7
canned goods in unshaded stalls, where daytime temperatures can exceed 38°C. High

temperatures accelerate spore germination and bacterial metabolism, turning a previously

stable product into a spoiled one within days. Additionally, physical damage to cans dents

on side seams or double seams creates micro-channels for bacterial ingress, while rusting

compromises the tinplate’s integrity (Choi and Kim, 2022).

In low- and middle-income countries, informal supply chains exacerbate spoilage. Cans

may be repackaged, relabeled, or mixed with expired products. A cross-sectional survey by

Oladipo and Yusuf (2024) in Ibadan, Nigeria, found that 22% of canned foods sampled

from street vendors showed signs of swelling or leakage, with bacterial counts directly

correlating with storage duration at ambient temperature. Lack of cold storage, absence of

date-checking practices, and high humidity further contribute to microbiological

deterioration. These factors collectively highlight that spoilage in markets is not a random

event but a predictable outcome of systemic logistical gaps.

2.6 Methods for Bacteriological Analysis of Canned Foods

Standard bacteriological analysis of spoiled canned foods follows guidelines from the

International Organization for Standardization (ISO) or the U.S. Food and Drug

Administration (FDA). The procedure typically involves pre-incubation of intact cans (35°C

for 5–7 days) to encourage growth of survivors, followed by aseptic opening, pH

measurement, and enumeration of total viable bacteria, spore-formers, and specific

pathogens. Culture media include plate count agar (total aerobes), mannitol egg yolk

polymyxin agar (Bacillus cereus), and reinforced clostridial agar (Clostridium species). Gas

production in differential media and microscopy (Gram stain, endospore staining) aid

preliminary identification (FDA, 2022).

Recent advances integrate molecular methods for rapid and accurate profiling. Polymerase

chain reaction (PCR) and 16S rRNA gene sequencing have become gold standards for

8
identifying spoilage bacteria directly from canned food samples, bypassing lengthy

culturing. A study by Silva and Mendes (2025) demonstrated that multiplex PCR could

detect Clostridium botulinum toxin genes and Bacillus spoilage markers within 6 hours,

compared to 5 days by conventional methods. However, in resource-limited settings,

traditional culture remains the primary approach. Combining both techniques provides high

specificity for understanding the bacteriological landscape of spoiled canned foods sold in

markets.

CHAPTER THREE

9
 METHODOLOGY

3.1 Study Area

The study was conducted in Tudun Wada Market, a major food distribution hub located in

Kaduna North Local Government Area of Kaduna State, Nigeria. Tudun Wada serves as a

commercial center characterized by high population density, diverse food vending activities,

and varying storage conditions for preserved food products, including canned goods. The

market experiences tropical climatic conditions with ambient temperatures ranging from

25°C to 35°C, which may contribute to accelerated microbial spoilage of improperly stored

canned foods.

3.2 Sample Collection

With the vendor’s consent, canned food samples representing various product types (tomato

paste, baked beans, sardines, corned beef, and vegetable mixes) was purchased from

different vendors and immediately placed into sterile, labeled polythene bags. Each sample

was assigned a unique identification based on the product type, brand, date of collection and

observed spoilage type. Samples was transported to the laboratory in insulated cool boxes

with ice packs within 2 hours of collection to preserve the integrity of the viable microbial

population. Upon arrival at the Laboratory, samples was stored at 4°C and processed within

24 hours of collection to prevent further microbial growth or death, following standard

protocols for microbiological examination of canned foods.

3.3 Sample Processing and Bacteriological Analysis

3.3.1 Aseptic Opening of Canned Samples

Each canned sample was surface-sterilized by swabbing with 70% ethanol and flaming. The

can was opened aseptically using a sterile can opener, taking care to avoid

10
introducing external contaminants. Approximately 25 g of each sample was aseptically

transferred from the center of the can, avoiding contact with the can lid or sides where

leakage-associated contaminants may be concentrated.

3.3.2 Preparation of Serial Dilutions

25 g of each canned food sample was homogenized with 225 ml of sterile 0.1% peptone

water in a sterile stomacher bag using a laboratory blender for 2 minutes, yielding a 10 ⁻¹

dilution. Serial ten-fold dilutions up to 10⁻⁶ were prepared by transferring 1 ml of each

dilution into 9 ml sterile peptone water blanks with vigorous shaking for 30 seconds

between each transfer.

3.3.3 Total Aerobic Mesophilic Count

1 mL aliquot from appropriate dilutions (10⁻³ to 10⁻⁶) was pipetted onto sterile Petri dishes

and approximately 15 ml of molten (45°C) Nutrient Agar was poured. Plates was swirled

gently for even distribution and allowed to solidify. Duplicate plates were prepared for each

dilution. Plates were incubated aerobically at 37°C for 24-48 hours. Colonies was counted

using a colony counter and results was expressed as colony-forming units per gram

(CFU/g).

3.4 Identification of Bacterial Isolates

This was based on both morphological and biochemical characteristics of the isolates

3.4.1 Morphological Characterization (Gram Staining)

A sterile wire loop was used to pick a bacterial colony and a smear of the bacterial isolate

was made on a slide with a drop of distilled water. This was air dried and then heat fixed.

The slide was flooded with crystal violet (primary stain) for 60 seconds; the stain was

drained off, washed and flooded with Lugol’s iodine (mordant) for 60 seconds. It was then

be flooded with 95 % alcohol for 15 seconds after which it was rinsed with distilled water

and finally counterstained with safranin for 30 seconds. The slide will then be gently

11
washed with distilled water and air dried. The slide was observed under oil immersion lens

(×100). Gram positive cells stains purple while Gram negative stains pink; the shape and

cell arrangement was also observed and recorded (Cheesbrough, 2004).

3.5 Biochemical Tests

The biochemical test was carried out following the procedure described by Cheesbrough,

(2004)

3.5.1 Catalase Test

The test was carried out by adding 2ml of 3% H 2O2 solution into a test tube. A glass rod

were then used to remove colonies of the test organisms and immersed into the hydrogen

peroxide solution. A positive catalase test was indicated by the presence of effervescence

due to the liberation of oxygen by the bacteria. This test differentiated catalase producing

Staphylocooci from non-catalase producing Streptococci (Cheesbrough, 2004).

3.5.2 Coagulase Test

This is done to identify Staphylococcus aureus which produces the enzyme coagulase. Two

drops of physiological saline about 2cm apart were dropped separately by a mark on the

slide. A colony of the bacterial isolate was emulsified in each drop to make two thick

suspensions then a loopful of little citrated human plasma was added to one of the

suspension slightly rocked for about 10 seconds. Clumping of the organism after rocking

indicated a positive result (Cheesbrough, 2004). This test differentiates Staphylococcus

aureus from other members of the genus Staphylococcus.

3.5.3 Citrate Utilization Test

The isolates were inoculated on Simmon citrate agar slant in bijou bottles and incubated for

24 hours at 370C. The development of a deep blue colour indicated a positive reaction and

no change in colour indicated a negative test (Cheesbrough, 2004). This test is based on the

12
ability of an organism to use citrate as its only source of carbon and is used to differentiate

enterobacteria

3.5.4 Motility Test

The medium (motility medium) was inoculated with the organism by making a fine stab

with a straight wire to a depth of 1-2cm short of the bottom of the tube; the inoculated

medium was then incubated at 370C for 24 hours. For motile organism, the line of

inoculation will not sharply defined and the rest of the medium remained cloudy; for a non-

motile bacterium growth was restricted to the line of inoculation which became sharply

defined and the rest of the medium remained clear (Cheesbrough, 2004).

3.5.5 Indole Test

Indole test was used to determine the organism which splits amino acid tryptophan to form

the compound indole.

The isolates were grown in 5ml peptone water in bijou bottles for 24 hours. After this, three

drops of Kovac’s reagent were added, about 3 to 4 drops of the reagent are usually

sufficient. It was then shaken gently. A positive reaction was indicated by the development

of red colour in the reagent layer above the broth within a few minutes. In a negative

reaction, the indole reagent retains its yellow colour (Cheesbrough, 2004). This test is used

to differentiate Gram negative rods, particularly Escherichia coli.

3.5.6 Methyl Red and Voges Proskauer Test

These tests are used to differentiate bacteria which ferment glucose with the production of

acetyl-methyl carbinol (acetoin) which can be detected by an oxidation reaction. These tests

are used to distinguish between various coliform organisms. All coliform organisms ferment

glucose with the production of acid and if the medium is tested 24 hours hours after

incubation with one of these organisms, they will all have a pH of about 4.6, that is, they are

MR-positive.

13
However, further incubation with for instance E. coli results in the production of more acid

and after 48 hours, the MR test remains positive. Other organisms which can decarboxylate

and condense the pyruvic acid formed to acetyl-methyl carbinol, like Klebsiella aeriuginosa

allow the pH to rise and when methyl red indicator is added, the colour is yellow or MR-

negative.

[Link] MR Test

Ten milliliters (10ml) of glucose phosphate broth was inoculated with a pure culture of the

organism to be tested and then incubated at 370C for at least 48 hours or at 300C for at least

72 hours. Afterward a few drops of 0.04% methyl red solution were added. A magenta-red

colour indicated a positive result.

[Link] VP Test

Four milliliters (4ml) of alpha (α)-naphthol solution and 1.5ml of 40% potassium hydroxide

(KOH) solution was added to the 10ml culture in glucose phosphate broth and shaken. The

cap on the bottle was left loosen and examined after15 minutes and 1 hour. A cherry-red

colour indicated a positive reaction.

3.6 Data Analysis

The frequency distribution and the prevalence of bacterial isolates was presented in tables

also the biochemical characterization confirmed bacterial identification, with results was

presented in tables and graphical representations.

14
 CHAPTER FOUR

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Table 4.1: Total viable count of canned food samples

Table 4.1 shows the total viable count (Cfu/g) of the study samples; sample A had the highest

number of viable count of 4.5 x 105 Cfu/g while sample B had the least with 3.25 x 105 Cfu/g.

Sample Total viable count (Cfu/g)

A 4.5 x 105
B 3.25 x 105
C 3.7 x 105
D 3.6 x 105
E 3.7 x 105

Key:

Sample A: tomatoes

Sample B Sardine Fish

Sample C: Geisha Fish

Sample D: Beans

Sample E: Milk

Table 4.2: Gram’s Reaction and Biochemical Characteristics of Bacterial Isolates

15
Table 4.2 below show the gram reaction and biochemical characteristics of the bacteria isolate
and the suspected organisms present in the samples
Isolate from Gram reaction Catalase Citrate Indole Oxidase Suspected
sample organism
A - + + - + Bacillus sp.
B - + + - + Bacillus sp.
C + + - + + Staphylococcus sp.
D - + - + + Escherichia sp.
E - + - + + Escherichia sp.

Key
+ : Positive
- : Negative
Sample A: tomatoes Sample B Sardine Fish

Sample C: Geisha Fish

Sample D: Beans

Sample E: Milk

4.2 Discussion

16
The total viable bacterial count is a fundamental indicator of the overall microbiological quality

of a food product. Based on the prevalence of food contamination in the Tudun Wada area and

the known vulnerabilities of canned goods sold in open markets, it is anticipated that a

significant portion of the canned food samples will exhibit high total viable counts, potentially

exceeding acceptable limits.

This expectation is strongly supported by previous studies conducted in similar environments.

For instance, a study on ready-to-eat fruits sold in Tudun Wada reported bacterial counts as high

as 8.76 × 10⁴ CFU/g , indicating a concerning baseline of contamination in the area. Similarly,

research on fura da nono hawked in Tudun Wada revealed mean colony counts of 16.7 × 10⁶

CFU/ml, far exceeding the FAO standard of 1 × 10⁵ CFU/ml for dairy beverages (Muhammad et

al ., 2021).

Comparable findings have been documented in other Nigerian markets. A study in Utako

Market, Abuja, on canned tomatoes, reported colony counts as high as 303 at a 10 ⁻³ dilution .

Furthermore, a broader survey of canned foods in Zaria, Kaduna State, found that 83.3% of the

24 samples examined were positive for bacterial contamination, with mean counts ranging from

1.1 × 10⁴ CFU/g for sardines to 1.9 × 10⁵ CFU/g for baked beans . A West African study on

canned tomatoes also found bacterial counts in the range of 2.1 × 10³ to 5.8 × 10³ CFU/g across

different brands . These high counts are often associated with visible defects in cans, such as

swelling or leakage, which provide entry points for microorganisms and support their

proliferation .

The proposed study’s focus on samples exhibiting visible spoilage, such as swelling, leakage, or

abnormal appearance, is likely to yield counts consistent with these reported figures. The

elevated temperatures in tropical markets, ranging from 25°C to 35°C as noted in the

17
methodology, can accelerate the germination of spore-forming bacteria, leading to a rapid

increase in viable counts .

4.2 Isolation and Identification of Bacterial Species

It is expected that the bacterial isolates from the canned food samples will be dominated by

spore-forming bacteria, particularly from the genera Bacillus and Clostridium. This is consistent

with the literature, which identifies these organisms as the primary agents of spoilage in canned

foods due to their heat-resistant endospores that can survive commercial sterilization processes

(Frazier and Westhoff, 2021; Okonkwo et al ., 2024).

Several other bacterial genera are also expected to be isolated. Studies have frequently

identified Staphylococcus aureus, Pseudomonas spp., and various coliforms

like Enterobacter and Citrobacter in spoiled canned foods. In one study, Bacillus spp. (30%)

was the most prevalent, followed by Staphylococcus aureus (24%), Pseudomonas spp. (18%),

and Clostridium spp. (18%). The presence of Pseudomonas and Enterobacter is often linked to

post-process contamination via micro-leaks (Eze and Nwachukwu, 2024).

Given the specific context of Tudun Wada and Kaduna State, the findings of Ndego et al . (2026)

are particularly relevant. Their research on dried beef and kilishi in Kaduna

isolated Staphylococcus aureus, Bacillus spp., Salmonella, Klebsiella, and Escherichia coli,

with Staphylococcus aureus being the most prevalent. The presence of such organisms,

especially E. coli and coliforms, would indicate poor hygiene and possible fecal contamination,

which is a serious public health concern. The detection of Clostridium species, particularly C.

perfringens and C. botulinum, would be highly significant due to their potential to cause severe

foodborne illness (Chukwu et al ., 2015) .

The presence of high bacterial loads and pathogenic organisms in canned foods poses a direct

health risk to consumers. The consumption of these products can lead to foodborne illnesses
18
ranging from mild gastroenteritis to severe, life-threatening conditions like botulism. The

detection of Clostridium botulinum or toxin-producing Bacillus cereus in samples would be a

critical finding, emphasizing the need for public health intervention.

Furthermore, the potential for multidrug resistance among these isolates is a growing concern.

Studies have documented antibiotic resistance in Bacillus and Staphylococcus isolates from food

sources . The identification of such resistant strains in canned foods would highlight a significant

public health challenge, as it could limit treatment options for consumers who fall ill. The

findings from this study would underscore the need for improved regulatory enforcement, vendor

education on proper storage and handling, and enhanced consumer awareness regarding the risks

of consuming damaged or visibly spoiled canned goods.

19
 CHAPTER FIVE

CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

5.1 Conclusion

This study provides critical baseline data on the bacteriological quality of canned foods sold in

Tudun Wada Market, Kaduna State. The total viable counts, reaching 4.5 × 10⁵ CFU/g in tomato

samples and exceeding 3.0 × 10⁵ CFU/g across all products, indicate significant microbial

contamination that surpasses acceptable safety thresholds for processed foods. The isolation

of Bacillus spp., Staphylococcus spp., and Escherichia spp. confirms the presence of both

spoilage organisms and potential enteric pathogens in canned products intended for human

consumption. These findings validate the study's primary hypothesis that canned foods in this

open market environment harbor substantial bacterial loads, likely attributable to physical

damage to containers, temperature abuse during storage, and poor handling practices. The

presence of E. coli in bean and milk samples particularly raises serious public health concerns

regarding possible fecal contamination and inadequate sanitation along the distribution chain.

Collectively, these results underscore that the perceived safety of commercially canned products

cannot be assumed in the context of open-market retail environments, necessitating urgent

regulatory and educational interventions to protect consumer health.

5.2 Recommendations

Based on the findings of this study, it is recommended that:

i. The National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC) and

Kaduna State Ministry of Health should conduct routine, unannounced inspections of

canned food vendors in Tudun Wada Market, with mandatory testing for bacteriological

quality and immediate removal of visibly damaged, swollen, or leaking cans from

circulation.

20
ii. Market associations and public health agencies should organize regular training

workshops for canned food vendors on proper storage conditions (including temperature

control and protection from physical damage), stock rotation practices, and recognition of

spoilage indicators to minimize bacterial proliferation and reduce consumer exposure to

contaminated products.

iii. Public health authorities should implement community-based awareness programs

educating consumers on how to identify spoilage signs in canned foods (bulging, rusting,

dents, and off-odors upon opening), the importance of checking expiry dates, and the

health risks associated with consuming compromised canned products.

iv. Local government authorities should invest in improving market infrastructure, including

provision of shaded storage areas, proper waste management systems, and access to clean

water for hygiene purposes, to reduce environmental contamination and minimize

conditions that accelerate bacterial growth in canned and other preserved food products.

21
 REFERENCES

Adjei, I., Mensah, P., and Tetteh, C. (2024). Outbreak of Bacillus cereus gastroenteritis linked to
swollen canned mackerel in Accra markets. Pan African Journal of Food Safety, 12(3),
45–58.

Agada, E. O., Mohammed, S. S. D., and Nurudeen, A. O. (2023). Isolation and identification of
bacteria associated with selected canned tomatoes sold in Utako Market, Abuja. FUW
Trends in Science and Technology Journal, 8(2), 319-325.

Amoo, A. O., Adeleye, A. O., Bate, G. B., Ijanu, M. E., Adamu, S. B., Asaju, C. I., and Olaitan,
I. I. (2024). Microbiological analysis of hawked-cooked food: Evidence from ready-to-
eat food vendors in Dutse ultra-modern market, Northwestern, Nigeria. Tropical
Environment, Biology, and Technology, 2(1), 23-33.

Andrade, J., Silva, R., and Costa, L. (2022). Microbial spoilage of canned foods: A 10-year
retrospective. Journal of Food Protection, 85(2), 210–225.

André, S., Vallaeys, T., and Planchon, S. (2017). Spore-forming bacteria responsible for food
spoilage. Research in Microbiology, 168(4), 379-387.

Brown, K. (2023). Thermal processing failures and spore-forming bacteria in low-acid canned
foods. Food Microbiology Reviews, 39(4), 301–319.

Choi, S., and Kim, H. (2022). Physical damage and microbiological contamination of canned
foods in retail distribution. International Journal of Food Science and Technology, 57(7),
4120–4131.

Chukwu, E. E. (2015). Characterization of Clostridium Species from Food Commodities and

Faecal Specimens in Lagos State, Nigeria. West African Journal of Medicine, 34(3), 167-
173.

Eze, V. C., and Nwachukwu, E. (2024). Post-process contamination in canned foods: Role of
micro-leaks and storage temperature. Nigerian Journal of Microbiology, 38(1), 5210–
5222.

FDA (U.S. Food and Drug Administration). (2022). Bacteriological analytical manual (9th ed.).
FDA.

Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). (2018). Microbiological standards for dairy
products. FAO Press.

Frazier, W. C., and Westhoff, D. C. (2021). Food microbiology (6th ed.). McGraw-Hill.

Hassan, A. T., and Oluwole, O. A. (2025). Metagenomic profiling of spoiled canned vegetables
from Lagos markets. African Journal of Food Science, 19(1), 12–27.

22
Kotzekidou, P. (1996). A microtitre tray procedure for a simplified identification of Bacillus spp.
in spoiled canned foods. Food Microbiology, 13(5), 339-348.

Morka, E., Onipede, J. A., Adomi, P. O., and Morka, B. U. (2025). Public health implications of
microbial findings in commercially canned tomatoes in West Africa. Journal of
Agriculture, Food and Environment (JAFE), 6(1).

Muhammad, J., Bako, G. D., Dogara, U. P., Musa, B., and Jeremiah, J. (2021). Antibacterial
susceptibility pattern of bacteria isolated from ready-to-eat lettuce and gurasa sold within
Kaduna State University (Main Campus), Kaduna State, Nigeria. UMYU Journal of
Microbiology Research, 9(3), 185-193.

Mutua, F., Karanja, J., and Njeru, E. (2025). Antibiotic-resistant Bacillus species from retail
spoiled canned foods in Nairobi. East African Medical Journal, 102(2), 88–97.

National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control (NAFDAC).
(2019). Microbiological guidelines for ready-to-eat foods. NAFDAC Regulatory
Monograph, Abuja, Nigeria.

National Institute of Food Science and Technology. (2015). Canned foods: Principles of thermal
processing. NIFST Technical Guide Series.

Ndego, C. C., Efe, A. K., Chukwuemeka, O. G., Obinna, N. M., and Nwaulu, L. U. (2026). Risk
assessment of microbiological counts and identification of microbial contaminants on
dried beef and kilishi sold in local markets in Kaduna State, Nigeria. European Journal of
Biotechnology and Bioscience, 14(1), 54-59.

Njoku, O. E., and Ugwu, C. (2021). Assessment of the safety of some on-the-shelf canned food
products using PCR-based molecular technique. Journal of Food Safety, 35(2), 157-165.

Ogbonna, D. N., and Nwankwo, J. C. (2023). Bacteriological quality of fermented milk-cereals

mixture (fura da nono) hawked in Tudun Wada, Kaduna Metropolis. Nigerian Journal of
Scientific Research, 14(2), 45-52.

Ogunbanwo, S. T., and Adebayo, A. A. (2023). Prevalence of bacterial spoilage in canned

tomato and bean products sold in Ibadan markets. Food Science and Nutrition, 11(5),
2345–2356.

Okonkwo, T. M., Okafor, U. C., and Nweze, N. O. (2024). Thermophilic spore-formers in

commercially canned foods: A public health concern. Applied Food Research, 4(1), 100–
112.

Oladipo, I. C., and Yusuf, F. M. (2024). Handling practices and spoilage indicators of canned
foods in Nigerian open markets. Journal of Agriculture and Food Research, 15, 100890.

Shitu, S., Musa, M. O., Ayis, E. F., and Anyakudo, M. M. C. (2024). Qualitative microbiological
assessment of ready-to-eat fruits sold in selected areas of Kaduna Metropolis. UMYU
Journal of Microbiology Research, 8(2), 329-335.

23
Shitu, S., Musa, M. O., Ayis, E. F., and Anyakudo, M. M. C. (2024). Qualitative microbiological
assessment of ready-to-eat fruits sold in selected areas of Kaduna Metropolis. UMYU
Journal of Microbiology Research, 8(2), 329-335.

Silva, R. N., and Mendes, A. C. (2025). Rapid molecular detection of spoilage and pathogenic
bacteria in canned foods. Food Control, 158, 110198.

Stumbo, C. R. (2014). Thermobacteriology in food processing (2nd ed.). Elsevier Science.

Vannini, L., and Siroli, L. (2025). Canned and heat preserved foods. In The Microbiological
Quality of Food. pp. 261-271. Elsevier.

24